In your video, at exactly 2 minutes the music doesn't start, Corey and Vman look at Eloy and something is wrong. He starts the music and the road comes to fix something that wasn't right. From other angles you can see... There was a technical failure at the beginning of the show...
@@dyogocesar9132 incorrect… the 515 intro was still playing, the live music never starts with 515 as an opener until Sid’s final extended scream, Corey just gave him a “let’s do this” air fist bump.
Yup, pretty normal thing for a ton of bands. They sound super tight, and it sounds way better. I'm not even a Slipknot fan, just super impressed by this guy.
I don’t know why people act like a click track is a bad thing…a lot of drummers can’t play with them and that speaks to their timing issues…so if he’s able to play flawlessly with it, it’s impressive.
Straight up lol. It's WAY easier to just uh not use a click. Any drummer will admit it's harder to keep the groove with the click as opposed to just.......jamming freely - especially during a live setting.
@@DeelyStanimals It's actually really tough to maintain a solid tempo without a click track. Sure, playing along in general might be "easier" - but the point is how consistent the tempo is without it.
No one legitimate is saying playing with a click is a bad thing, but generally speaking, you can tell very quickly when a drummer/band isn't using one due to the fluctuation in tempo and/or just being a little rushed. Or a lot rushed. To not use one and sound like you're using one is what's crazy. Especially in your first ever live performance with Slipknot when your adrenaline has got to be through the roof. Also see: how Danny Carey has never recorded to a click on any Tool album. Boggles the mind.
When they play Disasterpiece you can actually hear Eloy speed up on the third blastbeat in the intro, just like the record where Joey sped up. I guess he's doing it to stay true to the record and to the feel of the song. So he's definitely not using a clicktrack on that song.
Definitely that was the way the song was written. Which you can do with a click track live. If you using a click track through a DAW like protools or any other. So u map the tempo change. Still doesn’t answer the question that he is using a click live with them. Who cares if they are or not. A good drummer can still groove along a click track ;)
Which is why we love Eloy - he's staying true to Joey's playing where it matters. He's also been throwing in his own fills on some songs. Heretic Anthem during Sick new World saw him throwing down some amazing fills he's written for the music too. So not only is he staying true to the recorded material and SMASHING IT he's throwing in his own personality on top of it. Dude is a fucking powerhouse.
RIGHT?! I dont like the whos who on who is better...because they all are great... but eloy had them SMOKED at the age of 14... people are just massive gatekeepers when it comes to this band
I think the click gets such a bad rep because everyone that uses one uses a constant speed click. Like, big speed fluctuations are usually annoying as hell, but a lot of the small fluctuations in tempo, like the beginning of duality, actually help a lot of song styles. Thing is, metronomes can do that, and good drummers should be able to follow suit, so, if a band prepares enough, there should be no noticeable downside to a band using a click, at least from an audience perspective.
What’s with the hate? For real ? Take that bs attitude somewhere else. You wanna live like that have fun . Tryin to be big time with your comments is just LAME.
Obviously he was in one of biggest metal bands in the world and is now in another one of the biggest metal bands in the world, but in his lesser known work, he can really mess with time, such as polyrhythms and odd meters. The dude is quite literally the whole package for drumming. He's so versatile. And his ability to do odd meter/prog metal/djent could really bring Slipknot into uncharted territory musically. Orrrrrrr Slipknot could be his way to let loose and have his lesser known project Casagrande & Hanysz be where he's more thoughtful and meticulous with his compositions (similar to Aric Improta when he was in Fever 333 and then his main, lesser known band, Night Verses).
"but in his lesser known work, he can really mess with time, such as polyrhythms and odd meters." There are complicated parts like this in Slipknot and/or Sepultura
I'd really like to hear some odd tempos in new era slipknot material being written by Eloy. And I think he'll prove his worth to the band not only as a phenomenal drummer, but as an arranger as well.
