Dheeraj Panigrahi... Just ensure yourself of not being an stupidous guy as so to believe on whatever any illiterate leader(Modi) barked away... go and check out the fact what manmohan Singh has actually said.... he said that the Minority have the first right on the resources... now tell me what's wrong in this... you bloody fool....
He has no qualifications to be a pm ... 1. He has educational qualifications 2. A great deal of success 3. A great deal of experience 4. And most importantly, no political lineage.. 3.
Subramanian swamy is a self engrossed moron fuckall piece of shit. Let's not talk about him. In the little term whatever he had as Governor of RBI, Raghuram Rajan almost changed the system to make it open to all entrepreneurs. But India won't have him
@Mathe Logix yes, look 30 years before how your parents were living and how you and they are living, previous people used to go to ration for buying basics now almost all can afford food that too at restaurants and hotels, no of cars owner, no of house owner everything is because of population.
@Mathe Logix almost all countries has a same problem, practical knowledge is important which you will get once you actually do and not by reading, I think in today world most important is how the central banking system works and the digital currency is created by them out of thin air and we are being slaves to this system where we work and we get some numbers in our account which is just a digital no backed by the govt.
Gabriel Nadar well yes off course you have made this a political platform as well like cheerleaders have been in this country for only 4 years....before they weren't existed right
Simon Joseph this is what exactly i was thinking about🤔. And most strange fact is that... here nobody is talking about it...I mean just see the comment section!
It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was. He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste . This is one of the debating topic
Anujeet Swain lol do you realize that he has a bachelors in Engineering? He was an engineer before becoming an economist. The question was pretty general .How is that question tough? Answer will depend on peoples prespective, one would say lack of subsidy will force engineers to leave India for greener pasture were they could flourish which has been the case for several decades.This will result in no new tech being devloped in India thereby India will loose first mover advantage in new areas which could push economic growth.Another might say its the lack of enterpreneurship culture in India or pvt investments in R&D yada yada.in short it does effect .
He is an amazing guy. I just hope someday guys like them would be our leaders.. though everyone knows its never going to happen in a country like India. .
Be optimistic one day we will have leaders like this. We just have to create awareness among people and ask people to question government policies and promises before casting their votes.
Possible we can have such a leader. but we need to think beyond religion and caste come together vote for great india. Maybe possible next generation...
I'm glad that I watched this video because this was my thought since I've cleared 12th standard... just relieved to hear it from the former Governor of RBI
A guy from IIT asks why there is no research in India then says govt stopped funding on institutes coz students go outside and settle there. Dude you just answered your own statement.
He earned a measly 2 lakh per month... With the PHD at MIT and the wit he could've earned 5-10 times more than what he does now Reason- He wants to serve his country...True Hero of Nation 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Its Unfortunate for all of us Indians that we loose U as RBI governor. But Hoping & Voting is always there in our Finger.. the Day will come when People like U will serve India again. U should have to come.
Raghuram Rajan Sir, the very very educated and talented person. And it is unfortunate that our government really couldn't even preserve such a talented Person.This really shows that in politics there is no value for educated and talented people.😠😠
@@fifa0935 general category ka Bhai ab kuch nai ho sakta , desh se nikalne ke tareeke dhundne padh rahe heh mujhe bhe , Mai 83/100 Mei select nai hua aur SC dost 63 me naukri laga ke baitha heh
@@AmanSingh-bt1rx hum sab ki yahi halat hai bhai. Meine socha tha govt. Job k liye prepare krta hu or fir CGL mein 465 aaye tier 2 tak. Mujhe ummeed bhi nahi koi job milegi pr sc/st ko itne mein 4600 gp ki mil jaayegi tier 3 k baad bhi. Mein bhi aane wale 2-3 saalo mein country chhod dunga. Krte rhe BC fir ye log category category..
He is a man of great integrity and very strong acumen. He answered this question with great honesty and utmost clarity. It’s a pity that our government could not use his immense capability to its fullest potential. We need an absolutely strong bipartisan leader to lead our country and government institutions. Only this Mantra that take us towards 5 trillion Economy, which at this point is far from reality. We need an economist running RBI and not some IAS officer, with no formal background in economics. It’s time, we evolve and rise beyond vested and petty interests of some selected individuals. We are now at a stage, where people have started losing faith in banking sectors and other PSU’s. Our hard earned money is channeled through back door into some unscrupulous hands, leaving our banks reeling. Instead of taking clear concise action, all efforts are diverted towards short time solutions and not how entire system can be fixed once and for all. Richer are getting Richer and poorer are getting poorer; Economic disparity is in rise and people in power really need to grow beyond petty politics. It’s middle class who bear all the brunt. It’s time we advocate people like Raghu Ram Rajan to actively participate and help us come out of this rather difficult time. Educated people must come forward and demand change and rise beyond caste, creed, color and ethnicity. We must stand against this despotic, Machiavellian and directionless regime with hate filled vendetta.
