WINNER - Empty / Missing You [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2014
- WINNER (위너) - Empty (공허해) / Missing You (그리워해요)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe KBS World Official TH-cam : / kbsworld
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
KBS World is a TV channel for international audiences provided by KBS, the flagship public service broadcaster in Korea. Enjoy Korea's latest and most popular K-Drama, K-Pop, K-Entertainment & K-Documentary with multilingual subtitles, by subscribing KBS World official TH-cam.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
대한민국 대표 해외채널 KBS World를 유튜브에서 만나세요. KBS World는 전세계 시청자에게 재미있고 유익한 한류 콘텐츠를 영어 자막과 함께 제공하는 No.1 한류 채널입니다. KBS World 유튜브 채널을 구독하고 최신 드라마, K-Pop, 예능, 다큐멘터리 정보를 받아보세요.
------------------------------------------------
[Visit KBS World Official Pages]
Homepage: www.kbsworld.co.kr
Twitter: / kbsworldtv
Facebook: / kbsworld
Google+: plus.google.com/+kbsworldtv
KakaoTalk: @kbs_world (plus.kakao.com/friend/@kbs_world) - บันเทิง
![INFINITE - Back / Paradise / Be Mine / Bad [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Rf0pRjhbWzY/mqdefault.jpg)
![INFINITE - Back / Paradise / Be Mine / Bad [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](/img/tr.png)
![[Weekly Idol] 빅뱅 랜덤플레이 댄스 풀버전!! l EP.284 (EN/JP/CN)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/e3CgTkAd4sw/mqdefault.jpg)
Seriously BEST rookie of 2014.
I agree
That's why they deserve to win the MAMA 2014 BEST NEW ARTIST :) So help us to vote them :)
Sometimes I miss namtae with winner but I know they are all okay now... I just wish them all more happiness and success in life.
I love this early era of Winner, but the 4 members is just as good. I love Winner because they are such talented artists.
@@btwidk5945 This is why I'm an IC and I love all Park Inseos so much, we loved Nammie but he left and thanks to that scar, WINNER got even better and stronger, their last album (before Jinu and Hoony left to do their military service :'c haha, it hurts me so much) has the songs of their album debut now just with the 4 of them (as we've heard since many years ago in concerts and events). I'm just sharing if people haven't listened to them or are feeling as emo as I am RN because we don't have a full WINNER anymore.
I really hope Yoon will do his solo debut soon and Mino a comeback, I'm getting sad since they're not together anymore (do I have to say they're the only boy group I fully stan and I'm part of his fandom?). Being with them since their WIN era brings lots of emotions tbh...
Still missing him now :)
Before, idk if winner have 5 member
@@maslakhatulummah9538 yes :) winner is originally five and that was the maknae who left :( hey!!! He has a band and he is the leader and Vocalist. You might wanna check them out too if you have time and if they're your taste :) It's south club. Their latest release is rockstar. Thank you!!
Seriously idols must perform like this in live performances. Full of confidence and not overly concious.
It's YG thing.
you know sketchbook has post live editing right? thats why idols perform like this, their mistakes get edited afterwards
@@rhaennys7707sketchbook has the reputation of having their guests singing live. The audience there is aware of that. If an artist messes up, it would be a big news. There's no other explanation for this. Winner is just an excellent band.
@@woojinbloo44 yes they sing live, but only for those in the audience. Like I said, sketchbook has post live editing when it airs on tv.
Taehyun's voice just fit perfectly in Winner, I'm still missing him even now 😭😭
Senna I don't miss him, but I miss him with W 💔
Hi senna, can u tell me why he's out?
Same😭
Senna why did he leave?
Go listen to South Club, Taehyun's band. Taehyun needs everyone's support now as he's having hard time mentally!
You know the group is really damn talented when even the rappers can sing.
♪（ｖ＾＿＾）ｖ thanks for saying that. Hoony can sing. even though it's just 1 line, but his voice is sweet too.
