Union Budget 2024-25: Budget Roadmap For The Future? Shashi Tharoor Vs Milind Deora | Full Debate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ต.ค. 2024
- Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman presents the first budget of the Modi 3.0 government. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced a provision of Rs 1.52 lakh crore for agriculture and allied sectors in this year's budget. A Jan Samarth-based Kisan Credit Card will be introduced in five states. The government will also provide financing for shrimp farming and marketing. Additionally, the government aims to strengthen the production, storage, and marketing of pulses, Sitharaman said in her budget speech.
#shashitharoor #milinddeora #nirmalasitharaman #nirmalasitharamanspeech #budget2024 #budgetsession2024 #indiatoday #financeminister #bjp #pmmodi #narendramodi #rajdeepsardesai
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/c...
Download App: indiatoday.lin...
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday...
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
The amount of tax we r paying and the welfare measures we get.
Tax like Europe, infrastructure like Africa
Infrastructure...really I have seen how you keep your roads and other places so dirty. Trash everywhere, the government cleans and next moment people throw trash . You need to educate your people first from the school level, its point in screaming on TV.
@@15incognitoohh people threw trash and that’s why beams in airports and bridges collapsed?
Who wants infrastructure? We want freebies! We want pension! We want legal MSP !
You Andh-bhakt, you know nothing! Ask Dhruv Rathee ! He will convince you that India doesn't need infrastructure. We can use bullock carts and maybe flying horses!
@@15incognitoblame everybody never take responsibility is the motto of this government
They pay 50% taxes in Europe. Indians crying for like 10-12%
Worst Budget for middle working class... Worst FM
.well done shashitharor congress zindabad for truth peace unity democracy justice development employment opportunity honesty
Mr milind is acting like sanju verma😂
Chup be square-peg!
Milind as a common man I could'nt care less if i can't afford my daily bread....veggies, meat, everything is so expensive...Apple, Pepsi, Kia cars (WHY DO WE NEED MORE CARs when the roads are pathetic......
So true ..I agree totally 👍
If you can't afford daily bread, veggies, and meat then you do not come under the tax bracket. Stop fooling everyone with the same rhetoric. WHY DO WE NEED MORE CARs when the roads are pathetic. This is complete nonsense. If you are mentioning all the roads of India are pathetic by watching one or two videos then My dear I am sorry, you are blinded by the hate.
Nicely said, budget is driven by coalition compulsion. Nothing for the so called marginalised. Certain states are completely ignored. The fisherfolk, the rubber farmers, etc. The way the FM vociferously defends the budget is amazing, no shame at all. Unfortunate that the Bjp govt at the centre has no respect for federalism.
Great budget as always. Govt should impose more income tax. Cant we all give 50% of income tax for a prime minister who works 20 hours a day???
Modi ji ko puja karo desh ke virus!
@@princeofall433You mean a PM who wears fancy clothes and travels across the globe throughout the year?
@@Uff1234 India Today print media has an article on the Prime Minister's clothing expenses, ironically emphasizing that no taxpayer money is used for them. It's laughable that this trivial matter gets attention while critical issues like investment, national image, and security are at stake. Maybe the PM should just sit around doing nothing? These meetings, organized by the Ministry of External Affairs, are essential for our global standing, yet some seem more interested in fabric than in progress.
The RTI activist Sabharwal had sought the information from PMO to give details about the expenditure done (year wise) on the clothing of Atal Bihari Vajpayee from March 19, 1998, till May 22, 2004.
Similar information was sought for Manmohan Singh during his tenure from May 22, 2004, till May 26, 2014. According to a Times of India report, for PM Narendra Modi, the information was sought from May 26, 2014, till now.
The PMO office also mentioned that it may be noted, that expenditure on personal attire of PM is not borne on government account.
THE RTI REPLY
When Sabharwal received the RTI reply, he said that several people assume that the massive amount of expenditure is borne by the union government upon the clothes of PM Modi, but now that the RTI has replied, it is clarified that the government is not bearing any cost which comes along with PM's clothes.
According to the report, RTI activist Sabharwal said that he filed the RTI last year on December 9.
