Yeah. I would have fired him the first day. Way too many notes. No groove. He played like he was the only guy on the stage. Just awful. There is no way he played on those records.
Fran is a great bass player but it was Tom Schultz that wrote and recorded the bass on the album to this song and 98% of the first 3 albums. Fran only recorded a very small amount of bass
Ugggg,,, he's rushing so bad. There is no groove what so ever. Way too many notes. These guys are so inexperienced at live performance and it shows. There just up there playing parts. Boston wasn't a band, it was a Tom Schultz project. Great record but, I highly doubt if Fran played a note on the record.
Yes, Barry Goudreau was a key ingredient in the original lineup. Too bad Scholz felt they could no longer work together. As far as Sib, he was a fine drummer but I think Jim Masdea’s drumming was more powerful and may have been a better fit. Rock And Roll Band’s drum parts from the debut are standouts imo.
Goudreau’s VOCALS are CRIMMMINALLY underrated!! 👈 😱 My 🎧 are on 11 and I cannot believe my EARS!! What a TALENT! He’s carrying half the weight up there!! 🤘🤘
This is actually the first time I'd heard Delp live, & he's not hitting the notes the way he does on the albums. He probably had a bad day--not everyone is in perfect voice all the time, which isn't good for a singer. But Goudreau sounds awesome & so much like Delp.
I'm so in love with Brad Delp's voice. Whenever I hear Boston I wish I was born at least 10 years earlier lol. I was born in 1978 and first heard about this awesome band in the late 90s/early 2000s.
These guys were and are ROCK GODS! Boston was a great band ( live or studio) hard to believe they had so many hits with just a handful of albums.I ❤ BOSTON 4 EVER!
Barry Goodrow was definitely an asset. Great guitar player and voice one of a kind just like Brad Delp. But I did recall something years ago, Tom got his rocking sound from Barry Goodrow's, amplifier with a blown resistor. Either or the XPR modulator, One was supposedly used by Barry goudreau on stage, couldn't buy that one I believe it was an XPR a, gentleman would not sell it to me but he had an XPR. Which I bought, either or you can't beat anything with Boston's music and technology at the time, this band is my favorite and what all of them have achieved, will be in history books or at least mine.
Have come to realize that Barry Goudreau was a much more critical component of this band than I ever knew about ....through both his guitar and his voice.
Love the base player ..i need what hes taking...wow them vocals get a little ruff but thats diff between live and studio..watching def lep and you can tell there was some recording help with them live for joe
Dang, this is the BEST version of Boston, Giants Stadium 1979 live video I've heard!!! It sounds great!!! I wish you had more of Boston from this live concert. We all already know about Brad's voice, best in rock history. But dang, Barry is then the best harmonizing vocal ever! And this video clearly you can hear that. Thank you!!!
I like how Tom Scholz often would just slide up a couple of frets to hit a note instead of bending the string a couple of frets back. Unless you have a great ear for pitch and vibrato, players should consider this a bit more. Just a different approach that works.
Why not , do bolth, to me hitting a note or cord sounds better than just , bending a string to achieve a cord, only if you're playing a lead, or just put a capo on it , drop it down, a few frets. Detune. Have somewhat of an ear tuning but it's always one note flat which is good for a recording. But what the hell do I know about a guitar.
Barry Goodreau’s lead guitar work on that song just really puts it over the edge. The harmony guitar riffs are awesome but Barry really puts the icing on the cake too bad Tom Scholz just hates him so much. Envy is a terrible thing.
This just proves the high notes on the records were digitally produced. His normal singing here is great, he can't come close to any high notes. The "more than a feeling" song from this concert really proves it.
Brad did it differently here, but I heard him hit the highest note in more than a feeling. I saw them 5 times. Besides, this was an all analog recording on the original album.
Brad delp could hit the high notes live and did , theres plenty of live recordings where he does it, i have several so yes he could hit them and really did on the album recordings too
So, Brad's vocals aren't perfect in this performance BUT I love this so much more than the auto tune that people are using today. Because although it may be a little pitchy in the higher end, he is giving it everything he's got and he's probably been singing for several nights in a row. I just love this and respect this so much more than the way they do it nowadays.
