It's incredible that Abram can speak 3 languages fluently. I feel like no one is mentioning that, for a closed off community he is able to speak really well.
Europeans won't find that so incredible I guess, and after all, Mennonites are Europeans as well. Three languages are perfectly normal here - I'm currently learning my fifth. Besides, comparable groups like the Amish also speak more than one.
@indrahx5905 What would be the practical application of such persons learning so many languages? They seem pretty much set on thst life in America. That is a genuine question mate.
I agree! i want to start a simple community. i have no interest in radical shunning. AND yes, that is very crazy, no phone to save lives.. I just think no electronics for sabbath would be nice and make us very free (maybe no electricity). maybe simple farming with animals.. ....I would still probably use a tractor too. Why do people love hiking and camping and live such healthy lives? ! (almost a rhetorical question)
The doctor was trying to use the excuse of advanced medical assistance as a justification to break the rules and become more modern. When challenged on the issue, the truth came out. He was more interested in getting the phone than in helping the community. Putting his wants ahead of his duty to help the sick. He is a disgrace.
My grandmother was a Mennonite (Conservative) and she was allowed modern conveniences unlike the Amish. She was from Indiana. Some homes did use gas lighting instead of electricity. So you cannot say that the Mennonites reject all modern technology. Communal phones are allowed for emergency and cars and cabs are allowed to take people to the hospital. My Gramma was very old fashioned and dressed very conservatively including her bonnet. She was one of the most lovely people who ever lived on this planet. I never heard her say a bad thing about anyone, ever.
@Grizzisnothome they're literally in paradise & they KNOW it because they came from Belize which isn't doing so well. So the next generation will remember it!
The insane thing is that the language they speak barely has anything to do with the German we know today. I'm a native speaker and I really have to concentrate to understand anything at all, let alone everything. It's fascinating to see how a language can develop in such different ways. I don't speak lower German myself but heard it a lot as a child but this somehow sounds different still.
I heard a bit of German when I was a baby and very young from neighbors we had. I think it's High German or Modern German. It was weird learning so many words I didn't know i until I heard them as an adult. My family spent every Christmas with then for many years and the oldest Oma and Opa spoke English with a heavy accent.
they are like the German Russians who returned to Germany and immigrated. It hasn't evolved at all and would be very frowned upon now like old German Russian families that returned to Germany instead of immigrating after WW2 as they had no home to return to. The german they spoke was the german of the late 1880's probably, they had no influence to evolve the language unlike Germans of Germany.
It's actually Low German. For several years I worked in police department that had a Mennonite police chief. Strange situation as he didn't carry a gun but he had a shotgun at home. He occasionally would talk on the phone in their low German dialect and he was surprised when I understood him. He did drive a patrol car but he rarely stopped anyone. The rare times he did you knew they were getting a citation 😮 He was definitely different to deal with.
My farm is in southwest Ohio in the Ohio River valley. I feel very blessed to have Amish and Mennonite neighbors. We shop at Amish bakeries, vegetable stands, live animal auctions, and buy all our meat from a Mennonite butcher. Pleasant, honest, hard working wonderful people. Safe secure community.
There are differnt Mennonite groups in my area....I knew Mennonites who were like a regular church, then others who dressed more traditionally but live like most people...then there are the hard core old school Mennonites....and Hutterites, who all live in colonies and farm and run communal businesses like making steel roofing. They are honest and hardworking....and scrupulously honest.....somehting I have not found in my few dealings with the local less traditional Mennonites. I am curious though about the bible passage that say no to electronic technology....never seen such a thing myself.
that's great. I love driving by the Amish, seeing the little kids out there working at the stands or helping their parents work outside, makes me wish we had more of that now-a-days with all people. I have a Canadian friend who married a Mennonite lady, shes a super great cook, and all around great person.
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru? Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
@@wildscotsman1 I was reading about that last night. The villagers aren’t happy with them either because they say the government told them they could buy plots for $25 each plot. The government instead sold it to the Mennonites for a MUCH bigger price. They sold it out from under them.
I went to Belize several years ago on a cruise and I was shocked to see Mennonites riding around everywhere in a horse and buggy in the town we stopped at. Not what I was expecting at all but it was super cool to see!
Hey There! I hope you’re enjoying our documentaries so far! Just adding a note here to let you all know that we’re currently releasing a selection of our award-winning documentaries to highlight some topics that are really important to us. The first is ‘Las Abogadas’, following four immigration attorneys over a four-year odyssey as the US government upends every law to protect those fleeing from violence and war ⤵ th-cam.com/video/tgm_d0TaAII/w-d-xo.html
I am really curious how they got on at the new location. I would love to see a part 2 showing how that community is coming along and how their families back in the old community have adjusted without them there.
@@gregorsmithI doubt the ones in the Rainforest are thriving since you can’t grow crops in the rainforest. “However, due to high amounts of rainfall and fast uptake of nutrients from decomposing organic matter by plants, the soils in the tropical rainforest are generally nutrient-poor and non-fertile.”
Amazing! This is a fascinating documentary! Will there be another one so we can see how they have come along since they first arrived at their new home? Please make a part 2!! 🙏
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru? Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
@@wildscotsman1Imagine their chagrin at discovering rain forest is not lush soil. The life absorbs every drop of nutrient leaving the earth somewhat dead beneath. Clear the life and all the nutrient goes with it.
I went to college with a bunch of Mennonites. They were not like the Mennonites on this video. They composed 35% of the students. Many of them were of Russian ancestry, descended from Russian immigrants after the Revolution. Others were German. They were intelligent, studious and had finished high school. Many went to grad school and excelled. They dated and married to non-Mennonite Christians with the blessing of parents and clergy. I played basketball with tall Mennonites who were asked to try out for the Canadian Olympics. There were a lot like Baptists in doctrine but they tended to be pacifistic, liberal in politics but conservative on personal morality. They were good students, good friends to me and some have maintained friendship with me for the last 50 years. Most of them were very social and engaging. I am a Catholic, but I loved the Mennonites I have known. The world needs more of them.
I am a pure blood Mennonite with ancestry traced to 1714. My grandparents grew up this way. My parents less so and myself even less. The greatest gift my family and community gave me was Love.
Fascinating! What sweet people. I met some Mennonites in Mexico. Had no idea they were there. They still speak German (in addition to Spanish) and sell good cheese from bicycle baskets.
I used to buy cheese from them in Monterrey Mexico. The first time I saw them them we seemed equally surprised to see another blonde person haha. I admire them so much
Some natives (aka savages) are whining about them cutting trees on their own land that they legally bought for the farms while other nearby Peruvian villages are praising them for being helpful.
The Mennonites portrayed here are quite traditional and conservative. I work for a Mennonite. He is the best boss I have had. We have become friends. He was raised in Plot Deutsch which he said is not the same as low German. He drives a truck and they have campers and all of the modern conveniences. Most of his family have motorcycles which they take on long trips. There are many different kinds of Mennonites. Some are more relaxed than the others. The ones here seem almost Ahmish. Many of the Mennonites here are very wealthy and own planes.
That, from what little I know, is not your typical mennonite. They would normally shun outsiders and their world because it goes against the teachings of their Bible. I'm pretty sure buying planes goes against every fibre of their lives. Trucks, yes, I can understand the need for them, much the same as tractors and the like. Perhaps the odd 4X4 (atv) would be useful. But a plane? You may be telling the truth, sir, but I would question their faith in that case.
@@random-person1Hello. Iam 75 years old and live in northern Canada on a farm. It makes me sad how split up Mennonites are. I grew up Mennonite Brethern and my mother was a school teacher. We dressed like other people do and I went to various schools,but spent 4 years at a private Mennonite school. After that I attended a Bible college and worked in a telephone office. Sometimes my work helped save a life. My brothers in law have their own planes because they are wealthy. However the youngest is a missionary pilot in Indonesia, We don’t ban anything. We just know the difference between right and wrong. Modern things are not a sin. ‼️It is what you do with them that matters. ‼️I do not drive my car fast because I don’t want an accident. We have a computer and TV but do not watch immoral programs. We have a lot of Mennonites from eastern Pennsylvania who do not want much to do with us because we don’t agree with all their rules. I have never worn a head covering or long dresses and my husband would find it strange if I did. I grew up in a German church but very few here in Canada use that language anymore because it is not practical. I can read and write and still speak some high German and understand some low German as that is what my grandparents spoke.My grandparents actually came from Ukraine 100 years ago. Many Mennonites were invited by Queen Katherine the great to come and farm there but they lost everything due to the Communist revolution. They began a new life in Canada as refugees and were hard working and successful. They were progressive and very much valued education whereas those called old colony Mennonites who came to Canada around 1875 did not, nor did they want to learn English. So they moved to Mexico and endured much hardship and poverty. Some came back to Canada and with the help of other Mennonites eventually became more modern. My grandfather Abram Wiens was very involved with those coming back and other Mennonite refugees arriving from Germany, Paraguay, and a few other places and I heard many stories about the leaders who led Mennonites out of Ukraine into Canada. We have a book written by my husbands grandfather called At the gates of Moscow about the journey. Iam sad these people think they must live so primitively in order to enter heaven. Man made rules are not helpful. The only way to enter Heaven is to recognize we are sinful and in need of a Saviour. IF we ask him to forgive us he is gracious and do so. We need to live a purposeful life, read and study the Bible, but we DO NOT need 100 rules. Obeying rules and being good or making our families live in poverty and medical and educational and social ignorance is not what the Lord expects of us. If He did we should still be living like they did at the time of Jesus birth! That would not be practical either. Can you imagine Mennonite farmers in flowing robes and sandals??? Salvation does NOT depend on wether I have fire insurance or if I speak Plautdietsch . It is not spelled Plot deetch either. It does not matter if I have health insurance so that I can get medical help. It does not matter if my children get educated. My husbands uncle was a doctor who served God in various countries. We think that’s wonderful to serve your fellowman. We grow grain to feed the hungry. Iam very disappointed in people that are portrayed in this video. In fact it’s very very backward and sad. A phone is a NECESSITY as is health insurance and a vehicle. Iam so sorry for these women who have to obey every whim of their husbands. Moving to the jungles is just stupid.
