북원 분열 후 만들어진 네 칸국들은 이름을 어떻게 발음하면 될까요? 그리고 각 칸국들의 국명은 13세기 몽골처럼 각 지도자의 이름에서 따온 건가요? 아니면 부족명에서 따온건가요? 혹은 지명에서 따온건가요? 오늘 영상 정말 최고였지만 투메드 족의 알탄 칸이 명을 몰아붙이고 티베트와 연계하며 달라이 라마를 몽골계로 후원하는 등 16세기 중후반의 흥미로운 상황들은 설명되지 않은 게 너무 아쉬웠습니다. 그렇지만 정말 방대한 자료들을 통해 이런 좋은 영상 만들어주신 점 감사합니다!!
재밌게 봐주셔서 감사합니다. 알탄 칸의 경우 엄밀히 말하면 원나라/북원의 역사는 아니라서 딱히 설명은 하지 않았으나 나중에 기회가 생기면 꼭 다루도록 하겠습니다. 각 칸국들의 국명은 알탄 칸국을 제외하면 지도자의 이름에서 따온건 아니지만 그렇다면 어디에서 따온 건지는 모르겠습니다. 발음의 경우 한국어 위키백과에선 알탄, 자사그투, 투시예트, 세첸이라고 표기하고 있습니다.
the names of the Khanates Altan, Tumed, Zasagt, Setsen come from the sons of the descendant of Dayan Khan Geresenze. The Khalkha troops were divided by him, and his descendants already divided the territories
@@gogmagog9883 What is geresenze? I can't find the meaning of geresenze in google. Also if the names were originated from sons of the 'descendant' of dayan khan, Was mongol divided far after the death of dayan khan?
@@칸의장우산 Geresendze Jalayr Khuntaiji is the youngest son of Dayan Khan. According to Mongolian traditions, as the youngest son, he received his father's yurt, namely the territory of Khalkha (modern territory of Mongolia). Genghis Khan transferred power to Ogedei, but gave the territory of Mongolia to his youngest son Tolui, who was the ancestor of Dayan Khan. A similar situation was with Geresendze. After the death of Dayan Khan, the Mongols always tried to unite. Abatay Khan, Ligdan Khan, Galdan-Boshoktu Khan and others. They all tried to unite Mongolia
Amazing video. In between this, the Chagatai video, and the Ilkhanate one, I'm starting to sense a possible buildup to a Mongol Empire video. Would that be accurate, or are you just going to do the successor khanates?
I will do a video on the Mongols in general soon. There may also be a separate video on the Mongol Empire and its successors, since there were a lot of Turkified/Turkic successor states.
mongol empire were divided under 4 or 5 khan right after Genghis khan dies. the mongol empire under genghis khan is very big without doubt. but kublai is the founder of yuan dynasty and only control oriental asia, i dont think its any bigger than earlier dynasty. han or tang dynasty are fairly bigger since they intentionally call army to north to drive away all the horse raider tribes (thats when they start migrating to europe) they also setup trade governor to secure silk road. Qing dynasty run by manchurian emperor might be bigger than mongol if u are talking about size.(qing royal family always have marriage with mongol lords, that keeps its size to max)
Well, that means it was NOT China when non-Chinese ruled over China. It was not China who conquered the other nations. It was the Mongols and the Jurchens. But to be fair, Chinese-led Tang empire commanded a large territory and tributary system comparable to that of Yuan (including control over Mongolia and Central Asia).
East Asian history needs to incorporate the perspectives of nomad empires and China to fill in the gaps. When the Jurchen conquered China, it was initially a nomad nation. In addition, we need to understand the religious authority of shamanism, which is common in Nomad countries, to understand their thoughts.
Manchus has never been a nomad nation, Xiongnu Mongol Turks are nomadic ppl. Manchus' livelihoods were hunting and fishing then turned into farming. Before Manchus conquered China and Mongol, they have already sinicized under the rule of the Ming dynasty. And Come on, even Mongols don't believe in shamanism, they believe in Lamaism(Tibetan Buddhism), only Tengri(Sky or the longl live welkin) have some connection with original Shamanism.
@@lawrencezhang3050 So what is this?🤣🤣 th-cam.com/video/1UKOabLRssM/w-d-xo.html Shamanism is a traditional culture that remains even today in Korea. The Manchus also had a similar tradition.
@@lawrencezhang3050 That's why I said it's impossible to explain from only the Chinese perspective. Do you understand now? People with a shamanic mentality have different behaviors and attitudes.