Ban-ak Bannakan Hoony sings a lot now in their albums and concerts..he's really come a long way from K-pop star
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
This comment made my Day
Sub -Zer0 glad to hear it
Something I like about YG is that they dont let their artist to lipsync. Good job Winner.
Ikr. And btw, they don't allow any idols/artists to lipsync in Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook.
+jna hillarious 😂😂😂😂
+Pinoy Spoiler because se7n has say if artist in YG cant do lipsync or they will be die in his arms --
n all artist in YG scared with se7en,,, GD scared with se7n more than yang sajangnim --
+Indah Permatasari. But se7en is no longer in YG.
YG Lover but hes still in YGfams,,, and his word always use in YG... exp his word about lipsing....
I regret not having to stan this group fully when Taehyun was with them.
Same, i regret it so much.
I stan them from they debut and Taehyun use to be my bias
i fully stanned them when they had taehyun but somehow my feelings for them kinda dissapeared after hes not in winner anymore. oddly my bias was not taehyun. winner didn't felt like winner anymore after he left. it was like a new group. his leave was too impactful.
Its sad that some inseos left the fandom 'cuz of NamTae left the group 😢
for me, i tried to stay in the fandom but somehow it was hard :(
2022 and still the best cover of "Missing You"
How I wish to hear WINNER harmonize like this again 🥹
6:44
oh mi god!
A group with members that can all sing.
oh Lord, thank you, thank you, thank you!
+Sophia Bejarasco I KNOW RIGHT!! :DDDD
+rubiki an I love them soo much!
Who's your bias? Mines Taehyun.
+Sophia Bejarasco OMG ;_; i dunno all of them are awesome (about vocal/rap/dance skills) i honestly think all of them are on point, but i think jinwoo is my soft spot hahah like ugh my baby no one touch him! must be protected at all costs! hahah but like taehyun dude, taehyun and his f* harmonies and beautiful voice, then seungyoon with his powerful voice, god damn!, f* seunghoon with his particular raspy-softy voice? i don't even know how to describe it and his lyrics, i like his lyrics!!, also mino, mino is the master! hahah his lyrics, his singing voice! his rapsss ugh, and jinwoo there's something about jinwoo's voice like magical misterious ugh i don't know i just love them too much, i LOVE how all their voices BLEND so well together, like if they were handpicked by god to make beautiful harmonies ;_______; and to give me joy, plus they're hella handsome/cute, they write their music and play guitar ;_; those are suchhh bonuses !!! idk dude i just love winner so muuuhuhuhuchhh
+rubiki an Agree sis. It's just soo hard picking a bias, I just love them all equally. 😊
WHO COMES BACK HERE AGAIN & AGAIN? :)
I watch it everyday because i miss #WINNER so much. #WINNER please comeback!
I~ ♥This is my favorite performance in the whole kpop~
oh! I do! I love their group's unique and befittingly harmony with each other. Whoever puts them up together is such a genius.
+Bored Af me me me!! ahahaha
+Bored Af ME
They’re a 1 month rookie group here...
They're not looking like a rookie at all, perfectly doing adlib, and successfully covering famous song like its their own. Only them do that.
I watch this performance every day before I got to sleep.
I love these guys so much...
i love your profile picture suppose you are army?
+Arabel Rosario Yes haha I'm both, Army and inner circle
+Britta imnida me too Incle and Army, they're the best talents, handsome and dorks the perfect combination!
+Arabel Rosario that's so true :D both of them are able to make me laugh and cry
I thought I was the only one watching this before sleeping heheeee
a group where singers can sing and rappers can rap. and mind the moment all of them harmonize together 6:59
Unique, new, and emotional, cute dance choreography as well.
Itis Nabila & no to forget Lee SeungHoon was the one who came up with that cute choreograph.. he's really a genius choreographer since kpop star 1 and Who Is Next WIN.. & because of that, he's my BIAS...
thanks for this comment...indeed they are all around artist....
And for addition, the singers also can rap and the rappers also can sing. This is fact. Hahaha
mai 95 not all the singers, just taehyun and he isn't even good, lol.
