Funny how they treated and threatened Geralt as if they could do harm to him. This dude killed the king of wild hunt, banished an evil incarnation and defeated a higher vampire who's worth a 100 army.
He’s a lot stronger in the games than the book, he’s just a human with increased senses and physicality with great training. Sure he’s incredibly strong but it’s unlikely he’ll be able to stop the duchys entire army
Now imagine if you can chronologically start Blood and Wine before the Battle of Kaer Morhen, then Regis and Detlaff repay Geralt by joining the defense.... I'd happily pay another sixty bucks for that. Just.to.see.vesemir's alive....
William Antonio I wouldn’t, they wouldve shoved imlirith’s spoon up eridin’s ass and sliced through kaer morhen the vanished into smoke to unleash a swarm of vampires. The game would be done then and there......
@@haniabuhijleh1634 yah but who doesnt wanna see that cutscene....how about If Geralt is like, "you know what I hate portals...ciri lets take Detlaff and Regis to Aen Elle and make them hate portals too..."
I didnt let him live. when he unleashed the vampire horde on the city it was no longer just the personal grudge he held. 4 lives i could overlook due to the situation at hand. however when he placed his hand on the innocents that did nothing to him, allowed children to be slaughtered he no longer was in the zone of being relatable to me. he was a monster that had to be put down for good. Regis was slightly against it but by the end he realizes that when he unleashed that horde it forced geralts hand. i wanted to help him and side with him but he went way to far.
Obsidian Frost he was an alright guy before... syanna exposed him to emotions he didn’t know of before like love and the feeling of being lied to (Regis talks ab that at the beginning.) after being deceived like that which also caused the death of his friend so that he cut off his own hand, he went into a fury and confusion. He wasn’t a monster before, just a man in love. Syanna turned him into one.
@@antoniorodriguez162 I have the same toughts about Detlaff. Also, when you decide to kill Detlaff, the one person who has to suffer the most is Regis. He has to kill his friend, his blood-brother, and will be anathema for that. He has to suffer the most although he has no guilt in what happend to the knights or the town. He just wanted to help a friend. So I decided not to kill Detlaff, I thought Regis deserved some kind of happy ending.
Lairely so fuck everyone else. Regis needed to go threw this lesson. We all do. Sometimes our closest s friends are truly not the people we once knew. As in this case.
Taz O you know children were killed as well? A whole orphanage of them in detracts attack. Multiple innocent ppl killed for what? And your not gunna kill him because you don’t wanna hurt regis’s feelings?
I went with this ending, and spared dettlaff, it had nothing to do with syanna being the real villian, and it had nothing to do with dettlaff being manipulated. Regis did right by geralt in the past, and "died" for it. If he wanted dettlaff to live, then that's what I was going to do for him. Geralt owes him, and he seems like a genuine friend to geralt, so screw the consequences.
I'm not sure I agree with that, Dettlaff being used is no excuse to kill so frivolously and both are partly victims of circumstance. Whether you side with Dettlaff or Syanna is a matter of taste and both are bittersweet endings.
TrollHippo Exactly! So it's not just me then? In the "Happy Ending" version very much feels like something is just...missing. This feels a much more personal ending and... I don't know, better suited for a witcher.
Because Syanna is the cause of everything, and in the happy ending she gets away with it all compared to this one where she is basically punished for it. I honestly love this ending more, because I would rather let Detlaff live and Syanna die than have him become another victim of her own selfishness.
Snappy Zura Indeed :) But frankly I don't mind Detlaff's death. Actually on my first playthrough, I got that sad ending because I was going after Detlaff and not saving Syanna. I like Detlaff, he's such a great character. And I'm sure in the distant past he was a very honorable vampire. But I just could not let him go, no matter what "alternatives" Regis came up with. I wouldn't want to hear him out. Because no matter what is in the background, the fact is that he killed so many people. It was one thing to be blackmailed, but another to attack a town and murdering people out of gelosy and rage. If a love issue causes that to Detlaff, then he was a very dangerous and unstable vampire in my eyes. Such an awesome game :) We can really find our own moral choices among the path variations
You're kind of right, though the Duchess herself is kind of a douche too, maybe more than the sister. After finding some history books you can see that she literally wrote her sister out of history, she apparently also was the real bad one who blamed everything on her sister.
While I did sympathize abit with Syanna.. I do vastly regret that Dettlaff died because I collected the ribbon. I had no idea of the huge effect something so minor would have. I mean.. you play a round of Gwent for that ribbon, thus you play a round of Gwent for an entire ending! I found it hard to decline Regis' wishes because he's just so damn likeable and presents clear, logical evidence for his ways of thinking. I could not bring myself to decline his wishes of bringing Syanna to Dettlaff. But because of that Ribbon.. this resulted in Dettlaff going mental and in turn forces Regis to kill him. Regis is already walking a fine line between acting like the kind, wise man he is and returning to the old Vampire ways. Something like him having to kill his friend, his blood brethren, might tip the scale for him later down the line. I'd allow Dettlaff to walk free in a heartbeat because I could understand his situation (though his means.. not so much). I just didn't like that Regis was forced to do the killing blow because he felt he HAD to.
It should have been Regis who got the award in the endings where you aren’t thrown in prison. Not only did he betray the honor code of his brethren by killing Dettlaff, he also killed the man who he owed his life so Geralt and Toussaint could be spared.
h o w a b o u t a r o u n d o f g w e n t But realtalk, this being the only ending that's good for Regis makes me hesitate to agree that it's a "bad" ending. It also sees Dandelion partially reconciled with the duchess, and it's the only ending in which the true beast is brought to justice without Anna Henrietta also dying. The fact that she has a sob story to explain why she did it makes no difference, every killer has a motive. The only clearly "bad" part is that Geralt serves a short prison sentence, while every other ending, bare minimum, sees Regis having to permanently go into hiding from other vampires in addition to having to continue uncomfortably hiding his true nature from humans.
@@BigLeagueChewie Regis killed Detlaff for himself, a symbolic act to mark the ending of their bond, but it was Geralt who truly defeated Detlaff and killed him, R giving the final blow.
I'm disappointed in the lack of Dandelion in Witcher 3. Feels like he always had more time in the previous games. Glad to see him make a return for B&W, just wish it was under more pleasant circumstances.
