Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? | Part-02 | Ali Zaidi Vs Shabbar Zaidi | Z2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- "Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? Part 01" Watch a candid discussion between former Federal Minister Ali Haider Zaidi and Former FBR Chairman Shabbar Zaidi.
-----------
MM News TV - The Unbiased Perspective
MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information.
-----------
Follow us on:
Website: mmnews.tv/
Twitter: / mmnewsdottv
Facebook: / mmnewsdottv
Instagram: / mmnewsdottv
-----------
Watch Previous Episodes:
Ep 01: • Establishment or Govt:...
Ep 02: • Pakistan Hasn't Change...
Ep 03: • Corruption: The Ultima...
Ep:04: • FBR Should be Shut Dow...
-----------
Economic Genocide of Karachi:
Part -01: • Is Karachi facing an E...
-----------
#shabbarzaidi #alizaidi #federalboardofrevenue #z2 #povertyline #tax #psdp #establishment #businessmen #bureaucracy #naidqasid #pakistanipolitician #pakistanipolitics #govtemployees #pansion #sindhwastemanagement #karachi #genocide #economycrisis #dataanalytics #economicgeography #economyofpakistan #muradsaeed #corruptioninpakistan #altafhussain #mqm #mqmlondon #kachiabaadi #uno #sindhi #muhajir #sindhpolice #kattipahari #urduspeaking #pathan #gizri
![ลองสั่งของจากแอพ temu ถูกจริงหรอ?? ( part : 1/2 ) [โกงไหมครับ ep.89 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RTcZSQTiDZw/mqdefault.jpg)
PPP is only interested in making money from the taxes generated by Karachi.
The ppp have destroyed Karachi. At least Maryam from the corrupt PMLN is doing something good in Punjab. Karachi needs to get rid of the azaab of ppp
Plus mqm..
And mola sayasat
@@Hadi.AFOODbestforlife
Haqeeqat ye matarway hamesha mqm ko chupyengy aakhir inki bhooki jamat Jo hao
@@engr.a.d2850 bhi Jan.
Mara talaq kpk Sy ha ..
And UK Scotland sy..
Bs itna khaty han Jo zalim ha gult ha ..wo gult ha .. qasa moktasar
@@Hadi.AFOODbestforlife
To bhaijan Sach bola jaata hai to poora Sach bola jaata hai adhoora Sach hamesha zulm ko tahafuz dene k liye kaha jaata hai
زیدی صاحب
جلدی کریں درخواست دیں ھم آپکے ساتھ ھیں۔سندھ تین حصوں میں اور پنجاب چار میں تقسیم ھونا چاھیے۔
A very dangerous discussion by Ali Zaidi and Shabar Zaidi. This program must be kept as record. I am worried for the life of these two gentlemen .
dont be.
more and more people are talking about it . cmon now. FEAR = FALSE EVIDENCE APPREARING REAL. Dont Be fearful
th-cam.com/video/BnLN8SgLAXY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=00TCPnfhhpXUTdaX
How will over taxing increase grey economy.
He is a legend.... Mashallah he is very courageous and bold and a philosopher because his talks are not less deep than a philosopher... Great love from haripur,kpk❤
Very well raise voice for Karachi and identify the problem n plz continue on this topic
We need more podcasts like these Ali bhai !!!
Absolutely! Karachi is facing economic social political genocide including ethinic cleansing by the racist establishment of Pakistan!
this establishment imposed urdu and they created mqm against sindhies.................................how can you tell them racist???
when people from [anjab demand remove of urdu which was imposed by brits .............urdu is indian language then why you cry about racism???
hmari apni language he so hme nhi chahie apki language
Shabbar Zaidi sahab ne bilkul sae farmaye sari baten, He is a well-versed and brave person, he knows how things work and who are the beneficiaries of Karachi.
Still Musharraf s district govt idea is largely viable in pakistan because it was successful in the past and can also be now also all the divisions should be given the status of the administratively sub provinces!
Stop mediocre appreciation and start mindful messages.