Came back here upon hearing Treasure's upcoming guesting. Winner's hoobaes. Let's all hype it up!!
aaaa same with mee!!!✨
Same
❤❤❤❤❤❤
They were rookies in here, but looked like been years in music industry. Da*n talented!
I have to say that this was the first Winner performance I ever saw and I left thinking "wow, this guys are amazing, the feeling and vocals, they complement so well, no wonder why they won that show". I was really impressed, and a year later I watched WIN for the first time and in the first few episodes I couldn't believe that they were the same group of this performance. Even now it's really hard for me to crompehend how those five guys that couldn't even hold a note without fear nor look to anyone's eyes and were always behind the other group are this exact five guys. Now I don't only respect Winner for their talent but also for the unbelievable improvement they had in such a little time, it's seriously extraordinary and they prove me how far you can go if you don't give up and start believing in yourself, cuz this right here, they always had it and I can't wait to see how much of an amazing band they'll be in the future. Winner, fighting! ♥
🙏🙏🙏
waow what a kind and sweet way of describing them and of course I totaly agree with you. you're a jjang IC
your comment made me teary eyed.. i miss seeing them perform on tv..😭😭😭
My fave youtube comment ever. Bless your soul for wording your thought beautifully 👏
omg... it's like my story too, this is the first winner's performing that i watch and Kim Jin Woo caught my attention.
Their version of 'Missing You' was beyond perfection. I'm kind of sad it didn't get more attention. Like it really did showcase how amazing of a group they are. They have the ability of making any song they cover their's. Even back from their WIN days. And this especially highlights each one of their skills and voices. One of they few idol groups that CAN harmonize and aren't afraid to do it. And just like usual YG-style they use minimal to absolutely no MR in their performances. Beautiful.
+Elle Gee I was very disappointed when their MR removed for missing you has been deleted by KBS.. it had a lot of viewer and got a lot of praise
shenas mudjiono Well, KBS was never really fond of seeing YG prosper so much without them. Even then, WINNER's Empty and Missing You performances are both considered some of the best on Sketchbook.
@@gomie_9729 are you referring to their video performance in ice place? No wonder I can't found it
Namtae and Yoon has such different voice but they really completed each other tone beautifully
Watching this now because I'm sad and upset that their song "Really really" song wasn't even nominated in award shows when we all know they deserve to be nominated and win. 😢
yeah (T_T)
Its like popularty vs quality, and so sad they are not win
@@salsabillalla8893 The Song was good both Popularity wise and Quality wise.
yeah and the song was popular ofcourse how come they are so underrated
@@salsabillalla8893 exactly 😭
I feel empty coz i'm missing WINNER 😭😭😭
+Elle Moon i see what you did there :p
BTW i miss them too !!
+Elle Moon But now they've already come back!!! woohhh
what happen to them? I'm new that's y lol
+NerdySprinkle They were on a long break after their debut but they're back now with new album
You can see their new songs in their channel ^^
THEY ARE SO TALENTED
I like their cover of "Missing you" more than original
don't kill me
me too 😂
Bang!Bang!Bang!
+raluca radeanu (blackjack) lol
SAME. it is better to be quite honest. o_o i love 2e1 to the death but come on they OWNED the song !
yeah this sounds way better i reckon
I think WINNER is the best when it comes to covering a song of a YG artists ..like this one and Haru Haru of BB ..They made it like their own song ..
i agree
true.. even their own songs are very hard to cover and other idols barely cover them and own it bcs their voices are so distinct.
I'm hoping WINNER will cover more upbeat or hiphop BIGBANG songs because I know they will deliver.
And recent Still Life give me goosebumps.
when they started harmonizing during the end part of missing you it was like opening the gates to heaven and hearing angels sing oh my god
Legit.