By far the best ending.Would you like regis who saved ur ass many times,to put a hand against the man who saved his life when he helped on the regeneration ?Or would you like him to be haunted for all his life by his kind that can give him a permanent death? On all sites there is 0 info about this ending...you dont break out of jail,u are let out,and u even keep ur house.Also you can inform anna about the fact that syanna wanted to kill her next.Although she wont admit,she understands what her sister did.In addition,regis is happy ,u get to see dandelion again(and also u ask him about priscilla!),and still u get the ending with triss or yen in your house.Sad maybe ,but better good,other options would either harm regis or both of the women.
***** I agree with you,detlaff did bad things though im not sure if he deserves death.The only reason i didnt go to kill him(I would cuz he irritated me when he said he would kill both me and regis) is that regis is forced to be hunted by all the other higher vampires unless he hides and remains incognito.
TrollHippo It is safe,u are granted back ur house + u are accepted in toussaint normaly,and u can even tell the truth to henrietta,though she doesnt agree,she deeply understands.It is sad only for henrietta,geralt is fine,even meets dandelion .
Detlaff sent an entire enslaught of vampires to assault a city. Syanna wanted 5 people dead who wronged her. I'm pretty sure Detlaff was in the right until he decided to assault an entire city of innocents with hundreds of lives lost cause he got pussy whipped.
I love this ending. I think this is the best ending. I was aiming to get this ending because I don't want Regis to be shun by other vampire. Sure, the queen hates Geralt, but I think it's better to have awesome immortal friends than some useless selfish ruler who wouldn't care even a bit about the truth because she was overwhelmed by emotions. I was really sad during the prisoner event, thinking that Geralt's head will be chopped off, and you can guess my shiver when Dandelion appeared there. :)) It also fits the Witcher's theme perfectly, in my opinion. The reference from the book thrown here and there. Made me shivers more. I was afraid the ownership of Corvo Bianco would be revoked. But apparently it isn't so that's great. lol Awesome DLC. All hail CDPR, such a beautiful game.
@@porkcutlet3920 Geralt did his job. He was called to find the beast and kill it. He did it, both Syanna and Dethlaf deserved it. Leaving Syanna alive was not right, because the 5 victim was her sister. Leaving Dethlaf alive is wrong too, because he's the killer and too dangerous
@@extraditori6604 This makes no sense - how many people has Geralt slain, over Ciri? How many people have died just for knowing Ciri, or she’s slain (she became a murdering bandit briefly in the books and she enjoyed it, when she was in the rats.) This is the worst ending, because she only killed people who hurt her. She never turned her back to the city when it was on fire either. Dettlaf is a nutcase. Who killed hundreds of innocents, or thousands. Just because he got rejected, he behaves like an incel.
Bittersweet ending maybe. I liked it more than when the sisters reconcile. Mostly because I felt bad for Dettlaff being used by Syanna. I understood why she wanted the knights killed but also wanting to kill her sister was a bit much.
Agreed but dont forget that we land in prison too . In both the others endings geralt is heavily rewarded . I wanted both dead so I liked the both sisters dead one
Agreed Geralt doing chores very funny . I liked this Expansion a lot . Will be waiting for cyberpunk 2077( CD Project next game). It will be same as witcher 3 I hope
good thing about the prison is it unlocks new achievement "king of the clink". so without serving the jail, you'll never get 100% achievement in witcher3. in other words, CDPR encourage to experience this ending (could be in NG+) my heart really settles with this ending too. also even after you get this "mid" ending, once you visit beuclair palace, everything is normal again, only the character entry journal is slightly bitter. but in real game no one really beef with geralt.
And IMO it was the best ending. I chose it simply following my heart and I doubt I'd ever choose differently. Dettlaff didn't deserve death, he's been hurt and used. She deserved what she got.
No, no, of course he didn't deserve it! But it's the duchess' fault, not our decision's. If I were Geralt, I'd simply ask Dettlaff to scratch me and throw me around a little bit and then leave me there, pretending I'm half dead/beaten, for the duchess to find me XD THEN she couldn't blame me for Syanna's death! Or at least not that much... She'd see I tried, but simply he was too strong for me to defeat.
Wouldn't it be? XD I was honestly surprised there wasn't, very half-baked. Imagine the duchess and her army coming, though, and Geralt starting to panic, jumping up to Dettlaff, yanking his jacket rapidly like they often do in cartoons: "QUICK! Scratch me! Throw me! DO anything! We have to make this look reliably!" while Dettlaff is all like: "Whoa whoa, dude, wth?!..." And Regis being all like: D: !!! That would be a very funny little bonus option~
I like this ending the best, preferably speaking that I like ‘tragic’ endings, however. But I treated Dettlaff as a bro, even though Geralt and him didn’t like each other. He’s been through some shit.
Hmm Ok. This one seems more tragic th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html WItcher goes to the graveyard to meet Duchess while she gets sad upon the death of syanna
Thanks for great thorough video. I wanted to get the good ending, but not okay again to do this ending. So perfect; and thanks for choosing all conversation options, made me feel I missed nothing
Bro I wanna play as Regis that would be fun as fuck, imagine being Regis during the attack on Stygga castle (lady of the lake book)? Just fucking massacring a whole castle of people
@@kristenarcher5996 Haven’t got to reading the books yet but I definitely want to, really took a liking to Dettlaff, with everything besides the city attack ofc, but playing as them would be so cool
IMO this is the best ending... Syanna dies, Regis lives peacefully, Detlaff lives on his own ways and Geralt being neutral (that is how witchers lives, right? no political BS). The only regret I have is, not having my hands full against Jacques... should find a way to do so.
I think that the ending that both sisters reconcile in the end and forgive each other despite the faults where all survive is still the best ending. and to top it off I also think for the true happy ending it has to be finishing with yennefer in the end.
So far have only done a couple play throughs. 1 where the sisters make peace...and recently where both die. No matter what ending of the story itself...the very last moments between the 2 around the fire seem to bring a perfect close to the Witcher saga.