Eloy has learned from some of the best drum teachers in Brazil, including Aquiles Priester, since he was a child. He isn't a phenomenon; he's rather the result of decades of hard work by him, his family, and his teachers. Perhaps the state of the art in terms of drumming musical learning for heavy metal.
you could go to the same teachers since birth and be a trash drummer. dude has a natural talent, yes he had some great drummers helping him but that does not take away the fact he is just that guy
craig is pointing out facts. I get annoyed when people say about eloy, that he's playing "robotic" and doesn't bring the "energy" because he's not rushing and playing fkin tight as hell. Since when it is a weakness for drummers to play perfectly in time and having built up this skill over years of hard work... this man is just good. just because you are conditioned to hearing unclean drummers live, pls don't discredit the ones that have put the work in their craft.
From my experience, and I play drums with a click and only some my band members do as well: 1. The best way to check if the band is playing to a click is basiclaly overlay a click track to an entire song and see what happens. It will be dead obvious after only a few seconds really. Yes you can program tempo changes, even slight ones, but in general individual parts of the song will have set tempo. 2. You can absolutely play with a click as a drummer when no one else in the band does if you don't start the song, I do it all the time. You basically start the track (or somebody does for you) say a bar before your part starts, in sync with whoever's playing, and that's it. It works only if whoever starts the song is roughly in the right tempo, otherwise tempo change where there shouldn't be one doesn't sound great.
Ive been waiting for Craig... to me,literally the only one on youtube who isnt biased..who isnt saturated with the whole (look af me im an youtuber bs) just raw drum talk,jokes,and honest opinions... exactly how it should be.. Thanks again Craigo .. you are a real one
@@reynlord666 subs nowadays are for fakery and delusional mumble talkers who "act" like they care for the music... we know who Craig is..and Definitely who we search for when we want an honest view on our beloved music.. Keep being exactly how you are...the banter is 🤘🤘
Eloy has relit the fire for me. He his hard, stays true to time. Not shitting on Jay. Thank you for your time dude, kept the band going! But I’m super super happy having Eloy join the ranks and offering his talents ❤
Its awesome to watch you talking about eloy and slipknot, since the first time I had desires of seeing eloy on slipknot was on your brillhant react of him playing The Eloy Heretic Anthem. Fan service at its finest. Also, really dig that you brought a non-obvious angle about all of this ❤ Still, your reaction is the best 😅
as a brazilian and huge fan of Eloy, having watched him with both Glória and Sepultura several times live, Jay will probably always be my fav Slipknot drummer.. I absolutely love him on vol. 5 and that became my all time favorite album of the band it doesn’t mean I’m not totally excited to see what new works are coming out our way with Eloy, I’m super hyped to see if they somehow implement his unique style (which he developed even more lately in Sepultura) on Slipknot’s new stuff
Love using a click just for the first 8-16 bars at the start of songs. Really helps with starting off at the right tempo but then having the freedom especially to drag slow heavy parts. Have recorded a couple of albums that way too, just means the takes have to be solid all the way through.
I am a 63-year-old multidisciplinary artist, focused currently on the visual arts. However, I do anything and everything creative. I am finishing up an MA at the Royal College of Art in London. I only recently discovered your videos. I really like that you are passionate about your art. I LIVE FOR MY ART. You seem to be into the whole art of drumming and the people who make that art great. For me, when an artist in any form of creative expression is passionate, it lifts the boat for all of us. Thanks for that. Be well, by brother.
Im not a drummer, but I follow Eloy since he was 15 years old, and I rember a interview with one of his teachers, showing a techinque of getting completely out of the tempo, and returning it back with no problem after awhile (without metronome), because it helps a lot to improvise in brazilian tradicional rythms.
some fun facts. in science, we use things that are un changing to keep as a standard for measurment. take for example the measure of distance a meter is the length of the path travelled by light in a vacuum during a time interval of 1/299,792,458 of a second Eloy is the standard used to sync a metronome.
Craig, did you see the recent side view videos of Eloy's kit ? There are cables coming out of the very right hand kick. Kick 4 of 4. Interesting for a Slipknot set up.
