@@MTGGoldfish you also uses a deduce with 4 mana and the opponent was tapped out. And just didn't crack the clue. But that's doesn't matter if your opponent doesn't have any threats in their deck
@@ryanc3201 that's how I view his content, I judge how he plays the hand against how I would play it. And so if he forgets to do something. It's noticeable. But usually he talks through his choices. It helps me become a better magic player.
It's interesting how many "Why are there so many copies of this effect all in Standard at once?" decks opened up because WotC randomly decided to extend rotation an extra year.
I assume it was to differentiate it from alchemy right? since that is still 2 years but also includes the expanded universe sets they end up being fairly different
@@Vael221 WOTC decides changed std rotation based on paper cards mostly, some excuse about retaining value (which is irrelevant on Arena obviously). Alchemy is arena only so no reason to extend rotation.
I remember playing MTG with my friends back in the day, and we knew each others decks so well that we would run Jester's Caps and try to snipe each others win-cons.
Game 1 was literally the act of pulling apart an insect's limbs one by one and just an absolute satisfaction of playing with your food. Such an exquisite lobotomy!
'It's important to know what's in your opponent's deck' *exiles Guardian with Kotose, misses the one in the graveyard, uses Deadly Cover Up, exiles the Guardian he had missed and then says 'oh it was a 1 of'. Amazing :D
He exiled Coppercoat with The End, then Knight with Kotose, then Guardian with Deadly Cover Up. He didn't exile Guardian with Kotose. In fact, the Guardian was only in the yard because of deadly cover up.
When everyone wants to play something that you can just read off a small list and an entire tournaments worth of decks become unplayable its comepletely justified. Im a modern player and im wanting to build a lobotomy deck simply to punish uncreative people for making the game unfun. Im sick of seeing the same decks copy and pasted and printed out into sleeves, it completely kills the spirit of magic, Net decking metas and such. All these cool and fun cards an you want to play the same exact deck a thousand other people are playing??
LANTERN!!!! I remember when you played Kaya with surgical extraction Tron, the matchup against Merfolk was legendary. I have wanted you to play another deck like that for literal years!
Yes! He played freed from the real and the opponent just led the game with lighting bolt on their main phase and just kept tapping out every turn and the game was super easy
@@henrye3935 That's right! I'm going try and look for the video because I'm pretty sure it was close to ten years ago. Edit: I tried to linked it but you can search MTGGoldfish pretentious burn and it will pull up under a Much Abrew Freed From the Reel deck. Important part is at the six minute forty-two second point.
My thought as he started explaining the video from the start: Oh... He's exiling all of his opponent's nonlands, I get it now. Here I thought the challenge was winning with a deck on only lands.
I remember the "not pretentious" burn player. They would main phase their instant speed burn spells because playing on your opponent's turn was 'pretentious'
An interesting line during the Sheoldred part would have been to Path of Peril, bounce their Kotose back to your hand, Path wipes out the lockpick fairy, then sheoldred's edict kills the sheoldred.
Surgical and extripate, gimme the oldies! The new cards for this archetype have been great, "test of talents" "the end" haven't tried "deadly cover up" yet but definitely look to add it
I found that the end and coverup cost too much mana to play a lot in historic and use KRCG challice of the void, night of soul’s betrayal and the stone brain alongside wishclaw talisman and lifegain removal in march of wretched sorrow and consuming corruption.
I don't remember the exact video, but i do recall it was a Burn player who would just fire off Lightning Bolts main phase because playing at instant-speed was "pretentious".
You rock, man. Favourite TH-camr period. You are generous, a clever gamer, and so genial. Keep me playing Magic not gonna lie. Thanks for all your time and efforts.
Reminds me of an old friends mono black ramp deck. He would use armiliary sphere and terrain generator to ramp into urborg with cabal coffers. His entire game plan was to kick sadistic sacrament then use a drain card to kill. The one that costs two plus x and spend only black mana on x to drain that much. Fun memories 😊
I love this so much. It makes me think of the time, way back in return to ravnica and everyone was playing mono red, golgari value, and American control. I took our FNM by storm with budget grixis control with that one griffin that let’s you stack your deck and a full set of psychic intrusion, thoughtseize and dreadbore to make sure none of those elspeths hit the battlefield!