I consider this as happy ending, thought Detlaff is guilty for attacking the city, Syana is the main Villian and beast of Bauclair to me. I simply couldn't let Regis kill Detlaff, 'cause Regis was the one who helped Geralt to save Ciri and died (in books). In addition, the way Syanna treated Detlaff was disgusting, she is really cursed. If Syanna would killed that knights on her own, well it would be sort of justified, but this! The fact that Syanna feign love, well it hurt right, but I would move on, but wanting to kill for her. That's simply too much...
CDPR didn't get anything wrong, if this is your definition of a good ending then by all means its the good ending. For some it isn't. You as the player can choose that's the point.
I sympathize with Detlaff, but when he decided to launch his attack on Beauclair...when he decided to slaughter countless innocent men, women, and children over a lover's quarrel...that's when I decided he had to die. Yes, Syanna (and the duchess, to a large extent) shares the blame, but Detlaff's actions were unforgivable.
@@lorddormammu9881 Partly the Duchess's fault, but the duchess didn't slaughter hundreds of innocent civilians. That was all Detlaff. If he'd wanted to, he could have swept in, kidnapped the duchess, and ransomed her back in exchange for Syanna. Boom, no one hurt, except for Syanna, who was responsible for the whole bloody ordeal in the first place. But nope, instead he chose to abandon his false virtues of nobility and altruism and reveal himself for the true monster he always was. In attacking the city, he showed a blatant disregard for human life, so I don't see why Geralt should treat his life any differently
Here is the Evil ending th-cam.com/video/56FngMbS3io/w-d-xo.html Here is the happy ending th-cam.com/video/Sx__ZSYzQpU/w-d-xo.html Here is the Shit on Geralt ending th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html Final ending when Geralt goes home th-cam.com/video/J9mE58DmK1k/w-d-xo.html
To me this is the best ending not the bad ending - Syanna played Dettlaff and got what she deserved. At least with this ending regis will be free to stay also not not be forced to move away due to constant vampire attacks. Best ending by far.
I’m of the opinion that Annarietta was every bit as responsible for the attack on Beauclair as Syanna was. In my playthrough, Detlaff AND the sisters die.
Thanks for this. Made my decision that this is going with my Empress Ciri and Triss romance ending. The Witcher Ciri ending, Dijkstra rules and Yen romance being with the other, non blood bath ending. :) I couldn't get a straight answer on Reddit as to the pros and cons of this ending and the other one- everyone seemed biased in one way or another. Thanks again!
Gah! Why did you keep skipping through the conversations? I wanted to see the differences so I could weigh my options. I think it's kind of defeating the purpose the developers made by labeling the endings good or bad. Much like the many choices they give you throughout the game; it isn't about which one is "good"... it's about which choice you can live with.
Curious to know what would have happened when you find out who the fifth victim was meant to be in this ending... but you skipped that dialogue option.
I dont think anything would have happened cause the Duchess already said never to show my face again :D She probably loves her sister so much that she would prefer her in prison instead of dead.
If u kill detlaff . Dandelion comes along with the duchess and you get a fresh bunch of scoldings from the duchess. It isn't worth it :D If only I could kill the duchess :(
- Don't smile too wide, or someone will see yer fangs. Anyway good to see you MY VAMPIRE FRIEND - sure no guard will hear that just several feet from the prison
Regis doest have much role in previous witcher games. He appears in many Witcher 3 blood and wine quests though Dandelion has major role in all witcher games.
What an amazing game. I saved Detlaff too because I am a vampire apologist and he's ever so dreamy. Random aside, but I find it hard to believe they'd waste the headman's axe on common criminals - they'd be sent to the gallows.
Torn between this ending and the other where detlaff diess and both sisters live so my save has been stuck in limbo all this time I really wish there was an ending where they could all live
Just finished B&W and got the 'happy ending' (phrasing). Man I would have been pissed to get this ending. A random dues ex machina Dandeleon shows up and frees Geralt? Fuck that noise.
I felt bad for Detlaff, and I couldn't stand Syanna because she acted like the world revolved around her, was selfish, childish, manipulative and most of all - She felt zero remorse for what she was doing to him, the consequences, and what she wanted to do to her sister. I'm sorry but there were characters who had worse backstories / childhoods in the game and didn't turn out to be sociopaths. I wish Detlaff could've lived as well as Syanna, oh well.
You felt bad for someone who MURDERED INNOCENT PEOPLE (men, women and children), put an entire duchy to burn, just because of a heartbreak?? I mean, syanna is no saint (she is definitely a bitch), but once detlaff started murdering innocent people, i knew what I had to do. I could forgive killing 4 people (specially because they were rapists sons of bitches), but an entire duchy? No man, no. You could even come up with the excuse that regis doesn't deserve being forced to kill his friend, but if you watch the part where detlaff kills syanna, you can see that's not what regis wanted, just hear his voice saying "what have you done?". Sometimes we need to face the hard truth that, some people are not what we thought they were.
@@luccav.432 You know he's not human but a vampire less intelligent than humans, very emotional and more dangerous than the Emperor himself, he gave a certain threat and was completely ignored, the massacre was the Duchess' fault.
bad ending my ass...Geralt rests in prison for a bit...dandy gets to repay one of the I owe you's, Regis isnt exiled from Toussiant and murdered by other vampires for breaking their laws, Detlaff respects you (Witcher 4 Geralt Yen/Triss/Yen+Triss and 2 Higher Vampires protect Ciri :P lol) and the actual beast is dead...I loved the line when Geralt asks if he she gets exactly how badly she has fucked up..and Yen is on couch outside of my house...whilst lame its a better ending than the base game :p
People dont seem to favour the 'happy' ending. But just because the sisters reconcile, doesn't mean that syanna isn't punished afterwards. She will still have to answer for her crimes. Plus everyone is far better off overall than the other endings
id prefer something like that, maybe fight the vampire too, but my pride over Gwent made made me win that ribon and go for the good ending. i wanted some punishment to go on Syanna but at this point either both sister live or they both die
I chose this ending because I couldn’t bear to cause Regis to kill Detlaff, especially after what Regis did sacrifices for Geralt in the books. I think syanna deserved to die, if detlaff was human I’d say the same but he’s not human and thinks I’m very different ways from humans so while I don’t agree with what he did, he’s not EVIL like syanna mainly was. So yeah, I faced jail and spared detlaff just for Regis lol
Unpopular Opinion, but I think this is the best ending. True, its frustrating because Geralt is just watching everything and gets yelled at afterwards, but I think Syanna is the villain that needs to die, not Dettlaff. She is evil and manipulative, responsible for four murders and a broken heart and she wanted to kill her sister. Dettlaff might be more frightening, but he has a code of honor and isn't plain evil. I don't even classify him as a monster, he is way to passionate and intelligent for that. For all these reasons I prefer to let Dettlaff have his revenge. About the contract... Syanna is the real Monster anyways.
