ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ม.ค. 2024
- Five Nights at Freddy's has had quite a few fangames made over the years, however one stood among the rest, for better or for worse, Five Nights at Freddy's 3 Fan made aka The Return to Freddy's. Controversy, stolen asset, and possible legal issues? This fan game had it all, tune in to find out more!
Go to gamersupps.gg/toadbup and use code "TOADBUP" to get 10% off your entire order!
Twitter: / toadbup64
Instagram: / toadbup
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @toadbup
Music Used (In Order):
Professor E Gadd - Luigi's Mansion 3
Tropical Jungle - Nicktoons Battle for Volcano Island
World 7 - New Super Mario Bros. DS
Ghost Island - Pac Man World
Casino Delfino - Super Mario Sunshine
Level 3 (Temple of Nightmare) - Jack Bros
A Slice and A Scoop - FNAF Pizzeria Simulator
Outro by TimmyTurnersGranddad ( • Body Rock - WarioWare ... )
#fnaf #fivenightsatfreddys - เกม
Speaking of Sugar, after Sugar was removed in an update, Tyler wrote a message in the files calling Emil a bitch.
Didn't he also call Emil other stuff
@@Minecraft_2008. I don’t know. I’m just going by other videos and wikis.
Yeah in the files people found “emil” as well as “emil is a bi***” and I think something else as well but I don’t remember.
@@Minecraft_2008.he also called Emil a Jackass
Ah yes. Tactful.
1:06 the reason why nobody knocked FNaF for doing this is because the games were actually good. Each one held a similar formula while also being different enough to stand on it's own. Scott didn't rush his development. They were only released so early because he happened to finish them that early.
Each Banban game is, like, 2 hour of boring shlock because the Euphoric Brothers chose to make the games stretch as agonizingly thin as possible instead of improving the experience because they didn't want to be refunded. FNaF bumped out fairly solid games with complete experiences fairly quickly while BanBan pumps out a game the drags longer and longer with each release
I feel like this is less true for FNAF 2 since there are 11 animatronics and 9 of them act the exact same. The vibes and atmosphere were spot on, but the gameplay was mangled imo (pun intended)
@HabitsRabbits true. But it was still pretty hype when it came out. And even as one of the worst of the clickteam games, it's still decent enough to be worth its price.
My point was that the comparison of Banban and FNaF's complaints over their release schedules is odd. One was released early because the games were finished early, despite Scott's initial estimates having them release much later. People didn't complain because they were solid games, even if some weren't as good in retrospect
Banban provides a worse, more boring, and more dragged out experience each time, making none of the games worth your time or your money
@@HabitsRabbits that said, FNaF 2 was a bit too ambitious. Scott could have spent a little longer on it
@@mechamanw668 Very true. I don't think people give Scott enough credit for how cheap the classic games were. Even if FNAF 2 had the strategic complexity of a cardboard box gameplay wise, it still has a ton of little quirks and Easter eggs to have fun with. I've got loads of fond memories discussing the teasers with my friends back in first grade!
Garden of Banban really just feels like it's trying to do FNAF without any of the heart the games had. It's kind of sad, but I don't expect people will be talking about it for very long.
Yep
I heard that Emil Macko wasn’t even planning to make a game using Candy the Cat until he was stolen by Tyler, and Emil wanted to do the character justice. Five nights at Candy’s wouldn’t exist without Fnaf 3
I watched a video talking about the FNAC timeline and I remember the video mentioning this, that he made the game because of fears of people stealing the character, Minaxa made the video.
The "Fnaf 3"
bro its fnaf 3 fanmade, i mean, the return to freddys, i mean, the return to freddys classic there we go
We always have something good due to bad situations. Sadly its true
@@itnaboi The Return To Freddy's Classic Recoded*
The irl and ingame lore behind TRTF is fucking insane.
There is so much wild shit that went on behind the scenes throughout this game's series.
Super cancer
@@Markeplier23 frankburt strip club💀💀💀💀
Super Cancer
The animatronic strip club
Guy gets spring locked by slipping on some soap
I was friends with Tyler back in the day, and can confirm that he did fake his death and admitted to some… unsavory intimacy with a sibling.
Wait what the fuck
@@GhosOfTheMoon-hj9st fun times
@@LinkiePupgod dang, there is simply now way, how old were you two?
@@dreamercraftyt7480 all of us where in our mid-teens iirc I was still 14 and Tyler was something like 15( maybe 16.) it was 10 years ago. The info is out there.