Muhajer have only one land which is Karachi rest of the Karachiets have two land which may have in other parts of the country as well.
dont lie, Muhajir are a nation, whereever they go it becomes a dreamland, they gave us Karachi and we made it whole, now they all want to rip it apart, leave the place now and see if it worth shit without us, Karachi is nothing without its people
Love you zadi sab. From.kpk
Manshera...
Your my ideal my teacher ❤.
Live you long .
Please one ep on shia suni.fasad how we can eliminate this fasad..
Love you Ali sab and zadi sab
Aapkee baat pr mera 1 shair:
فاصلے دلوں کے بڑھائے گئے،
انسانیت کے درجے بنائے گئے،
کوئی کافر کوئی مسلماں ہوا،
ہمیشہ آدمی صلیب چڑھائے گئے۔
فروغ علی ساگر
My grandfather knows Karachi and Karachi politics like back of his hand. He was in job market in sixties, being a son of working poor father he was discriminated in NED college due to quota of 35 sears from 135seats. A college built by a Karachi Wala for Karachi wale students. In jobs especially in CSP selection there were 2% quota for Karachi domiciled. The bank job was very desirable in that time period, where a Shia candidate had better chance. Police jobs were mostly for one group of people, Redon being IG was Shia.
Please talk about the solution. According to my grandfather abolish quota for hiring and with whitest results and ability.
Urdu speaking candidate topped the CSP examination for straight twenty seven years and only few were hired. My dada never complained and moved on and he did very well in life.
I have to tell you that he would made a damn good CSP officer, a least better than goofy, poorly educated and corrupt officers.
My dadi a topper of DOW MEDICAL had to go through the same shit.
Shabbar Saheb comes from extraordinary wealthy and powerful family and well educated background and if he is frustrated. Just imagine my grandfather’s experience.😊
now you understand how Hindus in India feel? 2 countries were created out of India for Muslims but India still secular gives previlages to Muslims who are in India.
Every household in Karachi has endured similar harrowing ordeals. Even my extended family and I have comparable stories involving state institutions like PIA SBP Army...
Very true ❤
The domicile system was introduced by Bhutto. There is no sectarian angle to that since Bhutto allegedly and Nusrat Bhutto was 100% Pure Shia from Iran. PPP is majority Shia Political Party with minority Sunni Politicians Infact PPP was coined by Isphani at Al Murtuza House and the initial meeting was held at Lahore I forget the name of that person but he was Sayyed from Punjab.
Urdu speakers destroyed the city by this sectarian mentality believe me we are the problem not anyone else.
@@ChefbyMistake You are unaware of the basic law of Pakistan. Domicile certificate is the certificate of residence for a person who needs to prove his citizenship.
Quota system for hiring was done Ayub Khan.
Get you reading up to date.
11:44 Why? can you have a Non Muslim Finance Minister for Pakistan?
Fist thing it is a kolachi. Part of Balochistan. Was a capital of Pakistan. Now it is become Punjabistan, or desh of kachay kay dakot. Or we can call it a orphanage afghans, indians , bangali, memon, & others.
Sahi kaha
we panjabi rule bundloch.........................wah kia bat he...
@@vantagehistory1813
Yes punjabis were always slaves to British people and now to USA tareekh utha lo ye log kbh bh azaad haisiyat se nh rahy hamesha inpar dosroon ne hukmurani bh ki Hoti to bh Sahi tha par ye log hamesha ghulam hi rahy hain hamesha se hi ghulam rahy hain aur Muslim Punjabi to hamesha gair Muslim k bbarpoor ghulam rahy hain Inka zaroye maash bh inki ghulami me Raha hai
Urdu ka janaza he zara dhoom se nikly ...
Hum Mhujeero ka janza😂
Zabardas, put frequent episodes
Ye dono chaley Huey kartoos hai . Jab taqat thi tab Koch nahi kia ab new dokan kholne LAGEY hai.
Sun lo na baat.😅
Usually countries own an army. But, Pakistan army owns a country.
