In terms of animation as a whole I do prefer the 93 if you consider the entire series vs the OVA. I love the smoother animation. One thing I’d love to see you analyze too is the Sonic CD animated shorts by Toei. Those are nice and short so they shouldn’t be too long to analyze. The sonic riders opening animation would also be a nice candidate for analysis too.
cant really compare a 13 episode OVA to a full on 50 episode TV series though. david production was really consistent throughout the whole series. the OVAs were a bit smoother in parts but saying "as a whole" is cap.
I feel Jotaro's attack with the OVA had more of an impact. That damage transitioning from The World's Leg( as it ghostly fading into Dio) feels more cinematic and powerful as we see it's devastation !!! It was just a fantastic feat of animation!
The only downsides with the OVA are the removal of a lot of the more bizarre moments that basically comprise JoJo in favor of a more gritty tone, Jotaro emerging from the oil truck fire looking less cool than just suddenly appearing behind DIO (even if it makes more sense), and DIO looking too bulky and ugly for his own good. Otherwise, the way that the DIO fight goes in the OVA is really great.
I enjoy both versions immensely. Even with the OVA's smoother animation, I can't choose between either one since they both provide such a great yet different experience despite adapting the same material. The TV anime feels more manga accurate not only in character designs but in tone, making use of great voice acting, score and colour swaps that pop off the screen. Although, I would say that the new anime's strengths are best shown in part 5, so I'd highly recommend checking out either the Metallica fight or King Crimson introduction for the animation and direction.
I love how David Productions did Justice to JoJo's bizarre adventure with the adaptation it really needed considering its failures back in the day. And yes while in some parts the animation was rough and was later fixed in the Blue rays I still feel that despite all the time restraints they managed to give us an enjoyable time and keep the action consistent. Also I love the In-between memes while it catches me off guard it's certainly very entertaining 😂😂.
And even with the less smooth animation, they carried over the creativity of the manga by utilizing the constant palette change or how the openings are so unique that goes the same with the stand sounds and all.
A lot of ppl hates the ova but personally I love them so much , they are better then any David production animation since DP use a lot of still shots and I respect the different vision the director and character designer saw in the source material but I still like DP since that’s what araki wants
I commend you for taking on the awesome duties of comparing the animators style, timing and transitions from the ova to the tv series! Personally I enjoy the OVA better but still enjoy the tv series! Great to see different takes on the same EPIC Fight!!
I know how the Anime from David Production is more true to Araki's Style and Jotaro's fight with Dio there is Epic for how they handles it. But I still have an appreciation for the OVA and it's own version of that battle. It's 90's artstyle and slick animation will also amaze me.
So according to this video, the old and new JoJo's bizarre adventure anime both have the weaknesses and strengths, another words the equal in a way. That's a very interesting fact.
Yup. There's a reason even the Rohan OVAs are smoother than the TV anime. But man, how DavidPro capture the tone for the series just perfectly all around
Glad you added how rushed the modern anime wound up being, important context as to why the animation can wind up being stiff. Really cool to see your take on this, getting your Jojo info from memes is pretty par for the course 👌👌
the ova was far more cinematic and had a much more serious tone because it sorta removed the 'wacky jojo drama' vibes there was also a lot more fight choreography with dragged out scenes that werent even in the manga like dio throwing a boat onto jotaro and the two taking their fight onto a public highway, endangering civilians
One thing that should be said is the evolution of David’s Production later down the line with Part 5 and Rohan ovas, if you see the concept art they really went into detail the way everything is, even the mouth movements have a full page on it, its really good
I'm not sure if it's your editor or or yourself but these jokes that you have in there are great like the Illuminati triangle and the knight joke, I laughed a few more times
I like both versions, they each have their strenghs and weaknesses. While I certainly enjoyed the fluid action and camera movements of the OVA with even some extra fighting scenes added, that were not in the manga, I also really like the detailed sharp art of the new series and its sound design. And even though it didn't have much sakuga for the climax, the tv series itself had quite a bunch of cool sakuga moments in it. The one that stuck most to me, was where they fought the voodoo doll stand in the hotel room. Also some of polnareffs action looked so well animated.
What the...?! I wish I'd seen this post earlier. As the person who cast and directed the voices in the 1993 version of JoJo, I found your comparisons quite interesting.
Despite there being more consistency in in the new version like with the on-model drawings, there are some more creative choices in the older version that make the scenes more intriguing and unique. Despite the new one being sometimes more extreme and flashy, it has some pretty standardised movements and framing.