The aim was to clear the air around allegations levelled by political parties especially the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) supremo Arvind Kejriwal on PM Modi were right or wrong.
State general secretary of BJP Jeevan Gupta said that RTI information has unravelled the fact that opposition parties were upto a futile commotion. He added that since the opposition parties have hardly anything substantial to do, they comment over PM Modi's clothes. Gupta also said that once PM Modi wore a designer suit which was later auctioned.
Sasi Tharoor spoke about the issues faced by the common man and about the real state of the economy. Milind is talking about big projects, but Sasi talked about the pitiable condition of MSME sector which gives maximum employment. The final joke from Milind is that the government's role in employment creation is minimal. But the government is taxing the common man heavily and give tax reduction to corporates 😮
Exactly. Who gives a shit about Apple when MSMEs in India are struggling?
Also, what about Manipur - a state with the highest inflation (12.36%) in the country + devastating economic fallout from the almost 15 month conflict + floods?
Milind talks like a typical politician. He is not replying to the specific point raised by the anchor and Shashi Tharoor. Assam is governed bybBJP itself not by an ally!
Ok indian politicians need to stop watching the USA elections and taking notes on " how to Gaslight a county " 😏😏😏
I don’t have to say anything about budget 😂.. bcs I am salaried person and having already too low. But these kind of debates where 2 different parties person can seat and talk peacefully is really great.
1.) Why no free primary school education like in the US??
2.) When you have 120 billion barrels of Oil in Andaman, for 70 yrs of energy, why are we paying 110/- for petrol and 95/- for diesel? 3.) No respite from food inflation 4.) No private jobs, no improvement in jobs.. 5.) No respite from taxes for middle class!
What are you talking about man? No private jobs? There are a lot of high paying private jobs. People are simply not skilled enough. I work in the corporate world. I know the kind of employees companies are forced to hire simply because they cannot find anyone good enough. And even the experienced folks with the requisite skills are reluctant to do the job which they are being paid handsomely to do. They don't even show up to office. And I am not even talking about government jobs here. In private companies people are like this. I had long stopped blaming the government for anything. Because people in the government are no different to the everyday people I see around me. All of them are corrupt, lack basic civic sense, unprofessional, unskilled and downright pathetic.
In most European countries Primary and Secondary schools are free, social security, health service all free.
Too much talk; too much pampering; too many lies; too much greed; too little sincerity; too little compassion; too much criminalty ; too much fraudulent promises; too little fruitful work; too much extravagance; too little simplicity; too much arrogance; too lttle humility; too much pretentiousness; too little transparency; too much fear;/too little self confidence; too much pompousness; too little truthfulness; too much antics; too little love for others.
How can the world live in peace?
Deora yesterday Congress today RSS/BJP/Shinde perhaps he is not sure where he is, here today there tomorrow. His father must be turning in his grave metaphorically though!!!!!!
Whatever the budjet, im fed up with paying taxes and getting nothing. Thease people are taking developments , it is shame, we are not able to make a goo,d road ( means in a single rain, the road is vanishing ) so if you want to live in India, you need to know cheating like politicians or business man and you must be a poor whom get all free. These politicians are killed middle class people and still killing
If you are talking about Kerala then you are absolutely wrong, the highest payment by the central govt for new national highway project, suggest you drive from Kasaragod to Trivandrum, Vizh Port , then most important is the railway development in Kerala, yes if the Kerala govt has squandered money on unwanted luxuries then you are correct, Keralites have elected them and they face the consequences 😮
You are the last one to talk. Get your facts checked since the freedom of India. Your state got pampered with honey and money all along from previous governments including this one. You just got robbed by the leftist and Chinese people.
Milinds best suited job is to wash the shoes of FM minister and use it as a pillow to sleep on it.
Sadly, Mr. Deora has more and enough money, but we will definitely use it as a pillow.