F- TOM SCHOLZ (nicest way) -"Yeh, I'M TOM" "Id be the TALL, rich/famous Genius MIT post-grad, concert pianist ,rock star, GUITAR GOD, sound engineering music producing ,patented INVENTOR and entrepreneur w/ MODEL good looks"
Flat as a pancake. Kids at high school.thought it was Rush. Had the first record. Thank God for record clubs..13 records for one penny .just buy 6 more in 3 years
Again.... Scholz strumming chords through a machine and the REAL GUITAR PLAYER who gets no credit and was thrown out of the band, BARRY GOUDREAU is playing the guitar for real and the solos.
No human could actually sing the Boston tunes live. Brad was an amazing vocalist, but there is no doubt Tom did a ton of work manipulating his vocals in the studio.
This is just guys thrown together to promote a record. This isn;t a band. They just don't know how to play together. There is no groove. No timing. No sense of being a cohesive unit. Completely fake. And, there is no way this lead bass player played a note on the records. He's terrible. The records were great. But it's just studio work that didn't;t translate to live.
@@davidstewart4310 And,,,, it sounds like it. I would have fired that clown bass player on the first day of rehearsal.. Thanks for the info. You just confirmed what I thought.
Love the base player ..i need what hes taking...wow them vocals get a little ruff but thats diff between live and studio..watching def lep and you can tell there was some recording help with them live for joe
The bass player was just wild.
Yeah
Fran Sheehan
His style is very funky. I like this mix where you can really hear him.
Yeah. I would have fired him the first day. Way too many notes. No groove. He played like he was the only guy on the stage. Just awful. There is no way he played on those records.
Fran is a great bass player but it was Tom Schultz that wrote and recorded the bass on the album to this song and 98% of the first 3 albums. Fran only recorded a very small amount of bass
Fran Sheehan at 3:51 is my new favorite bassist!
Haha
Ugggg,,, he's rushing so bad. There is no groove what so ever. Way too many notes. These guys are so inexperienced at live performance and it shows. There just up there playing parts. Boston wasn't a band, it was a Tom Schultz project. Great record but, I highly doubt if Fran played a note on the record.
@@midlifemotox I'm sure everyone in the audience is like, "Damn we'd be having a great time if that bassist just wasn't rushing."
Barry's background vocals as well as Sib's drumming really brought the sound to life. Nothing better than the ORIGINAL LINE UP
Barry had a great voice.
Cool effect on Barry’s vocals too
RIP Sib Hashian
Yes, Barry Goudreau was a key ingredient in the original lineup. Too bad Scholz felt they could no longer work together. As far as Sib, he was a fine drummer but I think Jim Masdea’s drumming was more powerful and may have been a better fit. Rock And Roll Band’s drum parts from the debut are standouts imo.
Barry’s great as a singer and player in Boston and his solo album from 1980 is pretty awesome as well.
3:45 is the look of absolute rock and roll bliss, dude looks like he's in a state of Nirvana.
I was feeling it to then I saw your comment.
@@susanb2015 😊
The great Brad Delp. RIP.
Such a great band. Insane they aren’t in the RR hall of fame
There will never be another band like this!!! I'm still in love with them after all these years!! ❤
the bass player is off his tits ...love him !!!
WOW! Boston playing at NY Giants stadium. And getting positive results. Whoda, Thunk?
One of the best bands of all times
Goudreau’s VOCALS are CRIMMMINALLY underrated!! 👈 😱 My 🎧 are on 11 and I cannot believe my EARS!! What a TALENT! He’s carrying half the weight up there!! 🤘🤘
His record with delp was good also
This is actually the first time I'd heard Delp live, & he's not hitting the notes the way he does on the albums. He probably had a bad day--not everyone is in perfect voice all the time, which isn't good for a singer. But Goudreau sounds awesome & so much like Delp.
I remember listening to them on 8 track with my Koss headphones when they first came out. I was young but I knew what great timeless music was ❤
I'm so in love with Brad Delp's voice. Whenever I hear Boston I wish I was born at least 10 years earlier lol. I was born in 1978 and first heard about this awesome band in the late 90s/early 2000s.
3:28 is amazing!!!
What a great band Boston! Beautiful vocals and amazing musicians!
Great singer
The rest of the band trying to keep up with Fran,what a talent on bass! DaYuM
These guys were and are ROCK GODS! Boston was a great band ( live or studio) hard to believe they had so many hits with just a handful of albums.I ❤ BOSTON 4 EVER!
