I. Allegro con brio ∙ 00:19 opening theme (1st) 00:58 bird :) - building 01:37 cello chorale theme (2st) 02:48 third theme 03:57 minor, horn solo 04:21 return of first theme 05:03 bird :) 05:56 flute solo over second theme 06:20 fiery development 07:16 first theme in brass 07:54 birds :) 08:27 3rd theme in clar 09:25 coda II. Andagio ∙ 10:40 opening string choral 11:21 first theme in winds 12:46 big timp roll - return of opening choral now in winds 13:46 second theme in winds 14:26 violin solo on second theme 14:54 triumphant strings 16:17 return of the first theme 17:13 a low hum - building - release 18:51 back to second theme 19:46 pastoral winds/coda 20:27 big timp roll, tension, and triumphant release III. Allegretto grazioso - Molto vivace ∙ 21:37 passionate string theme (1st) 22:24 1st theme starts in winds 23:15 pleasant wind theme (2nd) 24:33 2nd theme now in strings - transition to minor 25:17 back to 1st theme 26:06 1st theme in winds, counterpoint with strings, then reverses 26:57 molto vivace, quick oboe theme IV. Allegro, ma non troppo ∙ 27:45 Trumpet fanfare!!!!! 28:17 main theme in cello 29:11 violins join in counterpoint 30:00 main theme faster 30:15 flute solo 30:42 back to main theme 31:09 new theme in woodwinds w/ development 32:34 return of opening fanfare melody w/ development 33:05 return of slow main theme 34:11 main theme softer 35:14 main theme now in clar and even softer 36:41 flute playing the first 3 notes of the theme 37:14 quick main theme to end the piece!! + coda 37:56 "Bravo!!"
This conductor and orchestra produce wonderful interpretations of every work they play. The Dvorak Symphony is new to me but I have enjoyed every piece of music of his that I have ever heard, and it was no exception. Thank you for the download.
The odd irony that I discovered this incredible orchestra in lockdown and I would now travel to Frankfurt in a heartbeat to see it led by Andres Orozco-Estrada and yet can't. Thank you for your high-quality commitment to sharing the art of the composer and the artistry of the performers
Orozco-Estrada is now the principal conductor of the Houston Symphony Orchestra. And he’s just as good in Jones Hall as we was in Frankfurt (although I love recordings made with him at the podium of that orchestra, too). I hope Houston might be a little more doable.
@@terrylindsay2386 The Houston orchestra is certainly good, from what little I've heard, but I'm saddened at this move. The synergy between orchestra and conductor, combined with stunning musicianship here, I suspect may not quite be matched in Houston. I hope I'm wrong.
@Alcina Thank you for taking the time to give me this information. I had no idea of the details of his connection with Houston (obviously). His work with the Frankfurt orchestra has been brilliant - including a great Mahler 2 so Houston can expect a memorable finale. I wonder why he resigned from Vienna, also where he will go next? I do hope we see more of him online.
@Alcina Hi Alcina, And I would be number two. He is at home with just about every facet of orchestral music and with the Frankfurt orchestra, in my opinion, out -performs the Berlin ensemble - more warmth, and a feeling of youthful spontaneity with even the deepest works. The Weiner Symphoniker is brilliant but rather traditional, so I rather think there could have been a clash in the general approach to performances and interpretation. Just guessing.
This is what we must design, no doubt, no hesitate an outstanding performance. Since I began to be fan of HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie, the emotion to listen any composer's music has grown up to the highest level. First, the musicians are all of them really soloists: I have heard them during the worst of coronavirus. Second: maestro Andrés Orozco-Estrada goes into the deepest feelings of the composition which ever it is. And, last but not least, the recordings and Filmings are possibly the best to be listen and watch. CONGRATULATIONS to everyone in HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie. Viel Danke. Muchas gracias, thanks a million 👋👋👋👋
It seems that the last movement of 8th symphony has some similar rhythms and playfulness as Dvořak´s Wind serenade of the last movement.... Also, 2nd movement of 8th symphony may be a version of the wind serenade... Watch the video of Conductor Estrada and the wind serenade.
TLDR: Bravo! I've only been had classical music in my life for maybe a litter over a decade now and mostly used Berlin Phil, Vienna Phil, and a few American orchestra as a references. But this orchestra easily one of my go-to's as of recently to listen to just for the sheer amount of energy these awesome musicians share among each other. It's something about the sound, balance, and direction of their playing that has had me hooked on them for a quite some time now.
The old #4 was the first piece of orchestral music I ever played as a high school grad. What I like about this particular orchestra is that the personnel seem to be having so much fun.