Syanna only dies if you make the wrong decisions after that it gives m the Dickson to either talk to syanna or go to the dutchmess should I talk to syanna to get her to forgive her sister?
I don't think this ending is that bad. Syanna is a treachorous bitch who got exactly what she deserved, Detlaff was being used and deserved to be spared in my opinion, and at least this way Regis doesn't get shunned. It's a shame that the duchess doesn't realise this and doesn't send Geralt to prision, but everything else that happened is cool as far as I'm concerned.
![[Live] : ONE 169 วันนี้!! "อนาโตลี vs อูมาร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IK3YZVWuFJg/mqdefault.jpg)
Geralt sitting in prison: “Okay, Gaunter, I need your help once again.”
He appears and another whole expansion is started. Imagine that. Lol.
Gaunter o dimm what a character. Loved that dlc.
as if Geralt was that stupid
The Witcher 3: Hearts of Blood and Wine
(cue gaunter's theme)
Why didn’t he just get ciri lol
Funny how they treated and threatened Geralt as if they could do harm to him. This dude killed the king of wild hunt, banished an evil incarnation and defeated a higher vampire who's worth a 100 army.
Still dies to fall damage tho
@Apache Helicopter But he did.
He’s a lot stronger in the games than the book, he’s just a human with increased senses and physicality with great training. Sure he’s incredibly strong but it’s unlikely he’ll be able to stop the duchys entire army
@@Bro1212_ Case signs, in the books and TV show, he aint showing up sign spamming like you can do in the games + you have sign upgrades.
Witchers aren’t demigods, he’s killed by a peasant with a pitchfork in the books.
Now imagine if you can chronologically start Blood and Wine before the Battle of Kaer Morhen, then Regis and Detlaff repay Geralt by joining the defense....
I'd happily pay another sixty bucks for that.
Just.to.see.vesemir's alive....
Justin by the detail they left for hearts of stone they may have added that.
William Antonio I wouldn’t, they wouldve shoved imlirith’s spoon up eridin’s ass and sliced through kaer morhen the vanished into smoke to unleash a swarm of vampires. The game would be done then and there......
@@haniabuhijleh1634 yah but who doesnt wanna see that cutscene....how about If Geralt is like, "you know what I hate portals...ciri lets take Detlaff and Regis to Aen Elle and make them hate portals too..."
sadly no matter how many ppl you bring, they all just gonna got frozen and unable to do anything.
@@shikniwho7215 people💀💀💀💀
in my play through ciri became empress if they were to hang him tousaint may face nilfgard wrath
Yeah including that scene would have been awesome :)
@@HippoReddy particularly if Geralt and Regis got to explain exactly what Syanna did +5th victim...
@Haljordan4life ?
@Haljordan4life The only thing cringe here is your dumb comment
@Michele So you'd rather kill Thaler, Roche and Ves? Those guys came for you to Kaer Morhen, for God's sake.
I didnt let him live. when he unleashed the vampire horde on the city it was no longer just the personal grudge he held. 4 lives i could overlook due to the situation at hand. however when he placed his hand on the innocents that did nothing to him, allowed children to be slaughtered he no longer was in the zone of being relatable to me. he was a monster that had to be put down for good. Regis was slightly against it but by the end he realizes that when he unleashed that horde it forced geralts hand. i wanted to help him and side with him but he went way to far.
Obsidian Frost he was an alright guy before... syanna exposed him to emotions he didn’t know of before like love and the feeling of being lied to (Regis talks ab that at the beginning.) after being deceived like that which also caused the death of his friend so that he cut off his own hand, he went into a fury and confusion. He wasn’t a monster before, just a man in love. Syanna turned him into one.
@@antoniorodriguez162 I have the same toughts about Detlaff. Also, when you decide to kill Detlaff, the one person who has to suffer the most is Regis. He has to kill his friend, his blood-brother, and will be anathema for that. He has to suffer the most although he has no guilt in what happend to the knights or the town. He just wanted to help a friend. So I decided not to kill Detlaff, I thought Regis deserved some kind of happy ending.
Lairely so fuck everyone else. Regis needed to go threw this lesson. We all do. Sometimes our closest s friends are truly not the people we once knew. As in this case.
Yeah dont kill him cuz of regis happy ending?? He fucking kill thousanad people cuz of his fury lol
Taz O you know children were killed as well? A whole orphanage of them in detracts attack. Multiple innocent ppl killed for what? And your not gunna kill him because you don’t wanna hurt regis’s feelings?
I went with this ending, and spared dettlaff, it had nothing to do with syanna being the real villian, and it had nothing to do with dettlaff being manipulated.
Regis did right by geralt in the past, and "died" for it. If he wanted dettlaff to live, then that's what I was going to do for him. Geralt owes him, and he seems like a genuine friend to geralt, so screw the consequences.
He’s probably the bestest friend of Geralt aside from Dandelion. In the book, he’s honestly really good for Geralt.
Plot twist: this is actually the good ending
Yup, because Dettlaf was used by Syanna
Yes, everybody good lives
Yeah could not agree more.
I'm not sure I agree with that, Dettlaff being used is no excuse to kill so frivolously and both are partly victims of circumstance. Whether you side with Dettlaff or Syanna is a matter of taste and both are bittersweet endings.
@Apollox44 Pollo does that change Anna's response?
"Dandelion is rarely indespensible"
Regis being the King of shade in the most polite manner
Best ending. True evil is dead
That Soap joke tho.
Ya very funny :D
I don't know :)) Why the hell do I like this ending more then the happy one?
This is definitely an interesting ending. I was actually disappointed with the happy ending too .
