“I love how the bat she uses represents she uses bats.” Nothing about the story would’ve been particularly less or more impactful with the inclusion of the photo. The weapon could’ve been literally anything.
@@Pleasestoptalkingthanksnot really cause, imagine she pulled out a whole ass katana or kitchen knife in her bedroom, that wouldn’t make sense as a kitchen knife belongs in a kitchen, and a katana? Well it’d have to be hanged up on the wall or framed, a baseball bat is perfect because if your a baseball player then surely you’d have one in your room, plus it also gives us details about the characters background, so that we could connect with her
When Lily had sleep paralysis, she saw Beth’s silhouette open the door, look around, then leave. She did not see her sister, neither did Lily see Beth when she looked at her bedroom across the hallway. Both of them heard footsteps downstairs. Beth was the first to be taken, as she turned the lights on and was taken through the window. Lily was the last to be taken. ( Copied and pasted my explanation to someone else cos I’m too lazy to type everything again. )
I don’t think it was it an actual taking of Beth or Lily but just an implication that she was overtaken by the “other Lily” aaaaand probably took and abused her sister-
@@Marino_Mania13 I think it's more literal than that. The timeframes don't really fit if it's all symbolic. Lily can't be outside the kitchen grabbing Beth through the window while also being upstairs hearing glass breaking downstairs.
I didn't consider this on the first watchthrough. I hate temporal monsters. The Time Guardians always get pissed at me when I have to break causality to kill them.
Here are the events in chronological order -Lily checks on Beth and finds drawing -Lily goes to sleep -Beth wakes up from nightmare while at the same time Lily "wakes up" and has sleep paralysis -Beth checks on Lily but can't see her, she hears noises and run downstairs -Lily wakes up from sleep paralysis and pick the phone while Beth is checking the kitchen -Beth is snatched out of the window, Lily hears it and goes downstairs with the bat -Lily swings at Other Lily under Beth's disguise and got taken by the monster Whether it's a literal monster or some sort of abusive sister allegory I leave it to you
Pero como se supone que no la vio ? Osea todo me cuadra menos eso La cama simplemente parece vacía Si hubiera un vulto o algo pues hay si pero tonces como ta eso
@@Paidelimon404 mira 4 meses tarde lo se jeje pero mira al parecer el monstruo yo digo que tenia algún tipo de poder o era otro plano de lo que ocurría en ese instante es decir el monstruo creo en la mente de Beth (la hermana menor) otra perspectiva de su vista de lo que ocurría en ese momento por eso Beth no veía lo que pasaba en el cuarto de su hermana cuando ella estaba en su parálisis del sueño ya lo demás ya lo resumieron esa es mi teoría bro saludos.
I see it as just a supernatural story of things that actually happen here on Earth. Abusive anything I don't see that. The video was pretty straight forward to me.
My guess on timeline: - Beth has a nightmare about Lily being killed by the Other Lily and goes to check on her. She finds the room empty (maybe because of OL’s influence?) and investigates noise in kitchen, before being snatched through the window by OL. Lily wakes up after her sleep paralysis and hears a noise downstairs. As she walks down the hallway she sees that Beth’s door is open, but ignores it after hearing more noises. When she gets to the kitchen, she sees the lights on and a broken window, before attacking OL, who is disguised as Beth. OL then kills Lily. The giveaway that Beth dies first is that her door is open before Lily goes downstairs. The kitchen lights are on and the window is broken, both things that occurred due to Beth being there first. Lastly, when Beth is taken, the clock reads 3:05, but when Lily goes downstairs, it’s 3:10.
I went through and have stitched together the timeliness of when each thing happens based on the clocks Lily:gets food at 11:41pm checks on Beth at 11:45pm guest to bed at 12:01am wakes up from sleep paralysis at roughly 3:22am goes downstairs and gets killed by OL at 3:25AM Beth:wakes up at 3:00AM checks lily's room at about 3:01Am and gets killed by OL at 3:10AM Beth died a whole 15 minutes before Lily but checked on her a whole 3 hours and 21 minutes before Lily woke up
But I do not understand. At 03:00 AM Beth opens Lilly's door (4:21 en el corto), and Lilly is not there, even the bed is made (and Lilly had left it unmade). It seems that the real OL... is Lilly
This is honestly probably one of the best horror animations ever made so far, it does so much right that a lot of modern horror media gets so wrong, it has tension, suspence, great atmosphere and genuinely surprising scares and twists, you managed to do more than 99% of horror movies and shows today could in the span of not even 10 minutes. You are a true artist and animator, and all your animations are truly works of disturbing art that deserves more recognition. Your animations have inspired me in a lot of ways and I hope you keep creating.