50:30 WOTC decided extended had failed, so now a decade later after standard failed they are making it extended, a format that was ALWAYS better than standard
I’ve seen deadly cover up and the end do work against domain because once their atraxa is gone wraths take care of heard migrations too easily, but this is pretty incredible. Extracting every creature from a mono white aggro deck is a sight to behold.
That was glorious! I actually tried something similar not long ago, but I didn't go all-in enough with the lobotomy cards and therefore it ended up being essentially a weaker Dimir control deck. Time to try again by embracing the jank more!
This archetype is honestly one of my favorite things. Sure, Extraction effects are only good against combo decks... but if you have enough of them, any deck is a combo deck. It's also deliciously salty, because your opponent ends up losing to a deck that conventional wisdom says is completely terrible. It's one of those weird things about Magic, like how Lantern works despite consisting primarily of objectively terrible cards, or how threatening a combo can be stronger than actually executing it (see Temur Twin for a good example of this).
Deadly Cover-Up is definitely a power house of a card. I took inspiration from your Land destruction video and made my own and let me tell you that you should've seen my opponents face when I used it to get their basic lands😂
I’ve been planning a deck with this concept for a while, I just never got around to building it due to not having the wildcards for it. Fun to see it in action
@ 36:00 roughly, after casting stone brain and exiling virtues, you should have casted path of peril for 3 mana, bouncing kotose back to your own hand with the hullbreaker trigger, it would have killed the prankster, then you casted sheoldred's edict to get rid of sheoldred, then the following turn you'd be able to get the rest of your opponent's etalis with the kotose.
Playing at Instant Speed is so pretentious lol. I remember that. You had cast Lightning Bolt at the end of their turn. And the lyrics to The End by The Doors are "This is the end, my only friend, the end"
I actually thought about building a deck like this last week, super neat to see you had the same idea and how you did it! I don't think I would have thought of Jace, but that's a great inclusion.
When Unglued first came out, my buddy built decks to play each other. One deck I ran used Hey Look at Me Im The DCI combined with Erradicate and Quash with Enter The Dungeon and a Shaharazd (we allowed a few proxies) to ban and exile my friends entire deck. With a set of Double effect cards (broken in subgames) you have so much advantage as more and more subgames start. This seems far more efficient.
This makes me nostalgic for the miserable Seasons Past list I played at one time that kept looping all the removal from the graveyard and included this exile all of style card so in one game I just exiled all of my opponent's real cards.
I think a Slime Against Humanity with Cut Your Losses would be a very fun Standard Against the Odds. The deck I run has 30 copies of Slime, 90 cards total and I run things like Academy Wall, Fallaji Archaeologist and Picklock Prankster. It's surprisingly good and lots of fun to play
This deck looks crazy villainous and I love it. Also have a future idea for against the odds. Currently trying to brew an explorer/pioneer Crime Novelist "Storm" Deck. Not having too much luck so far, but curious how you would do and if maybe its better for another format?
I know Jace isn't supposed to be our finisher but I am so happy he is such an effective finisher especially sine most people never thought he would be that good when he came out.
Brings back memories, I actually had a flicker deck in return to ravnica standard and would just cast slaughter games over and over with archaeomancer just for the cruel laughs..
This theme gives me major Jester's Cap vibes, only on steroids lol. The Cap only let you exile 3 cards from your opponent's deck. This is on a whole other level 🤣 Edit: That reanimator deck he faced off against that had Atraxias in it ALSO had a Jin-Gitaxias in the GY at time index 30:37 which to me seemed to be the biggest threat since it auto-counters the first Artifact, Instant, or Sorcery spell your opponents cast and lets your copy spells of the same type, which can be used to make infinite combos quite easily. I'd have removed that one ASAP before the others 🤔
I've been playing a variation of this idea in historic for a few years with unmoored ego and Necromentia to just disassemble opponent's decks out from under them. Very hit or miss at times but very fun
I've been playing a version in modern, I love this archetype and the surprising variety that you can get out of it. "Sowing salt" was a brutal 1 of that I ran for a while
It would be awesome if you'd include the wildcard count for these decks. Regardless, hilarious video. I almost want to make it, but I have no idea of what is played in standard
th-cam.com/video/KUXk8c_Zg8Q/w-d-xo.html
Non-pretentious Burn!
