Which sci-fi MECH / TITAN is best? | Factions Compared: Halo, WH40k, Titanfall and Mass Effect
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- On today's episode of Sci-Fi Factions Compared, we put the Colossus of Halo against the Imperial Titan from Warhammer 40k, the Atlas from Mass Effect, and the Titan from Titanfall!
Colossus from Halo Wars 2: • Video
Atlas Boss Battle from Mass Effect 3: • Mass Effect 3 - Atlas ...
***
Check out my second channel: / eckstoo
Follow me on Twitch: / eckhartsladder
Twitter: / eckhartsladder
Want to help the channel out?
Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71
Become a channel member: goo.gl/XFK2Lw
Join the (superfun!) Discord: / discord
Patreon: / eckhartsladder
Intro/Outro Music: Home - Resonance
Outro meme'd by: / freightmytrain
![[UNCUT] “บอสณวัฒน์” ลากไส้!! ใครหนุนหลัง "แม่ตั๊ก ป๋าเบียร์" I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 30 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QlD7mU2KKRk/mqdefault.jpg)
B I G
M E T A L
B O I S
based
THANK YOU!!!!!!
Love big metal bois
I think you gotta write I love mass effect bio the mechs in that game were pretty much just cobbled together for ground Units but I would say titans fall 2 is better than Halo Meachs Because they are specialized and the pilots had pretty much train day one and I don't know if you include his her not let it know you say was that there is a bond that the pilots develop between themselves and the Meach the Meach actually become an extension of who they are Plus they're smart enough to operate by themselves
The covenant vs yuzzhan vong.
Halo, Mass Effect and Titanfall mech walk into a bar.
The bar is located on the back of a Warhammer titan.
way underrated comment.
And a destiny Titan is leading that bar
Der UnbekannteLP no, that would be me. For I boop the snoot, small croaker
Ikr, they would’ve needed Gurren Lagann if they want to compete with WH40
@@combineeliteunit8769 VULKAN LIVES
Warhammer 40k Titans!
"Imagine a city that hates you. Now give it city leveling weapons and legs to walk on, then fill it with more things that hate you. You have a rough idea of a Titan."
Excluding the exaggerated lethality of 40K, it make sense that their Titans are number 1. After all, 40K Titans are basically small starships with legs.
They carry starship grade weapons and shields. I was disappointed that he didn't include the Tau Battlesuits.
The insanity of 40K requires everything to be turned 11 out of 10 the opening to 40k should tell you that the galaxy is F@*ked, your F@*ked, everything is F@*ked.
A gross over-simplification of the most hallowed constructs created by man... However their machine spirits appear to appreciate you definition of them, Cities are big and they like being called big...
Dude forget a city. An emperor class titan could literally level a continent. They are so revered by the tech-priests of the Adeptus Mechanicus, that their deployment is usually only permitted in literally apocalyptic level conflicts. The emperor protects.
I'm kinda surprised that you're using Titans rather than the comparable Imperial Knights. A Titan is the kind of thing you throw at Godzilla.
you think godzilla would stand a chance? nah!
haha. :D Imperator titan says "awh it has blue breath" "charging fusion annihilator" and "poof"
A knight could probably take on Godzilla
@@michael83479 slashy smashy metal boi
And what about Mecha-Godzilla?
WH40K: hey guys, love to be in this video
Every other sci-fi: aight, we fighting for second place
I think Halo can compete with Forerunners and Ancient Humans :B
@@alexisbaz8746 but then you would have the reality warping technology of the 20th millenium in the warhammer 40k universe.
@@pampanamonick7076 you are going to high end, in that case I can bring Silentium Flood and Precursors, the Forerunner can easily overrun IoM, the Ancient Humans to in a less degree, other Sci-fi are even more powerfull.
@@alexisbaz8746 i will say it now the maximum i know of the forerunners is that they scale to the precursers, that with theyre tech they could move a galaxy or solar system, but reality warping is way above that tho. But if you can could you give me some knowledge(my english is trash tier)
About all that you just said, please give me it, i am as blind to that lore as a baby.
@@pampanamonick7076 well, Forerunners have some hacks, they can turn organic beings into data, all of their ships manipulate the time inside the Ship to gave the crew more time to react accelerating time inside the ship. They can build metaphysical weapons able to target neurophysical constructs, Halo universe is a sentient being so the Halo probably destroys neurons from the universe, is a speculation but the Halo Array destroys Star Roads basically solidified tough and those construct are immune to super novas and black holes so the Forerunner have some kind of metaphysical weapons. The Ecumene has massive productoon capabilities able to made 29km long ships in minutes and those ships can tank supermacs witouth shield like nothing, they have a speed ranging from 4% speed of light to half speed of light, Sojourner Class Dreadnought can deploy 2 millon atack drones able to deflect exterminatus leves Ion Cannon of they are in huge swarms, 5000 War Spinx basically star fighters with Emperor Class Titan Firepower able to vaporize cities and excecute orbital bombardment, and of course able to fly extremely fast. The Sojourner has a weapon called Torsion Drave, a gravitational weapon able to tear apart from the inside other Forerunner Ships o Ancienr Human ignoring shields, anti matter torpedos with crazy tracking capabilities, point defense able to damage War Spinx and treaten UNSC Ships. Every Forerunner ship is made of light and nanolaminate armor able to quickly self repair and adapt to incoming atack, Forerunners had 100 millons of Sojourners, and then you have Fortress Class and the huge Mantle Aproach, a Forerunner ship can crush in a planet, leave a crater big enought to be seen from orbit and still be able to stay operational even ships like the Forerunner Dreadnouht a Research Ship not made for combat.
Warhammer: *is in title*
Everyone: "yea we know where this is going"
Tyler Kovacs everything in warhammer is op as shit
If it was based in reality Titanfall would win
unless it's guardsmen then they just loose immediately
@@jontheno3213 Do not underestimate the power of 1000 flashlights or the bayonets
@@hellsin5754 i think you mean hundreds of thousands
AHHHHHHH HE FINALLY DID SOMETHING ON TITANFALL HOLY SHIT
That momemt when ronin comes behind you
Ronin: nothing personnel kid
@@arthurblains8344 お前はもう死んでいる。
Smart core online
Nobody cares
Smart pistol
Everyone loses their minds
Now if only he did gundam.
@@aurumxargentum im assuming by your text its not korean so i dont know what your saying so sorry D:
I asked my friend what Warhammer was about and he just screamed loudly.
Close enough
BURN THE HERETIC PURGE THE XENOS REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE - Some inquisitor, probably
that's acurate
Purge the heretics in holy hell fire
WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAGHHHHH! Orkses are the biggest and the bestest!
“There is no titan that is more powerful than the others”
Me:Laughs in tone
That is funnh
Laughs in fully upgraded monarch monarch with 1500 health as I hunt you down like the coward you are hiding behind your shield.
@@themeddite cant forget the part where you double stun him and get full shields
“Right back at you buckaroo”
-Ion
Me: *laughs in legion or ronin*
Warhammer logic: "Bigger, Stronger, Thicker, also carries a church for the emperor's sake
Or if you are a man with fine taste, is made of wraith bone, shoots lasers and is piloted by a set of twins, one dead one alive
40k is autistic
@@keithstone8693 you're not wrong
@@keithstone8693 everything in 40k was created while sniffing at least 3 pounds of cocaine
@@danksanchez4324 yep, this is actually true when the writers were hired, 2 pounds of a drug of there choosing was given to them as part of there pay
Could have been slightly more balanced if he used imperial knights instead of Titans (40k would still win though)
couldve been more balanced if 40k wasnt in the list
Should have used dreadnoughts imo; fairly specialized, appear frequent enough, and wouldn’t necessarily curb stomp the rest of the contenders.
@@piecemakernoalias1018 Depends on who you put in there. Bjorn would kick each of these titans into oblivion.
@@rohitsayer1400 Yeah but... Bjorn is also a *named* dreadnought.
