Pashtuns, Tajiks, Uzbeks… : Afghanistan's Ethnic Cocktail |
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2024
- Watch full episode: • #AskAbhijit 38: Taliba...
#Afghanistan #Taliban
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/Abhi...
►Become A Member on TH-cam: / @abhijitchavda
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOIN #AbhijitChavda
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AbhijitChavdaPodcast
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Spotify: open.spotify.c...
★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
★Google Podcasts: podcasts.googl...
★Stitcher: www.stitcher.c...
★Amazon Music: music.amazon.i...
★Soundcloud: / abhijitchavda
★Audible: www.audible.co...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow
Thank you for watching!
Please share the video and spread the message. 🙏
I did my dna test and uploaded it to Ged match and it says I have baloch, Tajik afghan , Uzbek, Turk , iraqi , Kurd. Both of my parents and grandparents and great’s grandparents are Mexican. Thank you so much for this video. I wish I knew who came from this area from my family.
😂😂😂😂
Ethnic cocktail!!!😂😂😂😂
😂
@@haristufail2121 partition was due to one reason and that's i s l a m ..get over this bs
@@haristufail2121 warrior blood ?, Pakistan is literally conquered by everyone,
The pashtuns are an Eastern iranian ethnic group just like the tajiks. There is noting remotely Indian about either group. The region which we call afghanistan now was part of the mauryan empire for a short while. That does not make the afghanistani people Indian. Don't forget, the Indian subcontinent was ruled for centuries upon centuries by iranian and turk conquerors.
If ur history sense is 1500yrs span then its ok, but history goes long back, afghan was clearly part of ancient india, they were called Ghandhara, todays Kandahar in Mahabharat which is atleast 5k yrs ago
@@akashkp8707right 👍
@@akashkp8707it was called gandahara under. Chinese Buddhist empire you id iot
@@akashkp8707 so you consider pashtoons/pathans as (Northern Indian) ???
@@akashkp8707Gandhara and kandhar are completely different youre lying here secondly indian and iranian cuktures re different and have been different.Gandhara starts fron hindukush mountains and ends at potohar region in punjab.This are was indeed inhabited by indic tribes but these populations were decimated by turkic and iranian invasions in the pre islamic hephtalite/kushan e.t.c invasions and later starting from islamic ghaznavids/ghaurids invasions they were utterly destroyed theres a reason why these mountains are called hindukush.it was so much devastating that the native buddhists and hindus had to flee for europe in the west (the romas) and also for east deeper into india.Pashtuns only started inhabiting these regions 6 to 7 centuries ago.the areas of afghanistan has almost always been under iranian influence and pashtuns sfarred descending from the central asia no more than 2500 hundred years ago
These all countries end with a word stan, in them which is just Sanskrit word sthan, means place,
@shiva 🤣🤣 fake andhnamzi theory
@shiva I think you are correct.
Woh too hai
@shiva abey ncert ke chaaatukaaar , at least know the history from true sources , from evidences😐
@shivawhat are your views on Aryan Migration Theory
Afghanistan was part of Persia, this land belongs who ever lived and ruled, which includes, Persian/Tajiks, Pashtuns, and Turks.
Asmani kitab says der was no Persia even.So pls don't share ur asmani history.Earth is flat kind of a thing
@@109kunal yeah according to this guy history is 1400 yearsold bhai go before islam and you will find out that afghanistan especially kabul and kandhar were part of india
@@109kunal everything is not in india i myself pashtuns do you ever heard how pashto language souds ..more like persian ..bro plz do your research we were never indians we are eastern iranian people that what genetics shows ..our skin colour eyes colour hairs colour tells different story what this guy is telling us in video ..Indians ends with punjab .Their not a single common word between pashto and punjabi how come that ?
@Khattak Productions before pashto came hindus and Buddhist were there read about gandhar which became kandahar.Oh I forgot u r thought history in some madrasa where they teach u earth is flat
@@109kunal oh fuck what i am trying to say ..i am sincerely asking you to do your own research ..btw pashto is not a religion bro it is a language we Pashtuns speak ..its our language what has religion to do with ethnicity ... Plz sincerely do research and let me know if i am wrong then you can correct me..i had already told you that our Afghan culture shows many of our forefathers are buddhist . and then afterwards they converted to islam ..so what is the realtion between being buddhist and indian..buddhism is all over the world so all the buddhists of thailand myanmar china will be considered indians? No they will not because there is a difference between ethnicity and religion ..hope you will get my point and just go to any research paper book whatever you find which discussed about the Gene Study of Pashtuns ..there are plenty of research not by us but by many europeans and American ..Go and study that and let me know if i am wrong
I am Hazara and according to 23andme I have 80% Central Asia/ 11% Mongolia / 5% West Asia / 2% South Asia
According to myheritage I have 80% Central Asia / 7% Europe / 7% South Asia / 2% West Asia / 1% Native American
Good, u are 'global' 😁...join UN! 🙄😎
Then you have to learn your mother language (Uzbek)
Honestly, at this point everyone in Afghanistan is mixed with each other. I know a Pashtun guy who has cousins, they identify themselves as Uzbek and Tajik. To all Afghans, please stop spreading hate towards each other. It's not going to solve the issues of Afghanistan rather it would make it worse. You all should see each other us human beings whose belong to world.
