Karen Read Trial / Trooper Joe Paul Witness Expert
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 พ.ย. 2024
- This is an updated 3d illustration of how it's believed Karen Reads SUV reversed into John O'Keefe. It Shows from the data points how for and fast she traveled according to Trooper Joe Paul, an expert for the prosecution.
View my TikTok account at: @azgetindustries
![Chris Langan - The Interview THEY Didn't Want You To See - CTMU [Full Version; Timestamps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9miVG2xT5jY/mqdefault.jpg)
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
You forgot the pirouette 😅
Make sure it's counterclockwise
True. She should do a reenactment of exactly how Trooper Paul explains it, with him spinning while holding the glass and phone
😂 right
@@kathy9901 Then the ground opens and the earth tells him, in trooper Proctors voice, how things went down.
@@Lawh Even her diagram is off. He literally testified he flew up near the flag pole 30 ft. Also only the inside of his right arm was hit with the passenger side of the car. So obviously John did a side flip and his arm got hit in mid air. Also there were cars parked on the sides and Karen did a 3 point turn according to the CW...
This is awesome. Now I understand why the prosecution didn't even attempt a visual reconstruction...it makes NO SENSE at all.
Why do you think they did t hire a real company? They couldn’t even fabricated if they tried lol
Makes zero sense.
You forgot the pirouette, back flip, James Brown slide and the Electric Boogaloo with drink in hand!
🤣 well, it could happen, apparently...😂😂 poor guy. Can you I imagine when he heard himself saying that??
But did the drink spill? 😂
That would be amazing 😂
And she forgot to add subtitles explaining the "shawk and hawrerr!"
And… black strawssss 😊
The three people in the truck were parked behind the SUV they didn’t see John and Karen didn’t back up.
They also didn't see a jeep parked by the mailbox which everyone else, including those who left, claims was there. If true this, that the Jeep was there, it's just another example of the prosecution's witnesses contradicting each other's statements. After 7 weeks of this bullshit I reached the point where I wouldn't believe it was snowing without checking the National Weather Service first.
They didn't see anyone but Karen in the car as Ryan Nagel stated.
Excellent video. These are the types of video recreations that our experts create for trials. It's so much easier to understand the data when you can visualize it. Juries appreciate this.
It helps that she can string a sentence together too.
It's also exactly WHY there was no recreation in this trial, because their theory makes NO sense for how John not only ended up where he did, but also how he had no broken bones, or even fractures, after being hit by a car. In her recreation here, it's VERY evident that unless you honestly believe John did a pirouette, then he would have been partially on the curb/road. It also doesn't explain how he had blood on his shirt & shoes (gravity says those blood drops fell DOWN, which means he'd be bleeding while standing). It's just the most ridiculous trial I've ever watched.
@@forcryinoutloud *Absolutely the most ridiculous trial I've ever*
*watched and I'm a court trial nut! So many lies... The cover-up of*
*the corruption going on is absurd and if John hadn't lost his life*
*hilarious clown circus.* 🎪
*And the O'Keefe's still backing the McAlberts? PUHHHHlease!*
@@forcryinoutloudexactly & from pictures of where John was in the snow, there was compacted snow under him. Yet in his closing argument, Lally lied and said there was grass under him .... Does he think he's slick because technically under the snow, is grass? I do want to shove my boot up that rotten man's you know what. The judges instructions for closing was to only say things that were true based on evidence shown. So much of what he said was lies I was steaming.
Garbage in
Garbage out
Trooper Paul wasnt let in on the decision to place Brian Higgins’ Jeep in front of the mailbox. sure seems like she would’ve backed right into it
They are having a very hard time keeping their story straight
That's exactly what I thought. Why didn't defense mention that 🤔
I’ve been watching this trial for two months and it’s been incredibly helpful to see it visually. It makes it even more insane that this even went to trial. Your work is incredible!
From this it would make more sense that she backed into the hydrant than a person.
no bumper damage? lol sure bro makes total sense
@@enzoinfinity1 Seldon, that was sarcasm ...
That's always been a sticking point to me, if she was as drunk as they say (which I don't believe) how'd she expertly miss the fire hydrant?!
@@enzoinfinity1 I didn't say she did, I said it would be more likely. The hydrant was closer and there was debris around it, according to the pds "evidence"
For the life of me, I couldn’t not picture what Trooper Paul was claiming happened. It was hard just trying to comprehend him. This is very helpful, thank you!
People who talk BS talk in circles throwing in useless info in attempt to confuse you and next thing you know, they've got you wrapped around their finger.