@@random-person1Owning an airplane has NOTHING at all to do with your faith. If you need one to fly from your ranch to town to buy the nesscisities of life and can afford it well then Thank the Lord. If you use it to take others for pleasure rides in order to gain prestige and popularity I would question your need for it. Goodness if God allows you to have a computer,which I’m sure he does as long as you use it wisely, the same goes for an airplane. God wants us to have an easier life than they had 100 years ago. Just be sure to get flying lessons first. Do you really think God wants us to suffer hardship?? There is nothing wrong with any object or thing. It is HOW we use it and for what purpose we use it that matters. If I nearly beat my horse to death for not running fast enough then I would take you to the woodshed. Other than that please stop listening to foolish people. By the way I have been a Mennonite all my life.
Where do you live?? I’m in northern Canada. I was born Mennonite and I like watermelon, farmer sausage and roll Kuchen. ( kind of like fritters that are boiled in hot oil).😃 That’s a favorite Mennonite meal.I’m a 75 year old gramma and have lived on farms all my life. I speak German and can read my grammas Gothic print Bible. My mom was a teacher for a while. I attended a private Mennonite school in Abbotsford BC Canada. That school now has over 1000 students. My husband grew up on a farm which had a lake and was only 2 miles from the airport so they landed all the float planes there. In return my husband and his 4 brothers got free flying lessons. The youngest one became a missionary pilot in Indonesia. Two others had their own planes. One used his on a farm 100 miles from town. We never had one because they are very expensive and didn’t need one.l know very few Mennonite farmers that have planes so am curious where you live. Obviously not in some ridiculous jungle. Ahhhh maybe Pennsylvania?? We have many Eastern Pennsylvania Mennonites that have moved here. Some off shoot of the Amish. They have a100 rules such as dress codes, no red allowed, no musical instruments, head coverings, no fire insurance and the sad list goes on. They think they must do all these things besides accept Jesus Christ into their lives in order to get into heaven. We are much much more relaxed as you say. They don’t even allow the girls to have high school education whereas my own mom was a teacher. My husbands uncle was a doctor. I want to clarify that Plautdietsch and low German ARE the same. Even Plautdietsch is spoken differently in Belize than in Canada. They use a lot of en at the end of words. They came from Canada in the 1930’s or so because they refused to let their children go to public school or speak English. They were quarrelsome with a few Canadian rules so moved to Mexico and later to Belize to get away from government. They have many rules which they think qualifies them to get into heaven. That’s so sad because the only way to get to heaven is by admitting to Jesus that you have sinned and need his forgiveness. To grow in the Christian life it is important to read and study the Bible. I could write all night about Mennonites but I have all ready explained a lot in my other comments if you care to read them. Glad you have a good Mennonite boss. Give him greetings from our grain farm out west. Tell him gently he doesn’t need so many rules.😊
@dorothywillms115 for 75 years old, you seem to have a lot to say. I question your story from start to very long end. Or in other words, I don't believe any of it.
I live in the mountains of Virginia. We have a few communities here. My wife and I shop at a few of their stores. They sell fabric, soap, fresh food, and lots of baked goods. They are honest people that don't have their hand out. That alone is more than I can say for many Americans. They have their own private communities, but their work supports the outer communities too. They have my respect.
I have bought many baked goods from some of the Mennonites around here. Their baked goods are absolutely amazing! The care that they put into everything the do is unmatched.
to touch on what jujjuj7676 said, abuse to all beings, btw. Not only is human abuse rampant in there communities, but animal abuse as well. They view their animals as machines or products that make them money. They’ve done well to create a facade that most people find admirable for some reason. I know first hand that especially the Amish can be very dishonest with the general public. I live in central Virginia where their population is growing rapidly. They’re buying up all the land & they think the laws don’t apply to them. Don’t believe everything you see.
@@jujjuj7676 . Right. Because abuse never happens anywhere else. What can YOU possibly do to keep abuse from happening anywhere except in your own home?? And what is "abuse"? People really need to mind their business. This is surely what these people are trying to escape.
@@mark-ish Pretty much. If someone gets seriously ill they probably believe that God will either perform a miracle and heal them or he will take them as part of his "plan".
As a Belizean the Mennonite community are an integral part of Belize with their agriculture, dairy products and Chicken. It's not all of them that are this strict and they even marry outside their own kind. When I'm home in Belize we love taking day trips to "Spanish lookout" (their Largest community) to eat their delicious products 🇧🇿
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru? Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
I wish Abram all the best wishes for the future and may his family and land prosper in the future. I hope that we can all get to see this beautiful community again in a year or two?
What I admire are a couple of things. The unity and relying on each other. Always working, there is never an excuse to not work. Not feeling the need to buy stuff we usually throw away anyway. The optimism of Abraham is pure joy.
I lived near them in Pennsylvania. They are very self sufficient and caring. During Covid they helped their community and gave so much food and helped others. They have the black cars and don't go out of line. A lot of them have opened up a little and shop at Walmart for fabric. The families look very happy but the kids stare at everything when they are out. I'm very intrigued to see what will happen in the future.
I like the horse and buggy more imho. It's very traditional and a custom that I love about the Amish. I hope they stick to that and preserve their much of their unique cultural identity in the future.
They do as far I see in Ohio and PA. Some have neighbors outside their community that drive them in groups to stores sometimes and I see them at Lowes and Walmart mostly, but I've never seen any of them actually driving. @@IchigoOren
If you knew how badly treated those horses maybe you’d think differently. The Amish have a reputation amongst equestrians for how abusive they are to horses.
Honestly, as a 37 year old Southerner, I've been considering living this kind of life. I'm sick of the world today. People are only interested in themselves. Everything is fake. Every person who I've met who live this type of life is extremely happy.
Yes, there is a certain appeal to this kind of life, but not everyone who lives it is happy. Some people I know left this kind of Mennonite sect because things were not as they seemed to the outside. I don't know about this particular group, and it's certainly not so in all of these groups, but in some of them, there's a high degree of abuse. Having said this, there are some groups in which things are really good and people are truly happy. I truly hope that you find what you're looking for and that you get peace wherever you are and where you end up. :)
@@CyclingM1867DubbysMama Yea I hear people say that but I don't think there is as much abuse within this community from any other community. Non Amish communities have their own problems too and abuse happens all over the world in all cultures.
It wasn't emphasized in the film, but I suspect that the elderly in the communities are respected and considered important members to help carry on traditions and to provide adhesion to families. From what I have seen from living in a country where the elderly WERE much respected, Japan, that goes a long way as a means to help guide children, and it is an important element that makes for a healthy society. Most modern cultures have forgotten the importance of respecting the elderly and emphasizing their contribution.
We went to Pennsylvania about 10 years ago and were fascinated. We had the pleasure of being invited to an Amish home one day and they explained they would soon be adding on a Doedy house to retire in. It’s like a suite attached to their former house which a son and his young family will move into. I like the idea but it wouldn’t be possible in a city because of regulations. And,,,,,now a days with women working how can they care for elderly parents?
Certainly everyone eventually becomes old and most will eventually need care/support of one sort or another when they become less able to take care for themselves. One thing that I think is worth mentioning though, is that I believe that when an elderly person is respected and finds meaning in their existence by feeling productive (as in helping to raise children for example), and being loved or whatever it is that enhances the sense of honor and self esteem, it can well delay the point where they will be needing support from others due to being inhibited by age and poor health. Loneliness and isolation is not something that promotes good health.
The elderly are overrated. Look at the state of congress. Both wings.this admin and the last are old enough to remember the fucking jfk assassination so fuck outta here with that.
They are 100% stuck in time. They could be using self sustaining methods proven by modern science such as making their own bio char compost and compost tea to boost their farm yield, they could upgrade many things but they are stuck in a simpler time with less knowledge.
I am german native and I hardly understand some words. But I can understand why they live a life like that, why their youth is strugling and kind of rebelling, thats normal in all societys.
There are plenty of sub 100 IQ people who speak several languages. Not to imply he is stupid by any means but even the worlds top level geniuses are fully capable of being tragically mislead.
@@Mrs.RobinsonsI think it’s better modern kids spend all day scrolling TikTok and don’t know the limit of the skies because they aren’t taught respect
This was so interesting and very well presented. The fathers featured are very loving and obviously care deeply for their families. Good luck Abram and all the families. I'd love a follow up on the new colony . ☮️
if this is the first time watching it, might want to look it up from almost every other documentation / discovery type channels. Very old video i've seen at least a few dozen times on other channels.
He’s likely died of some jungle disease by now,gone broke or his kids took him to a mental institution. He was a STUBBORN uneducated and suspicious and prejudiced and bound by the RULES which he thought got him eternal life. Sad and tragic and completely unnecessary. Old fashioned CULT or SECT.
What a beautiful documentary. When we were younger we always thought the amish were strange. As I see what the world is becoming... maybe we are the strange ones. Morals, community, marriage vows that mean something. I'm not super religious so I could never fit in.... but... dear lord to I envy their convictions and would love to visit their community and pay my respects to their way of life. *but I'm assuming they would consider me NOT visiting as my respect... so ... i shall admire from a far.
They're definitely the weird ones, but modern society has also gone downhill. I think the best blend of morals, religion, and living with modern conveniences was the 1950s.
I grew up in PA. The Mennonite’s are awesome people! They are so hard working and kind. They do not judge others. They are also very open. They will talk to you. It seems these folk are a little more conservative than any Mennonites I’ve met in the USA. More along the lines of the Amish that I know. In fact I’d like to talk to the producer of this video. All the Mennonite’s that are friends with my family have cell phones, drive cars and have electric. I could be wrong but I think this group is a little “extra”, more along the lines of Amish. There are a lot of extreme religious folk that moved to South America. They moved there because their views where a little too extreme for America and Europe. I don’t think they are the typical Mennonite’s. But what’s a “typical” belief.
They moved to south America so they could deprive those children of their right to an education and any sort of opportunity to decide their future for themselves. It's really sad.
They are old order in tradition and yes closer to Amish in lifestyle but they practice faith differently. Like the Amish barely the Bible often and that's all Mennonites do.
This is what I came to say too. I'm next County over from Lancaster County PA. These people are more Amish that speak Pennsylvania Dutch its called. Mennonite here are not like this.
Say what you want, these people have skills, one major catastrophe and most of us are done, unable to forage, grow, deal with shelter and answer the problems, not wait for help! Most of society will wait for help and die doing it.
