Dr. Taimur Rahman explains in simple Urdu the difference between socialism and communism in Marxist theory and in terms of political ideology. Questions are welcome.
Sir, I am from India.I am biggest fan of your speech because your concept is so clear.Sir I don't know how give you thanks, but only can say lots of thanks Your are a good musician also, I hope you will read this message, sukriya sir.
Sir, I am an Indian, hailing from the Communist state of Kerala... Fraternal Greetings to all the Comrades & Workers of that part of globe..... India & Pakistan shall never remain enemies..... Together we have to stand for the oppressed.... Laal Salaam
Nice explanation. Revolutionary red salute with lots of love. I am from India, I couldn't understand few words but I understood the difference which you explained. I got the meaning. Thanks
Well explained sir. I am fan of you. Bottom line : End of feudalims and capitalism by Islihaati (By reforms) = Socialist Inqlaabi (By revolution) = Communist .
It has been a long time that i was in quest of videos for political science to comprehend such topics. Fortunately, i found a treasure in your shape. Sir I am highly inspired by your way of teaching and command over topics. You are an asset for us. I would like to tribute you with these lines of Shah Latif Bhiattai (translated) " every bird is not Hanj(name of a notorious bird) and every man is not handsome; however, among a few emanates fragrance"
Free of cost you are teaching us how honestly good im private student of i.R i want you describe every topic like communism socialism idealism nationalism realism realistic please describe in urdu Love you brother dont worry we will watch like share comments your everyone video
What I like about this vid is how u explained it all in your own way. I've seen too many vids where ppl keep saying the same buzzwords over and over again and it's clear even they don't fully understand what it means. The crux of teaching is not to just vomit out info u read frm a book, but to assimilate it, make it ur own, and then convey it. Bravo.
very well explained sir. we have a small group of people sharing same ideology in lyari town karachi, though i am new in to this group we always get help from your videos in our study circle. and its our wish to have you with us someday. i would be really pleased if you can refer some books to newcomers like me
Highly appreciable of you for making key concepts understandable to people, it would be highly beneficial to everyone especially students. Love from Srinagar Kashmir.
کچھ لوگوں نے اس وڈیو کو بھی ڈسلایک کیا ھوا ھے ۔۔۔حالانکہ اس وڈیو میں کسی کے خلاف کچھ نہیں کہا گیا۔ یہ ایک خالص علمی بات ھے۔۔لیکن سمجھ نہیں اتی کہ کیوں کچھ لوگ اتنے بڑے " کھوتے کے پتر" ھوتے ھیں ۔۔😂😂😂
Aoa. Sir I am requesting you please make a video on "water crisis in Pakistan "..I am very thankful to you. INSHALLAH you will soon make video about this problem
Sir u r gem , I subscribe your channel today , one of the Pakistani has recommended to listen your lectures . Lots of respect to you sir from India Kashmir.
"Individual rights are not subject to a public vote; a majority has no right to vote away the rights of a minority; the political function of rights is precisely to protect minorities from oppression by majorities (and the smallest minority on earth is the individual)." Ayn Rand
Thanks you so much sir! Believe me sir I didn't listen a lecture over socialism & communism ever it before in such a comprehensive manner within short few minutes vedio during my career in graduation in political science from 2014 to 2016.
Now i got it idea completely by understanding the philosophy of socialism & communism propounded by Marx & his co-partner angles. Completely understood the angles of left wing politics.
Sir, please explain the applicability of this theory in today's China . By the way, yor explanation is crystal clear. ❤️ I am sad only because these lectures are not in English.
sir well done first of all before you learning i am totally disturb and could not understand the both theory of communism and socialism but after watching your video i totally and easily understand these both differences.thanks.
اسلامی نظام جو ایک قدرتی جس آفاقی نظام بھی کہا جاتا ہے اس میں امیر و غریب کے لیے اس کی حیثیت و استطاعت اور حالات کے مطابق فرائض اور ذمہداریاں ہیں۔ جس طرح ورہاستی نظام، زکات و عشر کا نظام طبقاتی فرق کے خاتمے کا نظام وغیرہ ۔پر اس وضع کردہ طریقے پر چل کر یقینی کامیابی حاصل کرنا ۔ بدقسمتی سے ہم لوگ اس بتائے ہوئے راستے یا طریقے پر چلنے کی بجائے اپنے اپنے طریقے یا فلسفے جھاڑنا شروع کردیتے ہیں ۔ جس طرح ایک کہاوت ہے کہ کوا چلا ہنس کی چال جو اپنی بھی بھول گیا ۔
The thing people ignore is that Marx and Engels were German scholars who were French educated. German has different words for society and community with very different meaning whereas in French any group of people is called society. Therefore they ran into a lot of linguistic confusions and people did not know whether they were referring to socialism and communism in their works. The later Italian and Russian Marxists made the distinction clear, and even differentiated Marxist socialism from democratic socialism/capitalist communist hybrid economy.