This is so good! Thank you! I was expecting for a recreation like this to be shown at trial!
Yes strange this girl can do this this trial has been crazy and I feel many like lally are throwing the game here 😮
Also Brian Higgins car is supposed to be at the mailbox too. She can't reverse all the way to the driveway.
When the tow truck driver drove the suv onto the flatbed the taillight was mostly intact. Nothing like what the prosecution showed. And certainly not missing as what turned up on the lawn.
100%!! This Neverending "tailight field" that kept blooming for weeks was nuts! That was NOT what we saw on Karen's car in multiple videos,there was a lot of red....
Add to it that Dighton cop's testimony who was also there @towtruck & the defense theory of Proctor doctoring the tail light & planting 🚯the evidence is bulletproof, AF imo.
I wonder why the tow truck driver was not on the stand?
Also loading the Lexus on the tow truck lines up with the 1162 key cycle and you can see the driver spin the wheels in the snow in reverse trying to line it up with the truck
It’s clearly visible too after she hit John’s car! I’m so over the tail light gas lighting I have eyes lol
The Commonwealth never explained how John's blood pattern started from his head and went down him which means he was standing when the blood started coming out of his nose and ears!
🎯
Trooper paul says he flew 30 feet and was only struck on the arm so you need to fix this a little bit
He didn't fly. He didn't slide or roll. He was "propelled".
His testimony was so bad!
@@empireofpeaches "projected" but landed with no dirt or mud on him so I guess he gently skimmed the top of the snow only, but also didn't leave any tracks in the snow so I guess he flew threw the air, but also Trooper Paul adamantly refuses anyone who uses the word "flew" 😂
Give trooper Paul a break.
The crime scene spoke to him.
He knows what happened!!!
There were vehicles in front of house! Higgins and another truck
They need this for the jury to see how impossible that would be. Amazing work you've done here!!!! 💯🏆
Thank you so much for putting this visual together! Justice for John O’Keefe!
& Karen Reed!
Sadly, they are so trying so hard to prevent a woman from going to jail and make a witness LOOK credible (unbelievable they would take that much time calling others to fix a prior witness testimony)
Too much has gone uninvestigated. The house, the people with bloody knuckles, a dog...Noone will be found guilty. They did a shitty job investigating and a shittier job prosecuting....They have nothing but holes, it has to be reasonable doubt. And John O'keefe gets no justice.
@@jeanettecoleman-mz7ieand canton many there not happy about the attitudes within many in the community many standing with Karen after she is free I don’t think it will be the same of the likes of the Alberts and co I hope anyway and many other ppl in towns should do the same if you see or know something is wrong should come together and get the rats out the kitchen that’s me again being optimistic 😂I know one thing this world can’t continue the way it’s going 😢
Reportedly, John's final resting place was almost a straight shot from the Alberts' gate that opened to the fenced backyard.
First of all, you get points for keeping a straight face when mentioning Trooper Paul's claims.
Second... Trooper Paul seemed to accept that John ended up 30ft away, not 10ft.
This is the kind of video we NEED to see in court. This never made sense in court, and seeing this video proves even more it makes no sense.
I do wonder how she doesn’t hit the missing Higgy-Jeep complete with plow that was supposedly parked by the mailbox
We showed your amazing work on our latest show at around the 3hrs 35 min mark.
What a boost you have given me....Thank you so much!
Watching from Wales 🏴 and just wanted to remind you about the truck, with the snow plough attachment, that was also reportedly parked outside by the mailbox. In your digital representation Karen’s car would have smashed into said truck after breaking. Now I maybe remembering wrong but just in case I’m not I thought you may like to know. FYI your videos are great 👍🏻
Great point about the noise which I don't think anyone has taken into consideration. Even if they were having a party with loud music, they might not have heard it inside the house but the neighbours would have heard something. Hopefully this is something the reconstructionists will cover.
Great job. Your videos are always so clear.
I hope Netflix uses more of your work, I found this very helpful and accurate to what the Trooper claims he believed happened. Well done
Your comment makes no sense? Nothing Trooper Psul said was accurate, true, or believable? May I kindly ask what do you mean? This video proves the TP didn't know his as* from his elbow
@@eileencalabro7909 clearly you don't understand - but I'm saying this proves the trooper didn't know his ass from his elbow.
How he could be considered an expert is beyond me...
People in the house were listening to music so not surprising they didn't hear anything.
