even though i dont know some of the players, this criteria is better than most, even the irl version was bad and as he said, most of em only included stars instead who was the best statistically
@KEVIn-dq6pm No one will take a team of season that has lower leagues like the MLS and Japanese league seriously. The Club World Cup already showcase how inferior those leagues are.
I love it when Europe isn't the center of focus in these kinds of awards. Football is growing worldwide and many great players and leagues deserve recognition despite no TV deals.
I'm sorry but this lineup would get destroyed by so many European clubs. They are putting two strikers that haven't proven themselves in the toughest Leagues ahead of Halaand, Mbappe, Hary Kane, Osimhen, etc. I'll bet my nutsack that if those two strikers played in LA liga, Epl or Serie A, they won't even get half the numbers they are getting now. And they are putting an MLS star who's 5'3 ahead of the likes of De Bruyne, Bruno, Bernardo, Odegaard, Maddison, Pedri, etc. This is definitely not the Best XI. This is more like "Players that I think are the best"
@@benedictjajothey state in the video and description that this isn't the best XI in the world, but XI standout players. With an added twist that only 1 player from each league. No need to get defensive from an XI that is unique and not trying to overstep any bounds here
I guess it's moderately interesting to pick one player from each league, but using any sort of "Team of 2023"-like title seems completely out of place.
I've been wishing Liverpool would sign him for 3-4 years now lol . The guy is the complete CB, great in the air, accurate long passer as you mentioned, leadership, tackler, playing out from the back etc and also left footed .
@@kieran8845like vvd. Vvd is also pretty complete ngl. But dont you guys have quansah? Ive seen him in some europa league games and vs burnley and he looked incredible
Loved the video and the format, but as a Fluminense supporter I must add that German Cano at 35 years have numbers comparable to Haaland and Mbappé. His performance at Fluminense it's astonishing and he has become a club's legend. It would be cool to see a "Best team of each continent (UEFA, CONMEBOL etc.)". Thanks for the video and happy 2024! 🎉
LMFAOOOOOO you compared him to Haaland and Mbappe??? Buddy the Brazilian league is EXTREMELY WEAK compared to Europe’s Top 5 leagues. You can even say Portuguese and Dutch leagues are stronger too. That’s why you guys can never win the club World Cup, because only European clubs do
@@Mark-in4fr Welp, just reviewing the champions of the club World Cup says that you are lying. Brazilian teams have won the club World Cup. In fact, the first three times in a row they did. Chelsea also lost to a Brazilian side in 2012, and they almost lost again in 2021. I agree comparing him to Haaland and Mbappe is wrong, but I think you are mislead.
I love this concept! Great team as well. I was inspired to do my own, with the added challenge of not being allowed to use any of the players from Tifo's team: Zion Suzuki - Urawara Reds (J1 League) Lutsharel Geertruida - Feyenoord (Eredivisie) John Stones - Manchester City (Premier League) Piero Hincapié - Bayer Leverkusen (Bundesliga) Federico Di Marco - Inter (Serie A) Florentino Luis - Benfica (Primeira Liga) André Trindade - Fluminense (Campeonato Brasileiro Serie A) Oscar - Shanghai Port (CSL) Lionel Messi - Inter Miami (MLS) Peter Shalulile - Mamelodi Sundowns (PSL) Antoine Griezmann - Atletico Madrid (La Liga)
I think di marco is a really solid honorable mention for the left back position.. He had a break-out 2022-23 and he's by far one of the most offensively gifted full-backs in the world right now
Thank you for recognising el shenawy and what he's doing he's been the best player in Africa for the past couple of years . Al Ahly don't really get the recognition it deserves although its the most decorated club in the world and is always competing at the world stage❤ 🦅🦅
This TOTY refers to all leagues and has a variety of players, showing that you really care about what you're doing and do a lot of research but I don't think players who got their first impressive season will be compared to European giants. I mean, Kane will obviously have a part in the attack, other skilful wingers too etc. The team is creative but extremely hard to actually happen.
Yeah but it's Suarez. Man's an absolute baller and a legend, so him winning a vote is kinda obvious. Not to detract from his performance, one of the best strikers ever at his peak and still an absolute monster
@@thejukesterMonster indeed. Why did Suarez’ reputation go unaffected by the fact he’s a racist cannibal? Talented, but character is a massive part of world-class footballers, and Suarez has none.