The OVA's animation is excellent! I'm not a huge fan of the OVA in general (I prefer the colours and character art of the David Productions version), but it makes me wonder what the modern style and OVA budget/animation would look like together. Either way, both versions clearly had a lot of love poured into them.
honestly the ova has better animation imo, even if the artstyle is not as good as the 2014 one. The darby OVA is one of my favourites. Randomly every once in awhile ill just find myself rewatching the darby ova at 1 am
didn't get a notification for this ooof. a strayy cat i found currently has my headphones and is lisntenign to a gorillaz album but i'll make sure to watch later
I like the direction a bit more in the ova version of the scene but i think the anime does basically everything else better lol (art, animation, music choice, voice acting, sound effects, etc.) 6:53 About that, basically every jojo part's production becomes kind of a mess at some point (you even have stone ocean which has been messy since the start unfortunately), so having multiple directors and supervisors working on one episode is kind of the standard for the latter stages of each part. Tthe fact that the staff is capable of pumping out incredibly well adapted and directed episodes even despite those circumstances speaks volumes about their talent and love for jojo
the animation is the one thing i would have to disagree on, the ova's are muchhh better animated, the tv anime is pretty rigid, although that's kinda expected
@@GalekC I'd say overall the 2011 HxH is better animated, there are scenes that looked better in the 99 anime, but on average 2011's episodes tend to have more animation, and there's a lot of nice cuts not from fighting scenes that the 99 version didn't have, but I do prefer the 99 art style except for the color schemes, a lot of color choices were really wack compared to 2011.
David Production nails the feeling of JoJo. For as well animated as the OVAs are, they lack the flair of Araki's manga. But I have to say that the fight between Jotaro and Dio in the OVA is a work of art! DP's Stardust Crusaders actually started off super strong in the animation department, leaps and bounds ahead of the previous JoJo anime they worked on, but you can notice a decrease in quality during the second half as it went on, which is a shame. Had it featured the same quality of animation I believe it would be a closer call between both versions of the Jotaro/Dio fight.
While reading about animation (mostly 3d but also 2d) I have learned of a thing called "meri hari" which is the sort of the Japanese concept of anticipation, used heavily in kabuki theater. Basically it involves taking the motion slow at the start and then JACK IT UP in speed towards the end, as a sinewavish shock effect. Videogames with good animations do this all the time and it feels wonderful, usually what you see with fixed-framerate keyframes is that the body kinda stops and then teleports to a much later motion state to emphasize weight displacement. What I mean is that what Hayama did here was astounding, not only did he apply that anticipation concept very neatly but as you noted he increased the framerate towards the end of the punch, effectively giving off double the meri hari impact it should have had, almost replicating a sort of high shutter speed effect. No teleporting, but increasing perceived proximity/danger through smoothness, as if it equated speed. I just know the first time you showed it during the beginning of the video I couldn't stop rewinding to watch it again lol, masterful sequence. Personally, I'm a bit more of a fan of the OVA art direction where it comes to CD and colours (also I'm not a JoJo manga fan or even a fan at all, I just enjoy seeing stuff from it), but DP meticulously adapted all of it so credit where credit is due, blockier designs could more animation friendly.
OVA actually prettt liked in the community. JoJos one of the few manga that’s had pretty good to amazing adaptations for the most part. JoJos is goated!
@@A1000-b9s to be fair tho they couldn't possibly fit everything in the number of OVAs they were given, in fact the 90's OVAs start at the ndull fight and only later in the 2000's they adapted the stuff that came before and still had to cut a bunch of shit, and not all of their changes were bad, though I think the biggest problem is that they're kinda afraid of the more "bizarre" part of the series, unlike the anime which fully embraces it, so a lot of the wacky stuff is missing in favor of a more serious tone, and the characters unfortunately suffer from it and are turned into boring versions of themselves, and the art style is also more Kenshiro like than JoJo, though it's not always consistent cause some shots with Vanilla Ice and pretty much the entire Darby the gambler episode look more accurate to the manga art style, it's a little bit simplified for animation sake but still looked great, the whole OVA series looked good, but I wished they went with a more manga accurate style throughout all the episodes. Oh and on a kinda nitpick tangent I think the color schemes for the characters kinda suck, especially when compared to the anime, which I heard Araki himself helped with since part 3.
