हिंदी-उर्दू फासले पर, कि उर्दू ने हिंदी को नहीं अपनाया है, अशोक वाजपेयी जी का यह कहना कि यह जिम्मेदारी हिंदी की है, हास्यास्पद है। यह सचाई से मुकरने जैसा है। उर्दू में हिंदी शब्द अपनाने का काम तो उर्दू वालों को ही करनाहोगा।
Yahan baham pyar ke jalse the dastoore mohabbat kayam tha ya behas mai urdu hindi hai ya kurbani ya jhatka hai. Allama iqbal bahut pehle aaj ke mahol ke bare mai kah gaye the. Mai shahid khan hoon aur mai jab doosri class mai padhta tha to us waqt mai hindi ki takhti likhta tha to hamare class teacher head master ko lejakar dikhate the.
Zaban hindustani hai jab usmen sanskret k alfaz shamil ho toh woh Hindi hoti hai aur jab hindustani mein arabi aur farsi alfaz ho toh woh Urdu ho jati hai ,ek jaga prof. Ehtesham Husain ne likha hai -mushtaq, lucknow
جناب ذرہ ہندی کی ادب کو غور سے کہیں، شاید تب ایسی غیر علمی باتیں آپ اتنی آسانی سے نہیں کہیں گے، آپ اپنی سوچ کے بدولت ہندی کو برباد کر دیں۔ پڑھیں مُکتی بھود کو اور مہادیوی ورما کو اور کئی دیگر مصنفوں کو جنہوں نے ہندی کا چمن سبز سبز کیا ہے پھر آئیے گا۔
@@utkarshdube370 main bhi Hindu hun lekin agar tareekh sahi se padhoge to pataa chalta hai ki Urdu pyaar mohabbat bhaichare ki paidaish hai Aur hindi nafrat aur siyasat ki paidaish hai.
very nice discussion Agr punjab sey ajeem shayr Srdar Surjeet Patr ko v Shamil kr lete to baat ko 4chaand lg jata kyon k PUNJAB 5 drya ki dhrti ka literature Hindi Punjabi Urdu ka sangm confluence hai.Mai punjab distt Hoshiarpur sey belong krta hu Punjabi Hindi Urdu poetry ka shonk rkhta hu.Hr aadmi ko apni matri jubaan Mother Tongue pr confidence faith pyar hota pr aaj k yug mein convents school janey valey students bchey apni maat bhasha sey cut rhe hai un k liye 1shayr hai Shor kr apni jubaan sb ki jubaane seekh li Isi khta ney hm ko apney ghr mein goonga kr dia.Alfajo ko soch kr bolo kyon k in mein jaan hoti hai Innhi sey aarti ardas or ajaan hoti hai Ye smundr k vo moti hai jin sey insaan ki pehchan hoti hai.Aisi baani boliye mn ka aapa khoye Orn ko sheetl kre Aap v sheetl hoye.Gurdas Maan ney gaya hai Hr boli sikho sikhni v chahidi pr pkka dekh k kchhi ni dhaeedi
اردو ہندی سے زیادہ اچھی شاعری زبان ہے۔ جتنے شعر اردو میں ہیں شاید ہی ہندی میں اتنے ہوں۔۔ Translation:- Urdu Hindi sy ziada achi shairy zabaan hai Jitny shaie Urdu main hain shayed hi hindi main itny hoon...
Hindi Sanskrit se hi nikli hai. If we don't go for vocabulary, all effing grammar of Hindi (and Urdu) comes from Sanskrit. Everything. All verbs, roots, the prefixes and everything. Verbs as simple as hona, chalna, nachna, etc. come from Sanskrit.
MaRaaL FUSIONS aadit singh ne dono zubano ki grammar k baray me ye bat likhi hai vocublary k hawalay se kuch nahe kaha.. ..point to be noted. Aap ka comment to the point nhe.
It is fact that Urdu is Indian language but it is also fact that Muslims of Indian continent have given it communal & religious overtones else they would have never opted for Arabic script.
Gheddai Brothers You are wrong in this .Urdu or any language is best written in its original script and Everyone including hindus used to write and read it that script since beginning .All great non muslim writers including Premchand too wrote in that script . It was after partition that Communal minded hindus started campaign against urdu and it's script and giving over emphasis on sanskritized hindi ..And ignoring Urdu . But despite all those attempts Urdu is still thriving and alive . And despite its neglect by governments people still are reading and learning it through various means...And many non muslims are learning it with equal zeal through other means as they don't get it normally in schools
Urdu is dying in Pakistan as well. I can see it being replaced by English at one end and by the provincial languages at the other. Few Pakistanis now take pride in speaking Urdu, and I can imagine it is the same with Hindi in India.