"Jung kabhi jeeti nahi, election kabhi haara nahi"- Pakistan army 😂😂😂
Tum India men apni man chudao hamarey ghar ke matters men ghusney ki zaroorat Nahin hai.
make south sindh province come up and make south sindh province
Without Karachi , Pakistan will not progress because they are unable to argue any matter to them , not having any future plans and justifications.
#SHABBARZAIDI SAHIB - #THANKS ! #KARACHI #LIFELINE FOR #PAKISTAN. #NOOPTION FOR #SOLIDCITIZEN #MIGRATORSFROMINDIA #MAHAJIRS ..EXCEPT TO #WORK IN #FORCED CONDITION.. ITS #ECONOMICS PROGRESS?
Pakistan is comprised with mostly modern tribes religious educated not a good planners totally dependant on Bengal tigers UK , agriculturalists and Khans.
Who was Syed Sardar Ahmed who was Sindh Finance Minister from 2008-13?
Grateful to Shabbar zaidi because he raised voice against for world most oppressed occupied city❤
Excellent information and narration...
Khargosh khan bor analysis 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Zaidi bhai Allah ap Ki Hifzaaat farmay
Great direction for shabbar
Shabbar Zaidi very important point why i will not start the tribalism the same which is in Sindh
Shabbr bhai ki baatain Karvi sachiaoon pe mabni hoti hain. I myself Karachi born feel for Karachi so much 😢
Shabbar Zaidi Sahab bohat achi baat krty Hain
Sindhis are the fourth largest ethnic group in Karachi and grouping Punjabis with those nuswar barbarians is an insult.
Kya bol ra hai Bhai
@@engr.a.d2850 pretty self explanatory. Sindhi 4th largest ethnicity hain. Punjabio ko Pathano k sath group kar k Sindhio ko 3rd bolna baddianati hai
@@ibratnak
Ohh plz don't say k google kiya google bh wahi post krta hai Jo govt census provide krti hai aur yahi same mardum shumari me bh hua agar ye nh maanty to mardum shumari wali batain bh na karain aur apne Dil ko hosla dain q k Jo baat aap likh rahy hain bilkul hi ghalat hai video wali baat crystal clear bh hai aur usmy dum bh hai
Best podcast zaidi sahab
Dangerous Sawaalat nae. Haqq k sawaalat hain BHAI
ارے شبر صاحب یہ اتھنی سٹی کا ہی مسلہ ہے اپ لوگ گراس روٹ پر دیکھیں کراچی والے کبھی بھی پی پی کی نسلی سیاست کو نہں سمجھ سکتے
Don’t waste time leave Pakistan, live & prosper….
These two people are the agents of PPP
Karachi ko barbad armey garnels NY kya or PPP ney kya kaza mafia Pata ni it ney log kahan sy agye Pakistan ki Har city k mafia NY yahan akar kabza kya hoa Hain
Mashallah inshallah civilians k football banaya hua hai bus ⚽ enjoy kr rha hai kicks
Shabar sahab ko salam❤
Madre zaban AREBIC hote tou aaj yae halaat na houtae Shayad
Kame tum logo na bhi nahi karwa ya Karachi ma bata bana raha ho
Ali zaidi sb. it is requested to you plz let shabbar sb. Give chance to speak...
@@muhammadsaqib2961 so true. He is either Putin out senseless comment just to show his existence..
SHABBAR MASJID K BARE ME TO BOLTE HA LYKIN SCHEME 33 ME JO GAIR QANOONI IMARBARGAHEN LOGO KI ZAMEEN PA QABZA KR K BAN RAHI HA UNKE BARE ME KIA KHIAL H
Ali zaidi political leader of Karachi, does not know the political reality of Karachi. Khan SB ny bhi apny Saath heery rakhy hoy hain. Khan SB also made him head of sindh 🤫🤫😱
😂
شبر زیدی زندہ باد
Khatmals making sense!!!