Both Hancko and Giménez really stood out this calender year. Both would've been great in this team. Though I can't name a defender from the J-League you'd need to complete the switch. Or play a very attacking 3-4-3...
This video is great because it highlights those that do not have the luxury of being in a wealthy club that tends to win trophies. For the vast majority of teams now, it's no longer about winning trophies, but just having a good season. What that says about modern football is a much larger topic, but it's always good to highlight the outstanding players who have also done excellent.
Thank you for the nomination of Pedro Gonçalves 💚 he deserves it and he is being criticized lately for not being at his best, but he is still really important for Sporting and should be recognised for it, thank you for that Tifo 🙏
As an FC Cincinnati fan Lucho Acosta has been amazing for us. For those who don’t know when we got into the league in 2015 we were dead last 3 seasons in a row. 2021-2022 season helped us make our first ever playoff appearance and obviously this year he’s set the caliber for what we want our club to be he’s like a mini Messi and pretty sure they are decent friends as well
Diego Valdez from the Mexican League deserved a shoutout, amazing year overall playing a Bruno Fernandes-like role and played with the Chilean National Team
"But there’s a catch, we can only include one player from each league. " this basically explains why the list is so weird, love how there are no players from the Portuguese Champions, the Italian Champions, the Spanish Champions, the French Champions nor the World Champions and still have the nerve to call it a Team of the Year.
@@sushipizza4439 he was on team of the year in the argentinean league, so i just snuck him in. Dont really know how good he has been in belgium to be honest
@@beegyoshi5301 i dont even watch belgian league tbh. He wasnt too good in the europa league. I saw his game against Toulouse and liverpool. In those 2 games he made mistakes. I would put aldeweireld over him. He has been superb for Antwerp. Sorry for the spelling. I like grabara in goal though and other shouts. Solid team
Leandro Morgalla of now Red Bull Salzburg could've been a shout Started 2023 at 1860 München in the 3.Liga as a 17 year old and bossed the league leading to a team of the season choice in the 3. Liga. He now plays in the Austrian first division and the Champions League BUT I'm also an 1860 fan so maybe a bit bias
Suggestion: Dzecko as a striker would have also had a case. Man's been playing for so long, reached a CL final with inter last season and is now tearing up the Süper League in Turkey. But solid choices
Picking a Eredivisie player in the wrong position when Santi Gimenez has been sensational this year is just wrong. You talk about improvement being a huge factor, Gimenez scored just 7 league goals in 2022. The man has over 30 in 2023 and in a new league. There is absolutely no reason to not include him in this list.
Hancko plays left back for his country, so it isn't totally out of position. He also has played at least some minutes at left back for feyenoord. Gimenez is a star but Hancko is probably almost as important for Feyenoord
I really liked this video. This team is well balanced across age and nationality, and shows that there are footballers who are absolutely balling everywhere, not just in Europe. Plenty of players mentioned who I'd never heard of.
As a Sporting fan I don't really think Pedro Gonçalves should be in here. I mean yeah he got good stats but I think Gyokeres would be better, i know theres already 2 ST but idk, maybe even Morita could be here, he is one of the most underrated CMs around
You guys should do another video of the best players in any League not limited to yourself to one per country even if the players are all from the same league it doesn't matter because we all know the best players all play in England or Spain
Dear Tifo Football Creators , please restart the Sensible Transfers series . As a regular viewer it helped me to know more about the tactical and technical aspects of football⚽ and how does a team sign a player and what all qualities a certain team wants from a player when they sign him.