Thank you! I was wondering if I would be able to find it.
I have spent too much life watching Seth :D
haha, I could not for the life of me remember what seth was playing, the oppo is the only thing i remember from the movie.
I KNEW!
All I can recall is that Seth has made this callback before.
“We’re gonna hold up mana for the clue”
- Seth
Doesn’t crack the clue*
I have done that too many times
I changed my mind ;)
@@MTGGoldfish you also uses a deduce with 4 mana and the opponent was tapped out. And just didn't crack the clue. But that's doesn't matter if your opponent doesn't have any threats in their deck
Seth is so lucky there are people in the comments to point out every minor mistake he makes
@@ryanc3201 that's how I view his content, I judge how he plays the hand against how I would play it. And so if he forgets to do something. It's noticeable. But usually he talks through his choices. It helps me become a better magic player.
It's interesting how many "Why are there so many copies of this effect all in Standard at once?" decks opened up because WotC randomly decided to extend rotation an extra year.
I assume it was to differentiate it from alchemy right? since that is still 2 years but also includes the expanded universe sets they end up being fairly different
Yeah, that's actually my favorite part of the change. Decks like this or 36 wraths wouldn't exist without it.
@@Vael221 It was to revitalize Paper Standard. Reception is mixed so far.
@@Vael221 WOTC decides changed std rotation based on paper cards mostly, some excuse about retaining value (which is irrelevant on Arena obviously). Alchemy is arena only so no reason to extend rotation.
@@spencerbell8386 I still don’t hear about any stores playing standard events.
HE FINALLY SAID AFTERMATH ANALYST CORRECTLY
Gentlemen, we got 'em
Eijano: RESTORED!!!!
Was about to say the same thing
He said it right exactly once last video, and mentioned he says analysis! I was hopeful that since he noticed he’d clean it up. 😂
The world is healing
I remember playing MTG with my friends back in the day, and we knew each others decks so well that we would run Jester's Caps and try to snipe each others win-cons.
LOL, back then you had what, 1 or 2 good creatures lol
Game 1 was literally the act of pulling apart an insect's limbs one by one and just an absolute satisfaction of playing with your food. Such an exquisite lobotomy!
Seth be like 'Whats up guys! Miseries back on the menu with this one!"
The pure joy of Seth in first matchup is so contagious. Thanks for the awesome jank!
2:15 The culmination of Seth's training arc
'It's important to know what's in your opponent's deck'
*exiles Guardian with Kotose, misses the one in the graveyard, uses Deadly Cover Up, exiles the Guardian he had missed and then says 'oh it was a 1 of'. Amazing :D
Yeah, the timing on that was rough, lol.
Didn’t he exile Knight with Kotose?
He exiled Coppercoat with The End, then Knight with Kotose, then Guardian with Deadly Cover Up.
He didn't exile Guardian with Kotose.
In fact, the Guardian was only in the yard because of deadly cover up.
I love this deck because a noob random assorted pile of creatures would beat it, but a well constructed deck can't.
Yeah, those random lists that play two of every cool card in someone's collection would literally be unbeatable, lol.
@@MTGGoldfishOr those people with 240 card decks. (I am one of them haha)
The corner case where redundancy and consistency are the enemy 😅
@@smegmalasagna I too once didn't understand the purpose of a minimum card count. You'll get there friend
@@smegmalasagnaYOU
Most people’s goal is to win the game, but Seth’s is to make sure the opponent can’t win
Considering some decks that were meta, it's concerning how close those two ideas sometimes are.
Yep.
When everyone wants to play something that you can just read off a small list and an entire tournaments worth of decks become unplayable its comepletely justified. Im a modern player and im wanting to build a lobotomy deck simply to punish uncreative people for making the game unfun. Im sick of seeing the same decks copy and pasted and printed out into sleeves, it completely kills the spirit of magic, Net decking metas and such. All these cool and fun cards an you want to play the same exact deck a thousand other people are playing??