Haha, you must be green! Horror certainly is subjective, but im certain you'll be suprised to find horror from more places than just David Romeo. I think david is an incredible artist, but I've watched a couple frightening stories unfold that absolutely shook me far more. Hereditary is one of my all time favourites, I think you might enjoy it, as it's a psychological horror that plays with the concepts of the occult and hidden away family secrets.
Although the little sister did wake up and find her sister gone so I feel as if it was real, the little sister did see the things that littly saw too because the window was shattered and there was no trace of lilly.
From what I understood: 1 - Beth wakes up from a nightmare AT THE SAME TIME that Lilly is having a sleep paralisys. 2 - She goes down, and gets snatched. 3 - Lilly gets out of the paralysis, and runs to the kitchen, seeing the aftermath of the kidnapping. 4 - Lilly is killed too. I cannot quite understand why they don't really see each other, but my guess is that it's one of the monter's abilities.
I love the subtle detail of the clocks and the nonlinear story telling. When Beth wakes up and is taken, it’s 3:00am on her digital clock. When Lily wakes up and goes downstairs, it’s about 3:10am on the kitchen clock. I feel like this was very intentional because he took the time to animate the red seconds hand. P.s. I love the use the witching hour too. I went to a supposedly haunted school and 3am was always known as the haunting hour when odd things would occur. If you were stuck on guard duty and were posted at 3am, you almost kept your head down because you didn’t want to encounter any of the school’s many boogeymen.
I had no idea that you were the artist who made this short, took me nearly 5 years to rediscover your channel like this. It's very pleasant to rewatch this now! Especially after watching so many. I've watched far more gruesome horror films since then ofcourse, but this feels more so like returning to roots in someway.
@@comment_deleted Your absolutely right, but I have found a few who have particularly stood out to me in books and movies. It is incredibly closeminded to credit one artist as being "Better than the rest". I'd suggest that you browse more before coming to such a set conclusion.
@@comment_deleted I found this series called "Skinnamarink" which is pretty good, and you should give mystery flesh pit a try too. One is an episodic series, and the other is a web series.
Great animations does not distinguish by "high fps" or by "beautiful drawing". For me, great animations distinguish by their attention to details, just like you do. Reflexions on mirror, shadows projected, even how detailed are the background, those things makes this an incredible work. Congratulations to you all.
I think lilly suffers from vivid hallucinations aside from sleep paralysis, causing her to be paranoid and voilent, the other lilly symbolizes how she can be like a totally diffent person in one of those episodes
If you watch a two-part animation by sultan sketches, he explains his experience with sleep paralysis. And, he also had the "episodes," not waking up, and asking up in another level of sleep paralysis. And Lily probably didn't woke up completely, since once she swing the bat at her doppelganger, she woke up, at the moment she hit her little sister.
Pretty sure lilly actually killed her sister and the other lily is just how she sees hersekf when she has an episode and the part where ger siter gets taken is just her dreaming about accidentally killing her
Timeline: -Lily checks on her sister, finds drawing -Lily goes to sleep -Sleep paralysis, Lily tries to find Beth. Kitchen door window is broken. Lily accidentally hits Beth out of fear, but Beth is OL in disguise. Lily is killed. -Beth has nightmare about above events, goes to find lily and finds her gone (Lily is presumably invisible) -Beth goes downstairs to look for Lily. Is killed by OL. -Events in #3 become true. Edit: so in a nutshell, Lily's sleep paralysis and Beth's dream happened at the same time, but Beth got killed before Lily.
I've pieced it together First the little girl wakes up and checks Lily's room for sone reason she can't see Lily and goes down stairs turns the light on the window is intact THEN Lily "wakes" up and hears little sister get kidnapped through the window but doesn't know THAT'S what happened so she goes on to check it out sees the light turned on (by the little sister) and the broken window the 'other Lily' then shapeshifts? Into little sister and gets her killed I think then the jumoscare is the end of the timeline as it is. The events played out in different order for some reason some sort or time anomaly it seems
This has been out for a long time, and it is very good. Something I noticed is the monster felt the need to turn into her sister when hit the first time, perhaps if Lily had kept at it the monster would have been seriously injured or worse?
That was so good. Great jump scare at the end. You should already be under contract with someone and making buttloads of money by now, you're that good.