Urdu speaking Karachi main 1947 main Aaya, Patan Karachi main Ayub Khan K Dur Main Aaya, Sindhi Ka Originally Taluq Sindh se Hai, Jo Shehr Ek Baloch K Naam Pe Hai, Mahi Kulanchi, Jo baad main Karachi Bana Jisne iss Shehr Ko Abad Kiya, Chahe Keamari Ho Balochi Main Matlab Kia Ka Mehal, Chahe Aurangi Ho Ya Kaurangi Dono Balochi zuban K Alfa’s Hain, Tareeqi Kabristan Balochon Ki Karachi main Hai, Baluch Androne Sindh main majority main Hain, Iss Shehr K Liya Balochon Ne Do Pa Do British Raj Se Jang Ladi Aur Apni Naslen Qurban Ki , Lekin Indono Danishwaron Ne Balochon Ka Naam Lena B Gawara Nhi Kiya, Yani Baloch Karachi Ka indigenous Qaum Hai, Karachi Uska Nhi , Lekin Wo Quamien Jo Baad Main Yahan Abad Huwee Wo Karachi K stack holder Ho Gaye.
to jab itni sadiyon se yahan thay to us waqt Karachi ki kya hesiyat thi? bat karty ho? Urdu speaking ko nahi dena kuch to na do, is city ko dedo, Baloch ho yahan, Pathan ho ya Sindhi Punjabi, sab yahin rahen, is city ka bhala hoga to sbhi khayengy na? sirf urdu speaking Karachi ka kyun bat kary? kyun k hamara koi ghr nahi? jab sb yahan rehty hain to sab bat karen na is city ki
jb Karachi ki bat Urdu speaking karta hai to baqi kyun apna rona dhona shuru kardety hain?
shabber speaks sense. ali zaidi is an establishment tout and a turncoat from pti
These youtubers keep bashing pakistan to get indian views and earn money. Pakistan is doing fine, its not the best situation but things are not this worse.
Pakistan is not doing fine. We need to stop this ostrich approach. Pakistan is suffering due to its own establishment
زیدی صاحبان
کراچی کی مشہور زمانہ 1964 کی خونریز دہشتگردی کے بعد کراچی کے اسٹوڈنٹ لیڈرز،اصل محب وطن جاںنثار علی مختار رضوی، معراج محمد خان، شہنشاہ حسین اور فتحیاب علی خان کے بارے میں گفتگو کریں تو نئی نسل کی معلومات میں اضافہ ھوگا۔ ھو سکے تو اس سے قبل کے حالات گو کہ زیادہ اھم نہ ھوں
Why karachi all sindh is facing economic genocide , your talking only about karachi that is part of sindh is prejudice and never acceptable
Almost all jobs of province have been given to its rural voters by the PPP govt. from 2008. Even fake domicile of Karachi have been made by the Deputy Commissioner and mostly they are from rural Sindh. Even appointments in many Sindh Govt. Deptt. have been made in cities of rural Sindh, and then transferred to Karachi and later absorbed in Karachi quota. The son of the soil are treated as blue blood. This is the truth.
@@SaleemShaikh-w2b
Really kbh ja k dekha hai?
Ye Sab to mqm wala manfi propaganda hai Jo aaj tak muhajir krty hain aur hamesha se munh ki khaaty hain
شبر زیدی صاحب جو بات کرتے ہیں وہ کڑوی ضرور ہوتی ہیں لیکن کھری ہوتی ہیں-
جو میرے اور آپ کے گھر سے کچرے اٹھاتے ہیں وہ کام کا کچرا وہ بھیج دیتے ہیں اور جب بچا ہوا کچرا ہوتا ہے وہ کراچی شہر میں پھینک دیتے ہیں یہ میں افغانئوں کی بات کر رہا ہوں
علی سر عوام سچ سننے میں دلچسپی رکھتی ہے، ڈسکشن سے قبل پوائنٹ نوٹ کیا کریں...
صرف مختصر سوال کیا کریں....