@@ginogatash4030(sorry for my bad english Again) yeah they couldn't definitely but it's still a very good experience tho. The cuts of Animation is seriously amazing and at mostly better than The TV production. Still shout to david production. Their management is always great. Like they Manage to keep the Quality this consistent with a 50 high Quality episodes and there are cuts that are Really impressive Animation Wise. Also i think The colors and compositing and the shading was perfect in OVA tho. Sure it dosen't fit with jojo. But still it's such a vibe on its own. But if you look at the positives. Jojo got two adaptations which both of them are Really amazing in their own kind of thing. A lot of mangas dream for this kinds of adaptation
I mean 50 episodes to Limited episodes of OVA is unfair. They did a Really good job. Because this Quality is Really hard to keep for this many episodes
I like how Jotaro looks in the anime, the 2014 one, cause it looks like he is finally calmed down after the fight which suites his character while the jotaro in the ova looks like he is still angry, which, is kinda realistic but out of character for jotaro
I loved how the new one is very similar the art-style to the manga while the ova tried for a more serious and dramatic tone i also enjoyed the voice acting in the new one
I like the pacing and atmosphere in the ova more. The pacing lets viewer have time to breath and take these scene slowly and enjoy it. Many scene feels more meaningful cuz of the pace it delivers and the ova also add original scene that extend the fight scene for the better. The conclusion to the fight are more satisfying cuz of the pace it delivers too. The atmosphere is also intense cuz of the old artstyle. I prefer the ova more in my opinion.
Haven't watch so many anime but these old vs new comparison video are fun to watch. Will you do some more animation Breakdown on Naruto? And how many animes you have watched as a whole?
I didn't even know he did SF2V and I watched the entirety of it, though parts of my brain probably picked up DBZ memories. Sadly that anime has had some serious production problems in the latter half.
I tried Fumiaki timing on stickNodes in 18 frames at least and it wasn't bad,It looked a little stiff at first try but after a few more practices, it worked well,On flipaclip it was good I've been trying to understand animation and in between,Timing animation on my own so maybe that's why it sucked when I first tried out his timing because Jotaro vs Dio animation wouldn't have been that good if that timing was stiff
You should do a comparison of original hellsing vs hellsing ultimate. A good example is the first fight against the priest ghoul or the first fight between alucard and anderson.
I liked 1993 more idk Jojo animation today sometimes is to still and they barely move sometimes which is what is happening in Jojo part 6 in the 1993 you can feel the weight of jotaro jacket and the movement is just great I still like the new version tho and idk but the characters seem more expressive in the old one
I know this may seem a strange request and probably you wouldn't consider it. but can you review the animation of a anime sequel of a live action Tokusatsu series called “Kamen Rider W”? the anime sequel's title is “Fuuto PI”, It has great animation and I'd love for you to review it's animation also.
Looking at them side by side, each of them has their own strengths and weaknesses. The OVA seems to have more snappy, impactful animation, especially with the Anticipation of Jotaro's punch. There was a slow build up for a faster action. And which I think it looks better IMO. The TV series has the art and design more faithful to Araki's manga, which already looks beautiful. And to have Star Platinum's fist initially get bloody really puts the tension at the final fight better than the OVA. Interesting how the best posing and the use of sharp angular shapes are in different scenes in both. And IIRC, THE Satoshi Kon himself worked on the OVA as storyboarder and director of Ep 5. IMO, it might be my bias, but I would prefer the TV series version despite the OVA having more snappy timing. ForgottenRelics, if you could, I would like to see an analysis of My Hero Academia or other anime by Studio Bones.
Fumiaki Kouta è scrauso come animatore e sopratutto come character designer, Hayama ha fatto un lavoro molto più bello poi si parla di animazione in 3DCGI contro la vecchia pellicola, è ovvio che le proporzioni in CGI siano più precise prima era tutto su carta!
I disagree, the animation's better, which is to be expected when comparing a short OVA series to a full long TV series, but they don't really capture the flamboyant weird flare of Araki's work like the anime does, it's certainly cool, but trying to make everything more serious and gritty dampens contrast and makes the characters and story more boring and generic in my opinion, also I'm not the biggest fan of the more Kenshiro looking art style, it's not bad but I want the true Araki look with JoJo, which oddly does show up in the Darby OVA but not the rest of the series for some reason, seriously it's kinda jarring how off model the characters look compared to all the other episodes, and on the note of character designs the color schemes for characters are way better in the anime, and the dramatic color changes are a really neat touch, and I have to prefer the acting in the anime, especially for DIO, he sounds god awful in the OVAs, they just picked the least threatning old man ever, which I don't understand cause the drama cd from around that time had Norio Wakamoto who is the greatest contender for best DIO along with Takehito Koyasu as well as all the other actors being really well casted and doing a kickers performance but the OVAs just can't compete, not to mention that the OVAs had to cut a lot of the story which leaves some characters impoverished of their character development and such, so I have to prefer the anime adaptation overall.