I think it already does, but you need to speak an East Asian language. I know the histories of the nomadic people's of East Asia are covered extensively in Chinese. I think it's the English language resources that need to work on translating existing documents.
@@UbermanNullist en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Mongolia. 54.7% Lamaism, 2.5% Shamanism. The original folk religion of Han Chinese is also a kind of Shamanism, The ideas of 苍天（Blue Sky, our ultimate faith）and everything has a soul are very typical Shamanism ideologies. But it doesn't mean we are still into Shamanism nowadays. We were civilized, so we developed Confucianism and Daoism which also have much more influence than Shamanism in Korea.
The Mongolian Empire tore up the Covenant and attacked the Song Empire, which was defeated and dismembered. The northern Han people directly supported Kublai Khan to establish the Yuan Empire and then perished the Mongolian Empire 6 years later.😂From the Tang-Jin Dynasty, the Chinese ruled the Mongols without asking you to learn Chinese, but your own Kublai forced the Mongols to learn Chinese.None of the official language, writing, system and culture of the Yuan Empire belongs to Mongols, which can be said to be completely sinicized.
😂Korean fantasy, Kublai and Han warlords jointly established Yuan empire, and the official language, system and writing were all Chinese.Mongolians are required to learn Chinese to take part in the imperial examination, not the other way around ~Koreans are still slaves, because they have to learn Chinese ~
Kublai destroyed the Mongolian empire first, and only Henan and Hebei provinces near Beijing were awarded to the Mongolian king, more than all the Han provinces were Han kings.😂
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그렇게 생각하고 살아라 문화대혁명 때 글 아는 지식인 싹다 니들 손으로 죽여서 무식하고 천박한 인간들만 남았으니 무슨 말이 통하겠어 열심히 떠들어봐 세계가 중국을 무시할 순 없지만 절대 좋아하진 않는단다. 민족성이란 말이 괜히 나오겠어? 수천년동안 어쩜 그렇게 주변국들한테 못된 짓만 골라 하고 무대뽀인지ㅋㅋㅋ
absolutly uncorrect map, maybe China wants to take Kazakhstan? we see agressive policy of China for all neibors! freedom to Uigur Khaganate? former East Turkestan and all muslim miniorities!
Despite hearing of throat singing multiple times, I'd never actually heard it until this video. The sound itself feels otherworldly.
아바 왕조와 북부 베트남과의 관한 점도 잘 정리해놓으셨네요. 이번 영상도 한 수 배우고 갑니다!
Love the detail shown,for the rebellions especially
You are the best historical and linguistic mapper out there
Nice work!
북원 분열 후 만들어진 네 칸국들은 이름을 어떻게 발음하면 될까요? 그리고 각 칸국들의 국명은 13세기 몽골처럼 각 지도자의 이름에서 따온 건가요? 아니면 부족명에서 따온건가요? 혹은 지명에서 따온건가요? 오늘 영상 정말 최고였지만 투메드 족의 알탄 칸이 명을 몰아붙이고 티베트와 연계하며 달라이 라마를 몽골계로 후원하는 등 16세기 중후반의 흥미로운 상황들은 설명되지 않은 게 너무 아쉬웠습니다. 그렇지만 정말 방대한 자료들을 통해 이런 좋은 영상 만들어주신 점 감사합니다!!
재밌게 봐주셔서 감사합니다. 알탄 칸의 경우 엄밀히 말하면 원나라/북원의 역사는 아니라서 딱히 설명은 하지 않았으나 나중에 기회가 생기면 꼭 다루도록 하겠습니다. 각 칸국들의 국명은 알탄 칸국을 제외하면 지도자의 이름에서 따온건 아니지만 그렇다면 어디에서 따온 건지는 모르겠습니다. 발음의 경우 한국어 위키백과에선 알탄, 자사그투, 투시예트, 세첸이라고 표기하고 있습니다.
@@TheDragonHistorian 넵 감사합니다
the names of the Khanates Altan, Tumed, Zasagt, Setsen come from the sons of the descendant of Dayan Khan Geresenze. The Khalkha troops were divided by him, and his descendants already divided the territories
@@gogmagog9883 What is geresenze? I can't find the meaning of geresenze in google. Also if the names were originated from sons of the 'descendant' of dayan khan, Was mongol divided far after the death of dayan khan?