Or tau mech as the xv 8 xv 95 or the holy nerf that xv 104 riptide
you unfairly decided on warhammer, imperial knights, or the eldar wraithknights are way more on scale with the other universes mechs, and would still come in first place.
I expected a tau battlesuit
@@lucase3052 or a dreadnought
@@absolutelyloyalspacemarine1684 But those are essentially weaponized tombs, not really mechs. An Imperial Knight would be more apt, as it doesn't require you to be a nearly-dead, cybernetically linked, already genetically and surgically modified Space Marine. You still need a neural implant, but hey, it's better than Astartes training. Well, less likely to kill you, anyway. Or well, _slightly_ less likely to kill you. My point is a mostly normal human can still pilot it, a dreadnaught is too specialized
@@ElectromagNick Aren't Imperial Knights actually pretty hard to control, and even dangerous for their special pilots/knights?
@@adorablecenturion8436 I know they require quite a bit training, and the first time you establish a link with it, it's like every nerve in your body is being stabbed. And electrocuted. And set on fire. And you get just the worst migraine, like the absolute worst, the earth-shattering, kill-me-slowly-to-relieve-the-pain, fuck you in particular kind of migraine. This, as you can probably tell, has the _sliiiiight_ risk of driving you completely batshit. Oh, and death. Small risk of excruciating death. I mean, this _is_ 40K we're talking about.
But that's only the 1st time. Every subsequent link is more like if the inside of head was set on fire. You'll probably be fine.
Honestly when it comes to any sci-fi discussion and 40k is mentioned you know who's going to win.
i can't think of a single other universe quite as gloriously bonkers as Warhammer. The mechs are bigger than everything else, pack more firepower, and even carry forts around on their shoulders.... and they still prefer to kill one another with axes and chain flails...
any universe that takes itself seriously will always be at a disadvantage
Eve Online and Supreme Commander could both wipe the floor with 40k.
DeMause now why do you say that? I’ve personally played both and read a whole lot of 40k lore so I know my fair share of things on both and I think warhammer would win
@@katieshadowsong4665 Logistics. EVE and Sup Com both play out in real time, whereas everything that happens in the 40k universe takes months/centuries to do. An ACU could land on a planet, build an army, conquer the whole thing and then teleport to the next world before word ever got to the imperial guard to actually put up a defense. Let alone Titan legions, which are what the imperium would actually need to use against Sup-Com units.
DeMause that’s true but eventually there would be word sent out being like hey there’s this massive army just kinda teleporting around set up defenses.
As a 40k fan, I do agree that the "Titans" of 40k should be disregarded as completely OP to the rest of the stuff here. But I feel like they were a poor choice for this match-up. Comparing the Titans of 40k to the Titans of Titanfall is like comparing a battletank to a battleship. They are in completely different leagues in terms of scale and usage.
If 40k was to be included in this match-up, you should have used the smaller scale mechs of the Imperium. Dreadnoughts of the Space Marines, or at most, The Imperial Knights. Either that, or the advanced Battlesuits of the Tau Empire. That way, the 40k universe wouldn't have completely eclipsed the other options out of sheer scale and there would have been much more thoughtful debate as to how they fared with the others in terms of usefulness in their role and tactical flexibility.
On the topic of the Titanfall Mechs vs Halo mechs, my vote goes to the Titanfall mechs. While they are similar in terms of firepower, and size, Titanfall Mechs have a lot more maneuverability than the Halo Mechs. Plus, given the more myriad versions of Titanfalls mechs, they can be utilized in a number of varied tactics thanks to their exotic weaponry and specialized gadgets. Whereas the mechs of Halo seem to be utilized similarly to a battletank most of the time. While Halo Mechs seem to be more durable than the Titanfall ones, maneuverability and tactical flexibility outclasses durability when two pilots of a high skill rating are pitted against one another. Not to mention, the more cumbersome nature of the Halo Mechs makes it so that, if fighting against the mechs of Titanfall, lets the Titanfall mech have the initiative and decide the terms on which they fight.
Zepyrus-G I would have to disagree on the Halo vs Titanfall because Cyclopses. cyclops are notably more maneuverable than other UNSC mechs comparable to titans not specifically designed for speed and, if you take the Mega Blocks variations into account, can be specialized to fit many a role. Now taking adding the other UNSC mechs I’d say its at least a toss up at most favoring the UNSC
@@montypython5521 That is a very good point. Cyclops models can stand toe-to-toe agaimst the Titanfall mechs for sure so comparing those two is a 50/50 thing.
Though, this time in terms of battlefield command, I still feel Titanfall has the advantage given that their factions have incorporated their varied Titans into their military doctrine. Whereas Cyclops is one variant of the UNSC combat mechs. Mantis models for example are inferior to the Titanfall mechs yet are produced as much, if not more widely than the Cyclops. The UNSC utilize the Cyclops as a specialized tool modified for a needed combat role, whereas Titans in Titanfall are central to any large-scale offensive and as such their commanding officers would be able to utilize the Titans more efficiently than the UNSC could deploy the Cyclops.
But then again this is getting into strategy comparison rather than the vehicle itself so I'll stop myself right here, haha
yeah, and the titanfall mechs have the vortex shield of "no u".
this!
I realy love this comment section unloke the one from goku v.s OPM
What I think is so special about the 40K universe is that 99% of the fighting is done by regular men and women with mere basic armour and a mass-produced standard issue lasgun. You hear all about these titans and space marines and sisters of battle, but ultimately it is these regular normal brave men of the Imperial guard that are the backbone of the Imperium. Regular people like me and you, mass conscripted into the ranks to feed the ever-expanding meat grinder of the 40K universe. These people get no credit, have next to no joy in their lives and know they will never see their home or family again. They fight unspeakable horrors that simply cannot be described. Hordes of deadly aliens and truly incomprehensibly terrifying daemons of the warp on a daily basis, and die in the billions in the process. Yet despite all this, they stand, pick up their weapon, look death in the eye and fight. Not for glory, not for the promise of a better tomorrow, but simply just so the Imperium may carry on just for another day. Only in death does duty end.
*"For that weak sack of flesh that you so gleefully mock is no super soldier, no immortal warrior, no creature cursed by chaos like you. He is a man, an imperial guardsman drawn from some forgotten corner of the Imperium to fight for his species and for the safety of the people he loves. He is a factory worker, a farmer, a storekeeper, a father, a brother, a son, a mere man. And against creatures like you, teeming and numberless, powered by the very will of thirsting gods......... He holds the line. He has held the line for ten thousand Years."*
Guys in T-shirts trying to fight off Lovecraft-esque cosmic horrors with flashlights...they're brave as hell.
@@MyJourneyConcludes Such words,Such poetry
Its Amazing
THE PLANET BROKE BEFORE THE GUARD!
whats even more special is each regiment is different, not only do some regiments voluntier enmasse for the most extreme misions (the deathkorps) but some volunteer despite liveing a fairly good life on democratic planets and knowing full well the dangers of the guard (like the elysian drop troopers)
Bro I may be a huge titan fall fan but warhammer would win no doubt
U have no idea the warhammer universe is a place where war is forever and everything in the universe is trying to kill humanity so these crazy titans and space marines are needed to keep humanity alive as well as many trillions of soldiers
*laughs in transformers titans*
To be fair. The titanfall titans could and would compete against 40k knights.
Maybe knights but not a titan
@@mikd157 not even joking, the only transformer i know thats bigger than an emperor class titan is unicron and thats only because hes a literal planet and even then im pretty sure that if you were to deploy multiple emperor class titans, they could destroy him easy
NO.
40k titans are walking fortresses. if you were looking at mechs, you should have went for Knights, 1 crew mobile mechs.
Nah dude. Any Astartes would crush any of those other IPs.
@@uglyweirdo1389 na
Lore wise a single astartes could take down all of the other Factions walkers
Or even dreadnaught
Or sentinel
Voltron. "And I'll form the head!" *gets stomped flat by 40k Titan.*
Bo and Caleb Eskew dose it have a shield or shield busting weapons because from what I have seen it’s weapons would not do anything against void shields and if it’s flying it’s also got to dodge the hundred plus point defence guns and flack cannons as well as ground aa and thunderbolt fighters they send one must remember a Titian is more like a walking fortress
Is that your dreadnought? Great scheme
@@lincawebot3681 unless if you go with the godamn cartoon series.