I was just going to say that, drunk, down in the basement , being loud, I’m sure. No I wouldn’t count on any of them hearing it but wouldn’t a neighbor 🤷🏻♀️ guess not. Lucky, now he’s the neighborhood watchdog, very observant man, Lucky, he gets around
@@bowwow7505right, The neighbors house is so close to the fire hydrant as well..
This reenactment video recreation needs to go viral. And how is it that there’s nothing like this being shown in court??
I agree! Should’ve been the 1st thing shown with the lead investigator & medical examiner
How are they going to show a 200lb man getting thrown 30 feet by a car and the car only have a cracked tail light?
Because this an absurd rendition of what was testified to
Listen to the direct testimony b4 crucifying trooper
It's possible she drove back to argue with him. When I was younger we were sitting in our back yard when we heard what sounded like a garbage can being hit. A woman had hit a young man. We lived three houses down from the impact. There is just too much reasonable doubt in this case
The narrative also holds that O'Keefe saw and heard Karen backing up right at him at a high rate of speed but chose to just stand there anyway. No one would do that. It also makes no sense that Ms. Read would choose to drop O'Keefe off almost at the property line (and make him walk through the snow and through the ongoing blizzard) - versus the street point nearest the house entrance (where the walkway was). Of course, that property line area was lined up with the fenced-off area to the back of the house, where it makes more sense that the conspirators carried O'Keefe's body out and dumped it (one straight line from rear to front of property). Skirting the property line (and all those shadows) somewhat would prevent looky-loos from seeing what was going on. Besides, the Ford Edge (believed to be Brian Albert's) had been strategically (and temporarily) parked on the street (during the storm, which is prohibited) adjacent to the "dump" spot to prevent anyone driving by from seeing the illicit activity. This is per snowplow driver.
There is nothing that says John was sitting there staring at the vehicle backing up. More likely she dropped him off down the street, he was walking towards the house with his back to the car. Karen saw her opportunity and gunned her V8 in reverse and John just heard an engine revving assuming Karen was driving off until it was too late. Then he got hit and likely staggered to his final resting place.
@@andrewjames8980ur an idiot if u think that bc from what ur saying, Karen “gunned” it down the road n after John was hit by this V8, he kept walking n staggered to his final resting place, like that’s what ur saying happen. That he continued walking n fell to his resting place after he was hit by a V8 Lexus. Like r u fucking kidding me. U can’t be that dumb. I don’t know if any person that gets hit by a car that is going 24mph n can continue to walk n fall to there resting place but hey I guess u have seen some crazy shit. Honestly from what u think happened, u n trooper Paul shd be best friends bc both of ur conclusions r asinine. I just can’t wait till Monday when the FBI & DOJ experts come in n explain what they think happened. Bc I’m sure they have a more reasonable explanation then urs n trooper Paul.
@@andrewjames8980 well, witnesses including jenn said that karen suv was infont of the house
@@andrewjames8980 the CW didn't prove that.
@@andrewjames8980zero body trauma. Zero. 🤔
I think you and your work are absolutely amazing. Thank GOD, there will be actual educated experts provided by the feds on Monday to provide you factual information. I’m excited for you to be able to use this data to create the best 3D images we’ve seen yet.
I was wondering if we were ever going to see a computer reenactment. I was hoping it would be in the trial, however!
I didn't know you did the recreation in that Murdaugh docu-series. Wow!
Question about this one, please. Wasn't Agent Brian Higgins' Jeep parked at the mailbox? Karen would have hit it.
I thought the tail light broke after 5 am when she slowly backed into the vehicle in the back
The prosecution's claim is that she hit the victim so hard that it "projected" him 30 feet, broke the tail light, and pieces of the tail light ended up all over the area.
Even if there had been a boisterous party going on in that house, it’s not like there isn’t another house across the street, neighboring, etc., in real life… such a peculiar case, indeed
Azget Industries is one of the best in this field! She absolutely to have her work shown to larger audiences. Her future is limitless with her talent!!!!
I wish the defense showed this to trooper Paul at trial. And especially the jurors bc this wld be so helpful to see.
Just found your channel. The video was awesome. I liked and subscribed.
thanks for your work 🤗 where is the next video you mention at the end of this one, that shows it couldn’t have been like this presentation 🤷♀️
He's about as sharp as a beach ball.
*CAN YOU DO A BIRDS EYE VIEW WITH HIGGINS JEEP AND NAGELS BROTHERS FRIENDS PICKUP ACCOUNTED FOR PLEASE??!?*
These are AMAZING videos. Thank you for the work you’ve put into these!!!