Tyler was known to over share things when he would go live.
I can just confirm the claims.
@@LinkiePup God damn.
Fnaf 3 (fan made) clearly is a game made quickly and lazily to capitalize on fnaf3
Slight correction, I do believe that FNAF 3 (fanmade) was made before the actual FNAF 3.
I am not saying that justifies calling it that, but it's still slightly better than calling it after a game that already existed
Slight correction: Scott has confirmed that the toxic meter was used as theorized in the interview with Dawko
Fun fact, at the time, Candy wasn't well known yet. There was even a hoax about "leaked FNAF 3 pictures," which were mostly Emil Macko renders along with other pictures from other sources.
Also, how i remember, name Sugar was also given to him by fans, when everyone thought he will be in FNaF 3, and Tyler just used this name, maybe because also belived in these hoaxes(c'mon he was 13-14 when he created first TRTF).
@@sanek-puppet-463 Oh, I didn’t know that.
@@troin3925 idk if this real
Wasn’t Emils, animatronic Markiplier a fnaf 3 hoax at some point? Lol. Also why I am now all of a sudden as I am literally writing this comment, recalling an Emil style render of an animatronic alligator that was 100% not Monty because the render was a darker green and had smaller eyes with no glasses, the snoot was also wider.
@@adventurekitty101 The Markiplier render was also part of that same hoax.
Imagine if there was a timeline where Tyler was the biggest fnaf fan game maker and TRTF was actually fire
The good ending
"imagine"
Edit: Crap, I messed up, sorry: Team Radiance didn't make Dormitabis remastered, Expelled Studios did.
@@cheeseyleaves uhm dude, someone else created dormitabis remastered
@@cappedminer369 Oh crap, I forgot.
The difference between Scott's games releasing so quickly and banbans, is Scott's games were actually good
FRRR
But BanBan is funny XD
@DinoGoofHybridHero7531 I wouldn't really say it's funny, the people behind it aren't the best people either
@@AwakenedSpace80 hey at least they ain’t pedos XD
@DinoGoofHybridHero7531 The Euphoric Brothers are pretty scummy people. They make the games even worse on purpose just so people can't refund them, and they made a game about a school shooter and sold it as a comedic game. And then they have the audacity to act like whiny 13 year old crybabies when they're called out for their shitty behavior.
I Cant Wait For Google 2 (Fan-Made)!
lol funni comment :p
Bro, the return to google is so good!
You mean the return to searching search mode?
@@Accurate.Toy.Story.Collector what?? do you mean the return to searching search mode classic?
Three years back, I went to the TRTF wiki for kicks, and found that The Return to Freddy's has VERY weird lore.
SUPER CANCER
@@burner555 Exactly
like what?
@@nemui_777 The animatronics made in like the early 40's, the animatronics being both mascots and torture devices, "super cancer" (whatever that means)
SUPER CANCER
The reason why Tyler says sorry for "being incest" is because he said his girlfriend, and the person who got him to add kitty fazcat, was his sister! We don't actually know if that was a sick joke or a sick reality and I don't know what would be worse...
Nope, its fake, his ex was at uk, how would that be his sister
@@Wizardjones69 People... can have siblings that don't live with them..?
@@CometMothman and literally his ex girl friend confirmed that she isnt tyler sister
1:00
The reason people give Banban shit for its fast release dates is because unlike FNAF, in which you can clearly see Scott's passion and hard work in each game, which are all solid entries, Banban is just soulless and low-effort garbage all the way and never shows any signs of improvement.
The idea that banban never shows any type of improvement is just objectively false. I don’t care how much you hate the games, you cannot think they haven’t improved in at least a trivial manner unless you literally haven’t seen any of the games beyond what angry commenters are saying about them.
@@gotgunpowderwould’ve been a improvement if they stopped making them entirely
literally when garten of banban JUST released chapter 1, believe me, just the FIRST chapter, they were selling merch already, you can see their true intentions
Ironically that's one thing I actually like about Ban Ban. It feels like a game made in school as part of a group project.
Like you play it with a grain of salt and not take it too seriously.
Atleast that's the vibe I got from it.
toadbup’s videos make me feel fuzzy inside like a duckling filled with tarantulas
same
And now that I'm here, these replies are gonna get weird.
(I am deeply sorry I couldn't think of a better joke.)
