@@Agaettis I know he had thought things made noise when the sparkled, like if you had flashing lights or glitter, or sunlight hitting something metal, so I think he would have imagined the starry night in a similar way! I don’t know about the clouds though!
I don't understand why the Soviet Venus missions don't get more attention than they do. For the technology of the time to land on Venus and take pictures and transmit data was a HUGE achievement. Had it happened today it would've been widely publicised.
I watch a documentary called the sky at night, and there was a astronomer working on analysis star clusters who lost their sight, but was able to convert the images of the clusters and converted them to sound. What's amazing was they were able to make a few discoveries out of it.
I just wanted you to know that I started my masters in software engineering last week and in my technical writing class my professor had one of your videos linked for material to watch. You produce great content!
I love how here in the US we have glossed over the achievements of other countries, particularly Russia, in space. Excited to hear what Mars sounds like. (Edit: on the planet...)
To be fair, the whole point of the space race for the longest time was disregarding what Russia was doing and trying to upstage them at every turn to show that their accomplishments were subpar compared to ours. Bur yeah, now that the Cold War is over, I'd like to see more text books go back and highlight their accomplishments, especially in regards to Venus. They owned exploring that planet.
Wow. Just wow. The sound from another planet.... These are things ancient astronomers could only dream of. We should feel lucky for living in such a time
You best believe, in the after-times when I have a job, I'm gonna hit your patreon so hard! OLF too! Your content has been a lifeboat in what has been "a year."
Raycons are no joke. Bought a set for myself and the wife based on Joe's recommendation. Almost a year now: batteries still rocking, sound amazing, 100's of miles of biking, HIIT workouts, 1000's of work, even use them as mild ear protection when running equipment like saws -- absolutely love 'em.
I didn't realize that the Moon or Mars had quakes. I thought that plate tectonics had something to do with that. Thanks, Joe. The sounds are awesome! Great video.
Whoa thanks for the mention!, a few weeks ago I got told that I will need a bone conducting hearing aid as my ear drums are finishing their service life lol, its actually super cool since I tried one and it simply works well, that is done with vibrations on the side of my skull which I opted to get a titanium screw as a medium from the hearing aid to my ear. That level of clarity reminds me of the seismic recordings we hear from Mars which must be ridiculously clear for what it does.
@@lakshmiwillowrose5112 I don't know yet, I knew they were deteriorating my whole life due to surgeries and was just told a week ago its time to work out the operation to get the titanium screw, I have used siemons heating aids and have found that they are good, so for my bone anchored hearing aid I will try to stick to that brand but im not fussy
Great video, Joe. I like the notion that there is music and everything. Now I'm curious what a magnetar sound like! One can only imagine if it is the cosmic equivalent of dubstep🤔
@Unsaturated Hat The child they spent a fortune on then dump somewhere far far away. America hasn't visited the child for a long time till they got remarried with Space X. I'll stop now.
Excellent video, as always, Joe!!!! This one gave me chills, in a good way. It was cool to hear the audio from Saturn and Venus! I can't wait for more audio from across our solar system. We're missing out on such a big piece of our "hood" lol
Thanks for covering this. I'm absolutely fascinated by this one, and some years ago I went on a spree trying to find all the space audio I could. Unfortunately some of it is bogus - just heavily slowed recordings of people talking or making dumb sounds. So I'm glad to see a properly researched video on this. I would love to see more of this if possible EDIT: I went to the video showcasing the sounds of the planets, and, well... if you take the recording of Mercury, speed it up by about 3x and reverse it, you get the sound of some teenager just groaning into their mic. Quite disappointing, seems the BS recordings are still circulating
You're really out here making the best kind of content to consume on youtube. I care about EVERYTHING you talk about no matter how the channel deviates.
You missed two 'sounds', one being lightning, a falling whistle and two, much bigger, Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations - which helped form all of existence :-).
didn't the austronauts said it smelled like a very faint cooked steak smell? i always thought that was the effect of direct solar radiation on their skins
Astronaut Thomas Jones said it "carries a distinct odor of ozone, a faint acrid smell…a little like gunpowder, sulfurous." Tony Antonelli, another space-walker, said space "definitely has a smell that's different than anything else."