And that's the self deprecating attitude that would stop many more from entering politics. Don't know about India but over here if I do not like a candidate I don't vote for him..
he is one of the JEWEL that India has produced we are unfortunate that we had loose him as RBI GOVERNOR who could had a great job just because of dirty and dictator politics
Raghu sir ka background bahot strong h vo IIT se B.tech hai or IIM se MBA hai lekin yaha bat un 7-8 lakh engineering students ki hori h jo private college se nikalte h . . . No skills at all Koi kam ni seekhte 4 sal me . . . engineering is the biggest joke of the century . Or ab to IITians b Bank clerk ka exam dete hue mil jate h Problem education system ki hai hamara education system learning orientated ni h Log education/ degree sarkari naukri ko dhyan me rakh kar krte h Ex. B.Ed ki degree har teesre aadmi k pas B.ed mil jayega kyuk sarkari master ki bharti khub aati h Acha vo B.ed b farziwade sw krte h seekhte kuch ni 2 sal sirf exam dene jate h Mera sawal h bina practical learning k aadmi layak kese banega Innovation to dur ki bat hai """
Bhai mere 2 dost IIT se hai IITD unko job nhi Mila mujhe mil gya and I am from Manipal institute of technology (jaha se Satya nadela Rajiv suri Nokia ceo me btech Kia hai) and me abhi Amazon me work karta hu to prvt govt doesn't matter Ur mhenat matters
I agree a 100% on what Rajan has said. Producing engineers or doctors in large numbers does not make a great country but the quality of the doctors that come out makes all the difference. The greater the emphasis on merit than on caste and creed would go a long way. Our leaders are seeking the easy option of earmarking a certain set of seats thereby lowering the standards rather than the difficult option of improving the living conditions, educational facilities like books, good teachers and better schools and inculcating the habit of hard work and discipline in children. Consequently we get substandard engineers, doctors etc. Smart people will rise irrespective of the opportunity which may be about 1% but the majority are in the intermediate level of opportunity related excellence. Leaders who lack education, which is generally the case, always think that shortcuts to will yield results. Yes it does, but the wrong way. Just as we have leaders who lack leadership we produce doctors and engineers who lack the skills required to compete in the world. Let us not go by one Indra Nooyi or one Sundar Pichhai because they are in that 1% that will rise irrespective of any situation.
True, sudar Pichai, Indira nooyi, laxmi Mittal, satya Nadella they are not even one percent they are 0.0001 percent when compared to indian population.
For those of you he didn't understand why he meant 1 in 6, he is talking about ratio of Indian population to global population which is 1.2 billion : 7billion.
Great answer. We Indians need to stop overestimating our abilities. We cannot grow until we do some heavy self introspection and working accordingly. Hum hawaabaazi mein hi khush hain
What an answer.... Which could be only given by a person like him... He is positive as well as he Tell us that we are more capable what we are today...
You r a great person ever I have seen.. Who thik for country as good as possible manner but India nd Indian couldn't not understand your value that how much important you r for this country
Realistic sensible statements are the only answers to our questions gentleman...... Pull the right man for the right job, we need to get over our addiction to TEA
he is an economist...not a leader economists are like cheerleaders...no matter how much of a good dancer a cheerleader becomes...it can never replace virat kohli in IPL
Good example but Bad usage!!!!! Virat kohli can never be a cheerleader and cheerleader never tried her hands on Bat ..... also read carefully cheerleader has a LEADER in her already.... And so did we had a 10yr long term of a Economist and a leader .Keeping the head high ensures dignity but keeping it below the clouds is wisdom!!!
The reason why students go abroad is also because of the salary given to engineers in India. Engineers get a starting average salary of only 6 lacs in the core engineering fields which is demotivating for many. If you want engineers to dwell into research then make it a field which feels lucrative
Its sad that such men don't get opportunity to do their work properly as some people whose educational qualification is even not known at times, prevent them from doing so
Rightly said, we get immense pleasure by quoting few Indian personalities forgetting that we are actually underperforming given the huge population we have.
Bhaskar Rao It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was. He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste . This is one of the debating topic
Nither tough question nor new answer. But here who answer is the matter. This is the mindset of our people never see the content always see the person who says , there in thrives our politicians. Not issue based politics , personally centered politics exists here. Long way to go.
Well the question was good. But surely pretty dumb to be honest. Coz the question itself begins with the line that Indians are known as innvoators. I mean who said that. That is probably farthest from the truth. And that's where the question immediately dies and doesn't make sense any furthur
There should come a rule that if you want to be in politics, you have to be at least an IAS officer. For all jobs , we have qualification criterias. Because a person with less education shouldn't hold IAS OFFICERS under their control.
The biggest mistake is we dont realise we are far behind even the small european countries in many fields. One thing i dont like about modi govt is it celebrates on every little good thing it does. Instead why dont you just do your job given that we so behind and would take decades to catch up.
And the other biggest mistake is people forgetting we are way ahead of many European nations in many fields. But people will always point out negatives. And fyi, we were a colony. We were looted to core. Recovering from deep wounds take time. It's not like a magical snap of infiity gauntlet where everything will snap back to the perfect order it was before. The progress of this European nations came at cost of greatest human exploitation in the history of mankind
And when some one encourages the talent he is overthrown from this democracy and hence talents will always prefer to move out after learning from here .
The thought of spending money on student which go abroad after completing courses in Indian institutions is outdated. These Indians send "dollars"to India,they invest major amount of their remunerations in India. They are important source of our foreign reserves.
That's because the person answered his own question. The question in itself was so long and more of a speech. If one is asking a, question it has to be to the point
He said correctly that there should be plenty more CEOs working abroad and innovating things but there are very few. This is because of less opportunity provided to people living in India. Our education and work culture are suffering because of poor investments and implementation by the Government. If there is a need to broaden the scope of innovation then there is also a need to broaden the scope of inputs by the government.