Pedro Gonçalves from Sporting has not been having a great year, I think there were better picks, like João Neves, or Gyokeres (even if only for half a year, he has been instrumental for sporting)
I think Erling Haaland Still has to be here if were going for good stories. Imagine coming to a new league and breaking all records and winning throphies along the way. What a storyline that is❤
Why is this not a lets play mode in Fifa? It used to be in ol school PES You could even be a group of friends, make a draft or even randomize, then play a short cup
Akturkoglu should be there, led 2023 in assists, scored twice against United in Champions League, won league, national team made first place in their group to Euros.
typical team of the years are just gonna have 90% premier league players with the occasional non-premier league player in englishmen Bellingham and kane
Last year's FIFA Team of the year was Messi, Benzema, Mbappé, de Bruyne, Modrić, Bellingham, Hernández, van Dijk, Militão, Hakimi and Courtois, with Haaland being the 12th player. Only 3 players are from the PL, 4 from La Liga (all of them from Real Madrid), 3 from Ligue 1 (all PSG), 1 from Bundesliga and Serie A. So Premier league isn't as overrated as you think it is.
Would've made more sense to add Hidemasa Morita instead of Pote for the 8 role so Jude can play farther up more freely. I'm almost certain Morita's transition dribbling and defensive statistics are far superior to Pote's for this year as a whole.
Better than most of the lists of "Team of the Year" that I have seen so far this season.
even though i dont know some of the players, this criteria is better than most, even the irl version was bad and as he said, most of em only included stars instead who was the best statistically
@@KEVIn-dq6pm exactly
@KEVIn-dq6pm No one will take a team of season that has lower leagues like the MLS and Japanese league seriously. The Club World Cup already showcase how inferior those leagues are.
This should've been the IRL video, so much to expand on with the other leagues
They should do both. Have the great animated video and an indepth expansion on it on IRL
They did something similar. Not the same players but still
Wasn’t Jude Bellingham in the IRL video?
yawn. give it a rest.
@@Montycat78 Of course, he's English.
I love it when Europe isn't the center of focus in these kinds of awards. Football is growing worldwide and many great players and leagues deserve recognition despite no TV deals.
I'm sorry but this lineup would get destroyed by so many European clubs.
They are putting two strikers that haven't proven themselves in the toughest Leagues ahead of Halaand, Mbappe, Hary Kane, Osimhen, etc. I'll bet my nutsack that if those two strikers played in LA liga, Epl or Serie A, they won't even get half the numbers they are getting now.
And they are putting an MLS star who's 5'3 ahead of the likes of De Bruyne, Bruno, Bernardo, Odegaard, Maddison, Pedri, etc.
This is definitely not the Best XI. This is more like "Players that I think are the best"
@@benedictjajothey state in the video and description that this isn't the best XI in the world, but XI standout players. With an added twist that only 1 player from each league. No need to get defensive from an XI that is unique and not trying to overstep any bounds here
I guess it's moderately interesting to pick one player from each league, but using any sort of "Team of 2023"-like title seems completely out of place.
@@JasonRennie it's called a Challenge for a reason.
@@benedictjajo may I suggest you actually listen to the video before talking bs? it's called a Challenge for a reason.
Bastoni's long pass accuracy is INSANE, he is literally a passing sharpshooter
I've been wishing Liverpool would sign him for 3-4 years now lol . The guy is the complete CB, great in the air, accurate long passer as you mentioned, leadership, tackler, playing out from the back etc and also left footed .
@@kieran8845like vvd. Vvd is also pretty complete ngl. But dont you guys have quansah? Ive seen him in some europa league games and vs burnley and he looked incredible
Me too
This is already 100 times better than any other “Team of the Year” I’ve seen , top content as always
Loved the video and the format, but as a Fluminense supporter I must add that German Cano at 35 years have numbers comparable to Haaland and Mbappé. His performance at Fluminense it's astonishing and he has become a club's legend.
It would be cool to see a "Best team of each continent (UEFA, CONMEBOL etc.)".
Thanks for the video and happy 2024! 🎉
LMFAOOOOOO you compared him to Haaland and Mbappe??? Buddy the Brazilian league is EXTREMELY WEAK compared to Europe’s Top 5 leagues. You can even say Portuguese and Dutch leagues are stronger too. That’s why you guys can never win the club World Cup, because only European clubs do
@@Mark-in4frextremely weak? they got 80 matches per year. MORE than Europe normal league.
@@thoriqakbarthat explains why he has so much goals
@@thoriqakbareh? How does playing more matches mean you’re better 😂😂
@@Mark-in4fr Welp, just reviewing the champions of the club World Cup says that you are lying. Brazilian teams have won the club World Cup. In fact, the first three times in a row they did. Chelsea also lost to a Brazilian side in 2012, and they almost lost again in 2021. I agree comparing him to Haaland and Mbappe is wrong, but I think you are mislead.