Pashtuns are native to the southern part of Afghanistan. The Hazaras and Tajiks are the indigenous people of Afghanistan (central and northern Afghanistan). Hazaras and Tajiks speak a dialect of Persian. Pashtuns are a different race, their lands were cut in half with the Duran line. Half the Pashtuns are in Pakistan, half in Afghanistan. Pashtuns are a desi ethnic group. The rest of the Afghans are turkic or persian or a mix.
Wow - go read history. Who was Durrani. For as long as time and history have been recorded, Pashtuns have been synonymous with the term Afghan. If you're that obsessed with Tajiks and HAzaras, you have your own country to the north. Go right back. Pashtuns have always led Afghanistan and will always lead Afghanistan.
@@mastodonpatrol5750 I am Pashtun, but I’m not an uneducated one like some lol
@@emadh.3538 no pashtun says they are desi lmao
Hazaras arent native
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Not most of but there are some people in Pakistan that say that they belong to Arab or Turk tribes like Sayyad, Qurashi etc claim themselves as Arab while Mughals of Pakistan claim that they are Turks.
I was in a ClubHouse room with the geneticist Razib Khan. He said that Pashtuns were people at the periphery of Indus Valley, thus belonging to the same civilizational continuum. He also debunked that Pashtuns have Jewish ancestry and said these theories are usually made up by some crazy evangelical Rabbis.
Another point he made was that Pashtuns have lower occurance of Central Asian ancestry than even some groups in India, thus they are also no connected to Turks or Mongols.
Some of the Afghans/ Pashtuns are evidently "Israelites", i.e. lost or migrated tribes from the ancient kingdom of "Israel". Mind u, NOT fr the 'Kingdom of Judea' or as popularly as "Jews"! One ethnologist/ researcher found out that they resented the idea when called "Jews" and stated they were direct descendant of ' Israelites' ( ancient kingdom). This applies to quite a few groups in Northern Pakistan and Kashmir. All these tribes/ groups/ cohorts have "Israeli" genetic markers...as per quite a few researches. Even the folklore...common stories within these groups/ tribes conform to the exact known tales / Biblical descriptions!!
@@zyT175 true, overwhelmingly that is true...but there are tribes/ grps/ sects that tell those tales and their phenotypes also show that they are related to ' Semitic' / Middle Eastern people and not ' Indo-Aryan' or ' Indo- Iranian' cohorts. Truth be told, the genetic admixture of South Asia - India - Pakistan - Afghanistan- Nepal...is so old ( now estimated to be 10,000 years timeband!) that unless there is an large sample, omnibus genetic mapping study, there will always be info that comes in bits and pieces...and confusing!! 😊😁✌
@@zyT175 yes, agree with u partly! The IVC ( Indus Valley Civilization) spread from Western part of U P ( Uttar Pradesh state, India) in North India...right uptil Eastern Afghanistan, what was known as ancient ' Gandhara Civilization', i.e., modern day Kandhahar etc! Gandhara Art, Gandhara sculpture ...Buddhist art are world famous...as u wud surely know. The archelogicsl sites and diggings prove so clearly! So one can't deny tangible evidence, can one? ' South Asian' is a geographically recent name! It was know as "India" ( Roman) or " Indoi" ( Greek) since over 5000 years, bro'!! Yes, the central and Western half of Afghsnistan ( name derived fr Sanskrit ' Ashwa Gana', meaning ' Horse People) are more aligned towards Iran / Fars erc. Btw, Vedic Sanskrit and Iranic/ Old Avestan/ Parsi ( Frasi) are ABSOLUTE ' sister languages' and the civilizations and emerged out of the same ' Indo- Aryan' ( note ' Aryan' and ' Iran' are cognate words) ppl/ culture that is
to be found in the Rig Vedic text!!