Dr sahb jis trah sy ap ny Communism aur Socialism ko “Word , Meaning” wali practicing video k through explain kia hai. Es sy acha tha ap sirf Community aur Society ko achy sy explain kr dety.
salam sir, I love watching your discussion. Sir your explanations of the concepts are simplistic and easy to understand. In short sir, socialist regimes vied for establishment of a global communist society which they hadn't achieved because of the inherit flaw in communist ideology which is, the exclusion of human incentives' and their inability to handle unlimited power in the transition stages(Soviet Union and etc.) towards the establishment of communist societies and it, therefore, can be concluded that future efforts of the same sort will unsurprisingly fail.
Of all the "TH-cam Philosophers", I am finding you to be the clearest and most comprehensive! Not to mention amusing and entertaining, which all adds to a splendid and highly enjoyable spectacle! As it should be done. 👍 Loving every minute of it! Bravo!! Keep on keeping on. 🎸 Your a guitarist too! What guitars do use? I'm a bassist and amateur rhythm guitar player. Fender all the way!! 🎸🎸🎸 Thomas - Belfast - UK and Ireland.
![[Full Episode] The Restaurant War Thailand ศึกพ่อค้าซ่าแม่ค้าแซ่บ Episode 1 | 22 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BuzQ70v-UZQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Please remake this in English or add english subtitles. Professor your videos are incredible and so easy to understand!
Bro ! Turn the subtitles on !
Sir,
I am from India.I am biggest fan of your speech because your concept is so clear.Sir I don't know how give you thanks, but only can say lots of thanks
Your are a good musician also, I hope you will read this message, sukriya sir.
Sir, I am an Indian, hailing from the Communist state of Kerala... Fraternal Greetings to all the Comrades & Workers of that part of globe..... India & Pakistan shall never remain enemies..... Together we have to stand for the oppressed.... Laal Salaam
Avaneesh Tripathi aap be video dekh ke apna paper likha tha?
@@nobyjoseph3055 I m from Pakistan but love India too
Brother Is there any indian best nalyser please mention there name
Guru, you have a comment section. Thanks here as many times as you want. 🙃
بہت شاندار۔۔۔ علم سیاسیات کی مخصوص اصطلاحات کو جتنے آسان طریقے سے آپ سمجھاتے ہیں وہ قابل ستائش ہے۔
Nice explanation. Revolutionary red salute with lots of love. I am from India, I couldn't understand few words but I understood the difference which you explained. I got the meaning. Thanks
Bht Zabardast sir... Bht Clear bataya aap ne....
Thank you for sharing your experience.
Love from Nepal 🇳🇵
Well explained sir. I am fan of you.
Bottom line :
End of feudalims and capitalism by
Islihaati (By reforms) = Socialist
Inqlaabi (By revolution) = Communist .
Agreed!!💯
Thank you sir, this was one of my all time confusions that you cleard today.
SIR, YOU would be my BEST SEARCH on the entire TH-cam as of now, THANK YOU VERY MUCH!!!
Watch some capitalist videos on youtube then you can make millions without keeping bad eye on wealth of others :D
It has been a long time that i was in quest of videos for political science to comprehend such topics. Fortunately, i found a treasure in your shape. Sir I am highly inspired by your way of teaching and command over topics. You are an asset for us. I would like to tribute you with these lines of Shah Latif Bhiattai (translated) " every bird is not Hanj(name of a notorious bird) and every man is not handsome; however, among a few emanates fragrance"
I big fan sir from India, making so simple a way for understanding us .
Free of cost you are teaching us how honestly good im private student of i.R i want you describe every topic like communism socialism idealism nationalism realism realistic please describe in urdu Love you brother dont worry we will watch like share comments your everyone video
What I like about this vid is how u explained it all in your own way. I've seen too many vids where ppl keep saying the same buzzwords over and over again and it's clear even they don't fully understand what it means. The crux of teaching is not to just vomit out info u read frm a book, but to assimilate it, make it ur own, and then convey it. Bravo.
Sir, your lectures are amazing.
Sir kindly upload LUMS classroom lectures here and let us learn more from you.
thank you .
very well explained sir.
we have a small group of people sharing same ideology in lyari town karachi, though i am new in to this group
we always get help from your videos in our study circle.
and its our wish to have you with us someday.
i would be really pleased if you can refer some books to newcomers like me
Taimur bhai, app jo kar rahe hain wo boht badi khidmat hai ilm-o-fikr ki! Aap ki quwat e baazoo aur badhti jaaye!