It's a great we have both wrath tribal and lobotomy tribal in standard right now.
Seth single-handedly increasing Hearthstone's player base
There's a card name for that!
It's just as dumb and frustrating as Arena is at this point 😢
LANTERN!!!!
I remember when you played Kaya with surgical extraction Tron, the matchup against Merfolk was legendary. I have wanted you to play another deck like that for literal years!
Do you remember the name of the video? I would like to watch that match!
@@teafordaniel809Kaya’s Extraction. It was from five years ago
Same
Omg, I do remember the pretensious mono red player I think 😂😂 39:39
Can we get an explainer on this?
@@ethanleon7775I think it was actually Seth playing Lightning Bolt at the end of the guys turn, and he called him pretentious.
Yes! He played freed from the real and the opponent just led the game with lighting bolt on their main phase and just kept tapping out every turn and the game was super easy
@@henrye3935 That's right! I'm going try and look for the video because I'm pretty sure it was close to ten years ago.
Edit: I tried to linked it but you can search MTGGoldfish pretentious burn and it will pull up under a Much Abrew Freed From the Reel deck. Important part is at the six minute forty-two second point.
Same!
Pretentious red is one of my favorite MTGGoldfish videos. I gotta rewatch it every few months
Google couldn't find it, what's this?
@@njnjhjh8918 look up Much Abrew Freed From the Real Combo, and it’s the third match against (Not Pretentious) Burn
th-cam.com/video/KUXk8c_Zg8Q/w-d-xo.html@@njnjhjh8918
My thought as he started explaining the video from the start: Oh... He's exiling all of his opponent's nonlands, I get it now.
Here I thought the challenge was winning with a deck on only lands.
I remember the "not pretentious" burn player. They would main phase their instant speed burn spells because playing on your opponent's turn was 'pretentious'
thanks seth i’m totally gonna enjoy seeing this on the ladder this weekend! Deck is impressive.
An interesting line during the Sheoldred part would have been to Path of Peril, bounce their Kotose back to your hand, Path wipes out the lockpick fairy, then sheoldred's edict kills the sheoldred.
Came here to say the same
one of the best Against the Odds videos I've seen, very entertaining and also didactic
Yeees! I've been craving this kind of deck! Always wonderful seeing stuff like this, Lantern, or your old Kaya's Extraction :D
This and the all wraths death feel like checks on Arena players "are you playing any manlands in your deck?"
This is literally one of my favorite strategies on Arena! So excited for Surgical Extraction to be legal!!
Surgical and extripate, gimme the oldies!
The new cards for this archetype have been great, "test of talents" "the end" haven't tried "deadly cover up" yet but definitely look to add it
Deadly Cover Up & The End are so nice when aggro is your worst matchup
I found that the end and coverup cost too much mana to play a lot in historic and use KRCG challice of the void, night of soul’s betrayal and the stone brain alongside wishclaw talisman and lifegain removal in march of wretched sorrow and consuming corruption.
I don't remember the exact video, but i do recall it was a Burn player who would just fire off Lightning Bolts main phase because playing at instant-speed was "pretentious".
I amazed how well that worked first game, and sticking it to that emergence deck was satisfying to watch!
As someone who grew up making crappy Lobotomy decks, this is exactly my jam.
You rock, man. Favourite TH-camr period. You are generous, a clever gamer, and so genial. Keep me playing Magic not gonna lie. Thanks for all your time and efforts.
Reminds me of an old friends mono black ramp deck. He would use armiliary sphere and terrain generator to ramp into urborg with cabal coffers. His entire game plan was to kick sadistic sacrament then use a drain card to kill. The one that costs two plus x and spend only black mana on x to drain that much. Fun memories 😊
Easily the funniest, semi legit strategy I've seen in a while, killer stuff
Seth with the amazing and obscure Futurama reference at 26:08
Seths high, cherub-esque laughter while he cruelly dismantels the deck is a joy.