Astronauts coming back from space walks say it smells like ozone and gunpowder, though we're still not entirely sure if that's the smell of space or just an effect from the airlock.
The bit about the Sun is actually a really interesting and oft forgotten point when it comes to the concept of a Dyson Sphere. Unless you somehow encased the Sun in a transparent material containing a vacuum, it'd be really, really noisy living in one.
‘Musica universalis is a long time favourite philosophy/art inspiration of mine, and it’s lovely to see it balanced with recordings and songification of the solar system. There’s some really cool artwork inspired by this set of ideas and of course I’d recommend checking out Mike Oldfields Music of the Spheres if you found the Milky Way interpretation all tingly.
The sound of Saturn is exactly like you'd expect. Go find a longer recording of it - that to me is what space sounds like. th-cam.com/video/Sh2-P8hG5-E/w-d-xo.html - good example.
I absolutely love when your original southern accent peeps up through your words, like the way you say "Microphone" at 00:32. It happened in a recent video with the word "type" too, it's really precious. :D
Omg! That sonification of the milky way is exactly what i would imagine the universe to sound like! Luv that! I'm going to look out for other space sonifications!
Hey Joe, lovely video as always, I really liked the poetic part at the end, that we're so moved by music because we're made out of it. Just out of curiosity, do you like metal music? I'm into black metal myself, so it would be pretty nice to hear about your music taste. Maybe you can make a video on your other channel? Or share a Playlist on Spotify?
@Joe_Scott I've been watching for years. Your sense of humor (and humor "know-how") is freakin awesome! 2 quick things: 1) You played sound from Mars, where you say no audio has ever been recorded (or did you mean only from something *meant* to record audio? And I think I was somewhere on nasa.gov when I heard a recording of a Mars wind- or sandstorm. 2) You and I might well enjoy talking politics. Voting-wise, we're not close, but we'll do fine if we focus on ideas, AND if we knock back a few beers in the meantime. If you're ever around central Arkansas, give me a shout. Beers are on me.
@@borbleborb4586 Yes, Patreon. I don’t use Patreon for anything else but Joe. He has really cool things even for the lowest $2 tier. Like exclusive live chats etc.
*IT SHOULD BE NOTED:* As I have seen others take this quote literally, that the Moon ringing "Like a bell" is a _simile_ and the moon does not actually sound like a bell.
It’s funny how people comment on the black hole collisions being cute “the most powerful things in the universe and it makes a bloop noise lol” Like yeah, that’s what we were able to pick up.... over 1 billion light years away...
There's a great scene in the Expanse some MCRN marines are on the surface of Titan and their comms are jammed. They communicated by pressing their helmets together and yelling.
Chanting monks and meditation, those bell things, all throughout history really... people have been finding sound as a way to connect with the universe.
My Raycon review: I've had the E50 model (discontinued) for about 2 years now and I would give an overall positive review. I regularly get 8hr run times, with sielent idle periods. Charging is fast. They fit well and stay in place. They aren't perfect, I feel the sound is tuned very bass heavy, so sometimes voice calls can sound muffled. The mic isn't very good, so I use my hand as a reflector when on a call. And, the Bluetooth can be finnicky, ~80% success rate, requiring the reboot of my phone (Galaxy S9) or the buds to reconnect. But, compared to $30 ones that break in 2 months, or $200 name braded ones with the same features, I think they have good value.
I knew Joe was going to decimate the mood after saying "it seems like the universe has been singing to us this whole time" at 12:19 and he did not disappoint 😂😂😂
What a cool video! I'd never thought about sounds in space! Nor did I know we've had so many successful landings on other planets! Venus?! Who knew? I'm only surprised because usually I come into science-ed videos horribly jaded - "Yeah I've heard this before", or finding them horribly obtuse, like PBS Spacetime - bless them - sometimes is with their quantum "explanations". This was a rare mix of genuinely informative and accessible! Anyway, I'll shut up now.
ohmygosh ohmygosh! i absolutely love the idea of you listening to norwegian death metal while cross stitching. also, i love cross stitching. also, also, i'm definitely already looking up norwegian death metal to listen to while doing so.
My cousin is deaf and he was shocked when he was told that we can’t hear clouds from the ground, and that a starry night sky didn’t have a sound.