At his best, Andrés Orozco-Estrada is a top flight conductor - and he and the Frankfurt Radio Symphony are a wonderful partnership. This performance in many ways outclasses many of the performances of more "famous" orchestras - but this orchestra deserves to be considered in the same conversation as those orchestras. Many great conductors and orchestras have recorded the Dvorak 8th Symphony, but few have the combination of drama, intensity, beauty and charm. When life returns (hopefully soon), this work is an excellent one for the pair to tour with and show how magnificent this partnership is.
Personally, my favorite for this piece specifically is the performance recorded by Karajan and the Vienna Philharmonic in the 1980s, but the Frankfurt Radio Symphony always does deliver!
This conductor is one of my favorite conductors and one of the best. The Frankfurt Radio orchestra these past 4 years has become one of my favorite orchestra. In the 70's I auditioned for this same orchestra
Tschechisch: Génius! Čech, ve kterém se přirozeně spojuje tradice rakouská, uherská, romská, keltská..., kapku zkušenost americká a indiánská... + nebojácnost vytvořit jasnou krásnou, pro lidi chytlavou melodii. (nestyděl se za svůj obyčejný vesnický původ)... - a hle, je tu Antonín Dvořák! :-)
They have face nask. Next time (when we are in the "old) (???) Situation all audiance must wear face-mask. (Lol or no lol?) to listen better to the full value of the music.
Grazie maestro Andrés, grazie a tutti. Dopo una giornata di 12 ore di ambulatorio Covid mi avete donato gioia e ristoro. Siete una comunità di amici che suonano con una unità e un entusiasmo commoventi. Grazie maestro per la sua intelligenza e umanità musicale. Grazie ancora, avanti così....
In many ways this is my favourite Dvorak symphony. He's reached his mature style in his most personally expressive way. He's freed himself from "Brahmsianisms" here. Just pure Dvorak..
I listened to this piece in the the last concert before the Covid Lockdown early this year, which is also my favourite concert in my life so far. Miss these old days.
The second movement is remarkable. I love the flexibility of tempo between the simple flute motto (pushing forward) and the clarinet duet (lingering). These musicians have made my quarantine.
Yes, I've heard this symphony a million time and this immediatelly caught my attention! I've never heard it performed like that, which is strange, because it sounds so natural and logical.
By far the finest performance of this symphony that I've heard to date. In saying that, there isn't a work that I've heard from this orchestra that I haven't thoroughly enjoyed listening to.
@@MisterPathetique A million times better? Both recordings are fantastic, but I actually like the one with Orozco-Estrada a little more! I don't think the third movement here can ever be topped.
@@Failentin Of course I was exaggerating to make my point. This performance is not horrible, but I don't find it particularly good either. I don't think Orozco-Estrada has a lot of feeling for this music, and it shows right in the opening: the cellos should be leading, but here they're kinda drowned out. The third movement didn't impress me either, the melody tends to disappear because of Orozco-Estrada's random dynamic adjustments and tapered phrasing. But the worst thing to me is the general lack of energy and accent, and the flabby rhythm throughout the piece. And to be honest Orozco-Estrada is not helped by the overly compressed sonics either. I mean just compare the development section of the first movement or the very conclusion of the symphony with Honeck's performance, you'll understand what I'm talking about. Besides Honeck, I suggest you listen to Davis/Concertgebouw, Dohnányi/Cleveland, Neumann/Czech Philharmonic or even Karajan/Vienna Philharmonic. And then come back to Orozco-Estrada, you will immediately hear what's lacking in his performance. And please never assume that a performance "can't ever be topped". We can ALWAYS do better. Otherwise, why should we even bother playing this music?
Agreed: This is the loveliest rendition of this solo that I've ever heard. He has matched his vibrato and bowing and phrasing perfectly to the needs of that musical moment. Refined, yet lush. I'd love to hear much more of his playing.
No orchestra can play Dvorak's 8th better than the hr! Excellent performance. How I'd love to see a recording of Dvorak's 7th with this brilliant conductor and orchestra 😄
It would seem this Colombian fellow works with different music scores: Under his conducting, I can hear melodic lines of different instruments that I can not distinghish or hear with any other conductors. ¡Bravo!
I have performed this piece several times on 1st Horn - including with the Vienna Symphony (not the Philharmonic! :-) ) I really like this performance and yes, the conductor finds details that are often lost in the cascades of sound.
Extraordinari concert. En plena pandèmia pel COVID, la gran orquestra de Frankfurt ens ofereix una grandiosa actuació. Amb un dels millors Directors actuals. Sense presuncions, amb el seu treball, ANDRES OROZCO-ESTRADA ens fa gaudir de la música ben interpretada. Fóra del seu gran Alpe oper. Felicitacions Sinfonieorchester, i mestre Orozco-Estrada. Gràcies!