@@zyT175 Even when u examine the ancient texts of Bharat ( the ancient name of ' undivided India'), like"Mahabharata", u will find central characters like Queen ' Gandhari', who was a princess fr Gandhara Kingdom ( Kandhahar), married to blind prince Dhritarastra of Kuru kingdom. The brother of Gandhari was ' Shakuni' another central character of the epic text!! So these countries/ kingdoms/ satraps were always interacting/ intermingling and evolving over millennia! You might say present day Afghanistan was/ is an 'overlapping' geography!! 😊✌
@@zyT175 If u want to believe absolutely who can stop u?! But if I am showing u recorded, scientific evidence and genetic mapps, and u still living in denial, then that is ur adamant attitude. What can one say? 🙄😊...be happy brother! Btw, where are u from? Pakistan or Afg?
Hazara's being dependents of thr Mongolian soldiers is not contested to be true. There is very little evidence of them being dependents of Mongolian soldiers. However there is a theory of them being mixed with turkic and Mongolian, not just Mongolian. Please don't spread false statements that has already been debunked.
yeh i took a dna test and the closet ethnic groups were turkic people not persian or mongolian
Tajiks are the smartest ones traditionally dominating commerce and politics in Afghanistan ? Asking for a friend
@@xanshen9011 no their not we don't associate with pashtuns, tajiks are different thank you
@@xanshen9011 no bro pashtusn and tajisk are enemies stop lying we fight each other u fascist aughan
@@mariach9966 thank u
@@goodjob2876 i dont understand ur comment. Ur saying that tajiks are the original ppls which i agree with then you said pashtuns are not indic there iranic? No one said there weren't iranic i said linguistically pashtuns are iranic but not ethnically or historically.
@@tajik2595tajik are our slave😂
Kalash people of north Pakistan still follow the early vedic religion. Please make video on them.
No they dont theyre animists.Indians have an obsession with white skins and want to claim everyone from northern pakistan to germany.Vedic religion formed in punjab and sindh region after aryan steppe invasions no more than 3200 years ago
There is something I want to point out in this video, Abhijit says that the people in the north east are Tajiks and are a minority. Which is true, but people all across the north like Herat, even being on the border with Iran call themselves Tajik. With the exception being the various Turkic minorities on the border. Persian applies to Iran, Upper half of Afghanistan, and Tajikistan. We all speak Farsi or a variant of it. In Afghanistan if you speak Farsi as a native tongue then you are probably viewed as Tajik due to the historical ties we had with Tajikistan during the Samanid Empire.
Pashtuns are East Iranic people. They are not Indians.
However, the Indo-Iranians, or, Aryans were one group of people, more than 4000 years ago.
There has been interaction between Indic and Iranic people, over the course of time.
The hazara don't claim ancestry with Alexander. They claim ancestry with genhgis Khan (the Mongolians). Where do you get your information from?
Also, the tajiks are descendants of the ancient bactrian and soghdians. So how are they not "native"?.
This guy is a nationalist from India. What can you expect?
This man is Hindu nationalist and has no Idea about Afghans ethnic groups, he just goes on bar-king he shows how nonsense he is talking 😂.
Afghanistan was called khurasan, the land of Tajiks, but British change it to Afghanistan, pashtun immigrated from Sulaiman Mountain which is in india with the help and support of British to keep their influence in the region. Tajik and persian are the majority and the real citizen of the country. During the British colonization, a lot of pashtun moved from pakistan to present Afgahnistan to make pashtun dominate, but álmost faild, howevwe, now want to impliment such policy by bringing pashtun taliban again in power, but it will be impossible and a wishless dream.
#AskAbhijit
Most of the north india like UP and Bihar faced lots of destruction but how Nepal has still preserved their culture compared to northern India?? Also, please tell the History of Gorkhas or Gorkha people
Gorkhas, are kshtriya, those who are Gurkha or gorkha are disciples of baba gorkhnath from where they took this identity, the word means go rakshak,
@@ramanpalyal okay
Gorkhas Are The Descendent Of Kashtriy King Bappa Rawal ( Follower Of Sant Gorkh Nath Ji ) Who Defeated Arabs In 734, After War Their Soldiers Left West India And Went To Nepal ( Part Of India ), Married Native Woman's
Up and Bihar is not north India 😂😂😂 you are different from us physically and culturally
@@hdhsnskjv Failed comment ..
You are probably someone who believes that Punjabis are fair skinned like kashmiri and nuristani people. ...
Stop peddling lies khalastani supremacist .
#AskAbhijit Are the Rigvedic Pakthas tribe present-day Pashtuns?
Pashtuns are Hindus, who got converted to Islam, when we talk about minorities in Afghanistan like Sikhs and Hindus, they are also pakhtuns who didn't converted, just 1200 years back Afghanistan was ruled under Brahman shahi kingdom.