It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was. He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste . This is one of the debating topic
Indians are quite good. Only thing they are lacking is self confidence and not taking risks. Parents should encourage their kids in this direction. Also keep in mind, we are free to perform only actions. Results are not in your hands and should not think too much about them. Just do your best.Once this attitude becomes normal in Indians, sky is the limit. Mark my words.
It is modi's adherence to Demonetization that we have to loose such latent...no matter what credentials Urjit patel had once....we can see how great he is doing...this is the example of when politics enters into the financial market....Modi is entering everywhere he can...not listening to supreme court order....i don't where will India end...
Shreyash Sisodiya Urjit Patel is not even addressing any questions related to Demonetization!!! As RBI Governor he should be the one who come forward and show the citizens the real figure of Demonetization..
It is the part of our PM's policy....he dont want to keep high calibre people or the people who can be famous more than him in future..... we can say......
Dr. Rajan hit the nail on the head. Since we have 1/6 the Population of the World, on an average we should have 1/6 the world's Nobel Laureates, Billionaires, Entrepreneurs, Gold Medalists, Lyricists, Music Director of high repute. Top Athletes, Dancers etc etc. But the empirical data show India and Most Third World countries are NOT reaching their Potential (Just Average Level in Achievement) bc our Politics, Policies and Implementations are very poor & pathetic. We have Above Average World Corruption Index, Disease Index, Distribution & Mobilization of Agricultural or other finished Products etc etc. So we have too much of BAD stuff and too little of Good stuff, finally ending up sub par (Below Average) of achievements, either Invention/Innovation or discoveries... Our Education & Health are falling steadily instead of improving over time. Our curriculum is not fostering Original Thinking, but rote memory. A very small number (comparing to 1.6 billion people) of Indians went to US and settled as citizens (hardly 3 million total and 1 million green card holders maximum). Some of this People rose to get Nobel Prize like Abhijit Banerjee, Venky Ramakrishnan, to become CEOs like Sundar Pitchai and Sathya Nadella etc. This does not mean much to Indians. Bc AFTER high school and 4 years of college WHAT opportunities Indians get? IF one goes to Top 10 Universities of the World (like MIT, Harvard, Stanford, Oxford, Chicago, U Penn etc) Indians will flourish....But nearly 99.9% don't qualify for that level of intelligence and academic excellence. Only these huge population stays back and run the Country devising Bad Policies and supporting Bad Politics of Majoritarian Masses who are basically illiterates who take the Country backwards everyday!!! That is the Fate of India & Most other Third World Countries!!! India can at least talk about Chandrayaan 2 Program run at a cost of Rs. 1000 Cr and failed at the 3 Km distance from the Moon!! We can't connect the Rivers from North to South to meet the Water Need for Human Consumption & Agricultural Needs!! Our Priorities are very strange. Do We Need a Summit of PM Modi and Trump who is being Investigated for Egregious Conduct of High Crimes in Office? Very Pathetic, indeed!!
The problem is also with the individual. How many Engineering college students really study to gain knowledge? How many of them study from reference books thoroughly?Most of them only study to score marks or just pass. How many employees work continuously with good focus for all the 8 hours? Most of the IT employees are checking Facebook, Gmail, TH-cam and going out for multiple Tea/Coffee breaks along with meaningless chit chat now and then. Also many in India have this "Chalta hai/ Unnes- bees Attitude" which is spread across all domains. There is a guy in South India who planted an entire forest on his own! India's space research...I think ISRO is going great because the people are 100% dedicated! If the people responsible for creating the necessary atmosphere (I.e. government) and students and engineers or any other Indian of whichever domain, Puts in His/Her 100% involvement, Innovation is just a natural occurrence!
Let me explain My percentage was 58.8 No one will hire me but i was amongst most capable engineers my college produced So our system is f...ed up in terms of scoring and post education support.
I love the gentleman, but I disagree with the argument that Indian Engineers are not innovative... Forget engineers, the poor economy that we are, I think even an ordinary citizen is pretty innovative and the reader can visualize examples in our daily lives..
The Government doesn't focus on the Public Sector which essentially fuels Public Education. Therefore, tech companies like the Tatas and Infosys have started local training centres to compensate for the improper College Education of their hired engineers.
Indians are innovative. The fact he said cannot be ignored but remember the lack of oppurtunity we face in our country. Olympics,how many selection go uncorrupted??? Engineers, how many world class institutes do we have?? Even IITB is only in 200s. Funding is itself main problem,then how can they blame engineers going abroad???
ln.meivenkatkumar lakshminarayanan Bro, I understood your point but just think when these engineers study in India, they contribute to the expenses of the economy, and when they have the ability to earn they go to abroad and help growing their economy. To sum it up :I would say Stop complaining about things. "It's not your nation's duty to lift you, it's your duty to lift your nation."
ln.meivenkatkumar lakshminarayanan the thing is we don't even encourage innovations due to fear of failure.. Most of the established businessman doesn't wanna invest in any new idea..
Raghuram rajan sir highly intelligent and very talented honest man. BJP does not know how to utilise this gold man. India must need this kind of wonderful superb man. Best economist. Thanks 🎉 Sundara Raman chinnamanur Theni district Tamil Nadu
One minute silence for those who were expecting a question on mechanics.