شبر زیدی صاحب کا انداز گفتگو ہمارے دل کی آواز ہے...مدلل، فلسفیانہ، آن دا سپاٹ
14:50....look who you are talking to? Ali zaidi ne khud Aladin park kay sath walay plot par apartments ka Grey structure khara kia tha or ab wo demolish ho chuka hai....
Bilkul sahi 7.5 crore Muhajiron ki tarjumani ki hai Shabbar Zaidi Sb ne local police kyun nahi hai Karachi ki Muhajiron ki haqiqi leadership ko Muhajiron se door kyun Rakha hoa hai Altaf Hussain Haqiqi leader hain Muhajiron k
tery leader hoga Paleed, apni bat kar
Two clowns talking absurd and using terminologies with little relevance to Karachi.
Shabar sahib discussing with ali zaidi is good for his image because through your name he is getting views mostly people never interested in ali zaidi but if you are there then everyone wants to listen
There were many finance ministers of Sindh belonged to urdu speaking sindhis syed sardar ahmed and Wasim Akhtar .
Maharashtra economy depends on revenue from bombay & pune. Else bombay has no economic activities expect concentration corporate office and very high high revenue collection from bombay & pune.
Thanks!!
Two things can easily improve things from karachi. 1. Strong local govts and 2. Develop other small cities in Pakistan like Hyderabad sukkur Multan Quetta Peshawar Bahawalpur muzaffarabad etc so that they can absorb rural urban migration . No one will come to karachi if towns near them get developed. This will reduce population load on karachi and will also encourage many non karachites living in karachi to move back.
In every provance and in each district agencies are involved deeply behind the scene , story is same .... land mafia nexus with administration, judiciary, bureaucracy, and agencies..... business man community mind diverted to land and cases in courts and also blackmailed.... judiciary ma judges says we are pressurized tu batain Pakistan ma kaya ho sakta ha ...... airport say pasay wala koi aha jay tu agencies kay tout pechay lag jati hain kay is admi ko trap kasay karna ha .... bottom line agencies yah establishment khtam ho jay yah Pakistan tabah ho jay tub chance ha Pakistan theak ho jay....
جناب کراچی کی سیاست ہمیشہ انٹی اسٹبلشمنٹ رہی ہے ۔یہ روایت فاطمہ جناح کے دور سے چلی آرہی ہے ۔
from economic genocide to party politics...interesting
Very straight and knowledgeable person
شبد تم حقیقتاً حضرت امام حسین کے پیروکار ہو۔
Hey MMNews, may I ask why my comment was deleted? Ithni ghaand phat tih hai tou aisay shows bhi upload nahi kia kerou
Punjab want to destroy Karachi
Punjabis have their own land from attock to sadiqabad and Lahore to amrister is 15 crore punjabis land
Karachi destroy by pathans and afghanis
@@basitawan5959
Yeah they have land only no port no so quality agriculture and no biggest city as a business hub that's why they want to destroy
Understood now?
oye memon gamdu .........................panjabi are 2nd largest ethnicity in karachi.............karachi will be panjabi city.........................why we will destroy it??
tm panjabio ki ghulami kr rhe ho kbhi dekha he ghulamo ko marte hue apne hatho se??
Shabbar Zaidi has to be relocated to the Middle East due to such revelations and being Ahle Tashi
Shabbar Zaidi said he told security guard to shoot the political activist of Karachi and then later he said person who used to threat him he stopped threatening after he introduced him MPA of Karachi who was physically very weak.
sector incharge versus an elite from Interior sindh?
Being a human beings Need to be grassroots level facilities to all ucs immediately for better environment and economy crises Allah bless effectors
سندھ کے فنانس منسٹر کو وفاق سے فنڈ نہیں ملتا
Perpetrator is Islam identity located at Madarsa. I bet anyone to prove me wrong. 😅😅😅😅
Why don't they themself go to UN ? Aren't they living in Karachi? Aren't they more aware than common person of karachi?
Bs podcast banao views uthao kyu k awam ko chass chaie hy karna kisi ne kuch bhi nahi.