When Lily had sleep paralysis, she saw Beth’s silhouette open the door, look around, then leave. She did not see her sister, neither did Lily see Beth when she looked at her bedroom across the hallway. Both of them heard footsteps downstairs. Beth was the first to be taken, as she turned the lights on and was taken through the window. Lily was the last to be taken.
3:00 - Beth wakes up from a nightmare, went to Lily's room. couldn't find her 3:05 - Beth went down the kitchen, got eaten 3:00 - Lily saw Beth looking for her, but couldnt move or react. saw the Other 3:0x - Lily wakes up 3:12 - Lily killed the Other the weird parts -Beth couldn't see Lily -Lily thought she hit the Other, ,but actually killed Beth -Beth's corpse turned back into Other Lily It's either a time paradox/ groundhog day situation - Beth couldn't see Lily because the Other ate her (3:00 AM) and then the Other ate her in the kitchen (3:05 AM) - Lily had sleep paralysis and saw Beth, but couldn't say anything or move (3:00 AM) Found the monster and killed it. but killed Lily instead. and got eaten (3:12 AM) or... -The Other had obfuscated Lily from Beth's view. -The Other ate Beth, when Lily hit the Other, It quickly transformed into Beth to make Lily drop her guard. and then promptlly ate her.
Chronologicallly,after Lily went to sleep,story goes at 4:10 where Beth wakes up from nightmare and after going down she is being killed. There are several clues to that,like broken window and light being turned on,leaven the part with Lily to be the last.
I feel like im reliving my childhood finally after 4 years i found your channel again i love your work and hope to see so much more in the future you have brought me so many scares and most importantly motivation have a good day tarnished one -Sincerly Melina ❤
This other lily invaded the dreams of the sisters and shape-shifted to trap them one after the other in the following time sequences : 3 am: Beth wakes up after seing what happened to lily but she has no idea how the window broke, she heads down and gets snatched and the window breaks. Meanwhile Lily is rooted to her bed by the monster but she does notice the outline of her sister, then she goes down the stairs and HER moments are used before they happened by the monster wich instrumented everything.
Ví este corto en TikTok y quise dejar mi apoyo por acá. Realmente me fascinó. Me gustó la trama, la animación, incluso los sonidos. Sí asusta jaja. Me gustó mucho. Espero que tengas más apoyo. Mientras lo compartiré con mis amigos, para que se asusten xD Sigue así ✨
Really want to watch this animation but I just couldn't load it. But other videos in this channel is just fine. Wondering that if I can get any suggestion from here. Thanks
I can't tell if the meaning of this is that Lily is the Other Lily and something awful happens to the real Lily when she sleeps (like, she's taken over by the Other Lily) or if the Other Lily is supposed to just be another entity.... It's sad regardless, because based on the picture Beth drew, it seems like the Other Lily and her were friends? Maybe the Other Lily attacked because Lily saw the drawing and "knew" of its existence?
I'm surprised I scrolled so far and didn't see any other comments about this. It's one thing for some doppelganger monster to just attack some girls, but that drawing raises a bunch of other questions. Why does Beth already know about Other Lily? Why did she draw her like she was a friend? If they were friends, then what was with that ending scene?
@@MarsellusWallace Exactly my thoughts. That drawing raises more questions. Perhaps it’s the jealous ghost/evil spirit trope or something. Being possessive over Beth.
awake all night because my sleep paralysis has been so bad lately, listening to stories and smoking. links from those lead to browsing your animation. i love it all, of course (good pupper.) and then i watch this. well done, sir... i'mma go make coffee now. lots and lots of coffee.
I do not understand why the video is not reproduced, but in the other channel it does. Well, it was an amazing short. I hope the Kickstarter went well. By the way, your first work I saw was the Fatal Frame one.
I KNEW it was you! You made this! I could never find this after I watched it in a scary vids compilation,(scared the pants off little me) but after seeing pleasant inn I immediately recognized your style! Great work!
beth is first taken, as we see when lily goes downstairs in the kitchen, the window mirror is broken. plus the door to beths room is open. the thing made lily invisible when beth looked for lily in her room. and we can even see a girls silhouette during lilys paralysis
For whatever reason, this video just won't play for me. I had to go watch it on another person's channel, then come back here to comment. The scene during the actual sleep paralysis has some of the most disturbing use of music I've seen in a long time. Mimicking what Lily's heartbeat would be like in that moment.
@@Pers0n97 I am indeed. It might have something to do with it. Strange that I've never had this happen with any other video before. EDIT: The other channel I viewed it on is called Lets Read! in case that helps you find one that might work.