I know im late.
Voltron's torn apart Gaalra starships before tho
Why do warhammer super mechs have churches on top of them? Is it so they can prey and sing praises of god whilst they slaughtering thousands?
Pretty much, yes. Also so the crew can use their faith to beat back the Forces of Chaos.
YES SO WE CAN SING PSALMS TO THE GLORY OF THE HOLY GOD EMPRAH !!!!!! , while eradicating the unfaithfull , the mutant and the heretic !!!!
oh and "accidently" step on some of rowboat girlymans ultrasmurfs "im sorry princeps i really didnt see those bright blue buffoons under the left leg bastion" XD
the Titans are seen as literal manifestations of god (the Omnissiah) so they pray and worship them as such, therefore they have chapels on top of them that are dedicated for the Titan. We wouldn't want the Omnissiah to be disappointed, take control of the planet-destroying Titan and go on a tantrum, now do we.
Thousands? More like millions😂
ThatSpeciallyUniquePizzaGuy The Omnissiah is more of a robot Jesus than God
"How like a God He is, that ancient Machine, primal of all His Kind, the Imperator! His mighty Fists, massive like two Towers of Destruction, laden with Doom of Mankind's bitter Foes. He watches over us now as Battle joins, and in his Shadow we shall advance upon our Enemies and defeat them."
- Anonymous Adeptus Mechanicus Enginseer
01000111 01101100 01101111 01110010 01111001 00100000 01110100 01101111 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01101111 01101101 01101110 01101001 01110011 01110011 01101001 01100001 01101000 - Glory to the Omnissiah
*Halo, titanfall, and atlas argue about who's better*
*Warhammer 40k titan steps on all three in one step*
FOR THE EMPRAH
40K in a nutshell.
gundam shoots emperor-class right through in the head before the thing could even move
seriously, wh40 won only because he didnt include Mechwarriors or Gundam
@@Sansacar lololololol lol your ignorance is laughable.
I LOVE mechwarrior but the 100tonners are approx 18 metres tall and at best carry rail gun and laser tech.
A single warlord would literally step on an atlas and crush it to dust. No shot would go through the void shield.
Gundam is even less advanced and only a total weeaboo would think they stand a chance against imperial titans.
@@sarchlalaith8836 one atlas can't, yes. Dozen of Timber Wolfs with Clan tech can. And considering production costs, its a very good trade.
Next, Gundam. You clearly don't know anything about it if you think that way. I know you are wh40k fanboy and as the rest of your kind you are stubborn, stupid and think that wh would win just because it's bigger. But believe me, wh40k tech is one of the simplest there is. And there are many universes that wh don't stand a chance against.
@@Sansacar yeah you're an idiot. I was building Gundams and mech before you were born probably. If you think anything in the Gundam universe can compare to 12 void shields and armour so thick. Even orbital bombardment can be shrugged off then you're more of a clown than I think anyway.
The fire power a titan possesses is capable of shattering worlds.
They can literally mount weapons that open dimensional rifts and suck cities into a literal hell universe.
You got nothing. So shut up, read about it before you embarrass yourself any further.
Alright so:
Halo:Upgraded mantis. Ok.
Titanfall:A titan. Didn't see that one coming.
Mass Effect:Generic recycled boss... *Sigh*
Warhammer 40k:Emperor class army killers. F*ckin wut.
Edit:You could of included something from the Supreme Commander franchise like the King Kriptor or universal colossus.
I agree
Go with the classics, bring a Krogoth!
Or an armored core Arms fortress or something.
Totally agree
The Mechs from Mass Effect are a joke.
Or perhaps one of the many Mechs from Battletech/Mechwarrior.
I'm a WH40K fan and I agree that you deserve a pass to disregard them. I appreciate that you left it open to discussion between Halo and Titanfall.
I feel the Titanfall Mechs are superior because they can operate autonomously.
Also titanfall mechs are super agile and fast, they are very much matching in mobility to any person just much bugger
Offensively flexibility wise I agree but the defense systems are far more advanced with the mantis and colossus
Tristan C vanguard class titans and titanfall 1 titans had shields and plus if you really think about it a titan could really just run up to the mantis and trip it and the fight would basically be over less than a minute. Come on now titans are way more flexible than any other video gaming mechs.
Kamau MuseMorris I agree, the Mantis walker has almost the same problem the Galactic Empire's AT walkers have, over exposed cockpits and long spindly legs. Easy to knock down or trip up.
Agree completely, and if Eck isn't at all versed in the Battletech universe, he gets a free pass for skipping that aswell :)
I feel like when referring to 40k the “titans” shouldn’t have been on this list as they are in a different league but rather the imperial knights or Dreadnought would have made for a more close comparison.
Dreadnought is Basically Giant
Walking Coffin
@@rahadityap2375 with guns
*my god that's a lot of guns*
@@rahadityap2375 the kind of coffin Sarah Connor was buried in with a lot. More. Guns and guns
Just a little point of contention. You're right about having 40K at number 1. But I think you are comparing multi person, building sized, mechs with single person, tactical combat, mechs. Comparing apples to apples, the Tau mechs would have been a better comparison and more similar in size, utility and strength while having a single pilot to control them. You would have also had to choose from Crisis Suits, Stealth Suits, Broadsides, Stormsurge and Riptides. The number 1 spot would still go to 40K, but there wouldn't have been the vast differences for comparison.
Imperial knights are one man, and would still win my dude
@@Mantoisful isn't the definition of a mech a one manned weapons platform? Otherwise it might as well be called a walking multi person vehicle.
@@dazigolding5814 its piloted by one person, just other people are on it fixing stuff and other tasks.
@@Mantoisful okay... that's a lot of power for one person... thanks.
So what you're saying is, this guy knows jack shit about WH40K? WHO WOULD'A THOUGHT?!
A Mech episode without Battletech?
SHAME!
Timber Wolf for life, because I am clanner scum haha!
I'm with you guys on this battletech should have been mentioned.
Highlander a thicc boi.
An AC/20 Urbanmech is far superior than any of these
@@Colin8or I can see it now some shite Capellan Urbie staring up at a titan that just "accidentally" stepped on a lance of atlas's, one shot that would look the the deathstar exhaust from star wars
Picking imperial knights might have been more appropriate
Imperial Knights would still mop the floor with everything else.
@@Memento--Mori Ithink the titans from titanfall would win. They're more maneuverable
imperial knights cope with Eldar who are much much more maneuverable than Titan fall mechs
@@cfdj43 it really just depends on what equipment the knight has aint it
Having a big gun and alot of armour is useless if you can outmanouver it, the 1st one being the imperial knight and the 2nd one being a mech from titanfall
"There's no one Titan that is objectively better then another" may I introduce you to Scorch
May I introduce you to Tone, Pilot?
Northstar gang
Monarch uses arch rounds and drains both vortex shield energy and thermal shield faster. After that's gone you are a punching bag. And as for tone, long range is a better time to use your shield than when monarch is next to you. Idk how many times I've walked through a tone shield only for them to have swapped spots with me and given me the advantageous position.
Ion is the gentleman's choice
Please please please do more about Titanfall, it’s such a good series
Heard. pls do
Agreed
Fifthed!
Pls
That would be great, please do more Titanfall!
talking about Mechs/Titans and you don't mention Battletech/Mechwarrior?!
SHAMEFUL DISPLAY!!!!!!
Haven't even watched it yet and i'm already salty!
I mean, he did this first one about mechs with stuff he's familiar with. He doesn't have Star Wars level knowledge of every Sci-fi universe.
Battletech is baby stuff compared to stuff like Gundam, Macross, and Gunbuster.