There’s an off grid/prepper movement that seeks to be self sufficient, prodice as much of what they need as possible and do it like people did in the 800’s, using horses and mules as our forefathers did, to,relearn the old skills. And if anyone survives a SHTF situation these people will .
It all comes with a huge price.....laws rules and discipline to obey.....you have no freedom of speech and are not allowed to speak your truth and leave....what about the child abuse and traumas? This is not natural... you are not free to leave..it comes with a price.. they love you if you do 2hat they say, conditional love !
Much respect to Mennonites as well as Amish. They study at home & school and show love in the streets. Nothing wrong with this. Bless them all. They must follow the local, state and National laws is important.
I’m a retired underwriter and tracked insurance for car loans. Must have full coverage as stated in the finance agreement. Mennonites have cars and loans in the U.S. We have to accept a letter from their community saying they will cover if any damage if it happens. All policy numbers are the same SI1 (If I recall correctly). They are basically sovereign citizens here.
And they do honour their promises. The community will build any creditors an entire residential sub division if that's what it takes to settle their debt. Whatever it takes,they have resources, they have networks. The guarantee from community is probably more solid than an insurance policy.
@@m_christine1070 Not likely they will build an entire community to pay off debts. It’s sort of like a co-op. Every family pays into it monthly. Brother belongs to one for health insurance. I believe it’s 500 a month for his family of four rather than over 2 grand a month for the AHCA. He’s a small business owner and has a ton of overhead with the buildings, employees etc.
These are ultra conservative Mennonites, of course, but the majority of Mennonites in the world, like my mom's family and me, are modern people. You couldn't pick us out from a crowd of regular looking people. Most of us have modern conveniences, including TV and the internet. My mom was born and raised in the Mennonite Brethren church, which is a modern sect of Mennonites. I do have some distant relatives, though, who are super conservative Mennonites like the ones featured in this video. They live down in Paraguay. I've been fascinated by Anabaptist groups of all kind my whole life. Thanks for sharing this video about this particular group. :)
Finally a regular Mennonite. Thanks. I’m M.B. I bet your mom would be interested in all the comments I’ve left behind. I know our history very well. I’m deeply ashamed of this group and all the heartache they’ve caused and are now perpetuating like flies in South America. Benjamin B Jantz who helped 20,000 Mennonites out of Ukraine 100 years ago and my grandfather Abram A Wiens would be very grieved if they knew about this. My grandfather helped get many who came during and after WWII get their paperwork done as immigrants. His sister was married to Jacob B Jantz. These folks were never grateful to live in Canada and quarrelled a lot re language and education with the Canadian government. So they got mad and moved to Mexico and on to South America. Soon the world will be too small for them and many of us would be happy to see them leave for Mars. They can create all the havoc and heartache there because they have no government on Mars that I know of. And don’t kid yourself. These self righteous men are very abusive. They have no relationship with God. Only to their ordnance which means a zillion man made rules so that they can dominate their own families. It’s a tragedy. It’s deceitful and simply wicked but that’s how the devil works. He is never out of tricks.
P.S. The ones in Paraguay mostly came after WWII to the “green hell” in the Chaco where they really struggled for years. It was so hot they couldn’t cope well and they were even poorer than those that came to Canada. Some did come from Ukraine to Paraguay because Canada would not accept them ,usually because of a medical condition or Canada had filled its quota. My grandpa helped many that came to Canada via Paraguay with immigration matters.
50 years ago perhaps the assimilated Mennonites were the majority, but that has changed. MC-USA has fallen from over 250k members 50 years ago to perhaps 60k today. Wheras the Old Order Mennonites have gone from around 15k to 85k, the Old Colony Mennonites number up to 450k, both the Conservative and Holdeman Mennonites have increased dramatically in the last 50 years. The only very traditional Mennonite group that has shown a sharp decline, is the Reformed Mennonites. Simply because they don't raise their children in the faith, allowing them to run wild. In perhaps another 2, definitely 3 generations, the liberal Mennonite will have so completely assimilated into mainstream America as to be extinct, with only the traditional conservative Mennonites left. Unfortunately when you are a minority group and you surrender your distinctiveness as a people, taking on the distinctiveness of the majority group, they will assimilate you into extinction. That is how the melting pot works, 500 years of sacrifice and suffering, gone in a couple of generations.
@@calebalton2084 Thankyou for that information. It’s really sad but I see that in northern Canada where I now live. The MB church in my town,although popular with young families, has a Baptist minister,with Calvinist leanings. The church board is made of men who have done well financially or are just popular. They watch hockey and other sports,go hunting or quadding ,seldom read books and do not understand the scriptures because they have never attended a Bible school and don’t like to study the Bible. The care groups are social clubs. The stained glass windows are covered up with boards and bricks,illuminated with an orange glow. A lady (made the stained glass ones and is approaching 90 Her husband built a lovely communion table and pulpit,not being used, the organ and grand piano are out,taken over by an electric keyboard, hymns are no longer sung,coffee is slurped (and spilled) in the pews and most of all there is apathy and a desire to dominate,resulting in a lack,of love and respect especially for the elderly and widows. Adult Sunday school is also a thing of the past and only 3 or so men come to prayer meetings..Sunday evening services have been gone for years too. I’m sorry to sound so negative. Oh and choirs are definitely long gone. Where is the Mennonites love of music?? When you live 20 miles from church and the roads very full of ice and snow your motivation no attend slowly wanes. We pray for the MB church but we have been really disappointed the past 20 years.,,,,,,,interestingly my husband just got a call from the towns missions event planner and there too the Mennonites show very little interest. I have a friend with severe Parkinson’s in the care home and she gets almost no visitors. Nor does my mother,1000 miles to the south. Perhaps my blunt honesty will cause a few people to wake up and take notice. The MB church needs our prayers. In the end who do we think we are?
Loved the video. But a bit sad, because those children are not having the same opportunities as the others. From their birth, their paths are decided by their parents or ancestors, and they don't even know what is out there.
That actually happens to evrry body, even the country you are born has to do with that, the west just happened to try as much as possible to change it and level the playing field, it's not leveled bit it's better leveled than what's out there
My wife and I own a house and land in Belize, and we have been to Little Belize several times (we live very close to there). It's a picturesque community, and we've never interacted with unfriendly or "mean" people. We have good relationships with them, and have done business with many of 'em (a Mennonite built our interior house decor and shelving). We see many of them on the ferries, in the nearby towns, and along the streets of Corozal District. I've even had a beer with two of them at our community's local restaurant (no names will be named). 🙂 We even know some of the truck drivin', cell phone usin' "modern" Mennonites. It is sad, though, that they completely misunderstand Biblical doctrine, because they worship their traditions more than the actual God of the Bible. To see sin and evil in inanimate objects is just... silly. God NEVER said that modern appliances bar a person's entrance into Heaven. Faith in Christ gets one into Heaven, not adherence to ancient and unquestionable traditions. In fact, Jesus CONDEMNED those who cling to their traditions, and disregard the freedom of God's love shown to us through Jesus. Like I said - it's sad.
@tommyapocalypse6096 - Thank You! I've seen some documentaries on similar communities, i.e. the Amish, and the people chronicled in video and conversation are impressive. In very positive ways and IMHO very negative ways. The strengths sell themselves: division of labor / serious work ethic / DIY lifestyle / communal support from cradle-to-grave / healthy living condition / admirable stewardship of resources / land / pro-family. Yet...and this is a big yet, and it was only in the communities recorded ( can't it's true of ALL of the Amish ), they had an Us vs Them mindset towards anyone ( yes, Christians, too ) who were outside their communities as The Lost or those of The System of Satan. That's ultimately sad, but a bit angering as well. I don't have to agree with everything very traditional Christian communities do and believe, but I do challenge myself to hold them in my mind and heart with respect and love as my fellow brothers and sisters. ( I'm not saint. Not virtue-signaling. ) Maybe many of them do as well ( Amish, Mennonites, Bruderhof, etc. ). Anyone, of any community/denomination, who fundamentally sows discord among the Church is committing an abomination before God. We should be very, very careful how we view our brothers and sisters in Christ.
They may seem nice on the surface, but the male leaders in these types of communities give me abysmal vibes. That dinner scene with the 'Mayor' and his family made me feel so depressed for that entire family, look at the girls' faces at 12:50 onwards. I've seen better vibes at a fucking funeral than that, and that's every single day of their life through no choice of their own. To me, this shit is absolutely disgusting and deeeeeeply sad.
@@machtnichtsseimann They hold that us vs them mindset because NON Amish communities are always critiquing their culture by trying and always degrading them. That and they see how racist people in NON Amish communities are just want to be left alone is all they want. :) Just live and let live.. Hope that helps. 🙏
My first reaction with the settlers moving to Peru was “there goes the ecosystem” , and it looks like more recent news on that colony bears that concern out. Vast families leading to never-ending expansion into frontiers is not sustainable in the 21st century.
Sure. Once you get past the child abuse, lack of women's rights, tax evasion, rampant incest, amongst other things. Good luck if you want to leave the community as well.
Neat watch, I grew up in this community and brings back tonnes of memories. There is a neat aspect no doubt, but because it is closed off from society there is a lot of corruption and terrible things that happen in those communities. My home had personal, first hand experience. There is genuine people there though too that honestly want to do what's right for their families and they are trying to do the best with the knowledge they have.
The Mennonites where I live in Maryland don’t live in colonies, and are modern. They drive grey and black colored cars, have cell phones, are highly disciplined and are the nicest people you ever met. Maybe the rest of society should follow their lead.
This is so funny! What was reported by the local news a few years back was that this particular group of Amish Mennonites and I don’t mean these folks directly, but Mennonites is what they reported in the news was that they were some of the most profitable, biggest, drug dealers and transporters And the Canadian United States border and if anybody looks at a map where they are getting situated and located and now they are trying to go to Peru and now they’re down in Belize Mexico or Belize. I’m sorry South America it makes you think or it should make you think a little bit.
Horrible. if Adults decide for themselves to live such a live than its fine by me but children have no choice and are brainwashed. If somebody wants to be a farmer fine, if somebody wants to be a doctor fine too, society needs both but let people decide what they want.