I love this so much. It makes me think of the time, way back in return to ravnica and everyone was playing mono red, golgari value, and American control. I took our FNM by storm with budget grixis control with that one griffin that let’s you stack your deck and a full set of psychic intrusion, thoughtseize and dreadbore to make sure none of those elspeths hit the battlefield!
This deck would do nothing against Crim's 67 card decks composed entirely of 1- and 2-ofs
that first game was so crazy, I was dying laughing right with Seth.
"Wow, that's a risky strategy!"
Somehow that is so funny to hear on Against the Odds.
Absolutely loved this deck. Thanks Seth!
playing white for exactly one void rend is crazy
That's what I get for hanging out with Crim (although really the white is also so we can cleave Path of Peril too).
I absolutely love deck concepts like this 😂
I love how Crim's one or two-of deck building would destroy this strategy.
Forever Seth’s mortal enemy
I love that Seth created an amnesia deck and included Jace. Very thematic
I play something like this in modern and it feels extremely weird to have effectively my own deck explained to me
"We need a wrath or we're dead" game one, yup, definitely familiar gameplan haha
What about a pre-emptive continuous wrath like night of soul’s betrayal? Or in modern the bridge
Watching seth this happy brings joy to my mornings XD keep them againts the odds going man this is amazing LOL
Petition for this deck to be called “Brainworm”
50:30 WOTC decided extended had failed, so now a decade later after standard failed they are making it extended, a format that was ALWAYS better than standard
Hi Seth, it was me who sent you the "ten extractions" deck list. I must admit that your list is more interesting!
I hated lantern control in modern but for some reason, love this deck in standard :)
I’ve seen deadly cover up and the end do work against domain because once their atraxa is gone wraths take care of heard migrations too easily, but this is pretty incredible. Extracting every creature from a mono white aggro deck is a sight to behold.
That was glorious! I actually tried something similar not long ago, but I didn't go all-in enough with the lobotomy cards and therefore it ended up being essentially a weaker Dimir control deck. Time to try again by embracing the jank more!
this deck is the msot fun i had playing a deck since ages
38:55 I remember your story about somebody who likes to play only at sorcery speed, because they find instants to be "pretentious"
This archetype is honestly one of my favorite things. Sure, Extraction effects are only good against combo decks... but if you have enough of them, any deck is a combo deck. It's also deliciously salty, because your opponent ends up losing to a deck that conventional wisdom says is completely terrible.
It's one of those weird things about Magic, like how Lantern works despite consisting primarily of objectively terrible cards, or how threatening a combo can be stronger than actually executing it (see Temur Twin for a good example of this).
i love this as a concept was already using deadly cover-up primarily for this purpose and that alone was enough to win a bunch of games
This is a crazy deck. It's like a universal hater deck. I love watching you snipe all their threats.
Kotose and Shegeki are the coolest cards from Neon Dynasty.
The pretentious instant speed reference unlocked ancient memories in me. I appreciated that
Deadly Cover-Up is definitely a power house of a card. I took inspiration from your Land destruction video and made my own and let me tell you that you should've seen my opponents face when I used it to get their basic lands😂
Super fun deck. I built it and love the interactions. Thanks, Seth!
"I'm tellin you man, he counterspelled a wrath on an empty board. It was the funniest shit I've ever seen."
I love it. I’ve been playing this deck for fun on arena since the end came out ha. Coverup just made it more fun!
I’ve been planning a deck with this concept for a while, I just never got around to building it due to not having the wildcards for it. Fun to see it in action
"We are trying to exile... our opponent's will to play Magic" might be the singlemost sinister line in this whole episode.
Sweet! The Jester's Cap/Lobotomy/Eradicate deck I had from 25 years ago is seeing new life in Standard!
@ 36:00 roughly, after casting stone brain and exiling virtues, you should have casted path of peril for 3 mana, bouncing kotose back to your own hand with the hullbreaker trigger, it would have killed the prankster, then you casted sheoldred's edict to get rid of sheoldred, then the following turn you'd be able to get the rest of your opponent's etalis with the kotose.
Playing at Instant Speed is so pretentious lol. I remember that. You had cast Lightning Bolt at the end of their turn.