I wonder what he thought it would sound like
@@Agaettis I know he had thought things made noise when the sparkled, like if you had flashing lights or glitter, or sunlight hitting something metal, so I think he would have imagined the starry night in a similar way! I don’t know about the clouds though!
@@rachaelfitzpatrick8574 so, like sound effects in the movies (such as Audible Sharpness)
@@rachaelfitzpatrick8574 that's almost beautiful to think about.
@@dwc1964 yeah like that *chinnng* noise when someone unsheathes a sword!
11:39 Usually you'd apologize for sounds coming out of Uranus
Or a big fat asteroid.
Haha poop joke very clever!
I didn’t want to laugh at this, but I did.
Hey hey, guys!....
Butt! *snicker snicker*
🗿
“It seems like the Universe has been singing to us this whole time.”
The Ainur nod approvingly.
I love this! ^
Maybe we're Melkor all along
Ay, nice connection! Tolkien was on to something, come to find out! Not too surprising, dude was on another level.
I don't understand why the Soviet Venus missions don't get more attention than they do. For the technology of the time to land on Venus and take pictures and transmit data was a HUGE achievement. Had it happened today it would've been widely publicised.
I watch a documentary called the sky at night, and there was a astronomer working on analysis star clusters who lost their sight, but was able to convert the images of the clusters and converted them to sound. What's amazing was they were able to make a few discoveries out of it.
"The loudest thing, by far, would be the Sun"
So what you're saying is that a gigantic, perpetual thermonuclear explosion is loud?
I just wanted you to know that I started my masters in software engineering last week and in my technical writing class my professor had one of your videos linked for material to watch. You produce great content!
Me, waiting for the sound of Pluto after Neptune: ....oh
It's just a very faint barking sound...
That's so Mickey Mouse!
I love how almost all the planets sound like some degree of ancient eldritch horror.
If you listen to the full Saturn one, that could score a horror movie
I love how here in the US we have glossed over the achievements of other countries, particularly Russia, in space.
Excited to hear what Mars sounds like. (Edit: on the planet...)
@@lakshmiwillowrose5112 I meant what it sounds like on Mars. Oops.
@@diyeana haha, no worries!
Ok Melissa
To be fair, the whole point of the space race for the longest time was disregarding what Russia was doing and trying to upstage them at every turn to show that their accomplishments were subpar compared to ours. Bur yeah, now that the Cold War is over, I'd like to see more text books go back and highlight their accomplishments, especially in regards to Venus. They owned exploring that planet.
In Mother Russia achievements gloss over YOU!
Wow. Just wow. The sound from another planet.... These are things ancient astronomers could only dream of. We should feel lucky for living in such a time
You best believe, in the after-times when I have a job, I'm gonna hit your patreon so hard! OLF too! Your content has been a lifeboat in what has been "a year."
Imagine if they turn the microphone on and Africa, by Toto is playing on Mars.
Nah they turn on the microphones and just hear David Bowie singing
I'm pretty sure, if they turn the microphone on mars on, what they will hear is my neigbor screaming in his phone...
It's got to sound like this.
th-cam.com/video/D__6hwqjZAs/w-d-xo.html
Gonna be Rick Astley, for sure!
That is how it would sound like on Mars
th-cam.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/w-d-xo.html
Joe: being all deep
Joe one second later: "try raycon earbuds!"
Raycon good
Wires bad
ayyyy its da bee drawing i made
@@aiyhavnouneim wait really thats sweet
"What we hear is what we hear only because of the atmosphere" sounds like a poem
It’s like poetry, it rhymes
It has the measure of something like a children's rhyme, like ring around the rosy
Like it's a mnemonic device
That which sound is shallow and abound in the drowned.
🥰
Bars
Raycons are no joke. Bought a set for myself and the wife based on Joe's recommendation. Almost a year now: batteries still rocking, sound amazing, 100's of miles of biking, HIIT workouts, 1000's of work, even use them as mild ear protection when running equipment like saws -- absolutely love 'em.
I didn't realize that the Moon or Mars had quakes. I thought that plate tectonics had something to do with that. Thanks, Joe. The sounds are awesome! Great video.