Color reveal was Wizard of Oz like. ;)
Golden! OMG, so pure. No auto-tune, just jamming. The real deal of rock and roll! Smoking hot guitar players. Thanks for posting!
For such an epic production.....they killed it.
Lmao Fran is TWEAKING
Cocaine is a hell of a drug.
Magnífic band is místic Boston forever \m/
2:50 He was so freakin' adorable. And Barry was a damn good singer!
God they were a great band!
This song is a masterpiece love it. Boston is a masterpiece 💙💙💙💙
Barry Goodrow was definitely an asset. Great guitar player and voice one of a kind just like Brad Delp. But I did recall something years ago, Tom got his rocking sound from Barry Goodrow's, amplifier with a blown resistor. Either or the XPR modulator, One was supposedly used by Barry goudreau on stage, couldn't buy that one I believe it was an XPR a, gentleman would not sell it to me but he had an XPR. Which I bought, either or you can't beat anything with Boston's music and technology at the time, this band is my favorite and what all of them have achieved, will be in history books or at least mine.
Tom said the Boston guitar was chained soaks and 100w amplifiers…no idea what a soak is; he’s the engineer!
@jaybee9269 he means chained 100w amps together with a power soak which reduces volume without reducing gain.
1:36 That is the most rock-n-roll bass player ever.
Funniest clip of the whole thing. lol. Just boppin' his way across the stage out of frame.
The guitar sounds amazing
Have come to realize that Barry Goudreau was a much more critical component of this band than I ever knew about ....through both his guitar and his voice.
I love the bass player too. He's always bouncing with the beat🎸🎶👍
Late 70s gotta love it music was raw genuine and felt great awesome tune
They say a little before there time ❤️💯amazing
Love the base player ..i need what hes taking...wow them vocals get a little ruff but thats diff between live and studio..watching def lep and you can tell there was some recording help with them live for joe
BarrrrBarrosssss rockkkkkkkkkkk 🎵🎶😃🥰
Just awesome
Man , Barry plays all the leads.
vocals pretty good here
Never the same without Barry
Metal guitarplayer replies
What do you mean Barry
plays all the leads? Tom
Sholz didn't? Your comment
is hard to understand.
Dang, this is the BEST version of Boston, Giants Stadium 1979 live video I've heard!!! It sounds great!!! I wish you had more of Boston from this live concert. We all already know about Brad's voice, best in rock history. But dang, Barry is then the best harmonizing vocal ever! And this video clearly you can hear that. Thank you!!!
It does sound good.
Thanks for this. Looks like Fran Sheehan snorted more than his fair share.
He did seem to be moving around a lot.....
😅😅
Yess!!!
Just fantastic...😢
Nagyon szeretem a Bostont! Remek zenét játszanak!
The way that Fran is rocking his ass off on stage, looks like he belongs in
AC⚡DC not Boston.
I like how Tom Scholz often would just slide up a couple of frets to hit a note instead of bending the string a couple of frets back. Unless you have a great ear for pitch and vibrato, players should consider this a bit more. Just a different approach that works.
Or you can get ear training classes so you have better tuning
Why not , do bolth, to me hitting a note or cord sounds better than just , bending a string to achieve a cord, only if you're playing a lead, or just put a capo on it , drop it down, a few frets. Detune. Have somewhat of an ear tuning but it's always one note flat which is good for a recording. But what the hell do I know about a guitar.
I have enough problems trying to tune my , My g-string, no that's not funny, according to my PRS custom ..
Scholz es una guitarrista superior. No hay mas que decir.
They are good live i seen them in 85
Good lord 🔥
Nice
Sheeeesh!
Fran Sheehan looks like he's playing in a different dimension than the rest of the band. haha.
Little bit of struggle but damn good though!
WTF is the bass player with the red outfit on? Must have been that California dreamin' stuff with all those facial expressions @3:51 ....😂😂😂
Buddy’s in another Dimension. Galaxy 2095. Performing in front of Alieans 😂😂😂.
What kind of drugs was the bass player on?
Ain't it? He always kinda freaks me out a bit lol. The only other thing I can think of is maybe he needs to have a rhythm to not lose the beat.