Vielen Dank für Ihren wunderbaren Eindruck! Alles war großartig, vor allem aber das Solo des Konzertmeisters im zweiten Satz. Es war der beliebteste Ton, den ich je gehört habe.
What a great orchestra! To say the first fute player nailed the part is an understatement. Never heard it better. The trumpets and trombones! Holy cow. Y que viva Colombia! Un pais que amo mucho!
Súper concert ! 👏👏👏👏 Bravoooooo 🥰🥰🥰 thanks for this vídeo . The conductor is very very special for this music . Congratulations 👏👏🌹🌹🌹 The concertino Bravo for this expressions, and the quality play violin👏👏👏🥰🥰🥰🥰
@@MisterPathetique I've compared the two, over two days, and I believe you're right. Honeck is less athletic on the podium, but he gets the depth in the energy of the piece - i.e. exciting but not superficial - in a way which I don't think Orozco-Estrada quite does; though it remains a pleasing performance, and Estrada is still quite young and has room to develop.
Hoje temos mais de 514 mil.mortos aqui.... país à deriva....mas, enquanto houver Arte, estaremos seguros... parabéns para todos desta orquestra e grato pelos momentos que nos trazem alívio a tanto sofrimento.... abraços gratidão desde RioJaneiro.Brasil....continuem....por favor
Always have to chuckle at the beginning of the third movement because of how often it's used in Twoset's videos XD. Wonderful and capturing performance!!! Love the tension in the first movement.
Una maravillosa interpretación de la orquesta y genial dirección de la música. Este director expresa gran energía y control, es buena representación del continente americano allá en Europa.
Wieder ein fantastisches Konzert des HR-Sinfonieorchesters, vielen vielen Dank dafür! Leider war diesmal mein Lieblings-Fagottist nicht dabei, war aber akustisch für mich nicht wahrnehmbar. ;-)
Wunderschöne und lyrische Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und ethnisch komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der dritte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt lyrisch. Der intelligente Maestro dirigiert das kompakte und ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut phrasierten Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Como siempre, también ahora, Sinfoniorchester no defrauda nunca... Y Andres Orozco-Estrada un GRAN Director. Mejor que las "vedettes" Gergiev , Dudamel y Rattle.
Meilleur, je ne saurais dire et la musique n'est pas un sport mais une chose est certaine : Andrés Orozco Estrada est un grand maestro et sa conception très humaine de la direction d'orchestre nous comble un peu plus chaque jour.
Dvorak's melody is full of nostalgia and comfort . These performers and a prestigious conductor express Dvorak's aesthetics skillfully . Dvorak's work has a strong spirit , And Dvorak has an indomitable soul to confront his own misery . Dvorak is great and effulgent From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵 Which national are you watching this video ？
@@jenlw8974 Thank-you so much to your comments We know the situations of the UK on the TV Hang in there ！ Be on the alert for Covid - １９ The season of blooming cherry blossoms has come again in Japan . This season is marvellous , glorious and beyond your imagination for the cherry blossoms in full bloom everywhere in Japan , (parks , hills , mountains , on the banks of rivers , various gardens , domestic Bonsai and etc. ) However , for the second year in a row , just like last year , when we felt lonely to prevent Covid - １９ the banquets in famous public parks under the cherry blossoms in full bloom have been perfectly banned , The Rite of Spring peculiar to Japan from １０００years ago can no longer be held . We are very lonely and unfortunate . This year too , the cherry blossoms are destined to fall lonely in front of us . The true cherry - blossoms viewing , shortly speaking , the true banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom is to lay rugs under the cherry blossoms in full bloom and sing and dance with eating various Bento and drinking Japanese sake , beer , Japanese shochu , wine ,etc . The number of the infected people is gradually decreasing , Be on the alert for Covid - １９ Cheer up ！ Someday please visit Japan distinguished Four Seasons and Japanese delicious foods wait for you Good luck ！
The concert performances of the last 3 Dvorak Symphonies led by A O-E and the FRS are, imo, in the same class as those led by George Szell and the Cleveland Orchestra recorded in the late 1950's and Istvan Kertesz and the LSO. Before he left Frankfurt I wish he had led a performance of the Dvorak 6th. Similarly I hope he leads performances of the Brahms Serenade #1 and the Schumann Symphonies during his tenure in Cologne. These concert videos are uniformly of the highest quality with superb ensemble playing and never a sign of the jaded playing which seems to infect so many supposedly top-notch orchestras. I always look forward to A O-Es returns to Frankfurt!