ACCURATE ASF
jinwoo looks like an english prince i'm dying
+Baekyeol Park ifkr
winner is so underrated
it kills me
Me. All day long.
for a rookie group that won most popular group on mtv asia2016 and won on style icon asia2016, i don't think so. most likely underpromoted or achievements never mediaplayed
yes they are underrated and whats worse is nam taehyun is out :(
+Renzmico Capua They used to be not underrated but after that 2 years hiatus? That's when things went downhill for them. They are underpromoted and underrated both internationally and in sk. Let's not deny that c:
but now there are not,look how successful Really Really,the most streaming song in 2017
I always come back to this performance, like I'd never get tired of this, especially their rendition of Missing You. But every single time, the harmonization around 6:45 still fvcks me up, I will always find myself crying over it. Just when are we gonna hear those harmonizations ever again? FVCK 😭😭😭😭💔
i know your feels! I'm lay in my bed while crying because this is so beautiful…. i love them so much
Aaaa me too😭😞
Go listen to South Club, Taehyun's band. Taehyun needs everyone's support now as he's having hard time mentally!
OMG SAME I ALSO GOT EMOTIONAL ON THE SAME PART
If my rookie group ain't singing like this, I DON'T WANT THEM. Sorry 🤷♀️🤷♀️
Proud inseo/sinner circle here 😂😂
4:56 look at that smile. That's the face of an artist immersed in the beauty of music
Proud Leader ^__^
+YGfamily4ever i noticed that too!!!
likelikelike ur comment :")
+YGfamily4ever Wow, thank you so much for pointing that out! Beautiful~
+YGfamily4ever true....Winner forever..^^
Last time i watched because i miss Winner,now i watch because i miss 2ne1 :')
ify
I miss hanbin 😢
Virtual huug!!!! 💞
waaahhh! this is exactly how I feel
Me too 😭
Kang Seung Yoon here is already a very very talented singer. But daaaaamn, have you heard him sing in 2020? Improvement goes over the roof ❤
Yes that's our leadernim
King
Uri KING Seungyoon!!!!
He's finally releasing his well-deserved full album. Pls support him
To me, Winner was the best in 2014.
Sometimes i feel sad because YG didn't invest in the talented boys.
I want the boys keep the style like this.
To be fair, they were immensely popular in SK even to this day. They didn't need heavy investment/promotion. They were that famous.
I'M CRYING 😭😭😭 NAM TAEHYUN.....
me too :((
and if you realize that taehyun part in empty said Now we are just a memory
I was happy, don’t forget me
Zahra Putri Andhita yes you're right...now that part become real :'(
Zahra Putri Andhita i was thinking the same😢 I miss him so much already😢 like I hope that I wake up someday and yg announces that taehyun is joining winner again..😢😢😭
"Let's meet again" ..... That's too much to handle
i miss him too. it's so sad, i can't stop crying when i heard about him.
for the nth time, I'm here again, watching this perfection.. I miss winner so much! please comeback soooon~
3 years later.. still here. I love Winner so much.
Len Tan me too
Len Tan and it's already 2014 and I'm still here
5 years...
2022
i'm just saying this again that both OT5 WINNER and OT4 WINNER hold the a different type yet similar amount of power. No side is better or worse than the other.
I just regret the fact I never hear WOT5 in person.
Life lessons can be learned through Winner's songs :D
"Love is just a word..."
That was deep
it's 2ne1 song, but winner cover is really good
ThePolidash
I just realized that it was 2NE1'S song :D I mean the cover was so amazing.. I couldn't even tell...
ThePolidash They made the rap parts themselves, the original version doesn't have them.
The K-POP NERD Fatema Kamal winner changed some of the lyric~
Okay I know you came back here bc you miss OT5
*SAME* **cries in the corner**
:( im in 2019 :(
Fvk still here 2020 i still miss our maknae with his hyungs
Yes
🥺🥺🥺
2021
Empty Will always remain as one of the best debut song in KPop history
Who's here in 2019?? 🙋🏻♀️🙋🏻♀️🙋🏻♀️
🙌❤🔥
2020
Hello from 2020 😂
I just can't get bored of this performance. Their Missing You cover is their most amazing cover - it made me tear and because I don't usually get goosebumps or tears that's what I call a performance. I love them no matter what others may say they are super talented in every ways - not to mention they are rookies like whaat? Jinwoo is like gooosh he improved so much and the way he looks is just woww I can almost touch his feelings.