*chileans on the moon*
"man I'm starting to miss home"
*moonquake happens*
"aah, much better!"
Mongolians next door: I feel ya, man.
😂😂
I broke into tears when the galaxy was singing. I don't know why. It was such a beautiful song. 💖✌🖖
seek help
@@ManzanaRepublica Why so rude? 🙄
Humor has value. I agree w/ both statements 😁
"The music of the spheres"
😀😀😀
Coldplay?
Eyes up, guardian!
Rush, Analog Kid?
@@rad666a it is the soundtrack to the video game Destiny
Whoa thanks for the mention!, a few weeks ago I got told that I will need a bone conducting hearing aid as my ear drums are finishing their service life lol, its actually super cool since I tried one and it simply works well, that is done with vibrations on the side of my skull which I opted to get a titanium screw as a medium from the hearing aid to my ear. That level of clarity reminds me of the seismic recordings we hear from Mars which must be ridiculously clear for what it does.
that's so sad about your ear drums. what brand of hearing aid do you use? my grandma has tried many different ones.
@@lakshmiwillowrose5112 I don't know yet, I knew they were deteriorating my whole life due to surgeries and was just told a week ago its time to work out the operation to get the titanium screw, I have used siemons heating aids and have found that they are good, so for my bone anchored hearing aid I will try to stick to that brand but im not fussy
"What does the Solar system says?"
Ring-ding-ding-ding-dingeringeding
Took me a moment to get the reference. Nice one!
Surprise:
Uranus sounds like "winds" 😉😉😉
(sorry, i had to)
Yeah, those smelly winds could be 900 km/h fast
Yes
@@ortherner hey! do u know isaac arthur? i've heard he's from orth, too 😁
@@globalSchelmuffsky what
@@ortherner they're making fun of Isaac's speech impediment...
Great video, Joe. I like the notion that there is music and everything. Now I'm curious what a magnetar sound like! One can only imagine if it is the cosmic equivalent of dubstep🤔
Imagine how far ahead we'd be if the US and Russia would stop acting like petty divorcees and actually work together.
Imagine...it's easy if you try.
Then China would be the jealous new wife? India would be.... errr.. Underpaid secretary?
imagine how far ahead we'd be if we stopped discriminating against each other for no good reason and just united as people
@Unsaturated Hat Haha, true!
@Unsaturated Hat The child they spent a fortune on then dump somewhere far far away. America hasn't visited the child for a long time till they got remarried with Space X. I'll stop now.
Excellent video, as always, Joe!!!! This one gave me chills, in a good way. It was cool to hear the audio from Saturn and Venus! I can't wait for more audio from across our solar system. We're missing out on such a big piece of our "hood" lol
The sounds actually are ASMR worthy imo.
Finally a fellow Norwegian death metal cross stitcher
i hear he loves ulcerate
Thanks for covering this. I'm absolutely fascinated by this one, and some years ago I went on a spree trying to find all the space audio I could. Unfortunately some of it is bogus - just heavily slowed recordings of people talking or making dumb sounds. So I'm glad to see a properly researched video on this. I would love to see more of this if possible
EDIT: I went to the video showcasing the sounds of the planets, and, well... if you take the recording of Mercury, speed it up by about 3x and reverse it, you get the sound of some teenager just groaning into their mic. Quite disappointing, seems the BS recordings are still circulating
4:43 hence why frozen russians would be so keen to explore such a hell-scape.
Another great video about a stunning topic!
You're really out here making the best kind of content to consume on youtube. I care about EVERYTHING you talk about no matter how the channel deviates.
You missed two 'sounds', one being lightning, a falling whistle and two, much bigger, Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations - which helped form all of existence :-).
The sounds of space are so interesting. Now we need the smells of space
didn't the austronauts said it smelled like a very faint cooked steak smell? i always thought that was the effect of direct solar radiation on their skins
Astronaut Thomas Jones said it "carries a distinct odor of ozone, a faint acrid smell…a little like gunpowder, sulfurous." Tony Antonelli, another space-walker, said space "definitely has a smell that's different than anything else."
Astronauts coming back from space walks say it smells like ozone and gunpowder, though we're still not entirely sure if that's the smell of space or just an effect from the airlock.