いい時代になりました。私が幼いころは、動画なんて、見れなかった。今は、こんなに簡単に一流の演奏がみれるんだから、すごいよね、
One of the finest performances of this piece I've ever heard. BRILLIANT wind solos!!!
Ja! Ich bin SPRECHLOSS!
Carla Andrada is captivating to watch - and listen to😊.
30:15 Flute solo by Clara Andrada de la Calle
Yayyyy
Très bonne flûtiste et jolie femme en plus, toujours un plaisir de retrouver Clara !
All her solos were magnificent! Dvořàk surely wrote beautifully and often powerfully, with lots of surprises for anyone listening for the first time!
Wonderful, standout solos.😍😍😍
I. Allegro con brio ∙
00:19 opening theme (1st)
00:58 bird :) - building
01:37 cello chorale theme (2st)
02:48 third theme
03:57 minor, horn solo
04:21 return of first theme
05:03 bird :)
05:56 flute solo over second theme
06:20 fiery development
07:16 first theme in brass
07:54 birds :)
08:27 3rd theme in clar
09:25 coda
II. Andagio ∙
10:40 opening string choral
11:21 first theme in winds
12:46 big timp roll - return of opening choral now in winds
13:46 second theme in winds
14:26 violin solo on second theme
14:54 triumphant strings
16:17 return of the first theme
17:13 a low hum - building - release
18:51 back to second theme
19:46 pastoral winds/coda
20:27 big timp roll, tension, and triumphant release
III. Allegretto grazioso - Molto vivace ∙
21:37 passionate string theme (1st)
22:24 1st theme starts in winds
23:15 pleasant wind theme (2nd)
24:33 2nd theme now in strings - transition to minor
25:17 back to 1st theme
26:06 1st theme in winds, counterpoint with strings, then reverses
26:57 molto vivace, quick oboe theme
IV. Allegro, ma non troppo ∙
27:45 Trumpet fanfare!!!!!
28:17 main theme in cello
29:11 violins join in counterpoint
30:00 main theme faster
30:15 flute solo
30:42 back to main theme
31:09 new theme in woodwinds w/ development
32:34 return of opening fanfare melody w/ development
33:05 return of slow main theme
34:11 main theme softer
35:14 main theme now in clar and even softer
36:41 flute playing the first 3 notes of the theme
37:14 quick main theme to end the piece!! + coda
37:56 "Bravo!!"
Bravissimo il maestro. Bravissima tutta l'orchestra. Bellissima musica. Grazie.
0:19 - I. Allegro con brio
10:40 - II. Adagio
21:37 - III. Allegretto grazioso - Molto vivace
27:45 - IV. Allegro, ma non troppo
Andrés is so consistently wonderful in every performance. I just love this guy and his band!
erm actually it's an orchestra, not a band 🤓
He's truly a joy to watch
@@mrman5066 what was blud yapping about amirite
@@mrman5066 You're right, it's an orchestra.
This conductor and orchestra produce wonderful interpretations of every work they play. The Dvorak Symphony is new to me but I have enjoyed every piece of music of his that I have ever heard, and it was no exception. Thank you for the download.
The odd irony that I discovered this incredible orchestra in lockdown and I would now travel to Frankfurt in a heartbeat to see it led by Andres Orozco-Estrada and yet can't. Thank you for your high-quality commitment to sharing the art of the composer and the artistry of the performers
Orozco-Estrada is now the principal conductor of the Houston Symphony Orchestra. And he’s just as good in Jones Hall as we was in Frankfurt (although I love recordings made with him at the podium of that orchestra, too). I hope Houston might be a little more doable.
...
@@terrylindsay2386 The Houston orchestra is certainly good, from what little I've heard, but I'm saddened at this move. The synergy between orchestra and conductor, combined with stunning musicianship here, I suspect may not quite be matched in Houston. I hope I'm wrong.
@Alcina Thank you for taking the time to give me this information. I had no idea of the details of his connection with Houston (obviously). His work with the Frankfurt orchestra has been brilliant - including a great Mahler 2 so Houston can expect a memorable finale. I wonder why he resigned from Vienna, also where he will go next? I do hope we see more of him online.
@Alcina Hi Alcina, And I would be number two. He is at home with just about every facet of orchestral music and with the Frankfurt orchestra, in my opinion, out -performs the Berlin ensemble - more warmth, and a feeling of youthful spontaneity with even the deepest works. The Weiner Symphoniker is brilliant but rather traditional, so I rather think there could have been a clash in the general approach to performances and interpretation. Just guessing.