The part where they all sing in diff tones is just beyond perfection. Their road to becoming WINNER was full of unfortunate events and fails but in the end I think it was all worth it. They have lots of supporters and have the talent and sense to make it big. WINNER hwaiting~~ Incles love you so much ^___^
thats why they are called WINNER
Weeks have passed. And i still cant get over their version of this sonngg. So peeerrfffff!!
This is my favourite version of this song!!
you know wat it's been 6 months and we just celebrated 200 days ytd, and im still not over S/S ㅠ_ㅠ (and here i am...again)
A year has passed and I still can't get over winner and their voices and their beauty
Their live performance is no joke. Every members have their own colours of voices. Love it so much! I will keep on supporting WINNER and SOUTH CLUB!
This will always be one of my favorite performances of Winner.
The harmony and choreography is on point!
This is the only group that all of them are the main vocalist.
What people don't realize is that all 5 harmonized so well in a live event. That is talent.
i know even the rapper line! they are all so talented!
Their rendition of 2ne1 - Missing You was so good. They truly give justice to the song. I always believe that only YG artists themselves can sing their own produce song.
4:57 Thats a genuine smile from a guy who truly loves music :')
Namtae and SeungYoon harmonization still kills me. Now that Namtae is leaving...
do you know why namtae leaveing the group?
can you tell me the reason why?
deldeldel well I'm not sure what is the exact reason for that. In some reports says that it is due to Taehyun's health condition which probably makes it hard for him and Winner to promote. Also he expressed his desire to sing in his previous instagram post (but unfortunately he deleted it) so who knows if it might be due to YG hidden agenda as well. Cheers.
Their vocals are so amazing and the harmonies in Missing You wow they are so beautiful they always leave me speechless. Also can I just say NamTae's voice just sucks me in... it is like it puts me in a trance so smooth and soothing
Super high class model and having idol at kpop as part time
"That we had each other back then" the last line of nam taehyun tho
They are harmonizing so perfectly and yet you can clearly hear their separate voices distinctively.
The 52 people that disliked this video obviously don't know what real talent is.
These boys are so heavily talented I'm dumbfounded.
blackjack here and Missing You was like a new song...Winner made it their own and it was so touching. To hear each of them sing alone and together was precious. These young men continue to soar in 2017 and I am so proud of them. The raps where so emotional as if this song spoke of them. Thank you Yu Huiyeols sketchbook, KBS and most of all WINNER's Yoon, Mino, Jinu, Hoony and Taehyun(gone but not forgotten)Fighting!
I know many people miss the OT5, Taehyun was my bias in Winner back then but now I'm seeing all of them being success on their own way.. Since Taehyun's departure, the role in Winner became more balanced,, each of them got their own role in the group and they're shining because of it.. And not to mention how Taehyun is also successful by exploring his own music just the way he want in his band.. This cover is so beautiful that this will be always in my heart and make me came here every now and then...
And also love this dandy look on Seunghoon,, just perfect
Winner jjang 💙💙💙💙
💙💙💙💙💙
I swear, WINNER is so underrated. The more I get to know them, the more I fall in love. At first, I just wanted to know their names because I've seen them first on a BIGBANG x WINNER video. I thought they're cute and adorable but I didn't know who's who, so I searched. Then, I've become a fan instantly because they are not just "pretty faces", they're immensely talented as well. :) Daebak! .xx
+Lemon Soju they arent underrated.... they are hella popular...in korea as well as internationally.... their achievement during DEBUT is no joke... they are 2014 monster rookie. they are fastest group in kpop history to win in music shows after 6 days of debut.. and the only kpop group with highest itunes charting record. just check their achivement in wiki.