TrollHippo Exactly! So it's not just me then? In the "Happy Ending" version very much feels like something is just...missing. This feels a much more personal ending and... I don't know, better suited for a witcher.
talas attila I am sure many feel the same way :D
Because Syanna is the cause of everything, and in the happy ending she gets away with it all compared to this one where she is basically punished for it. I honestly love this ending more, because I would rather let Detlaff live and Syanna die than have him become another victim of her own selfishness.
Snappy Zura Indeed :) But frankly I don't mind Detlaff's death. Actually on my first playthrough, I got that sad ending because I was going after Detlaff and not saving Syanna. I like Detlaff, he's such a great character. And I'm sure in the distant past he was a very honorable vampire. But I just could not let him go, no matter what "alternatives" Regis came up with. I wouldn't want to hear him out. Because no matter what is in the background, the fact is that he killed so many people. It was one thing to be blackmailed, but another to attack a town and murdering people out of gelosy and rage. If a love issue causes that to Detlaff, then he was a very dangerous and unstable vampire in my eyes. Such an awesome game :) We can really find our own moral choices among the path variations
I think this is the "best" ending since the true villain of the story, Syanna dies and Dettlaff who was being used was allowed to live.
Ok but the queen now hates Geralt
TrollHippo Yeah... there really isn't any outcome where everyone leaves happily.
***** Yes best dlc this year
Agree, not to mention Dandelion gets to work his magic, although Anna putting him in prison was definitely uncalled for
You're kind of right, though the Duchess herself is kind of a douche too, maybe more than the sister. After finding some history books you can see that she literally wrote her sister out of history, she apparently also was the real bad one who blamed everything on her sister.
In an alternative reality, Anna and synna die ...and geralt is enjoying the vineyards.
While I did sympathize abit with Syanna.. I do vastly regret that Dettlaff died because I collected the ribbon. I had no idea of the huge effect something so minor would have. I mean.. you play a round of Gwent for that ribbon, thus you play a round of Gwent for an entire ending! I found it hard to decline Regis' wishes because he's just so damn likeable and presents clear, logical evidence for his ways of thinking. I could not bring myself to decline his wishes of bringing Syanna to Dettlaff.
But because of that Ribbon.. this resulted in Dettlaff going mental and in turn forces Regis to kill him. Regis is already walking a fine line between acting like the kind, wise man he is and returning to the old Vampire ways. Something like him having to kill his friend, his blood brethren, might tip the scale for him later down the line. I'd allow Dettlaff to walk free in a heartbeat because I could understand his situation (though his means.. not so much). I just didn't like that Regis was forced to do the killing blow because he felt he HAD to.
Yeah regis had a lot of faith in detlaff
It should have been Regis who got the award in the endings where you aren’t thrown in prison. Not only did he betray the honor code of his brethren by killing Dettlaff, he also killed the man who he owed his life so Geralt and Toussaint could be spared.
h o w a b o u t a r o u n d o f g w e n t
But realtalk, this being the only ending that's good for Regis makes me hesitate to agree that it's a "bad" ending. It also sees Dandelion partially reconciled with the duchess, and it's the only ending in which the true beast is brought to justice without Anna Henrietta also dying. The fact that she has a sob story to explain why she did it makes no difference, every killer has a motive. The only clearly "bad" part is that Geralt serves a short prison sentence, while every other ending, bare minimum, sees Regis having to permanently go into hiding from other vampires in addition to having to continue uncomfortably hiding his true nature from humans.
@@BigLeagueChewie Regis killed Detlaff for himself, a symbolic act to mark the ending of their bond, but it was Geralt who truly defeated Detlaff and killed him, R giving the final blow.
I totally agree
I'm disappointed in the lack of Dandelion in Witcher 3. Feels like he always had more time in the previous games. Glad to see him make a return for B&W, just wish it was under more pleasant circumstances.
Hmm agreed he even sides with anna if u visit syannas grave when anna is alive
Here it is th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html
By far the best ending.Would you like regis who saved ur ass many times,to put a hand against the man who saved his life when he helped on the regeneration ?Or would you like him to be haunted for all his life by his kind that can give him a permanent death? On all sites there is 0 info about this ending...you dont break out of jail,u are let out,and u even keep ur house.Also you can inform anna about the fact that syanna wanted to kill her next.Although she wont admit,she understands what her sister did.In addition,regis is happy ,u get to see dandelion again(and also u ask him about priscilla!),and still u get the ending with triss or yen in your house.Sad maybe ,but better good,other options would either harm regis or both of the women.
Hmm good logic . I personally would have wanted Anna dead too :D
*****
I agree with you,detlaff did bad things though im not sure if he deserves death.The only reason i didnt go to kill him(I would cuz he irritated me when he said he would kill both me and regis) is that regis is forced to be hunted by all the other higher vampires unless he hides and remains incognito.
True Green . But developers probably wanted Geralt to have a happy or safe ending
TrollHippo
It is safe,u are granted back ur house + u are accepted in toussaint normaly,and u can even tell the truth to henrietta,though she doesnt agree,she deeply understands.It is sad only for henrietta,geralt is fine,even meets dandelion .
Detlaff sent an entire enslaught of vampires to assault a city. Syanna wanted 5 people dead who wronged her. I'm pretty sure Detlaff was in the right until he decided to assault an entire city of innocents with hundreds of lives lost cause he got pussy whipped.
I love this ending. I think this is the best ending.
I was aiming to get this ending because I don't want Regis to be shun by other vampire.
Sure, the queen hates Geralt, but I think it's better to have awesome immortal friends than some useless selfish ruler who wouldn't care even a bit about the truth because she was overwhelmed by emotions.
I was really sad during the prisoner event, thinking that Geralt's head will be chopped off, and you can guess my shiver when Dandelion appeared there. :))
It also fits the Witcher's theme perfectly, in my opinion.
The reference from the book thrown here and there. Made me shivers more.
I was afraid the ownership of Corvo Bianco would be revoked. But apparently it isn't so that's great. lol
Awesome DLC. All hail CDPR, such a beautiful game.
Well said . All hail CDPR :)
This has turned out to be the best game I ever played .
Bim777 this ending feels the most canon to the books.
I love of how people are threatning geralt when he is the only one that can save them from detlaff
So yen nor ciri doesnt know anything about geralt being in prison? hahaha
Depends. If you don't romance with Yen nor Triss and Ciri dies, you ll stick to Dandelion
how is this a bad ending?