He didn't say "Mech suit", he said "Mechs,Titans", so the Battlemechs would qualify. Plus, he has WH Titans, Halo Goblins, and Mass Effect Atlases. So if it was mech-Suits/exo-skeleton suits, someone should tell Ecks that
@@TheMindRobber42 I figured. I grew up with it so my first reaction is emotional lol
There actually is a Titan in Titanfall that is regarded as better than all other Titans, the Vanguard class. Remember BT-7274? He was a Vanguard. Vanguards had the ability to use any Titan weapon and abilities. It had a regenerating shield and the most advanced AI of any type of Titan, making the Vanguard class the First and so far only self-aware Titan in Titanfall.
yeah, but even Stryders from Titanfall 1 were better. 6 batteries I believe were on a Stryder. BT-7274 had 5. And stryders could also move faster, had regenerating shields, and customized loadout. Honestly, if we are going to do a comparison with Titanfall, use Titanfall 1. The pathetic titans from the sequel are easily dominated by an atlas at most.
Screw Hammond Robotics. They need to get themselves straight.
But bt could switch weapons on the fly, while this may just be a mechanic, he also is intelligent thanks to his advanced ai, with almost human qualities like when he turned a pole with wire into a zipline by hurling it at a building. This shows that bt and by extenaion the vanguard class are more advanced than most normal titans
Also 2 notes
1. Not to be rude at all, but stryders do have less armor, making them vulnerable in combat, a northstar could take stryder down with tethers and her railgun
2. Why was bt the only titan in the campain to show autonomy
Vanguards were the militias own build of an atlas, BT (AKA the cutest fuckin killing machine ever) was notoriously better than others for a lot of reasons: Plot armour, his AI seems to be far more advanced than any other titan and he is capable of quickly changing his entire loadout to another class, no other titan is capable of this. a Standard Vanguard is what you get at the beginning of the game, similar or almost identical to an Atlas.
@@dragonlord3376 i think it was due to BT's extended lifespan, its kinda shown to us that BT has been around for a long ass time, considering he's been with latimosa since the start of his career and he an old Vet, and tians develop their AI the longer they live and more they connect with their Pilot
You should have used dreadnaughts or imperial knights as a slightly more fair comparison.
HAHAHAHAHA! More "fair"
@@Rurik_Luci I mean, Titanfall can probably match those two...
@@cannypride8191 easily
@@cannypride8191 a dreadnought probably but against something like an imperial knight probably not, one chainsaw to the face and you're gone lol
@@toeseater2855 Knights are still doable by Titanfall, right? lower-end ones that is. Titans are the ones that outclass everything else
40K Mechs. Tau battlesuits don't get a mention?
So do Imperial Knights
because they are disgusting xenos and are nothing compared to the glorious god machines of the omnissiah.
or eldar waithbone constructs.....im pretty sure some of them have eldar in them and we cant forget the orks!
He went for big and really powerful not all of the ones he could name. Having to name and explain a hundred different mechs would take too long
Wh40k Mechs could get their own video series.
I would've rather seen the dreadnought or the maybe imperial knights from 40k, or even some of the mechanicum stuff. Pitting the 40k titans against some dinky paperweights is incredibly unfair.
Agreed
I think even the Terminators would be a more fair comparison. They are mechs technically, since the operator doesn't fully move, just crossing their arms.
@@ExternalDialogueThe Terminators would be the only thing you could pit. Imperial knights have G-Gundam logic(Just put a martial artist with good aim in an imperial knight, or Guts from Berserk in an imperial knight its as good as a done deal. Or if the Emperor/Omnissiah allows put Sly Marbo in an imperial knight there won't be another mech anything period), and dreadnoughts could deploy Deredeo, and Leviathan which are hard to kill, and have nigh unavoidable aim.
He said the best and the titans are the best in the wh40k universe well they are the best for the imperium
40k titans were a unfair choise i feel, knights would have fit better.
Or picked the humble Jegan from gundam ( Char's Counter Attack version not F91).
And they would still be the best. Knights are more advanced than titans. 🤔
I think he did say we was looking at the best mechs from each universe, so that would default him to titans. Plus, he does seem to be a bit on edge/afraid of 40k stuff, since he has several times put 40k in a comparison video and then gets a lot of comments from 40k fans (passionately) correcting him when he doesn't put it as #1. So, taking the super op titan makes it easy for him to say it's the best and avoiding all that. To be fair to the 40k fans though, I do think they tend to be right about how 40k stuff should have won a lot of previous comparisons but didn't. Eckharts simply isn't as familiar with 40k as he is with other sci-fi universes such as Star Wars or Halo, and while doing his best to compare, his lack of knowledge on 40k showed and skewed results.
Knights? maybe even dreadnoughts
Battlesuits better
*space marine see’s titan from titanfall*
Space marine: Which chapter are you from, brother?
TF2 titans are still significantly taller than space marines
Shouldn't 40k's mech be either the Imperial Knights for the Astra Militarum or the Dreadnought for the Adeptus Astartes?
Knight might still be to big, proper size would probably the mentioned Dreadnought or the Mechs the Sororitas somtimes use
I'm not sure Dreadnoughts count as Mechs on the level this video is going for. A Dreadnought is technically a cyborg, albeit one with the biological Space Marine completely encased within it. The occupants mortally wounded body is wired directly into the exterior sensory suite, and they typically inhabit this new form until killed outright.
Titans rather belong to the Adeptus Mechanicus
Angustus_Jan the Sororitas mechs are called penitent Engines, which have the worst criminals strapped to them while the machine tortures them and can attack enemies
@@Zombiewithabowtie A dreadnought is essentially a walking talking talking armored tomb with guns.
No one Titan better than the other?
Someone never used Tone
Did someone say... Tone?
Ronin would beat a Tone in a one on one
@@ninjasnowball2415 if the Ronin was able to get close enough sure. Tone had so much ability to keep everything off of it and kill you before it got to the point
lol I think if we had a group of the meks titanfall would win just because of all the variety of the meks and special stuff they have cough cough tone camp
@@lilcoolcat LMAO a single Tone shows up to fight all of WH40K
it teleports behind the 40K and just starts unloading the tracer rounds into it's head
You have open Pandora's Box, now I want you to make a vs with Gundam, Battletech or Macross.
That's my suggestion though I added StarCraft and the Terran Dominion just for kicks.
Sdf might be the one thing actually capable of going against 40k lol
@@micheal5973 actually its Gundam but only late UC, dark history era of Gundam can stand to 40k. But if you want something that can out match the Imperiums titans look to Five Star Stories and their Mortar Heads.
Armored Core
Barry Bend I was thinking bout that gigantic mech from Seed Destiny tbh. The only thing limiting the Gundams are the whiny little bitch pacifist pilots. Look at what Mikazuki Augus was capable of (Tekkadan’s last stand. The video on YT is about 40 minutes long but worth it)
Battletech not being included should be some kind of crime.
DeMause Heresy if I may so, I shall inform the holy inquisition for the Emperor
Agreed, either he's totally unfamiliar with the Battletech Universe or he has some sort of bias against it.
What about the 50+ mechs from Robotech RPG? Had almost a dozen of their RPG books, listing transforming mechs, standard mechs, and star ships. Played Battletech as well, and they actually used some art from Robotech.
Best Sci-fi Mech?
Everything in BattleTech
ALL SYSTEMS NOMINAL
best sci-fi mech?. Shinkiro - Code Geass due to its absolute defense system basically making it almost immortal
as a Clanner and a fan of BT/MW since the 90s when I was a kid, i have to give a shoutout to the Timber Wolf. One of the most powerful yet well balanced mechs in its universe, fast enough to keep pace with other mechs almost half its size but with enough firepower to probably threaten anything short of a colossal mech.
I've been thinking of a Timby vs AT AT battle for a while, but I suspect that the Timby would both run rings around and maybe even outgun the AT AT
@@sana__6 an AT AT could probably take out a Timber Wolf (or probably even fully armoured Assault Class mechs) in a single shot with the main cannons at full power (Reference: SW Ep 5 ESB destroying the shield generator).