Kedarnath sb is awesome, shamim sb you are gem.Ashok Sir is genius.
हिंदी-उर्दू फासले पर, कि उर्दू ने हिंदी को नहीं अपनाया है, अशोक वाजपेयी जी का यह कहना कि यह जिम्मेदारी हिंदी की है, हास्यास्पद है। यह सचाई से मुकरने जैसा है। उर्दू में हिंदी शब्द अपनाने का काम तो उर्दू वालों को ही करनाहोगा।
Pure gem of a thought at 39:50
It was such a pleasure to listen to this lovely n intimate conversation
Waah..anand aa gya..zabaan ke hawale se kaafi kuch jaanane ka mauka mila..puri rekhta team ko badhai..
Yahan baham pyar ke jalse the dastoore mohabbat kayam tha ya behas mai urdu hindi hai ya kurbani ya jhatka hai.
Allama iqbal bahut pehle aaj ke mahol ke bare mai kah gaye the.
Mai shahid khan hoon aur mai jab doosri class mai padhta tha to us waqt mai hindi ki takhti likhta tha to hamare class teacher head master ko lejakar dikhate the.
ALLAH AAP SAB MOHABBAT PHELANE WALON SE BHI MOHABBAT
FARMAE
Brilliant. My love Urdu ❤️
U Can Read Urdu?
Rekta_Znda_abad Alla kara yah silsala jare raha_hum tulba kuch sekhay***Ameen****
बहुत ही सार्थक चर्चा..... सुन कर बहुत ही अच्छा लगा...
Very interesting and informative discussion. Keep it up!
Excellent discussion.
APJ Kalam (ex president of India and a Tamilian) writes poetry in Tamil.
Zaban hindustani hai jab usmen sanskret k alfaz shamil ho toh woh Hindi hoti hai aur jab hindustani mein arabi aur farsi alfaz ho toh woh Urdu ho jati hai ,ek jaga prof. Ehtesham Husain ne likha hai -mushtaq, lucknow
Baat urdu Hindi ki aur board english may bilkul is tarah jesay jinnah gandhi dono gujrati thay aur fight urdu hindi ke language par thi... ...
A very interesting discussion.
Dr Surender Bhutani Warsaw (Poland)
is programme ka anuwaan nazdeekian aur doorian bhi rakh sakte the!
I love this discussion
URDU IS GREAT
اردو از گریٹ، ہندی از گریٹ، ہندوستان از گریٹ
अशोक वाजपई साहब का व्यक्तिव विराट है
केदारनाथ जी भी जिंदादिल
bahot Umda. Maja aa gaya.
Urdu language is more expressive than Hindi!
جناب ذرہ ہندی کی ادب کو غور سے کہیں، شاید تب ایسی غیر علمی باتیں آپ اتنی آسانی سے نہیں کہیں گے، آپ اپنی سوچ کے بدولت ہندی کو برباد کر دیں۔ پڑھیں مُکتی بھود کو اور مہادیوی ورما کو اور کئی دیگر مصنفوں کو جنہوں نے ہندی کا چمن سبز سبز کیا ہے پھر آئیے گا۔
@@utkarshdube370 main bhi Hindu hun lekin agar tareekh sahi se padhoge to pataa chalta hai ki
Urdu pyaar mohabbat bhaichare ki paidaish hai
Aur hindi nafrat aur siyasat ki paidaish hai.
Agyeya,muktibodh, Kedarnath singh,Nagarjun ko parhiyega
Kash Mujhe Urdu Jubaan Padhna Aata?
@ Rekhta - Humble request to kindly upload urdu, hindi and english subtitles of all fantastic videos...
Loved it.
very nice discussion Agr punjab sey ajeem shayr Srdar Surjeet Patr ko v Shamil kr lete to baat ko 4chaand lg jata kyon k PUNJAB 5 drya ki dhrti ka literature Hindi Punjabi Urdu ka sangm confluence hai.Mai punjab distt Hoshiarpur sey belong krta hu Punjabi Hindi Urdu poetry ka shonk rkhta hu.Hr aadmi ko apni matri jubaan Mother Tongue pr confidence faith pyar hota pr aaj k yug mein convents school janey valey students bchey apni maat bhasha sey cut rhe hai un k liye 1shayr hai Shor kr apni jubaan sb ki jubaane seekh li Isi khta ney hm ko apney ghr mein goonga kr dia.Alfajo ko soch kr bolo kyon k in mein jaan hoti hai Innhi sey aarti ardas or ajaan hoti hai Ye smundr k vo moti hai jin sey insaan ki pehchan hoti hai.Aisi baani boliye mn ka aapa khoye Orn ko sheetl kre Aap v sheetl hoye.Gurdas Maan ney gaya hai Hr boli sikho sikhni v chahidi pr pkka dekh k kchhi ni dhaeedi
दिनमान साप्ताहिक में शमशेर बहादुर सिंह ने
उर्दू पाठ्यक्रम चलाया था.