@@dyl_pickle16-mta48 I guess by that logic it isn't canon, but usually I reserve that term for made up filler stories, rather than adaptations that just couldn't quite get all the story as accurately as they wished.
@@carloscauan7967He's kinda got a point, David Productions has never went above and beyond when it comes to animation. Honestly I think that's something that's holding JoJo back.
you gotta do the whole episode, there's so many problems with the anime and its "faithful to the manga" structure, such as bringing out polnareff to job to DIO and forcing jotaro to distract him (wasting our time as viewers), whereas in the OVA polnareff actually helps jotaro by distracting DIO right before he discovers jotaro is alive! it's mucy more than that too, there's so much that happens between joseph's blood being absorbed and DIO's death that was packed with effort and new action events being injected that they just ignored for "faithfulness" even when that stubborn approach david decided to take output a wholly inferior product araki is not perfect, and the OVA was directed by the likes of katsuhiro otomo and satoshi kon. it's almost laughable to compare that stunning 93 OVA to david's carbon copy of the heavily flawed original.
I was originally going to cover the whole fight but there simply wasn't enough time, I think the fight takes place over at least 3 episodes in the tv anime and 2 in for the ova's. But it would genuinely take almost a month to make a side-by-side comparison like that. It would either have to be a general overview or a comparison of a specific moment like this one :)
@@forgottenrelics1197 i understand!! but man, this particular topic is one of the most interesting differences in adaptation wars. i would love to see more content involving the jojo ova and anime :)
Anime Merch Here👔
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
►JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Merch: bit.ly/ForgottenRelicsJJBAMerch
►Anime Merch: bit.ly/ForgottenRelicsAnimeMerch
►Shop Meme Merch: bit.ly/ForgottenRelicsMemeMerch
►Extra 10% Off Discount Code: Relics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In terms of animation as a whole I do prefer the 93 if you consider the entire series vs the OVA. I love the smoother animation. One thing I’d love to see you analyze too is the Sonic CD animated shorts by Toei. Those are nice and short so they shouldn’t be too long to analyze. The sonic riders opening animation would also be a nice candidate for analysis too.
yes i agree, those sonic cd 2d animated cutscenes look better the more i watch em
Slight correction, those cutscenes were done by studio Junio, not Toei.
@@CatInfant yeah I believe Hisashi Eguchi handled the first part of the op
cant really compare a 13 episode OVA to a full on 50 episode TV series though. david production was really consistent throughout the whole series. the OVAs were a bit smoother in parts but saying "as a whole" is cap.
@@CatInfant Toei commissioned the animation to Studio Junio though, it's in the credits.
Off topic but I love the small bits of humor you’ve been injecting in these recent videos. Just adds another level of personality I really appreciate
I feel Jotaro's attack with the OVA had more of an impact. That damage transitioning from The World's Leg( as it ghostly fading into Dio) feels more cinematic and powerful as we see it's devastation !!! It was just a fantastic feat of animation!
Nah it absolutely did
Ova stand we're stronger so guess that explain why
Just my personaly prefrence but I think Jotaro's character design in the OVA looks better then the design made by David Production
@@The_Blue_Otaku Nuthin' Wrong with that!
and ova the world was screaming
The only downsides with the OVA are the removal of a lot of the more bizarre moments that basically comprise JoJo in favor of a more gritty tone, Jotaro emerging from the oil truck fire looking less cool than just suddenly appearing behind DIO (even if it makes more sense), and DIO looking too bulky and ugly for his own good. Otherwise, the way that the DIO fight goes in the OVA is really great.
Jojos without the bizzare isnt jojos anymore. Its *literally* in the name.
That is part of the problem with having such a short series, there's basically no time for goofy moments
I enjoy both versions immensely. Even with the OVA's smoother animation, I can't choose between either one since they both provide such a great yet different experience despite adapting the same material. The TV anime feels more manga accurate not only in character designs but in tone, making use of great voice acting, score and colour swaps that pop off the screen.