With that in mind, the AT AT has an *EXTREMELY* limited firing arc, which is a fatal flaw. The firepower of a Timber Wolf could definitely destroy an AT AT. Though I doubt an Alpha Strike would do it in one shot. Probably at least a couple of Alpha Strikes.
With that in mind, if the Mech Warrior took the Timber Wolf head on with no evasion, he'd likely get smoked. If it were a 1 on 1, he'd be dead. If this was a Lance, then the AT AT would probably kill one, *MAYBE* two (depends on the recharge time for the main weapon at full power - we have no idea, since we only see it used once) mechs before the rest would scatter, surround, flank, and then destroy the AT AT.
If the Mech Warrior knew what he was getting into ahead of time, and could approach from the rear or ambush the AT AT, then yeah I think a single Timber Wolf could easily kill an AT AT - as long as he knew to stay in the flanks.
@@RhelrahneTheIdiot fuck i nearly forgot about that one fucking love that anime
YES! Your standard medium mech would crush everything on this list with the exception of the absurdity that is war-hammer. Love that there's people that still know what Battletech is.
*sees titanfall logo in thumbnail* SMART CORE READY
*SWORD CORE READY*
Flame core online!
righteouskill45 Better ingredients, better pizza. Papa Scorch
DASH CORE ONLINE. A Stryder with a triple threat would absolutely shred most TF2 Titans.
GoldPicard Are you sure about that? Take the damage and health of everything in tf1 and now you have it in tf2 units.
I feel like for 40k you should have used the tau as they are like the battlesuit faction and they dont get mentioned nearly as much as the imperium and orks so it would be kinda refreshing and new to some people.
thats because blue space commies are ghey :D
@@SPAMLANWALKER well said battle brother
@@lordinquisitorpeter8221 there is only one good tau, who's the only tau to use his mech to fight with a big sword for the sake of glorious melee
Tau is mostly gae
I first discovered WH40k from the ps2 game WarHammer 40k Fire Warrior. So already I have a Tau bias 😂
I mean... dreadnaughts are kinda like mechs.
Actually that's probably the most comparable, a lot of people are saying an Imperial Night but they would still destroy any of these. the dreadnought is probably the only one they could even put up a fight against and I still think they would win.
@@IdaKicker dreadnoughts are more like weaponized tombs
This video made me play some good ol titanfall
Is that game still available?
@@Mercenary-st8ge Yup, Titanfall 2 Ultimate Edition is 15 dollars last time I checked.
@@ordohereticus5530Oh okay. Would you recommend both 1 and 2? Is there anyway I can buy the game without making an account on EA?
@@Mercenary-st8ge Definently 2. Its better in almost every way (graphics, customization, movement etc) and it actually still has people who play it unlike 1 where you can't really find games anymore.
TF1 IS STILL ALIVE. Five years and 41 days playtime later I'm still playin it on my XB1 and still making people salty because if you can believe it, there are STILL new people coming on and of course they get salty when they meet those of us who are TF1 veterans of when it was out back on the 360.
talking about Mechs and not slotting in Battletech is... dissapointing
Word!
As a fan of 40k I think you messed up by including the titans rather then the battlesuits of 40k. A better comparison for the other weapons would be the bane of tabletop players and wrath of the tabletop, the Imperial knight. The other weapons platforms were around the same scale. And that doesn't include the other platforms of around the same scale from the other races.
Also Battletech would like a word about Mechs. The humble Steiner scout lance would have been more appropriate a comparison then 40k.
Are you not forgetting the most magnificent and glorious of all small(-ish) scale imperial walkers, the mighty DREADKNIGHT, designed by SUPREME GRAND MASTER KALDOR DRAIGO himself?!
I can agree with that, there's also the blueberries' Riptide and Stormsurge that could have been fairer competitors in this. Or, Emperor forbid, that newfangled XV95 Ghostkeel...
@@marcustulliuscicero5443 The baby carrage bot?
Michael Finlayson I think the Tau Battlesuits would have been better for this video. Honestly i find the mechs of the Imperium rather unwieldy. I’ve destroyed quite a few while playing with Orks (though Necrons are the best just saying).
Yeah... Looking at the general sizes of the competition, I would say Knights are still a tad too heavyweight. Only Halo on this list had anything even remotely close, and that was an artillery mech....
I would point more toward dreadnaughts, dreadknights and the newbie Armigers for the imperium and battlesuits of the Tau in this list...
For 40k, I think you needed to use the Tau as the comparison, not the imperium in this case, if we want to consider scale differences.
Or include the imperium and talk about imperial knights.
🤓🤓
Pretty sure tau riptide would pulverize all of these in 1v1
@@Jebu911definitely. Even a Broadsider could possibly do that as well
Spartans vs N7 or Pilots (Titanfall) and UNSC Marines vs System Alliance Marines
UNSC wins every time
Spartans are two powerful for them, id compare N7 and pilots to ODSTs
my guess is N7 < SPARTAN and UNSC marines < SA marines
100% American Buffalo Spartans would crush all of them if pilots don’t have titans. N7 vs pilots might be interesting as one has superior defense and weapons while the other has superior speed, mobility and tactics
Spartans Win almost every time. The Pilots are F@*#$! and the N7s, well it depends on if they have the bull@#$* space magic or not.
IF the N7 is a biotic they win, if the Pilot has a Titan they win, however even if the Pilot has a Titan the Spartan will win if they have an AI.
If they all have full capabilities then the Spartan will win as the Pilot will lose his advantage to the Spartan who will then kill both the Pilot and the N7.
Spartan + Titan FTW.
No pacific rim mention? I never saw any of the mechs on this list use a ship as a baseball bat.
slayerlord007 jaegers would crush all the other mechs except maybe 40K mechs.
@@flameconvoy7424 "maybe"
Depends on the scale of these mechs, as 40k imperial knights roughly match pacific rim, but IMO titans, even scout titans, would literally mop the floor with the pacific rim mechs
@@flameconvoy7424 "maybe"
@ivan ivanovitch ivanovsky Maybe 1v1 a Jaegar would stop a warhound, if the Jaegar got the drop on it and stayed within melee range (if the titan isn't equiped with a CCW). Anything bigger it would either be eradicated at range, by escorting titans/skittari, or by the titans own close in defense systems.
There a lot of other Mechs in 40k that are a lot more comparable to the other factions in this video, Imperial Guard Sentinels, Tau battlesuits, Eldar War Walkers for example.
Could of said they had to be single pilot/crew vehicles (which all Imperial Titans are not, they have one Princeps and at least two Moderati plus servitors/techpreiests etc)
wouldn't really say sentinels are mech more with the current role of walkers a more suitable comparison would be Knights but none the less they'd still win all engagements.
Imperial Knights and wraith knights would also i think be more comparable.
@@ummdustry5718 Imperial knights are piloted by a single human and wraith knights useually have a single liveing pilote. dreadnoughts have a single cripple as a pilote and wraithguard and wraith lords have single souls as pilotes. and of cause tau battle suites and what ever orks have like killer kans. tyranid biotitans also work.
and all tryanid beasts of dreadnought size and larger like carnifexes
Let's not forget the skiitarii infantry that comes along with a legion
could you please do a "wich sci-fi faction has the best emperor"? It would be so cool
Easy, Galactic Empire, The "God Emperor" can't even get out of his chair after he dies, Palp just respawns.
Forgetting the granddaddy of them all. BATTLETECH! I really would love to see your thoughts on clan wolf's forces at the battle of Tukayyid on Hoth, first attacking the rebels, then holding against the empire.
Ooooo!
@@prophetofbeans6781 I know right? What would happen if a couple AT-ATs went up against a star of Timberwolves?
@@lightfootjpauls Or a star of Direwolves
Gundam is the true grandaddy of them all.
@@collins.4380 I would actually say that against AT AT's, a Star of Timber Wolf mechs would be better than a star of Dire Wolf mechs.
We know that the AT AT has a lot of forward facing firepower, but lacks maneuverability and firing arcs. They're also super slow.
