"what kind of person tries on clothes and then leaves them on the floor liker this" Im going to take an educated guess and say youve never worked retail Its not every customer thats aweful, but the aweful ones are the ones who'd do that
I absolutely despise James Corden but I’ve always liked his two Doctor Who episodes. I guess I just like it feeling a lot more down to earth everyday life, and I do like Smith and Corden’s chemistry quite a lot.
Yeah I agree, there's something just nice about a super grounded episode. James acts more how a normal person would react to being around the doctor. The mundane aspect of his character against the doctor just works.
Honestly it's hell working in any sort of commercial business. I worked at a swimming baths for a while and on more than one occasion we found literal feces in the showers. People are savages.
How I understood the River Song storyline is that she was stolen as a child to be raised by the Silence, escaped as a kid and regenerated into Mel as we knew her, still with the poisoned thoughts of wanting to kill the Doctor though. Then in Lets Kill Hitler the Doctor shows her the error of her ways and she goes on the right track, only to then be kidnapped by the Silence and forced to wear the suit to kill the Doctor.
@@Heisenborg it's contrived. Her being kidnapped feels like they don't wanna deal with the consequences of any particular plot point. "Wouldn't it be crazy if River killed the doctor! Oh don't worry, I'll come up with some explanation for it...Wouldn't it be cool if River was Amy and Rory's kid!! But it would be annoying having a baby to deal with, gotta get her away from her parents asap so we can set her up for more crazy stuff...etc"
It's all very contrived and pretentious. It's the kind of "overcomplicated" plot that doesn't feel satisfying to watch. It feels like a plot I'd create for a Sims machinima as I was going along
@@apocalypsepreventionagency That one episode where all the times are merging is absolutely hideous and the best representation of how ridiculous it got. I hate it.
When I was a little kid, my mom and I loved this episode. We must have watched it together over 20 times. While I recognize its flaws, I have an enormous amount of nostalgia for this episode and still watch it sometimes when I'm feeling down. I can unashamedly say this is my favorite episode of Doctor Who 😂
I'm not a big James Corden fan, and I don't like The Lodger that much, but for some reason, I really like this one. It's one of my favourite episodes of Series 6. I assume it's just because it's got Cybermen in it, and I like seeing them in a completely terrible state and trying to rebuild. And how was Craig so mediocre, when he was so good in Gavin and Stacey. He WROTE that as well!
“Money and scriptwriting time is clearly something moffat didnt have in 2011” ..... and... every year before and after that with RTD also 😂 It baffles me why the BBC are STILL so stingy with one of their most watched shows worldwide.
Yeah, why didn't they make the Wedding of River Song a 2 parter? It's clear that the budget was funnelled to that episode at the expense of this one, so why not just make a 2 parter and save more money?
A lot of criticisms for this episode are very valid but one thing about the Doctor going on about how tomorrow is the day he dies isn’t ridiculous even as he’s a time traveller, because the fixed point in time may state his age for instance, specific details associated with his death, he can put off the date as much as he wants but he’ll still age in the meantime and therefore a paradox could occur if, for instance, he was meant to be on that beach with the astronaut when he was 908 not 909. So in this case, he’d know that he could only put it off until the day before his birthday at latest or he’d be breaking the fixed point event. This is why he says “I can’t put it off any longer”.
I identified hard with the supervisor with the mess that was the changing rooms in the beginning. I worked in a shop and people do this. And it did Jed to drive me a bit mad.
Something that is never addressed is this, the Tardis translates all languages psychically. The Tardis knows all languages possible, as does the Doctor. But how come the Tardis never translates the languages such as Horse, Baby or Cat which can seemingly be learned and spoken?
We lose such musical and entertainment geniuses before their time... But James Cordin is _STILL_ with us. Tho I remember being very happy at the return of the Cybermats, the rest was vomit inducing.
Lol the implication of the supervisor's line is that the other girl was supposed to clean up the mess before her shift ended. Also, people leave stuff out like that pretty frequently
Doctor Who was my first exposure to the black hole of non-comedy known as "James Corden." I still maintain that his fame is only slightly less believable than Kim Kardashians, and she has slightly more to offer humanity.
when i was younger this was the only Corden episode I watched & thought he just existed in this episode not till the show came to iPlayer round 2020 did i even realise he had appeared prior.
I don’t care about this episode or Corden, I just wanna thank Harry for that massive nostalgia trip in reminding me that “Come Outside” was a thing, and how much it was a part of my very early childhood, lmao. 🤣
I assumed the silence kidnapped her twice. So when she first regenerated and kissed the doctor that was only the first attempt. They put her in that suit twice. And both times River was stronger than the suit.