I love your art styles! I'm too busy admiring your animations to be scared. I am thrilled instead. Also is that the house from the exorcist? i love that!
That feeling of immense terror when Lily thought she had just brained her sister with the bat made my stomach drop.
i love how her being a baseball player was shown in the picture at the beginning explaining why she picked a baseball bat later
Imagine just hitting a monster in the monster says ow
That's a bat
“I love how the bat she uses represents she uses bats.”
Nothing about the story would’ve been particularly less or more impactful with the inclusion of the photo. The weapon could’ve been literally anything.
@@Pleasestoptalkingthanksnot really cause, imagine she pulled out a whole ass katana or kitchen knife in her bedroom, that wouldn’t make sense as a kitchen knife belongs in a kitchen, and a katana? Well it’d have to be hanged up on the wall or framed, a baseball bat is perfect because if your a baseball player then surely you’d have one in your room, plus it also gives us details about the characters background, so that we could connect with her
Si somos sinceros parece que la otra Lily es la que juega béisbol 💀
When Lily had sleep paralysis, she saw Beth’s silhouette open the door, look around, then leave. She did not see her sister, neither did Lily see Beth when she looked at her bedroom across the hallway. Both of them heard footsteps downstairs. Beth was the first to be taken, as she turned the lights on and was taken through the window. Lily was the last to be taken.
( Copied and pasted my explanation to someone else cos I’m too lazy to type everything again. )
I don’t think it was it an actual taking of Beth or Lily but just an implication that she was overtaken by the “other Lily” aaaaand probably took and abused her sister-
@@Marino_Mania13 I think it's more literal than that. The timeframes don't really fit if it's all symbolic. Lily can't be outside the kitchen grabbing Beth through the window while also being upstairs hearing glass breaking downstairs.
@@zaprowsdower4938 It’s just my theory
I didn't consider this on the first watchthrough.
I hate temporal monsters.
The Time Guardians always get pissed at me when I have to break causality to kill them.
@@Marino_Mania13 not every film has to be symbolic
Here are the events in chronological order
-Lily checks on Beth and finds drawing
-Lily goes to sleep
-Beth wakes up from nightmare while at the same time Lily "wakes up" and has sleep paralysis
-Beth checks on Lily but can't see her, she hears noises and run downstairs
-Lily wakes up from sleep paralysis and pick the phone while Beth is checking the kitchen
-Beth is snatched out of the window, Lily hears it and goes downstairs with the bat
-Lily swings at Other Lily under Beth's disguise and got taken by the monster
Whether it's a literal monster or some sort of abusive sister allegory I leave it to you
Pero como se supone que no la vio ? Osea todo me cuadra menos eso
La cama simplemente parece vacía
Si hubiera un vulto o algo pues hay si pero tonces como ta eso
Ooooooh
@@Paidelimon404 mira 4 meses tarde lo se jeje pero mira al parecer el monstruo yo digo que tenia algún tipo de poder o era otro plano de lo que ocurría en ese instante es decir el monstruo creo en la mente de Beth (la hermana menor) otra perspectiva de su vista de lo que ocurría en ese momento por eso Beth no veía lo que pasaba en el cuarto de su hermana cuando ella estaba en su parálisis del sueño ya lo demás ya lo resumieron esa es mi teoría bro saludos.
I see it as just a supernatural story of things that actually happen here on Earth. Abusive anything I don't see that. The video was pretty straight forward to me.
Dose It mean that when other Lily gets backup and kills beth It actually kills her?
My guess on timeline:
- Beth has a nightmare about Lily being killed by the Other Lily and goes to check on her. She finds the room empty (maybe because of OL’s influence?) and investigates noise in kitchen, before being snatched through the window by OL. Lily wakes up after her sleep paralysis and hears a noise downstairs. As she walks down the hallway she sees that Beth’s door is open, but ignores it after hearing more noises. When she gets to the kitchen, she sees the lights on and a broken window, before attacking OL, who is disguised as Beth. OL then kills Lily.
The giveaway that Beth dies first is that her door is open before Lily goes downstairs. The kitchen lights are on and the window is broken, both things that occurred due to Beth being there first. Lastly, when Beth is taken, the clock reads 3:05, but when Lily goes downstairs, it’s 3:10.