Dire Wolves are too vulnerable to a frontal assault from AT AT's. They would basically trade blows, and sure a star of Dire Wolves might actually win against the 3 (or so) AT AT's we saw in ESB, but they would take heavy losses. I'd suspect that at least 3 Dire Wolves would get destroyed.
Now, a Star of Timber Wolves, on the other hand, are quite a bit faster. They can flank the AT AT's and unleash their firepower unharassed.
If we have to also deal with the supporting Imperial forces (AT ST's and infantry), then things get more muddled for the Clan forces, unless they too have supporting forces.
I think the Clans would still win more often then not - but they would take pretty heavy losses if they have to deal with the supporting Imperial forces.
I feel that the Titanfall Titans are indeed better than any mech that the Halo universe has come up with. Titans fill both specialized roles and are flexible enough to fill a more unconventional role. Not only that but since there is a neural link between pilot and titan, the titan will move and act alot faster and more fluidly than any Mantis. Add the skill of an individual pilot, that literaly a single pilot can turn the tide of a battle, and you have yourself one powerful killing machine.
Geo Del are we gonna count the first Spartan armor suit as a mech? Kinda was
@@lucashenry5024 Well it wasnt made as a mech...more of an exo suit at that point. I wouldnt really count any of the Spartan armor. Even so, I feel Titanfall still has the best mechs in the form of Titans, most notably the Vanguard class Titan.
What about that mech from Halo: Legends?
Mantis does allow a neural link between its pilot, IIRC. Not just for the Spartans either, every member of the UNSC can pilot the Mantis, given the expertise. It's the same way how Scorpions can be operated with just one driver.
Also, do Goliaths not get a part in this? That massive Railgun looks bigger than the ones on the Cobra.
You right Bt World Kick ass
WARHAMMER 40K HAS ALL THE BEST TOYS. TITANS - STRATEGIC VALUE: ABSOLUTE
I am suprised you talked about the Imperium's mechs instead of the T'au, a faction that is quite literally ALL MECH. Our scouts? Mech suits. Our Comanders? Mech suits. Our artillery? Mech suits. Our Boarding craft? Mech suits. Our largest land veicles? Mech suits.
It also would have made for a more interesting analysis, as the T'au are not as extensivly covered as the Imperium, and it would have given the other francises a fighting chance.
Then Imperial Knights exist, which are basically the mechs of the Imperium
Rather than Titans, which are just tower sized weapons platforms with legs and void shields
We don't talk about the space communists >:cc
@@adorablecenturion8436 this is heresy i am inquistor kenobi i heard the word space communist and tau said and am here to deliver the EMPEROR's truth.
We talk about the tau, but not on family friendly sites
Fuck you commie weeb, for the glory of the necrontir!
Why Imperial titans why not imperia knights?
Arttu Honkasalo Knights would still be pretty powerful, though not unbeatable. I’d say a group of around 3-5 titans from titan fall can beat the mainline knights, and a single Titanfall titan can beat an Armiger class Knight
@@imperialguardsmen8543 but still more reasonable than flat out titan 😂 but true.... I feel that a even a veteran astartes could beat all three tho not easy.....
He said that he wants to focus on the best of every universe so an Imperator Titan is "quite" superior than an Imperial Knight, even when the Imperial Knight would do the top a bit more interesting, compare an Imperial titan, even the smallest with those "upgraded power armor" suits are just a joke...
the smallest titan available is about 5-6 times bigger than the largest imperial knight
Imperator Titan, God Machine of the Imperium. Says all it needs to, Eck.
Dude how can you do a mech comparison and leave out battletech? Also 40k has no business being on this list large titans carry warship grade weapons. None of your other universes are anywhere close to that kind of power by comparison.
I agree that Warhammer 40k doesn't belong on this list, or any of the list really. It is meant to just be over the top, where as the others are meant to be realistic. It isn't fair to anything else to compare it to 40k.
@@coriusfarinprimarchofthese7007
Makes me feel bad for Warhammer fans. They never get included in things like this because it's not as well known as the others and those who know about it and are not die hard fans write it off because of how over the top powerful it is.
true plus with most of these lists if warhammer 40k is mentoined you know 40k wins, its a universe thats in a league of its own
*Coughs in gundam* beam rifles in the UC are comparable to (and in some cases more powerful than) warship cannons.
.... then of course theres the galaxy reset button: The Turn A gundam. damned thing has the power to eliminate ALL technology other than its self and what ever its pilot has on him/ her. when i say all technology, what i mean is ALL technology.... that is to say everything MADE. paper, clothes, pencils, spears.. absolutely EVERYTHING, gone.
.. probably the only thing that could defeat anything 40k tbh. the damned things weapon has a radius greater than the milkyway galaxy too.. soo.. lol.
Imperial Knights belong in this list, Eckharts should've put one of them in place of AN IMPERATOR TITAN
Titans are just giant weapons platforms
TITANFALL in an Eckharts video!
Bt from Titanfall. Hands down best mech
goodest boi
BT-7274 is the best of boys. I will voluntarily build him up again piece by piece.
if he was an ion titan he'd be even better
@@YangusCool he can be any titan.... that's why he's so good
Death Dealer you sir are correct.
What about the Imperial Knight? 😂
O yes..... Change Warhammer 40k to Imperiun of Mankind since... All warhammer faction have their titans....
Nice work btw.... 😂
King Crab in the Battletech franchise: Am I a joke to you?
The atlas AWS 80, mad cat and annihilator yes
Compared to Warhammer, yes
@@ferrusmanus184 Laughing in a Gundam.
@@pirotess2 We have titans with guns that are wider than a gundam is tall. Let that sink in.
@@ferrusmanus184 no matter how power of weapons if that can't hit. And how big of a WH40K Titans? I remember that Warlord-class titan around 30~33m, Imperator-class titan is 55m tall but really slow with no close-range weapons while gundam tall around 20m and much more mobilize.
I personally feel imperial knights are closer to the scale and power of what the other universes can field, I feel in cases like these its logical to compare kind to kind comparting an imperator vs a titanfall mech feels like comparing the strength of a star destroyer to a CR90 corvette, I personally still think 40k would win if you had chosen to exclude the titan class mechs and only considered imperial knights but I do see arguments for why the titanfall or halo mechs could take it down, also something to consider is how large a formation hey usually get deployed in, titanfall is usually 6 v 6 if i recall so that would be a lance of 6, halo I have no idea on, mass effect again falls behind with its single mech lances and 40k usually only fields 3 knights per lance, and in a 2 v 1 scenario between titanfall mechs and an imperial knight I'm not sure who would win personally
Rank that up to the entire IMC against a Titan in 40K, yeah it may take it down. Im a little skeptical because I don't know MUCH about 40K, but everything falls eventually.
A Doggo Friend, look it up. One has to look at the pure “wtf” that 40k produces. Like holy shit.
@@vanguardiano7309 when some titans fire bigger bullets then the size of titanfalls dropships form their miniguns at the same fire rate as a normal minigun with shielding that can withstand planet cracking bombardments I have a hard time feeling they would win
bowmanruto I’d say the Tau wold be better for this than the imperium with how many different battle suits they have
Seeing as the wh40k wiki on emperor class Titans (the largest class) gives the height as 46 meters at the smallest to 140 meters at the largest? Yeah the 40k fanboys give completely ridiculous capabilities for fascism porn
When I think of Mechs I think Mechwarrior/Battle tech.
"For The Duke! For House Davion!"🌟
Mech assault 1 and 2
"Inner-Sphere barbarian, call your name, family, and unit designation."
@@Kissamiess I am Star Captain Dredhawk From Clan Wolf Beta Galaxy (The Shadow Wolves). I am no Freebirth Scum but a Trueborn of Clan Wolf.