Pashtuns were Buddhist before Turks forcibly converted them
@@SanjayRoy-vz5ih They were Hindus before Ashoka. Panini was a Hindu from Pushkalavati(Now Charsadda).
@Chachu P 🤣🤣
@Chachu P no they are aliens came from Mars.
Leave us afghans alone
One of very good QnA.
Afghanistan is an artificial country created by the British. Tajiks are not the minority in Afghanistan either, and Pashtuns are natives of Afghanistan - all these are yet to be supported by facts & evidence- - this video offers interesting information but has many many inaccurate. People known today as Tajiks and Pashtuns are genetically pretty much the same, however culturally and linguistically different. Yet Pashtun's origin is a question to date simply because of war, lack of record keeping and general neglect. Hazaras genetically show a mix of Mongolian and eastern Asian DNA, but their origin is yet to be cleared. You have Turkmans, Aimqa, Uzbeks, Kyrgyz, and many other tribes that ethically and genetically are linked to tajiks, but they are labelled differently. Also, those who say tajiks are from Tajikistan are oxymorons who also call Fari Dari. Tajik literary means not a Turk, a term adopted as Turk numbers grew in other parts of the country. All that aside modern state of Afghanistan is nothing more than a British cluster fuck
@terroristrepublicofindia hi troll, thanks for introducing yourself. I guess reading is not your strong suit.
Im pakistani but I think our country is created by British in 1947
@@BarlasF, of course, do you think the British Empire creating reserve countries in the conflicted areas was pure luck? Pakistan is half India, and the other half is from the Persian Empire, which never belonged to Britain in the first place. Plus, Gandi, Jennah and all those involved in the division of 1947 were sold-out agents. The most recent division was in the 90s Yugoslavia - the same division plan by a fake ethnic majority in a conflict zone. You have to be a historian to know the mess was created intentionally.
Pashtuns are Iranic peoples like Tajiks , Kurds and others they are not Indo Aryan peoples like Indians
Iranians are themselves Indo Aryans. 😂😂
pashtuns are linguistically iranic but not ethnically. Their ethnic group is nomadic tribal peoples. They migrated from the sulieman range 300 yrs ago then settled in southern afg. They have their own laws and culture.
@@mariach9966 😂😂😂 what do you saying Pashtuns are Iranic peoples Iranic is ethnolinguistic group is a group that is unified by both a common ethnicity and language
@@mariach9966 Modern Iranian peoples include the Baloch, Gilaks, Kurds, Lurs, Mazanderanis, Ossetians, Pamiris, Pashtuns, Persians, Tats, Tajiks, Talysh, Wakhis, Yaghnobis, and Zazas. Their current distribution spreads across the Iranian Plateau, stretching from the Caucasus in the north to the Persian Gulf in the south and from Eastern Turkey in the west to Western Xinjiang in the east[16]-a region that is sometimes called the Iranian Cultural Continent, representing the extent of the Iranian-speakers and the significant influence of the Iranian peoples through the geopolitical reach of Greater Iran.[17]
@@yaqubleis6311 bruh thats what i was saying.... both pashtuns and baloch are nomadic tribal ppls who are linguistically iranic relax.
Your absolutely right the original Afghans are hindo aryan mixed which linked to north indian . I am Afghan after dna test thats what i found north india 41 % 31 % Afghan and did more research on the original Afghan people and got Hindo Aryan
You are 50 percent Iranian so you are not Indian like Hindus, stop compare yourself self with Hindus I am Afghan too
@@ayk875Nope He said 50% is Indian stop lying
#AskAbhijit Sir I want to know about the barbaric acts of Britishers in India because as per our Great NCERT books Britishers only did reforms in the society.
This "reform" thing really created a rift between the congress party and two factions were developed one was naram dal and other was garam dal, the garam dal which included tilak, rai and pal was of the opinion that Independace should be first priority and reform should be the next while the former group was of the opposite opinion.
I am a Pashtun and totally reject connection to Hindus our ancestors follow ibrahimi religion. Gandaraha has nothing to do with Pashtuns. Ashoka and Chauhan are not Pashtuns or links to Pashtuns because every Pashtun belongs to a tribe which these people don’t. Pashtu is an eastern Iranian language and only similar to that.