I went through and have stitched together the timeliness of when each thing happens based on the clocks
Lily:gets food at 11:41pm checks on Beth at 11:45pm guest to bed at 12:01am wakes up from sleep paralysis at roughly 3:22am goes downstairs and gets killed by OL at 3:25AM
Beth:wakes up at 3:00AM checks lily's room at about 3:01Am and gets killed by OL at 3:10AM
Beth died a whole 15 minutes before Lily but checked on her a whole 3 hours and 21 minutes before Lily woke up
@@SW1NDL_3Rhow?
@@yatsuto6088 I looked at the clocks and did a little math
@@SW1NDL_3R Me too so how did Beth check on her 3 hours and 2 minutes before she woke up?
But I do not understand. At 03:00 AM Beth opens Lilly's door (4:21 en el corto), and Lilly is not there, even the bed is made (and Lilly had left it unmade). It seems that the real OL... is Lilly
I was not expecting the fast child snatch. I like the stories you animate almost as much as I like the animations themselves, and that is rare for me.
Did you hear the *bonk* on the door as she was dragged away?
You have a potential to become a famous animator. Well done bro
Thank you ^/////^
He already is bro.
@@magesticcrab2164 Told ya hahaha
@@magesticcrab2164 Yeah, but he deserves to be more famous. Seriously one of the most underrated channels I've ever seen.
Definitely….
This is honestly probably one of the best horror animations ever made so far, it does so much right that a lot of modern horror media gets so wrong, it has tension, suspence, great atmosphere and genuinely surprising scares and twists, you managed to do more than 99% of horror movies and shows today could in the span of not even 10 minutes. You are a true artist and animator, and all your animations are truly works of disturbing art that deserves more recognition. Your animations have inspired me in a lot of ways and I hope you keep creating.
Same, other Lilly, who's hungry, Agamemnon counterpart, and don't hug me I'm scared are my favorite horror shorts of all time
Haha, you must be green! Horror certainly is subjective, but im certain you'll be suprised to find horror from more places than just David Romeo. I think david is an incredible artist, but I've watched a couple frightening stories unfold that absolutely shook me far more. Hereditary is one of my all time favourites, I think you might enjoy it, as it's a psychological horror that plays with the concepts of the occult and hidden away family secrets.
Although the little sister did wake up and find her sister gone so I feel as if it was real, the little sister did see the things that littly saw too because the window was shattered and there was no trace of lilly.
It helps that this was made 5 years ago as well
@@matthewdennis3675 the window wasn’t shattered before the little sister went downstairs
From what I understood:
1 - Beth wakes up from a nightmare AT THE SAME TIME that Lilly is having a sleep paralisys.
2 - She goes down, and gets snatched.
3 - Lilly gets out of the paralysis, and runs to the kitchen, seeing the aftermath of the kidnapping.
4 - Lilly is killed too.
I cannot quite understand why they don't really see each other, but my guess is that it's one of the monter's abilities.
Someone here said that you should pay attention to the clock on the wall. Beth was killed at 3:05. Lily came downstairs at 3:10
You deserve to be paid. I almost cried its so scary! And I love horror.
wtf he wast paid
that's the real horror in this story
Aeris for you to be able to be paid i think you need at least 4000 subs and 100 hours of videos im pretty sure
I love the subtle detail of the clocks and the nonlinear story telling.
When Beth wakes up and is taken, it’s 3:00am on her digital clock.
When Lily wakes up and goes downstairs, it’s about 3:10am on the kitchen clock. I feel like this was very intentional because he took the time to animate the red seconds hand.
P.s. I love the use the witching hour too. I went to a supposedly haunted school and 3am was always known as the haunting hour when odd things would occur. If you were stuck on guard duty and were posted at 3am, you almost kept your head down because you didn’t want to encounter any of the school’s many boogeymen.
The small detail that shows a frame of lily playing baseball, and then having a baseball bat at the ready is so good.
I had no idea that you were the artist who made this short, took me nearly 5 years to rediscover your channel like this. It's very pleasant to rewatch this now! Especially after watching so many. I've watched far more gruesome horror films since then ofcourse, but this feels more so like returning to roots in someway.
Can you still watch? Me and others are unable to watch, the video keeps loading endlessly.
@@comment_deleted Your absolutely right, but I have found a few who have particularly stood out to me in books and movies. It is incredibly closeminded to credit one artist as being "Better than the rest". I'd suggest that you browse more before coming to such a set conclusion.
@@comment_deleted I found this series called "Skinnamarink" which is pretty good, and you should give mystery flesh pit a try too. One is an episodic series, and the other is a web series.