Should W40k have been the titans? I feel Imperial Knights would have been more on par with the rest of the candidates on this list. Most Imperial Knights were piloted by a single individual. They carried large amounts of firepower, close quarters weapons, and shields on some occasions, but were only a few stories tall. Titans on the other hand, were almost never piloted by one person and are more akin to large walking weapons platforms than the mechs of Titanfall who share the same name. Titans were also very rare to see on the battlefield compared to the other factions. They're considered a highly valuable military and religious resource and would only be deployed if absolutely necessary. Emperor class titans are so rare because the Imperium doesn't actually know how to make them anymore. Knights were smaller, and more readily available with innumerable worlds being solely dedicated to knightly houses or the mechanicum that builds and maintains them.
Imperial Knights still would mop the floor with everything else though...
On that note knights are also kind of rare the most numerous in percentage would be the tau withe the riptide and ghostkeel wich still would vaporize the other mechs on this list.... heck even crisis suits could give them a run for their money
@@Blutwind True, but things complicate when I comes to xenos. If he used a weapons platform like titans, then should not have also gone with scarabs for halo?
The game "Space Marine" is first about defending a Reaver Titan, making drama about that... When you know how Lucius Pattern or Imperator class Titans are stronger than multiple Reavers, it really is stunning.
The most important part is not how rare they are, but how difficult it is to pilot them, usually multiple "pilots" are trained and die one after the other trying to control the Titan, having to be one and stable with the spirit of the machine... which is hard since it's forgotten technology.
@@ipatchymakouli415 Only adds to my point :)
WH40k titans in a nutshell: If you don't go to church, church will go to you. With guns.
Battletech Atlas? Highlander? King Crab? OMEGA?? *LEVIATHAN?????*
Honestly the fast heavies might be the most impressive thing Battletech has to offer, 75 tons of mech capable of 80+kmh that's otherwise pretty well protected and armed would tear apart the more static forces in most other sci-fi universes.
Give me a good old Shadow Hawk any day (Fang of the Sun Dougram OG design not 2010 pos)
@@brothersgt.grauwolff6716 or its Japanese Battletech variant.
The Collegia Titanica is not a part of the Imperial Guard/army. The titans of the Collegia Titanica are under the direct control of the Adeptus Mechanicus though their support may be lended to the Imperial Guard on such occasions that they are needed. However a Titan shall never be part of the standard Imperial Guard order of battle, their place is at the center of Adeptus Mechanicus Formations where their machine spirits can be properly cared for and worshiped and rather than trust beings as mundane as guardsmen to safeguard these hallowed constructs, the Mechanicum will insist on scores of their most elite Skitarii to guard them.
Just to Further the your Explanation,
Imperial Knights however Could be working Directly With Imperial guard, If not their own Retainers/arms-men then what ever battle group they are a part of. On the same note some houses work directly with space marines or alongside the Mechanics depending on their oaths.
@Random Imperial Guard Blasphemy! After we found you an STC for knives you expect us to find a way to strap a knife onto a rifle and then think of a way to strap a massive and ineffective one onto a God-Machine?!? Who do you think we are? Hereteks!? No, you shall be content with your Knives, Chainswords and should we find that it would not insult the God-Machines we might consider producing a chainsword large enough to be equipped by a Titan. Now in the meantime take this Lasrifle go to a warzone and die like a good Guardsman!
@Random Imperial GuardOnly if it pleases the God-Machine! And death to the Xenos Scum!
Titan fall 2
North star
Primary: PLASMA RAIL GUN!
Ah, a fellow Northstar main?
Shows Gundam
Me: *literally dies inside*
Talking about 'Mechs and BATTLETECH is NOT in this video?!... i am disappointed in you Eckharts, you really let me down here >_
Too bad kid
And no Gundam either this is unacceptable!!!
Battletech is the OG mech franchise.... It's a shame it never really took off like other stuff from around the same time. All the factions in play and the timeline after the Clans invade make it way more compelling than Star Wars, which has pitted essentially the same two forces against each other since it's creation and played with the same stale tropes.
Make sure to leave a dislike
@@g3n3raljo41 Well of course i still enjoyed watching the video the comment was mostly meant as a joke however i do hope Eckharts does decide to do a redoo with including Battletech in it at some point or better yet do a Battletech focused video at some point in the future.
*STANDBY FOR TITANFALL!*
Hope yal have found respect to give to my big metal bois, Titans.
"All Praise be the Omnissiah!"
@@brothersgt.grauwolff6716 01001001 00100000 01110100 01101000 01101001 01101110 01101011 00100000 01111001 01101111 01110101 00100000 01101101 01100101 01100001 01101110 01110100 00100000 00100010 01000001 01101100 01101100 00100000 01010000 01110010 01100001 01101001 01110011 01100101 00100000 01100010 01100101 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01001111 01101101 01101110 01101001 01110011 01110011 01101001 01100001 01101000 00100001 00100010 11101111 10111011 10111111
The 40k or titanfall?
@@nonname1239 40k
@@nonname1239
Boi look at his name and picture, think about it.
"Which sci-fi mech is best?" - COMPLETELY ignores all mech themed sci-fis except for one.
Man I gotta say, it's a really misleading title.
It's a little weird to talk about sci-fis that for the most part don't focus on mechs or even have very many.
He's not very educated on 40K I think
So
He probably didn't consider Imperial Knights lmao
I know. No Gundam, no Battletech. Heck, there are mechas that could absolutely shitstomp 40k, like Gurren Lagann for example. It just seems like a weird choice of franchises.
@@ASNS117Zero He probably isnt familiar with those franchises, and they arent really what his viewerbase comes to watch. Halo, mass effect, star wars, etc. are his bread and butter so of course he's gonna focus on those. Titanfall is a bit random I guess.
Also, I dont get the impression he has any interest in focusing on any sort of anime content.
You compared mechs and skipped Battletech? Yet you included Halo and Mass Effect?
Blasphemy!
*HERESY!*
Blood of Kerensky, what a dezgra video!
@@vizerandevir6422 I blame Catalyst game labs.
Or Gundam.
I would have put Mech Warrior in here
I was also excpecting Gundams in this.
@@HEYabbot Gundam, Cores (from Armored Core), Wanzers (from Front Mission), Hawken, Battle Engine Aquila, Jehuty/Anubis (from Zone of the Enders), Skell mechs (Xenoblade), any of the Metal Gears. There are tons of mechs to be compared, and I'd have loved to see some of these from the big mech series be included.
@@Darkkai3 I agree with you immensely. But the Metal Gears would probably be the lowest because they can be destroyed by ONE DUDE. Hell! One dude took on three metal gear Ray's by himself!
No Macross?
@@dazigolding5814 Metal Gears are very powerful, snake just win because metal gear rex have a fragile spot make purposely by the creator. Metal Gear Rex is a nuclear warhead launcher with legs.
i think a more fair comparison in 40k would be to compare the smaller knight titans which are sized more like the titanfall titans. the space marine dreadnoughts are also similar in size to the atlas from mass effect. good vid
Dreadnoughts are about 17' tall, titanfall mechs are about 20' and knights are about 35'
I didn't even think about that.
And of course T'au battlesuits, Eldar wraithbone constructs and Ork mechs.
Necroledo of course, but ecks usually focuses on imperium units
The thing is, Imperial Knights would still mop the floor with other shit.
No Battletech, Armored Core, or Front Mission? I mean, excluding Gundams are obvious as they can be stupid OP, but still.
To be fair... Armored Core's Mechs can also be overpowered compared to some of these (Minus Obvious WH40K)
No Macross?
I saw a video where they compared Gundam with WH40K and it was ridiculous xD
They didn't mention the Titan class tho but still it was hilarious...
@@slenderuncut1821 your talking about Commisar Gamza right? I will say the Gundam video is the only one where his assessment of Gundam's survivability in 40K is inaccurate.
@@barrybend7189 well all in all its all just fanfic xD
Replicators vs a Unified Star Wars universe (392nd try now, *_I._** WILL NEEEEVER EEEVER GIVE UP!!!)*
yeah eck do it man
This will be a thing
@@thatguybrody4819 one day man one day
I see you realy hate star wars universe for put in to this meat grinder XD
@@Ballagorn_Ironblood it will definitely put a huge hole in their universe
Now, as a massive 40k fan, I feel that going to Titan class walkers are indeed the most powerful out of the mechs you used in this list, I do feel that they are indeed on a completely different level or even a different classification.