I did LMAO!
He is an electrical engineer, why would he receive a mechanics question?
I expected that lmao !!
Same 😂😂
Even i thought, it must be something "तीतर के दो आगे तीतर तीतर के दो पीछे तीतर आगे तीतर पीछे तीतर बोलो कितने तीतर"
we can't have him as our pm because he is educated, talented, honest. He doesn't fulfil all the requirements to b our pm.
sohail kaiser excellent comments u r true sohail
Yes manmohan Singh was fit and look what did he do
MUSLIMS HAVE FIRST RIGHT TO ALL RESOURCES IN INDIA. very educated comments by great manmohan singh
Dheeraj Panigrahi... Just ensure yourself of not being an stupidous guy as so to believe on whatever any illiterate leader(Modi) barked away...
go and check out the fact what manmohan Singh has actually said.... he said that the Minority have the first right on the resources...
now tell me what's wrong in this... you bloody fool....
No he can be PM, but some baba ji will have to first claim that his Kundali has RajYog..then only.
He has no qualifications to be a pm ...
1. He has educational qualifications
2. A great deal of success
3. A great deal of experience
4. And most importantly, no political lineage..
3.
He is an honest man. Not fit for our politics.
Razi Rahman "AN HONEST MAN"
100./.
Lol true af
go watch Subramaniam swamys's on him ;)
Subramanian swamy is a self engrossed moron fuckall piece of shit. Let's not talk about him. In the little term whatever he had as Governor of RBI, Raghuram Rajan almost changed the system to make it open to all entrepreneurs. But India won't have him
he is a gold medallist from IIT and IIM...
@@shrisub881 there is always exception
And from MIT
Akshay Lray So he is very smart.
@@sayanmondal4570 you mentioned a good point, otherwise Indian engineers(specially Kota guys) think that IIT is better than MIT
OMG.
3 Major Reasons for our Sorry State
1.Overpopulation
2.Corruption in Government
3.Lack of Civic Sense
Over population is not a problem
@Mathe Logix yes, look 30 years before how your parents were living and how you and they are living, previous people used to go to ration for buying basics now almost all can afford food that too at restaurants and hotels, no of cars owner, no of house owner everything is because of population.
@Mathe Logix I am talking in favour of population and not about innovation.
@Mathe Logix almost all countries has a same problem, practical knowledge is important which you will get once you actually do and not by reading, I think in today world most important is how the central banking system works and the digital currency is created by them out of thin air and we are being slaves to this system where we work and we get some numbers in our account which is just a digital no backed by the govt.
@Mathe Logix PM is puppet of Israel, whole world is puppet of Jews and Israel.
We need him but we dont deserve him.
He is Batman.
True!
absolutely true because some only few gains knowledge rest just are wanna be or orthodox.
Nice one. Your comment is deep.
May be u don't... He was a chamccha of congress.. This servitude attitude of people like u is the problem of this country
Gold medalist iit delhi
Gold medalists iim ahemdabad
Pht MIT
He is god 😂
Vineet Shady except the last one
PhD in what any idea.
@@nabil6135 PhD in kapukedara
but he is not an economist...😁😁😁😁
@@sameersam3809 came here after swami s interview na?
Why can't we have him as our prime minister?
because people belive in chaiwala and panipuriwala more than elites
Kunal Deshbhratar the word "elite" is not right, I suppose. it should be "educated" as a term...
right
because he doesn't speak HINDI
Because we dont like honest people.We are morally corrupt.We want those who can crack jokes for people to laugh.
whatever he is saying is correct, some cheerleader are just exaggerating about India.
these cheerleaders are founders of coaching centers at Kota
Gabriel Nadar well yes off course you have made this a political platform as well like cheerleaders have been in this country for only 4 years....before they weren't existed right
@@poojavishwakarma7251 ok, remove modi fans and think whether what i said is logically correct or no.
@Itachi Uchiha possible
Not true talking about 1.2billion not even half of them get access to good education
We are not innovators we are जुगाडी...😂😂😂
As RRR said let’s just be normal enough
lol , 5 ka fevicol 50 ka karcha bachana
😂😂😂😂😂
Lol....exactly🤣
Ye to 💯 true only
Ohh... Where is the tough Engineering question???
Simon Joseph this is what exactly i was thinking about🤔. And most strange fact is that... here nobody is talking about it...I mean just see the comment section!
@@ankishamishra2429 hun ever heard of clickbaits?
Its says "tough engineer question" not "tough engineering question" which essentially means that an engineer asked him a tough question.
It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was.
He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste .
This is one of the debating topic
Anujeet Swain lol do you realize that he has a bachelors in Engineering? He was an engineer before becoming an economist. The question was pretty general .How is that question tough? Answer will depend on peoples prespective, one would say lack of subsidy will force engineers to leave India for greener pasture were they could flourish which has been the case for several decades.This will result in no new tech being devloped in India thereby India will loose first mover advantage in new areas which could push economic growth.Another might say its the lack of enterpreneurship culture in India or pvt investments in R&D yada yada.in short it does effect .
He is an amazing guy. I just hope someday guys like them would be our leaders.. though everyone knows its never going to happen in a country like India. .
couldn't agree more...wish that will come true
Be optimistic one day we will have leaders like this. We just have to create awareness among people and ask people to question government policies and promises before casting their votes.