These are old colony people.They have roots in russia, and it is a totally different group from most Mennonites. These are the most conservative of The Old Colony Mennonites. Horse and Buggy groups are a very small subset of the Larger Old Colony movement. The education was so substandard that the colony had Amish from the States that are teachers.
Wonderful Documentary, the insight of how Mennonites lives. This is the first time I heard of this Group. Your voice is clear & Crystal. I hope of of these group Follow Up. Thank you👍👍👍👍
I lived with them in Winton California for 6 months. They do love God beyond a doubt. Moving to isolated areas as they are doing here does not however follow the great commission.
My mother has very good friends I believe they are part of the Mennonites of Alberta, Canada. They are extremely good, decent people, hard working,etc. Just, honest, good families.
The Mennonites are amazing people of God. Simplistic life. They are so humble and happy, each with that contagious smile. Unlike my suburban neighborhood with overpowering wealth.
You could have said this particular kind of Mennonite. It sounds horrible beyond comprehension to me but .Iam 75 now and I was Born Mennonite. The privilege of the name should be taken away from them as they do NOT represent the majority of us. My grampas name was Abram and this is an insult to his name. He was a refugee from Ukraine in 1924. He worked for Mennonite Central Committee assisting refugees from war torn Russian Ukraine during the Russian revolution to Canada. I learned a lot from him as I was the eldest grandchild. My mother was a school teacher of 12 grades during WWII. My parents were babies when they came from Ukraine. I was aware of Mennonites who were unhappy with the Canadian school system and didn’t want their children to learn English so quite a few moved to Mexico where they lived in abject poverty. A few tried to come back and my grampa often had to meet them at the border crossings between Abbotsford BC and Vancouver. I wasn’t told much as a kid but I remembered strange events and my mother filled me in when I was in my 20’s and 30’s. It was often just pathetic, filth and starvation and new borns and their moms didn’t always make it. These men are not what they want you to think. Some of these people stayed with my grandparents till they recovered or churches found them lodging. I’m not sure if welfare was a thing in the 1940’s and 50’s but most of these people finally saw the light and adapted to English and Canada. Others stayed in Mexico or wandered even further south. All in order to keep things as they had been 150 or more years ago in Germany. It started around the time of the reformation. Our founder was Menno Simons a former Catholic priest or monk.Some Mennonites became extremely strict and narrow minded while others became successful farmers,especially after Catherine the great invited German farmers to come and toil the soil of Ukraine. They really prospered until the revolution although some came to the USA and Canada around 1875. I really don’t see how there could have been Mennonites in Belize before 1900. I think they have no idea what their history is and tell the media stories. I know the North American governments and Mennonite leadership was very frustrated with these STUBBORN people who refused to adapt to a new and wonderful land which they weren’t all that grateful to be in. In fact I can see still see my grandfathers pained face. These people simply weren’t grateful. Their God was their RULES. They lived and died by man made RULES. So did the Doukabors in southern B.C. They were a disgrace and influenced by insane leaders who burned their own farms down. These people could have hooked up with a Bruderhaus community or Hudderites which they must have heard about it but NO NO NO. All you suckers out there admiring them or thinking they seem wholesome and innocent THINK AGAIN.
@@dorothywillms115 Thanks for your words Dorothy. I wonder how much better we are off now. Seeing that the world is changing, mass depopulation and migration. A new time of an old agenda. We are now being eliminated by disease and poisoned food and water, the air we breed. The fake climate inatative. We are being controlled by the globalists above us. I guess life isn't as simple as it was and humanity is changing. Wonder if these folks knew something we are now facing in our changing world.
9:50 dit wud me t' dunkel senn,😅 dit lat schmock😅 So interesting to watch my people live this way. We are Mennonites too (from Russia 🇷🇺, now living in Germany 🇩🇪). "It's against our religion... We have to... why? I don't know..." that's really sad/ tragic...
I support several indigenous tribes in this area. I DON’T think they are going to be so welcoming. Many of the tribes are nomadic, so they might not be found out right away, but, they WILLmeet. On the other hand, I’m very impressed with this gentleman’s language skills. Would love to see a follow-up on this!
13:50 I am German, and I can barely understand a few words. I guess people from Northern Germany would find it easier to understand "Plattdeutsch". There are so many different dialects in German speaking countries, you sometimes feel they speak a completely different language.
40 families living in the middle of nowhere, where is the initial food supply and where does the sewage go while they are constructing this self sufficient community ? If someone becomes ill what happens ?
Modern society seems dark and hopeless. People tend to fight on the Internet over sensitive topics, and the age of hate has begun. Many of us are busy stereotyping each other. Excessive sense of competition, hatred, selfishness, anxiety, and depression constantly approach us. Especially after the introduction of the internet, we compare ourselves to others more often than ever and end up suffering from low self-esteem. I might believe that the Mennonites are a lot happier than us in some points...
What I am struck by most is the arrogance of religious folk that they think their desire for isolation is a good reason to start cutting down trees the names of which they have never heard spoken. Great video though, absolutely remarkable to get so much footage and conversation from such a reclusive society. Going to watch the rest of your list now. Thank you.
@@lauramann4323 that's true of course but we have already got enough cleared arable land on the planet to feed the current population more than three time over. In the last 100 years the planet lost more forest than it had in the previous 9000 years. I think humanity is covering it's eyes as it shoots it's self in the foot and these folk are a glaring example of that with their lack of concern for the environment they destroy to create an environment that suits just their own needs.
Fascinating people. It's like going back in time and seeing the world from centuries past. Not a religious man, never have been, but I'm always interested to learn about other cultures and traditions.
It is not a ""weakness "" to have emotions,,saying goodbye is heartbreaking,, emotions are what makes us all human,,all the same..To care,to love..Great great video.👍💯
It's incredible that Abram can speak 3 languages fluently. I feel like no one is mentioning that, for a closed off community he is able to speak really well.
My thoughts exactly!
He's just reciting a manual for a tv in German and dutch.
Europeans won't find that so incredible I guess, and after all, Mennonites are Europeans as well. Three languages are perfectly normal here - I'm currently learning my fifth. Besides, comparable groups like the Amish also speak more than one.
@indrahx5905 What would be the practical application of such persons learning so many languages? They seem pretty much set on thst life in America.
That is a genuine question mate.
To be able to speak to other people.
when the doctor said he couldn’t have a phone to call for more advanced medical care, that was the most crazy thing to me
Same. 😢
I agree!
i want to start a simple community. i have no interest in radical shunning. AND yes, that is very crazy, no phone to save lives.. I just think no electronics for sabbath would be nice and make us very free (maybe no electricity). maybe simple farming with animals.. ....I would still probably use a tractor too.
Why do people love hiking and camping and live such healthy lives? ! (almost a rhetorical question)
the doctor is a genius and a good man
Stop trying to put your standards on others God takes care of his own.
The doctor was trying to use the excuse of advanced medical assistance as a justification to break the rules and become more modern.
When challenged on the issue, the truth came out. He was more interested in getting the phone than in helping the community. Putting his wants ahead of his duty to help the sick.
He is a disgrace.
My grandmother was a Mennonite (Conservative) and she was allowed modern conveniences unlike the Amish. She was from Indiana. Some homes did use gas lighting instead of electricity. So you cannot say that the Mennonites reject all modern technology. Communal phones are allowed for emergency and cars and cabs are allowed to take people to the hospital. My Gramma was very old fashioned and dressed very conservatively including her bonnet. She was one of the most lovely people who ever lived on this planet. I never heard her say a bad thing about anyone, ever.
Need a follow up on their new life in peru
I could watch a whole season!! Funny because that was my comment too!
@Grizzisnothome they're literally in paradise & they KNOW it because they came from Belize which isn't doing so well. So the next generation will remember it!
@Grizzisnothome who says what is modern? It's really all perspective, but I get what your concern is.
Most Definitely
1st thing I was looking for when this ended
same for me
The insane thing is that the language they speak barely has anything to do with the German we know today. I'm a native speaker and I really have to concentrate to understand anything at all, let alone everything.
It's fascinating to see how a language can develop in such different ways. I don't speak lower German myself but heard it a lot as a child but this somehow sounds different still.
I heard a bit of German when I was a baby and very young from neighbors we had. I think it's High German or Modern German. It was weird learning so many words I didn't know i until I heard them as an adult. My family spent every Christmas with then for many years and the oldest Oma and Opa spoke English with a heavy accent.
they are like the German Russians who returned to Germany and immigrated. It hasn't evolved at all and would be very frowned upon now like old German Russian families that returned to Germany instead of immigrating after WW2 as they had no home to return to. The german they spoke was the german of the late 1880's probably, they had no influence to evolve the language unlike Germans of Germany.
I thought it was Swiss German.
Isn't their German Switzdeutsche or swiss German??
It's actually Low German. For several years I worked in police department that had a Mennonite police chief. Strange situation as he didn't carry a gun but he had a shotgun at home. He occasionally would talk on the phone in their low German dialect and he was surprised when I understood him. He did drive a patrol car but he rarely stopped anyone. The rare times he did you knew they were getting a citation 😮 He was definitely different to deal with.
Franz seems like a really good father and a very friendly thoughtful guy.
Amen to that
He had to get a phone for work !
A man should not be punished for trying to provide for his family !
My farm is in southwest Ohio in the Ohio River valley. I feel very blessed to have Amish and Mennonite neighbors. We shop at Amish bakeries, vegetable stands, live animal auctions, and buy all our meat from a Mennonite butcher. Pleasant, honest, hard working wonderful people. Safe secure community.
There are differnt Mennonite groups in my area....I knew Mennonites who were like a regular church, then others who dressed more traditionally but live like most people...then there are the hard core old school Mennonites....and Hutterites, who all live in colonies and farm and run communal businesses like making steel roofing. They are honest and hardworking....and scrupulously honest.....somehting I have not found in my few dealings with the local less traditional Mennonites. I am curious though about the bible passage that say no to electronic technology....never seen such a thing myself.
that's great. I love driving by the Amish, seeing the little kids out there working at the stands or helping their parents work outside, makes me wish we had more of that now-a-days with all people. I have a Canadian friend who married a Mennonite lady, shes a super great cook, and all around great person.