That’s a very creative saying
thank you i think?
Nowadays, Tyler himself is still making video games, except he has moved on from making fangames into creating his own original projects and such.
okay but are they good
@@Monochromiaa There's an upcoming one that actually seems pretty good, but we won't know if it's an original idea with a good storyline until it actually drops. Given this man's horrible, and I mean HORRIBLE track record it's hard to imagine he made a turnaround though (It wasn't touched on very much in this video, but he is basically THE copycat and bad writer who has done some extremely questionable things behind closed doors but I can't remember the specifics. Minaxa has a good video on the whole franchise and Tyler that explains everything)
@Monochromiaa They haven’t released yet but the trailers to them look extremely well done!
@SkiggsMoDiggs Yeah, his history isn’t that great, but I can safely say that he has improved alot and matured alot ever since 2018!
@@GoldenSavor I have yet to see anything related to his newer game, but I will say that it is possible he has improved, after all we all have to start somewhere, and while his start may not have the best it is possible for people's skills to improve and move towards original content (for example, Toby Fox started out making rom hacks and is now a well established Indie dev who has even done work for the Pokemon franchise)
"Hey gordon.. i found where the combine are in this pizza place"
Edit:"this is barney from black mesa I Just got you're notifications using a transmitter in city 17"
Edit:"I'm currently tracking down the combine with Gordon freeman wish me luck"
is that........really barney calhoun...............i lobe him....
Holy carp……. It’s half-life witty man! 🔥🔥🔥💀💀💀
Is that born calgoob
"Look Gordon a rope, we can use it to- HELP ME GORDON!"
@@merchantziro4285 THATS HLVRAI NOT HALF LIFE YOU IDIOT /lh
Tbf to Scott, he released QUALITY games witthin short time frames, whereas BanBan is, not as great. Like, some features and parts feel like it could have thrived if given more time
First time im so early lol
8:59 IDK why but love how the sc gets a little squished when it gets "bit" 😂
FNaF lacks a lot of poishing,tho
“If you want to learn about F*cking kitty fazcat” had my dying
Tyler's now making a game called "the road that falls" with like...a huge text wall of stuff going like "YOU THOUGHT TRTF MEANT THE RETURN TO FREDDYS?!?!?! WRONG, ITS MY NEW HORROR GAME" or something.
8:03 Tyler sounds like bob from bob’s burgers but even more tired
Stealing other people's work takes a toll on you
FNaF did actually get a good deal of heat for pumping out games, I remember a lot of people talking about how Scott was milking the franchise, so this isn't a double standard against BanBan here.
The funny thing is that this isn't the only FNAF fan game that is illegal. There was a mobile game called FNAF 4 before the actual FNAF 4 came out that was actually illegal for several reasons. It was a terrible platformer trying to pass itself off as the real FNAF 4, with title art being a Gmod picture with Pinkie Pie and TF2's Sniper in it. This thing has been lost to time sadly, but it's weird to even know that it happened.
And not even the first for Scott to threaten, (see: Case Animatronics)
there are also two other remakes of FNaF 2 that were taken down by Scott
One of them made by the FNaF+ developer
@@atanaZion This reminds me, there used to be a fnaf mobile game called 'Vincent'
@@PlanForGaming I knew about it!
I don't remember the content but aside from controling Purple Guy it had nothing to do with FNaF whatsover
@@atanaZion I vaguely remember it having a fnaf free roam of some of the games? I think.
Found a link for a video, I thought it looked better than that and had other fnaf games but the Illuminaghti music pretty much confirms its the same game:
th-cam.com/video/lOE0WK9BBT8/w-d-xo.html
The fact that anyone could put out something like this and genuinely be proud of what they've done is insane lmao
You cant be telling me that banban 5 released literally two days later from 4. Even considering both being developed at the same time that is just nuts.
That's because it didn't
Like granted I ain't giving them praise BUT it does usually take like a couple months between each game.
The dev is actually still working on the series but he's rebooting it as it's own IP called The Road That Falls (Yes it uses the same TRTF abbreviation the old games used). Not sure how the game is coming along but given the other titles in the series I expect it will be utterly insane if it ever launches.
Bro is saying it will be on PS5 on the trailers,lol
A: Talking to people that were little kids when FNAF first came out makes me feel old and is scary.
B: FNAF was *very* much criticized for it's rapid releases early on. And in general, there was a lot of contra to FNAFs popularity.
