ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Comparison tool review between the Makita 36 volt reciprocating saw model XRJ06Z, the Makita 18 volt recip saw model XRJ05Z, and the Dewalt Flexvolt 60 volt reciprocating saw model DCS388b.
Featured tools:
Makita 18V XRJ05Z - amzn.to/3vM5bfE
Makita 18V Kit - amzn.to/4b8Klaw
Makita 36V XRJ06Z - amzn.to/47PUSV0
Makita 36V Kit - amzn.to/3vOo8OL
Dewalt 60V DCS389B - amzn.to/3HqnA4h
My favorite Showa work gloves 12 Pack - amzn.to/4erxhyH
(if you're between sizes, go up)
Dewalt vs Milwaukee Review
• Video
Business Contact: alex@toolrev.com
Visit our website: www.toolrev.com
ToolRev participates in the Amazon affiliate and Home Depot associate programs from which we earn commissions on purchases made through our links.
#makita #dewalt #reciprocatingsaw
To be clear I give the win to Makita's 18 volt. Its light weight, rafter hook, adjustable shoe, and one handed blade change make it the best reciprocating saw on the market right now in my opinion.
Thanks for the video I'm buying the Makita 18v tomorrow
I have the Makita 18 and like it a lot.
That's the one I had bought because of the adjustable shoe. Unfortunately, I didn't see the *Max* line on the shoe and tightened the lever in the wrong spot- the lever doesn't stay down so well anymore, but at least the shoe is locked. Maybe I'll get it one of those tacky bandages or a bandana.
Would you still say Makita's 18 volt is the best?
And would you pick cordless over corded
Makita tools last longer ☺️
Made in asia 's ! Done well ! Our machines working well ! Too ! English
I own the same DeWalt saw you show in the video. In my opinion you could go to war with that thing. Its a BEAST!
I own the Makita 18v. And I love it. I love how it has a 1 1/4 inch stroke vs almost every other sawzall's 1 1/8 inch stroke, yet can go the same speed. I also love the adjustable pivoting shoe. I use that alot when cutting up furnaces and A/C units.
As for the vibration? Well, I have a Makita 18v grinder to counter that. :D
I like your video. But if it's one thing that I haven't seen anybody do maybe you can do this is if you can take two adapters for a Makita and put two of the biggest batteries for DeWalt on a Makita 36 volt saw. Meaning in theory ....that Sawzall would have anywhere between 40 volts to 120 volts
Thinking about upgrading from Makita (1x18v) to the (2x18v), doesn't look more powerfu, wonder if its just a longer run time or less stress on the batterys, Most helpful, Thanks
If you have the XRJ05 the only big upgrade you're getting with the XRJ056 is much less vibration, which is not worth the extra weight in my opinion. I think the XRJ05 is the best saw on the market right now. Not crazy about the XRJ04.
Hey I just got a xrjo5 brushless makita and haven’t tried it out yet but noticed #1 and 2 speed seem the same?? What’s up with that. Usually one will be geared much slower?
I don't remember if I could hear or feel the difference but I would think you should be able to. Low is 0-2,300 strokes/min & high is 0-3,000. Maybe someone can test theirs and let us all know. If you get another one to compare let us know what happens.
Amp hour has no effect on run speed or power, that is only the capacity of the power in the battery. Sometimes a lower ah like a 3.0ah has a higher discharge rating and that can effect power by a bit.
A lot of tools produce more torque and speed on larger packs. You can hear it, feel it, love it.
Sure it can, your not gonna tell me a 1500mah 4 cell pack will run with a 3000mah 8 cell pack same cells in both packs only the 3000 mah has 8 cells total by running 4 extra cells in parallel you get twice the runtime yes but under a heavy load the 8cells are going to have a performance advantage.
You are so freaking right! I hear so much people make that mistake.
Ah affects the amount of power delivered. For instance, imagine a single cell can output 20 amps. A 1p battery will output 20amps, a 2p can likely output double amps. A 3p battery can do 3x amps so 60 on this case. Sure it affects runtime, but also available power.
This also assumes that the tool can extract that much power.
