How can you breach visa conditions, get a suspended sentence, and then go and breach again, blow the 1 year minimum, how about a 1 way air ticket out of the country.
This is utterly absurd. There appears to be a wilful undermining of the intention of the legislation. Who were the “experts” the police consulted? It’s good the AFP have a good relationship with them, but the purpose of the legislation is paramount, and should not be undermined by public servants. Thanks James for your attention to this.
There was supposed to be a one year mandatory sentence set by parliament but there was something in the over-riding legislation that gave the Judge power to ignore it - and he did and then there was a subsequent visa breach. That judge needs to go back to jidge school.
This is abhorrent, to know they are not even held accountable under our Laws, this sends a clear message to all , sneak into Australia, and no law applies. The chair shows good reason why she shouldnt be there, unskilled and in a position due to sex, not skill
What do you EXPECT JUST ANOTHER FEMALE IN THE ROOM, WHO IS NOT QUALIFIED FOR THE POSITION.The Majority of Male's today are USELESS IN THIS GOVERNMENT.HALF PUBLIC SERVANT'S NUMBERS.
Thank you senator Paterson for doing your job. The obstruction by highly paid, over- rated public servants whom you've previously questioned has been nauseating. Also that of the ALP. As I heard Mike Jefferies say on 2GB not long ago, such ambitious people "fight like weasels on meth" to advance above others up the public service greasy pole, then do SFA once there.
Keep up the great work, hopefully they actually scamper with actual results after this, to think if YOU didn't bring this up it would have stayed unhinged.
INDIVIDUAL MAGISTRATE'S AND OFFICERS DETERMINE THE OUT COME OF MOST OF THESE REPEAT OFFENDERS. Show us their Bank Accounts $$$$$$ We know who are the repeat OFFENDERS.
James good to see you hard at work for the best interests for Australians, can't believe you have to check Australian law/policies are being enforced. Personal judgement not minimum standards and benchmarks that's our law WTF.
The State in which the Commonwealth matter is heard has no jurisdiction. The State Court should be closed then reopened as a Commonwealth or Federal Court and it deals with that legislation. Indeed, the very reason for closing then reopening is to avoid this multiple agency conglomeration
Such bizarre laws: so imagine as an Australian citizen I apply for an immigration visa and just break laws I get a get out of jail card. WTF is happening to our country.
Its a tough one. On the other hand, 75% have not reoffended and are now more likely to add to society through tax rather than such a drain through incarceration. Our criminal system will process the reoffenders, hopefully severely. These members of the police force are not to blame and a credit to our society. And so is Senator James Paterson. Unfortunately there have been victims who I hope are at least compensated throughout this mess, which Senator Paterson is right to look to the opposing Minister for at the very least, education, support and training, and if necessary, the opposing Minister's job if negligence persists.
Every department in this country is a complete failure if we put Australian judges back in control we may have a chance for the laws of this country to be used
Was It the African guy claiming to be indigenous that got bail?? 🤣🤣🤣 I'm sorry but this country is a joke. We're becoming like Canada - all woke and no sense.
Should we have confidence in these people that they will ever be able or willing to protect us? OMG give the job to someone who is competent and not corrupt! Great job Senator Patterson! We need more people like you in parliament!
Great job James
Thank you Senator James Paterson.
This is a fantastic exposé in all the right ways, kudos Senator Paterson
How can you breach visa conditions, get a suspended sentence, and then go and breach again, blow the 1 year minimum, how about a 1 way air ticket out of the country.
Couldn’t agree more…
Do five km over the limit you get in more trouble,this really is a joke
You Should be In Charge of This Department .
Awesome work Senator Paterson
His a little ripper
This is utterly absurd.
There appears to be a wilful undermining of the intention of the legislation.
Who were the “experts” the police consulted?
It’s good the AFP have a good relationship with them, but the purpose of the legislation is paramount, and should not be undermined by public servants.
Thanks James for your attention to this.
There was supposed to be a one year mandatory sentence set by parliament but there was something in the over-riding legislation that gave the Judge power to ignore it - and he did and then there was a subsequent visa breach. That judge needs to go back to jidge school.
@dfor50 ....I agree with you. The thing is, the judges are being paid off by the government.
All done by design.
Activist Judge
I'm a TaxPayer and get chased up for a late speeding fine, and threatened with court/ jail
You do not need to face these if you are an illegal immigrant criminal who never pay tax here!
James is straight up no mucking around his a leader in the making
This is abhorrent, to know they are not even held accountable under our Laws, this sends a clear message to all , sneak into Australia, and no law applies. The chair shows good reason why she shouldnt be there, unskilled and in a position due to sex, not skill
Yes this whole idea of filling all of these jobs with women because of their sex not their skill isn't really working out .
Thank heavens for James Paterson.
The chair shouldn't interrupt wasting time that could be in answering questions.
The Chair is a Labour Senator - a lame attempt to mitigate the exposure - thank Senator Patterson!
In America it's called a Filibuster, suprised we don't have a word for it here, seems to happen all the time.