This is what we must design, no doubt, no hesitate an outstanding performance. Since I began to be fan of HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie, the emotion to listen any composer's music has grown up to the highest level. First, the musicians are all of them really soloists: I have heard them during the worst of coronavirus. Second: maestro Andrés Orozco-Estrada goes into the deepest feelings of the composition which ever it is. And, last but not least, the recordings and Filmings are possibly the best to be listen and watch.
CONGRATULATIONS to everyone in HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie. Viel Danke. Muchas gracias, thanks a million 👋👋👋👋
I love this maestro best myself
It seems that the last movement of 8th symphony has some similar rhythms and playfulness as Dvořak´s Wind serenade of the last movement.... Also, 2nd movement of 8th symphony may be a version of the wind serenade... Watch the video of Conductor Estrada and the wind serenade.
TLDR: Bravo!
I've only been had classical music in my life for maybe a litter over a decade now and mostly used Berlin Phil, Vienna Phil, and a few American orchestra as a references. But this orchestra easily one of my go-to's as of recently to listen to just for the sheer amount of energy these awesome musicians share among each other. It's something about the sound, balance, and direction of their playing that has had me hooked on them for a quite some time now.
The old #4 was the first piece of orchestral music I ever played as a high school grad. What I like about this particular orchestra is that the personnel seem to be having so much fun.
The best recorded, best filmed, best conducted and best played orchestra I've heard on YT. Hope to hear them in person some day.
one of my favourite bits of music. absolutely divine. its food for my soul.
At his best, Andrés Orozco-Estrada is a top flight conductor - and he and the Frankfurt Radio Symphony are a wonderful partnership. This performance in many ways outclasses many of the performances of more "famous" orchestras - but this orchestra deserves to be considered in the same conversation as those orchestras. Many great conductors and orchestras have recorded the Dvorak 8th Symphony, but few have the combination of drama, intensity, beauty and charm. When life returns (hopefully soon), this work is an excellent one for the pair to tour with and show how magnificent this partnership is.
In my opinion, I also think they have the best audio considering that it is free to watch!
Personally, my favorite for this piece specifically is the performance recorded by Karajan and the Vienna Philharmonic in the 1980s, but the Frankfurt Radio Symphony always does deliver!
@@titanicman9329 just wondering, do you play any instruments?
@@titanicman9329 Christoph von Dohnányi's Decca versions of the 7th, 8th and 9th symphonies with the Cleveland Orchestra are worth mentioning.
@@Avalokitasimha Am here in Cleveland with its phenomenal Orchestra--THIS PERFORMANCE has them beat!
This conductor is one of my favorite conductors and one of the best. The Frankfurt Radio orchestra these past 4 years has become one of my favorite orchestra. In the 70's I auditioned for this same orchestra
What did you play?
Tschechisch: Génius! Čech, ve kterém se přirozeně spojuje tradice rakouská, uherská, romská, keltská..., kapku zkušenost americká a indiánská... + nebojácnost vytvořit jasnou krásnou, pro lidi chytlavou melodii. (nestyděl se za svůj obyčejný vesnický původ)... - a hle, je tu Antonín Dvořák! :-)
Finally nobody is caughing since there is barely an audience!
They have face nask. Next time (when we are in the "old) (???) Situation all audiance must wear face-mask. (Lol or no lol?) to listen better to the full value of the music.
It'really true, but performers love audience because it gives them energy, fire and even inspiration to play "with life".
@@eduardoxavier7878 Yeah for sure. That whole "pandemic" is a farce and I feel for all the artists that suffer under the sanctions.
@@lele9exlYou are right! Artists love public applauses!
@@petrusdenoude8837 rfvng
Grazie maestro Andrés, grazie a tutti. Dopo una giornata di 12 ore di ambulatorio Covid mi avete donato gioia e ristoro. Siete una comunità di amici che suonano con una unità e un entusiasmo commoventi. Grazie maestro per la sua intelligenza e umanità musicale. Grazie ancora, avanti così....
The first 60 seconds, from 0:21 to 01:21, are a little masterpiece in themselves. I could listen to this opening a hundred times!
Did you notice the train at 2:50? It's in the background.
Che meraviglia... E che orchestra! Ascoltando le melodie di Dvorak (dei Poemi Sinfonici in particolare) non riesco a non piangere...
Vero, musica incredibile
In many ways this is my favourite Dvorak symphony. He's reached his mature style in his most personally expressive way. He's freed himself from "Brahmsianisms" here. Just pure Dvorak..
Absolutely love this spirited, bright, almost animated interpretation by Orozco-Estrada!
En plena Pandemia....un regalo de Dvorak...Andrés Orozco-Estrada...Clarita...todos...¡¡¡ gracias de verdad !!!!