We all like having good honesty neighbour regardless of their religion
@@sailingaeolusIs any credit due, though? Honesty is what the majority of people want in a neighbor.
unless you're born into it and dont want to be a part of it, in which case your entire family will exclude you, forever. Pure abuse
This is such an interesting watch! Please follow up with part two and three even. I would LOVE to see it all complete
Yes I want to see more please I’m just curious about their life style
YES! A follow up is definitely needed.
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru?
Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
@@wildscotsman1
I was reading about that last night. The villagers aren’t happy with them either because they say the government told them they could buy plots for $25 each plot. The government instead sold it to the Mennonites for a MUCH bigger price. They sold it out from under them.
What about doctors, dentist? What happens if someone got sick? At least they are not producing trash and they don’t use plastic
We definitely need a followup on this please. This was so interesting.
I went to Belize several years ago on a cruise and I was shocked to see Mennonites riding around everywhere in a horse and buggy in the town we stopped at. Not what I was expecting at all but it was super cool to see!
I love Abrams's optimism and salute the courage of those who left all behind and the documentary team. You all rock ✨
better than bein stuck in a honky tonk prison.
Hey There! I hope you’re enjoying our documentaries so far!
Just adding a note here to let you all know that we’re currently releasing a selection of our award-winning documentaries to highlight some topics that are really important to us. The first is ‘Las Abogadas’, following four immigration attorneys over a four-year odyssey as the US government upends every law to protect those fleeing from violence and war ⤵
th-cam.com/video/tgm_d0TaAII/w-d-xo.html
I am really curious how they got on at the new location. I would love to see a part 2 showing how that community is coming along and how their families back in the old community have adjusted without them there.
there is no part 2. this is just a rerun that many other channels have but his watermark in it. Nothing else has been made about them.
Update they getting screwed out of their land seems like. They are under heavy investigation by government and conservation groups for deforestation.
Yeah me too I’m dying to know how they made out. I bet they’re thriving.
@@gregorsmithI doubt the ones in the Rainforest are thriving since you can’t grow crops in the rainforest.
“However, due to high amounts of rainfall and fast uptake of nutrients from decomposing organic matter by plants, the soils in the tropical rainforest are generally nutrient-poor and non-fertile.”
@@laikanbarth speculation
Amazing! This is a fascinating documentary! Will there be another one so we can see how they have come along since they first arrived at their new home? Please make a part 2!! 🙏
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru?
Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
@@wildscotsman1Imagine their chagrin at discovering rain forest is not lush soil. The life absorbs every drop of nutrient leaving the earth somewhat dead beneath. Clear the life and all the nutrient goes with it.
@@MavonEastThey would’ve known that if they had the internet to Google it.
@@MavonEast Please, do not speak of that which you know nothing about. You obviously have not farmed before.
@@wuznotbornyesterda I think he is right about the fertility of the jungle.
Oh, this was well done. Thank you for such a nice video. With people like this in the world there may be hope after all!
No crimes, terrorism and poverty
Amazing. Such a courageous group of people. I wish them well.
I can't wait to see follow ups of this story..and it wish them all well and success!!!
Love the hat,,wow 🤠
Wow. When he finally got to his land and grabbed the earth with his hands, I couldn’t keep the smile from my face. How awesome are these ppl !!!! ❤
I wish you’ll make a part-2 of this story.
Great video
I have a feeling Franz family is going to be different as every parent wants their children to live a better life then he did
Part 2 please ❤
I went to college with a bunch of Mennonites. They were not like the Mennonites on this video. They composed 35% of the students. Many of them were of Russian ancestry, descended from Russian immigrants after the Revolution. Others were German. They were intelligent, studious and had finished high school. Many went to grad school and excelled. They dated and married to non-Mennonite Christians with the blessing of parents and clergy. I played basketball with tall Mennonites who were asked to try out for the Canadian Olympics. There were a lot like Baptists in doctrine but they tended to be pacifistic, liberal in politics but conservative on personal morality. They were good students, good friends to me and some have maintained friendship with me for the last 50 years. Most of them were very social and engaging. I am a Catholic, but I loved the Mennonites I have known. The world needs more of them.
“Franz discovered the internet “
I love it !
* country music playing 🎶😂
As I understand there many different Mennonites, some very conservative and some very liberal about the modern society
I am a pure blood Mennonite with ancestry traced to 1714. My grandparents grew up this way. My parents less so and myself even less. The greatest gift my family and community gave me was Love.
I've never read a more accurate description of my Forfathers...Thank you,my Friend.
Absolutely! Good honest hardworking people. Who Respect others.
Fascinating! What sweet people. I met some Mennonites in Mexico. Had no idea they were there. They still speak German (in addition to Spanish) and sell good cheese from bicycle baskets.
I used to buy cheese from them in Monterrey Mexico. The first time I saw them them we seemed equally surprised to see another blonde person haha. I admire them so much
How depressing.
WOW. He speaks Spanish fluently! I am amazed. I love this type of documentary. I wish this family to be successful in in whatever they do in Peru. :)
I'd love to have an up date on this family, I wish them well.
Some natives (aka savages) are whining about them cutting trees on their own land that they legally bought for the farms while other nearby Peruvian villages are praising them for being helpful.
The Mennonites portrayed here are quite traditional and conservative. I work for a Mennonite. He is the best boss I have had. We have become friends. He was raised in Plot Deutsch which he said is not the same as low German. He drives a truck and they have campers and all of the modern conveniences. Most of his family have motorcycles which they take on long trips. There are many different kinds of Mennonites. Some are more relaxed than the others. The ones here seem almost Ahmish. Many of the Mennonites here are very wealthy and own planes.
That, from what little I know, is not your typical mennonite. They would normally shun outsiders and their world because it goes against the teachings of their Bible. I'm pretty sure buying planes goes against every fibre of their lives.
Trucks, yes, I can understand the need for them, much the same as tractors and the like. Perhaps the odd 4X4 (atv) would be useful. But a plane? You may be telling the truth, sir, but I would question their faith in that case.
@@random-person1Hello. Iam 75 years old and live in northern Canada on a farm. It makes me sad how split up Mennonites are. I grew up Mennonite Brethern and my mother was a school teacher. We dressed like other people do and I went to various schools,but spent 4 years at a private Mennonite school. After that I attended a Bible college and worked in a telephone office. Sometimes my work helped save a life. My brothers in law have their own planes because they are wealthy. However the youngest is a missionary pilot in Indonesia, We don’t ban anything. We just know the difference between right and wrong. Modern things are not a sin. ‼️It is what you do with them that matters. ‼️I do not drive my car fast because I don’t want an accident. We have a computer and TV but do not watch immoral programs. We have a lot of Mennonites from eastern Pennsylvania who do not want much to do with us because we don’t agree with all their rules. I have never worn a head covering or long dresses and my husband would find it strange if I did. I grew up in a German church but very few here in Canada use that language anymore because it is not practical. I can read and write and still speak some high German and understand some low German as that is what my grandparents spoke.My grandparents actually came from Ukraine 100 years ago. Many Mennonites were invited by Queen Katherine the great to come and farm there but they lost everything due to the Communist revolution. They began a new life in Canada as refugees and were hard working and successful. They were progressive and very much valued education whereas those called old colony Mennonites who came to Canada around 1875 did not, nor did they want to learn English. So they moved to Mexico and endured much hardship and poverty. Some came back to Canada and with the help of other Mennonites eventually became more modern. My grandfather Abram Wiens was very involved with those coming back and other Mennonite refugees arriving from Germany, Paraguay, and a few other places and I heard many stories about the leaders who led Mennonites out of Ukraine into Canada. We have a book written by my husbands grandfather called At the gates of Moscow about the journey.
Iam sad these people think they must live so primitively in order to enter heaven. Man made rules are not helpful. The only way to enter Heaven is to recognize we are sinful and in need of a Saviour. IF we ask him to forgive us he is gracious and do so. We need to live a purposeful life, read and study the Bible, but we DO NOT need 100 rules. Obeying rules and being good or making our families live in poverty and medical and educational and social ignorance is not what the Lord expects of us. If He did we should still be living like they did at the time of Jesus birth! That would not be practical either. Can you imagine Mennonite farmers in flowing robes and sandals??? Salvation does NOT depend on wether I have fire insurance or if I speak Plautdietsch . It is not spelled Plot deetch either. It does not matter if I have health insurance so that I can get medical help. It does not matter if my children get educated. My husbands uncle was a doctor who served God in various countries. We think that’s wonderful to serve your fellowman. We grow grain to feed the hungry. Iam very disappointed in people that are portrayed in this video. In fact it’s very very backward and sad. A phone is a NECESSITY as is health insurance and a vehicle. Iam so sorry for these women who have to obey every whim of their husbands. Moving to the jungles is just stupid.
@@random-person1Owning an airplane has NOTHING at all to do with your faith. If you need one to fly from your ranch to town to buy the nesscisities of life and can afford it well then Thank the Lord. If you use it to take others for pleasure rides in order to gain prestige and popularity I would question your need for it. Goodness if God allows you to have a computer,which I’m sure he does as long as you use it wisely, the same goes for an airplane. God wants us to have an easier life than they had 100 years ago. Just be sure to get flying lessons first. Do you really think God wants us to suffer hardship?? There is nothing wrong with any object or thing. It is HOW we use it and for what purpose we use it that matters. If I nearly beat my horse to death for not running fast enough then I would take you to the woodshed. Other than that please stop listening to foolish people. By the way I have been a Mennonite all my life.