Jinnah ne ye plot alag hy juttam pejar ke liya liya thha😂
Good job 👍
Best analyst ever
ye waqt ab shyd ane wala h UN wala
Jo mojuda halaat hain kho ke is say. ziada dangerous halat nahinho sakte
Yes, but you don't want to speak the truth. Karachi is an economic hub before Pakistan because of Gujurati-speaking people (Memon,Bohra,Ismaili,Khoja,Parsi) not because of other races.
They already left the city and settled in Punjab.
@@ChefbyMistake who told you that. You will not find Paris’s, khoja, Ismaili and Vohra in Punjab.
@@nizamuddinahmadaali3244 This is not correct, You got no Idea how they left and the Hubs are now in Punjab. Karachi is only for operations not for Headoffices.
Kaunsa Gujarati Punjab chala Gaya ?! Vast majority of Gujaratis live in karachi. PS karachi was a small town of less then 4 lacs before partition and was nothing more then the port city for north western india . That’s it. Karachi became financial and economic hub after partition thanks to all muhajirs including Gujaratis and memons
@@msr7373 karachi was economic hub even before muhajir............................ muhajir was coming in karachi since 1990s...............examples are musharraf ki family and general baig abbu and ammi came in pakistan after his promotion to 2 start general.............................
y
Good mashwara UN me jana chaiye balky me he try krta hu
اس موچھون (مچھر ) والی سرکار کو Economics کا کیا پتا ؟
We are Urdu speak Sindhi❤
You can not be sindhi
@@behuman1967true. Sindhis will never accept you. They will always be considered the Panahgir and ghair muqami .
Shrow men pta lag gaya dono ki hawa nikal gai he genocide kon he sb ko pta he pr pta he yahan khul bola to wapas kis men jayenge
Orneval more greetings to you do anyone even hear you in Pakistan you are seen and heard more in India than in Pakistan but sir come and know very well whose foundation is based on hatred
They are discussing karachi here not BJP post 2014 whose foundations are based on Muslim hate 😅😅😅
General Zia supported MQM.
For what, zia supported mqm
@@behuman1967 Divide and rule
@@naherf385all generals supported parties . Bhutto was the foreign minister of Ayub and called him his daddy
@@msr7373 True. His name was in Hamood ur Rehman's report too declaring him as the only civilian along with 13 generals who were responsible for the debacle of East Pakistan. Had he not hidden the result of this report, punished these criminal generals, and tendered an apology to the nation, he would not have been hanged by his handpicked sly fox, Gen Zia ul Haq who destroyed the basic fabric of our society.
#freePOJKandGB
Okay. Free Jammu and Kashmir, Free Khalistan, free Assam, Free Nagaland, free Mizoram, Free Manipur, Free Arunachal Pradesh, free the Naxalites.
Deal?
@@Yankee7000 aaja krale,
@@Yankee7000tum pakistan se ho
@@akshay131 I am a citizen of the world.
@@Yankee7000 ok kindly tell citizen of this world what do you know about kashmir
shabbar sb ne 3 dafa 3 crore bola khi ki abadi ko, yeh khud aUR mr zaidi ki gov ne khi ki abadi ko 2 crore hi mana hai. agar voter khi s bahar ka bhi hai tab bhi resources to shehar k use kar raha hai.
shabar nhi babar sher hain yeh uchal uchal kar layty hain yeh ............... banda mast hai qasam se zaya kar aray rahy hain shabar sahab jaise logon ko love u shabar sahab mere start ki lins ka bura nhi mana koi main fan hogaya hn shabar zaidi sahab ka
کراچی کے ٹیکس وافاق لیتا ہے
Dordari karachi khagaya hi
How will these people ever stand up to Israel all the west shame on Pakistani
Islam ka swad 😂😂 talwar se salwar phnnne wale le rhe h
I am worried for both of you, especially for Mr. Shabar Zaidi, but there is also a glimmer of hope that if someone talks about the Karachi issue, it will not always be like this.