I love this concept! Great team as well. I was inspired to do my own, with the added challenge of not being allowed to use any of the players from Tifo's team:
Zion Suzuki - Urawara Reds (J1 League)
Lutsharel Geertruida - Feyenoord (Eredivisie)
John Stones - Manchester City (Premier League)
Piero Hincapié - Bayer Leverkusen (Bundesliga)
Federico Di Marco - Inter (Serie A)
Florentino Luis - Benfica (Primeira Liga)
André Trindade - Fluminense (Campeonato Brasileiro Serie A)
Oscar - Shanghai Port (CSL)
Lionel Messi - Inter Miami (MLS)
Peter Shalulile - Mamelodi Sundowns (PSL)
Antoine Griezmann - Atletico Madrid (La Liga)
As a Leverkusen fan, Hincapie really shouldn't be there. Man has barely played this season. Either Grimmaldo, or Kossonou would be a better choice
Tifo just uploaded a video on Oscar!
I think di marco is a really solid honorable mention for the left back position.. He had a break-out 2022-23 and he's by far one of the most offensively gifted full-backs in the world right now
One of the best "team of the year" videos I've seen so far
Amazing choices
I was expecting Endrick to be the one from Brazil's league, but Cano's choice made me so happy. The guy really deserves it.
Todd Boehly gonna add all to cart
Can’t do, none of them play for Brighton.
lmao@@thepeopleslibrary9345
Thank you for recognising el shenawy and what he's doing he's been the best player in Africa for the past couple of years . Al Ahly don't really get the recognition it deserves although its the most decorated club in the world and is always competing at the world stage❤ 🦅🦅
This TOTY refers to all leagues and has a variety of players, showing that you really care about what you're doing and do a lot of research but I don't think players who got their first impressive season will be compared to European giants. I mean, Kane will obviously have a part in the attack, other skilful wingers too etc. The team is creative but extremely hard to actually happen.
I am almost certain that JJ argued vociferously for Pedri instead of Bellingham
I think JJ would argue for Pedri regardless of the question put to him.
"JJ so who do we pick from the Eredivis-"
"Pedri's done well you know"
Great video as always!! Happy Holidays everyone!
Honourable mention for Suarez who was voted player of the year ahead of Cano, despite the fact his team didn't win the league
Yeah but it's Suarez. Man's an absolute baller and a legend, so him winning a vote is kinda obvious. Not to detract from his performance, one of the best strikers ever at his peak and still an absolute monster
@@thejukesterMonster indeed. Why did Suarez’ reputation go unaffected by the fact he’s a racist cannibal? Talented, but character is a massive part of world-class footballers, and Suarez has none.
This is peak sport journalism. Thanks to tifo who provides us more knowledge than any other football media.
As a Sporting CP fan I think that Pedro Gonçalves has had one of his worst years while at the club.
@@HernasRoom all that u said is true but i think tifo could have chosen a better player from Liga Portugal than Pote
@@HernasRoom thats exactly what i thought, and he would suit that 8 role too
You said it Hernas, both a curse and a blessing having stats become so grand in the game.@@HernasRoom
This is by far the best team of the year i've watched!!!!!!
Santi Giménez should’ve be included. Second behind haaland in goals scored this season amongst U23
Both Hancko and Giménez really stood out this calender year. Both would've been great in this team. Though I can't name a defender from the J-League you'd need to complete the switch. Or play a very attacking 3-4-3...
Surely there's a Saudi League player who could slot in at leftback?
@@Jothamvvw nah not telles.
Swap Cano with Gimenez and Hancko with Marcelo?
@@b1ued they had a solid case for selecting Cano, tho...
Cano is such an underrated player
This video is great because it highlights those that do not have the luxury of being in a wealthy club that tends to win trophies. For the vast majority of teams now, it's no longer about winning trophies, but just having a good season. What that says about modern football is a much larger topic, but it's always good to highlight the outstanding players who have also done excellent.
Nice to see Tifo highlighting leagues outside of europe, especially the J League and Brasileirao
Very good concept and execution of this video!