SUBRONEEL GHOSHAL totally agree👌👌
Possible we can have such a leader. but we need to think beyond religion and caste come together vote for great india. Maybe possible next generation...
True
Best RBI Governor ever
@Just Dab are you safforn fan
@Just Dab so u r a safro fan
@@kalyansurya1215yes, he is and I think u are topi fan
@@kaustuv2386 im not like you topi copy saffron man
Im just common gdp
Gdp utterly 5%
@@kalyansurya1215 Tax pay kya na thik se??
A government that let this gem go has deprived RBI of such a brilliant person. Political parties have ruined India.
sir please join as governor again INDIA needs you the most
Sagar Sutar ⏬
no we don't
we have plenty of economists
kaushik basu is my favorite
Vihari N yess true and also our nobel prize winner for 2016 dec. Stint THE GREAT mr urgit patel too
Call raghuram rajan back and save current indian economy
@Aayush Singh what makes you think that he is corrupt??
@Aayush Singh Oh you just follow whatsapp forwards?? Good.
@Aayush Singh 🤭
Yes sirrrr
@Aayush Singh lawda ka fact hai
Swamy or Rajan or manmohan
Tino me se kisi ek ko economist hona chahiye tha. Atleast nimmo tai ko to bilkul nhi
I have huge respect for him after apj kalam for his simplicity and clarity
He is who we need but do not deserve.
Hiren Joshi Batman.?
Samarth Verma 😉
Abdur Rehman Yes. :)
Well spoken!
*you
I'm glad that I watched this video because this was my thought since I've cleared 12th standard... just relieved to hear it from the former Governor of RBI
Diveen Varma t😂
He is such a talented, honest and wonderful person who resigned his job to not the lie to us(Indians). Hats off to you sir.
“Enthusiastic” he quoted
- Tough to keep on going with that In India
A guy from IIT asks why there is no research in India then says govt stopped funding on institutes coz students go outside and settle there. Dude you just answered your own statement.
No funding that's why they go abroad
@@rohitbharti5869 they go abroad that's why no funding.
@@vickykumar-km6lg Most Of the Indian can't afford to sattel in abroad
Uploaded in 2016! I found in my recommendation in 2020😔😤
He earned a measly 2 lakh per month... With the PHD at MIT and the wit he could've earned 5-10 times more than what he does now
Reason- He wants to serve his country...True Hero of Nation 🇮🇳🇮🇳
IIT BRO WTF IS WIT *?
@@humanhuman9228 That is "wit"-intelligence bro keyboard gave me titlecased 😂😂
Usne pehle hi kaafi paise kama liya hai
we need a PM like him, a very talented person
Its Unfortunate for all of us Indians that we loose U as RBI governor. But Hoping & Voting is always there in our Finger.. the Day will come when People like U will serve India again. U should have to come.
Raghuram Rajan Sir, the very very educated and talented person. And it is unfortunate that our government really couldn't even preserve such a talented Person.This really shows that in politics there is no value for educated and talented people.😠😠
The hero we didn't deserve but the hero we need.
India never changes until they break from superstition and blind belief. And where everyone is treated as humans without caste discrimination.
Bhai discrimination toh ab general category k saath ho rha hai
Dont you think Americans portray blind beliefs in the name of faith?
@@fifa0935 general category ka Bhai ab kuch nai ho sakta , desh se nikalne ke tareeke dhundne padh rahe heh mujhe bhe , Mai 83/100 Mei select nai hua aur SC dost 63 me naukri laga ke baitha heh
@@AmanSingh-bt1rx hum sab ki yahi halat hai bhai. Meine socha tha govt. Job k liye prepare krta hu or fir CGL mein 465 aaye tier 2 tak. Mujhe ummeed bhi nahi koi job milegi pr sc/st ko itne mein 4600 gp ki mil jaayegi tier 3 k baad bhi. Mein bhi aane wale 2-3 saalo mein country chhod dunga. Krte rhe BC fir ye log category category..
Discrimination, aka, reservations
We Indians are fools... But he is one of those few intelligent Indians.
He is a man of great integrity and very strong acumen. He answered this question with great honesty and utmost clarity. It’s a pity that our government could not use his immense capability to its fullest potential. We need an absolutely strong bipartisan leader to lead our country and government institutions. Only this Mantra that take us towards 5 trillion Economy, which at this point is far from reality. We need an economist running RBI and not some IAS officer, with no formal background in economics. It’s time, we evolve and rise beyond vested and petty interests of some selected individuals. We are now at a stage, where people have started losing faith in banking sectors and other PSU’s. Our hard earned money is channeled through back door into some unscrupulous hands, leaving our banks reeling. Instead of taking clear concise action, all efforts are diverted towards short time solutions and not how entire system can be fixed once and for all. Richer are getting Richer and poorer are getting poorer; Economic disparity is in rise and people in power really need to grow beyond petty politics. It’s middle class who bear all the brunt. It’s time we advocate people like Raghu Ram Rajan to actively participate and help us come out of this rather difficult time. Educated people must come forward and demand change and rise beyond caste, creed, color and ethnicity. We must stand against this despotic, Machiavellian and directionless regime with hate filled vendetta.
Our system don't deserve him. Our system deserve people who say more but do less.