Syanna caused all this, she got what she deserved.
This is not the bad ending, this is the best ending, everyone gets what he deserves.
You mean everyone except for Geralt. He should have been executed for letting Syanna die.
@@porkcutlet3920 By who? Lol gl with that.
@@porkcutlet3920 Geralt did his job. He was called to find the beast and kill it. He did it, both Syanna and Dethlaf deserved it. Leaving Syanna alive was not right, because the 5 victim was her sister. Leaving Dethlaf alive is wrong too, because he's the killer and too dangerous
Err...Detlaff is still out there somewhere.
@@extraditori6604 This makes no sense - how many people has Geralt slain, over Ciri? How many people have died just for knowing Ciri, or she’s slain (she became a murdering bandit briefly in the books and she enjoyed it, when she was in the rats.)
This is the worst ending, because she only killed people who hurt her. She never turned her back to the city when it was on fire either.
Dettlaf is a nutcase. Who killed hundreds of innocents, or thousands. Just because he got rejected, he behaves like an incel.
Bittersweet ending maybe. I liked it more than when the sisters reconcile. Mostly because I felt bad for Dettlaff being used by Syanna. I understood why she wanted the knights killed but also wanting to kill her sister was a bit much.
Agreed but dont forget that we land in prison too . In both the others endings geralt is heavily rewarded . I wanted both dead so I liked the both sisters dead one
The prison bit was fun though. :)
Agreed Geralt doing chores very funny . I liked this Expansion a lot . Will be waiting for cyberpunk 2077( CD Project next game). It will be same as witcher 3 I hope
good thing about the prison is it unlocks new achievement "king of the clink". so without serving the jail, you'll never get 100% achievement in witcher3. in other words, CDPR encourage to experience this ending (could be in NG+)
my heart really settles with this ending too. also even after you get this "mid" ending, once you visit beuclair palace, everything is normal again, only the character entry journal is slightly bitter. but in real game no one really beef with geralt.
Everyone I know thinks this is the good ending.
And IMO it was the best ending. I chose it simply following my heart and I doubt I'd ever choose differently.
Dettlaff didn't deserve death, he's been hurt and used. She deserved what she got.
Hmm true but I felt geralt didn't deserve prison
No, no, of course he didn't deserve it! But it's the duchess' fault, not our decision's.
If I were Geralt, I'd simply ask Dettlaff to scratch me and throw me around a little bit and then leave me there, pretending I'm half dead/beaten, for the duchess to find me XD
THEN she couldn't blame me for Syanna's death! Or at least not that much... She'd see I tried, but simply he was too strong for me to defeat.
Sapphiresenthiss Bluescales Haha that would have been a good option to add for geralt :D
Wouldn't it be? XD I was honestly surprised there wasn't, very half-baked. Imagine the duchess and her army coming, though, and Geralt starting to panic, jumping up to Dettlaff, yanking his jacket rapidly like they often do in cartoons: "QUICK! Scratch me! Throw me! DO anything! We have to make this look reliably!" while Dettlaff is all like: "Whoa whoa, dude, wth?!..." And Regis being all like: D: !!!
That would be a very funny little bonus option~
Sapphiresenthiss Bluescales Ya that would be hilarious :D. I think CDPR tried to make the endings as serious as possible
Yeah, this ending makes no sense. keep your vineyard, really?
CD Project red probably didn't want to piss off the players who got this ending :D
its the first player home. why take it away at the end of the day its better that way overall. from the prespective of the creators
Dandelion convinced her.
20:20 bottom right corner lmfao
haha
I like this ending the best, preferably speaking that I like ‘tragic’ endings, however. But I treated Dettlaff as a bro, even though Geralt and him didn’t like each other. He’s been through some shit.
Hmm Ok. This one seems more tragic th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html
WItcher goes to the graveyard to meet Duchess while she gets sad upon the death of syanna
Yeah, I suppose in a way they’re all tragic though. But I see what you mean!
Spastic Two-Headed Dragon Agreed
Thanks for great thorough video. I wanted to get the good ending, but not okay again to do this ending. So perfect; and thanks for choosing all conversation options, made me feel I missed nothing
You're Welcome .
man, this game is the greatest game ever in history.
it's very emotional
Yes agreed :)
Waiting for cyberpunk 2077
this and RDR2 habe the best game protagonists
I think this is the good ending.
Syanna gets her comeuppance.
And Detlaff lives.
Imagine a game where you play as Dettlaff, that would be the most badass game ever made
The combat possibilities would be craaaazy
So prototype? Or infamous second son
Bro I wanna play as Regis that would be fun as fuck, imagine being Regis during the attack on Stygga castle (lady of the lake book)? Just fucking massacring a whole castle of people
@@kristenarcher5996 Haven’t got to reading the books yet but I definitely want to, really took a liking to Dettlaff, with everything besides the city attack ofc, but playing as them would be so cool
I killed everyone and now i live as a happy father to ciri.
That was the perfect ending for me.
IMO this is the best ending... Syanna dies, Regis lives peacefully, Detlaff lives on his own ways and Geralt being neutral (that is how witchers lives, right? no political BS). The only regret I have is, not having my hands full against Jacques... should find a way to do so.
Not really neutral. If it was by the code he would've killed the vampire and given his head as payment
No witches don't kill higher lifeforms like dragons and such @@stompingpeak2043
28 minutes and 40 seconds into Witcher and chill and he gives you that look...
That moment when geralt looks at you :D
This is my new favorite ending. Syanna had her reasons but she was truly the villain in this story.
I think that the ending that both sisters reconcile in the end and forgive each other despite the faults where all survive is still the best ending. and to top it off I also think for the true happy ending it has to be finishing with yennefer in the end.
Hmm that does seem a better ending but for the last quest I would prefer triss or ciri :)
I didn t know about this... After 5 years
So far have only done a couple play throughs. 1 where the sisters make peace...and recently where both die. No matter what ending of the story itself...the very last moments between the 2 around the fire seem to bring a perfect close to the Witcher saga.
All because we miss the ribbon lol
Can't exactly see this as a happy ending where you let the vampire willing to commit genocide go free.
A happy and a sad ending is just a game of gwent away or refusing to spend some crowns..