Et Carla à la flûte 😍
Clara plays with a lot of passion and is beautiful.
I am also one of her big fans and am so glad to see her in action when I do.
the other orchestra members are equally committed to the music; she just happens to be more eye-catching.
@@paulwilson4738 opppp}} @}p
@@frankstein9982 Very true; she seems to get a lot of screen time, esp. when there's a wind focus.
Si Fernandez en la pandemia mundial y local....nos queda la Música que no es poco....gracias.
Horacio, te felicito!!
Me encanta mucho esta sinfonía y con Clara Andrada muy bonito, saludos desde México
I listened to this piece in the the last concert before the Covid Lockdown early this year, which is also my favourite concert in my life so far. Miss these old days.
0:19 begins | 4:22 repeat intro | 7:16 heroic section | 10:41 2nd movement | 21:38 3rd movement |
27:46 4th movement (green ranger) | 37:45 ending
Très beau concert avec une flûtiste d'exception qui crève l'écran !
The second movement is remarkable. I love the flexibility of tempo between the simple flute motto (pushing forward) and the clarinet duet (lingering). These musicians have made my quarantine.
Good ears! That is one of the most remarkable moments in this performance.
Yes, I've heard this symphony a million time and this immediatelly caught my attention! I've never heard it performed like that, which is strange, because it sounds so natural and logical.
Espectacular, la ejecución.Clara......absolutamente brutal.
Orozco Estrada......impecable.Me he emocionado
By far the finest performance of this symphony that I've heard to date. In saying that, there isn't a work that I've heard from this orchestra that I haven't thoroughly enjoyed listening to.
Manfred Honeck performed it with the SAME orchestra and it's literally a million times better. Check it out, it's also on TH-cam.
@@MisterPathetique A million times better? Both recordings are fantastic, but I actually like the one with Orozco-Estrada a little more! I don't think the third movement here can ever be topped.
@@Failentin Of course I was exaggerating to make my point. This performance is not horrible, but I don't find it particularly good either.
I don't think Orozco-Estrada has a lot of feeling for this music, and it shows right in the opening: the cellos should be leading, but here they're kinda drowned out. The third movement didn't impress me either, the melody tends to disappear because of Orozco-Estrada's random dynamic adjustments and tapered phrasing.
But the worst thing to me is the general lack of energy and accent, and the flabby rhythm throughout the piece. And to be honest Orozco-Estrada is not helped by the overly compressed sonics either. I mean just compare the development section of the first movement or the very conclusion of the symphony with Honeck's performance, you'll understand what I'm talking about.
Besides Honeck, I suggest you listen to Davis/Concertgebouw, Dohnányi/Cleveland, Neumann/Czech Philharmonic or even Karajan/Vienna Philharmonic. And then come back to Orozco-Estrada, you will immediately hear what's lacking in his performance.
And please never assume that a performance "can't ever be topped". We can ALWAYS do better. Otherwise, why should we even bother playing this music?
Une interprétation exceptionnelle et Clara l'incomparable.
Oh my favorite concertmaster! love his solo 14:26 with him the orchestra has another energy.
Thank you so much for your kind words!🙏😃💚
@P1xlz Thank you so much for your kind words!!🙏🙏☺️
@@floriniliescu ong
Agreed: This is the loveliest rendition of this solo that I've ever heard. He has matched his vibrato and bowing and phrasing perfectly to the needs of that musical moment. Refined, yet lush. I'd love to hear much more of his playing.
Wunderbarer Dvorak, wunderbares hr Sinfonieorchester! Bravissimo!
En casa siempre nos gustó la novena sinfonía de Dvorák ¡Pero la octava no se queda atrás! ¡Preciosa interpretación de esta maravillosa orquesta!🎉
Meine Lieblingssinfonie von Dvorak, schön, sie hier ein weiteres Mal zu hören!
Auch meine!
Muy merecidos aplausos 👏 para todas y cada uno de los miembros de la orquesta y para su Director.
6:59 Gut strings!? You gotta love to see it, especially in a modern orchestra!
I didn't even notice. Thanks for the information.
Yes! I've been waiting for this Symphony with this conductor and Orchestra.
¡Qué asombroso es Dvorak! Ejecución maravillosa de esta orquesta, ¡perfectamente perfectos! Muchas gracias. ¡Bravísimo!
Mavelous performance! Congratulations from the bottom of my heart.
An excellent overall performance. But, I admit all the time I caught myself waiting to hear and see that magnificent lady playing the flute!
No orchestra can play Dvorak's 8th better than the hr! Excellent performance.