"Cheap jumpscare simulator", was one of the most frequent descriptions, going as far as even denying it the status as a horror game.
4:20 using the anniversary Gokus in a random segment of the video for numbering reasons is a nice touch, due to recent events especially, RIP Toriyama
great video though I had a fun watch!
ITS SO WEIRD TO THINK ABOUT BEING OLDER THEN AN ADULT TH-camR. As a kid, all the adults on here seemed so old and now they're younger than me.
1:01 easy, the fnaf games were good quality and had lots of longevity in the way of lore and stuff, plus with custom nights had good replayability as well as them not pretending to be anything other than low budget, simple games
Ban ban doesn’t do any of these even slightly and each game is significantly shorter than even the shortest fnaf game despite their popularity
saying FNaF has lot of longetivity is insane
YOu could beat all of them (including SL) in less than one hour and their gameplay is pretty much the same so no replayability
@@atanaZion First, fnaf is based around Its lore, not gameplay. Second, each game has unique mechanics. Fnaf 1 had cameras and doors, fnaf 2 had the Freddy mask which when you used It you couldn't watch the cameras, fnaf 3 had audio lure, vent doors, phantoms and system errors, fnaf 4 had a completely different gameplay than all the other games, fnaf 5 was different each night, fnaf 6 had the tycoon gameplay and tasks progress instead of hours; and that's just the core gameplay mechanics of each game.
Sure, If you play them enough, you'll learn their patterns, but that's just every single game in existence.
The TRTF novel is something else, it's more of a drug trip than LSD Dream Simulator
When he wrote "being incest" I think he meant being insensitive
no, he meant being inappropriate with his sister (allegedly)
it’s really cool to see videos made by channels that aren’t as massive getting sponsorships
3:52 kitty fazcat is his computer background
Bro, that mention of Yamimash unlocked a part of my brain I haven't accessed in close to a decade at this point.
DOKKAN BATTLE MENTIONED!!!!
I see you grinding those links while keeping an eye out for foxy, living the sweet sweet life
How does the custom night work if there's no AI tho??
Actually I'm not too sure. Either they took the source code from another fnaf game, decided to use ai ONLY for the custom night for some reason, or manually scripted every level of difficulty per animatronic 🤷
@@ToadBup hm, maybe the number is just the amount of times they appear. idk if just 1 to 1 or more. but yeah, who knows :p
new toadbup video, i used to pray for times like these 😭🫂
"NO! YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO OBEY ME!"
The 5 Souls of the Children he murdered: 😊
A child with a red soul:
YIPPEE IM SO HAPPY WHEN TOAD BUP UPLOADS
Bro fucking "yipee"'d what the hell
I was always confused by the updated broken doors cause i was like "how do i get in and out of the office?"
It says a lot when a creator takes a creation from someone else and just take their renders, thinking they can do so. Even when that person’s creation wasn’t ready to be published.
Bro just found ur chanel and alr love it big w
9:18 TOADBUP PLAYS DOKKAN BATTLE?! ABSOLUTELY BASED! Love that game to death
It's absolutely wild to me that I have barely watched anything in regards to FNAF but suddenly I'm being pelted with videos about Return to Freddy's. I am somehow thoroughly invested in learning about this goofy stuff and I've only ever seen Security Breach.
can we get a ham sandwich video
Holy Molly I just watched he movie today from reccomendation
So if there's no AI and everything is scripted, what does changing the numbers for custom night do? Are there 20 scripts per animatronic or is it a placebo that doesn't affect anything?
2:51 lmfaoooo I was not at all prepared for the combination of the genuinely flabbergasted delivery of disturbing news/the cat/the sound effect😂😂😂☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️
“Bout to drop a sick TH-cam short, gonna fake forever sleep to get some hype on it”
Dokkan is Peak 9:19
Legends better frfr i have both
@ToiletBonnie. dragon ball mobile games are peak (I also have both)
7:11 I knew damn well you like dragonball when i heard that soundtrack you used bruh lmao
Fan made games is soo crazy and weird, and gotta say garten of banban gets their seat FAST AS HECK. Love your vids
8:57 Erm actually this was the bit of 83🤓
Withered Bonnie after you give them their face back: "Thank."
amazing video toadbup! i loved the part with the ghjahskkavaknakbjkh
At least fnaf doesn’t have the low poly remote
yes new toadbup video love this stuff
8:56 burnnnnnnnnn hahahah😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
1:13 I like how he has kitty faz cat from the return to freddy's as his pc wallpaper in his background monitors
Outro music's a bop i'de vibe to it for about an hour and think it was 5 minutes lol
The games included the game creator and his ex girlfriend at the time as animatronics, even lore about what happened to the ex girlfriend animatronic after they broke up. It was wild, and the game creator made like 4 different animatronics of himself in the games. Even mentioning super cancer and how I think one of the characters become an animatronic to prevent his death?