Where do you live?? I’m in northern Canada. I was born Mennonite and I like watermelon, farmer sausage and roll Kuchen. ( kind of like fritters that are boiled in hot oil).😃 That’s a favorite Mennonite meal.I’m a 75 year old gramma and have lived on farms all my life. I speak German and can read my grammas Gothic print Bible. My mom was a teacher for a while. I attended a private Mennonite school in Abbotsford BC Canada. That school now has over 1000 students. My husband grew up on a farm which had a lake and was only 2 miles from the airport so they landed all the float planes there. In return my husband and his 4 brothers got free flying lessons. The youngest one became a missionary pilot in Indonesia. Two others had their own planes. One used his on a farm 100 miles from town. We never had one because they are very expensive and didn’t need one.l know very few Mennonite farmers that have planes so am curious where you live. Obviously not in some ridiculous jungle. Ahhhh maybe Pennsylvania?? We have many Eastern Pennsylvania Mennonites that have moved here. Some off shoot of the Amish. They have a100 rules such as dress codes, no red allowed, no musical instruments, head coverings, no fire insurance and the sad list goes on. They think they must do all these things besides accept Jesus Christ into their lives in order to get into heaven. We are much much more relaxed as you say. They don’t even allow the girls to have high school education whereas my own mom was a teacher. My husbands uncle was a doctor. I want to clarify that Plautdietsch and low German ARE the same. Even Plautdietsch is spoken differently in Belize than in Canada. They use a lot of en at the end of words. They came from Canada in the 1930’s or so because they refused to let their children go to public school or speak English. They were quarrelsome with a few Canadian rules so moved to Mexico and later to Belize to get away from government. They have many rules which they think qualifies them to get into heaven. That’s so sad because the only way to get to heaven is by admitting to Jesus that you have sinned and need his forgiveness. To grow in the Christian life it is important to read and study the Bible. I could write all night about Mennonites but I have all ready explained a lot in my other comments if you care to read them. Glad you have a good Mennonite boss. Give him greetings from our grain farm out west. Tell him gently he doesn’t need so many rules.😊
@dorothywillms115 for 75 years old, you seem to have a lot to say. I question your story from start to very long end. Or in other words, I don't believe any of it.
I live in the mountains of Virginia. We have a few communities here. My wife and I shop at a few of their stores. They sell fabric, soap, fresh food, and lots of baked goods. They are honest people that don't have their hand out. That alone is more than I can say for many Americans. They have their own private communities, but their work supports the outer communities too. They have my respect.
I have bought many baked goods from some of the Mennonites around here. Their baked goods are absolutely amazing! The care that they put into everything the do is unmatched.
I totally agree. It's admirable how self sufficient they are and don't expect any handouts
Yea, until you see the abuse that goes unreported, its not what you see, its what you don't see that matters. 🤔
to touch on what jujjuj7676 said, abuse to all beings, btw. Not only is human abuse rampant in there communities, but animal abuse as well. They view their animals as machines or products that make them money. They’ve done well to create a facade that most people find admirable for some reason. I know first hand that especially the Amish can be very dishonest with the general public. I live in central Virginia where their population is growing rapidly. They’re buying up all the land & they think the laws don’t apply to them. Don’t believe everything you see.
@@jujjuj7676 . Right. Because abuse never happens anywhere else. What can YOU possibly do to keep abuse from happening anywhere except in your own home?? And what is "abuse"? People really need to mind their business. This is surely what these people are trying to escape.
I hope no one needs immediate medical assistance. Especially the children.
They do not care.
@@petersorensen4396no, I suspect they would say, "its gods will"..what ever happens happens.
@@mark-ish Pretty much. If someone gets seriously ill they probably believe that God will either perform a miracle and heal them or he will take them as part of his "plan".
Actually a lot of them still use modern medicine for medical emergencies.
As a Belizean the Mennonite community are an integral part of Belize with their agriculture, dairy products and Chicken. It's not all of them that are this strict and they even marry outside their own kind. When I'm home in Belize we love taking day trips to "Spanish lookout" (their Largest community) to eat their delicious products 🇧🇿
Spanish Lookout is in Corozal district correct?
Similar to North American Amish and Mennonites
Before you know it they will be taking over your government and your entire country. Don't be fooled.
I repeat. Am so fascinated by this. It's just wow....
I’m glad to hear that some marry out because they would eventually end up with only incestuous pairs.
Ive watched this a few times before. Im always so fascinated. Great documentary.
Thank the Lord for Mennonites, Amish and Hutterites! They make fantastic neighbors and are absolutely reliable friends.
We need a part 2! I would love to know how it went.
What happened to Mennonites who moved to Peru?
Members of this austere group recently migrated to Peru from Bolivia and Belize, where they have long-established populations. But now they're being investigated by prosecutors in Peru, accused of illegally deforesting more than 34 square kilometers of rainforest over the past five years.
I wish Abram all the best wishes for the future and may his family and land prosper in the future. I hope that we can all get to see this beautiful community again in a year or two?
What I admire are a couple of things. The unity and relying on each other. Always working, there is never an excuse to not work. Not feeling the need to buy stuff we usually throw away anyway. The optimism of Abraham is pure joy.
I lived near them in Pennsylvania. They are very self sufficient and caring. During Covid they helped their community and gave so much food and helped others. They have the black cars and don't go out of line. A lot of them have opened up a little and shop at Walmart for fabric. The families look very happy but the kids stare at everything when they are out. I'm very intrigued to see what will happen in the future.
I like the horse and buggy more imho. It's very traditional and a custom that I love about the Amish. I hope they stick to that and preserve their much of their unique cultural identity in the future.
Um right. Am from Philadelphia. Knew of the Amish. Good folks. Great food.
They do as far I see in Ohio and PA. Some have neighbors outside their community that drive them in groups to stores sometimes and I see them at Lowes and Walmart mostly, but I've never seen any of them actually driving. @@IchigoOren
If you knew how badly treated those horses maybe you’d think differently. The Amish have a reputation amongst equestrians for how abusive they are to horses.
Honestly, as a 37 year old Southerner, I've been considering living this kind of life. I'm sick of the world today. People are only interested in themselves. Everything is fake. Every person who I've met who live this type of life is extremely happy.
Grass is not greener in the other side...
Yes, there is a certain appeal to this kind of life, but not everyone who lives it is happy. Some people I know left this kind of Mennonite sect because things were not as they seemed to the outside. I don't know about this particular group, and it's certainly not so in all of these groups, but in some of them, there's a high degree of abuse.
Having said this, there are some groups in which things are really good and people are truly happy.
I truly hope that you find what you're looking for and that you get peace wherever you are and where you end up. :)
@rationalconservative386 Oh please.
@@CyclingM1867DubbysMama Yea I hear people say that but I don't think there is as much abuse within this community from any other community. Non Amish communities have their own problems too and abuse happens all over the world in all cultures.
@@evanstar84 He's right though..
we need a update, i need to know how it is going with them!!
this needs to be a weekly serie of 30-45 minutes on how life is going with them!!!!
It wasn't emphasized in the film, but I suspect that the elderly in the communities are respected and considered important members to help carry on traditions and to provide adhesion to families. From what I have seen from living in a country where the elderly WERE much respected, Japan, that goes a long way as a means to help guide children, and it is an important element that makes for a healthy society. Most modern cultures have forgotten the importance of respecting the elderly and emphasizing their contribution.
I agree and I sometimes feel that we Westerners have went down the wrong path. I hope things will get better for our people soon. 🙏
Amen to that!😢
We went to Pennsylvania about 10 years ago and were fascinated. We had the pleasure of being invited to an Amish home one day and they explained they would soon be adding on a Doedy house to retire in. It’s like a suite attached to their former house which a son and his young family will move into. I like the idea but it wouldn’t be possible in a city because of regulations. And,,,,,now a days with women working how can they care for elderly parents?
Certainly everyone eventually becomes old and most will eventually need care/support of one sort or another when they become less able to take care for themselves. One thing that I think is worth mentioning though, is that I believe that when an elderly person is respected and finds meaning in their existence by feeling productive (as in helping to raise children for example), and being loved or whatever it is that enhances the sense of honor and self esteem, it can well delay the point where they will be needing support from others due to being inhibited by age and poor health. Loneliness and isolation is not something that promotes good health.
The elderly are overrated. Look at the state of congress. Both wings.this admin and the last are old enough to remember the fucking jfk assassination so fuck outta here with that.
I grew up Mennonite. And my great grandparents were amish. They are a wonderful people.
What Bible is he talking about?? God doesn't limit us like this!
What inspiring people, their attitude and everything👍
Please make a follow up Part 2
nothing inspiring about them
@@dani6.6 awww you gave yourself a thumbs up 👍😂😂😂,.
@@TxDuallyNation nice argument
@@dani6.6 Greetings from Mr. Nakitu Minajasi 🤭
They should since this was filmed in 2018.
I don’t think they’re stuck in the 19th century, that’s how they want to be. My hope for them is to be able to continue this way of life.
they need to move forward
@@daylehudson6810 It's their own business, not yours,
They are 100% stuck in time. They could be using self sustaining methods proven by modern science such as making their own bio char compost and compost tea to boost their farm yield, they could upgrade many things but they are stuck in a simpler time with less knowledge.
At least you can’t blame them for global warming
I am german native and I hardly understand some words. But I can understand why they live a life like that, why their youth is strugling and kind of rebelling, thats normal in all societys.
Whats with all the horror movie music and sound effects? 😂 Just to make it more gripping for viewers or something??
Interesting that Abram speaks PlattDeutsch, English, and Spanish. Not a stupid man for sure.
Yeah for such isolation, He's on top of it all. I admire that.
There are plenty of sub 100 IQ people who speak several languages. Not to imply he is stupid by any means but even the worlds top level geniuses are fully capable of being tragically mislead.
I respect their work ethic, they are most welcomed in my country.
IT'S NOT THAT THEY'RE STUCK IN THEIR TIME, BUT THAT THEY'RE NOT STUCK IN OUR TIME.
Exactly ! Very sad- So many of them behind the times will just jump boarders to find a better life! smh
@@Mrs.RobinsonsI think it’s better modern kids spend all day scrolling TikTok and don’t know the limit of the skies because they aren’t taught respect
I think your caps lock is stuck in it's keyboard.
I live in a community surrounded by Amish and Mennonites. They live a much more peaceful life than I do
This was so interesting and very well presented. The fathers featured are very loving and obviously care deeply for their families. Good luck Abram and all the families.
I'd love a follow up on the new colony . ☮️
if this is the first time watching it, might want to look it up from almost every other documentation / discovery type channels. Very old video i've seen at least a few dozen times on other channels.
He’s likely died of some jungle disease by now,gone broke or his kids took him to a mental institution. He was a STUBBORN uneducated and suspicious and prejudiced and bound by the RULES which he thought got him eternal life. Sad and tragic and completely unnecessary. Old fashioned CULT or SECT.
What a beautiful documentary. When we were younger we always thought the amish were strange. As I see what the world is becoming... maybe we are the strange ones. Morals, community, marriage vows that mean something.