How I'd love to see a recording of Dvorak's 7th with this brilliant conductor and orchestra 😄
Dvoraks 7 with HR is now on TH-cam :-)
@@tribonian3875 Yes, I've seen it, but thanks for letting me know! :) It was a really wonderful performance, as expected 😄
I remember Sezi Ozawa's BSO played in Salt Lake City 40 years ago. That's the reason I keep coming back to this music whoever played.
The video recording is so amazing!
Sublime. Thank you again.
It would seem this Colombian fellow works with different music scores: Under his conducting, I can hear melodic lines of different instruments that I can not distinghish or hear with any other conductors. ¡Bravo!
I have performed this piece several times on 1st Horn - including with the Vienna Symphony (not the Philharmonic! :-) ) I really like this performance and yes, the conductor finds details that are often lost in the cascades of sound.
Sehr eindrucksvoll，vielen Dank。
30:14 this flute solo is quite bears quite a delicate and jovial melody; I admire this section most out of the symphony
Wow, I love the interpretation of the longer descending notes from 22:48 compared with from 22:53 .... pure beauty!❤
Extraordinari concert. En plena pandèmia pel COVID, la gran orquestra de Frankfurt ens ofereix una grandiosa actuació. Amb un dels millors Directors actuals. Sense presuncions, amb el seu treball, ANDRES OROZCO-ESTRADA ens fa gaudir de la música ben interpretada. Fóra del seu gran Alpe oper. Felicitacions Sinfonieorchester, i mestre Orozco-Estrada. Gràcies!
Excelente orquesta, excelente director y músicos...
Vielen Dank für Ihren wunderbaren Eindruck!
Alles war großartig, vor allem aber das Solo des Konzertmeisters im zweiten Satz.
Es war der beliebteste Ton, den ich je gehört habe.
Vielen Herzlichen Dank!Ich freue mich sehr,dass Ihnen mein Solo gefallen hat!💚😃🙏
どうもありがとうございました!😆
どういたしまして😃
Ich werde dich weiterhin unterstützen！
@@meimama1031 Herzlichen Dank😃💚
I would like to say , great player with great audio technical system ! marvelous!
I m now the fans of hr!
I love how much fun he has in M3. It's one of my favorite scherzo movements ever!
While this is certainly NOT one of my favorite Dvorak SYMPHONIES, It IS the BEST performance of it I've ever heard.
ソーシャル ディスタンス オケ、、しっかりと鳴って♬いました。第4楽章の、、ブラボー👏
What a great orchestra! To say the first fute player nailed the part is an understatement. Never heard it better. The trumpets and trombones! Holy cow. Y que viva Colombia! Un pais que amo mucho!
Súper concert ! 👏👏👏👏 Bravoooooo 🥰🥰🥰 thanks for this vídeo . The conductor is very very special for this music . Congratulations 👏👏🌹🌹🌹 The concertino Bravo for this expressions, and the quality play violin👏👏👏🥰🥰🥰🥰
Horns are awesome at 37:19
There is no better performance of this piece...brilliant!
Manfred Honeck performed it with the SAME orchestra and it's literally a million times better. Check it out, it's also on TH-cam.
@@MisterPathetique I've compared the two, over two days, and I believe you're right. Honeck is less athletic on the podium, but he gets the depth in the energy of the piece - i.e. exciting but not superficial - in a way which I don't think Orozco-Estrada quite does; though it remains a pleasing performance, and Estrada is still quite young and has room to develop.
@@RobertJonesWightpaint I wholly agree with your analysis.
Hoje temos mais de 514 mil.mortos aqui.... país à deriva....mas, enquanto houver Arte, estaremos seguros... parabéns para todos desta orquestra e grato pelos momentos que nos trazem alívio a tanto sofrimento.... abraços gratidão desde RioJaneiro.Brasil....continuem....por favor
That you for your wonderful videos. I am enjoying them with my grade school students, as we are studying Dvorak.
A wonderful listening experience - thank you
Видео, операторская работа, монтаж - все экстра-класса! Великолепно!
Amazing quality, both video and audio! I have never heard another dvorak 8 as crisp as this!
One of the greatest symphonies.
Always have to chuckle at the beginning of the third movement because of how often it's used in Twoset's videos XD.
Wonderful and capturing performance!!! Love the tension in the first movement.
so glad I found this channel!
Me too. Been watching for hours all day.
Una maravillosa interpretación de la orquesta y genial dirección de la música. Este director expresa gran energía y control, es buena representación del continente americano allá en Europa.
I love the second clarinet player, he is so into the music! as it should be!