+Lemon Soju their leader KANG SEUNG YOON got rookie of the year award in 2010 even before debuting in WINNER YG. and LEE SEUNG HOON was under top 5 in kpop star 2011. but these amazing boys were being kept in YG dungeon for 1 yr and 5 month (long hiatus after debut).....it afffected them alot since they are just rookies.... anyways we are hoping to gain new fans plus lost fans this comeback "EXIT"........XIT is yet to come....................
and here i am wondering about how their performances because i knew (curious about) them from bandal chingu :') and search for them. and now empty, sentimental cannot not be played on my phone. i fall in love instantly and yeah they are so underrated 😭 they are so kind omg, and have faces and talents God!
SAME! HIGH FIVE.
dont forget to listen to "Dont Flirt" :)
WINNER is literally so classy. I'm glad they don't let Big Bang overshadow their concept or their music style. I know it must have been hard to make music that sounds as good as Big Bang's without sounding alike or dressing alike. YG doesn't pick the wrong people to continue their legacy. I'm really glad that YG has WINNER in their company.
Hoony's rap killing me
Mino's rap killing me
Jinwoo's voice killing me
Teahuyn's voice killing me
Yoon's voice killing me
namtae is always my bias in Winner, however im still supporting Winner til now even w/0 namtae..
i'm exo-L.. but i really love winner-empty.. best song ever!!!!
me too :) ... but i like both
Yeeeeaahhh me tooo. B.I, Bobby and winner made that song...
Im an EXO L too and Inner Circle at the same time :) let's love all fandoms. No to bashing and hating
I'm exo l as well! But I really love empty
Miss Eve Welcome.. welcome.. :))
" ..please be happy
until the end of time, let's remember
that we had each other back then. "
Nam Tae Hyun :( & also..... 2NE1 :(
im cryingggg T_T those lyrics!!!!
Winner is so tall
CAN'T BELIEVE THIS IS ALMOST 7 YEARS AGO
*"What we had now is only a memory. I was happy. Don't forget me. Let's meet again"*
*"Until the end of time, let's remember that we had each other back then"*
I keep replaying this video today because of 2ne1 and Taehyun 💔😭
Taehyun's voice was such a beautiful match with everyone in Winner too :(
Only Winner and their performances can bring tears to my eyes, good and happy tears :') they are all pure artists, so talented, so hard working~~ I really wish i could meet them someday, and i kind of don't want them to change their image, i really love this solemn pop music rather then the upbeat 'in your face' kind of feel~ but oh well, change is inevitable, Good luck Winner in all your future endeavors!
The harmonization here stays iconic after years. I miss OT5.
Nam was my bias and when he left I lost interest in Winner. But now I came back and I really love all of them , not only one bias this time I have four 😊
Mandy VIP Do you still support Nammie? It's sad if you don't anymore, but I respect your decision, IC 💙
Actually it did not affect me when taehyun left, because mino is my bias but i still want them complete because winner will always be ot5, but ot4 left are the best for me now because they stayed together and fight back again🥰
"Please be happy. Until the end of time, let's remember that we had each other back then" :(
😥
Seungyoon's eyes are so beautiful. So special. You can see the passion in his eyes. Love you, Leader Yoon.
Datcu Florentina i found him really attractive everytime 😍😍😍
My comment is so late but if u noticed in 4:56 he smiled..that smiled like a proud brother 😢😚😚
Our yoon is so precious!!
jinu is sssoooooo handsome in here
Who's here in 2020 😭😭😭
Winner is the only group I know that can look expensive, swag and sexy at the same time. Seriously I never saw any group that seems like who came out from the Gentleman Magazine.
uniqe and the only one..
They will make history like bigbang did.
I'm glad they are not "Bigbang 2.0" in YG
but they will be "Winner 1.0"
YES! I am so glad that YG saw what's unique in WINNER and trusted them to show their own colors. I honestly think that he likes Winner.
I agree, they bring new style to yg. btw, Cant wait for winner next album
In my opinion they were hit when they debut then they been in break for 1 and half year before they release exit album.that time they were’nt as big as they should be if yg continue to promote them but then yg debut ikon and ikon made their impact well and winner was almost left behind and neglected. Then blankpink 2016 they debut as well. And they focus on foreign audience and supporters that they ddnt even did to winner.. winner almost disband bcoz of taehyun departure. But good thing they build themselves again after really really comeback album..lets just be happy to whichever path they chose. Taehyun and winner is happy now and i hope they receive more acknowledgement more than what they receiving right now.. they deserve it. They work hard for it winner ot5 or winner ot4 lets support them.more than we should...