Thank you for the nomination of Pedro Gonçalves 💚 he deserves it and he is being criticized lately for not being at his best, but he is still really important for Sporting and should be recognised for it, thank you for that Tifo 🙏
Was not expecting a Sporting player, but always good to see one of our boys in these lists 💚
As an FC Cincinnati fan Lucho Acosta has been amazing for us. For those who don’t know when we got into the league in 2015 we were dead last 3 seasons in a row. 2021-2022 season helped us make our first ever playoff appearance and obviously this year he’s set the caliber for what we want our club to be he’s like a mini Messi and pretty sure they are decent friends as well
Al ahly fan here, glad to get some recognition
Awesome list. Love seeing Acosta get some love.
Happy new year! This is a great lineup!
i feel like some people don’t appreciate how impressive and good this video is
Diego Valdez from the Mexican League deserved a shoutout, amazing year overall playing a Bruno Fernandes-like role and played with the Chilean National Team
If there wasn't a J League player with outsized grit, I'd never try The Athletic free for 30days. Forza Ryukyu
"But there’s a catch, we can only include one player from each league. " this basically explains why the list is so weird, love how there are no players from the Portuguese Champions, the Italian Champions, the Spanish Champions, the French Champions nor the World Champions and still have the nerve to call it a Team of the Year.
At 35 German Cano has been unbelievable this season for Fluminense and the reason why we got out first Libertadores Cup
Brilliant content, only thing keeping The Athletic interesting.
عالمي يشناوي 🔥❤️
Tried to do this myself with 11 leagues:
Mbappe Suarez Tadic
Grønbæk Bellingham
Di marco Rodri Frimpong
Antonio silva kevin macallister
Grabara
Kevin mac allister? Are you a USG fan or a person who sees the belgian league? Idk what hes really done but idk.
@@sushipizza4439 he was on team of the year in the argentinean league, so i just snuck him in. Dont really know how good he has been in belgium to be honest
@@beegyoshi5301 i dont even watch belgian league tbh. He wasnt too good in the europa league. I saw his game against Toulouse and liverpool. In those 2 games he made mistakes. I would put aldeweireld over him. He has been superb for Antwerp. Sorry for the spelling. I like grabara in goal though and other shouts. Solid team
Terrific video!
Cano is such an amazing player.
Early shout for 2024 - Alex Paulsen from Wellington Phoenix in goal, if only for his penalty saving ability.
This channel deserves way more attention and views than he gets.Keep up man
It's not a single person
You feeling better now?
@@vandiomage-hh3owhe expose your likebait comment buddy 🤡
I thoroughly enjoyed that 👏👏👏👏👏.
Great video, as usual
creative ! loved it
Great content, though if the selection criteria is like this Icardi (preferably) or Torreira should be in this list
Right back should've been Sacha Boey
Central defender must be Acerbi. he stopped everyone (except Ekuban in last 2023 match)
Leandro Morgalla of now Red Bull Salzburg could've been a shout
Started 2023 at 1860 München in the 3.Liga as a 17 year old and bossed the league leading to a team of the season choice in the 3. Liga. He now plays in the Austrian first division and the Champions League
BUT I'm also an 1860 fan so maybe a bit bias
Should do a whole podcast or a longer video on this 😕
Will you do one for women's football?
Suggestion: Dzecko as a striker would have also had a case. Man's been playing for so long, reached a CL final with inter last season and is now tearing up the Süper League in Turkey. But solid choices
Picking a Eredivisie player in the wrong position when Santi Gimenez has been sensational this year is just wrong. You talk about improvement being a huge factor, Gimenez scored just 7 league goals in 2022. The man has over 30 in 2023 and in a new league. There is absolutely no reason to not include him in this list.
You're right, especially since he was not only part of Mexico's triumph at the Gold Cup, but also scored the winning goal in the final.
Hancko plays left back for his country, so it isn't totally out of position. He also has played at least some minutes at left back for feyenoord. Gimenez is a star but Hancko is probably almost as important for Feyenoord
Wow! what a pick kudos.
Certainly an interesting way of doing this list
Great list. And excellent criteria.
I really liked this video. This team is well balanced across age and nationality, and shows that there are footballers who are absolutely balling everywhere, not just in Europe. Plenty of players mentioned who I'd never heard of.