@@jeffancy1 money doesn't matter if someone decides to do consensual slavery under others feet 😄😄😄😄
Where is the contra-budget of the INDI alliance? Why don’t states want to compete with each other and become at least a trillion-dollar economy? WB has a coast; why isn’t WB trillion-dollar economy? Some people deserve a “pessimist trophy”. So does Mr Tharoor🏆
Mr Deora nearly 25 mınutes were spend dıscussıng allocatıon for Bıhar and AP Sır be genuıne understand the plight of mıddle class and others
I understand the pain of Taxes and that burden. But this is the cyclic effect brought down by the previous governments including this government, and also by not bringing more people under the tax regime gradually. For example, farmers do not come under tax even if they are earning 10 times more than me or you. This is the scary part: if the government taxed farmers, all the streets of Punjab and the common man would get on the road for the strikes. We are our own enemy. Opposition rants on Adani Ambani issues, opposing projects which are in the welfare of states and its public. I had high hopes for the opposition but when I see them blabber things and the same rhetoric without any sensible facts then it aches me. I literally cannot defend them just for the sake of defending them.
Milind a jumper... betrayal 😢😢😢
Very true
I remember Milind Deora criticism of BJP Government. Year before he had sharp attack on Nirmal Sitaraman.
Bihar, Odisha, Jharkhand are 3 states if gets to work with full potential can drive India's 5 trillion dollar economy rapidly. They should be uplifted whether they are part of ruling party or not
Why do you think a trillion dollar economy is good?
You can't consider all 28 states for that sum of budget , but can consider that may matter most at the moment..
pampering is the act of politics in India from 1947 onwards. Under what basis the Andhrapradesh state has been divided into two?.what was the promise extended to build new capital? The Congress started the appeasing politics in India .
BJP divided it and u should question the BJP 😂😂 🤦🤦
Hey u r the one who said : My ground Assessment BJP will get 420 😂😂😂 Sanghi Blind bakth😂😂😂
@@dinesh6489 ignorance still leading.
@@dinesh6489 Modi is ruling.
Milind - what type of highways and bridges is constructed, see how many bridges collapsed ?
Good budget
India has only two states Bihar and andhra
Great budget as always. Govt should impose more income tax. Cant we all give 50% of income tax for a prime minister who works 20 hours a day???
Pls add Gujarat too
What prompted some to comment BHIAR AND ANDRHA ARE ONLY STATES OF INDIA. AP GOT WHAT THERE IN REORGANIZATION ACT WHICH WERE DENIED EARLIER.THIS PROVED COILATION HAS TO COME TO GET WHAT IS PROMISED BY THE PARLAMENT.
😂😂 Khan from South
Get Subramanian Swamy to rat out Nirmala
Parkala Prabhakar will also😂
Shashi tharoor himself accepts it is only facilitating debt for andhra and not any direct giving; how come then patronising the coalition partner. It is intelligent management. Again, shashi tharoor was telling on apportioning from CSR funds, again, it is better management rather than inflation fuelling money supply from government and at the same time addressing the issue of employment. Milind has nicely said about on cell phone importing creating debt and today exporting providing employment and containing trade deficit. It is the financial management one has to look and that is excellent.
See this is manners and education
Milind Deoraji though you have our respect you are a traitor for switching parties. Congress made you what you are today. You left Congress for your selfish gains and you will regret in your life.
true, also why should someone in STCG give so much money if someone earns 50k and if someone earns 500k there is huge difference , there should be different deductions based on profit s, don't need to simplify tax make it complex no issues but don't charge everyone same , everyone does not lead a same life rich has luxurious life where as poor thinks of how to send daughter to school
Mr Milind Deora is living in a dream world where inflation is coming down, unemployment is coming down. Mr Sardesai wake him up
@@narayanan26 only govt jobs are not jobs. Try private jobs then u will know.
Looks like SS stays ignored in the budget despite the 9 MPs
It was a good discussion beyond politics
Best budget after independence of India.. Modi ji always stay with common man..
Shame on Milind deora
But why?
Shame on rice bags
Chup be traitors k chamche!
The tension between political survival and equitable administration. It's a valid concern that if budgetary decisions are overly influenced by political considerations, it could lead to imbalanced development and potential instability.
In April 2020 The Brazilian government established a benefit for its people, with a value of BRL 600 ($1101) per person (up to 2 people could receive it within the same household)
At least now a non finance person is able to understand budget.Congress budgets were just numbers and datas thrown at us.Also it’s correct qualifications are not guarantees that candidate is employable so industrial training proposed is an opportunity.