عمدہ معلومات فراہم کی گئی ہیں 👍🏽 شکریہ 😊
بہت شکریہ سر
بہت کچھ سیکھنے کو ملا اس ویڈیو میں۔۔۔
خوووب سر جی۔ کلیئریٹی ہو گئی بہت اچھے طریقے سے سمجھایا❤️
Brilliant and lucid explanation. Thank you sir.
Love from India🇮🇳
Naxal movement ab be chal rhi ha???
@Council for Human Rights Abuses in Pakistan Pakistan mein Naxal ab to bhoth thory communist bachay hein
Aap ki speech ka kamal yeh hai k Aap in theories ko badi aasan language men samjhaty hain jo har kisi ka kaam naheen
Highly appreciable of you for making key concepts understandable to people, it would be highly beneficial to everyone especially students.
Love from Srinagar
Kashmir.
بیسیوں ویڈیوز دیکھ ڈالیں سمجھ نہیں ائی۔ سلام تیمور صاحب اپ نے یہ گتھی سلجھا دی
Belkul, I watched 4 videos for this purpose but found it Very helpful among them all.
Jazak'Allah sir,❤️
Thank you so much for making this video. This just solved my lifelong confusion with the two terms :))
Wah bht khoob. ..first time it is explained in easy and simple way
Shortly....
Cute and understanding style of teaching. Thank you sir I am new fan of you
I really like your program on ptv home.You are a brilliant teacher .
Timing on ptv plz
بہت اچھے طریقے سے سمجھایا آپ نے ❤
کچھ لوگوں نے اس وڈیو کو بھی ڈسلایک کیا ھوا ھے ۔۔۔حالانکہ اس وڈیو میں کسی کے خلاف کچھ نہیں کہا گیا۔ یہ ایک خالص علمی بات ھے۔۔لیکن سمجھ نہیں اتی کہ کیوں کچھ لوگ اتنے بڑے " کھوتے کے پتر" ھوتے ھیں ۔۔😂😂😂
Ma sha allah Sir
Ap ko Allah pak ny jo smjhany ki slahiyat di h bohut hi Great h
Aoa. Sir I am requesting you please make a video on "water crisis in Pakistan "..I am very thankful to you. INSHALLAH you will soon make video about this problem
I am a big fan of you ..i watched all the Philosophy Lectures , please i request you to kindly upload more videos on Philosophy
آپ بہت عمدگی سے تفہیم کرتے ہیں اپنے موضوع کی ، بہت شکریہ
What a wonderful wonderful video.
Highly appreciable of you for making key concepts understandable to people
I wish this was in English. Or at least if there were subtitles.
why? where are you from
Sir u r gem , I subscribe your channel today , one of the Pakistani has recommended to listen your lectures . Lots of respect to you sir from India Kashmir.
Sir ap K lectures se mere economics K concept kafi clear huy hain❤❤❤❤❤ love U sir
Great Sir Apki Videos Dekh Keh Maza Ageya...Zindagi mil Gayi...Know I will be good boy...and do good Things in my society.
Em student from UOS ..... helpful and informative video ...keep it up bro ... New subscriber
You gave us a lot of information clearly and in a few words brief but comprehensive
On every topic,your suggestion is needed,sir.
Elaborated in the most easy way. Very helpful
"Individual rights are not subject to a public vote; a majority has no right to vote away the rights of a minority; the political function of rights is precisely to protect minorities from oppression by majorities (and the smallest minority on earth is the individual)." Ayn Rand
Thanks you so much sir! Believe me sir I didn't listen a lecture over socialism & communism ever it before in such a comprehensive manner within short few minutes vedio during my career in graduation in political science from 2014 to 2016.
Now i got it idea completely by understanding the philosophy of socialism & communism propounded by Marx & his co-partner angles.
Completely understood the angles of left wing politics.
Jazak'Allah. I will be writing this in paper tomorrow maybe!
Thanks a lot sir u just removed doubts in my mind regarding socialism and communism.
Marvelous explanation and in a candid way.
Thank you, sir! Miss your lectures!
AP bhi Sr k student thi
U r pride of Pakistan sir💕💕
Sir fantastic explanation. Lots of clarity. More power to you.
Sir I have been your fan since you appeared on PTV ... You are my source of inspiration....
Speechless.. U r giving a great ideology nd thoughta
Topic is good. Appreciated from India.
Upper stage : communism
Lower stage : socialism
Amriyat : minority rule
Burgeosis right will remain
You are the asset of Pakistan sir...ALLAH bless you always....
Sir, please explain the applicability of this theory in today's China .
By the way, yor explanation is crystal clear. ❤️ I am sad only because these lectures are not in English.