Just as many others have said, that changing room is actually pretty tidy compared to how people really leave changing rooms in... I mean where's the spilled drinks, empty coffee cups, other various wrappers and litter, and occasional pile of various bodily fluids... 😬 There's a reason most retail or ex retail staff are depressed and hate everyone XD
Maybe because I watched this long before I knew who James Corden was (I live in Latin America), but I kiiiind of enjoyed the episode. It is certainly not good and full of goofy moments, but I don't know, I can't hate it. I agree with your rating though.
I've said this is in other videos that have spoken about this episode. I HATE HATE HATE the whole "speaking Baby" thing, it's just too ridiculous and stupid to be anything other than annoying and it makes no sense!
Even before he was the equivalent of a hemorrhoid I wanted his character to be turned into a cyberman at the end, love being stronger than technology is such bs
7:03. Doctor "The world is ending!" Craig "Never mind that, There's no more milk left in the house and if I don't get some milk there will be hell to pay!"
My man I worked in a grocery store and people would leave cold meat on the shelf, so we would have to throw it away, like hundreds of $$. People are awful
Harry was right to take a deep breath at the beginning of this video; as James Corden sucks the life out of everything, just by the mention of his name.
I can't say I liked the episode, simply because of the way they handled the cybermen. The cyberbody is not a suit of armour that goes over the human host. At best, nothing but the brain remains after all the cyber stuff has been put on, and it certainly doesn't get destroyed by "the power of love" bull. Corden I didn't really have any problem with, but it was all kind of meh in terms of likeable characters. I didn't DIS-like them, so there's that.
You evidentiary haven't ever had to hang around the ladies changing rooms (waiting for your gf, wife, auntie, trans/NB mate, mother, cross-dressing biker-gang friend, whatever). Ladies changing rooms are always an absolute train-wreck of clothes just littered about on the floor. The only place thats worse are ladies restrooms. Filthy, filthy places. (No, I don't go in there. I've had them described, many times by various female friends, gf's, and my wife. Anyway, that was the MOST believable part of the episode.
I know the whole not compatible thing isnt a criticism of this episode since it was written first, but i still think its plausible that the master, a time lord, would be able to make time lord compatible cybermen
I have to admit that even though everyone hates on the chibnall era I personally think that this episode is worse or on par with the majority of his episodes.
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [WEDDING OF RIVER SONG REVIEW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vVZ6lYryZj0/mqdefault.jpg)
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [WEDDING OF RIVER SONG REVIEW]](/img/tr.png)
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [THE NEXT DOCTOR REVIEW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/b09eTgLRZ0M/mqdefault.jpg)
![DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [NAME OF THE DOCTOR REVIEW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zLI9rxyg2F8/mqdefault.jpg)
"what kind of person tries on clothes and then leaves them on the floor liker this"
Im going to take an educated guess and say youve never worked retail
Its not every customer thats aweful, but the aweful ones are the ones who'd do that
People can get this entitled... gosh
Primark mate
I absolutely despise James Corden but I’ve always liked his two Doctor Who episodes. I guess I just like it feeling a lot more down to earth everyday life, and I do like Smith and Corden’s chemistry quite a lot.
@Sic Semper Tyrannis I agree.
I reluctantly agree, although I still definitely have a firm anti cordon agenda
Yeah I agree, there's something just nice about a super grounded episode. James acts more how a normal person would react to being around the doctor. The mundane aspect of his character against the doctor just works.
its cuz this is british james corden
1:32
It's fairly typical for customers to just do what they want and leave a mess. I swear when I worked in retail I was slowly going insane....😃
I was just about to say… it’s pretty much a perfect portrayal of a retail life
@@DannyyF1 ya unfortunately it is....🤷
Exactly, that's actually pretty tidy for what state customers leave changing rooms in... 😂
Honestly it's hell working in any sort of commercial business. I worked at a swimming baths for a while and on more than one occasion we found literal feces in the showers. People are savages.
How I understood the River Song storyline is that she was stolen as a child to be raised by the Silence, escaped as a kid and regenerated into Mel as we knew her, still with the poisoned thoughts of wanting to kill the Doctor though. Then in Lets Kill Hitler the Doctor shows her the error of her ways and she goes on the right track, only to then be kidnapped by the Silence and forced to wear the suit to kill the Doctor.
Yeah, but it still doesn't make sense....river deserved so much better
@@nellrose4699 why doesn’t it make sense?
@@Heisenborg it's contrived. Her being kidnapped feels like they don't wanna deal with the consequences of any particular plot point. "Wouldn't it be crazy if River killed the doctor! Oh don't worry, I'll come up with some explanation for it...Wouldn't it be cool if River was Amy and Rory's kid!! But it would be annoying having a baby to deal with, gotta get her away from her parents asap so we can set her up for more crazy stuff...etc"
It's all very contrived and pretentious. It's the kind of "overcomplicated" plot that doesn't feel satisfying to watch. It feels like a plot I'd create for a Sims machinima as I was going along
@@apocalypsepreventionagency That one episode where all the times are merging is absolutely hideous and the best representation of how ridiculous it got. I hate it.