A better comparison would be either Dreadnoughts/Helbrutes from the Imperium or Chaos respectively or even the T'au XV8 Crisis battle suit. These are more generic and single-manned vehicles which are more in line with more common sci-fi mech type units. That being said, I think that the Dreadnought might lose to a Titanfall titan depending on the armour penetration capabilities of it's weapon. The XV-8 Crisis suit would still top the list, having better firepower and mobility than a Titanfall titan.
A more even comparison would be those new heavy dreadnoughts, or the Contemptor pattern. The Wraithknight and Riptide are also good xeno choices, and the Riptide matches most closely in type to the other mechs on this list.
@@scytheseven9173 I thought the Riptide would be a bit too big considering it is about 3 timez the size of a Crisis suit. A Contemptor would be under the Dreadnought catagory and I do believe that, rules ignored, it is a much better dreadnought than the standard box variant.
Alright, then the XV95 Ghostkeel battlesuit. That's a better size, but the XV8 is too small compared to the others.
@@scytheseven9173 I thought an XV-8 was the same size as a Titanfall titan.
No, it's only about twice the height of a Fire Warrior. The XV9 Hazard or XV95 Ghostkeel are closer in size to a Titanfall Titan
Everybody gangsta till the churches start walking and killing whole armies...
If you were to ban multi-crewed mechs from this Factions Compared video, it would leave WH40k with the Imperial Knight as their best mech, which to me would place it in the same three-way brawl as Titanfall and Halo far far FAR more evenly. Imperial Knights, while quite potent bruisers with a flexible arsenal in the majority of cases, are still not a clear cut winner over either the #2 or #3 mechs, and do have deficiencies that the mechs can overcome, either in a group setting or 1v1.
@@internetzenmaster8952 But that's Orks for ya. While everyone else is having fun with their cannons and lasers the Orks weaponize the hell out of the Gravity Gun from Half Life 2
*halo mech loads it's main weapons*
*Knight from warhammer revs up the three bus long chainsaw and cannon as long as a jumbo jet*
As soon as I saw that 40k was going to be included i knew it was immediately going to win, but it's strange that you went with titans which are leagues above the other competitors, and not use Imperial knights, space marine dreadnoughts, or at least Tau battlesuits, since those are much closer in scale and power to the rest
Using a Titan against these other mechs is like putting a puma in a cage fight, with house rats or a middle school boxing match then put a US marine in.
It should not have been done.
@@marrqi7wini54 ^ this
You forgot about the knights in warhammer 40000
“There is no one Titan that is objectively more powerful than the others”
Vanguards: Am I a joke to you?
Maybe do Gundam at some point, I think it'd go over well, seeing as more mech stands at 84% of the vote at the time of this comment being posted
Atlas from the Battletech universe vs. AT-AT
Really depends on the type of Atlas, because it can either out range the AT-AT and simply rain down heavy fire, out run the AT-AT and strafe it, or simply out last the AT-AT in a brawl.
@@HawkTheRed, ASD7-D-A best bet it'll chew up the AT-AT in short order and still have ammo to spare cause it drops the LRM 20 for additional ammo storage for the rotary AC 6.
The AT-AT get shitstomped in a minute
The atlas will win easy
Best in my heart..... METAL GEAR REX 🔥
You can't talk mechs without including Mechwarrior or Battletech.
TBF, both of those are the same thing
Mechwarrior is the way to call a pilot of a battlemech in BattleTech franchise.
@Michael Fox Guys simple solution, edit comment and replace "or" with with a slash ( / )
I think the Imperial Knights would be a better fit here.
@@magnus9564 No. You have obviously not played titanfall. While the imperial knights are indeed powerful outfitted with power cannons and melta guns, the titanfall titans boast powerful weaponry as well as being much more maneuverable. Imagine an imperial titan shelling a titanfall titan, the latter stopping literally every projectile and then shooting it back all at once at the former.
@@savage7882 There are imperial knights the size of titans
@@savage7882 Magnetics don´t work on energy weapons (as melters or lasers)
Honorable mentions:
- X1-Alpha from Future Cop LAPD
- F.E.A.R
- Pacific Rim
- MechWarrior/Battletech
- Metal Gear Solid
- Code Geass
- Neon Genesis Evangelion
- Gundam
- Supreme Commander
- Command & Conquer (?)
Pat Labor
Full metal panic
Armored Core
Heavy Gear
Chrome hounds
@@blurwake Aw hell yeah! Armored Core is such an underrated series.
One word:
Battletech.
Mechwarrior
For Battletech, we just have to nominate the Timberwolf/Mad Cat. Mobility like a mech 25 tons lighter, firepower like another 25 tons heavier, maximum armor for its weight class. Add in the flexibility of Clan Omni technology, and you have a "jack of all trades" death machine that is exceptional by basically every metric relevant to combat.
Its only real weakness to speak of is its high price, the economics and logistics of using and supporting such a machine.
Pilots prepare for Titan- WHAT THE F&#! IS THAT?!
*Warhamer Titan Drops*
That could just crush the entire enemy army AND your army. No weapons needed.
Tbh I think you should have gone with imperial knights instead of titans for 40k. It would have been more balanced. They are the equivalent to the rest of the mechs from the other factions in this video. Titans are just in another class
The granddaddy of all mechs( real robot wise ) is Gundam but Echartsladder don't go to SEED as every mech not stated as an ace unit are total trash. Plus the mechs in SEED have worse battery life than most diesel subs from WW2.
Barry Bend Seed was fine, Seed Destiny...it was beyond lacking. I’d take Mikazuki Augus and the Barbatos any day of the week though. If you remember btw, nuclear power was banned in Seed, so yeah
@@lucashenry5024 yeah but the Coordinators/ naturals seems a bit too black and white of a conflict even by Gundam standards. Also Zaft is more strategically inept that Zeon( who I give a pass as poetically they mirror Nazi Germany) oh and every antagonist except Artrun is basically Jerid Mesa.
Gundam Build Divers has nice furries
@@barrybend7189 seed suits operating on batteries is the writer's answer to the horrifying implication of using nuclear powered mechas in terrestrial environment. The damage would be HUGE...well sometimes. This lead to the next point in that the nuke MS doesn't consistently explode into nuke fireballs. I mean, some got slash/shot with a beam weapon directly in torso and yet...small explosion?
Nuke ms in Seed also tend to bite them in the ass when people survive them point blank lol.
@@secondsein7749 well the choice of batteries alone is lazy. I think a better power system is Hydrogen/Oxygen power cells( Gundam 00's Flag and Teirien series MS use) which can be used with batteries as an alternative to nuclear power.
WH40K: (Weaponizes a damn church)
For 40k, I think it would be more even if you used Dreadnoughts, since they are more of a mech. But then we would need to bring out Contemptor-Galatus Dreadnought, so the result would be the same
Derp
A United Warhammer40k universe vs The Forerunner...:3
Forerunner
Forerunners stomp most modern day 40k factions with ease as proven on forum's they can fight on par with the war in heaven necrons or old one's.
Forerunners wouldn't last a day.
...both would either a) murder each other instantly instantly or b) get locked in an eternal struggle unless forerunners get attacked by the flood or they use halo rings to annihilate the warhammer 40k peoples.
Dr_President9 agreed.
40k normally stomps everything, but the forerunners have such mastery of time, space and reality that it all becomes a moot point that their opponent out numbers them and can summon daemons.
The only chances the 40k universe have would be the direct intervention of the most Powerful Warp entities such as The Emperor and the Chaos gods, or the weird time travel shannanigans from Orikan the Diviner.
Even then, the Warp entities are much like the Flood. Without sentient beings to feed their power they become nothing, so a Halo activation would possibly stop even them.
I would give it 7/10 to the Forerunners.
I wish you had included the Battletech universe in this, their mechs are freaking awesome!