True :)
I consider this as happy ending, thought Detlaff is guilty for attacking the city, Syana is the main Villian and beast of Bauclair to me. I simply couldn't let Regis kill Detlaff, 'cause Regis was the one who helped Geralt to save Ciri and died (in books). In addition, the way Syanna treated Detlaff was disgusting, she is really cursed.
If Syanna would killed that knights on her own, well it would be sort of justified, but this! The fact that Syanna feign love, well it hurt right, but I would move on, but wanting to kill for her. That's simply too much...
I go for this ending every time
This is the best ending, Dettlaff is awesome, CDPR got the endings the wrong way around.
CDPR didn't get anything wrong, if this is your definition of a good ending then by all means its the good ending. For some it isn't. You as the player can choose that's the point.
I sympathize with Detlaff, but when he decided to launch his attack on Beauclair...when he decided to slaughter countless innocent men, women, and children over a lover's quarrel...that's when I decided he had to die. Yes, Syanna (and the duchess, to a large extent) shares the blame, but Detlaff's actions were unforgivable.
@@captainhobo1234567 man, Detlaff gave them 3 days.. the concequences are Queen's fault
@@lorddormammu9881 Partly the Duchess's fault, but the duchess didn't slaughter hundreds of innocent civilians. That was all Detlaff. If he'd wanted to, he could have swept in, kidnapped the duchess, and ransomed her back in exchange for Syanna. Boom, no one hurt, except for Syanna, who was responsible for the whole bloody ordeal in the first place. But nope, instead he chose to abandon his false virtues of nobility and altruism and reveal himself for the true monster he always was. In attacking the city, he showed a blatant disregard for human life, so I don't see why Geralt should treat his life any differently
What's the music that plays when she dies it's been in my head for days and its killing me cuz I dont know it
Here is the Evil ending th-cam.com/video/56FngMbS3io/w-d-xo.html
Here is the happy ending th-cam.com/video/Sx__ZSYzQpU/w-d-xo.html
Here is the Shit on Geralt ending th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html
Final ending when Geralt goes home th-cam.com/video/J9mE58DmK1k/w-d-xo.html
troll join back or we will dislike and unscribe this.WE ALL WILL.come back to friends. I am kal
If you went with the empress ending this don’t make sense as it’s a part of the empire ciri would just get his ass out
To me this is the best ending not the bad ending - Syanna played Dettlaff and got what she deserved.
At least with this ending regis will be free to stay also not not be forced to move away due to constant vampire attacks.
Best ending by far.
I’m of the opinion that Annarietta was every bit as responsible for the attack on Beauclair as Syanna was. In my playthrough, Detlaff AND the sisters die.
True good end. I regret saving Syanna.
Thanks for this. Made my decision that this is going with my Empress Ciri and Triss romance ending. The Witcher Ciri ending, Dijkstra rules and Yen romance being with the other, non blood bath ending. :) I couldn't get a straight answer on Reddit as to the pros and cons of this ending and the other one- everyone seemed biased in one way or another. Thanks again!
You're Welcome :)
I love that he named the rat Stephan, likely after Stephan Skellen
Gah! Why did you keep skipping through the conversations? I wanted to see the differences so I could weigh my options. I think it's kind of defeating the purpose the developers made by labeling the endings good or bad. Much like the many choices they give you throughout the game; it isn't about which one is "good"... it's about which choice you can live with.
I already made the conversations in my previous ending videos. didnt want you to get bored watching them again :)
*Ah*. Fair enough. Sorry, I was looking for the various endings that I didn't get and what all was different from the ones I did see.
RoseKoneko Ok np. Thanks for watching :)
Well I saved syanna but these two sisters (Anna and Syanna) killed both in ceremony.
I thought this ending is what will happen in the novel.The best ending was too bright,but the story always ends in the somethng lacked in the novel
Hmm interesting. Didn't read the novels . Might read in the future .
U wish I didn't take this damn ribbon! And I didn't do a save before that scene - I'm so sad now
RyukaMoon it’s fine man this ending is good in its way too
Curious to know what would have happened when you find out who the fifth victim was meant to be in this ending... but you skipped that dialogue option.
I dont think anything would have happened cause the Duchess already said never to show my face again :D
She probably loves her sister so much that she would prefer her in prison instead of dead.
But I think there will be a slight difference if U actually kill the Evil Vampire ( Detlaff ) for killing Syanna .
If u kill detlaff . Dandelion comes along with the duchess and you get a fresh bunch of scoldings from the duchess. It isn't worth it :D If only I could kill the duchess :(
- Don't smile too wide, or someone will see yer fangs. Anyway good to see you MY VAMPIRE FRIEND - sure no guard will hear that just several feet from the prison
Nice dialogue
They are not even close to the prison.
I can’t believe how a side quest chance everything.
well what if you do this while dandelion is held imprisoned by the witchunters in the main quest in novigrad?!
I really like to know about regis more and dandelion.
I got more curious about these folks.
Regis doest have much role in previous witcher games. He appears in many Witcher 3 blood and wine quests though
Dandelion has major role in all witcher games.
So you mean He'll appear in sidequests, contracts, and many more?
CrimsonFox Hound No regis only in main quests . Dandelion appears in some side quests
): then books the Read
got this ending, and i came here because i love how geralt talk with the rat haha
What an amazing game. I saved Detlaff too because I am a vampire apologist and he's ever so dreamy. Random aside, but I find it hard to believe they'd waste the headman's axe on common criminals - they'd be sent to the gallows.
I like how he has no boots but he makes that sound while he's walking on some rocks bare foot
Haha me too :)
This is actually good ending, since the real beast (synna) is dead....who will not hesitate to back stab the duchess , if given chance.
Torn between this ending and the other where detlaff diess and both sisters live so my save has been stuck in limbo all this time
I really wish there was an ending where they could all live
Why does Detlaff look so similar to Emperor Emhyr ?
Naw he don't
Stupid question but can you get that stick he was using to fight the prisoners with as a weapon outside of this quest?
Hmm not sure didn't check the inventory
Syanna had it coming TBH.
if you ask Regin : Whatll you do now.. what's his answer?
I don't think he'll go to nilfgaard right?
