You can make national language Tamil if you want I am dam sure no north Indian would fight on that Even if you impose Tamil Telugu Malayalam Kannada of anything I am happy to learn it without any debate .
@Minni Why not every language given the same status Malyayam,Kannada, Telugu, Tamul, Hindi,Bengali, Gujarati,Bhojpuri,Marathi, Punjabi, Jharkhand,Oriya,And language from north-east too.
Like Jallikattu , the entire Tamil people should be brought together along with Students , for a large People's Movement to oppose imposition of Kindi in IITs IIM's etc .
where did your son and daughter study and what language they studied. If you say English then you should ha*g yourself. If you don't want hindi please don't learn English as well.
@@svinodmenon1985 If You are so servile to Kindhi , you are free to educate your children in Kindhi Medium . You won't do it because you won't want to destroy their future .
Tamil is one of the widespread languages in the world. It is official language in Tamil Nadu, Srilanka and Singapore. You find Tamil-speaking populations in Myanmar, Bahamas, Seychelles, Guadeloupe, Malaysia, Singapore, Philippines, Mauritius, South Africa, Indonesia, Cambodia, Thailand, Burma, Vietnam, Pakistan, Réunion, Guyana, Fiji, Suriname, Trinidad and Tobago, France, Canada, USA, UAE, UK, South Africa, Australia, the rest of the EU countries and the list goes on. There are around 11 crores (110 million) of Tamils around the globe. Come on…let’s be honest. Proud to be a Tamilian 💪.
Why can’t we have Tamil or telugu or kanada or Malayalam as medium of instruction in IIT instead of Hindi? This is a stupid move by union to divert people from inflation topics ..
@@sid.7146 dude do you realise what this imply, a hindi speaker cannot study in an IIT institute of non-hindi states on all india quota, we will essentially become like EU.
@@anonymousking634 all enginnering and mbbs books are same only language is different and college will provide him translation system for all students. What's the problem we have to learn other Indian languages. When Indians want to do mbbs in Russia without knowing Russian language how they will do
@Sid shetkar.. Russia is a foreighn country.. So if anybody wants to learn in Russia means.. They should learn their language.. Do you think India is only for hindi speakers??While our ancesotor form this nation everyone accept the theme of Unity in differeance.. Then why only people like you not accepting the differance.. This is my country..I should have all rights to study what I am want in my comfortable language inspite of imposing like this..
I have been to many countries around the globe. I know the importance of English. Nowadays millions of students from China, Japan, France, Germany…etc., are learning English. They even go to UK, USA, Canada and Australia. The next generation has been encouraged and persuaded by the government and parents to learn English.
@@sid.7146 Cheez yeh hai na, agar koi English baath kare tho usko default se hi show off mana jaata hai. Kitne log hai jo angreji baath karthe vakt sochte hai "are bhai, dekho main angreji baath karunga tho kitna smart lagunga!". Angreji baath karne vaala sankhya Bharat main kam hain. Generally jo shehero ke higher income ilaako main rehte hai. Aur vo log isiliye baath karthe hai kyunki naturally aatha hai. In fact, there are many of us who refrain from speaking English in many places just to satisfy people's ego, because they'll think we are "show offs" when we have better things to do than to show off to anyone. Kisiko laddu pede nahin milte hai angreji show off karke. Sirf gaali and "English is only a language not knowledge", "English is not a measure of intelligence", "look at China and Japan", "Angrej ka aulad, NRI ke bacche" etc.
@@TV-er6xl We know this is not 1965.We know that India doesn't comprise only the Hindi heartland. We respect our mothers and sisters snd dont use words like bahan.... and ma ki ..... in day to day discourse. You use such words because you are the descendants of Mughals and Turks who came to India on horseback and slept with your daadis. Thus was born a new set of people with mixed blood, with Indian mothers and fathers who were Mughals, Persians..... ?? Their association with the local population gave birth not only to a hybrid population but also a new language-Hindi-a mix of Hindustani, Arabic, Farsi(Persian) and a little dose of Sanskrit. How desi is Hindi? Delete Arabic and Farsi words and it ceases to be a language in every sense of the term. Dravidian languages -Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Tulu and Kannada have deep roots in the Indian soil. Afghans and Tartars could not corrupt either the people or the languages. South Indian names feature in the Who's Who in the IT field in the West. The names of people from Nirbhayaland are found in the Registers of Police Stations and jails extending from Canada in the West to Australia in the South East. The white man sees these dark skinned 'self styled Aryans ' as a bunch of stinking people who live only to eat, drink, loaf around and molest women.
Hindi has just originated in 1857 while my Marathi language is 8th century old and maybe more older as Tamil languages oldest literature sangam literature has mention of Marathi speaking people. Marathi is also on the way to get classical language tag but this gov is intentionally opposing it, they are always against Maharashtra. Point is hindi doesn't deserve that significance.
@@risenrisenrise Marathi was replaced by Hindi in Mumbai. Hindi film industry has headquarters in Mumbai where most of the people in Maharashtra knows Marathi. It is huge historical mistake of Maharashtra to accept Hindi. Damn sure Marathi and other northern languages will be vanished within few hundred years.
@@risenrisenrise hindi is a prakrit language. It keeps changing. Sanskrit-prakrit-sauraseni-ardhamagadhi-(awadhi bhojpuri brajbhasha Bangla assamiya)-hindavi-hindi-something else tomorrow. You cannot exactly date any prakrit language. Whatever was Sanskrit back in the time is the modern North Indian languages today. You can just trace their origin.
Jawaharlal Nehru formed Linguistic States with the express purpose of preserving and protecting the language , culture and ethnicity of social groups to cement Unity in Diversity. The RSS has divided India as Hindu-India and Non-Hindu India to capture Power . Amit Shah is now dividing India as Hindi India and Non-Hindi India . Linguistic states should guard agaist the imposition of Hindi in their states . TAMIL NADU HAS ONLY TWO LANGUAGES, TAMIL AND ENGLISH . NO PLACE FOR HINDI IN TAMIL NADU .
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪..
Any proof. I know South only fight with language issues but they wil support muslim an Christian with this. Who will believe these people.@@karthikkarthik453
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥.,
Mr. Narayanan Tirupati may be representative of BJP'sTamil Nadu unit,and he is not representative of Tamil Nadu public The true Tamil public will never allow hindi imposition and also Hindi to replace English as medium of instruction in school, colleges either run by Union or state govt.
Narayan Tripathi is a crook and a culprit in TN no one respects him as a tamilian. He is an anti Tamil. So if you take to input From that mental we don't respect your channel too
hi joker i dont know tamil language but to get a job in tamil nadu i need to have tamil as my language in matric class first tell your state to stop this necessary criteria of imposing tamil on the people who dont know it
@@upschidden4228 Mr overcooked!!! Try to understand that wherever you go for better livelihood you must learn the regional language of the region that offers all your needs
@@upschidden4228 Mr.Half boiled, it is the right of TN govt to select its employees from the people who knows the state' s language I.e., Thamizhe, to serve its people to the satisfaction of the people and its govt..
Hindi must be removed as a mandatory language from Karnataka schools. Considering Hindi marks while evaluating students calibre is utter nonsense. I had faced difficulty while writing Hindi question paper in the exam.
Hello south , be united and fight over the linguistic war. Also if hindi speaking ministers or public ,they don't know english to communicate with south should be stopped our tax too.
Hey dumb, South sates contribute more GST and getting less compensation from union. See you people are not capable of learning English to competate with southern people who learn English so you people want Hindi to in exam, education, and everywhere so you people can survive where other states people need to learn Hindi to survive. Better you learn English like we Do. We speak tamil we learn English, we speak Malayalam and we learnt English, we speak Telugu and we learnt English, we spoke kanada and we learnt English, we spoke marati and we learnt English. Better you learn English Along with Hindi. Don't ask us to learn your language for you comfortable. If we need we can learn. Don't impose.
Keeladi excavations have proved that Tamil language had well developed written scripts 2400 years ago . We are happy with our two language policy . Why should we bother to learn a mongrel of a language 200-500 years old ?