@@칸의장우산 Geresendze Jalayr Khuntaiji is the youngest son of Dayan Khan. According to Mongolian traditions, as the youngest son, he received his father's yurt, namely the territory of Khalkha (modern territory of Mongolia). Genghis Khan transferred power to Ogedei, but gave the territory of Mongolia to his youngest son Tolui, who was the ancestor of Dayan Khan. A similar situation was with Geresendze. After the death of Dayan Khan, the Mongols always tried to unite. Abatay Khan, Ligdan Khan, Galdan-Boshoktu Khan and others. They all tried to unite Mongolia
amazing work, congrats
Amazing video. In between this, the Chagatai video, and the Ilkhanate one, I'm starting to sense a possible buildup to a Mongol Empire video. Would that be accurate, or are you just going to do the successor khanates?
I will do a video on the Mongols in general soon. There may also be a separate video on the Mongol Empire and its successors, since there were a lot of Turkified/Turkic successor states.
@@TheDragonHistorian Cool! I look forward to it; your videos are some of the best out there.
@@dionadair8195 Thanks, I'm glad you like them!
Brilliant work!
China had biggest territorial extent when non-chinese dinasties ruled.
mongol empire were divided under 4 or 5 khan right after Genghis khan dies. the mongol empire under genghis khan is very big without doubt. but kublai is the founder of yuan dynasty and only control oriental asia, i dont think its any bigger than earlier dynasty. han or tang dynasty are fairly bigger since they intentionally call army to north to drive away all the horse raider tribes (thats when they start migrating to europe) they also setup trade governor to secure silk road. Qing dynasty run by manchurian emperor might be bigger than mongol if u are talking about size.(qing royal family always have marriage with mongol lords, that keeps its size to max)
Well, that means it was NOT China when non-Chinese ruled over China. It was not China who conquered the other nations. It was the Mongols and the Jurchens. But to be fair, Chinese-led Tang empire commanded a large territory and tributary system comparable to that of Yuan (including control over Mongolia and Central Asia).
Nope you forgot tang
And those non-chinese were eventually sinicized
@@miliba Not everyone
Awesome. You're like expert at history
Mongol Yuan vs Manchu Qing
Pick your side 🍇🍇🍇
Nemesis brother nomads
Mongol
Yuan
+ China Ming
@@papazataklaattiranimammanchus aren’t nomads 😭
3:32 Poland jumpscare
Jaxa?
what song
After this video, the golden horde is next and its successor states
What is the name of First Music?
"Wuxia 3 (Healing)" by PeriTune.
@@TheDragonHistorian thank you!
🇲🇳💞🇰🇷
Best music 2:39
East Asian history needs to incorporate the perspectives of nomad empires and China to fill in the gaps. When the Jurchen conquered China, it was initially a nomad nation. In addition, we need to understand the religious authority of shamanism, which is common in Nomad countries, to understand their thoughts.
Manchus has never been a nomad nation, Xiongnu Mongol Turks are nomadic ppl. Manchus' livelihoods were hunting and fishing then turned into farming. Before Manchus conquered China and Mongol, they have already sinicized under the rule of the Ming dynasty. And Come on, even Mongols don't believe in shamanism, they believe in Lamaism(Tibetan Buddhism), only Tengri(Sky or the longl live welkin) have some connection with original Shamanism.
@@lawrencezhang3050 So what is this?🤣🤣 th-cam.com/video/1UKOabLRssM/w-d-xo.html
Shamanism is a traditional culture that remains even today in Korea. The Manchus also had a similar tradition.
@@lawrencezhang3050 That's why I said it's impossible to explain from only the Chinese perspective. Do you understand now? People with a shamanic mentality have different behaviors and attitudes.
I think it already does, but you need to speak an East Asian language. I know the histories of the nomadic people's of East Asia are covered extensively in Chinese. I think it's the English language resources that need to work on translating existing documents.
@@UbermanNullist en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Mongolia. 54.7% Lamaism, 2.5% Shamanism.
The original folk religion of Han Chinese is also a kind of Shamanism, The ideas of 苍天（Blue Sky, our ultimate faith）and everything has a soul are very typical Shamanism ideologies. But it doesn't mean we are still into Shamanism nowadays. We were civilized, so we developed Confucianism and Daoism which also have much more influence than Shamanism in Korea.
Yuan dynasty🇲🇳🥰
@Leadergrimiceshake mongolia
@@BJHhoho It was both
Yuan is the Chinese spelling, and dai-on is the correct spelling.
드디어 원나라!!
The Ming Dynasty tore it apart
@@gnffoodingredients8405 well, a cult rebellion caused by heavy discrimination towards the han people and famine did. Ming just picked up the remains.
very cool
Song?