@@winterx2348 Lack of gravity also effects the sense of smell and taste so what are they really smelling??
You'll have to use my smell-o'scope
Is it April 1st?? I have never once heard of trips to or landing on Venus in my life. My jaw hit the desk.
Something about the Uranus and Neptunian EM sounds has also captured me, it just sounds so cold and alien for lack of a better word
i see Joe Scott upload, i click on it as fast as i can
Click like then watch
The bit about the Sun is actually a really interesting and oft forgotten point when it comes to the concept of a Dyson Sphere. Unless you somehow encased the Sun in a transparent material containing a vacuum, it'd be really, really noisy living in one.
I'm pretty sure the concept of the Dyson sphere does not include filling it with an atmosphere...
That fact that the question I had in my head from reading the title was immediately answered thank you joe❤
‘Musica universalis is a long time favourite philosophy/art inspiration of mine, and it’s lovely to see it balanced with recordings and songification of the solar system. There’s some really cool artwork inspired by this set of ideas and of course I’d recommend checking out Mike Oldfields Music of the Spheres if you found the Milky Way interpretation all tingly.
There's definitely a music of the universe, on an other note, I now question myself whether I'm a cylon or not.
The sound of Saturn is exactly like you'd expect. Go find a longer recording of it - that to me is what space sounds like.
th-cam.com/video/Sh2-P8hG5-E/w-d-xo.html - good example.
Sounds scary haha
@@immense_dreamer like a chorus of thousands of tortured souls screaming from the fields of punishment
Exactly haha
I love this video. Anything space related is what I’m all about, but this was such a creative look at our solar system it surprised me. 💕
(Perseverance extends microphone. Faintly off in the distance, Opportunity sings happy birthday to itself)
The solar system is in the library section of the universe " they're just being quiet🤫"
“There’s music in the solar system”
- Space Trucking by Deep Purple
I absolutely love when your original southern accent peeps up through your words, like the way you say "Microphone" at 00:32.
It happened in a recent video with the word "type" too, it's really precious. :D
Omg! That sonification of the milky way is exactly what i would imagine the universe to sound like! Luv that! I'm going to look out for other space sonifications!
Soooo, Tolkien was right? The universe is the music of the Ainur? Noice...
Joe make a video about VR from early to possible true BCI Matrix level VR in the future.
Hey Joe, lovely video as always, I really liked the poetic part at the end, that we're so moved by music because we're made out of it. Just out of curiosity, do you like metal music? I'm into black metal myself, so it would be pretty nice to hear about your music taste. Maybe you can make a video on your other channel? Or share a Playlist on Spotify?
Yay another metalhead here! 🤟
@Joe_Scott I've been watching for years. Your sense of humor (and humor "know-how") is freakin awesome!
2 quick things:
1) You played sound from Mars, where you say no audio has ever been recorded (or did you mean only from something *meant* to record audio? And I think I was somewhere on nasa.gov when I heard a recording of a Mars wind- or sandstorm.
2) You and I might well enjoy talking politics. Voting-wise, we're not close, but we'll do fine if we focus on ideas, AND if we knock back a few beers in the meantime. If you're ever around central Arkansas, give me a shout. Beers are on me.
This was so awesome
💜 thanks! i'm his PR manager.
One day ago? The video is from 32 minutes ago. Is there some channel member thing or something?
@@borbleborb4586 Yes, Patreon. I don’t use Patreon for anything else but Joe. He has really cool things even for the lowest $2 tier. Like exclusive live chats etc.
That moment when the universe is more musically talented then you
Your pfp make it better
Lol technically every piece of music ever was produced by the universe.
If you think about it our universe is so large that a specific pattern of stars could be playing Never Gonna Give You Up!
It’s had a lot of practice
But you ARE the universe. You are of it not just in it
This video did so well! Good Job Joe!
Love these videos! Keep up the great work!
E.T. would finally phone home with that microphone 😁
1st season of “Mars Got Talent”
To follow
Joe, I'm glad you got a good dose of beauty after that "worst human experiments" video, I was kind of worried about you. And me. And all of us.
*IT SHOULD BE NOTED:* As I have seen others take this quote literally, that the Moon ringing "Like a bell" is a _simile_ and the moon does not actually sound like a bell.