I keep repeating 06:44 feels like i am serenaded by angels 👼 omo i miss nam taehyun’s voice harmonizing with the other members. Anyway, Winner is amazing as always. I wish they’ll get the number of views they deserved.
kang seungyoon has one of the best (most versatile) voices in the industry.... I am so mad he is so underrated.
hoon and yoon were both famous before joining yg, now they are rarely seen and are forgotten easily.. yg has not only stopped winner from growing but killed whatever popularity hoon and yoon had.
I....I... yeah thats right. :'( our babies deserve more, the ammount of raw talent and artistry they have... yg fucking owes them.
sau p today is their comeback !!!😘😘😘
But people and fans treat them now equally..
Stop blaming yg for everything!!!. They are doing fine now
la lala i think so too 🤔
Yg has the best live singers
Not blackpink
Thank you to all Winner Parents to brought such handsome sons and talented to this world🙏
wait they were rookies that time?? wow treasure really follow their seniors footstep
They were a month old rookie group 💙
Just look at how Kim Jinwoo has grown so much now..
OH MY GOD. THESE BOYS ARE ANGELS. I've never heard ANYONE sing Bom's verse and not sound horrid!
They'reperfect 😭😭 I can't deal with how perfect they are OMG.
6:44 i always come back to this
After watching winner performing this without taehyun (gda 2018) made me want to jump to this video immediately i miss taehyun singing with winner 😭
what a shame, my two ultimate groups in yg. i don't even know why i torture myself and keep watching this. i feel so sad and dumb because i'm crying over people who doesn't even know about my existence.
lee seunghoney same, same
lee seunghoney ikr, ive never cried because of any celebrities before. taehyun's departure & 2ne1's disbandment hurt me a lot 💔
I feel you. My two ultimate groups in all of Kpop actually. 😭 😭 😭 💔💔💔
damn ify
IS THIS FUCKING LIVE?! THEY ARE FLAWLESS
yes live.. everyone who performing on YHY's stage should sing live
Winner, I'm always missing you!
That last part by Namtae, it's so heartwarming.
It is 2020 and I am here again, hurting myself. 🙃
This was beautiful. They don't seem like rookies at all. It feels like they debuted years ago. ♡
I wonder if audiences were even breathing , I can't breath here . their harmony is killer
Back then when Win-who is next survival..these boys divided into two Team A now become winner and Team B now become ikon..these two groups are very talented YG highlighted that team A has a lot of potentials when it comes of composing songs..three of them yoon,mino including nam..their forte is ballad songs..team B is more on hiphop w/c theyre also competitive too with amazing leader b.i that was highlighted also by YG himself.. i love them both...ive seen every struggles, hardships and conflicts..yet theyre all debuted as winner and ikon...im happy..then
i'm so in love with nam tae voice in this song (missing you) 😢😢😢
miss you nam tae 😢
wow their voices blend together seamlessly
the color of their voices match so perfectly... it's like a gift from god the harmonies they do ;__;
That moment when i realize nam taehyun has better eye makeup than i do... Winner fighting!!
This along with baby baby are one of the best performances i've seen on sketchbook! Winner is def one of the best idol groups out there😭
Nam Taehyun's voice hit different level of nostalgia
6:43 still gets to me every time
same 💕
For me it's the adlibs @ 6:29 - 6:43 ♥
That's when the tears came
♥♥♥
yeah...it makes me miss 2ne1 more..and also taehyun...
Rewatching this over and over again because I will surely miss Taehyun's voice with the rest of them.
Winner is definitely one of the best boy groups that has a very good vocal combination.
*lemme cry for a while
BRIBRI'S B agree much. Their harmonization is just WOW!!!!!!!!!!
I used to melt listening to Taehyun’s voice :( miss him in the group
it's 2021 and I still keep coming back here