Although, I would say that the new anime's strengths are best shown in part 5, so I'd highly recommend checking out either the Metallica fight or King Crimson introduction for the animation and direction.
I love how David Productions did Justice to JoJo's bizarre adventure with the adaptation it really needed considering its failures back in the day. And yes while in some parts the animation was rough and was later fixed in the Blue rays I still feel that despite all the time restraints they managed to give us an enjoyable time and keep the action consistent.
Also I love the In-between memes while it catches me off guard it's certainly very entertaining 😂😂.
And even with the less smooth animation, they carried over the creativity of the manga by utilizing the constant palette change or how the openings are so unique that goes the same with the stand sounds and all.
Crazy how fluid they get with the animation despite all the details on the designs
That’s because OVAs have better animation because it’s directly marketed towards buying VHS tapes.
Kakyoin eating a cherry is objectively the best scene in the history of scenes...
A lot of ppl hates the ova but personally I love them so much , they are better then any David production animation since DP use a lot of still shots and I respect the different vision the director and character designer saw in the source material but I still like DP since that’s what araki wants
You can't say that they are better than "any" David Production anime, you can say that they are better than "Jojo's David Production anime"
@@snakewatch5468 well yeah I meant only jojo since the video is about jojo…. For example fire force is better animated then the ova
@@hellodigitalworld8224 yeah that's true
DP did a great job with animation in part 4 and 5
@@geox8485 part 4 is my favorite
I commend you for taking on the awesome duties of comparing the animators style, timing and transitions from the ova to the tv series! Personally I enjoy the OVA better but still enjoy the tv series! Great to see different takes on the same EPIC Fight!!
I know how the Anime from David Production is more true to Araki's Style and Jotaro's fight with Dio there is Epic for how they handles it. But I still have an appreciation for the OVA and it's own version of that battle. It's 90's artstyle and slick animation will also amaze me.
So according to this video, the old and new JoJo's bizarre adventure anime both have the weaknesses and strengths, another words the equal in a way.
That's a very interesting fact.
I just gotta say, I love the editing on this video.
0:51 Unexpected cameo of the Spanish language
Yup. There's a reason even the Rohan OVAs are smoother than the TV anime. But man, how DavidPro capture the tone for the series just perfectly all around
Glad you added how rushed the modern anime wound up being, important context as to why the animation can wind up being stiff. Really cool to see your take on this, getting your Jojo info from memes is pretty par for the course 👌👌
the ova was far more cinematic and had a much more serious tone because it sorta removed the 'wacky jojo drama' vibes
there was also a lot more fight choreography with dragged out scenes that werent even in the manga
like dio throwing a boat onto jotaro and the two taking their fight onto a public highway, endangering civilians
One thing that should be said is the evolution of David’s Production later down the line with Part 5 and Rohan ovas, if you see the concept art they really went into detail the way everything is, even the mouth movements have a full page on it, its really good
I'm not sure if it's your editor or or yourself but these jokes that you have in there are great like the Illuminati triangle and the knight joke, I laughed a few more times
i don't have an editor haha, although i've been considering it again lately
I like both versions, they each have their strenghs and weaknesses. While I certainly enjoyed the fluid action and camera movements of the OVA with even some extra fighting scenes added, that were not in the manga, I also really like the detailed sharp art of the new series and its sound design. And even though it didn't have much sakuga for the climax, the tv series itself had quite a bunch of cool sakuga moments in it. The one that stuck most to me, was where they fought the voodoo doll stand in the hotel room. Also some of polnareffs action looked so well animated.
Yeah part 3 actually had a lot of sakuga, the animators especially seemed to love Silver Chariot and Magician's red
I just wish the pacing was good like the manga
What the...?! I wish I'd seen this post earlier. As the person who cast and directed the voices in the 1993 version of JoJo, I found your comparisons quite interesting.
Despite there being more consistency in in the new version like with the on-model drawings, there are some more creative choices in the older version that make the scenes more intriguing and unique. Despite the new one being sometimes more extreme and flashy, it has some pretty standardised movements and framing.
The OVA's animation is excellent! I'm not a huge fan of the OVA in general (I prefer the colours and character art of the David Productions version), but it makes me wonder what the modern style and OVA budget/animation would look like together. Either way, both versions clearly had a lot of love poured into them.
honestly the ova has better animation imo, even if the artstyle is not as good as the 2014 one. The darby OVA is one of my favourites. Randomly every once in awhile ill just find myself rewatching the darby ova at 1 am
didn't get a notification for this ooof. a strayy cat i found currently has my headphones and is lisntenign to a gorillaz album but i'll make sure to watch later
i'll have to start the "youtube has a weird glitch that unsubscribes and turns notifications off" bit from now on
I prefer the horror vibe of the 93 version, episode 5 which was storyboarded by Satoshi Kon is the best on this aspect imo.
