What a GREAT game. So well played by all three evils, all of them sold the Lunatic in different ways: Claire claiming SW, Daniel "letting" himself be strung along as Marionette Exorcist, Amy Rose orchestrating whispers and star passing. I loved all four living players voting on the same player with confidence.
I think that's the best I've ever seen lunatic work. Also I think Sam lying to Daniel probably cemented in his mind that Daniel was good, because Daniel was the one being "deceived" 😅
Jams, that was brilliant. Well done! As a ST with a new group, I tell my players that I wake them up if the script says so, regardless of no information. It gives the UT and others the confirmation that they didn’t die in the night.
Being given to the Lunatic as one of their minions when you're actually a God Father is always such a treat. Sure, the rules say you're my demon's Lunatic, but I'm the one who gets to feed you info, scheme with you, build entirely made up worlds with you. Together, we can secure the win for the evil team, and I'm so sorry you don't get to share the victory with us. 😺
I just noticed another tiny detail that probably contributed to how well stringing along the lunatic went: because Sam told Daniel he was the mario, and because all the evils were next to each other so that Amy could pass it along to Claire, Claire knew Sam had a mario and was able to ask him about it. Granted, we don't see the whole conversation, so Sam might've let slip that there was a marionette, but there's a good chance that Claire already knowing about it really helped convince him that he was the real demon.
I’ve been low key obsessed with Emerald since that one quantum mutant game. Suuuuper happy to see him pop up here. And a great lunatic setup. I’m excited to see how this goes!
JC: "loads of worlds, where we haven't killed an evil yet"... when the ONLY 2 dead players got killed in the night (and there is no vig on the script!, so no reason for the demon to kill a minion) 🤣😂🤣
Richie with two dead evils, a fact that he has been told by the Oracle, along with additional information on Claire being evil fron the undertaker. "We've only killed good players and we're about to go to sleep with 3 evil players."
I think that on final day the Claire, Amy Rose, Lorinda evil team was also viable, although it would involve Jams making weirder Storyteller decisions than either the truth or the Richie No Dashii world. As Hobbe would have a true 2 on Amy Rose and Claire and Daniel would be poisoned the entire game. It would however involve giving JC true info on Richie despite being No Dashii poisoned. The Richie, Claire, and Lorinda world was simply so perfect though, including all of Evil's bluffs. I'm pretty sure nothing could disprove it and Richie is sus enough to help sell it. It's also almost certainly for the best that Daniel broke Sam's bubble when he did, as nothing explains the Oracle 2 if Sam was the real demon
What a GREAT game. So well played by all three evils, all of them sold the Lunatic in different ways: Claire claiming SW, Daniel "letting" himself be strung along as Marionette Exorcist, Amy Rose orchestrating whispers and star passing. I loved all four living players voting on the same player with confidence.
I think that's the best I've ever seen lunatic work. Also I think Sam lying to Daniel probably cemented in his mind that Daniel was good, because Daniel was the one being "deceived" 😅
This was the only time I actually saw the lunatic work. They played Sam like a fiddle. Very impressive to see evil pull that one off.
@@someguy9164Link?
Jams, that was brilliant. Well done!
As a ST with a new group, I tell my players that I wake them up if the script says so, regardless of no information. It gives the UT and others the confirmation that they didn’t die in the night.
I'm surprised Sam didn't tell Jams that kiwis are flightless birds. The mental image of one soaring through the air is hilarious.
Yes I also cracked up because kiwis don't fly!
Imagined it had been catapulted or something 😂
@@justicedinosaur7302 That reminded me of animation called "Kiwi!"
This is a masterpiece of a game. Beautiful work
This game is such a great showcase of the power of both Lunatic and Marionette. I loved it.
Great game… fantastic last sequence from Daniel. Also a great setup for actually making a lunatic work (which doesn’t happen often).
masterpiece lunatic game
probably the best ive ever seen
Absolutely brilliant. One of my favorite watches.
Being given to the Lunatic as one of their minions when you're actually a God Father is always such a treat. Sure, the rules say you're my demon's Lunatic, but I'm the one who gets to feed you info, scheme with you, build entirely made up worlds with you. Together, we can secure the win for the evil team, and I'm so sorry you don't get to share the victory with us. 😺
I just noticed another tiny detail that probably contributed to how well stringing along the lunatic went: because Sam told Daniel he was the mario, and because all the evils were next to each other so that Amy could pass it along to Claire, Claire knew Sam had a mario and was able to ask him about it. Granted, we don't see the whole conversation, so Sam might've let slip that there was a marionette, but there's a good chance that Claire already knowing about it really helped convince him that he was the real demon.
Watched about 20 of these games so far, the Daniel/Sam conversation is up there with the best moments!
Sam is so good at evil, he probably would have won for good on accident if not for the last minute reveal.
Crushed by a large rock ❌
Rocked by a large crush ✔
I’ve been low key obsessed with Emerald since that one quantum mutant game. Suuuuper happy to see him pop up here. And a great lunatic setup. I’m excited to see how this goes!
JC: "loads of worlds, where we haven't killed an evil yet"... when the ONLY 2 dead players got killed in the night (and there is no vig on the script!, so no reason for the demon to kill a minion) 🤣😂🤣
Richie with two dead evils, a fact that he has been told by the Oracle, along with additional information on Claire being evil fron the undertaker. "We've only killed good players and we're about to go to sleep with 3 evil players."
Amazing game, thanks for the upload!
'Clockroach poker' -JC
"Fun, niche things that you shouldn't do" is what Blood on the Clocktower is all about
I think that on final day the Claire, Amy Rose, Lorinda evil team was also viable, although it would involve Jams making weirder Storyteller decisions than either the truth or the Richie No Dashii world. As Hobbe would have a true 2 on Amy Rose and Claire and Daniel would be poisoned the entire game. It would however involve giving JC true info on Richie despite being No Dashii poisoned. The Richie, Claire, and Lorinda world was simply so perfect though, including all of Evil's bluffs. I'm pretty sure nothing could disprove it and Richie is sus enough to help sell it. It's also almost certainly for the best that Daniel broke Sam's bubble when he did, as nothing explains the Oracle 2 if Sam was the real demon
This is one of my favourite games of all time, and No Dashii is my least favourite demon.
I feel like I always see Sam be dealt the Lunatic rather often
predict: good wins
Whats all this passing nominations and defence about?