Exactly bro
Like Narendra chodi
And that's the self deprecating attitude that would stop many more from entering politics. Don't know about India but over here if I do not like a candidate I don't vote for him..
@@gabrielnadar5985 😂😂
I know right. Our country is run by illiterate stupid people.
he is one of the JEWEL that India has produced
we are unfortunate that we had loose him as RBI GOVERNOR who could had a great job
just because of dirty and dictator politics
The reason is curriculum and methodology , implementation . Approach of professors towards syllabus completion, students struggling around cgpa
Please give /upload the entire video of this discussion
Raghu sir ka background bahot strong h vo IIT se B.tech hai or IIM se MBA hai lekin yaha bat un 7-8 lakh engineering students ki hori h jo private college se nikalte h . . .
No skills at all
Koi kam ni seekhte 4 sal me . . .
engineering is the biggest joke of the century .
Or ab to IITians b Bank clerk ka exam dete hue mil jate h
Problem education system ki hai hamara education system learning orientated ni h
Log education/ degree sarkari naukri ko dhyan me rakh kar krte h
Ex. B.Ed ki degree har teesre aadmi k pas B.ed mil jayega kyuk sarkari master ki bharti khub aati h
Acha vo B.ed b farziwade sw krte h seekhte kuch ni 2 sal sirf exam dene jate h
Mera sawal h bina practical learning k aadmi layak kese banega Innovation to dur ki bat hai """
Bhai iitian ko bhi job nahi mil rahi hai
Yes bro
Bhai mere 2 dost IIT se hai IITD unko job nhi Mila mujhe mil gya and I am from Manipal institute of technology (jaha se Satya nadela Rajiv suri Nokia ceo me btech Kia hai) and me abhi Amazon me work karta hu to prvt govt doesn't matter Ur mhenat matters
I am working as a Medical Representative today after passing Computer Engineering with 58% Marks from reputed University.
Probably the best RBI governor, the nation has ever seen. Had the capability of changing things drastically with the decisions he took.
Handsome and Charming and Heart melting Respective RBI CEO Mr Raghuram Rajan. God bless you.
💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
No single controversial event in his life ?
No..
then he can't be minister or politician
I agree a 100% on what Rajan has said. Producing engineers or doctors in large numbers does not make a great country but the quality of the doctors that come out makes all the difference. The greater the emphasis on merit than on caste and creed would go a long way. Our leaders are seeking the easy option of earmarking a certain set of seats thereby lowering the standards rather than the difficult option of improving the living conditions, educational facilities like books, good teachers and better schools and inculcating the habit of hard work and discipline in children. Consequently we get substandard engineers, doctors etc. Smart people will rise irrespective of the opportunity which may be about 1% but the majority are in the intermediate level of opportunity related excellence. Leaders who lack education, which is generally the case, always think that shortcuts to will yield results. Yes it does, but the wrong way. Just as we have leaders who lack leadership we produce doctors and engineers who lack the skills required to compete in the world. Let us not go by one Indra Nooyi or one Sundar Pichhai because they are in that 1% that will rise irrespective of any situation.
True, sudar Pichai, Indira nooyi, laxmi Mittal, satya Nadella they are not even one percent they are 0.0001 percent when compared to indian population.
For those of you he didn't understand why he meant 1 in 6, he is talking about ratio of Indian population to global population which is 1.2 billion : 7billion.
Thanks for this input!
Great answer. We Indians need to stop overestimating our abilities. We cannot grow until we do some heavy self introspection and working accordingly.
Hum hawaabaazi mein hi khush hain
What an answer....
Which could be only given by a person like him...
He is positive as well as he
Tell us that we are more capable what we are today...
He is greatly talented
Totally Agree with it & End Reservation for SC/ST too , India will be at the top again
The question was economical rather than 'Engineer Question'
Only some people understand such a great answer. What he said was absolutely correct, we are not innovative.
During his tenure he used to say banks were asked to clean their balance sheets. Are they even now only in the cleaning mode?
When An Intellect Talks You Can Feel It.
I am shocked that I never realized what he said, being at least 1 in every 6 should normal,we are under performing. Lot of Talent just get Wasted
All because of Politics.
it's funny that most of people don't even know how backward we are from rest o f the world
How many time will I get this video in my recommendation?
What a beautifully put answer . Such a great individual and intellectual . Proud of him as a proud Indian . Jai Hind
Had he accepted DEMONETISATION, he would have continued as the RBI governor
You r a great person ever I have seen.. Who thik for country as good as possible manner but India nd Indian couldn't not understand your value that how much important you r for this country
I have been thinking about the same question for a long time.
Realistic sensible statements are the only answers to our questions gentleman...... Pull the right man for the right job, we need to get over our addiction to TEA
he is an economist...not a leader
economists are like cheerleaders...no matter how much of a good dancer a cheerleader becomes...it can never replace virat kohli in IPL
Good example but Bad usage!!!!!
Virat kohli can never be a cheerleader and cheerleader never tried her hands on Bat ..... also read carefully cheerleader has a LEADER in her already....
And so did we had a 10yr long term of a Economist and a leader .Keeping the head high ensures dignity but keeping it below the clouds is wisdom!!!
the whole nation is equally capable, when are you climbing the stairs???
Japan knows and Indians don't. pity we don't recognize our leader!!!
Piyush Upadhyay yeah!!!we have seen capability of his successor who is a handpicked tool...