Remember once Pakisthan declared Urdu as its national language and imposed it in East Pakistan (Bangladesh). India is very diverse in many layers... India will only work if we accept others' differences and tries to coexist with them. We can't unify anything that pre-existing before India..
Mr Stalin is one of the strongest leaders from Tamil Nadu. Someone like chief minister of Tamil Nadu Mr Stalin should challenge the union government. We had enough of the union government dictating us and telling us what to do. He is roaring like a lion 🦁 💪.
If you kill regional languages lot's of associated art, science, technology, medicine dies along with it. Why are you forcing some thing on others who have better track record. What's the difference between the colonization by the British Raj versus Hindu Rashtra? They want the coastal India to become the Colony of Ganges belt?
Boycott The imposition of Hindi in our south... We have our own history we are carrying it from our ansectors... I will speak my Telugu in my Telugu states... I will survive with English At other states... Jai hind 🇮🇳❤️
Hindi is incompetent language to become medium of instruction in higher eductional and research institutions.. English is back-bone of india. All free thinking Indians love and respect English. English is effective tool to Protect, Preserve and Promote regional languages. English can alone to keep India long live.
Dont start again your imposition.. our forfather fought against it and this generaition we will also……. Proud to be Tamil… My language, my soul, my life my tamil… its not a language its a emotion.. Dont impose ur language and culture on us
Hindhi is a foreign language like latin greek. Father transfored =pita Mother transformed to =matha.... Linguistic research will show you proof. The orgin or father and mother words are came from Latin greek. Sanskrit is also correlated to europian languages
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥..
@@sid.7146 I just love my Language end of the discussion Don"t Impose. U Understand. Do not impose ur language... or any other language may it be English or Germannn. U linguistic fanatic do we impose Tamil on you??????
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
I'm also from Telangana only.. don't spread this false propaganda Aryan invension theory there is no any proper testimony to support this theory.. Britishers used this to divide people...జై హింద్..
Keep the hindi only where it is spoken. Let's the state decide the comfortable language. Just adopt English as a common language across nation. All smartphone users now understand English. Language is emotion... touching it will create political wave and people won't mind choosing an alternative party
99% of people born in Tamil Nadu will not go out of the state in their lifetime let alone to Kindhi speaking states beyond the Vindyas . Learning kindhi is as good as learning Mandarin.
Even I'm against imposition but I don't understand why does DMK family run international schools teach Hindi only to the elites but doesn't even give a choice to the poor kids to study Hindi?
@@pavan4707 Two language formula is the policy of Karunanidhi's DMK and Jayalalithaa's ADMK . The people of Tamilnadu wholeheartedly support this policy . Certain family members of the leaders of the DMK do run CBSC schools and teach Hindi to the students in those schools . That's purely business . Tamilnadu is better off without Hindi . We are perfectly ok with Tamil and English . Why should we learn Hindi ?
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
@@pavan4707 elites ? If they run cbse school they have to follow rules of central educational board It's that simple . Even if it's CM of state he is not above law
Let the hindi wala learn Telugu in their school curriculum first then we'll talk later. Telugu in Telugu states just like hindi in Hindi region. Jai Telugu thalli 🔥✊
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state
@@karthikkarthik453 proto Dravidian language splitted into 4 branches - proto North dravidian,proto south dravidian, proto South Central , proto central Dravidian proto south dravidian - tamil-kannada proto south Central Dravidian - Telugu,chenchu proto central Dravidian - kolami,naiki proto North dravidian - kurukh,malto,brahui this is how south languages splitted from it's ancestor proto dravidian,tamil is one of all sanskrit has nothing to do in splitting proto dravidian Sanskrit entered to Indian subcontinent after split of proto Dravidian Sanskrit got influenced by proto Dravidian after 1500bce and it's splitted into several pakrits and indo aryan languages words like phalam(fruit), kunda(pot),mayura(peacock),kann(eye),danda(stick),deevena(bless) etc are mentioned in Rigveda which are of dravidian origin,it shows Sanskrit has dravidian language influence too later like English now, Sanskrit was promoted as tantrik, mantras,hyms language Brahmin character is introduced by central asian migrants and vedic religion is formed, started mixing vedic religion and indigenous tribal tradition, cultures and ancestral stories into it and promoted
Our first choice is always our State language and our second choice is English because English is the "lingua franca" of the world! & Today India's science, technology, space sector, research, education, information technology are all in English and not in Hindi..! There is no point in learning Hindi
@@jzbu2534 How do u say. it is not the oldest language. If so, then which is the oldest language? Tamils believe that their language is 50000 years old. So, they claiming it as the oldest language is is correct.
@@amiedn01 there are many languages that existed before tamil egyptian civilization was the first they spoke what tamil no and there are many languages before that no doubt in it
@@amiedn01 BTW I don't have any problem with it just saying facts it's the oldest existing language which means people are still talking it you can only see tamil if you search that way
பல மொழி என்றால் இந்திய ஒன்றியம் ஒன்றாய் இருக்கும் ஒரு மொழி என்றால் இந்திய ஒன்றியம் பல நாடுகள் ஆகிவிடும். தமிழ் எங்கள் உயிருக்கு நேர். தமிழுக்காக ஆயுதம் ஏந்தவும் தயங்கமாட்டோம் கவனம். வாழ்க தமிழ் வளர்க்க தமிழர் நாடு
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
English is not only damaging French but also the other languages of world. Specially with reference to India who has languages with rich literature and ancient background but because of English today many Indian languages specially regional languages like Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada who has very ancient history and enormous literature, today facing lots of hard ships even in their regions also. Since these languages have either no or very limited scope out of their states/provinces. Even in their own provinces, because of English their new/young generations do not show any interest in their native languages. Even the Govt official , who are mostly convent or English educated do not show any sincere interest in their own languages because they themselves do not want to work in their native languages because they do not feel comfortable in their languages. Once I went to the Tamilnadu's traditional cities Madurai and Vellore and talk to some of the English medium students and even students from Tamil schools I asked them if they have ant knowledge of following Tamil poems Netuntokai nanuru (400 long poems) Kuruntokai anuru (400 short poems) Narrinai (400 Tinai landscape poems) Purananuru (400 Outer poems) Ainkurunuru (500 very short poems) Patirruppattu (Ten Tens) Or any Idea of 5 Tamil epics Silappatikāram, Manimekalai, Cīvaka Cintāmaṇi, Valayapathi Kuṇṭalakēc Or the old literature : Tholkappiyam Surprisingly the English medium students looked at me , smiled at me and told me that they never heard these names more surprising thing is that even Tamil students do not have much knowledge about these epics, writers or poems. However most of them knew whos is GB Shaw, Bernard, Shakespeare. They also knew who wrote The tempest, Much ado about nothing and many more, even the rural students knew about English writers. I have 1st Chosen to visit Tamilnadu because I had heard that people from this state always said that they are proud of their rich and 2000, 3000 ancient literature and they always have hue and cry for their language, fight with the central/federal govt. for imposing certain language on them but neither the common person nor the Govt. never ever ever stand against English who is really responsible for destroying and damaging their rich literature. After this I realize that this only a political stunt and drama and nothing else. Sadly I had seen the same situation in Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra. I am so sad and heart broken that almost all the rich Dravidian literature is dying so fast and their politicians are making them fool by showing the fear of imposing certain Indian language on them. No doubt that we should have knowledge of modern world languages as they help us in getting jobs and in global communications but we should learn them only as one language and not chose them as medium of instructions and than try to adhere them into our personal life. I have sound knowledge of English and respect this language but at home I always speak Punjabi with my Parents and kids and with my friends I prefer to speak Hindi over English in my friend circle and when in visit Delhi and meet the friend from Bengal and Tamilnadu I try to speak in Tamil or Bangla if they have communications problems in Hindi or English. I warn every one that this is the time that we all should stood against the English monopoly ( not Language ) otherwise I will give you the guarantee that the time is not far when our languages, specially regional languages become " Once upon a time "
U really think kerala ..just like TN we don't want hindi..if anyone wants to learn hindi they are free to learn..we don't restrict any language here..bt no one can impose any language
As India is a country of diversity , Hindi cannot be the main language ...Why oppose English as a link language and in higher education? Foolish! English is in India since 200 years! The Southern states seem to have more self esteem and think logically correct
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥...