@@animemanganet >> It was the 1970s, so probably cocaine. Maybe he’s just happy like Tom?
OMG! Barry sanders 😊looks like an IGMO NOW!!!!
The whole tune is a bass solo. Fire that guy.
デルプが動いてる😊
What’s going on here?
Can't belive the empty seats ??????
Barry Goodreau’s lead guitar work on that song just really puts it over the edge. The harmony guitar riffs are awesome but Barry really puts the icing on the cake too bad Tom Scholz just hates him so much. Envy is a terrible thing.
How about his backup vocals too? Sounds like he could have been a singer in a band himself
Barry always been great…but he needs to be in a band like this to be great. Yeah, Tom’s a control freak and a perfectionist, for sure. Bless him!
Miss h?hm
Anyone in the audience?
You only see the people in bad seats behind the stage!
They were soo anti-disco, but were wearing disco garb. Fine. Giving them a pass. They were great none the less.
Love Tom, but noone is ever gonna accuse him of hittin the gym too hard.
Goofy-looking nerd that rocks so hard!
What the hell is
that supposed to mean?
Brad sounds good, just a terrible recording. The audio keeps slipping in an out
This just proves the high notes on the records were digitally produced. His normal singing here is great, he can't come close to any high notes. The "more than a feeling" song from this concert really proves it.
Brad did it differently here, but I heard him hit the highest note in more than a feeling. I saw them 5 times. Besides, this was an all analog recording on the original album.
Brad delp could hit the high notes live and did , theres plenty of live recordings where he does it, i have several so yes he could hit them and really did on the album recordings too
you’re full of it digital voice in the 1970s yeah right
Brad delp lead singer
Bassist is making drugged out faces at 4 minutes. LMAO. Delp probably wanted to smash in his face.
I saw thesr guys livr atound the same time and their sound was impecable. This sucks.
Not too bad for the era.
Haha, that silk dressed bass player looks so weird...
So, Brad's vocals aren't perfect in this performance BUT I love this so much more than the auto tune that people are using today. Because although it may be a little pitchy in the higher end, he is giving it everything he's got and he's probably been singing for several nights in a row. I just love this and respect this so much more than the way they do it nowadays.
Also, stage monitoring wasn't that great in those days. He might have been having a hard time hearing himself.
The singer is struggling without his vocal amp..the band sounds horrible..this is a wreck
Macho Man on bass.
And tom Schultz lead guitarist
F- TOM SCHOLZ (nicest way)
-"Yeh, I'M TOM"
"Id be the TALL, rich/famous Genius MIT post-grad, concert pianist ,rock star, GUITAR GOD, sound engineering music producing ,patented INVENTOR and entrepreneur w/ MODEL good looks"
Flat as a pancake. Kids at high school.thought it was Rush. Had the first record. Thank God for record clubs..13 records for one penny
.just buy 6 more in 3 years
Again.... Scholz strumming chords through a machine and the REAL GUITAR PLAYER who gets no credit and was thrown out of the band, BARRY GOUDREAU is playing the guitar for real and the solos.
ロックを聞きなれて来た僕だけど、ボストンの衝撃は違った。相当なショックだった。トム・ショルツさんが早く亡くなってしまったことが本当に残念。
Tom Scholz no. El cantante Brad Delp.
No human could actually sing the Boston tunes live. Brad was an amazing vocalist, but there is no doubt Tom did a ton of work manipulating his vocals in the studio.
Screw the HOF they should be honored they're not in it these days
This is just guys thrown together to promote a record. This isn;t a band. They just don't know how to play together. There is no groove. No timing. No sense of being a cohesive unit. Completely fake. And, there is no way this lead bass player played a note on the records. He's terrible. The records were great. But it's just studio work that didn't;t translate to live.
All bass on the album was Tom Scholz apart from the final song called LET ME TAKE YOU HOME TONIGHT
@@davidstewart4310 And,,,, it sounds like it. I would have fired that clown bass player on the first day of rehearsal.. Thanks for the info. You just confirmed what I thought.
@@midlifemotox Habria que despedirte a ti por decir estupideces.Estas hablando de la mejor banda de Rock de la historia.
Love the base player ..i need what hes taking...wow them vocals get a little ruff but thats diff between live and studio..watching def lep and you can tell there was some recording help with them live for joe