I'm not super religious so I could never fit in.... but... dear lord to I envy their convictions and would love to visit their community and pay my respects to their way of life. *but I'm assuming they would consider me NOT visiting as my respect... so ... i shall admire from a far.
They're definitely the weird ones, but modern society has also gone downhill. I think the best blend of morals, religion, and living with modern conveniences was the 1950s.
I grew up in PA. The Mennonite’s are awesome people! They are so hard working and kind. They do not judge others. They are also very open. They will talk to you. It seems these folk are a little more conservative than any Mennonites I’ve met in the USA. More along the lines of the Amish that I know.
In fact I’d like to talk to the producer of this video. All the Mennonite’s that are friends with my family have cell phones, drive cars and have electric. I could be wrong but I think this group is a little “extra”, more along the lines of Amish.
There are a lot of extreme religious folk that moved to South America. They moved there because their views where a little too extreme for America and Europe. I don’t think they are the typical Mennonite’s. But what’s a “typical” belief.
They moved to south America so they could deprive those children of their right to an education and any sort of opportunity to decide their future for themselves. It's really sad.
They are old order in tradition and yes closer to Amish in lifestyle but they practice faith differently. Like the Amish barely the Bible often and that's all Mennonites do.
There are different levels re: how conservative they are.
This is what I came to say too. I'm next County over from Lancaster County PA. These people are more Amish that speak Pennsylvania Dutch its called. Mennonite here are not like this.
@@honeybadger5933 There's different levels of conservatism. The Amish originally split from the Mennonites.
Imagine a world with no art and music
You must live in a concrete jungle if you think human made art and music is better than the art and music of nature that these people have.
Imagine living in a world where everything is new and exciting !
I remember my first time on an airplane .
They sing. That is music. Islam has branch in Iran and Saudi who outlaw all music and art
A great tale, and so great to be there to document their journey. Thank you
Excellent video, as good as Hollywood productions.
Say what you want, these people have skills, one major catastrophe and most of us are done, unable to forage, grow, deal with shelter and answer the problems, not wait for help! Most of society will wait for help and die doing it.
There’s an off grid/prepper movement that seeks to be self sufficient, prodice as much of what they need as possible and do it like people did in the 800’s, using horses and mules as our forefathers did, to,relearn the old skills.
And if anyone survives a SHTF situation these people will .
@@teresahiggs4896 And when they get sick or cancer, are they going to get 21st century treatment?
@@teresahiggs4896is rather stick with internal combustion and learn to distill alcohol fuels. Horses sound like more work than some copper tubing.
It all comes with a huge price.....laws rules and discipline to obey.....you have no freedom of speech and are not allowed to speak your truth and leave....what about the child abuse and traumas? This is not natural... you are not free to leave..it comes with a price.. they love you if you do 2hat they say, conditional love !
I really enjoyed this video/story! One can feel the pure happiness in Abrams joy of his new chapter in life❤️
Much respect to Mennonites as well as Amish. They study at home & school and show love in the streets.
Nothing wrong with this. Bless them all. They must follow the local, state and National laws is important.
Pagan myself but i truly admire their pioneering spirit , no-one could wish them anything other but well 👍👍
Twenty children?? The poor mother. That's not emotionally healthy. Children need more individual time with their parents.
Very Self Sufficient, and Self Reliant type of People. Living on their own land, and growing their own Food! And "Debt" Free! True Freedom!
I’m a retired underwriter and tracked insurance for car loans. Must have full coverage as stated in the finance agreement. Mennonites have cars and loans in the U.S. We have to accept a letter from their community saying they will cover if any damage if it happens. All policy numbers are the same SI1 (If I recall correctly). They are basically sovereign citizens here.
don't let the crazy people hear you..
@@DistractedDaisy I don’t care! 🤣 There are many different sects.
And they do honour their promises. The community will build any creditors an entire residential sub division if that's what it takes to settle their debt. Whatever it takes,they have resources, they have networks. The guarantee from community is probably more solid than an insurance policy.
@@m_christine1070 Not likely they will build an entire community to pay off debts. It’s sort of like a co-op. Every family pays into it monthly. Brother belongs to one for health insurance. I believe it’s 500 a month for his family of four rather than over 2 grand a month for the AHCA. He’s a small business owner and has a ton of overhead with the buildings, employees etc.
This was a very interesting and informative video, thank you for sharing.
The more children the closer you are to god. Seems like a play to always be growing the community at all costs.
These are ultra conservative Mennonites, of course, but the majority of Mennonites in the world, like my mom's family and me, are modern people. You couldn't pick us out from a crowd of regular looking people. Most of us have modern conveniences, including TV and the internet. My mom was born and raised in the Mennonite Brethren church, which is a modern sect of Mennonites. I do have some distant relatives, though, who are super conservative Mennonites like the ones featured in this video. They live down in Paraguay. I've been fascinated by Anabaptist groups of all kind my whole life. Thanks for sharing this video about this particular group. :)
Finally a regular Mennonite. Thanks. I’m M.B. I bet your mom would be interested in all the comments I’ve left behind. I know our history very well. I’m deeply ashamed of this group and all the heartache they’ve caused and are now perpetuating like flies in South America. Benjamin B Jantz who helped 20,000 Mennonites out of Ukraine 100 years ago and my grandfather Abram A Wiens would be very grieved if they knew about this. My grandfather helped get many who came during and after WWII get their paperwork done as immigrants. His sister was married to Jacob B Jantz. These folks were never grateful to live in Canada and quarrelled a lot re language and education with the Canadian government. So they got mad and moved to Mexico and on to South America. Soon the world will be too small for them and many of us would be happy to see them leave for Mars. They can create all the havoc and heartache there because they have no government on Mars that I know of. And don’t kid yourself. These self righteous men are very abusive. They have no relationship with God. Only to their ordnance which means a zillion man made rules so that they can dominate their own families. It’s a tragedy. It’s deceitful and simply wicked but that’s how the devil works. He is never out of tricks.
P.S. The ones in Paraguay mostly came after WWII to the “green hell” in the Chaco where they really struggled for years. It was so hot they couldn’t cope well and they were even poorer than those that came to Canada. Some did come from Ukraine to Paraguay because Canada would not accept them ,usually because of a medical condition or Canada had filled its quota. My grandpa helped many that came to Canada via Paraguay with immigration matters.
50 years ago perhaps the assimilated Mennonites were the majority, but that has changed.
MC-USA has fallen from over 250k members 50 years ago to perhaps 60k today.
Wheras the Old Order Mennonites have gone from around 15k to 85k, the Old Colony Mennonites number up to 450k, both the Conservative and Holdeman Mennonites have increased dramatically in the last 50 years.
The only very traditional Mennonite group that has shown a sharp decline, is the Reformed Mennonites. Simply because they don't raise their children in the faith, allowing them to run wild.
In perhaps another 2, definitely 3 generations, the liberal Mennonite will have so completely assimilated into mainstream America as to be extinct, with only the traditional conservative Mennonites left.
Unfortunately when you are a minority group and you surrender your distinctiveness as a people, taking on the distinctiveness of the majority group, they will assimilate you into extinction. That is how the melting pot works, 500 years of sacrifice and suffering, gone in a couple of generations.
@@calebalton2084 Thankyou for that information. It’s really sad but I see that in northern Canada where I now live. The MB church in my town,although popular with young families, has a Baptist minister,with Calvinist leanings. The church board is made of men who have done well financially or are just popular. They watch hockey and other sports,go hunting or quadding ,seldom read books and do not understand the scriptures because they have never attended a Bible school and don’t like to study the Bible. The care groups are social clubs. The stained glass windows are covered up with boards and bricks,illuminated with an orange glow. A lady (made the stained glass ones and is approaching 90 Her husband built a lovely communion table and pulpit,not being used, the organ and grand piano are out,taken over by an electric keyboard, hymns are no longer sung,coffee is slurped (and spilled) in the pews and most of all there is apathy and a desire to dominate,resulting in a lack,of love and respect especially for the elderly and widows. Adult Sunday school is also a thing of the past and only 3 or so men come to prayer meetings..Sunday evening services have been gone for years too. I’m sorry to sound so negative. Oh and choirs are definitely long gone. Where is the Mennonites love of music?? When you live 20 miles from church and the roads very full of ice and snow your motivation no attend slowly wanes. We pray for the MB church but we have been really disappointed the past 20 years.,,,,,,,interestingly my husband just got a call from the towns missions event planner and there too the Mennonites show very little interest. I have a friend with severe Parkinson’s in the care home and she gets almost no visitors. Nor does my mother,1000 miles to the south. Perhaps my blunt honesty will cause a few people to wake up and take notice. The MB church needs our prayers. In the end who do we think we are?
I'm an outsider to all this, and this thread is so very very fascinating. Also sad.
Loved the video. But a bit sad, because those children are not having the same opportunities as the others. From their birth, their paths are decided by their parents or ancestors, and they don't even know what is out there.
That actually happens to evrry body, even the country you are born has to do with that, the west just happened to try as much as possible to change it and level the playing field, it's not leveled bit it's better leveled than what's out there
Sehr interessante Video 👍🏻
My wife and I own a house and land in Belize, and we have been to Little Belize several times (we live very close to there). It's a picturesque community, and we've never interacted with unfriendly or "mean" people. We have good relationships with them, and have done business with many of 'em (a Mennonite built our interior house decor and shelving). We see many of them on the ferries, in the nearby towns, and along the streets of Corozal District. I've even had a beer with two of them at our community's local restaurant (no names will be named). 🙂 We even know some of the truck drivin', cell phone usin' "modern" Mennonites.
It is sad, though, that they completely misunderstand Biblical doctrine, because they worship their traditions more than the actual God of the Bible. To see sin and evil in inanimate objects is just... silly. God NEVER said that modern appliances bar a person's entrance into Heaven. Faith in Christ gets one into Heaven, not adherence to ancient and unquestionable traditions. In fact, Jesus CONDEMNED those who cling to their traditions, and disregard the freedom of God's love shown to us through Jesus. Like I said - it's sad.
Amen Tommy!
