Q) What's is this Kashmir issue? Ans) They just want Independence from India. Q) Why do they want Independence? Ans) Because it's a Muslim majority so they don't want to stay with a Hindu majority India. Q) How did kashmir became a Muslim majority at the first place? Ans) Just like how West Bengal and Assam are now becoming Muslim majority gradually before our eyes and Hindus are doing nothing about it.
Haha Sir I am from Kashmir,,it didn't become Muslim majority suddenly or like assam etc We converted 6 centuries ago in a mass conversion along with our Hindu king ,,the king was influenced by Sufi saint Amir kabir so he converted and amir kabir converted 15 lakh brahmins in just months As a kid I grew up pro Pakistani as a grew up old I realized my alliance with India so I am fit with India unless people like exist here who always poke nose in jindu muslim issues,,,I am good with Gandhi's India not Savarkers india Thanks
@@drshaunmurphy9250 when you say "we converted" does is it include you too? Then when did this shaun Murphy came? Is this cyber jihad to manipulate kaphirs or something else?
@@drshaunmurphy9250 kashmiris would have had their autonomy and even protected status like the north eastern states if and only if they didn't had this weird obsession with Pakistan which mostly was nurtured by the ruling class of Kashmir to bargain with Delhi but ultimately backfired.The Indian state maybe 3rd class in all other aspects but the one thing it's good and across all parties is that it never entertains secession
The title is misleading from what the speaker said. His exact words at 16:40 were "The reasons why J&K & Hyderabad were not part of Pakistan is also because Mr Jinnah did not want it". Removing the "also" changes the whole meaning. Pretty poor choice of a title.
Incomplete partition of India is the most unfortunate event that has happened to India. Islam is the antethesis of secularism because it doesn't grant religious freedom. Thanks to social media, it won't be long that everyone will eventually realize this.
Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed and Mr Shakeel Chaudhary from Pakistan would differ on this. @print maybe you should organize a session with Mr Ahmed and Mr Chaudhary on this topic
- Do you support Pakistan? :Never. I love India as much as you do. -Good. Do you support Ummah & Kashmir separatists? : Yes. Kashmir should be free. -Does Umma & Kashmir separatists support Pakistan & Vice versa? : Yes. Well but.. -Fair enough.
Dear Sir, WHERE are the "ethnicities" of North east included in the anthem of India by Mr. Tagore? Ditto the case of Kashmiris? It would've been good if you had admitted this!! The fact is that MANY significant ethnicities/regions have been left out and therefore it needs be amended to reflect the current and FUTURE of India -- NOT the time of Tagore any more!!
As a Kashmiri i would like to see an independent state, a state that all kashmiris can live their lives as kashmiri citizens, i do not want it aligned with either pakistan or india. the 700000 indian occupying troops in Jammu and Kashmir is testament to the fact that india is an occupier akin to the british in india.
Q) What's is this Kashmir issue?
Ans) They just want Independence from India.
Q) Why do they want Independence?
Ans) Because it's a Muslim majority so they don't want to stay with a Hindu majority India.
Q) How did kashmir became a Muslim majority at the first place?
Ans) Just like how West Bengal and Assam are now becoming Muslim majority gradually before our eyes and Hindus are doing nothing about it.
Haha
Sir I am from Kashmir,,it didn't become Muslim majority suddenly or like assam etc
We converted 6 centuries ago in a mass conversion along with our Hindu king ,,the king was influenced by Sufi saint Amir kabir so he converted and amir kabir converted 15 lakh brahmins in just months
As a kid I grew up pro Pakistani as a grew up old I realized my alliance with India so I am fit with India unless people like exist here who always poke nose in jindu muslim issues,,,I am good with Gandhi's India not Savarkers india
Thanks
@@drshaunmurphy9250 when you say "we converted" does is it include you too? Then when did this shaun Murphy came? Is this cyber jihad to manipulate kaphirs or something else?
@@drshaunmurphy9250 Most Muslims in Kashmir are Infilatrors from Pakistan who did that over some decades.
Actually ahoms don’t have history in present day Assam going back 250 years
@@drshaunmurphy9250 kashmiris would have had their autonomy and even protected status like the north eastern states if and only if they didn't had this weird obsession with Pakistan which mostly was nurtured by the ruling class of Kashmir to bargain with Delhi but ultimately backfired.The Indian state maybe 3rd class in all other aspects but the one thing it's good and across all parties is that it never entertains secession
The title is misleading from what the speaker said. His exact words at 16:40 were "The reasons why J&K & Hyderabad were not part of Pakistan is also because Mr Jinnah did not want it". Removing the "also" changes the whole meaning. Pretty poor choice of a title.
Thanks this was the comment i was looking for
Very nice, look forward to read the book in detail.Thanks
Too heavy for this session:) He should be on Karan Thapar show
Translation . If Jinnah wanted, traitor Nehru would have surrendered j&k.
Incomplete partition of India is the most unfortunate event that has happened to India. Islam is the antethesis of secularism because it doesn't grant religious freedom. Thanks to social media, it won't be long that everyone will eventually realize this.
For such an authority on a subject the anchor needs more preparation set the stage or questions.
Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed and Mr Shakeel Chaudhary from Pakistan would differ on this. @print maybe you should organize a session with Mr Ahmed and Mr Chaudhary on this topic
Ishtiaq Ahmed has written an endorsement for this book... and a review in Friday Times as well
@@srividya6938 thanks for the info , will check
Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed was all praise for this book.
- Do you support Pakistan?
:Never. I love India as much as you do.
-Good. Do you support Ummah & Kashmir separatists?
: Yes. Kashmir should be free.
-Does Umma & Kashmir separatists support Pakistan & Vice versa?
: Yes. Well but..
-Fair enough.
ccp bot spotted.
Free East Turkistan. Should establish diplomatic mission here.
xing ping, stop oppressing Uyghur People.
Poor anchor - could not get a word in :-))
Why did Pakistan happen?
Dear Sir, WHERE are the "ethnicities" of North east included in the anthem of India by Mr. Tagore? Ditto the case of Kashmiris? It would've been good if you had admitted this!!
The fact is that MANY significant ethnicities/regions have been left out and therefore it needs be amended to reflect the current and FUTURE of India -- NOT the time of Tagore any more!!
Excellent
23:00 Rightly put, Identites are fluid.👍
@theprint please remove ccp bots for a safe and democratic comment section.
Yes she read the book 😅😂😂 what a beautiful lie 😂
Very well described.
World should officially recognised Kashmir as part of PAKISTAN
BS history
Nonsense
As a Kashmiri i would like to see an independent state, a state that all kashmiris can live their lives as kashmiri citizens, i do not want it aligned with either pakistan or india.
the 700000 indian occupying troops in Jammu and Kashmir is testament to the fact that india is an occupier akin to the british in india.
History and geo-politics are stacked against 'independence' of J&K.
Kashmir is not destined to be independent
And about indian troops, kashmir is border state and that too with pakistan and China, what do you expect
There is no such option. You are not a Kashmiri.
th-cam.com/video/MQuMN1ftexQ/w-d-xo.html