U deserve waaaayyy more views and subs and u can become something
Aw, thank you! ^/////^
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😢😢😢😢😮😮😮😅😅😅😊😊
Пкффкпппвфівп❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great animations does not distinguish by "high fps" or by "beautiful drawing". For me, great animations distinguish by their attention to details, just like you do.
Reflexions on mirror, shadows projected, even how detailed are the background, those things makes this an incredible work.
Congratulations to you all.
I think lilly suffers from vivid hallucinations aside from sleep paralysis, causing her to be paranoid and voilent, the other lilly symbolizes how she can be like a totally diffent person in one of those episodes
If you watch a two-part animation by sultan sketches, he explains his experience with sleep paralysis.
And, he also had the "episodes," not waking up, and asking up in another level of sleep paralysis. And Lily probably didn't woke up completely, since once she swing the bat at her doppelganger, she woke up, at the moment she hit her little sister.
Who do y’all think died? Beth probably did, but what about Lily?
Then why the fuck does her daughter draw the other lily??
@@frickfactor5038 that’s not her daughter it’s her sister
Pretty sure lilly actually killed her sister and the other lily is just how she sees hersekf when she has an episode and the part where ger siter gets taken is just her dreaming about accidentally killing her
Timeline:
-Lily checks on her sister, finds drawing
-Lily goes to sleep
-Sleep paralysis, Lily tries to find Beth. Kitchen door window is broken. Lily accidentally hits Beth out of fear, but Beth is OL in disguise. Lily is killed.
-Beth has nightmare about above events, goes to find lily and finds her gone (Lily is presumably invisible)
-Beth goes downstairs to look for Lily. Is killed by OL.
-Events in #3 become true.
Edit: so in a nutshell, Lily's sleep paralysis and Beth's dream happened at the same time, but Beth got killed before Lily.
Why couldnt Beth see Lily when she still alive?
@@namnathan7038 Not sure. This is the only thing I couldn’t figure out, but I think it has something to do with the sleep paralysis
the most pointless comment ever
@@boomervergil1328 ?
@@boomervergil1328 how so?
That was so freaky. The movements were unsettling for "other lily"
Animation is never easy (especially when it comes to horror), so I definitely give you props for this beautifully well-made animation! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
I really love this short film for showing just how terrifying sleep paralysis can be
Wooooah! The little sister Beth was already gone throughout the whole animation! What a cool twist!
This is fantastic work. I love the twist at the end. Brutal and jarring.
So amazing. The character's movement, actions and reactions are really believable. If you know what i mean by that.
I've pieced it together First the little girl wakes up and checks Lily's room for sone reason she can't see Lily and goes down stairs turns the light on the window is intact THEN Lily "wakes" up and hears little sister get kidnapped through the window but doesn't know THAT'S what happened so she goes on to check it out sees the light turned on (by the little sister) and the broken window the 'other Lily' then shapeshifts? Into little sister and gets her killed I think then the jumoscare is the end of the timeline as it is. The events played out in different order for some reason some sort or time anomaly it seems
FR I knew i wasn't crazy thank you
Yes
Bro explains better than my teachers 💀
This has been out for a long time, and it is very good.
Something I noticed is the monster felt the need to turn into her sister when hit the first time, perhaps if Lily had kept at it the monster would have been seriously injured or worse?
Probably
Yep that’s probably why it changed into someone she cared about.
Dude, I seriously have no idea why you don't have more subs. You are awesome!! All your stuff. You deserve so much more credit
That was so good. Great jump scare at the end. You should already be under contract with someone and making buttloads of money by now, you're that good.
I love your animation style, colour, and texture. Everything is perfect, story, sound everything.
Beautifully well done! So dark, and atmospheric!
-MBK
What if don’t understand is why was lily not in her bed when her little sister went to check on her
She was already taken by the other
But then there would have been broken glass by the door.
Signoff[サインオフ] it is likely that Beth (little sister) had a hallucination that Lily wasn’t there, but Lily saw the silhouette of Beth.
When Lily had sleep paralysis, she saw Beth’s silhouette open the door, look around, then leave. She did not see her sister, neither did Lily see Beth when she looked at her bedroom across the hallway. Both of them heard footsteps downstairs. Beth was the first to be taken, as she turned the lights on and was taken through the window. Lily was the last to be taken.
It was the same story from the perspective of the older sister first and then shows it from the perspective of the younger sister
Why is this not on over at least a mil views. Great animator, super creepy too. And why isn't he on over a mil subs. I don't get it
3:25 When the thunder clashes the window lights up for half a second and if you look at the right of the window you see something
Mayhulk
I know, I see it to! :)
Where?