I like this episode. It’s a fun more earth grounded episode. I don’t even mind corden in this as it’s just before he became insufferable
"Don’t you think he sounds tired?"
Yea
@@Alderath989
Heyo Dismay
He sounds like he has slowed his audio.
When I was a little kid, my mom and I loved this episode. We must have watched it together over 20 times. While I recognize its flaws, I have an enormous amount of nostalgia for this episode and still watch it sometimes when I'm feeling down. I can unashamedly say this is my favorite episode of Doctor Who 😂
I'm not a big James Corden fan, and I don't like The Lodger that much, but for some reason, I really like this one. It's one of my favourite episodes of Series 6. I assume it's just because it's got Cybermen in it, and I like seeing them in a completely terrible state and trying to rebuild.
And how was Craig so mediocre, when he was so good in Gavin and Stacey. He WROTE that as well!
“Money and scriptwriting time is clearly something moffat didnt have in 2011”
..... and... every year before and after that with RTD also 😂
It baffles me why the BBC are STILL so stingy with one of their most watched shows worldwide.
and hilariously so much into Eastenders.
1:33 I guess you've never worked clothing retail. This is exactly how some people leave the fitting rooms.
Yeah, why didn't they make the Wedding of River Song a 2 parter? It's clear that the budget was funnelled to that episode at the expense of this one, so why not just make a 2 parter and save more money?
7:52 No it wasn't. "The ship was there before the shopping centre", while not the most inspiring, is still and answer to "Why a shopping centre?"
A lot of criticisms for this episode are very valid but one thing about the Doctor going on about how tomorrow is the day he dies isn’t ridiculous even as he’s a time traveller, because the fixed point in time may state his age for instance, specific details associated with his death, he can put off the date as much as he wants but he’ll still age in the meantime and therefore a paradox could occur if, for instance, he was meant to be on that beach with the astronaut when he was 908 not 909. So in this case, he’d know that he could only put it off until the day before his birthday at latest or he’d be breaking the fixed point event. This is why he says “I can’t put it off any longer”.
I identified hard with the supervisor with the mess that was the changing rooms in the beginning. I worked in a shop and people do this. And it did Jed to drive me a bit mad.
Something that is never addressed is this, the Tardis translates all languages psychically. The Tardis knows all languages possible, as does the Doctor.
But how come the Tardis never translates the languages such as Horse, Baby or Cat which can seemingly be learned and spoken?
Maybe the Doctor is making it up?
@@user-is7xs1mr9y he is a liar
The doctor lies
Wake up.
See James Cordon.
Day ruined.
6:42 stop making me giggle
We lose such musical and entertainment geniuses before their time... But James Cordin is _STILL_ with us.
Tho I remember being very happy at the return of the Cybermats, the rest was vomit inducing.
Lol the implication of the supervisor's line is that the other girl was supposed to clean up the mess before her shift ended.
Also, people leave stuff out like that pretty frequently
2 minutes in and can I just say… obviously you’ve never worked in retail lol people are savages
Doctor Who was my first exposure to the black hole of non-comedy known as "James Corden." I still maintain that his fame is only slightly less believable than Kim Kardashians, and she has slightly more to offer humanity.
James Corden, as much as I hate him, is infinitely more talented than Kim Kardashian.
I love that your opening to the video matched mine when I saw what episode it would be on.
As someone who works in clothing you would be surprised how many clothes are left on the floor and all around the place lmao
I completely forgotten about this episode
1:32
You ever been in a clothing store Harry?
when i was younger this was the only Corden episode I watched & thought he just existed in this episode not till the show came to iPlayer round 2020 did i even realise he had appeared prior.
i ReAlLy LiKeD hiS hAt
Couldn't Amy and Rory just have travelled to Colchester to look around. I'm living in Leeds but I could travel to London to do some shopping!
I don’t care about this episode or Corden, I just wanna thank Harry for that massive nostalgia trip in reminding me that “Come Outside” was a thing, and how much it was a part of my very early childhood, lmao. 🤣
I assumed the silence kidnapped her twice.
So when she first regenerated and kissed the doctor that was only the first attempt. They put her in that suit twice. And both times River was stronger than the suit.
My day be so fine
Then boom
James Corden
Just as many others have said, that changing room is actually pretty tidy compared to how people really leave changing rooms in... I mean where's the spilled drinks, empty coffee cups, other various wrappers and litter, and occasional pile of various bodily fluids... 😬 There's a reason most retail or ex retail staff are depressed and hate everyone XD
This review is literally just "If you thought the Lodger was bad..."