اردو ہندی سے زیادہ اچھی شاعری زبان ہے۔
جتنے شعر اردو میں ہیں شاید ہی ہندی میں اتنے ہوں۔۔
Translation:-
Urdu Hindi sy ziada achi shairy zabaan hai
Jitny shaie Urdu main hain shayed hi hindi main itny hoon...
نہیں یہ سہی نہیں ہے، شاعری کو گنتی کرنا آسان نہیں اور کہاں اردو شروع ہوتی ہے اور کہاں ختم اور کہاں ہندی یہ اصل میں عالمی معمہ ہے
اردو انتہائی خوبصورت زبان ہے اس میں ہندی کی گنجائش نہیں
Dono apni jagah mahfuj hai...Tulna mat kijiyega
Abe urdu jaisi koi bhasha hai hi nahin, yeh hamari indo arya khadiboli bhasha ke saath khilvaad hai. Hamein tumhari urdu chahiye hi nahin
वाह...
59:57 अद्भुत
at @15:46 अहमद मुश्ताक़
Hindi Sanskrit se hi nikli hai. If we don't go for vocabulary, all effing grammar of Hindi (and Urdu) comes from Sanskrit. Everything. All verbs, roots, the prefixes and everything. Verbs as simple as hona, chalna, nachna, etc. come from Sanskrit.
Aadit Singh urdu is not come from sanskrit urdu Persian Turkish arabic r the mixture of language they each have eachother in their language
MaRaaL FUSIONS aadit singh ne dono zubano ki grammar k baray me ye bat likhi hai vocublary k hawalay se kuch nahe kaha.. ..point to be noted. Aap ka comment to the point nhe.
हिन्दी और संस्कृत का व्याकरण और लिपि भर
एक है.उसके शब्द स्रोत अनेक भाषाओं, बोलियों,उपबोलियों में हैं। यह संस्कृत की बंधक नहीं है
♥~♥~♥
जश्न-ए-रेख्ता को उर्दू और हिन्दी में भी लिखना चाहिए, सिर्फ अंग्रेजी में ही नहीं
It is fact that Urdu is Indian language but it is also fact that Muslims of Indian continent have given it communal & religious overtones else they would have never opted for Arabic script.
Gheddai Brothers You are wrong in this .Urdu or any language is best written in its original script and Everyone including hindus used to write and read it that script since beginning .All great non muslim writers including Premchand too wrote in that script .
It was after partition that Communal minded hindus started campaign against urdu and it's script and giving over emphasis on sanskritized hindi ..And ignoring Urdu .
But despite all those attempts Urdu is still thriving and alive .
And despite its neglect by governments people still are reading and learning it through various means...And many non muslims are learning it with equal zeal through other means as they don't get it normally in schools
This discussion seems belated.
Today, both Urdu and Hind are dying in India.
English has taken over.
Urdu is dying in Pakistan as well. I can see it being replaced by English at one end and by the provincial languages at the other. Few Pakistanis now take pride in speaking Urdu, and I can imagine it is the same with Hindi in India.
Schyan Zafar
Sridhar Kaushik han sch m kuk ye bat b apne english m hi boli
Sridhar Kaushik i
हिंदी के पाठ्यक्रमो में सुधार का सुझाव तो दे दिया, लेकिन उर्दू के पाठ्यक्रमो में सुधार का सुझाव वाजपयी जी नहीं दे पाए ।
URDU ABHI BHI HAMARE SKL MEIN TOH COMPULSORY HAI CLG MEIN BHI OPTIONAL SUBJECT HOTA HAI IN.PAK
Across The Borders
Sanskrit>prakrit>upbransh>maghribi hindi>khadi boli>urdu
so urdu come from sanskrit
Punjabi sindhi blochi pashto kadr ha
پروگرام اردو پر ھے لیکن پسمنظر جش ریخط انگریزی مٰن لکھا ھے۔ عجیب بات ھے
noorul qureshi aapka naam noor ul qureshi ..Arabi mein hai magar yahan angrezi mein likha hua hai...Ajeeb baat hai
@@MyJourney2U 😂
North.indians.lost.the.culture.by.mughal.invasion.
NISAR AHMED KANNADA MI LIKTE HAI MUSALMAN HAI
the host should speak less.