10 minutes of Slipknot Ear-O-Vision > react videos. I cannot wait to hear the professionally produced version of these shows or at least something better than phone audio with Eloy on drums. Even on these recordings you can feel the rawness and power he brings. Jay is and was amazing but Eloy captures the essence of Joey (ergo the heart of Slipknot) so very well. Cannot wait to hear more
I remember seeing a bunch of the slipknot boys’ names on JH Audio’s endorsee lists many ears ago. I’m not sure if it’s the video quality or if it’s IEMs that blend in with their skin tones, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they were all on them which doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re playing to a click. There’s a LiveBPM app (I believe with the same name) that I wanted to test the videos with, just to see how much variation there is in tempo because it’s just so tight, but then again, I know that Eloy is just a beast. I’ve even spoken to him about this (amongst other things) a few years ago and all he had to say was “No No, I’m not that good, man. I just try.” Top guy, top drummer and I am so stoked for him.
I think the case with Duality, is that because as you said its a big song that they want at tempo, so Eloy counts it in to the metronome he has at the side of him to make sure it starts at the right speed. If you let the guitars and vocal control the speed anything can happen, especially as they aren't on clicks.
From the club show you can see corey point to eloy to start the, eloy loose to his left, nods his head three times at the tempo then counts in. Even if hes not using it through the songs hes using a blinking click to get the tempo at the start, i believe.
I had the same doubt as to whether they were playing with a click or not. So I conducted a test: I downloaded the audio from "Before I Forget" at this show and tried to put it on the grid in Reaper The song starts at 136 bpm, which is the original tempo of the studio version. After the first verse where Eloy makes the snare fills, the song jumps to a faster bpm. So the fact is that the click is only being used at the beginning of the song to ensure it doesn't start faster than it really is
Sorry for the honesty, but Jay never had the power or precision needed, also, his double bass was sloppy and inconsistent. Finally a drummer who can honor Joey's legacy.
Not hating, but Joey’s tempo was even more sloppy than Jay’s, he used to rush absolutely eveything. Though, he had the right energy and glue with the band.
@@volpe_sol dude, get some new ears and watch Disasterpieces…if Joey was going faster is because the band wanted to go faster and for a period Slipknot had that thing to change it live. But before the Vol 3 tour it was really impressive what they could do while throwing pigs’ heads at each other.
@@or1on89 I love how the band sounded with Joey, he's the og after all. Im just pointing out the FACT that he wasn't the tightest drummer in terms of fluctuating tempos. Watch him subbing for Korn during the 2007 self-titled era especially.
Slipknot is such a huge act. I would beleive there is a crew member in the back whose job is to be a metronome operator for Eloy. Making live adjustments based on whats happeneing (i.e. surfacing)
I dont get why people have a problem with a click being utilized. I had a band in high school and something we noticed when we played was we would end up finishing sets too early. We would have a 20-30 minute slot, we would hit our last song and there was an awkard amount of time leftover where we could have played one more or spent some time doing crowd work. We watched a video of us playing and realized we were playing way too fast. So we bought a wireless system for some in-ear monitors for ourselves and we played to a click we could all hear. The difference was VERY noticeable. Soon enough we started utilizing backing tracks, synths, choral parts, bass drops, etc and brought more dynamics to what we were playing. We were just a highschool band that dropped $400 on a small monitor system and we suddenly had a new level that other bands we were playing with that just werent at. We'd be the only band at a gig with in ear monitors and our laptop set up off to the side plugged into our monitors and into the house for all the different effects. We stopped playing in mid 2019 (life, were all still friends and jam now and then) but whenever we play together we still use our in ear monitors in the jam room, still play to clicks, still use effects.