And the lyrics to The End by The Doors are "This is the end, my only friend, the end"
Probably one of my more favorite decks you've played in recent memory
Dinos climbing up a beanstalk is hilarious to me
That Kaya deck from against the odds is my all time favorite deck/video I have seen on TH-cam
I actually thought about building a deck like this last week, super neat to see you had the same idea and how you did it! I don't think I would have thought of Jace, but that's a great inclusion.
Is it really worth splashing white for TWO copies of Void Rend? Especially when one of them is in the sideboard. It seems like such a waste.
Now we need a seductive goat reference, maybe bloomburrow will bring one
Excited to see surgical extraction with this deck!
I always love these decks. It’s really fun to get people with these cards
When Unglued first came out, my buddy built decks to play each other. One deck I ran used Hey Look at Me Im The DCI combined with Erradicate and Quash with Enter The Dungeon and a Shaharazd (we allowed a few proxies) to ban and exile my friends entire deck. With a set of Double effect cards (broken in subgames) you have so much advantage as more and more subgames start.
This seems far more efficient.
I really love this kind of "anti-meta" deck
This makes me nostalgic for the miserable Seasons Past list I played at one time that kept looping all the removal from the graveyard and included this exile all of style card so in one game I just exiled all of my opponent's real cards.
I WAS JUST THINKING ABOUT BUILDING THIS DECK AND THIS VIDEO POPPED UP OMG
That first game brought me so much joy lol
This reminds me of an Ice Age-era deck built around Orcish Spy and Millstone, ensuring that they drew all or no land
Deadly cover-up can exile basic lands in somebody’s deck too. so against mono color decks it’s particularly fun.
Great decktech.
I have this deck in Historic with surgical extraction, KTCG, challice of the void, stoneclaw talisman and night of soul’s betrayal. It’s super fun.
I remember hearing you tell a story about it on one of the replays some time ago I do recall.
The "pretentious instants" thing was hilarious
This deck is the most my thing kind of deck ever in this series
Seth, you're a monster and I'm here for it.
Crim is the villain we need, but Seth is the villain we deserve!
This is the most evil deck I've ever seen and I love it
I think a Slime Against Humanity with Cut Your Losses would be a very fun Standard Against the Odds.
The deck I run has 30 copies of Slime, 90 cards total and I run things like Academy Wall, Fallaji Archaeologist and Picklock Prankster.
It's surprisingly good and lots of fun to play
At 10:14 why didn't you blow up the land with Ossification on it with Field of ruin and get back Ketose and exile another bunch of cards?
This deck looks crazy villainous and I love it.
Also have a future idea for against the odds. Currently trying to brew an explorer/pioneer Crime Novelist "Storm" Deck. Not having too much luck so far, but curious how you would do and if maybe its better for another format?
I know Jace isn't supposed to be our finisher but I am so happy he is such an effective finisher especially sine most people never thought he would be that good when he came out.
There are deck trackers that keep track of what you've seen in your opponent's deck. Those will be a god-send in this type of deck.
Brings back memories, I actually had a flicker deck in return to ravnica standard and would just cast slaughter games over and over with archaeomancer just for the cruel laughs..
I don't think it's possible to surpass this video; you've won the game of Magic the Gathering.
This is my kind of deck!
This theme gives me major Jester's Cap vibes, only on steroids lol. The Cap only let you exile 3 cards from your opponent's deck. This is on a whole other level 🤣
Edit: That reanimator deck he faced off against that had Atraxias in it ALSO had a Jin-Gitaxias in the GY at time index 30:37 which to me seemed to be the biggest threat since it auto-counters the first Artifact, Instant, or Sorcery spell your opponents cast and lets your copy spells of the same type, which can be used to make infinite combos quite easily. I'd have removed that one ASAP before the others 🤔
I've been playing a variation of this idea in historic for a few years with unmoored ego and Necromentia to just disassemble opponent's decks out from under them. Very hit or miss at times but very fun
I've been playing a version in modern, I love this archetype and the surprising variety that you can get out of it.
"Sowing salt" was a brutal 1 of that I ran for a while
It would be awesome if you'd include the wildcard count for these decks.
Regardless, hilarious video. I almost want to make it, but I have no idea of what is played in standard