In the end the middle class is suffering all this talk about allocating funds for the development of the country we are seeing from centuries and all our money goes into the pocket of these politician. It's waste of time watching these debate.
The salaried class continue to be squeezed. It's just so appalling to see that income tax rate remains unchanged, long term n short term capital gains tax is increased where we invest money after paying income tax to govt and on top of all this we pay 18pc GST on every product or service we buy. There is absolutely no benefit and focus on the salaried class. It is encouraging salaried class to look at ways and means to save tax which may actually enhance black money
Milind deora ditched congress? Cant believe.
The family took benefit from congress for several years.
Modi Modi Modi everywhere Modi Modi,demons' days are numbered!
Rajdeep says reduce LTCG since he is adversely affected by it. I like him for saying that 😂
Stop talking of IPhones talk about Income tax and tax benefits to middle class people. This person enjoyed all the benefits from congress and parachuted to bjp.
Congress brazenly did injustice to ap during partition further self immolation methods of economic management of ysrcp did deprived ap development coilation govt forced to do some justice to ap. WHEN COMPARED TO EARLIER CONGRESS COILATION BJP HAS NOT COMPROMISED ON NATIONAL PRIORITIES.
We can put a new slab for income above 50lakhs as 35% and above 2 crores as 37%, because for company GM directors free furnished house,free electricity house help,cook, provisions, free car with driver,all plane travels free after that he will get for example 5 to 500 crores a year we can tax him 35 to 37%.Narayanamoorthy, Ambani can pay some extra tax they are not eating gold, same food like us.
I find Tharoor in an attacking pose but he firgets inck Rajdeep that why Cong gave disastrous performance with MMS Sonia Rahul headed govern ? Why nation is showing improved oerformance in almist all fields incl Health n Edu over Cong did in six plus decades ? Karnatak govt is raising taxes why ? Is this not inflation ? Why give freebies to get votes n why increase taxes ?
It is natural every opposition parties will oppose the ruling pary even if they present good budget. Finally it is people of India should give the certificate for the outcome of the budget benefits.
It's the worst budget. Just squeezing money from people and no proper plans
What about freebies provided by these states' government , which could have been used development projects. Shashi contradicts himself . Initially, he claims that cg is supporting only allies, and then he says they are not providing relief but facilitating credit only.
Milind is not so happy post June 4. Grass is turning green where you left from🙂
They have been talking about employment since last 10 years 🤣🤣🤣
Rajdeep has his own agenda.
InternationalCivil Servant VS BombayTurncoat
So 2004-2014 were all "kursi bachao" budgets. Congress got 145 and 206 seats then. Dr. MMS said "coalition dharma". Double standards.
Ever heard of 'two wrongs don't make a right'?
1st- The stupid dots alliance are misleading people. 2nd- Especially Bihar has been neglected by Congress after they gave the "bimaru" tag to many states. 3rd- All states have got and are getting their share from the union budget. 4th- The dots alliance have only mislead people as they cannot win elections without peddling lies as there are no scams in the present dispensation. 5th- I saw the 2004-2005, 2005-2006 budgets. UPA then gave Bihar huge grants at that time and when Nitish came to power, Bihar state was not mentioned in the budgets. 6th- Just because the states names are not there in the budget, it does not mean they are not been given a share and they have to be given a share according to Finance commission guidelines and rules.
Look at conditions of mumbai roads it’s pathetic
Mr. Deora, what about the farmers of our state?
Because giving to congress states are same like to giving to freebees
Anyone plz tell these traitors to take classes from Modi ji as to how one should love his/her motherland!
As usual Sardeep always interrupts! He won't let others talk.
Nice to hear miland & tharoor are friends!
He has to moderate the discussion. He let both talk for a long time uninterrupted as appropriate.
The allocation of Rs 72 K For port in Maharashtra will be constructed by ADVANI, SHAME! For belligerent stand of their interest on one GUJARAT who keep reporting NPA and loaned given to him are written off. Why keep giving loan by banks to failing company.