Got to say you got my interest through the whole thing, very well made video.
I like the direction a bit more in the ova version of the scene but i think the anime does basically everything else better lol (art, animation, music choice, voice acting, sound effects, etc.)
6:53 About that, basically every jojo part's production becomes kind of a mess at some point (you even have stone ocean which has been messy since the start unfortunately), so having multiple directors and supervisors working on one episode is kind of the standard for the latter stages of each part. Tthe fact that the staff is capable of pumping out incredibly well adapted and directed episodes even despite those circumstances speaks volumes about their talent and love for jojo
the animation is the one thing i would have to disagree on, the ova's are muchhh better animated, the tv anime is pretty rigid, although that's kinda expected
Pretty much HxH 1999 vs 2011 all over again, lmao
@@GalekC I'd say overall the 2011 HxH is better animated, there are scenes that looked better in the 99 anime, but on average 2011's episodes tend to have more animation, and there's a lot of nice cuts not from fighting scenes that the 99 version didn't have, but I do prefer the 99 art style except for the color schemes, a lot of color choices were really wack compared to 2011.
David Production nails the feeling of JoJo. For as well animated as the OVAs are, they lack the flair of Araki's manga. But I have to say that the fight between Jotaro and Dio in the OVA is a work of art! DP's Stardust Crusaders actually started off super strong in the animation department, leaps and bounds ahead of the previous JoJo anime they worked on, but you can notice a decrease in quality during the second half as it went on, which is a shame. Had it featured the same quality of animation I believe it would be a closer call between both versions of the Jotaro/Dio fight.
While reading about animation (mostly 3d but also 2d) I have learned of a thing called "meri hari" which is the sort of the Japanese concept of anticipation, used heavily in kabuki theater. Basically it involves taking the motion slow at the start and then JACK IT UP in speed towards the end, as a sinewavish shock effect. Videogames with good animations do this all the time and it feels wonderful, usually what you see with fixed-framerate keyframes is that the body kinda stops and then teleports to a much later motion state to emphasize weight displacement. What I mean is that what Hayama did here was astounding, not only did he apply that anticipation concept very neatly but as you noted he increased the framerate towards the end of the punch, effectively giving off double the meri hari impact it should have had, almost replicating a sort of high shutter speed effect. No teleporting, but increasing perceived proximity/danger through smoothness, as if it equated speed. I just know the first time you showed it during the beginning of the video I couldn't stop rewinding to watch it again lol, masterful sequence.
Personally, I'm a bit more of a fan of the OVA art direction where it comes to CD and colours (also I'm not a JoJo manga fan or even a fan at all, I just enjoy seeing stuff from it), but DP meticulously adapted all of it so credit where credit is due, blockier designs could more animation friendly.
OVA actually prettt liked in the community. JoJos one of the few manga that’s had pretty good to amazing adaptations for the most part. JoJos is goated!
kinda I heard people upset at the ways it deviates from the source material, especially after the anime came out.
@@ginogatash4030 yeah i heard that it is
@@A1000-b9s to be fair tho they couldn't possibly fit everything in the number of OVAs they were given, in fact the 90's OVAs start at the ndull fight and only later in the 2000's they adapted the stuff that came before and still had to cut a bunch of shit, and not all of their changes were bad, though I think the biggest problem is that they're kinda afraid of the more "bizarre" part of the series, unlike the anime which fully embraces it, so a lot of the wacky stuff is missing in favor of a more serious tone, and the characters unfortunately suffer from it and are turned into boring versions of themselves, and the art style is also more Kenshiro like than JoJo, though it's not always consistent cause some shots with Vanilla Ice and pretty much the entire Darby the gambler episode look more accurate to the manga art style, it's a little bit simplified for animation sake but still looked great, the whole OVA series looked good, but I wished they went with a more manga accurate style throughout all the episodes.
Oh and on a kinda nitpick tangent I think the color schemes for the characters kinda suck, especially when compared to the anime, which I heard Araki himself helped with since part 3.
