SUCH A FORLORN SOUND..TAKING YOU BACK TO A MOMENT IN YOUR LIFE..BE IT LOVE OR LOSS...DREAMS UNACHEIVED..ASPIRATIONS..JUST OUT OF REACH..THE TIMES OF YOUTH..IN YOUR LIFE THAT PASS ALL TO QUICKLY..WE ARE ALL SUFFERING..INSIDE. STILL....THIS SONG..THE FEMALE BACKING VOCALS..TRANSEND..TAKING ME BACK TO PLACES..AND EVENTS IN MY LIFE..TRAGEDY..AND MINUTE TRIUMPHS OF..GIRLS...LONG GONE..BUT REMEMBERED.WITH THIS SONG.
Two of the very best acts of that era. Wonderful real music with meaning, I used to wander around with this song in my lips, mesmerized by its beauty and sadness.
Some folks are objecting that the video is spliced and truncated. It is, and I wish it weren't. Some folks are objecting that the live audio track has been replaced with the album track. It has, and I wish it hadn't. That said, this video rules far, far more than the absolutely nothing like it that was ever available publicly before it. What a blessing to have stumbled into such awesometh in the year 2013.
@@rjvanderwoud Is it possible that Tanya's part of the original live recording was not that strong? I've seen several videos of her live and she's all over the place. The studio/video of this song is great, but I think they heavily manipulated her voice during production. FWIW... Not a Tanya Donelly hater. She's fantastic in anything done with Belly and Throwing Muses. Wish I could have been around the Newport RI scene about the time she and Kristin were playing local venues.
Sorry, but no way in hell. Starts live but after the first pre-strum it's all over and back to the studio demo version, which you can listen and compare. So I suppose you might as well enjoy the demo video too, which is very nice.
![Catherine Wheel - Judy Staring at the Sun [6-25-95]](/img/n.gif)
Here near 2025 . I forgot how in love with Tonya I was from this video. Nice to see an old love again . 🖤
I'm 65 and absolutely love driving my convertible Mustang down the highway head banging to this song 😊 real true rockers NEVER get old😊
Still love them in 2020! They are the creators of ambient alt rock.. only awesome people can relate to this music, and that is why it's not Pop.
SUCH A FORLORN SOUND..TAKING YOU BACK TO A MOMENT IN YOUR LIFE..BE IT LOVE OR LOSS...DREAMS UNACHEIVED..ASPIRATIONS..JUST OUT OF REACH..THE TIMES OF YOUTH..IN YOUR LIFE THAT PASS ALL TO QUICKLY..WE ARE ALL SUFFERING..INSIDE. STILL....THIS SONG..THE FEMALE BACKING VOCALS..TRANSEND..TAKING ME BACK TO PLACES..AND EVENTS IN MY LIFE..TRAGEDY..AND MINUTE TRIUMPHS OF..GIRLS...LONG GONE..BUT REMEMBERED.WITH THIS SONG.
I got into these guys back in 2013, the year after I fell in/out of love. Their music helped to heal me and start a new chapter in my life.
God, I loved this band and song… we need a revival
I still love this song after almost 30 years since its release.
Two of the very best acts of that era. Wonderful real music with meaning, I used to wander around with this song in my lips, mesmerized by its beauty and sadness.
So underrated.
Just want to confirm she is an American F'ing beauty
She complements the band so well
Those was artists, songwriters - performers;not the shit of this days.
Agree. Another underrate band.
Some folks are objecting that the video is spliced and truncated. It is, and I wish it weren't.
Some folks are objecting that the live audio track has been replaced with the album track. It has, and I wish it hadn't.
That said, this video rules far, far more than the absolutely nothing like it that was ever available publicly before it. What a blessing to have stumbled into such awesometh in the year 2013.
NO Jc,. ... its better with NO video. All music is. No visual stimulates the brain. Music is intended to apply to ones own exp.
superb track
I was at this show! I thought it was at The Academy but could be wrong. It was just an amazing evening!
Beautiful song.
I saw Catherine Wheel on the same bill as Tanya in Buffalo, NY but they never teamed up that day. Separately I saw Belly and they were solid.
I was at that show and saw both of them prior to the show while waiting on line to get in!!!! Awesome!!!
TD is so cool ❤
omg Tanya Donelly 😭
Great song
This is the studio sound.
Pure Magic
Would loved to have heard the actual live recording. I saw CW in concert and they were amazing!!!
Yeah, it's a bummer the original sound was replaced. But still nice footage.
@@rjvanderwoud Is it possible that Tanya's part of the original live recording was not that strong? I've seen several videos of her live and she's all over the place. The studio/video of this song is great, but I think they heavily manipulated her voice during production.
FWIW... Not a Tanya Donelly hater. She's fantastic in anything done with Belly and Throwing Muses. Wish I could have been around the Newport RI scene about the time she and Kristin were playing local venues.
@@WHJeffB That might well be. I have no idea how this video came about. By the looks of it she's having a party though.
thanks RJ, this is great.
Nice... odd but nice. Loved CW and Belly. Speaking of, I saw Radiohead open for Belly in Norfolk, VA. You read that correctly. Haha
That serves Radiohead right, hahah!
Still love their sound so much!!
Thank you!!! =))
Amen
Kinda cut up. Would have loved to see CW live.
One of the most underrated bands of all time. ❤️
This is a concert video with the studio recorded version of the song overdubbed, Certainly not live.
Tanya stole the show from Rob! 🙂 That performance was pure goodness.
true that
Sorry, but no way in hell. Starts live but after the first pre-strum it's all over and back to the studio demo version, which you can listen and compare. So I suppose you might as well enjoy the demo video too, which is very nice.
Its not the original audio from the concert.
A
Bonita
any tanya is better then nothing.
this is not a live version of what are you kidding me
Man she’s suffering.
Are they a better version of Bush really?
Catherine Wheel and Bush shouldn't be mentioned in the same sentence. CW light years ahead.
This looks/sounds lipsynced.
Studio-audio overlay
fake
Lip sync... disappointing
I saw this tour. Unfortunately Tanya Donelly sounded awful when she came out and sang. Out of tune and scream-y. I can see why they did this.
As much as I love Tanya and have seen her live a couple times now, she does that live unfortunately at times.
@@spectralthundr9525 She is best with Throwing Muses and Belly
I've seen Belly 3 or 4 times, she's always on so don't know which shows you've seen.