All 3 drummers are incredible in their own way. The songs Joey wrote no one can compete with they have some of the greatest drum parts in metal. Jay did an incredible job of brigning his own style into the band and making it his own and not just coping Joey. Jay is also a spectacular drummer to watch and brings the slipknot vibe to the band. Really excited to see what eloy can bring with his precision and pwoer to the band. However Mario Duplantier is the best metal drummer
We are not Your Kind and Grey Chapter are insane great albuns, but yeah dude, Eloy is a master since his 15 years old. Jay was playing on Agaisnt me, took him time to keep up on live performances, very hard job. He was in the second biggest metal band of today, the bar is very high on being a pro. And Mario is surreal
I think there were songs they did and songs they didn’t use clicks for. Some of the songs sound better done without, but songs like psychosocial kinda really need that consistency to have the same weight to them as the record.
totally agree with everything in this but just wanted to add: my band has guitar-started songs that I (sometimes) play with a click where I don’t count in and the guitarist doesn’t wear in ears! It is possible! I use an SPDSX with a footswitch to the left of my hihat pedal, that footswitch starts/stops the click in my headphones anytime I want. So I’ll let the guitarist start the song, and then when I come in I just hit the footswitch and we’re on the click. Guitarist is good+rehearsed enough that he’s never very far off and the transition isn’t jarring. I’ll frequently cut the click after 8ish bars of the song, and then maybe bring it back in later in the song just to check. it also lets us rawdog gradual tempo changes which typically feels better to me than trying to follow an accelerating or slowing metronome. But I do also sometimes use more traditional preprogrammed tempo map clicks on certain songs with many tempo changes for the first couple shows of tour just we can get our sea legs under us so to speak.
Regardless, all that matters is they sound much better playing closer to the bpm of the recorded songs. It not only flows better, makes them heavier, but allows for Corey to not be rushed and out of breath.
I remembered Eloy's interview from drumeo, he mentioned there that he didn't use click track or metronome when he was recording or playing with Sepultura. He is following the flow or the feel.
Pro drummers are so use to practice and play with a click you cant really tell, that s how they developpe solide time groove and correct the tendencies of rushing and dragging fills...to the point that the click is part of your brain even if there is none
Played in a slipknot tribute band (that ran Sid and Craig's parts via a backing track) - we based EVERYTHING off the studio releases, so the tempo maps looked like a rollercoaster after I finished building the click/backing track. Fluctuations every bar - not huge ones, but noticeable.
Exactly what I said on some other reactions, Eloy's timekeeping is just the best. It's a big change for Slipknot, and NOT a dis on Jay or Joey, their styles were just more rushed and a lot of people loved that about them. It's all subjective people, it's completely fine to have different styles of playing. Metallica in the 80's prided themselves at playing their songs faster and faster than their records. It's just cool we're getting a more controlled and album-tight Slipknot now.
Eloy is the click lol he is just that good he's insane the lad won an international drumming tournament at 14 years of age, he played absolutely insane in sepultura too
I was one of the many fans that was pissed when Jay got fired but seeing Slipknot Saturday at SNW I realized Joey will NEVER be replaced but damn Eloy is ELITE!
where eloy really screwed up was not starting when corey told him to do it and he just ignored it, in this band if you bother the bosses corey or clown you're finished
You're spot on. And to those taking issue with it, so what if they did play the whole set to a reference click? There are many production related reasons to do so and any band actually able to play to a click are far more capable musicians for it in my book. I'm all for whatever works for the band and the music. I find the majority of people griping about a click are those unable to keep time well enough to walk at a steady pace, let alone keep time in a band setting. Great video.
Playing to a click, especially with alot of time sig and tempo changes, is a LOT harder than folk think it is, especially live. It takes getting used to, for sure. Personally, I don't care, either... Eloy can use whatever ingredients he wants to cook with, and I am still gonna eat whatever comes out, bc that shit is gonna be gourmet! \m/
I had actually thought he was doing something like this (not having a click playing during the song, but using some kind of a reference to count him off), so it's good to know that a seasoned pro also thinks that!
Hated you? Far from it you have a new sub. Is so refreshing to hear someone talking facts and using logic to back it up rather than just spewing vitriol. Excited is the word from me, the best in metal playing for the biggest in metal. Dear me they’re spoiling us.