@@ginogatash4030(sorry for my bad english Again) yeah they couldn't definitely but it's still a very good experience tho. The cuts of Animation is seriously amazing and at mostly better than The TV production. Still shout to david production. Their management is always great. Like they Manage to keep the Quality this consistent with a 50 high Quality episodes and there are cuts that are Really impressive Animation Wise. Also i think The colors and compositing and the shading was perfect in OVA tho. Sure it dosen't fit with jojo. But still it's such a vibe on its own.
But if you look at the positives. Jojo got two adaptations which both of them are Really amazing in their own kind of thing. A lot of mangas dream for this kinds of adaptation
Finally
It's here
DEEZ NUTZ
Both are great. My favorite is the prequel Oav from 2000, very dark and great music, and mature.
93 Dio looks way more menacing than modern Dio. He looked like a trans non gender on the modern adaptation, 93 Dio looks like old Broly.
you could feel the crack on The World
like it's plastic, real strong plastic
Obviously the OVA has better animation but the modern version has everything else done better.
Music, voice acting, colours, the fabulousness.
Sounds like cope to me.
@@Charlestouchdown whaaaaa?
@@Charlestouchdown Having a preference = coping?
I mean 50 episodes to Limited episodes of OVA is unfair. They did a Really good job. Because this Quality is Really hard to keep for this many episodes
Finally a Jojo video
I like how Jotaro looks in the anime, the 2014 one, cause it looks like he is finally calmed down after the fight which suites his character while the jotaro in the ova looks like he is still angry, which, is kinda realistic but out of character for jotaro
I loved how the new one is very similar the art-style to the manga while the ova tried for a more serious and dramatic tone i also enjoyed the voice acting in the new one
Pyrocynical 👀 I see you're a man of culture
Ova just look like a design of Hokuto no ken
In EP 11 to 13 and 2000 ova
Jotaro just nearly look like Kenshiro
Awesome !
I like more the feel of the new anime.
The OVA changed the way characters behave, look and talk that it was weird.
I know you usually do comparison from older to newer. But you HAVE to talk bout yusuke's fight against doctor kamiya from yu yu hakusho
I like the pacing and atmosphere in the ova more. The pacing lets viewer have time to breath and take these scene slowly and enjoy it. Many scene feels more meaningful cuz of the pace it delivers and the ova also add original scene that extend the fight scene for the better. The conclusion to the fight are more satisfying cuz of the pace it delivers too.
The atmosphere is also intense cuz of the old artstyle. I prefer the ova more in my opinion.
Omg
Can you do a Doraemon animation breakdown now?
Haven't watch so many anime but these old vs new comparison video are fun to watch.
Will you do some more animation Breakdown on Naruto?
And how many animes you have watched as a whole?
I love when Masunaga comes up in a video lol
it's been a while haha so i guess it was due
I didn't even know he did SF2V and I watched the entirety of it, though parts of my brain probably picked up DBZ memories. Sadly that anime has had some serious production problems in the latter half.
I tried Fumiaki timing on stickNodes in 18 frames at least and it wasn't bad,It looked a little stiff at first try but after a few more practices, it worked well,On flipaclip it was good
I've been trying to understand animation and in between,Timing animation on my own so maybe that's why it sucked when I first tried out his timing because Jotaro vs Dio animation wouldn't have been that good if that timing was stiff
More Jojos pleasse
You should do a comparison of original hellsing vs hellsing ultimate. A good example is the first fight against the priest ghoul or the first fight between alucard and anderson.
I liked 1993 more idk Jojo animation today sometimes is to still and they barely move sometimes which is what is happening in Jojo part 6 in the 1993 you can feel the weight of jotaro jacket and the movement is just great I still like the new version tho and idk but the characters seem more expressive in the old one
it helps that the old one was an ova, so much less tighter then a tv anime schedule, although it also helped it had a great staff list!
I know this may seem a strange request and probably you wouldn't consider it. but can you review the animation of a anime sequel of a live action Tokusatsu series called “Kamen Rider W”? the anime sequel's title is “Fuuto PI”, It has great animation and I'd love for you to review it's animation also.
Space Dandy was included!
Looking at them side by side, each of them has their own strengths and weaknesses. The OVA seems to have more snappy, impactful animation, especially with the Anticipation of Jotaro's punch. There was a slow build up for a faster action. And which I think it looks better IMO. The TV series has the art and design more faithful to Araki's manga, which already looks beautiful. And to have Star Platinum's fist initially get bloody really puts the tension at the final fight better than the OVA. Interesting how the best posing and the use of sharp angular shapes are in different scenes in both. And IIRC, THE Satoshi Kon himself worked on the OVA as storyboarder and director of Ep 5.