It’s funny how people comment on the black hole collisions being cute “the most powerful things in the universe and it makes a bloop noise lol”
Like yeah, that’s what we were able to pick up.... over 1 billion light years away...
loving this talk of EDL And quantum supremacy
😂
What a glorius revelation to know that the universe has been singing to us this whole time
There's a great scene in the Expanse some MCRN marines are on the surface of Titan and their comms are jammed. They communicated by pressing their helmets together and yelling.
"The music of the balls"
Damn, I came too early to read the comments.😭🤦♂️
This video is very insightful. Never even thought about this before
@joescott thanx for advertising the raycon ear buds. I bought a pair last week thru ur affiliate link and I love them!
"...When the morning stars sang together, and all the sons of God shouted for joy..." -Job 38:7
what he says: "Saturn, the Jewel of our solar system"
what I hear: "The Jool of our solar system"
...I have played too much KSP.
The Jule of our solar system? Sometimes they’re deadly and become kJ!
Gosh, that was a GOOD video... Rare topic, top quality!! Cudos JS!!
Cool video joe!
If you want to find the secrets of the Universe, think in terms of energy, frequency and vibration. -Tesla
Great vid... But these records will have nothing on the whale songs recordings. :)
Chanting monks and meditation, those bell things, all throughout history really... people have been finding sound as a way to connect with the universe.
Hey a million subs! Good job man keep up the great work!
The sounds of Venus are more pleasant than anything from Cardi B
Hey Joe, You're Awesome!
I learn something new every time I click on one of Joe's videos. It makes me want to pretend I'm smart the next day.
Ooooh! The sonification of the Milky Way was gorgeous! I must find more!
SUPER COOL!!! Loved the sonification of the Milky Way!
Sound of the milky way made me laugh. Thanks Joe. My son was just diagnosed with (treatable/survivable) cancer so I needed that.
Yeah.... Let's all get romantic about the music of the solar system and the vibrations that connect us with the universe. Good stuff! 💖💖💖
Amazing video Joe!
My Raycon review: I've had the E50 model (discontinued) for about 2 years now and I would give an overall positive review. I regularly get 8hr run times, with sielent idle periods. Charging is fast. They fit well and stay in place. They aren't perfect, I feel the sound is tuned very bass heavy, so sometimes voice calls can sound muffled. The mic isn't very good, so I use my hand as a reflector when on a call. And, the Bluetooth can be finnicky, ~80% success rate, requiring the reboot of my phone (Galaxy S9) or the buds to reconnect. But, compared to $30 ones that break in 2 months, or $200 name braded ones with the same features, I think they have good value.
wow that sonification of the milky way gave me goose bumps!
I knew Joe was going to decimate the mood after saying "it seems like the universe has been singing to us this whole time" at 12:19 and he did not disappoint 😂😂😂
Thank you very much Joe, I'm 37 and I've been wondering about this since I was a kid. thank you, good video.
I think this is really cool. It also reminds me how the Bible says that the stars sing and that God knows each of their voices. Pretty cool.
Love the ending metaphor about music and puny humans. ALL is harmonic vibration indeed, Sir.
“if you can expand your idea of what sound is” that made my day
Always fascinating Joe, thanks as always. 👍🏴
What a cool video! I'd never thought about sounds in space! Nor did I know we've had so many successful landings on other planets! Venus?! Who knew?
I'm only surprised because usually I come into science-ed videos horribly jaded - "Yeah I've heard this before", or finding them horribly obtuse, like PBS Spacetime - bless them - sometimes is with their quantum "explanations". This was a rare mix of genuinely informative and accessible!
Anyway, I'll shut up now.
ohmygosh ohmygosh! i absolutely love the idea of you listening to norwegian death metal while cross stitching.
also, i love cross stitching.
also, also, i'm definitely already looking up norwegian death metal to listen to while doing so.
Such a cool video, cheers joe!
This program does not get enough love...sounds like a video to me!
Norweigen deathmetal and cross stitching? Two things I never would imagine go together.
Can we all just appreciate that Segway 12:45
Great video Joe!!!
Brings a whole new meaning to the 'Planet Suites'