All of the tracks used in the video are listed in the end credits
REMEMBER KIDS that's why you cant argue with each other every time
Nice, the remake of China is beginning!
Although with my most disliked dynasty.
Make a video about berber languages
이제 주치 울루스만 해주시면...ㅎㅎ
The map of the Great Mongol Empire is waiting for you
cool
有没有准噶尔汗国？
最后出现了。
How Mighty Have Fallen !!!
Empress Ki ruined it
Yuan Empire 🇲🇳
Northern Yuan 🇲🇳
@@papazataklaattiranimam Turkish people are turkified Greeks
@@saymumssoul5062 and you are gay
Not entirely sinicized.
But got Russified a lot after Soviets(Outer Mongolia)
The Mongolian Empire tore up the Covenant and attacked the Song Empire, which was defeated and dismembered. The northern Han people directly supported Kublai Khan to establish the Yuan Empire and then perished the Mongolian Empire 6 years later.😂From the Tang-Jin Dynasty, the Chinese ruled the Mongols without asking you to learn Chinese, but your own Kublai forced the Mongols to learn Chinese.None of the official language, writing, system and culture of the Yuan Empire belongs to Mongols, which can be said to be completely sinicized.
@@jiyakuches220 Mongolia is not rusified, just their alphabets changed,
Next: Golden Horde
👍👍👍
I have video about Powhatan Confederacy.
Yuan empire ✔️
Moongol badchina❌
💥👍👏🏻👏🏻👏✊
плюс 10 социального кредита
Wowwww!
Mistake:"Henan-Jingbei Province"should be Henan-Jiangbei Province
What have I done...
So china was at their biggest size under the Mongols🇲🇳
Not China. The regime is not Chinese it’s Mongol. Think of British India
It would be Qing dynasty
The yuans lasted soooo long
고려가 없고 원나라 영토로 표시되어 있는거 잘했네요.
When golden horde
Holden Gorde
@@papazataklaattiranimam Ghen wolden horde
你是韩国人?
他是的。准确地说：他是韩裔。
Mongol empire is biggest
+999999999 social credits
The bulgars were iranic nomads
More like -999999999
@@xanshen9011 -3131313131 credits
@@papazataklaattiranimam Huns, scythians, sarmatians, ashina tribe, avars, hepthtalites, genghis khan, sumerians, cinmerians = IRANIC
Free Kurdistan
왜 sea of japan 인가요 ?
한국빼고 세계인들은 다 그렇게 생각하니까
The Qing was the strongest dinasty.
So basically the Ostrogothic Kingdom but in Asia
History of my brother buddish
Jaxa
First
Make Mongol Uuls Great Again 😂
고려는 원나라에 정복당했던 적이 없음. 내정간섭을 받긴 했으나 국호, 왕실 모두 유지됨. 중국 한인들(송)은 멸망해 노예 신세가 되었지만
고려는 민족성과 자주성을 모두 유지한채 원 멸망 지켜봄ㅋㅋㅋ
😂Korean fantasy, Kublai and Han warlords jointly established Yuan empire, and the official language, system and writing were all Chinese.Mongolians are required to learn Chinese to take part in the imperial examination, not the other way around ~Koreans are still slaves, because they have to learn Chinese ~
Kublai destroyed the Mongolian empire first, and only Henan and Hebei provinces near Beijing were awarded to the Mongolian king, more than all the Han provinces were Han kings.😂
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그렇게 생각하고 살아라
문화대혁명 때 글 아는 지식인 싹다 니들 손으로 죽여서 무식하고 천박한 인간들만 남았으니 무슨 말이 통하겠어
열심히 떠들어봐
세계가 중국을 무시할 순 없지만 절대 좋아하진 않는단다. 민족성이란 말이 괜히 나오겠어? 수천년동안 어쩜 그렇게 주변국들한테 못된 짓만 골라 하고 무대뽀인지ㅋㅋㅋ
그래서 연한색으로 속국 표시한거잖아
원황실과 혼인관계라 영향 엄청 받았죠. 원나라는 고려를 외국으로 간주했지만요. 고려가 원나라의 일부는 아니지만 원의 영향 하에 있던건 팩트.
고려의 암흑기..ㅠㅜ
absolutly uncorrect map, maybe China wants to take Kazakhstan? we see agressive policy of China for all neibors! freedom to Uigur Khaganate? former East Turkestan and all muslim miniorities!
It's a historical mapping video? wtf are you on about
1. Yuan Yunnan province is incorrect
2. If u don’t know northern yuan history (= only read the wiki) then I don’t recommend u do this
First