The actor who played val also appeared twice in classic who
Maybe because I watched this long before I knew who James Corden was (I live in Latin America), but I kiiiind of enjoyed the episode. It is certainly not good and full of goofy moments, but I don't know, I can't hate it. I agree with your rating though.
I've said this is in other videos that have spoken about this episode.
I HATE HATE HATE the whole "speaking Baby" thing, it's just too ridiculous and stupid to be anything other than annoying and it makes no sense!
I told ya Harry, I told ya you wouldn’t like the power of love ending
Even before he was the equivalent of a hemorrhoid I wanted his character to be turned into a cyberman at the end, love being stronger than technology is such bs
7:03.
Doctor "The world is ending!"
Craig "Never mind that, There's no more milk left in the house and if I don't get some milk there will be hell to pay!"
RIP Pippin
I think this was before James Corden was all that famous
That Hamilton insert 😂
I wish I got the colchester leadworth joke. Lol
What song is at 5:04? It’s on the tip of my tongue but can’t work it out
psycho - slowthai
Yo did u just attack our home girl Auntie Mabel
pain
Oh god you just reminded me of that dog.....I'm sad now
I mean, to be fair, we are all addicts when it comes to living.
My man I worked in a grocery store and people would leave cold meat on the shelf, so we would have to throw it away, like hundreds of $$. People are awful
I think by tomorrow I'm going to die he means in 24 hours from then.
Don't want to seem petty but please tell me you do know what the "cyber rat" is please or don't you actually know?
I don't care what you say, I like flashing lights trope. Because losing electricity is a fucking nightmare, especially at night.
Harry was right to take a deep breath at the beginning of this video; as James Corden sucks the life out of everything, just by the mention of his name.
1:35 trust me they do hahaha
Man. I can't stand James Corden. But this episode is a guilty pleasure of mine. I enjoy it a lot.
I like to think that Rule 1 is that the Doctor lies, and the first lie is that Rule 1 is Don't Wander Off.
Still dumb though
Harry it's very disappointing you didn't use the Come Outside "Good and strong" bit in this review at any point ☠️
I can't tell if Harry made up the "I really liked his hat line". Did he? It seems too cringe for me not to remember it
I can't say I liked the episode, simply because of the way they handled the cybermen. The cyberbody is not a suit of armour that goes over the human host. At best, nothing but the brain remains after all the cyber stuff has been put on, and it certainly doesn't get destroyed by "the power of love" bull.
Corden I didn't really have any problem with, but it was all kind of meh in terms of likeable characters. I didn't DIS-like them, so there's that.
I like Closing Time
This is my all time Favorite Doctor Who episode! My very guilty pleasure
Reason number 523 I avoid post 1989 Doctor Who at all costs.
Oof
Oof
Oof
5 HOURS!?
You evidentiary haven't ever had to hang around the ladies changing rooms (waiting for your gf, wife, auntie, trans/NB mate, mother, cross-dressing biker-gang friend, whatever). Ladies changing rooms are always an absolute train-wreck of clothes just littered about on the floor. The only place thats worse are ladies restrooms. Filthy, filthy places.
(No, I don't go in there. I've had them described, many times by various female friends, gf's, and my wife.
Anyway, that was the MOST believable part of the episode.
Series 6 is as confusing as the FNAF timeline.
I like this episode
I like James Corden things like his two Doctor Who episodes as well as him as Smithy in Gavin and Stacey but I despise him.
Unrelated, but has anyone else noticed the Doctor Who TH-cam channel's videos have been deleted? Or is it just me?
the only good thing is the cybermats
Yeah but....when did amy become a model???????
She's Nurse Gladys Emmanuel, and none of your nonsense!
Yes
the lodger was great. This one... not so much
I know the whole not compatible thing isnt a criticism of this episode since it was written first, but i still think its plausible that the master, a time lord, would be able to make time lord compatible cybermen
SUSSY SUS SUS SUS SUSSY
Harry I love your channel but…
YOU LEAVE NURSE GLADYS EMMANUEL ALONE!!!!
Loved the Hamilton reference
I really liked this daft episode - love the LGBTQ stuff, especially as a chubby chaser mmm
James Corden is not a bad actor
8/10
James Corden has ruined so much for me.I will say the thing of love ending the day is rubbich
sussy
Sussy
Yes it sucked! Terrible comedy everywhere and the Cybermen are a goddamn joke.
2/10
I have to admit that even though everyone hates on the chibnall era I personally think that this episode is worse or on par with the majority of his episodes.
Yoooo
Also loved the 2 emotional speeches the doctor makes in this episode, the actual story tho sucks
Really poor episode. Do you think you could review classic episodes that are either considered classics or worst of classic who?
Stop just Stop .. these Episodes Are Awesome .... Don't you have a Creative Avenue To Pour The Time You Wasted Making A Video So Obviously .... Really
At least it was better than the lodger
As a resident of Colchester I promise you it looks nothing like this