Also, thunderclap can be heared in the same time with lightning flash, which is unrealistic.
@@docmoreau7540 no it’s not it means the lightning strike was close by
3:25 - 3:26
I really love the time loop/not knowing what’s real thing going on with this
Am I the only one who wants a sequel/series?
Ayo, the sound the child made when she hit the fridge 🤣
Lol imagine having part2 title as other other lily nice job the horror is awesome
Please make more horror shorts, these are so good
This man is such a great animator he brings true terror in a video
that final thud while beth was being snatched was gold
I loved this so much, absolutely amazing! I loved the characters, the designs, and the animation! Also I love the little Cartoon Cat teddy
That last scene where she bust through the window scared the fuck outta me bruh. Great animation as always
3:00 - Beth wakes up from a nightmare, went to Lily's room. couldn't find her
3:05 - Beth went down the kitchen, got eaten
3:00 - Lily saw Beth looking for her, but couldnt move or react. saw the Other
3:0x - Lily wakes up
3:12 - Lily killed the Other
the weird parts
-Beth couldn't see Lily
-Lily thought she hit the Other, ,but actually killed Beth
-Beth's corpse turned back into Other Lily
It's either a time paradox/ groundhog day situation
- Beth couldn't see Lily because the Other ate her (3:00 AM) and then the Other ate her in the kitchen (3:05 AM)
- Lily had sleep paralysis and saw Beth, but couldn't say anything or move (3:00 AM) Found the monster and killed it. but killed Lily instead. and got eaten (3:12 AM)
or...
-The Other had obfuscated Lily from Beth's view.
-The Other ate Beth, when Lily hit the Other, It quickly transformed into Beth to make Lily drop her guard. and then promptlly ate her.
Chronologicallly,after Lily went to sleep,story goes at 4:10 where Beth wakes up from nightmare and after going down she is being killed.
There are several clues to that,like broken window and light being turned on,leaven the part with Lily to be the last.
Something about this video is strangely broken only for my TH-cam account, so I had to log out to watch it, but I'm glad I did!
Amazing work. Ending scared the nuts out of my body tho
I feel like im reliving my childhood finally after 4 years i found your channel again i love your work and hope to see so much more in the future you have brought me so many scares and most importantly motivation have a good day tarnished one
-Sincerly Melina ❤
This other lily invaded the dreams of the sisters and shape-shifted to trap them one after the other in the following time sequences : 3 am: Beth wakes up after seing what happened to lily but she has no idea how the window broke, she heads down and gets snatched and the window breaks.
Meanwhile Lily is rooted to her bed by the monster but she does notice the outline of her sister, then she goes down the stairs and HER moments are used before they happened by the monster wich instrumented everything.
Ví este corto en TikTok y quise dejar mi apoyo por acá.
Realmente me fascinó. Me gustó la trama, la animación, incluso los sonidos. Sí asusta jaja.
Me gustó mucho. Espero que tengas más apoyo.
Mientras lo compartiré con mis amigos, para que se asusten xD
Sigue así ✨
this captures horror really good
Love your style of animation. So different from the generic llama arts style and it’s copiers. Keep up the great work
Great work David. Pleasantly twisted.
Sound design is so good!!!
This is probably one of the best horror videos
Always good to look at a old classic, thanks for the horror :D
Really want to watch this animation but I just couldn't load it. But other videos in this channel is just fine. Wondering that if I can get any suggestion from here. Thanks
set quality to 360p, at least it worked for me.
@@bananowy_ocet Thanks a lot:) It worked for me too.
Nice, a bit confusing but the overall effect hits the spot. Reminds me of my moms cooking.
Watch a few more times, focus on details, you will get it.
Striker 198 I am still confused after watching like five times
@@eveec6144 I got it the second time watching it
this animation made my day, it's so creepy
I can't tell if the meaning of this is that Lily is the Other Lily and something awful happens to the real Lily when she sleeps (like, she's taken over by the Other Lily) or if the Other Lily is supposed to just be another entity.... It's sad regardless, because based on the picture Beth drew, it seems like the Other Lily and her were friends? Maybe the Other Lily attacked because Lily saw the drawing and "knew" of its existence?
I'm surprised I scrolled so far and didn't see any other comments about this. It's one thing for some doppelganger monster to just attack some girls, but that drawing raises a bunch of other questions. Why does Beth already know about Other Lily? Why did she draw her like she was a friend? If they were friends, then what was with that ending scene?