Mother languages considered as a highest position, even higher than their own religion. It is everything. It is life. There will be no identify at all without mother languages in this world. When any people loose their languages, they loss everything as in history of many nations, people's...
First of all India is India because of the unity in diversity factor that is a very alien concept in the rest of the world. And by doing these sort of things the govt is just pushing India towards disintegration and nothing else. I am a Bengali girl and this language makes up my heart, soul and body. You cannot forcefully impose something in the country tht is known to be the "largest democracy of the world." Remember why Bangladesh was created, because of this issue only. The thing is tht the more you try to grab a handful of sand the more easily and quickly is slips off of your grip. If you want india to be one forever you have to respect everyone's emotions. We are all human beings and speaking the language of our choice is our birth right. And if this keeps on going then we must be prepared for the division of our country as well and nothing else. And the person who truly respect their own mother tongue can never disrespect or disregard someone else's. And this whole concept of making India one by unifying a language is just a very uneducated way of thinking cz tht is never possible in a country like ours.
If they push hindi as national language in India then it India may divide into many countries... In that Tamil Nadu Will be the first state will be detach from union of India..hope that wont happen and delhi imperialism should not cross the limits.
sadly, Telugu people aren't actively protesting this. They have to learn from Tamils. I'm a Telugu myself and I'm seeing my mother tongue lose respect and die, helplessly.
I hope Mr Vaddkan is not able to put his points in Hindi as he is able to deliberate in English.Hindi is a mixer but other classical languages are pure.
Many people do not understand Hindi in India. Even educated people. If you instruct in Hindi how are we suppose to understand what is being taught? Should we all fail?
Vaddakan means man belongs to North in Tamil ....do you know any question raised by MP'S in South , the answer is in hindi ?? All central Govt schemes..this yojna...that yojna....can anyone understand...why cant they name them in local languages ?? If this is not imposition then what is ???
We only recommened not imposing hindi is like camel entering into tent. Why the hell these BJP makes such a recommendations. Modi and co is spoiling the nation
Let them do. North will compeletly forget english. The global firm's eye will turn towards south for englis known workforce. Already that's what the scenerio right now. Let them do happily. I am not against north. Still central imposing it. Even in National exams questions have appeared only in hindi and english. We are feeling like betrayed. They are once again pulling back underdeveloped states.
Marathi was widely spoken in MP at time of Rani Ahilyabai Holkars time, so why can't u teach Marathi there? No need of hindi then! What about various dialects which hindi alone is killing in up and bihar?
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics': (1) Based on discrimination: The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages. (2) Based on practicality: Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on TH-cam entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English. (3) Based on uniqueness: If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi. (4) Based on imposition: After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'. (5) Based on the two v/s three language formula: The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language. (6) Based on the existing concept of India: Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality. (7) Based on statistics: Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace! (8) Based on pride and politics: Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional. (9) Based on nationalism: India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back. (10) Based on globalization: Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
The opposition to three-language policy, prominence given to Sanskrit over and above Tamil and other languages and trying to impose Hindi as National language is against social justice, federalism, pluralism and equality (whether it is Congress or BJP). This is purely dictatorship by the union government.
If Hindi is imposed, southern India will divide from India. This bjp is carving the path for it. Amit shsh is idiot. English is the only thing we gained from british, dont lose it idiots. அட கொக்கா மக்கா அவன் பெயரே tom வடக்கன் 😂😂😂 வேடிக்கைதான் மக்களே
Hindi is not mother tongue of any Hindus in the world, 6000 old languages Tamil, Gujarati, Marathi, Kashmiri, Bengali, The RSS Sanskrit Brahmins Gujarati marvadis banya want to introduce 100 years old Hindi of Brahminsm, British, Arabic, Persi...
If Hindi can be better than English in higher learning - Implement completely Hindi based higher education in the Gangetic belt and prove by showing UP and Bihar does better than the Coastal states (Gujarat to WestBengal along the coast). Don't destroy what's there instead build new in the proposed formula and show it's better - Then people will follow voluntarily. DON'T FORCE. SHOW BY EXAMPLE. Gangetic belt has more population than USA.
LEARN , THE STATE LANGUAGE. AND PASS THE EXAM., AND THEN ONLY U ALL HINDI., SHOULD BE GIVEN ENTRY TO THAT STATE, THEN ONLY U PEOPLE., KNOW THE PAIN ., OR THE IMPOSITIION., OF OTHER LANGUAGE TO YOU HINDI. FIRST DO THIS. AND COME TO MAINLY SOUTH STATE. IF U WANT TO COME KARNATAKA., FIRST., PASS THE BASIC KANNADA., EXAM., COMPULSORY., AND THEN ONLY U WILL BE GIVEN., PERMISSIION TO ENTER KARNATAKA., THEN IS IT OK.
This is what will happen when illiterate people are chosen as representatives, what will happen to those who wish to go abroad for education or jobs or does the visva guru think that only he is entitled to travel abroad.god knows where all these fellows get these stupid ideas from.
divide and rule consempt by bjp ,1st in hinduism...now in hindhi imposition in south...bjp may gain now,bt in near future peaks hatred may raise in hindhi belt to non- hindhi ppl..south and eatern states ...now bjp may gain..bt if it force imposition cont..ppl living hindhi and non-hindhi regional,language war...peaks.hope it will be cool down.smooth.hope ppl will relaize🙏🏻🙏🏻
75 years ago one Home Minister United a divided India into one country . Now the present Home Minister is dividing one country into two as India and Hindia .
I wonder,when it is put forth every time whenever language cry starts that hindi speakers are 40% in this country,how many of them can read and write in hindi. Ok.Let me get this straight to the point.Give us a time of 50 years so that we can prove to be no less than those good reproducers,the "Vadakkans".
English is not only damaging French but also the other languages of world. Specially with reference to India who has languages with rich literature and ancient background but because of English today many Indian languages specially regional languages like Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada who has very ancient history and enormous literature, today facing lots of hard ships even in their regions also. Since these languages have either no or very limited scope out of their states/provinces. Even in their own provinces, because of English their new/young generations do not show any interest in their native languages. Even the Govt official , who are mostly convent or English educated do not show any sincere interest in their own languages because they themselves do not want to work in their native languages because they do not feel comfortable in their languages. Once I went to the Tamilnadu's traditional cities Madurai and Vellore and talk to some of the English medium students and even students from Tamil schools I asked them if they have ant knowledge of following Tamil poems Netuntokai nanuru (400 long poems) Kuruntokai anuru (400 short poems) Narrinai (400 Tinai landscape poems) Purananuru (400 Outer poems) Ainkurunuru (500 very short poems) Patirruppattu (Ten Tens) Or any Idea of 5 Tamil epics Silappatikāram, Manimekalai, Cīvaka Cintāmaṇi, Valayapathi Kuṇṭalakēc Or the old literature : Tholkappiyam Surprisingly the English medium students looked at me , smiled at me and told me that they never heard these names more surprising thing is that even Tamil students do not have much knowledge about these epics, writers or poems. However most of them knew whos is GB Shaw, Bernard, Shakespeare. They also knew who wrote The tempest, Much ado about nothing and many more, even the rural students knew about English writers. I have 1st Chosen to visit Tamilnadu because I had heard that people from this state always said that they are proud of their rich and 2000, 3000 ancient literature and they always have hue and cry for their language, fight with the central/federal govt. for imposing certain language on them but neither the common person nor the Govt. never ever ever stand against English who is really responsible for destroying and damaging their rich literature. After this I realize that this only a political stunt and drama and nothing else. Sadly I had seen the same situation in Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra. I am so sad and heart broken that almost all the rich Dravidian literature is dying so fast and their politicians are making them fool by showing the fear of imposing certain Indian language on them. No doubt that we should have knowledge of modern world languages as they help us in getting jobs and in global communications but we should learn them only as one language and not chose them as medium of instructions and than try to adhere them into our personal life. I have sound knowledge of English and respect this language but at home I always speak Punjabi with my Parents and kids and with my friends I prefer to speak Hindi over English in my friend circle and when in visit Delhi and meet the friend from Bengal and Tamilnadu I try to speak in Tamil or Bangla if they have communications problems in Hindi or English. I warn every one that this is the time that we all should stood against the English monopoly ( not Language ) otherwise I will give you the guarantee that the time is not far when our languages, specially regional languages become " Once upon a time "
After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI. For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens .
S, in order to hide their inefficiency in the last eight years rule BJP has now taken hindi language imposition issue when election year is nearing to divert the attention of hindi speaking states where BJP started loosing it's popularity. Narayanji is correct.
Mr. Vadakkan, please ask PM not to try speaking in Tamil, he is just murdering it, we hardly understand a single word that he utters, it really hurts us...
Just shut up North karnataka coastal karnataka are not fanatics they respect our national language except South interior karnataka anyway we hate dk dmk people they should ve driven away from karnataka
All.the Southern States are not opposing.Hindi ! It is only in Tamil Nadu ! That is also only by.the Dravidian Parties ( DMK & ADMK) That is their. dirty political.survival !
Instead of Hindi, make Tamil the medium of instruction in all IITs, IIMs and other central universities. Tamil is the oldest and classic language in India. So respect the language by giving it priority.
@@harishprabhakar9744 If Hindi can be made the medium of instruction in Tamil Nadu, why Tamil cannot be made the medium of instruction in Hindi speaking states
@@harishprabhakar9744 Tamils are not coming to Hindi speaking states; in fact, it is Hindi speakers who are coming to Tamil Nadu 70% of the construction workers are Hindi speakers Tamils are not selling panipoori in Hindi speaking states. But everyone who is selling panipoori in Tamil Nadu are Hindi speakers. This the case in Kerala, Karnataka, Andhra and Telungana
One more important thing reconstitution of parliament seats new seats are gonna come after delimitation . Hindi heart land will be rewarded with more parliament seats because of its high population and rest of India will be punished with less seats because of controlling the population by successful implementation of family planning. Very very dangerous for all non Hindi native speakers.BJP thinks to come to power again by winning subsequent seats in Hindi heart land that's roughly about 250 seats that's why BJP is appeasing hindi speaking people
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥....
We Respect our mother language Kannada why I speak to Hindi.... We are not UP MP Northern states we are Dravidian states we are own language and culture do you know that........
For the purpose of interacting with anyone across the nation, yes, one should learn Hindi in the current day context. But the recommendation for implementing Hindi as medium of instruction in IITs and IIMs will entirely block the gate for Tamils and students of entire southern states. Most of the north Indian students who are even doctorates in various disciplines can not properly read, write or speak in English. Even during viva for civil services, an interpreter is provided to assist to assist the aspirants in the interview. Instead of improving the standard of English, the current dispensation is contemplating to introduce Hindi as medium of instructions in the institute of higher learning. Even if Hindi were to be in place in Tamilnadu, it would be one language paper for the students and it wouldn't have found its place in learning other subjects. The venture of Amit Shah headed committee will not only face stiff opposition from Tamilnadu and this action would make the people of southern states to unitedly fight against the move of the Centre till it scraps the recommendation since it takes away the liberty of studying in English in IITs and IIMs. Anyway, BJP has given a wonderful subject to DMK to salvage all the 40 loksabha seats in the 2024 election. Shri Annamalai, though a new entrant to BJP from Tamilnadu, Shri Amit Shah could have solicited his opinion as to the implementation of the recommendation of the committee in introducing Hindi in IITs and IIMs. In the opinion of many in Tamilnadu, BJP is devoid of intellectuals politically and educationally to a larger extent.
![The Paradoxes of India with Shashi Tharoor [JLF 2023]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gNbekPfJgRc/mqdefault.jpg)
Let’s make Tamil as national language and let North Indians prove they patriotism
They will die 😂
🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳 சரி கேள்வி !!! True to the core, let them prove their national patriotism.
They will become the Anti Indians 😂😂😂
You can make national language Tamil if you want I am dam sure no north Indian would fight on that
Even if you impose Tamil Telugu Malayalam Kannada of anything I am happy to learn it without any debate .
@Minni Why not every language given the same status
Malyayam,Kannada, Telugu, Tamul, Hindi,Bengali, Gujarati,Bhojpuri,Marathi, Punjabi, Jharkhand,Oriya,And language from north-east too.
Like Jallikattu , the entire Tamil people should be brought together along with Students , for a large People's Movement to oppose imposition of Kindi in IITs IIM's etc .
where did your son and daughter study and what language they studied. If you say English then you should ha*g yourself. If you don't want hindi please don't learn English as well.
@@svinodmenon1985
If You are so servile to Kindhi , you are free to educate your children in Kindhi Medium . You won't do it because you won't want to destroy their future .
Tamil is one of the widespread languages in the world. It is official language in Tamil Nadu, Srilanka and Singapore. You find Tamil-speaking populations in Myanmar, Bahamas, Seychelles, Guadeloupe, Malaysia, Singapore, Philippines, Mauritius, South Africa, Indonesia, Cambodia, Thailand, Burma, Vietnam, Pakistan, Réunion, Guyana, Fiji, Suriname, Trinidad and Tobago, France, Canada, USA, UAE, UK, South Africa, Australia, the rest of the EU countries and the list goes on. There are around 11 crores (110 million) of Tamils around the globe. Come on…let’s be honest. Proud to be a Tamilian 💪.
Yes
dont underestimate classical languages
Why can’t we have Tamil or telugu or kanada or Malayalam as medium of instruction in IIT instead of Hindi? This is a stupid move by union to divert people from inflation topics ..
Government already stated work on provide higher education in Tamil,telegu and Kannada
@@sid.7146 what are they going to do with learning these languages abroad?? It is one DUMBEST idea ever seen.
@@sid.7146 dude do you realise what this imply, a hindi speaker cannot study in an IIT institute of non-hindi states on all india quota, we will essentially become like EU.
@@anonymousking634 all enginnering and mbbs books are same only language is different and college will provide him translation system for all students. What's the problem we have to learn other Indian languages. When Indians want to do mbbs in Russia without knowing Russian language how they will do
@Sid shetkar.. Russia is a foreighn country.. So if anybody wants to learn in Russia means.. They should learn their language.. Do you think India is only for hindi speakers??While our ancesotor form this nation everyone accept the theme of Unity in differeance.. Then why only people like you not accepting the differance.. This is my country..I should have all rights to study what I am want in my comfortable language inspite of imposing like this..
I have been to many countries around the globe. I know the importance of English. Nowadays millions of students from China, Japan, France, Germany…etc., are learning English. They even go to UK, USA, Canada and Australia. The next generation has been encouraged and persuaded by the government and parents to learn English.
These countries students learn English for communicate English speaker not for show off purpose.
Arey dont worry English will not go anywhere.
@@sid.7146 put some common sense in your comment.
@@sid.7146 Cheez yeh hai na, agar koi English baath kare tho usko default se hi show off mana jaata hai. Kitne log hai jo angreji baath karthe vakt sochte hai "are bhai, dekho main angreji baath karunga tho kitna smart lagunga!". Angreji baath karne vaala sankhya Bharat main kam hain. Generally jo shehero ke higher income ilaako main rehte hai. Aur vo log isiliye baath karthe hai kyunki naturally aatha hai. In fact, there are many of us who refrain from speaking English in many places just to satisfy people's ego, because they'll think we are "show offs" when we have better things to do than to show off to anyone. Kisiko laddu pede nahin milte hai angreji show off karke. Sirf gaali and "English is only a language not knowledge", "English is not a measure of intelligence", "look at China and Japan", "Angrej ka aulad, NRI ke bacche" etc.
@Elon Mesk
Absolutely 👍
All non Hindi speaking states must defy at any cost against Hindi as a national language.
Definitely Sir.
Yes, for sure.
Hindhi speaking States would take similar stand ! Tamil Nadu can't succeed in this battle ,! This is not 1965 this is 2022 ! Mind it !