@@appleNomi oh bhai...it does not matter whether u "reject" it or not!! Facts and science cannot be denied! Yes, oc course, Pashtun is an Eastern Iranic language. True. But so is Sanskrit, a 'sister' language to Farsi/ Parsi in the ' Indo-European' grp of languages! So, the Pashtun speakers in 'Purushpur'( ancient Sanskrit name of Peshawar/ 'Pekhwar') are definitely descendants of Vedic ppl fr their matrilenial side at least! How can u deny history! When the Scythians (one of ancient ancestors of Pashtuns) came, when the Hepthalites ( known as 'White Hunas' and later 'Abdalis' )...they came on horseback. And most took wives/ partners locally...as was the norm of invaders. The invaders never brought their tribal families along. That's well established. The Heptalites ruled a large part of Ancient North India including what is North Pakistan/ Gilgit Baltistan/Kashmir/ to the East uptil Mathura and right uptil Western Nepal! So the Hepthalite influence and gene spread far and wide. The most famous among the Hepthalite was King ' Kanishka', who's statues and artifacts are still preserved in Northern Pakistan / Peshwar and Indian museums! He embraced Buddhism and helped spread the message frm Kashmir, North India to across the borders into Central Asia. Most of the ' Gandhara Art' ( found in Pakistan/ Gilgit/ Northern Afghanistan like Bamian) are because of the ancient ruler ' Kanishka'. You don't need to take my word. Go to ur local museum, library...talk to univ professors and u will find the truth!!
Bullshit! Just stop bragging when you don't know anything about a topic. What is the need to speak if have got no clue whatsoever about a region and its people. As an Afghan, I can clearly say that whatever you said is totally wrong.
Bro truth is had to digest
@@craftyunicorn4291 no for u ppl. Go and have a DNA test lol
@@mastodonpatrol5750 like seriously many Afghan have DNA test. Are you kidding me
Its a shame because I love all my Indo aryan brothers and sisters yet they keep claiming different desecents that contradict their actual origins which is south asian this includes the people native to pakistan and Afghanistan. The Hazaras who are mongolian and the Turkic groups such as Uzbeks and Turkmens are the exception, who are not south Asian but true central asians. Pashtuns are south asian, even dna proves it repeatedly
@@bharatv5563 I know that the Aryan Invasion is fake. I was using an example to to describe the region not the actual ethnicity
WTF as a pashtun my dna said 40 percent irrish bruhh
@Chachu P um no they are not. Jewish people are semitic and my wife actually has Jewish ancestry in her. She did a two test to confirm it and sure enough the both came up with Jewish ancestry. Pashtuns are not Jews just like Burushos are not macedonian or albanian. Pashtuns are quite clear a combination of persian and Indian populations, not Jewish. Pakistanis do the same thing with the arab and Turk theory and it is not true
@@turabkhan5306 well you know that there was occupation of the british at one time but you have to read about that. They never conquered them but they did occupy. Also you should read up on admixtures in different ethnic populations
@@ulrichenry4881 yes, but a certain section of Pashtuns are 'Israelite' descent, NOT 'Jews'. There were 2 kingdoms, Israel and Judea ( and they were not exactly friends). And these grp among Pashtuns have a very old familial tale that says they were fr Israel. Many grps, in and around the area, e.g., a cohort in Kashmir seem to hv direct connection with Israelites ( not necessarily Judeans)...
this man is just bluffing Regarding HISTORY and GENETICS. He got his knowledge from some youtube videos and nothing more.
How
He is an emminent historian of India,
Pashtuns aren't Indian (by subcontinent) they are iranian , Iranian and indo-aryan are two branches of same subgroup.
There language family maybe iranian but they are an extention of South asians
@@Shiva-nx1tnImpossible. indus river is the natural border between Iranic peoples and indic people.
@@BarlasF nope Even If You say Indus valley check lower afghanistan was a colony of Indus valley
#askabhijit can there be an asian united like european unioun, if yes, what should be done?
I don't think it's possible as everyone in the Asia has some problem on or the other so I don't think it is possible in near future but in 30-40 year there is a slight chance the union might take place as nowadays leaders wouldn't be there.
@@zeus1962 We Have Chinese Who want to Rule asia..So they wont Unite.
And Its De facto supporters like Pak
European union is based on Religion even though there's no fuss about it. And that's why they don't Turkey as part of their own.
So for Asia it's Not Possible !!
An Arab can never get along with a pork eating Vietnamese and so on
I have seen a video claiming afghans are jewish. It is bunkum nonsense. Afghans are 50 percent indian. It is an extension of the population of North india. I am 100 percent South Asian. Why people are obsessed with people outside indian subcontinent. I see pakistani people trying to be persians, arabs, central asians. We see this cheap behaviour in all Muslims in indian subcontinent.