@@MarsellusWallace Exactly my thoughts. That drawing raises more questions. Perhaps it’s the jealous ghost/evil spirit trope or something. Being possessive over Beth.
this makes me feel bad but it also makes me want to see these types of content more good job..
I was holding my breath for so long I got a headache. Well done!
The fact that watching this at 2am and suddenly the video informed me that it suddenly broke right at 2:34 is even scarier
love this guys work, wish i could actually watch the video since it keeps buffering on higher quality settings
Me when other lily disguised as Beth: clever bastard.
awake all night because my sleep paralysis has been so bad lately, listening to stories and smoking. links from those lead to browsing your animation. i love it all, of course (good pupper.) and then i watch this. well done, sir... i'mma go make coffee now. lots and lots of coffee.
Thank you! I hope your sleep paralysis didn't get worse because of my shorts. XD
@@cinemamind nah, I'm trying to get it, just because old want to see if it is too scary.
And also, write about it.
Hey man , it's been 6 years now , how are you doing?
the way her body banged on the door bro
You ever thought about joining Disney?
I do not understand why the video is not reproduced, but in the other channel it does. Well, it was an amazing short. I hope the Kickstarter went well. By the way, your first work I saw was the Fatal Frame one.
I KNEW it was you! You made this! I could never find this after I watched it in a scary vids compilation,(scared the pants off little me) but after seeing pleasant inn I immediately recognized your style! Great work!
I saw this a long time ago and rediscovered your channel recently. I had no idea you were the creator of this. What a pleasant surprise
David Romero's "Coraline" like dark nightmarish fairytale.
Ok the ending actually got me! xD
The monster is so damn creepy and I love it.
1:21 I knew that was the Baseball bat over the fireplace!
Am I the only one that just can't have this video run properly?
If memory serves me well, you were working on a project for Netflix. How did that turnout?
Also, great vid.👍
Довольно таки жутко, после просмотра, меня настигло странное чувство страха.
Dang she got hit off the fridge 😂 that killed me
Same I laughed so hard I know I probably should not have but it was so funny bahahahahaah
Nah cuz where are the parents this late at night
Holy shit that twist scared me
The bang on the fridge made me remember all the memes I watched of people hitting their his and it almost made me laugh
This makes me glad all the doors into my house dont have windows
I have never seen sleep paralysis animated but that was accurate af
beth is first taken, as we see when lily goes downstairs in the kitchen, the window mirror is broken. plus the door to beths room is open. the thing made lily invisible when beth looked for lily in her room. and we can even see a girls silhouette during lilys paralysis
Trevor Herderson + David Romero = Perfection
This a nice ode to nightmare on elm street with the ending. this is cool,
I respect that kid going down the stairs without lights 😮
This is why stormy or rainy nights in general gets a bad rap. Our brain registers this experience as a reference = scary.
Bravo. Love the work.
From Russia with love ;)
Why's everybody commenting this
For whatever reason, this video just won't play for me. I had to go watch it on another person's channel, then come back here to comment.
The scene during the actual sleep paralysis has some of the most disturbing use of music I've seen in a long time. Mimicking what Lily's heartbeat would be like in that moment.
same, i thought it was my internet but i guess not ? Like it just won't load at all
Something is up with that video, I too can't get it to play.
Are you from Canada? Is this some kind of weird region lock thing?
@@Pers0n97 I am indeed. It might have something to do with it. Strange that I've never had this happen with any other video before.
EDIT: The other channel I viewed it on is called Lets Read! in case that helps you find one that might work.
@@animatorbug Thanks for the name, it will indeed be useful :)
@@Pers0n97 im also in canada so it would make sense if that was the issue since theres 3 of us lol
This is going to give me nightmares
I love this animation
From Russia with LOVE 🔥
From Russia 🇷🇺 with love ❤️
Nepravilno!
From Russia with love:D
Vot kak pravilno
From Brazil🇧🇷❤️
I don’t know why , but Beth getting slapped on the fridge before getting taken is funny to me
I remember this from when I was a kid, it horrified me, but only because the final part
I love your art styles! I'm too busy admiring your animations to be scared. I am thrilled instead. Also is that the house from the exorcist? i love that!
I thought it was going to be in fact her little sister behind her, just didn't expect that plot twist.
this needs to be made into a full length animated or live action movie
Nice jump scares. Usually they are so obvious but the one with paralysis demon over the bed and at the end were able to catch me off guard.
Ok. I DO love it