I saw a video of a guy trying to drive backwards at the speed of 27 miles per hr in a 7,000 lb suv. He said he couldn't not get up that speed at such a short distance.???
That was Turtle Boy. He only got to 17mph and said it was really difficult
Her car data proves she did that.
And now, for the illustration of how John received all those bite marks on his arm. Like your channel!
Poor trooper paul. He cant help it. Shoulda quit before testifying.
You forgot about the Jeep with a snowplow attached that was parked by mailbox. She would’ve had to miraculously stopped, on an icy road, before hitting it. This trooper is so full of shite it’s clear he has no education on physics or even basic common sense.
Excellent work! Both here and with the Murdaugh case! I'd seen your re-creations of the Murdough killings and thought they were super helpful! Thanks for doing the Read case too. Best of luck with your Netflix deal!
Nice work! I couldn't believe Trooper Paul didn't have something like this (but then again, he couldn't have)
You can't make assumptions about noise "certainly" being heard inside the house.
There was also a Jeep parked next to the mail box she would've ended up hitting, also possibly a truck parked in that area she would've hit too.
I believe all the “witnesses” in the house agree a Dodge Cherokee with a plow is parked along the street with its rear aligned with the mail box. Thread that needle.
Jeep Wrangler with a plow...No such thing as a Dodge Cherokee! I got you're point, and you are correct!
Wouldn't she have hit that backing up 62,or 3 feet??
To do to John what the alberts & accomplices did, they have hearts of Stone, to match their faces!
Wow! That was YOUR work in the Murdaugh documentary?! That’s awesome! You do fantastic work! I hope you reupload all your other TikToks to this channel because I don’t have a TikTok but would like to see your other videos.
Outfrickenstanding!! Excellent video!
I appreciate your illustrations so much. They really augment what some of the witnesses were trying to convey.
*Subscribed...excellent! Good luck with Netflix!* 💖
Seems implausible someone could accelerate in reverse to 24 mph in such a short distance with a snow covered road.
Yes, that is true from a guy that used the measurement mentioned in court and the vehicle speed backwards. He tried several times and could not reach the speed mentioned in court.
So the literal black box evidence, straight out of her car, isn’t good enough proof?
This is a great example of the fact when some people have their minds made up, before the case even goes to trial, then there is absolutely not one bit of physical evidence is going to change their mind. (Even when that person most definitely committed the crime.) It shows that most people, are not capable of staying completely biased.
@@JustKatTalking Which trial have you been watching?
I have been hit by a car going over 30 in the snow vehicle was traveling in reverse down a hill at approximately 30 to 35 and when the car hit me my arm didn't break the tail light or hurt me badly as there was no friction it just lifted me up slightly and I pushed myself away from the car my estament was from my ability to avoid the car I thought I had plenty of time to get away from being hit but.the car was moving much faster than that
Several friends and I was pushing cars up a hill that people insisted on going up imzsted of around zwe were having fun with it charging 5 dollars a car as they had a small amount of traction but not enough to take them to the top and the five of us would push them up the vehicle that hit me we had pushed it up to the top and we were om our way back down when the person thought they had tje car I'm drive but had it I'm reverse insted when they stepped on the Gas they went flying backwards and thinking that they were in drive pushed the gas all the way to tje floor to help slow their decent they were flying backwards at a very high rate of speed I turned in time to see car and atempt to get out of tje way but they were going much faster than I precived which I thought was about 25 in reality it was between 30 and 40.mph just as they struck me they put the car I'm drive as I pushed out the way I received no major injuries as we kept.pishimg cars for 2 more hours making 200 dollars between the five of us I belive that no person broke.tjay taillight and that the guy went flying as that truck would hit him high enough om his body to push him down not up and would have ran him over 😮
@@JustKatTalking Cars don't have black boxes like airplanes do.
Proctor knew he could make this kid do and say whatever he wanted!
What about the supposed jeep with the blow? Was that taken into account in your recreation?
Awesome recreation! So glad to find you!
Wow, your video randomly popped up in my feed, this is a town away from mine so I clicked… and you quite talented. Seriously, I feel like everyone is so snarky in comments nowadays, but I was very impressed with your models. I’d say too bad the state couldn’t find someone with your skill to reconstruct the scene… but I’m starting to think maybe they wanted it that way 😮 Good luck with your bid to Netflix! 💜💜
Keep in mind that noise travel further in cold weather. Plus the fact that Higgins' Jeep was parked in front of the mailbox according to his own testimony.