I haven't met him later so not sure
at the very end I mean .. you didn't ask him in your video
so I wonder if you'd know
sorry about my rubbish question my English is bad
FATTAN SA Oh I got it I asked him in my other video but I played it long so I forgot . Let me find the video
FATTAN SA th-cam.com/video/Sx__ZSYzQpU/w-d-xo.html
geralt finally noticed me in the end if u know wat i mean
Yeah :)
Just finished B&W and got the 'happy ending' (phrasing). Man I would have been pissed to get this ending. A random dues ex machina Dandeleon shows up and frees Geralt? Fuck that noise.
There is another ending where duchess gives geralt an earful
th-cam.com/video/hpjlfssaAbo/w-d-xo.html
If only I knew that timy little ribon make her live...
I felt bad for Detlaff, and I couldn't stand Syanna because she acted like the world revolved around her, was selfish, childish, manipulative and most of all - She felt zero remorse for what she was doing to him, the consequences, and what she wanted to do to her sister. I'm sorry but there were characters who had worse backstories / childhoods in the game and didn't turn out to be sociopaths. I wish Detlaff could've lived as well as Syanna, oh well.
You felt bad for someone who MURDERED INNOCENT PEOPLE (men, women and children), put an entire duchy to burn, just because of a heartbreak?? I mean, syanna is no saint (she is definitely a bitch), but once detlaff started murdering innocent people, i knew what I had to do. I could forgive killing 4 people (specially because they were rapists sons of bitches), but an entire duchy? No man, no. You could even come up with the excuse that regis doesn't deserve being forced to kill his friend, but if you watch the part where detlaff kills syanna, you can see that's not what regis wanted, just hear his voice saying "what have you done?". Sometimes we need to face the hard truth that, some people are not what we thought they were.
@@luccav.432
You know he's not human but a vampire less intelligent than humans, very emotional and more dangerous than the Emperor himself, he gave a certain threat and was completely ignored, the massacre was the Duchess' fault.
bad ending my ass...Geralt rests in prison for a bit...dandy gets to repay one of the I owe you's, Regis isnt exiled from Toussiant and murdered by other vampires for breaking their laws, Detlaff respects you (Witcher 4 Geralt Yen/Triss/Yen+Triss and 2 Higher Vampires protect Ciri :P lol) and the actual beast is dead...I loved the line when Geralt asks if he she gets exactly how badly she has fucked up..and Yen is on couch outside of my house...whilst lame its a better ending than the base game :p
Was Regis still forced to leave Toussaint? Because at the end 2 Bruxa's call him out for being a traitor.
All the endings are arguable.
the prison gate didn't open for me
What's the trackname for the song playing after Syanna is stabbed?
No clue . Ill try to find out
this should be the better ending. i shouldnt have gotten the ribbon for syanna
People dont seem to favour the 'happy' ending. But just because the sisters reconcile, doesn't mean that syanna isn't punished afterwards. She will still have to answer for her crimes. Plus everyone is far better off overall than the other endings
I never really cared that much about Dandelion in the main game, but seeing him work so hard to get his friend freed from prison makes me like him
Bro i gave her ribbon to her on a whim. That really saved my ass
id prefer something like that, maybe fight the vampire too, but my pride over Gwent made made me win that ribon and go for the good ending. i wanted some punishment to go on Syanna but at this point either both sister live or they both die
Ya I got the both sisters live ending when I first played the fast few rounds .
Weird when i got to that scene she just dissapeared from his hands and he got mad at Geralt
Because you got her the magic ribbon
This is the good ending.
stupid question but... what set of armor u have on before detlaff killed the syana
Its the Vampire Armour you get from the secret vampire hideout while traveling with regis
srry for late answer ... hmm ok thx i have just bought this dlc though
Isaac Clarke Hmm nice have fun
What decision make difference between Detlaf kill Syana or Syana is saved by teleported to fairytale?
You need to win the ribbon from the blond girl in the fairyland in order to save syanna
th-cam.com/video/0rcO0665T0I/w-d-xo.html
SPOILER ALERT: The best ending for me is.....
..... the death of both Anna and Syanna. Unfortunately, Dettlaff will die as well :/
I chose this ending because I couldn’t bear to cause Regis to kill Detlaff, especially after what Regis did sacrifices for Geralt in the books. I think syanna deserved to die, if detlaff was human I’d say the same but he’s not human and thinks I’m very different ways from humans so while I don’t agree with what he did, he’s not EVIL like syanna mainly was. So yeah, I faced jail and spared detlaff just for Regis lol
Detlaff still evil too, because he massacre innocent people while his target just syanna.
Bad ending? Regis is happy = good ending
I would love to know what path was taken leading to this point... the unseen elder? or land of a thousand fables?
Land of a thousand fables but don’t get the ribbon from the drug dealer
its the good ending for me cause detlaff lives XD
Unpopular Opinion, but I think this is the best ending. True, its frustrating because Geralt is just watching everything and gets yelled at afterwards, but I think Syanna is the villain that needs to die, not Dettlaff.
She is evil and manipulative, responsible for four murders and a broken heart and she wanted to kill her sister. Dettlaff might be more frightening, but he has a code of honor and isn't plain evil. I don't even classify him as a monster, he is way to passionate and intelligent for that. For all these reasons I prefer to let Dettlaff have his revenge. About the contract... Syanna is the real Monster anyways.
i won't say this is unpopular opinion since in every ending video, either good or bad one, they all say she deserve to die.
Syanna only dies if you make the wrong decisions after that it gives m the Dickson to either talk to syanna or go to the dutchmess should I talk to syanna to get her to forgive her sister?
I don't think this ending is that bad. Syanna is a treachorous bitch who got exactly what she deserved, Detlaff was being used and deserved to be spared in my opinion, and at least this way Regis doesn't get shunned.
It's a shame that the duchess doesn't realise this and doesn't send Geralt to prision, but everything else that happened is cool as far as I'm concerned.
Ya The main reason I called this bad is because geralt was sent to prison. Washing others clothes, cleaning prison ?:D
*good ending
Based
Hey, what should be done to achieve this ending???
not getting the ribbon i suppose
DO not visit the small girl to take the ribbon in imaginary land
20:19 Heey, Cancer is playing Warframe
Does anyone know the song at 3 minutes???