Ein hervorragendes Orchester! Die Soli der Flötistin gefallen mir ganz besonders
Wieder ein fantastisches Konzert des HR-Sinfonieorchesters, vielen vielen Dank dafür! Leider war diesmal mein Lieblings-Fagottist nicht dabei, war aber akustisch für mich nicht wahrnehmbar. ;-)
Joyous! Bravo. 15:38
Love the end of the second movement. Like a weight being lifted off your shoulders.
Wow - great performance and brilliant sound recording. Most TH-cam performances have poor sound quality but this one stood out. Bravo!
Thank you very much...fan from Korea
Thank you for such an excellent performance!
Awesome ending, i love Dvorak.
A charming symphony wonderfully performed. I almost forget Covid. Thanks a lot
13:47 Hard to describe this gorgeous melody.
Did you notice the train motif in 2:50 with the flute solo, in the background?
Wunderschöne und lyrische Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und ethnisch komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der dritte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt lyrisch. Der intelligente Maestro dirigiert das kompakte und ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut phrasierten Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
klingt wie meine schulaufsätze, wenn ich ne 1 brauchte...
@@M4r1a_Schn33 Viele Schulaufsätze brauche ich.
@@notaire2 Go on, notaire2. Schön wenn’s dir so gut gefällt! 👍🏻😎
@@mz4802 Thanks for affirmative comment!
Como siempre, también ahora, Sinfoniorchester no defrauda nunca... Y Andres Orozco-Estrada un GRAN Director. Mejor que las "vedettes" Gergiev , Dudamel y Rattle.
Meilleur, je ne saurais dire et la musique n'est pas un sport mais une chose est certaine : Andrés Orozco Estrada est un grand maestro et sa conception très humaine de la direction d'orchestre nous comble un peu plus chaque jour.
오 ! 👍
이 아름다운 실황영상을
인생 클래식님이 보셔야할텐데
최고의 연주 감사드립니다. 트롯신
Wonderful Symphony~♡
Simplemente hermoso :')
HRSO and Orozco-Estrada never disappoint
Fantastic performance!
Muy pulcra la interpretación. Me encantó
Dvorak's melody is full of nostalgia and comfort .
These performers and a prestigious conductor express Dvorak's aesthetics skillfully .
Dvorak's work has a strong spirit ,
And Dvorak has an indomitable soul to confront his own misery .
Dvorak is great and effulgent
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
Which national are you watching this video ？
From the UK!
@@jenlw8974
Thank-you so much to your comments
We know the situations of the UK on the TV
Hang in there ！
Be on the alert for Covid - １９
The season of blooming cherry blossoms has come again in Japan .
This season is marvellous , glorious and beyond your imagination for the cherry blossoms in full bloom everywhere in Japan , (parks , hills , mountains , on the banks of rivers , various gardens , domestic Bonsai
and etc. )
However ,
for the second year in a row ,
just like last year , when we felt lonely to prevent Covid - １９
the banquets in famous public parks under the cherry blossoms in full bloom have been perfectly banned ,
The Rite of Spring peculiar to Japan from １０００years ago can no longer be held .
We are very lonely and unfortunate .
This year too , the cherry blossoms are destined to fall lonely in front of us .
The true cherry - blossoms viewing , shortly speaking ,
the true banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom is to lay rugs under the cherry blossoms in full bloom and sing and dance with eating various Bento and drinking Japanese sake , beer , Japanese shochu , wine ,etc .
The number of the infected people is gradually decreasing ,
Be on the alert for Covid - １９
Cheer up ！
Someday please visit Japan
distinguished Four Seasons and Japanese delicious foods wait for you
Good luck ！
MÜZİK RUHUN GIDASIDIR.
La musique est la nourriture de l'âme.
I think the concert hall reflects their sound better than ever before :) I checked my ear buds cause I never heard this kinda record quality Lols
참 좋습니다.
Concertmaster and Flautista are rock stars.
Excelente Gracias
Omg Clara’s (flutist) smile ! 31:12 ♥️
The concert performances of the last 3 Dvorak Symphonies led by A O-E and the FRS are, imo, in the same class as those led by George Szell and the Cleveland Orchestra recorded in the late 1950's and Istvan Kertesz and the LSO. Before he left Frankfurt I wish he had led a performance of the Dvorak 6th. Similarly I hope he leads performances of the Brahms Serenade #1 and the Schumann Symphonies during his tenure in Cologne. These concert videos are uniformly of the highest quality with superb ensemble playing and never a sign of the jaded playing which seems to infect so many supposedly top-notch orchestras. I always look forward to A O-Es returns to Frankfurt!
Well, this was a definite surprise.
thank you for the music :)
Super !!