Thank you for putting in all this work. The visuals are incredibly helpful. Good luck with netflix!!
So glad this popped up on my feed. It’s fascinating!
I am OUTRAGED! If you live in Massachusetts these are the officers and experts protecting you! Petrifying and infuriating!
With the treasonous government's "authority" to put you in a cage!!
Such amazing content! Always makes the highly publicized trials you cover so easy to follow and understand!
Amazing work. I wish you all the best as you continue to further your career.
Your videos have made me understand in 2 minutes what I could not understand in 10 weeks of trial. Thanks!
Your videos are terrific. You could contact attorneys in your area to see if they could use your work.
👍🏻👍🏻Wow great work ,so glad turtle boy showed clip of yr video and linked yr channel tonight .yr very clever & talented.
well this is an instant sub. showing people visibly how stupid some of these theories are is a skill that more defense teams need to start taking advantage of.
Big props for doing more to illustrate their case than the Commonwealth. 😊
I am in awe of you and your work, so talented.😮
just found you and subscribed to you through TB Live yesterday/today. Thank you too for your work to find truth and justice!
Also, the road in front of the house isn't straight, it has a bit of a curve to it. I'm not sure why Paul's evidence doesn't reflect that.
Lol, I can't imagine how ridiculous you must have felt trying to recreate this guy's nonsense theory. Good effort though!
Thankyou for the demonstration
Excellent breakdown. Also the McCabes and Albert's sat they couldn't see John because there was so much snow and Jennifer looked out at Karen's car at least 3 times in 3 different positions and people were in and out if the house. If there was so much snow, his landing would be softer.
Great job ! Love your videos and the time and effort you take to put them together !!
You do fantastic work and really put this into perspective! I wish you the best in your budding career and hope to see more from you! xx
Very good to put a visual to verbal testimony. Stunning work. Keep it up! 👍👏
Thank You so much for putting his "expert opinion" into a visual form. It helped me confirm that not only did his explanation SOUND ludicrous but it also LOOKS ludicrous!
Here from TB 🐢 great work 👏🏻
Awesome animations, thanks. Would be really cool to see a birds eye view of all of the parties movements for the night, from the bar to yo the house and next morning. Even a low quality animation to make it quicker to create. Multiple different claims and some actual data which shows how some cant be telling the truth. Very fascinating case and it looks like cops killed a cop and are trying to cover it up, so there's a lot of interest in this case.
This will be a documentary (some content creators have already been approached by people regarding documentary) so having some really good animations od the different stories/versions would not only be cool to see but could end up in the documentary
I second this. Lawyer Lee does summary videos and she's put together with her viewers a timeline so maybe that's a good source to go off of
This is absurd. He also said his arm was out on a hinge.
It just doesn’t even make sense. If she backed up that far she would’ve hit Brian Higgen’s jeep! It’s amazing how she can drive in reverse on a snowy road and not completely lose control of her car at 24mph.
Yea, as if a tail light explodes and throws fragments that far in front of the alleged impact...
Thus is the most ridiculous theory I've ever seen, although you did a great job of recreating this bogus theory.
Wow Azget where have you been !
Higgins vehicle, with an attached plow, is missing in front of the mailbox.
Also can you do another video of the phone data showing john going into the house with the apple data
Great work ❤ respect
Great video! Cant waiit to watch more of what you do!
Amazing video. I came & subscribed from Turtleboy live🐢. He sent his chat here to see your amazing videos. 💕Free Karen Read💕 🙌🏽Justice for John O’Keefe🙌🏽
The problem with Paul's testimony is, he would have been run over by the back of the SUV in order for that taillight to hit his right arm. If side swiped his left arm would have had to be sticking out. Zero injuries to the left arm. Now, if his back is to the SUV and it hit his right arm, the injuries would have been on the other side of the arm, and his elbow probably would have been broken. He wasn't hit by the SUV.
I hope you get the Netflix gig. Netflix needs some truth and integrity.
I don’t like your videos - I love them! I just didn’t know they were you! So happy to have found them. Thank you.
Great job! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
I just found out about you from watching this video on 🐢 boy’s TH-cam channel!
I also just realized that I saw one of your videos on the Alex Murdaugh trial, I believe on Netflix.
Anyway, great work and I’m definitely a new Sub! 😉
Subscribed because of Turtleboy! Great work!
Me too
That looks exactly like when he drove her car forward and backwards at the CPD, exactly like it 🤔🤦♂️
Great video!