When you are actually a naturally talented drummer and you are into the stuff you are playing, particularly with faster music I find it easy to stay 'in time ' for me the slower the song the more difficult it is to hold perfect 'time'.
"I'm a very hateable character" pfffft It's hard to hate that sexy mug of drumming knowledge. Loving the uploads, loving the pod, keen to see you back in Aus soon Reynlord
I play to a click in a live electronic act, and I play without it in rock gigs. I've been using a portable metronome for years to get a tempo reference before starting a rock song. It's super helpful.
I mean, a lot of music sounds significantly better to me when there's a natural shift in tempo between parts. I think a lot of people are way too obsessed with making things "perfect" and a lot of subtlety gets lost in my opinion. Nothing to do with hate, just different aesthetic sensibilities.
To be fair it does change how a performance sounds, but it's kind of personal preference at that point. I like that Slipknot doesn't play to a click although the pretention around it is very dumb.
Didn't expect to see my video in a Craig Reynolds video today but that's pretty cool
In your video, at exactly 2 minutes the music doesn't start, Corey and Vman look at Eloy and something is wrong. He starts the music and the road comes to fix something that wasn't right. From other angles you can see... There was a technical failure at the beginning of the show...
@@dyogocesar9132 incorrect… the 515 intro was still playing, the live music never starts with 515 as an opener until Sid’s final extended scream, Corey just gave him a “let’s do this” air fist bump.
Ever run into the DAAP gang?
@@TheHouseOfMasks I understood. Because at that moment he looks at the road, he runs to adjust something on the drums. Thanks for clarifying.
you're pretty cool. thanks for the great vid
Eloy's Doctor, on his birth:
"congratulations, it's a metronome"
he's AMAB (assigned metronome at birth)
Last time I saw this joke was Thomas Haake drum play through
🤣🤣🤣
EVEN IF he was on a click for the ENTIRE show why should we give a flying fuck if he sounds this fucking good.
You're right
EXACTLY! lol who gives flying fu***
It doesn’t matter one bit. It’s just like when people try to use triggers as some kind of evil word.
Yup, pretty normal thing for a ton of bands. They sound super tight, and it sounds way better. I'm not even a Slipknot fan, just super impressed by this guy.
@@BrofUJu Eloy’s been my favorite drummer for a decade now. Do a deep dive of his drum play throughs you will not be disappointed
Slipknot is honored to have Eloy Casagrande today
Com certeza absoluta
O nome da banda no Brasil hoje é "Eloy Casagrande and The Slipknots".
@@mariomuraokajunior1899 Verdade irmão
@@mariomuraokajunior1899 "Eloy e seus slipinotos" kkkkk
They worship the flipflop😂
He's not using the metronome, the metronome uses Eloy.
Because Eloy is that good. 8:13 is Eloy making sure the metronome is with him.
My boy eloy is not using a click. He created the tempo
He is the click
Actually the click need to follow eloy 😎
XD
and yet he messed it up. Not even really a fan of jay. But Eloy’s first show was kinda meh IMO. people = shit’s intro was so bad.
@@nathandrums0 you kidding right?
The Eloy Heretic Anthem cover reaction was one of my faves. Feels like everything has come full circle
Looove that cover so much
"gimme that dick" - Craig
I don’t know why people act like a click track is a bad thing…a lot of drummers can’t play with them and that speaks to their timing issues…so if he’s able to play flawlessly with it, it’s impressive.
Straight up lol. It's WAY easier to just uh not use a click. Any drummer will admit it's harder to keep the groove with the click as opposed to just.......jamming freely - especially during a live setting.
Yeah, I was going to say. Way harder to play with a click than to play without one in my experience.
@@DeelyStanimals It's actually really tough to maintain a solid tempo without a click track. Sure, playing along in general might be "easier" - but the point is how consistent the tempo is without it.