(Take it with a grain of salt since it has been a bit)
Ngl i thought the title said “making an illegal Fnaf game”
People born in 2004 are now 20 and it like, I still can't wrap my head around it.
You should review the sequels. Btw, Bonnie is a girl in TRTF.
9:15
im literally playing dokkan watching this 😭
tyler sound like if phone guy was drunk
The part where they all do the freddy light thingy reminds me of the last scene of the Monitor Series, episode 3
well now I gotta know what Dokkan event you were playing
Btw, this became a full on series of insane games
The phone guy sounds like my grandpa trying to ask me how my day went
3:05
Its mario the music box. He mentioned he's working on a full video for it,
I remember ragging on these games way back in the day, thank you for bringing back some nostalgia
This fan game was actually my introduction to cory! So in a way, I have to thank this fan game for introducing me to one of my favorite youtubers
I think the incest thing in Tyler’s apology was due to the fact that he claimed his Ex Girlfriend (who he based Kitty Fazcat on) was his sister. I have no evidence to say if it’s true or not because I only heard about this in another video and the person in that video didn’t go further from just stating it
Actually, so many people knocked FNAF for being released super fast. It might be hard to remember, but FNAF was not the beloved franchise that we know and love today, but people were annoyed and tired of how frequently it was releasing and felt it didn't innovate very well for it to be releasing so fast. That being said, the reason it's easy to forget is that the art style and presentation of the games are rather pretty good for its time. Ban Ban looks like a bunch of shapes thrown in with unreal engine assets. FNAF honestly still looks good, at least when it comes to the actual renders of the characters and settings.
Dokkan battle mentioned = immediate sub
9:20 Loved the Dokkan Battle reference (that game has destroyed my soul)
It's been bothering me since I began watching you but you sound exactly like prolific kirby fan; Antdude, its scarily similar and I don't think i'd be able to catch on if you two swapped voice overs on footage
Well there is one big difference in fnaf releasing 4 games in a year and banban releasing 5 in a year is that fnaf was a 2d game that can be created much faster than a 3d game (also Scott didn’t just take stuff from the unreal asset store)
Dude the Coryxkenshin videos on it were my introduction to Cory, I had no idea all this other stuff happened holy shit
toadbup got a fresh cut 🔥 🔥
Aww man i thought it was gonna be a lbp one but its okay also could you make a little big planet horrors levels video?
the reason people dont like garten of banban is because its a lazy cash grab meant to attract kids and be as profitable as possible. people didn't mind fnaf releasing so quickly back then because of the amount of hype surrounding it and how good quality the games were despite the development time.
4:50 to be fair, OG golden Freddy was a recolour of Freddy’s model
Tgc gonna be happy that you love their gamersupps flavour lol
The return to Freddy's is one of the community's most controversial fangames.
Not only it was used as "Fnaf continuation" jokes, it had many controversial things overall and many more things, there was even a strip club edition of it.
who the heck is garbymash?
I remember I was 7 when the first fnaf games came out. And I thought the Fan FNAF 3 trailer was official, but I definitely thought some of the textures were weird. As well as the function and mechanics.
The creator joked that his girlfriend was his sister and now we dont know if he was lying or not
I was crying until I saw this video thank you toadbup!
Imagine an endoskeleton just doing the Macarena at Domino’s💀💀💀
The best return to freddys lore is supercancer being a thing
While K was active back then unfortunately I could never play the games bc I had no computer so I could not know how the fnaf fan game scene was back then. I only watched playthroughs, the smike type of channels, and of course game theory.
“Gordan doesn’t need to hear all this he is a highly trained professional”
9:20 watching this while playing dokkan 😭
On the puppet camera you can tell the cast poster was put there through photoshop, it looks like it was just sloppily put there and that among other things are killing me haha
This fan game was unnironacly one of the first fan games i heard about (and i was like.... 7 maybe)
I love how every time he says "the office" it shows an image of Michael Scott, lol.