Also voltage drop in the cells is less based on the more parallel circuits. This is what effectively affects the power available to the tool. A 1 p will have a huge drop at high loads compared to a 2 or 3 p battery
(p stands for parallel circuit)
@@jacobecorder Right, if what you are saying is true doesn't the *tool itself* have to be designed to realize that power? Consider these two Makita recipro saws, one with a single battery , the other with dual batteries. I remain convinced that the only thing more Ah gives you is increased run time, at least with these two saws. If you look at the Makita website and compare the single battery 05Z with the double battery 06Z, there's no talk or specs listed about any extra torque with the dual battery model. The stroke length is the same, the strokes per minute are the same, the cutting capacity is listed to be the same. That leaves me to believe that the dual model merely gives you more run time....and that's it.
Why did you delete the first upload?
BTW nice review ! 👍👍
The first upload had the ToolRev logo in the upper left corner of the screen, which I found distracting.
jó teszt. üdv Magyarországról.
How do we know you’re not pushing down harder on the dewalt.. not saying you did but for a true test you need to hang a weight to the saws and let that pull them down, not the force of your hand..
I've seen other channels, and even Manufacturers, using weights. But weights aren't a true test because not all saws handle pressure the same way. You have to feel the saw cut to find it's sweet spot. Some saws cut faster with less pressure. It's a good question, thanks for asking.
Is the height of these in rear with the batteries a problem? They look really tall compared to corded versions.
It’s not a problem. You can flip the blade and saw upside down if you’re cutting close to the ground, or whatever, same way you would with a corded recip.
I've got the Makita 36V and it has great balance so the 10.2 lbs doesn't seem to wear me out like you would think by looking at it. It has anti-vibration technology which helps with fatigue as well. Love the rafter hook on it , but I wish the shoe was adjustable like the 18V version has. I bought it to replace my Porter cable Tiger saw which is a beast of a saw! The 36V Makita keeps up with it no problem. I was just chewing up 6x6's for about 3 hours the other day... riping right through them like my corded tiger saw would have.
Ya know I never really used the adjustable shoe much on my corded Makita during the years I used it before my cordless DeWalt. I just use short and long blades. The 10.2 lbs on the DeWalt is only an issue when I do a lot of overhead reframing. Plus no rafter hook sucks. I'll say it again, I think Makita's 18 volt is the best all around cordless saw on the market.
That 18 volt Mak is no slouch !
Ya, the Makita 18V brushless is my favorite all around saw.
How much vibration are you talking about? Was ready to click the Buy It Now button !!!
Not enough to worry about with any of these. All recips have vibration right so it's relative one to another. if you're asking about the single battery Makita, it has the worst of the three and I would still carry it over the other two.
@@toolrev I will be ordering it Makita xrj05z in the morning. Need to get some steel and wood cutting blades also. Not scrapping my 18 volt setup anytime soon. My Makita 36v circular saw is my go to saw 99% of the time. 18 or 36v hedge trimmers are also on my wish list. I'll be using the sawzall for cutting limbs more then anything else. When the Loppers are not quiet big enough.
Great saw! :)
Are the Makitas models made in Japan?
I didn't check the label but all of my corded Makita tools are from China or Taiwan.
Makita has a very small few tools still made in Japan. I own their corded impact driver (the only of it's kind on the market) and it stamped "Made in Japan" on the back. A rarity indeed.
@@DIY-fz9cn I have the cordless 1/2 inch impact. It's made is japan too.
First review I have seen that said the DeWALT was better than the Makita. Nice video.
He didnt - look at the pinned comment at the top - he said point blank the makita is best. he said in the vid only that the dewalt a little bit faster with a 6ah battery than the makita with a 5ah battery - of course.
Higher amp-hour batteries do not increase the output or "speed" of the motor/device
That is incorrect. Many tools run faster on higher amp hr batteries.
You're wrong, its been tested
@@toolrev it is you that is incorrect. The 6.0 stands for milli amp hours stored in the battery not for its max discharge.
You're missing the point. No one is talking about the meaning of amp hours. The REALITY is that many saws and drills run FASTER on larger batteries. END OF STORY! The guy you're telling is wrong is talking about how this has been tested by people on TH-cam like REAL TOOL REVIEWS. The rest of us know this because we USE CORDLESS TOOLS EVERYDAY FOR WORK!