*_Bro, Hum v india say hai, bengali v hai, itni urdu to samajhme ana hi normal see baat hai bengali k liye .._*
Very simply elaborated
Beautifully explained. Thank you so much
this is what we call a service to humanity
Love From INDIA
My Allah Bless you Brother
JAI HIND
sir well done first of all before you learning i am totally disturb and could not understand the both theory of communism and socialism but after watching your video i totally and easily understand these both differences.thanks.
Great well explained with nice details of evolving the idea of socialism and communism.
i am from pakistan . your lecture is so good . I really like your lectures
Farq pta chal gaya... Thank you sir.
kya zabardast and concise explanation hai.👌
Sir you are my guide, my mentor ! Thanks for your efforts for us...
Watching from Bangladesh.
Allah bless u..
Wonderfully differentiate the difference between the two.
Thanks
Kamaaaaaaal❤
اسلامی نظام جو ایک قدرتی جس آفاقی نظام بھی کہا جاتا ہے اس میں امیر و غریب کے لیے اس کی حیثیت و استطاعت اور حالات کے مطابق فرائض اور ذمہداریاں ہیں۔ جس طرح ورہاستی نظام، زکات و عشر کا نظام طبقاتی فرق کے خاتمے کا نظام وغیرہ ۔پر اس وضع کردہ طریقے پر چل کر یقینی کامیابی حاصل کرنا ۔ بدقسمتی سے ہم لوگ اس بتائے ہوئے راستے یا طریقے پر چلنے کی بجائے اپنے اپنے طریقے یا فلسفے جھاڑنا شروع کردیتے ہیں ۔ جس طرح ایک کہاوت ہے کہ کوا چلا ہنس کی چال جو اپنی بھی بھول گیا ۔
Dr Taimor i am your follower since 2013. i have a query, kindly elaborate it....
how can we understand the Hegelian history of philosophy ?
The thing people ignore is that Marx and Engels were German scholars who were French educated. German has different words for society and community with very different meaning whereas in French any group of people is called society. Therefore they ran into a lot of linguistic confusions and people did not know whether they were referring to socialism and communism in their works.
The later Italian and Russian Marxists made the distinction clear, and even differentiated Marxist socialism from democratic socialism/capitalist communist hybrid economy.
The best way of explaining the terms
Great 🙏
Thanks sir .
I am from India study in class 8 .
My civic teacher asked me that what is🤐
Your good handwriting I’m glad that you are being exposed to quality content aT this age :-)
Dr sahb jis trah sy ap ny Communism aur Socialism ko “Word , Meaning” wali practicing video k through explain kia hai. Es sy acha tha ap sirf Community aur Society ko achy sy explain kr dety.
Good job mjy ap k alwa ksi smj nai ati,sir 18 lecture b daikh loo mgr ap ki smj ati h
very well explained. commendable way of teaching.
sir you are really amazing
Great, very helpful thank you Sir !
salam sir, I love watching your discussion. Sir your explanations of the concepts are simplistic and easy to understand.
In short sir, socialist regimes vied for establishment of a global communist society which they hadn't achieved because of the inherit flaw in communist ideology which is, the exclusion of human incentives' and their inability to handle unlimited power in the transition stages(Soviet Union and etc.) towards the establishment of communist societies and it, therefore, can be concluded that future efforts of the same sort will unsurprisingly fail.
I have become your fan Dr. Taimur sahab.
bot khub.... u r giving us right way... from INDIA
Excellent sir u r 👍 great. Thanks
I have never heard such a great lecture n my life.even from my professors
سر میں ابھی آپ ہی کی جامع میں آیا ہوں آپ سے ملنے۔
Love from India sir beautiful analysis ❤❤🙏🙏
Behtareen !
Brilliant way of explanation sir.Alot of confusions have been revomed from now.
Thank you so much
These lessons need to be relearned
Of all the "TH-cam Philosophers", I am finding you to be the clearest and most comprehensive! Not to mention amusing and entertaining, which all adds to a splendid and highly enjoyable spectacle! As it should be done. 👍
Loving every minute of it! Bravo!!
Keep on keeping on. 🎸 Your a guitarist too! What guitars do use? I'm a bassist and amateur rhythm guitar player. Fender all the way!! 🎸🎸🎸
Thomas - Belfast - UK and Ireland.
Because he is professor in university
Thanks for clearing the concept of these two confusing terms in a simple manner.
Finally i understood the difference and its historicity. Thanks
Amazing, explained in very concise and conceptual way...
Aoa, kindly tusi week vich koi ak program Punjabi zaban vich v zaror start karo. Thanks
Always informative,clears many concepts
MashAllah your teaching is awesome.
Sir please mention books and terms you have used in description box.
your videos are brief & comprehensive.. excellent..
Aaap jaise teachers ki hi zaroorat hai Pakistan ko❤❤❤