@@TV-er6xl 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@TV-er6xl We know this is not 1965.We know that India doesn't comprise only the Hindi heartland. We respect our mothers and sisters snd dont use words like bahan.... and ma ki ..... in day to day discourse. You use such words because you are the descendants of Mughals and Turks who came to India on horseback and slept with your daadis. Thus was born a new set of people with mixed blood, with Indian mothers and fathers who were Mughals, Persians.....
?? Their association with the local population gave birth not only to a hybrid population but also a new language-Hindi-a mix of Hindustani, Arabic, Farsi(Persian) and a little dose of Sanskrit. How desi is Hindi? Delete Arabic and Farsi words and it ceases to be a language in every sense of the term. Dravidian languages -Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Tulu and Kannada have deep roots in the Indian soil. Afghans and Tartars could not corrupt either the people or the languages. South Indian names feature in the Who's Who in the IT field in the West. The names of people from Nirbhayaland are found in the Registers of Police Stations and jails extending from Canada in the West to Australia in the South East. The white man sees these dark skinned 'self styled Aryans ' as a bunch of stinking people who live only to eat, drink, loaf around and molest women.
Hindi is kuppai.Tamil is classical.3000 years old pride.First I am Tamilan then Indian.
Hindi has just originated in 1857 while my Marathi language is 8th century old and maybe more older as Tamil languages oldest literature sangam literature has mention of Marathi speaking people. Marathi is also on the way to get classical language tag but this gov is intentionally opposing it, they are always against Maharashtra.
Point is hindi doesn't deserve that significance.
@@risenrisenrise Marathi was replaced by Hindi in Mumbai. Hindi film industry has headquarters in Mumbai where most of the people in Maharashtra knows Marathi. It is huge historical mistake of Maharashtra to accept Hindi. Damn sure Marathi and other northern languages will be vanished within few hundred years.
@@risenrisenrise Hindi is originated in 7th century from sauraseni prakrit. It's not originated in 1857.
@@billubhai5644 still Malyalam, kannada, Marathi, Gujrati, Tamil, Telugu, Odissi are more older than hindi so 👎
@@risenrisenrise hindi is a prakrit language. It keeps changing. Sanskrit-prakrit-sauraseni-ardhamagadhi-(awadhi bhojpuri brajbhasha Bangla assamiya)-hindavi-hindi-something else tomorrow. You cannot exactly date any prakrit language. Whatever was Sanskrit back in the time is the modern North Indian languages today. You can just trace their origin.
Jawaharlal Nehru formed Linguistic States with the express purpose of preserving and protecting the language , culture and ethnicity of social groups to cement Unity in Diversity.
The RSS has divided India as Hindu-India and Non-Hindu India to capture Power .
Amit Shah is now dividing India as Hindi India and Non-Hindi India .
Linguistic states should guard agaist the imposition of Hindi in their states .
TAMIL NADU HAS ONLY TWO LANGUAGES, TAMIL AND ENGLISH .
NO PLACE FOR HINDI IN TAMIL NADU .
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪..
Any proof. I know South only fight with language issues but they wil support muslim an Christian with this. Who will believe these people.@@karthikkarthik453
south India should goes separately from union if Hindi is imposed
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥.,
Mr. Narayanan Tirupati may be representative of BJP'sTamil Nadu unit,and he is not representative of Tamil Nadu public The true Tamil public will never allow hindi imposition and also Hindi to replace English as medium of instruction in school, colleges either run by Union or state govt.
Narayan Tripathi is a crook and a culprit in TN no one respects him as a tamilian. He is an anti Tamil. So if you take to input From that mental we don't respect your channel too
hi joker i dont know tamil language but to get a job in tamil nadu i need to have tamil as my language in matric class first tell your state to stop this necessary criteria of imposing tamil on the people who dont know it
@@upschidden4228 Mr overcooked!!! Try to understand that wherever you go for better livelihood you must learn the regional language of the region that offers all your needs
@@upschidden4228
Mr.Half boiled, it is the right of TN govt to select its employees from the people who knows the state' s language I.e., Thamizhe, to serve its people to the satisfaction of the people and its govt..
@@upschidden4228 up me hindi nhi aayegi to kya aur kaise job krega ..Tamil nadu me jana hai to tamil sikhna pdega
Hindi must be removed as a mandatory language from Karnataka schools. Considering Hindi marks while evaluating students calibre is utter nonsense.
I had faced difficulty while writing Hindi question paper in the exam.
Hello south , be united and fight over the linguistic war. Also if hindi speaking ministers or public ,they don't know english to communicate with south should be stopped our tax too.
Hello panparak if south not contribute tax north will collapse
Hey dumb, South sates contribute more GST and getting less compensation from union. See you people are not capable of learning English to competate with southern people who learn English so you people want Hindi to in exam, education, and everywhere so you people can survive where other states people need to learn Hindi to survive. Better you learn English like we Do. We speak tamil we learn English, we speak Malayalam and we learnt English, we speak Telugu and we learnt English, we spoke kanada and we learnt English, we spoke marati and we learnt English. Better you learn English Along with Hindi. Don't ask us to learn your language for you comfortable. If we need we can learn. Don't impose.
Keeladi excavations have proved that Tamil language had well developed written scripts 2400 years ago . We are happy with our two language policy .
Why should we bother to learn a mongrel of a language 200-500 years old ?
Just eject Southern Indian states from Union if you wish to impose useless language on Southern India.
Remember once Pakisthan declared Urdu as its national language and imposed it in East Pakistan (Bangladesh).
India is very diverse in many layers... India will only work if we accept others' differences and tries to coexist with them.
We can't unify anything that pre-existing before India..
Mr Stalin is one of the strongest leaders from Tamil Nadu. Someone like chief minister of Tamil Nadu Mr Stalin should challenge the union government. We had enough of the union government dictating us and telling us what to do. He is roaring like a lion 🦁 💪.
If you kill regional languages lot's of associated art, science, technology, medicine dies along with it.
Why are you forcing some thing on others who have better track record.
What's the difference between the colonization by the British Raj versus Hindu Rashtra?
They want the coastal India to become the Colony of Ganges belt?
Boycott The imposition of Hindi in our south... We have our own history we are carrying it from our ansectors... I will speak my Telugu in my Telugu states... I will survive with English At other states...
Jai hind 🇮🇳❤️
Hindi is incompetent language to become medium of instruction in higher eductional and research institutions.. English is back-bone of india. All free thinking Indians love and respect English. English is effective tool to Protect, Preserve and Promote regional languages.
English can alone to keep India long live.
@Learn Analyze useless dead language. We love English
Dont start again your imposition.. our forfather fought against it and this generaition we will also……. Proud to be Tamil… My language, my soul, my life my tamil… its not a language its a emotion.. Dont impose ur language and culture on us
Hindhi is a foreign language like latin greek. Father transfored =pita
Mother transformed to =matha....
Linguistic research will show you proof.
The orgin or father and mother words are came from Latin greek.
Sanskrit is also correlated to europian languages
Why u give don't give same treatment to English.that impose all over india
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥..
@@karthikkarthik453 You My Bro... Nanba Long Live My Love Tamil
@@sid.7146 I just love my Language end of the discussion Don"t Impose. U Understand. Do not impose ur language... or any other language may it be English or Germannn. U linguistic fanatic do we impose Tamil on you??????
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
I'm also from Telangana only.. don't spread this false propaganda Aryan invension theory there is no any proper testimony to support this theory.. Britishers used this to divide people...జై హింద్..
Better make Malayalam as Indian language! Because when political people get treated abroad, they need to communicate with medical professionals.😂😂😂😂😂
Savage
Superb 👌 🔥🔥🔥🔥😂😂
Keep the hindi only where it is spoken.
Let's the state decide the comfortable language.
Just adopt English as a common language across nation.
All smartphone users now understand English.
Language is emotion... touching it will create political wave and people won't mind choosing an alternative party
99% of people born in Tamil Nadu will not go out of the state in their lifetime let alone to Kindhi speaking states beyond the Vindyas . Learning kindhi is as good as learning Mandarin.