Afghans are not 50 percent Indian pajit, Afghans ancestor's are Iranians, don't compare yourself with us we are not the same , even if it is it will be 20 percent bs of your old ancestors live in Afghanistan
@@ayk875 they are fifty percent indians. It is a fact. Other fifty percent indians other fifty percent is central Asians and other nonsense. India is a great civilization. I am just telling about some facts. A person becomes great by his actions. Just because you are Afghan does not make you great. I see such ugly people like you commenting. If you think you don't have any Indian ancestry inspite of all the evidence then you are a lier.a major population of Afghans will have fity percent south Asian ancestry. If you want to deny this fact inspite of all the evidence it means you are a lier. We may find some handful of people with less than 30 percent south Asian ancestry. Just because you are Afghan does not make you great. I see this ugly behaviour.
Not every pakistani is trying to be arab or turkish you guys think that everyone is like you but the fact is from last one thousand years foreigner people ruled you Ghazvavids Ghouris abdalis mughals all are foreigner turks only south indians are the real indians remaining all are mixed
I have to disagree with your comment on hazaras. They are a turko mongol people, hazaras are not an ethnicities but a confederation of tribes from across the world. Linguistically hazaras speak Persian but also have a secondary language in which is practically common with Turks. Then they have a minority language which is common with mongols and they speak a reminante of a language that no one know where it comes from.
I live with hazaras. They're speaking 30% (Uzbek, Turks)
There are about 80 milion pashtuns in the world ❤
Genetic research had showed that we pashtuns are eastern iranian dont make false claims
Oh really pashtun gene's is full of mixture..there is nothing Iranian dna
pashtuns are not iranian.they westerm indians.
Pasthuns of khyber pakhtunwa are more indians than iranian because of they are adjacent to Pakistan punjab and sindh region both pasthuns and baloch are indo iranian genetically and culturally genetically indian are desencents of iranian and west asian before becoming a human
@@mastodonpatrol5750bro if you read the history of Macedonian empire , greco bacaterian empire indian empires such as Mauryan empire , kashmiri karkota dynasty ,hindu shahi dynasty , also persian empires and turkish empires first alcohon huns , nezak huns , kushan empire and Last turk shahis Afghans , Pakistanis and north indians have mixed genitics of indo greeks , indo partians , indo synthians because all rulers ruled in Afghanistan , Pakistan and north west india too
@@zyT175 sindh considered themselves specially sindhi nationalist such as sla considered themselves as indian
Pashtuns are Not Bani israiel and Not turk and Not greece Not Arab . Because pashtuns have longer History then Bani israiel ❤
Yahud
what should be done with the muslims residing in India?
There is nothing you can do to them
@@XalaalSomalis cus their culture is foreign to this land
@@anirudhsevar no its not
Ethnic cleansing
Please do a book recommendation video
Are such ethnic groups as the Tajiks,
respectively, descendant of Indo-Aryans from India's North?
no
@@Tajikdxt They must be blood related to Punjabis, so much similar
Moreover the whole indians are desencents of west asia mostly from iran
@@alimalhi6923they're not similar what so ever
Sir Hajara (who are Shias) ko bhool hi gaye aap. 1880 tak central Afghanistan was Hajaaristan.
@@__Man__ where are you from
Im tajik(lives in india)
ASI is a genetic component which exclusively found in people of Indian subcontinent. Pashtuns are 10 to 15%... Thus, very much Indic.
10 to 15 % is a small number I reckon to be considered as indic.
@@Doomedgorilla nice joke by a Eurasian 🤣
Moreover pashtuns of khyber pakhtunwa are mostly indian because they are adjacent to punjab and sindh region
@@goodjob2876 ... I know all that. Tajiks are original people of Sogdia and Bactria. Pashtuns are mostly Iranic...but have a dash of Indic in their genes
Is there any way Hinduism can be established again in Afghanistan and Pakistan in our life time?
Brown breed lindustani 🐖🇮🇳 talking about pashtoon 😂😂😂😂
First establish hinduism in india😂
@@sameerabbasi8923😂😂😂😂😂
Nicely explained! Also curious about your name, both Punjabi and Rajput?
Pashtuns are very related to Panjabis, while Tajiks are related to Iranians and Tajiks of Tajikistan.
True
Mulla omar Father of Ahmad shah masood😂
@@BahramkhiljiWhy did the one-eyed Dajjal hide in Pakistan, oh yes because he was afraid of Massoud. Hahahaha
@@Bahramkhilji don't use the Turk name's 😂
Ok i have few questions can someone help me please…
1. Is it true that first time in ethnicity/demographic status of Tajik first time recorded in Russian ethnology which was started by Ashkenazi Jewish history of world for empires to analyze?