Fantastic work Senator,all these detainees should be deported enough is enough ,
Five uniforms and three civilians and they still don't know what is going on.
The chairs a twit.
Absolutely
@@AA-oc9vu she is absolutely irritating every single time
What do you EXPECT JUST ANOTHER FEMALE IN THE ROOM, WHO IS NOT QUALIFIED FOR THE POSITION.The Majority of Male's today are USELESS IN THIS GOVERNMENT.HALF PUBLIC SERVANT'S NUMBERS.
Thankyou, it seems every time they run interference when the questions seem valid?
@@markward1473 correct! Plus, they are scared of James
The Chair should be VERY quiet . . . James needs to get an overall picture of the entire circumstances.
She seems competent.
I'm amazed.
Thank God.
The DPP lawyers avoid answering, though.
Not surprised.
Yes, great job Senator.
Totally incompetent instead of worrying about gender equity let’s get the best people for the job
All these people when they did not oppose the bail of such type criminals, have no consideration to the safety of Australians!
Why so lenient on immigrants!
FFS
Do your job!!!
Sack the chair person immediately
Theres no other way to take this other than that these "agencies" are incompetent. One hand doesnt know what the other hand is doing.
Thank you senator Paterson for doing your job.
The obstruction by highly paid, over- rated public servants whom you've previously questioned has been nauseating. Also that of the ALP.
As I heard Mike Jefferies say on 2GB not long ago, such ambitious people "fight like weasels on meth" to advance above others up the public service greasy pole, then do SFA once there.
Wow, at last somebody can answer questions
Again, as usual Senator Paterson makes these idiots look like fools. Sen Paterson for PM
This Chair is problematic!
11:02 here the chair is giving eyes to the woman AFP Assistant Com. as if to say " i will save you from the nasty Senator's questions". What a crock.
what is the chair's name?
Probably Karen
I hope Andrew Giles is watching this.
Keep up the great work, hopefully they actually scamper with actual results after this, to think if YOU didn't bring this up it would have stayed unhinged.
Thank you for fighting for justice for the citizens of this wonderful country
INDIVIDUAL MAGISTRATE'S AND OFFICERS DETERMINE THE OUT COME OF MOST OF THESE REPEAT OFFENDERS. Show us their Bank Accounts $$$$$$ We know who are the repeat OFFENDERS.
The overall recidivism rate in Australia is 60% the two year recidivism rate is 42%, another excellent non-story
This is like looking at a circus 🎪 how anyone of these incompetent people can keep there jobs is unbelievable? In the private sector you would be gone
James good to see you hard at work for the best interests for Australians, can't believe you have to check Australian law/policies are being enforced. Personal judgement not minimum standards and benchmarks that's our law WTF.
The State in which the Commonwealth matter is heard has no jurisdiction. The State Court should be closed then reopened as a Commonwealth or Federal Court and it deals with that legislation.
Indeed, the very reason for closing then reopening is to avoid this multiple agency conglomeration
Australian Federal Police my god. These guys haven’t got a clue how to answer questions. No wonder our country is fucked
We shoukd be abke to speak about these matters.
We would have all said NO
Who could have guessed that this would happen????
Fancy that!!!
Such bizarre laws: so imagine as an Australian citizen I apply for an immigration visa and just break laws I get a get out of jail card. WTF is happening to our country.
Its a tough one. On the other hand, 75% have not reoffended and are now more likely to add to society through tax rather than such a drain through incarceration. Our criminal system will process the reoffenders, hopefully severely. These members of the police force are not to blame and a credit to our society. And so is Senator James Paterson. Unfortunately there have been victims who I hope are at least compensated throughout this mess, which Senator Paterson is right to look to the opposing Minister for at the very least, education, support and training, and if necessary, the opposing Minister's job if negligence persists.
Its what the govt wants
Egads, what a shock...
Every department in this country is a complete failure if we put Australian judges back in control we may have a chance for the laws of this country to be used
Great work Senator Paterson, keep the pressure on.
Being in politics 5 minutes what qualifications has he got to question people with more qualifications than him is this invasion of people's identity
Was It the African guy claiming to be indigenous that got bail?? 🤣🤣🤣 I'm sorry but this country is a joke. We're becoming like Canada - all woke and no sense.
point of order in red jacket, go back to sleep.
Senator paterson seems to be the only politician concerned with Australian public safety
This woman!!!
How can opposition senator question people when not in government get back to working on you reume for the Australian taxpayer😮
Is it me or are the chairs always running interference?
Look at all those senior police. Government muppets
Stole my identity. Knew it.
The chair makes things harder not smoother
more women in resposible positions
No thanks
Fkn hell!!!!
Peter Dutton released plenty of detainees when he was minister, the Senator has a short and selective memory.
He also deported over 6000.
Should we have confidence in these people that they will ever be able or willing to protect us? OMG give the job to someone who is competent and not corrupt!
Great job Senator Patterson! We need more people like you in parliament!
Paper shufflers