Even I'm against imposition but I don't understand why does DMK family run international schools teach Hindi only to the elites but doesn't even give a choice to the poor kids to study Hindi?
@@pavan4707
Two language formula is the policy of Karunanidhi's DMK and Jayalalithaa's ADMK . The people of Tamilnadu wholeheartedly support this policy .
Certain family members of the leaders of the DMK do run CBSC schools and teach Hindi to the students in those schools .
That's purely business .
Tamilnadu is better off without Hindi .
We are perfectly ok with Tamil and English .
Why should we learn Hindi ?
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
@@pavan4707 elites ? If they run cbse school they have to follow rules of central educational board It's that simple . Even if it's CM of state he is not above law
Playing dirty poloticd by TAMILIAN POLITICIANS just for vote bank.
Pani Puri language 🤣😂😂🤣😂😂😂
Language is a choice. To impose nobody has the right.
No one is imposing
Iits have given a choice if you want too learn in tamil you can
@Amber english sikhne me kya jata hai .
@Amber-mt3nvwe love English
Let the hindi wala learn Telugu in their school curriculum first then we'll talk later.
Telugu in Telugu states just like hindi in Hindi region.
Jai Telugu thalli 🔥✊
___ Southern India and all other non hindi belts will stand up, and protest against Hindi imposition and Sanskrit imposition.🔥🔥🔥
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state
@@karthikkarthik453 Indeed, its History and Truth, well said Brother...!!! 🔥🔥🔥
@@karthikkarthik453 proto Dravidian language splitted into 4 branches -
proto North dravidian,proto south dravidian, proto South Central , proto central Dravidian
proto south dravidian - tamil-kannada
proto south Central Dravidian - Telugu,chenchu
proto central Dravidian -
kolami,naiki
proto North dravidian -
kurukh,malto,brahui
this is how south languages splitted from it's ancestor proto dravidian,tamil is one of all
sanskrit has nothing to do in splitting proto dravidian
Sanskrit entered to Indian subcontinent after split of proto Dravidian
Sanskrit got influenced by proto Dravidian after 1500bce and it's splitted into several pakrits and indo aryan languages
words like phalam(fruit), kunda(pot),mayura(peacock),kann(eye),danda(stick),deevena(bless) etc are mentioned in Rigveda which are of dravidian origin,it shows Sanskrit has dravidian language influence too
later like English now, Sanskrit was promoted as tantrik, mantras,hyms language
Brahmin character is introduced by central asian migrants and vedic religion is formed, started mixing vedic religion and indigenous tribal tradition, cultures and ancestral stories into it and promoted
Our first choice is always our State language and our second choice is English because English is the "lingua franca" of the world! & Today India's science, technology, space sector, research, education, information technology are all in English and not in Hindi..! There is no point in learning Hindi
Tamil was a oldest language in the world about 3500 years old.
Saaman supporting Hindi and Sanskrit.
Sorry to say but it's not the oldest language but it's the oldest existing language there is a big difference
@@jzbu2534 How do u say. it is not the oldest language.
If so, then which is the oldest language?
Tamils believe that their language is 50000 years old. So, they claiming it as the oldest language is is correct.
@@amiedn01 there are many languages that existed before tamil egyptian civilization was the first they spoke what tamil no and there are many languages before that no doubt in it
@@amiedn01 BTW I don't have any problem with it just saying facts it's the oldest existing language which means people are still talking it you can only see tamil if you search that way
UP and Bihar are living by the handout monies from the tax monies taken from the coastal India. But all they can offer is HINDI.
பல மொழி என்றால் இந்திய ஒன்றியம் ஒன்றாய் இருக்கும் ஒரு மொழி என்றால் இந்திய ஒன்றியம் பல நாடுகள் ஆகிவிடும். தமிழ் எங்கள் உயிருக்கு நேர். தமிழுக்காக ஆயுதம் ஏந்தவும் தயங்கமாட்டோம் கவனம். வாழ்க தமிழ் வளர்க்க தமிழர் நாடு
♥️🐅💪💪தமிழ்
Bro I am from kerala what is this
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪
English is not only damaging French but also the other languages of world. Specially with reference to India who has languages with rich literature and ancient background but because of English today many Indian languages specially regional languages like Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada who has very ancient history and enormous literature, today facing lots of hard ships even in their regions also. Since these languages have either no or very limited scope out of their states/provinces. Even in their own provinces, because of English their new/young generations do not show any interest in their native languages. Even the Govt official , who are mostly convent or English educated do not show any sincere
interest in their own languages because they themselves do not want to work in their native languages
because they do not feel comfortable in their languages. Once I went to the Tamilnadu's traditional cities
Madurai and Vellore and talk to some of the English medium students and even students from Tamil schools I asked them if they have ant knowledge of following Tamil poems
Netuntokai nanuru (400 long poems)
Kuruntokai anuru (400 short poems)
Narrinai (400 Tinai landscape poems)
Purananuru (400 Outer poems)
Ainkurunuru (500 very short poems)
Patirruppattu (Ten Tens)
Or any Idea of 5 Tamil epics
Silappatikāram,
Manimekalai,
Cīvaka Cintāmaṇi,
Valayapathi
Kuṇṭalakēc
Or the old literature : Tholkappiyam
Surprisingly the English medium students looked at me , smiled at me and told me that they never heard these names more surprising thing is that even Tamil students do not have much knowledge about these epics, writers or poems. However most of them knew whos is GB Shaw, Bernard, Shakespeare. They also knew who wrote The tempest, Much ado about nothing and many more, even the rural students knew about English writers. I have 1st Chosen to visit Tamilnadu because I had heard that people from this state
always said that they are proud of their rich and 2000, 3000 ancient literature and they always have hue and cry for their language, fight with the central/federal govt. for imposing certain language on them but neither the common person nor the Govt. never ever ever stand against English who is really responsible for destroying and damaging their rich literature. After this I realize that this only a political stunt and drama and nothing else. Sadly I had seen the same situation in Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra. I am so sad
and heart broken that almost all the rich Dravidian literature is dying so fast and their politicians are making them fool by showing the fear of imposing certain Indian language on them. No doubt that we should have knowledge of modern world languages as they help us in getting jobs and in global communications but we should learn them only as one language and not chose them as medium of instructions and than try to adhere them into our personal life. I have sound knowledge of English and respect this language but at home I always speak Punjabi with my Parents and kids and with my friends
I prefer to speak Hindi over English in my friend circle and when in visit Delhi and meet the friend from
Bengal and Tamilnadu I try to speak in Tamil or Bangla if they have communications problems in Hindi or English. I warn every one that this is the time that we all should stood against the English monopoly ( not Language ) otherwise I will give you the guarantee that the time is not far when our languages, specially
regional languages become " Once upon a time "
You Can Impose Hindi In Karnataka Andhra Telungana Kerala But Not In THAMIZHLNAADU🖤❤
U really think kerala ..just like TN we don't want hindi..if anyone wants to learn hindi they are free to learn..we don't restrict any language here..bt no one can impose any language
What sin the telegu & the malayali folks commit ??
@@achuthramr5767 what
we don't want hindi in all south
@Minni 🆗🗿
Why only South India? What about West Bengal and North Eastern States. Most people there are also not well versed in Hindi.
even odisha Jharkhand too 😢
As India is a country of diversity , Hindi cannot be the main language ...Why oppose English as a link language and in higher education? Foolish! English is in India since 200 years! The Southern states seem to have more self esteem and think logically correct
Vaddakan does not want Tamil be taught in UP, but he wants Hindi to be taught in Tamil Nadu. What a bullshit logic this is?
Don't pay GST and create own army to each state is the best solution
Pls teach Tamil, kannada, Telugu and other South launguage for north Indian to get job in south. Young youth will make national integration. Jaihind
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥...
Two language is enough for this world one for local another for global
Mother languages considered as a highest position, even higher than their own religion. It is everything. It is life. There will be no identify at all without mother languages in this world. When any people loose their languages, they loss everything as in history of many nations, people's...
Well spoke A. saravanan I'm happy for taking out Kannada name,thank U.