He is absolutely right. It's a wrong perception we have that we are innovators it's a very low percentage
He is best Economist
He is best GOVERNOR(RBI)
along with best attitude to say no to listen a best student queries about india
The reason why students go abroad is also because of the salary given to engineers in India. Engineers get a starting average salary of only 6 lacs in the core engineering fields which is demotivating for many. If you want engineers to dwell into research then make it a field which feels lucrative
Its sad that such men don't get opportunity to do their work properly as some people whose educational qualification is even not known at times, prevent them from doing so
Rightly said, we get immense pleasure by quoting few Indian personalities forgetting that we are actually underperforming given the huge population we have.
A word in Enough .....
I mean to say that Genius!!!!
Hai n!!???
Where is second part...
FORGET ABOUT EXCEEDING OUR LIMITS, FIRST THINK ABOUT ACHIEVING OUR POTENTIAL.
Where can I find the full video?
here i didnt find any tough question
did anyone find ???
Bhaskar Rao It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was.
He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste .
This is one of the debating topic
Nither tough question nor new answer. But here who answer is the matter. This is the mindset of our people never see the content always see the person who says , there in thrives our politicians. Not issue based politics , personally centered politics exists here. Long way to go.
Well the question was good. But surely pretty dumb to be honest. Coz the question itself begins with the line that Indians are known as innvoators. I mean who said that. That is probably farthest from the truth. And that's where the question immediately dies and doesn't make sense any furthur
How do you eat mongoes?
I think you find this question would be tough!
@@anujeetswain7368 LOL HE ISN'T A ECONOMIST
Whatever he said I am completely agree with him 👍👍
There should come a rule that if you want to be in politics, you have to be at least an IAS officer. For all jobs , we have qualification criterias. Because a person with less education shouldn't hold IAS OFFICERS under their control.
Especially LLB and BCom graduates
the statement tells everything about the person...well said, sir
The biggest mistake is we dont realise we are far behind even the small european countries in many fields. One thing i dont like about modi govt is it celebrates on every little good thing it does. Instead why dont you just do your job given that we so behind and would take decades to catch up.
Crazed by religions.
And the other biggest mistake is people forgetting we are way ahead of many European nations in many fields. But people will always point out negatives. And fyi, we were a colony. We were looted to core. Recovering from deep wounds take time. It's not like a magical snap of infiity gauntlet where everything will snap back to the perfect order it was before. The progress of this European nations came at cost of greatest human exploitation in the history of mankind
@@abhishekphand4789 2 PSCYCHIATRISTS FOR 20 MILLION PEOPLE IN IVORY COAST ..
MUST BE LOTS OF WTICHDOCTORS N RITUALS THERE.
@@abhishekphand4789 yep millions of europeans went down looting in africa..
Because if dey don't celebrate .....
Den so many motherfuckers a saying dat dey had done nothing and are going to give their vote to congress
And when some one encourages the talent he is overthrown from this democracy and hence talents will always prefer to move out after learning from here .
The thought of spending money on student which go abroad after completing courses in Indian institutions is outdated. These Indians send "dollars"to India,they invest major amount of their remunerations in India.
They are important source of our foreign reserves.
Can i complete my M.B.A from IIM. And what is the capital structure.
Dr Rajan usually gives straight forward answers. First time I heard him giving a half hearted answer, almost evasive
That's because the person answered his own question. The question in itself was so long and more of a speech. If one is asking a, question it has to be to the point
He said correctly that there should be plenty more CEOs working abroad and innovating things but there are very few. This is because of less opportunity provided to people living in India. Our education and work culture are suffering because of poor investments and implementation by the Government. If there is a need to broaden the scope of innovation then there is also a need to broaden the scope of inputs by the government.
I have always admired this Economist.. He unveiled many names of fraudsters and submitted it to Modi Govt but no action was taken...
Rotational dynamics kyu nahi pucha bhai
Today BJP announced new Research center for engineers in their first budget. good governance
Thug lifi comment
It's not about who have more or less potential
It's all about who are achieving their full potential
Best question Engineer to Engineer.... thanks sir ...it is also my question
Misleading title.
i can see ned stark 🤣🤣
😆
@@prakhart92 me too
It was tough question though , being an economist he didn’t had any answer to what the question was.
He just ignored the fact that why the subsidies for research were taken away instead he spoke waste .
This is one of the debating topic
Indians are quite good. Only thing they are lacking is self confidence and not taking risks. Parents should encourage their kids in this direction. Also keep in mind, we are free to perform only actions. Results are not in your hands and should not think too much about them. Just do your best.Once this attitude becomes normal in Indians, sky is the limit. Mark my words.
Indians are as good as any nation...But more people less productivity...Australia for ex has more Olympic medal with Mumbai population
The guy asked the question and Raghuram Ji upgraded the question, answer is yet to come.
It is modi's adherence to Demonetization that we have to loose such latent...no matter what credentials Urjit patel had once....we can see how great he is doing...this is the example of when politics enters into the financial market....Modi is entering everywhere he can...not listening to supreme court order....i don't where will India end...
Shreyash Sisodiya Urjit Patel is not even addressing any questions related to Demonetization!!! As RBI Governor he should be the one who come forward and show the citizens the real figure of Demonetization..