IMO, it might be my bias, but I would prefer the TV series version despite the OVA having more snappy timing. ForgottenRelics, if you could, I would like to see an analysis of My Hero Academia or other anime by Studio Bones.
Fumiaki Kouta è scrauso come animatore e sopratutto come character designer, Hayama ha fatto un lavoro molto più bello poi si parla di animazione in 3DCGI contro la vecchia pellicola, è ovvio che le proporzioni in CGI siano più precise prima era tutto su carta!
I think the berserk animations would be an interesting video topic
Do an Avatar the Last Airbender animation breakdown one day please 😭
For the love of god it's not an anime
@@mohabalserafe3795 So
1:27 excuse ME
But if you're sensitive to blood you might as well pick the old one.
…Did someone else edit this?
a big issue with 93 is that all the characters look way too old except dio, jotaro looks like a 40 year old
i dont know anything about the animation but im mostly affected by sound effect and ost I think lmao
Come on man, you cant spoil the show with your title
Hey
Despite being non-canon, I’ve always viewed the OVA as superior to the anime.
I disagree, the animation's better, which is to be expected when comparing a short OVA series to a full long TV series, but they don't really capture the flamboyant weird flare of Araki's work like the anime does, it's certainly cool, but trying to make everything more serious and gritty dampens contrast and makes the characters and story more boring and generic in my opinion, also I'm not the biggest fan of the more Kenshiro looking art style, it's not bad but I want the true Araki look with JoJo, which oddly does show up in the Darby OVA but not the rest of the series for some reason, seriously it's kinda jarring how off model the characters look compared to all the other episodes, and on the note of character designs the color schemes for characters are way better in the anime, and the dramatic color changes are a really neat touch, and I have to prefer the acting in the anime, especially for DIO, he sounds god awful in the OVAs, they just picked the least threatning old man ever, which I don't understand cause the drama cd from around that time had Norio Wakamoto who is the greatest contender for best DIO along with Takehito Koyasu as well as all the other actors being really well casted and doing a kickers performance but the OVAs just can't compete, not to mention that the OVAs had to cut a lot of the story which leaves some characters impoverished of their character development and such, so I have to prefer the anime adaptation overall.
also the OVAs aren't really non canon, they're just a limited retelling of the canon it's not like they made up a new story.
@@ginogatash4030 It’s not canon because parts of the story were altered, added onto, or removed completely.
@@dyl_pickle16-mta48 I guess by that logic it isn't canon, but usually I reserve that term for made up filler stories, rather than adaptations that just couldn't quite get all the story as accurately as they wished.
First liek
John John ova kinda goofy
:(
Only good animation from David Production with Jojo is Part V.
Tell me you never actually watched the Jojo anime without telling me you never actually watched the Jojo anime.
@@carloscauan7967 I probably watched and read this series before you did but keep trying dude.
@@carloscauan7967He's kinda got a point, David Productions has never went above and beyond when it comes to animation. Honestly I think that's something that's holding JoJo back.
you gotta do the whole episode, there's so many problems with the anime and its "faithful to the manga" structure, such as bringing out polnareff to job to DIO and forcing jotaro to distract him (wasting our time as viewers), whereas in the OVA polnareff actually helps jotaro by distracting DIO right before he discovers jotaro is alive!
it's mucy more than that too, there's so much that happens between joseph's blood being absorbed and DIO's death that was packed with effort and new action events being injected that they just ignored for "faithfulness" even when that stubborn approach david decided to take output a wholly inferior product
araki is not perfect, and the OVA was directed by the likes of katsuhiro otomo and satoshi kon. it's almost laughable to compare that stunning 93 OVA to david's carbon copy of the heavily flawed original.
I was originally going to cover the whole fight but there simply wasn't enough time, I think the fight takes place over at least 3 episodes in the tv anime and 2 in for the ova's. But it would genuinely take almost a month to make a side-by-side comparison like that.
It would either have to be a general overview or a comparison of a specific moment like this one :)
@@forgottenrelics1197 i understand!! but man, this particular topic is one of the most interesting differences in adaptation wars. i would love to see more content involving the jojo ova and anime :)
Absolutely awful video with no conclusion stretched out to 8 minutes for no reason (except ads ofc)
Bruh 😐