First of all India is India because of the unity in diversity factor that is a very alien concept in the rest of the world. And by doing these sort of things the govt is just pushing India towards disintegration and nothing else. I am a Bengali girl and this language makes up my heart, soul and body. You cannot forcefully impose something in the country tht is known to be the "largest democracy of the world." Remember why Bangladesh was created, because of this issue only.
The thing is tht the more you try to grab a handful of sand the more easily and quickly is slips off of your grip. If you want india to be one forever you have to respect everyone's emotions. We are all human beings and speaking the language of our choice is our birth right.
And if this keeps on going then we must be prepared for the division of our country as well and nothing else. And the person who truly respect their own mother tongue can never disrespect or disregard someone else's.
And this whole concept of making India one by unifying a language is just a very uneducated way of thinking cz tht is never possible in a country like ours.
Well said sister
They cannot impose. We will declare freedom
Hindi in IITs, please no.
If they push hindi as national language in India then it India may divide into many countries...
In that Tamil Nadu Will be the first state will be detach from union of India..hope that wont happen and delhi imperialism should not cross the limits.
Hope our Telugu people get liberated as well
Kerala too
Linguistic states must protect their Mother Tongues from the onslaught of the marauding Hindhi viciously pushed and forced by BJP.
sadly, Telugu people aren't actively protesting this. They have to learn from Tamils. I'm a Telugu myself and I'm seeing my mother tongue lose respect and die, helplessly.
We south indians never allow Hindi imposition....we will chase away Hindi imposition
This is a joke even shah knows it's not possible
Hindi dint even exist while othr Indian languages wrote poems and scriptures..
Its stupidity to communicate in such language
I hope Mr Vaddkan is not able to put his points in Hindi as he is able to deliberate in English.Hindi is a mixer but other classical languages are pure.
Many people do not understand Hindi in India. Even educated people. If you instruct in Hindi how are we suppose to understand what is being taught? Should we all fail?
Learn hindi to buy panipuri and to communicate with chapris 😂😂😂
Vaddakan means man belongs to North in Tamil ....do you know any question raised by MP'S in South , the answer is in hindi ??
All central Govt schemes..this yojna...that yojna....can anyone understand...why cant they name them in local languages ?? If this is not imposition then what is ???
Soon the Union Government will realise that imposing Hindi in IIT, IIM etc. in South India particularly will be a misadventure.
We only recommened not imposing hindi is like camel entering into tent. Why the hell these BJP makes such a recommendations. Modi and co is spoiling the nation
Let them do. North will compeletly forget english. The global firm's eye will turn towards south for englis known workforce. Already that's what the scenerio right now. Let them do happily. I am not against north. Still central imposing it. Even in National exams questions have appeared only in hindi and english. We are feeling like betrayed. They are once again pulling back underdeveloped states.
Correct
Marathi was widely spoken in MP at time of Rani Ahilyabai Holkars time, so why can't u teach Marathi there? No need of hindi then!
What about various dialects which hindi alone is killing in up and bihar?
Mr. Vadakans response would not have been sane, if he had remained in congress.
Punjabi, rajasthani, gujarati, marathi, kannada, tamil, telugu, odisha, bengali, bhojpuri, assamese, manipuri, wherein hindi is spoken in India
Vadakkan means northe ... good representation 🤣🤣🤣
Teach south Indian language to hindi belt...
@Learn Analyze crap power bhayas
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics':
(1) Based on discrimination:
The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages.
(2) Based on practicality:
Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on TH-cam entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English.
(3) Based on uniqueness:
If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi.
(4) Based on imposition:
After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'.
(5) Based on the two v/s three language formula:
The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language.
(6) Based on the existing concept of India:
Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality.
(7) Based on statistics:
Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace!
(8) Based on pride and politics:
Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional.
(9) Based on nationalism:
India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back.
(10) Based on globalization:
Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
Hindi is capable of dividing India into peaces
Hindi people work in south India as a labour,, so you ask use to learn servent language
The opposition to three-language policy, prominence given to Sanskrit over and above Tamil and other languages and trying to impose Hindi as National language is against social justice, federalism, pluralism and equality (whether it is Congress or BJP). This is purely dictatorship by the union government.
Why is this a question? When in Rome do what the Romans do. When in Tamil Nadu, speak Tamil ❤
If Hindi is imposed, southern India will divide from India. This bjp is carving the path for it. Amit shsh is idiot. English is the only thing we gained from british, dont lose it idiots. அட கொக்கா மக்கா அவன் பெயரே tom வடக்கன் 😂😂😂 வேடிக்கைதான் மக்களே
Hindi is not mother tongue of any Hindus in the world, 6000 old languages Tamil, Gujarati, Marathi, Kashmiri, Bengali, The RSS Sanskrit Brahmins Gujarati marvadis banya want to introduce 100 years old Hindi of Brahminsm, British, Arabic, Persi...
Let's make Tamil as national language. It has Rich Literatures than any other languages in the world.
North Indians , who opt to learn only in Hindi , should not be admitted to institutions in Tamil Nadu where the medium of instruction is English.
Amitsha is opposing english because he& his family is very poor in English.
If Hindi can be better than English in higher learning - Implement completely Hindi based higher education in the Gangetic belt and prove by showing UP and Bihar does better than the Coastal states (Gujarat to WestBengal along the coast).
Don't destroy what's there instead build new in the proposed formula and show it's better - Then people will follow voluntarily. DON'T FORCE. SHOW BY EXAMPLE. Gangetic belt has more population than USA.
LEARN , THE STATE LANGUAGE. AND PASS THE EXAM., AND THEN ONLY U ALL HINDI., SHOULD BE GIVEN ENTRY TO THAT STATE, THEN ONLY U PEOPLE., KNOW THE PAIN ., OR THE IMPOSITIION., OF OTHER LANGUAGE TO YOU HINDI.
FIRST DO THIS. AND COME TO MAINLY SOUTH STATE.
IF U WANT TO COME KARNATAKA., FIRST., PASS THE BASIC KANNADA., EXAM., COMPULSORY., AND THEN ONLY U WILL BE GIVEN., PERMISSIION TO ENTER KARNATAKA.,
THEN IS IT OK.
Tom Vadakkan
Tamil perspective: the name says everything... Hahaha
This is what will happen when illiterate people are chosen as representatives, what will happen to those who wish to go abroad for education or jobs or does the visva guru think that only he is entitled to travel abroad.god knows where all these fellows get these stupid ideas from.
Karnataka people wanted Kannada and English only
I am also a kannadiga. but they are imposing hindi on us. In bangalore they are giving more importance to Hindi people only. BJP is imposing hindi.
Start protest against hindi
Karnataka except South interior part mysore belt no body opposes hindi vehemently it will be a failure
Make it Indian national language Tamil.why did not do like that.
divide and rule consempt by bjp ,1st in hinduism...now in hindhi imposition in south...bjp may gain now,bt in near future peaks hatred may raise in hindhi belt to non- hindhi ppl..south and eatern states ...now bjp may gain..bt if it force imposition cont..ppl living hindhi and non-hindhi regional,language war...peaks.hope it will be cool down.smooth.hope ppl will relaize🙏🏻🙏🏻
75 years ago one Home Minister United a divided India into one country .
Now the present Home Minister is dividing one country into two as India and Hindia .
I wonder,when it is put forth every time whenever language cry starts that hindi speakers are 40% in this country,how many of them can read and write in hindi.
Ok.Let me get this straight to the point.Give us a time of 50 years so that we can prove to be no less than those good reproducers,the "Vadakkans".
