Hi Ryan! I just have a few questions for you. Isn't the SSPX borderline schismatic if not actually so? Why would you choose to risk that for your family (especially when the FSSP is also available)? On another note, did Jesus not say to Peter that 'whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven'? How can you understand, then, the authority of the papacy without understanding that anything the Church allows, God allows. And the Church, the Papacy, will figure itself out since the Pope himself is in constant communication with God, and God has entrusted His Church to him. Do you not trust that God would not let his Church go astray? I understand seeing the beauty and holiness in Tradition, and Traditional churches, but how can you justify schism. Ever. I can't understand it. FSSP is a valid choice, and then you remain under the One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Church Jesus instituted. Then, you can simply lean back and trust that Jesus will figure everything out. That is what we are meant to do as his children, isn't it? Hope you could clear some of this up for me, thanks
@@jennamaria2485 that was five questions. And I find the comment about risking my family to be insulting and ignorant and I don’t much care for it, which leads me to suspect that you had no intention of wanting me to “clear things up” for you. But I’ll play along for the moment. There is no such thing as borderline schismatic. You either are or you are not. You cannot be in schism if you seek permissions from and receive said permissions from the Vatican. The sspx does not deny the authority of Rome. The excommunications were deemed invalid, making all punishments erroneous. Speaking of erroneous, authority can become erroneous if authority is abrogated when one undermines the trust of authority. “But though we, or an angel from heaven, should preach unto you any gospel other than that which we preached unto you, let him be anathema.” The Church has had heretical Popes in the past. It wasn’t fixed by sitting on laurels of apathy. If I missed anything, it’s because you wrote too much. Come on, really? The sspx is the problem here? Not enough pachamama’s, suppression of the liturgy, you can reach God from other religions or blessing same sex couples? Listen, if you don’t know that there is a crisis in the Church then I can’t help you. Either folks are smart enough to listen to the what the sspx has to say, or they listen to folks who are not in the society tell them what to think…. Or they love this synodal heretic crap. Pray for the Church, pray for the Popes holy intentions, God bless.
@@reclaimingthesword9426 I'm sorry if my comment seemed confrontational. I have heard a lot of negative things on the SSPX and their standing in the Church. I have seen your videos and from what I can tell you are not the kind of man to risk your family, and that I why I was genuinely confused and concerned. I still struggle to understand their place... but thanks for sharing your perspective.
I am happy to hear of your Rosary prayers. Very good advice. Mother Mary, Queen of the Holy Rosary, pray for us!
We have two options, stay or leave the church, in both you will need to pray in spirit and true and keep the Word and obey the Lord!
@@maustoth no one hear is talking of leaving the Church. Don’t even flirt with the notion.
Leaving the Church is not an option, you shouldn’t talk like that.
Hi Ryan! I just have a few questions for you. Isn't the SSPX borderline schismatic if not actually so? Why would you choose to risk that for your family (especially when the FSSP is also available)? On another note, did Jesus not say to Peter that 'whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven'? How can you understand, then, the authority of the papacy without understanding that anything the Church allows, God allows. And the Church, the Papacy, will figure itself out since the Pope himself is in constant communication with God, and God has entrusted His Church to him. Do you not trust that God would not let his Church go astray? I understand seeing the beauty and holiness in Tradition, and Traditional churches, but how can you justify schism. Ever. I can't understand it. FSSP is a valid choice, and then you remain under the One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Church Jesus instituted. Then, you can simply lean back and trust that Jesus will figure everything out. That is what we are meant to do as his children, isn't it? Hope you could clear some of this up for me, thanks
@@jennamaria2485 that was five questions. And I find the comment about risking my family to be insulting and ignorant and I don’t much care for it, which leads me to suspect that you had no intention of wanting me to “clear things up” for you. But I’ll play along for the moment.
There is no such thing as borderline schismatic. You either are or you are not. You cannot be in schism if you seek permissions from and receive said permissions from the Vatican. The sspx does not deny the authority of Rome. The excommunications were deemed invalid, making all punishments erroneous. Speaking of erroneous, authority can become erroneous if authority is abrogated when one undermines the trust of authority. “But though we, or an angel from heaven, should preach unto you any gospel other than that which we preached unto you, let him be anathema.” The Church has had heretical Popes in the past. It wasn’t fixed by sitting on laurels of apathy. If I missed anything, it’s because you wrote too much.
Come on, really? The sspx is the problem here? Not enough pachamama’s, suppression of the liturgy, you can reach God from other religions or blessing same sex couples? Listen, if you don’t know that there is a crisis in the Church then I can’t help you. Either folks are smart enough to listen to the what the sspx has to say, or they listen to folks who are not in the society tell them what to think…. Or they love this synodal heretic crap. Pray for the Church, pray for the Popes holy intentions, God bless.
@@reclaimingthesword9426 Couldn't have put it better myself!
@@reclaimingthesword9426well said. I pray that more people study this and comprehend.
@@reclaimingthesword9426 I'm sorry if my comment seemed confrontational. I have heard a lot of negative things on the SSPX and their standing in the Church. I have seen your videos and from what I can tell you are not the kind of man to risk your family, and that I why I was genuinely confused and concerned. I still struggle to understand their place... but thanks for sharing your perspective.