2. Is it true the word Tajik comes from tardjik which then comes from Sart?
3. Is it also true that in Turan ( Turkistan) farsi speakers of Turkics origins are called Tardjiks which then belonged to mainly Samarkand/Bukhara. Well known fact Samarkand/Bukhara once 80%-90% Farsi speakers now only 2 % farsi.
4. Is it true that first Badge of Tajiks that actually came into Afghanistan from Tajikistan in between 1838-1938? Tajikistan artificially first came into existence via by Russians to seperate Turkic-Uzbek speakers from Turkic-Farsi speakers?
5. Is it also true that 27% of Afghanistan whom are Farsi speakers by mother tongue without lineage lost or mixed now called Tajiks are also mixed with real Tajiks (Central Asian migration era 1838-1938)
6. Is it true Between 1838-1938 its Said Abdur Rahman Khan gave 500,000 individuals who came from Turkistan call tajiks were given land?
7. Does anyone know the total 🟰 number of true Tajikistani Tajik population of all 3 migration phases of tajiks from Turkistan (1838-1858 Russian invasion 320,000 Uzbeks and 450,000 Tajiks) (1861-1898 356,000 Tajiks and 120,000 Uzbeks 15,000 turkman) and of course (1900-1941 119,000 tajiks plus many)
Please be respectful as i have been if you don’t know please don’t respond just randomly
Can you make video of abhira tribe and these descedents.?
Please read some history books,than talk about history of Afghanistan, pushtun is not either dominant or the original ethnicity in Afghanistan, pushtun is coming from the south Asia recently,and British support them to make fake propaganda history.
Mulla omar father of ahmad shah pig😂
Ok can you tell us who are the real ethnicity of Afghanistan? Kulabi? which have started immigrating in Afghanistan during the Russian empire expansion in 1890 the Amir Habibullah Khan give the land and refuge and of Ghazi Amanullah Khan granted them citizenship. Finally the Saqawathes shows the real Faces.
We pashtun have defended Afghanistan from British imperialism. The people like you are nether a Tajik and nether Afghan. You are refuge's from Kulab. Serve yours god rahmanrahuf . Sissy
I 100% disagree with u my brother.
DNA proves that Pashtun are from central Asian. Because Pashtun 65% DNA match with tajiks.
Check it
Some says they are from Iran, some says they are lost Israeli tribe
@@Alice-7777
Just look at their action and behaviour pattern, They fire up bomb in Israel and in Afghanistan as well , so both of them descended of King David and King Saul, and both of these kings had schizophrenia which explains today's situation
Beg to differ with your statement of Pakistani population trying to prove Turkish or Turkic origin. Not the case.
People with Turkic roots such as Mughals Khiljis, Chugtais, chengezis, Qizilbash etc claim turkic roots and they have the right to do so. Muslim Rajputs, Jats Aheers, Brahmin converts, Baluch or Pashtun never claim Turkic origin.
Never heard Afghan Pashtuns claiming we are lost Israeli tribe; is this theory popular among Pakistani Pashtuns?
watch Rudy rochman he ask question also to afghan pashtons they also say that we are bani israil
@@IbrahimKhan-id6wiMaybe they found some who were told this from the internet. Otherwise, not a locally accepted theory.
what about the balochis? are they descendants of the people living in the corresponding place, of ancient bharatvarsha?
Bharat was only few parts of north India. It's only Muslims who United HINDUSTAN
@@syedabbas5822false claim S there are many empires and cultural similarities everywhere
The Scythians migrated or came to India's North, which would be Rajasthan and Punjab...and then branched out?
Pashtun are the most hated and rejected ethnic both inside Afghanistan 🇦🇫 and Pakistan 🇵🇰
Pashtun conquerd both and trolled you all😂
@@BarlasF Punjab owns you 🤣.
@@randomfootages9120 we have a big share in pak army politics, no own any any one in Pakistan its a federation lol 😝
@@BarlasF you people are being ruled and controlled by Punjabi 😂.
Pashtuns are like Jews in the Middle East nobody likes them, oh yes they are one and the same
Za paktoon ym kakar from India 🇮🇳
AskAbhijit# Will there be any apocalyptic situation in the coming future, and what type will it be?
Aliens , viruses (Zombies), diseases,etc.
yes you are first
Yeah but please comment something else, it's annoying to comment first word only
@@simulify8726 sorry
#AskAbhijit Is the practice of SATI a hindu belief or medieval superstitious belief? What is the origin of SATI?
Ever heard of witch hunting
@@simrank5370 yes, I have What happened to 'Joan of arc' is a great example.