@tommyapocalypse6096 - Thank You! I've seen some documentaries on similar communities, i.e. the Amish, and the people chronicled in video and conversation are impressive. In very positive ways and IMHO very negative ways. The strengths sell themselves: division of labor / serious work ethic / DIY lifestyle / communal support from cradle-to-grave / healthy living condition / admirable stewardship of resources / land / pro-family. Yet...and this is a big yet, and it was only in the communities recorded ( can't it's true of ALL of the Amish ), they had an Us vs Them mindset towards anyone ( yes, Christians, too ) who were outside their communities as The Lost or those of The System of Satan. That's ultimately sad, but a bit angering as well. I don't have to agree with everything very traditional Christian communities do and believe, but I do challenge myself to hold them in my mind and heart with respect and love as my fellow brothers and sisters. ( I'm not saint. Not virtue-signaling. ) Maybe many of them do as well ( Amish, Mennonites, Bruderhof, etc. ). Anyone, of any community/denomination, who fundamentally sows discord among the Church is committing an abomination before God. We should be very, very careful how we view our brothers and sisters in Christ.
They may seem nice on the surface, but the male leaders in these types of communities give me abysmal vibes. That dinner scene with the 'Mayor' and his family made me feel so depressed for that entire family, look at the girls' faces at 12:50 onwards. I've seen better vibes at a fucking funeral than that, and that's every single day of their life through no choice of their own. To me, this shit is absolutely disgusting and deeeeeeply sad.
@@machtnichtsseimann They hold that us vs them mindset because NON Amish communities are always critiquing their culture by trying and always degrading them. That and they see how racist people in NON Amish communities are just want to be left alone is all they want. :)
Just live and let live..
Hope that helps. 🙏
Don’t be nice then insult a cult
Wow, I randomly just watched this whole thing. this randomly popped up in my recommended feed. Glad I watched it now I know more about the Mennonites.
The best people with a kind heart. My family survived their first year in Canada with the help of the Mennonites.
My first reaction with the settlers moving to Peru was “there goes the ecosystem” , and it looks like more recent news on that colony bears that concern out. Vast families leading to never-ending expansion into frontiers is not sustainable in the 21st century.
Greetings from Egypt to all of you in this wonderful community ❤❤
This was amazing I hope there's a follow-up
What a wonderful community.
Sure. Once you get past the child abuse, lack of women's rights, tax evasion, rampant incest, amongst other things. Good luck if you want to leave the community as well.
Neat watch, I grew up in this community and brings back tonnes of memories. There is a neat aspect no doubt, but because it is closed off from society there is a lot of corruption and terrible things that happen in those communities. My home had personal, first hand experience. There is genuine people there though too that honestly want to do what's right for their families and they are trying to do the best with the knowledge they have.
If peace of mind and soul was a person, this is the real deal.
"Their only moment of leisure is in church every Sunday." That's not leisure dude
For you
Only in your opinion
Facts
Please do an update! This was very heartwarming to watch.
They’re very good with their hands. Would love to live such a simple happy life 💜 sad that they don’t have music though
If there was ever a disaster these people would survive with no problem. Lots to learn from the Amish/Mennonite Communities
I loved this. Definitely would love to see how everything turned out for them.
The Mennonites where I live in Maryland don’t live in colonies, and are modern. They drive grey and black colored cars, have cell phones, are highly disciplined and are the nicest people you ever met. Maybe the rest of society should follow their lead.
This is so funny! What was reported by the local news a few years back was that this particular group of Amish Mennonites and I don’t mean these folks directly, but Mennonites is what they reported in the news was that they were some of the most profitable, biggest, drug dealers and transporters And the Canadian United States border and if anybody looks at a map where they are getting situated and located and now they are trying to go to Peru and now they’re down in Belize Mexico or Belize. I’m sorry South America it makes you think or it should make you think a little bit.
Horrible. if Adults decide for themselves to live such a live than its fine by me but children have no choice and are brainwashed. If somebody wants to be a farmer fine, if somebody wants to be a doctor fine too, society needs both but let people decide what they want.
The woman don’t look happy at all.
25% of American women take psych meds, are they happy?
Probably not allowed to cuz flirty is evil blah blah
These are old colony people.They have roots in russia, and it is a totally different group from most Mennonites. These are the most conservative of The Old Colony Mennonites. Horse and Buggy groups are a very small subset of the Larger Old Colony movement. The education was so substandard that the colony had Amish from the States that are teachers.
Wonderful Documentary, the insight of how Mennonites lives. This is the first time I heard of this Group. Your voice is clear & Crystal. I hope of of these group Follow Up.
Thank you👍👍👍👍
I lived with them in Winton California for 6 months. They do love God beyond a doubt. Moving to isolated areas as they are doing here does not however follow the great commission.
I definitely have respect for all people and have been around these people while growing up and they are lovely 👍
Amazing documentary. Thank you.
My mother has very good friends I believe they are part of the Mennonites of Alberta, Canada. They are extremely good, decent people, hard working,etc. Just, honest, good families.
The Mennonites are amazing people of God. Simplistic life. They are so humble and happy, each with that contagious smile. Unlike my suburban neighborhood with overpowering wealth.
You could have said this particular kind of Mennonite. It sounds horrible beyond comprehension to me but .Iam 75 now and I was Born Mennonite. The privilege of the name should be taken away from them as they do NOT represent the majority of us. My grampas name was Abram and this is an insult to his name. He was a refugee from Ukraine in 1924. He worked for Mennonite Central Committee assisting refugees from war torn Russian Ukraine during the Russian revolution to Canada. I learned a lot from him as I was the eldest grandchild. My mother was a school teacher of 12 grades during WWII. My parents were babies when they came from Ukraine. I was aware of Mennonites who were unhappy with the Canadian school system and didn’t want their children to learn English so quite a few moved to Mexico where they lived in abject poverty. A few tried to come back and my grampa often had to meet them at the border crossings between Abbotsford BC and Vancouver. I wasn’t told much as a kid but I remembered strange events and my mother filled me in when I was in my 20’s and 30’s. It was often just pathetic, filth and starvation and new borns and their moms didn’t always make it.
These men are not what they want you to think. Some of these people stayed with my grandparents till they recovered or churches found them lodging. I’m not sure if welfare was a thing in the 1940’s and 50’s but most of these people finally saw the light and adapted to English and Canada. Others stayed in Mexico or wandered even further south. All in order to keep things as they had been 150 or more years ago in Germany. It started around the time of the reformation. Our founder was Menno Simons a former Catholic priest or monk.Some Mennonites became extremely strict and narrow minded while others became successful farmers,especially after Catherine the great invited German farmers to come and toil the soil of Ukraine. They really prospered until the revolution although some came to the USA and Canada around 1875. I really don’t see how there could have been Mennonites in Belize before 1900. I think they have no idea what their history is and tell the media stories. I know the North American governments and Mennonite leadership was very frustrated with these STUBBORN people who refused to adapt to a new and wonderful land which they weren’t all that grateful to be in. In fact I can see still see my grandfathers pained face. These people simply weren’t grateful. Their God was their RULES. They lived and died by man made RULES. So did the Doukabors in southern B.C. They were a disgrace and influenced by insane leaders who burned their own farms down. These people could have hooked up with a Bruderhaus community or Hudderites which they must have heard about it but NO NO NO. All you suckers out there admiring them or thinking they seem wholesome and innocent THINK AGAIN.
@@dorothywillms115 Thanks for your words Dorothy. I wonder how much better we are off now. Seeing that the world is changing, mass depopulation and migration. A new time of an old agenda. We are now being eliminated by disease and poisoned food and water, the air we breed. The fake climate inatative. We are being controlled by the globalists above us. I guess life isn't as simple as it was and humanity is changing. Wonder if these folks knew something we are now facing in our changing world.
9:50 dit wud me t' dunkel senn,😅 dit lat schmock😅
So interesting to watch my people live this way. We are Mennonites too (from Russia 🇷🇺, now living in Germany 🇩🇪).
"It's against our religion...
We have to... why? I don't know..."
that's really sad/ tragic...
Quick question,Do they have a very distinct German accent? Like are they understandable in comparison to the average German ? Thanks.
My heart breaks for Abraham's mother
I support several indigenous tribes in this area. I DON’T think they are going to be so welcoming. Many of the tribes are nomadic, so they might not be found out right away, but, they WILLmeet.
On the other hand, I’m very impressed with this gentleman’s language skills. Would love to see a follow-up on this!
13:50 I am German, and I can barely understand a few words. I guess people from Northern Germany would find it easier to understand "Plattdeutsch". There are so many different dialects in German speaking countries, you sometimes feel they speak a completely different language.
yeah, it sounds really weird. Sounds more like dutch
Living in that tropical climate? In those heat trapping getups? And no A/C? I’d spontaneously combust within hours.
It's actually it's less hot like that, u don't Arabs in the dessert naked, do u ? It always depends on the fabric u use and the undergarments
40 families living in the middle of nowhere, where is the initial food supply and where does the sewage go while they are constructing this self sufficient community ? If someone becomes ill what happens ?
"I have too much to learn to waste my time in school". Benjamin Franklin
Classroom time ends at 13 but learning continues forever. They got it right
Modern society seems dark and hopeless. People tend to fight on the Internet over sensitive topics, and the age of hate has begun. Many of us are busy stereotyping each other. Excessive sense of competition, hatred, selfishness, anxiety, and depression constantly approach us. Especially after the introduction of the internet, we compare ourselves to others more often than ever and end up suffering from low self-esteem. I might believe that the Mennonites are a lot happier than us in some points...
What I am struck by most is the arrogance of religious folk that they think their desire for isolation is a good reason to start cutting down trees the names of which they have never heard spoken. Great video though, absolutely remarkable to get so much footage and conversation from such a reclusive society. Going to watch the rest of your list now. Thank you.
But we all at least indirectly cut down plants, including trees, to eat.
@@lauramann4323 that's true of course but we have already got enough cleared arable land on the planet to feed the current population more than three time over. In the last 100 years the planet lost more forest than it had in the previous 9000 years. I think humanity is covering it's eyes as it shoots it's self in the foot and these folk are a glaring example of that with their lack of concern for the environment they destroy to create an environment that suits just their own needs.
Fascinating people.
It's like going back in time and seeing the world from centuries past.
Not a religious man, never have been, but I'm always interested to learn about other cultures and traditions.
It is not a ""weakness "" to have emotions,,saying goodbye is heartbreaking,, emotions are what makes us all human,,all the same..To care,to love..Great great video.👍💯