Milind Deora - what about common people ? u r an industrialist n ur father as well. No one need mobile,
Food prices, LPG ,patrol, diesel, who is taking measures to control prices.
Why Karnataka giving away freebies when they no money
Now they want center to pay for their mistakes????
Deora the sell out....Switch party for RS seat and now dance to the tune of the new master....
Politics 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 now Modiji in real politics mood 😊😊😊 Modi 4.0 fix ✅✔️☑️
Milind Deora is dynasty politics
Mr Deora talking about Sweden.....See the garbage everywehere its getting bad to worse....ground reality ....
Rajdeep should bring some quality people to debate with tharoor. Milind simply wasting time
Rahul's dream of Pushing Karnataka as poorest state is working perfectly. May be Telangana is next victim.
Chandrababu Naidu,his son lokesh Red book democracy ruling in Andhra Pradesh
Canada gave 300 (after tax 270) per week for those who lost the job due to covid
Cong/ UPA served themselves all these decades incl Sonia ked ten years vs sekfless non corrupt givernance by Modi Bjp. So Tharoor talks but his party doesnt walk d talk.
Hiw can milind match Sasi..😮😮
Max TAX/GST: is collected from Southern States.
28 States with9 UT.
1.4 billion indians;
So , how come collected monies are given to the FAVORED only?
To keep their SEATS..POWER.. and make more ?
what happens to the rest of the nation NON BJP states?
how?
why?
where is the justification?
we are indians first.
Budget is ok, opposition must not politicize everything, taroor is not clear' looks like want to create nonsense
Member of parliament purandeswari relitives sandya aqva drugs rocket CBI enquiry going on at visakhapatnam port, what happened?, PM Modi ji save India of drug rocket
This Milind, unethical & opportunistic 😢
one big point, who gives internships? it's only the top rich companies who give internships. Now that too govt wants them to give thru CSR funds!!! ridiculous. Most MSMEs don't give internships as they want directly trained manpower to survive. So ultimately rich cos. are benefitted thru this. Rich cos. already give good internship money. What's help of Rs. 5000/- a month to them? 😃🤣 20:32
It is natural kursi bachao. What is wrong ?
Two congressies ?? 🤔
Oh.. sorry! 😂
What good does building roads do when people driving on them are bel buddhi? Education is important. Make the country more capable.
But why this lady is so arrogant while talking to anyone in the parliament?
is this it arrogant FM reduce the long term capital gains ! ?
Milind Deora is a congressi😂
Miland is always quoting about foreign countries no idea about suffering of common India man ! Good he is out of congress !
Rajdeep permanent anti bjp every day.
Another rajya sabha seat ?
F Desai obstructs Milind, while staying silent while Shashi speaks. Nonsense.. by dalali Desai..
Shashi for pm
Worst budget for common people.
Why Rajdeep has to intrude only in noncongress. Spokesperson?
Deora is ex congress man who has lost and cut off the connections from the common people from the constituency. He is corporate man and has got lot of benefits from congress and forgot the congress and set in lap of Modi’s group.
Shashi we would have done ghotale pe ghotale my conclusion
Why not coalition compulsion, you help.more thr states which supported you...remember double engine?
Milind, you seem to be trying to convince yourself about the budget. You're body language is not aligned with what you are saying.
Shashi not accepting indians global power he continuesly blame modi government that the mentality of congress party we would never accept it in our country
Well said
Call more Shashi, if not for anything , but for beautiful english
Mr Milind Deora, it's disappointing to see you defend such a weak and useless budget.
one big point, who gives internships? it's only the top rich companies who give internships. Now that too govt wants them to give thru CSR funds!!! ridiculous. Most MSMEs don't give internships as they want directly trained manpower to survive. So ultimately rich cos. are benefitted thru this. Rich cos. already give good internship money. What's help of Rs. 5000/- a month to them? 😃🤣
Rajiv
Canada
Its unfortunate that South Mumbai is represented by a fool
Mature debate. About time BJP had more Milinds
Dalali Desai.. 😊 is Shashi a foren agent? Who cares fdi ? Indian savings is superb
Population control is a must…
Rajdeep page 3