He will not come because demonetization is not his idea...what can he say...😂😂
urgith patel planted by mukesh ambani actualy. modi 's nda is marwady mafia
Beipe
It is the part of our PM's policy....he dont want to keep high calibre people or the people who can be famous more than him in future..... we can say......
Could not agree more with you sir. We need to foster the ecosystem that could nurture our engineers to innovate.....We are currently just not there !!
I wish I could learn to talk like him
Dr. Rajan hit the nail on the head. Since we have 1/6 the Population of the World, on an average we should have 1/6 the world's Nobel Laureates, Billionaires, Entrepreneurs, Gold Medalists, Lyricists, Music Director of high repute. Top Athletes, Dancers etc etc. But the empirical data show India and Most Third World countries are NOT reaching their Potential (Just Average Level in Achievement) bc our Politics, Policies and Implementations are very poor & pathetic. We have Above Average World Corruption Index, Disease Index, Distribution & Mobilization of Agricultural or other finished Products etc etc. So we have too much of BAD stuff and too little of Good stuff, finally ending up sub par (Below Average) of achievements, either Invention/Innovation or discoveries... Our Education & Health are falling steadily instead of improving over time. Our curriculum is not fostering Original Thinking, but rote memory. A very small number (comparing to 1.6 billion people) of Indians went to US and settled as citizens (hardly 3 million total and 1 million green card holders maximum). Some of this People rose to get Nobel Prize like Abhijit Banerjee, Venky Ramakrishnan, to become CEOs like Sundar Pitchai and Sathya Nadella etc. This does not mean much to Indians. Bc AFTER high school and 4 years of college WHAT opportunities Indians get? IF one goes to Top 10 Universities of the World (like MIT, Harvard, Stanford, Oxford, Chicago, U Penn etc) Indians will flourish....But nearly 99.9% don't qualify for that level of intelligence and academic excellence. Only these huge population stays back and run the Country devising Bad Policies and supporting Bad Politics of Majoritarian Masses who are basically illiterates who take the Country backwards everyday!!! That is the Fate of India & Most other Third World Countries!!! India can at least talk about Chandrayaan 2 Program run at a cost of Rs. 1000 Cr and failed at the 3 Km distance from the Moon!! We can't connect the Rivers from North to South to meet the Water Need for Human Consumption & Agricultural Needs!! Our Priorities are very strange. Do We Need a Summit of PM Modi and Trump who is being Investigated for Egregious Conduct of High Crimes in Office? Very Pathetic, indeed!!
why did raghuram rajan resign?,,,,,,,,,............ think )
The problem is also with the individual. How many Engineering college students really study to gain knowledge? How many of them study from reference books thoroughly?Most of them only study to score marks or just pass. How many employees work continuously with good focus for all the 8 hours? Most of the IT employees are checking Facebook, Gmail, TH-cam and going out for multiple Tea/Coffee breaks along with meaningless chit chat now and then.
Also many in India have this "Chalta hai/ Unnes- bees Attitude" which is spread across all domains. There is a guy in South India who planted an entire forest on his own! India's space research...I think ISRO is going great because the people are 100% dedicated!
If the people responsible for creating the necessary atmosphere (I.e. government) and students and engineers or any other Indian of whichever domain, Puts in His/Her 100% involvement, Innovation is just a natural occurrence!
U r really inspiring us to we have to move on tooo...... More
The second question he wasn't allowed to ask (maybe due to time constraints) was another deep and relevant question.
Let me explain
My percentage was 58.8
No one will hire me but i was amongst most capable engineers my college produced
So our system is f...ed up in terms of scoring and post education support.
I can relate to that bro, if you are seeing this message after 9 months, i might tell you we are exceptions in this system
I love the gentleman, but I disagree with the argument that Indian Engineers are not innovative... Forget engineers, the poor economy that we are, I think even an ordinary citizen is pretty innovative and the reader can visualize examples in our daily lives..
Raghuram Rajan sir's fans hit like here....
The Government doesn't focus on the Public Sector which essentially fuels Public Education. Therefore, tech companies like the Tatas and Infosys have started local training centres to compensate for the improper College Education of their hired engineers.
Indians are innovative. The fact he said cannot be ignored but remember the lack of oppurtunity we face in our country. Olympics,how many selection go uncorrupted??? Engineers, how many world class institutes do we have?? Even IITB is only in 200s. Funding is itself main problem,then how can they blame engineers going abroad???
exactly .... one easy example is the difference in the payscale between a research student in USA and in India
ln.meivenkatkumar lakshminarayanan
Bro, I understood your point but just think when these engineers study in India, they contribute to the expenses of the economy, and when they have the ability to earn they go to abroad and help growing their economy.
To sum it up :I would say Stop complaining about things.
"It's not your nation's duty to lift you, it's your duty to lift your nation."
smit masrani it's about support from government not lifting government is not providing any help
ln.meivenkatkumar lakshminarayanan the thing is we don't even encourage innovations due to fear of failure.. Most of the established businessman doesn't wanna invest in any new idea..
That was his point exactly
Raghuram rajan sir highly intelligent and very talented honest man. BJP does not know how to utilise this gold man. India must need this kind of wonderful superb man. Best economist. Thanks 🎉 Sundara Raman chinnamanur Theni district Tamil Nadu
I wish modi government will book 2 seats in future
1 is for raghuram rajan
And
2nd is for sashi tharoor sir