@@MrSaran1988 Abhijit sir has already made a video on it.
Search "Abhijit Chawda Sati"
Afghanistan thank you for giving feroze khan and kader khan
There are several theories and schools of ethnographic postulates - among Pashtuns there is diversity and admixture. One school of thought claims they are a mixture of Rajput and Iranic...another says they are Iranic n Hepthalite ( Abdali ppl) mixture ..another says they descended fr Israelites ( note ' Israelites' not fr Judea kingdom, who were called Jews!) ...and still others Vedic ( Aryans) and Hepthalite/ Mongol admixture! The truth lies somewhere in the middle...like ALL ethnicities in the subcontinent Pashtuns are also an ' ethnolinguistic' grp that has, for obvious reasons, a varied genetic profile!
You are very ill informed and biased.right in the start you started with a blatant lie pashtuns are not the people of gandhara and thus mahabharata.Pashtuns started invading the region comprising gandhara about 6 or 7 centuries ago.starting from ghaznavid and ghaurid period the native populations of gandhara were decimated and gradually replaced by the pashtuns.
@@bilalkhanmuhammadzai3340 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂, and where did these Pashtuns come from ?, they magically appeared like the aasmani kitaab from the sky ?, pathetic caveman afghandu
Pashtuns are eastern Iranians
Nope
Please tell us about cast mess.
Schaduled cast. Who is responsible
for this mess.
We as a society are responsible to transform a system to benefit the ppl to hold on to privilege and power they didn't earn
Dna or khoon is important as it denotes ones founder n history
The ethnicity of pakhtoon are contested but the theory of Aryan and Bani isreal are best suited from all angle and you have beautifully lied that the theory of Bani isreali is non existentential at all and it has been debunk by many medical test but you must need to educate yourself in this regard, in many history book pakhtoon are described as bani isreal and the oldest record is from 9th century and many indian subcontinent historical records as well and recently an isreali organisation conducted an DNA test on a town in U.P (mahliabad as far as i remembered) in which pakhtoon of Afridi tribe was examined, even though paktoon in decently india are mixed with other Muslim but the result are astonishingly similar. Moreover the first prime minister of isreal wrote a book on lost tribe of isreal and dedicated a whole chapter to paktoon/pashtun. As isreal believe that until and unless all lost will not returned to holy land then there messiah will not return. Moreover they have made a song on pakhtoon as bani isreal. I have watch many videos of Rabbi (jews priest) almost all have same instance and used to describe us lost cousin/distance cousin.
I will try to post videos in this comment section.
But pakhtoon have india ancestry is a total myth used to spread by ultra nationalist indian.
Haplogoup tells all my friends..
We are indians 😂😅
#AskAbhijit How was Razia Sultan?
Overrated
I think she must be beautiful
@@MAni-wm1lc why??
@@anahita934 just for fun
Tajik and Pashton are Iranian
Sir aapko follow karta hoon
Uzbek Türkmen is turk
You need to update and re study your history; Kandahar was the Hazara =Azra Turkic Persian speaking people areas and ruling under Amir=leaders. Many historian from chines to greek all with the same conclusion that the Hazara are the oldest group of people residing in Afghanistan.
The Tadjiks should be in Tadjikistan and Tadjikistan should be again an entire Tadjikistan including the current north-eastern Afghan province of Badakhshan.
Afghanistan belongs to the true Afghans whose descendents are in "Nuristan". The ancient regions of Bactriana and Margiana are their original homeland, far bigger than the small mountainous place where they are now.
Pashtuns should have their country, a Pashtunistan that the British chose to make impossible.
Afghanistan - the name is pretty recent and yes and it was given by a pashtun ruler.. otherwise it was mostly knows as aryana way before and khorasan later
Tajiks can go to Tajikistan 😂
pashtoon culture and tradition are 5 thousand year old and you gujjrat is 7 hundrad year old you copy our culture so that not make any sense to interlink with your self
You are crazy bro, Pashtuns are %40 Indi, %11 jewish and %30 turk.
Native are Pashtuns?
What the hell is indo Iranian, indian are Iranian hindi
Shame on you
False statements
You have no idea what the he’ll your talking about 😂
IF YOU DON'T KNOW SOMETHING DON'T SPEAK , NEVER pakistanese cannot be equal with TURKIC nations even Tajikistan OK Pakistanese same with indians and mixed with afghans ok .NEVER mix cultures
😂i never heard a single pakistani calling himself arbic or Persian this shows your research 😂
You need to do more research facts are facts it's has nothing to do with your sentiments hope your community understand it
Everything u said was wrong
Mahabharat is Mythology