As a Sporting fan I don't really think Pedro Gonçalves should be in here. I mean yeah he got good stats but I think Gyokeres would be better, i know theres already 2 ST but idk, maybe even Morita could be here, he is one of the most underrated CMs around
morita? 🤣🤣 joao neves must play golf
@@afruas he's good too but he kinda only emerged this year
@@Edu23u which is the year the video refers to?
Admin knows ball when they said ManCity is not the same without Rodri. 👏👏👏
Well done Tifo. Well done.
Ahly!❤
You guys should do another video of the best players in any League not limited to yourself to one per country even if the players are all from the same league it doesn't matter because we all know the best players all play in England or Spain
THANK YOU for herman cano!! but what a weird list!! an fc Cincinnati guy??
shenaaaaaaaawy ♥♥♥♥
الله عليك ياشنو ياحبيبنا مشرف مصر
I'm watching this while Rodri just scored against Sheffield ud
Why would you not include an overview of the whole team at the end of the video ???
Tifo please can you Give a better and more Expanded Explanation on the Tifo IRL page 🙏🙏
Looking forward to it
Dear Tifo Football Creators , please restart the Sensible Transfers series . As a regular viewer it helped me to know more about the tactical and technical aspects of football⚽ and how does a team sign a player and what all qualities a certain team wants from a player when they sign him.
Pedro Gonçalves from Sporting has not been having a great year, I think there were better picks, like João Neves, or Gyokeres (even if only for half a year, he has been instrumental for sporting)
Excellent list
Elshenawy is one of the best in saves world wide
I want a cultured passer tattoo 😂
Instead of Goncalves I would put Manuel Ugarte
might just make this squad in FM or Fifa, see how well they do over 5 seasons
That you didnt pick Joey Veerman of PSV is strange.
Incredible Team of the year XI
"Thanks for the shopping list"
Your pals Mo and Todd
FIFA wouldve put only european players thank you for the creativity
James Tavernier?
I think Erling Haaland Still has to be here if were going for good stories. Imagine coming to a new league and breaking all records and winning throphies along the way. What a storyline that is❤
Why is this not a lets play mode in Fifa?
It used to be in ol school PES
You could even be a group of friends, make a draft or even randomize, then play a short cup
GONCALVES INCLUDED
never been this early have a good one yall
You too man, happy holidays
What would a world TOTY look like if you do the selection based solely on their overall score based on performance?
Where would they finish in the prem?
Great to see an ex Celtic player in this list in Jeremie frimpong
Akturkoglu should be there, led 2023 in assists, scored twice against United in Champions League, won league, national team made first place in their group to Euros.
Imma make this team in UT and get absolutely battered, but it’ll be fun 😊
Well it’s missing three players, so not off to a great start
@@callum2474 Try it in football manager
Missing Amahl Pellegrino
Should have included saudi pro league
PLEASE MAKE SENSIBLE TRANSFERS
typical team of the years are just gonna have 90% premier league players with the occasional non-premier league player in englishmen Bellingham and kane
Last year's FIFA Team of the year was Messi, Benzema, Mbappé, de Bruyne, Modrić, Bellingham, Hernández, van Dijk, Militão, Hakimi and Courtois, with Haaland being the 12th player.
Only 3 players are from the PL, 4 from La Liga (all of them from Real Madrid), 3 from Ligue 1 (all PSG), 1 from Bundesliga and Serie A.
So Premier league isn't as overrated as you think it is.
sensible transfers soon hopefulyy
Amazing list, but I think I would put Griezmann ahead of Bellingham
Would've made more sense to add Hidemasa Morita instead of Pote for the 8 role so Jude can play farther up more freely. I'm almost certain Morita's transition dribbling and defensive statistics are far superior to Pote's for this year as a whole.
1 player only from a league is a great rule.
el shenawyyyyyyy
How similar is David Hancko to Josko Gvardiol?
They had to comply with their inane
' only one player per league ' rule. 🤷♂️. So they went politically correct.
what happened to sensible transfers?
GERMAN CANO MENTIONED ❤
Scrap the ‘one from each league’ concept and lets find out who you think are the best 11 in the world full stop!