தமிழ் எங்கள் உயிருக்கு நேர்...வாழ்க தமிழ் வளர்க்க தமிழர் நாடு
English is not only damaging French but also the other languages of world. Specially with reference to India who has languages with rich literature and ancient background but because of English today many Indian languages specially regional languages like Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada who has very ancient history and enormous literature, today facing lots of hard ships even in their regions also. Since these languages have either no or very limited scope out of their states/provinces. Even in their own provinces, because of English their new/young generations do not show any interest in their native languages. Even the Govt official , who are mostly convent or English educated do not show any sincere
interest in their own languages because they themselves do not want to work in their native languages
because they do not feel comfortable in their languages. Once I went to the Tamilnadu's traditional cities
Madurai and Vellore and talk to some of the English medium students and even students from Tamil schools I asked them if they have ant knowledge of following Tamil poems
Netuntokai nanuru (400 long poems)
Kuruntokai anuru (400 short poems)
Narrinai (400 Tinai landscape poems)
Purananuru (400 Outer poems)
Ainkurunuru (500 very short poems)
Patirruppattu (Ten Tens)
Or any Idea of 5 Tamil epics
Silappatikāram,
Manimekalai,
Cīvaka Cintāmaṇi,
Valayapathi
Kuṇṭalakēc
Or the old literature : Tholkappiyam
Surprisingly the English medium students looked at me , smiled at me and told me that they never heard these names more surprising thing is that even Tamil students do not have much knowledge about these epics, writers or poems. However most of them knew whos is GB Shaw, Bernard, Shakespeare. They also knew who wrote The tempest, Much ado about nothing and many more, even the rural students knew about English writers. I have 1st Chosen to visit Tamilnadu because I had heard that people from this state
always said that they are proud of their rich and 2000, 3000 ancient literature and they always have hue and cry for their language, fight with the central/federal govt. for imposing certain language on them but neither the common person nor the Govt. never ever ever stand against English who is really responsible for destroying and damaging their rich literature. After this I realize that this only a political stunt and drama and nothing else. Sadly I had seen the same situation in Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra. I am so sad
and heart broken that almost all the rich Dravidian literature is dying so fast and their politicians are making them fool by showing the fear of imposing certain Indian language on them. No doubt that we should have knowledge of modern world languages as they help us in getting jobs and in global communications but we should learn them only as one language and not chose them as medium of instructions and than try to adhere them into our personal life. I have sound knowledge of English and respect this language but at home I always speak Punjabi with my Parents and kids and with my friends
I prefer to speak Hindi over English in my friend circle and when in visit Delhi and meet the friend from
Bengal and Tamilnadu I try to speak in Tamil or Bangla if they have communications problems in Hindi or English. I warn every one that this is the time that we all should stood against the English monopoly ( not Language ) otherwise I will give you the guarantee that the time is not far when our languages, specially
regional languages become " Once upon a time "
After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI.
For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens .
As a Tamil, I never allow , some parsi Turkish language (Hindi) take over my Dravidian pride languages.....
Hindi is not a regional language of any state. Hindi not mother language of any indian state.
In Karnataka actually Congress imposed Hindi in the name of Three language formula. Now playing double game
3 languages is fine. But instructing strictly in Hindi is disadvantageous for non Hindi students
That's the reason why Karnataka, Telangana and Andhra Pradesh people know Hindi very well due to 3 language formula
@@davidalexsebastiank6250 only people in city knows. Not even 5% population in Karnataka Andhra and Telugana knows Hindi. Only city people
@@Nt-nc9ps But I've seen that nowadays village people in Karnataka and Telangana people understand and speak good Hindi/Urdu
We want 2 language policy
Brahmins want to change Indian Hindus mother tongue 6000 years old as 2600 Aryan Sanskrit Colonization with caste atrocities of Manudharma, Sanathana
Sanskrit oldest language next tamizh nalla uruttu thiruttu dravida gumbalange
Why maximum.promotion for HINDI ??
@Gigolo Gandhi YES ,BROTHER !
See the BJP spokesperson name Mr.Tom vadakkan lmao .
Vadakkans means North Indians in Tamil
S, in order to hide their inefficiency in the last eight years rule BJP has now taken hindi language imposition issue when election year is nearing to divert the attention of hindi speaking states where BJP started loosing it's popularity. Narayanji is correct.
Stalin govt should not accept the proposal of Amit Shah . It should file a case in a constitutional court for Stay .
Mr. Vadakkan, please ask PM not to try speaking in Tamil, he is just murdering it, we hardly understand a single word that he utters, it really hurts us...
Better than sudalai stalin his pronounciation is worst
@@rbhargava9676 If you don't know Tamil, please... Does he at least speak your language Gujarati properly?
I am a kannadiga not gujarati hindi our brahmin language we are proud of it
@@rbhargava9676 you can be but dont speak for whole kannadigas
Just shut up North karnataka coastal karnataka are not fanatics they respect our national language except South interior karnataka anyway we hate dk dmk people they should ve driven away from karnataka
Even West Bengal they are against Hindi imposition why you media not showing it.
All.the Southern States are not opposing.Hindi ! It is only in Tamil Nadu ! That is also only by.the Dravidian Parties ( DMK & ADMK)
That is their. dirty political.survival !
RSS why silent on 22 crores Hindus have no food for one time daily , it working for Gujarati corporates to buy MP MLA s
Instead of Hindi, make Tamil the medium of instruction in all IITs, IIMs and other central universities. Tamil is the oldest and classic language in India. So respect the language by giving it priority.
In iit madras only ,it is possible
@@harishprabhakar9744 If Hindi can be made the medium of instruction in Tamil Nadu, why Tamil cannot be made the medium of instruction in Hindi speaking states
Hindi me mbbs sirf hindi speaking states me shuru hui hhhh baaki me nahi ,,,, ,tamilnadu ke log tamilnadu me raho
@@harishprabhakar9744 Tamils are not coming to Hindi speaking states; in fact, it is Hindi speakers who are coming to Tamil Nadu
70% of the construction workers are Hindi speakers
Tamils are not selling panipoori in Hindi speaking states. But everyone who is selling panipoori in Tamil Nadu are Hindi speakers.
This the case in Kerala, Karnataka, Andhra and Telungana
@@voice2712 time change hoga
Maharashtra ke baad up ki economy aa gayi h fir gujraat aur fir tamilnadu okkkk
One more important thing reconstitution of parliament seats new seats are gonna come after delimitation . Hindi heart land will be rewarded with more parliament seats because of its high population and rest of India will be punished with less seats because of controlling the population by successful implementation of family planning. Very very dangerous for all non Hindi native speakers.BJP thinks to come to power again by winning subsequent seats in Hindi heart land that's roughly about 250 seats that's why BJP is appeasing hindi speaking people
It is hightime we realise that we are living in someone else's country (Hindia)
No need of national language.
Same question to northern states,,,why not Tamil Telugu malayalam Kannada in northern states,,,u teach first out languages
Before Aryans this land belongs to tamils when sanskrit entered into india Tamil language split into telugu, malayalam, kannada , tulu languages, actually we Dravidians are real indians hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥....
@@karthikkarthik453 thanks dude
We Respect our mother language Kannada why I speak to Hindi.... We are not UP MP Northern states we are Dravidian states we are own language and culture do you know that........
For the purpose of interacting with anyone across the nation, yes, one should learn Hindi in the current day context. But the recommendation for implementing Hindi as medium of instruction in IITs and IIMs will entirely block the gate for Tamils and students of entire southern states. Most of the north Indian students who are even doctorates in various disciplines can not properly read, write or speak in English. Even during viva for civil services, an interpreter is provided to assist to assist the aspirants in the interview. Instead of improving the standard of English, the current dispensation is contemplating to introduce Hindi as medium of instructions in the institute of higher learning. Even if Hindi were to be in place in Tamilnadu, it would be one language paper for the students and it wouldn't have found its place in learning other subjects. The venture of Amit Shah headed committee will not only face stiff opposition from Tamilnadu and this action would make the people of southern states to unitedly fight against the move of the Centre till it scraps the recommendation since it takes away the liberty of studying in English in IITs and IIMs. Anyway, BJP has given a wonderful subject to DMK to salvage all the 40 loksabha seats in the 2024 election. Shri Annamalai, though a new entrant to BJP from Tamilnadu, Shri Amit Shah could have solicited his opinion as to the implementation of the recommendation of the committee in introducing Hindi in IITs and IIMs. In the opinion of many in Tamilnadu, BJP is devoid of intellectuals politically and educationally to a larger extent.
Then regroup all states and make India a unitary government, lets not forget states were separated on the basis of language.