No one legitimate is saying playing with a click is a bad thing, but generally speaking, you can tell very quickly when a drummer/band isn't using one due to the fluctuation in tempo and/or just being a little rushed. Or a lot rushed. To not use one and sound like you're using one is what's crazy. Especially in your first ever live performance with Slipknot when your adrenaline has got to be through the roof.
Also see: how Danny Carey has never recorded to a click on any Tool album. Boggles the mind.
Cause the majority of drummers don't do they homework properly. The freaking metronome should be every musician's friend.
When they play Disasterpiece you can actually hear Eloy speed up on the third blastbeat in the intro, just like the record where Joey sped up. I guess he's doing it to stay true to the record and to the feel of the song. So he's definitely not using a clicktrack on that song.
Well…that’s the tempo on the original song…it’s not a defect, it is made on purpose to charge up the start of the song 😅😊
@@or1on89 Yeah, that's literally how the song is written.
Definitely that was the way the song was written. Which you can do with a click track live. If you using a click track through a DAW like protools or any other. So u map the tempo change. Still doesn’t answer the question that he is using a click live with them. Who cares if they are or not. A good drummer can still groove along a click track ;)
Which is why we love Eloy - he's staying true to Joey's playing where it matters. He's also been throwing in his own fills on some songs. Heretic Anthem during Sick new World saw him throwing down some amazing fills he's written for the music too. So not only is he staying true to the recorded material and SMASHING IT he's throwing in his own personality on top of it. Dude is a fucking powerhouse.
Did it on people = shit too
Eloy is for sure the metronome. Just go watch his Modern Drummer appearance in 2005 when he was 14. lol
RIGHT?! I dont like the whos who on who is better...because they all are great... but eloy had them SMOKED at the age of 14... people are just massive gatekeepers when it comes to this band
I love how Craig talks about the click like it's the newest drug on the market for drummers. If he had a click who fucking cares, Eloy plays great.
i do love the click but it discredits Eloy for reddit to be like ‘he’s on a click that’s why he’s so tight’. He’s not and that’s even more impressive
also all the influencer types claiming they know he’s on a click. I’m just showing the proof he isn’t and why it’s so impressive
@@reynlord666 I got that and agree, it just looks mentally exhausting for the big boy drummy drum drum influencers to think about it.
I think the click gets such a bad rep because everyone that uses one uses a constant speed click.
Like, big speed fluctuations are usually annoying as hell, but a lot of the small fluctuations in tempo, like the beginning of duality, actually help a lot of song styles. Thing is, metronomes can do that, and good drummers should be able to follow suit, so, if a band prepares enough, there should be no noticeable downside to a band using a click, at least from an audience perspective.
What’s with the hate? For real ? Take that bs attitude somewhere else. You wanna live like that have fun . Tryin to be big time with your comments is just LAME.
He just LOCKED. IN.
Exactly! That’s what a pro does !
Obviously he was in one of biggest metal bands in the world and is now in another one of the biggest metal bands in the world, but in his lesser known work, he can really mess with time, such as polyrhythms and odd meters.
The dude is quite literally the whole package for drumming. He's so versatile. And his ability to do odd meter/prog metal/djent could really bring Slipknot into uncharted territory musically.
Orrrrrrr Slipknot could be his way to let loose and have his lesser known project Casagrande & Hanysz be where he's more thoughtful and meticulous with his compositions (similar to Aric Improta when he was in Fever 333 and then his main, lesser known band, Night Verses).
"but in his lesser known work, he can really mess with time, such as polyrhythms and odd meters."
There are complicated parts like this in Slipknot and/or Sepultura
Best metal drummer on the planet and watching him on drumeo get super serious about nailing drums for a Christmas song made me love him even more.
I'd really like to hear some odd tempos in new era slipknot material being written by Eloy. And I think he'll prove his worth to the band not only as a phenomenal drummer, but as an arranger as well.
I stumbled upon night verses. Fucking awesome music! Aric improta is amazing!
Eloy has learned from some of the best drum teachers in Brazil, including Aquiles Priester, since he was a child. He isn't a phenomenon; he's rather the result of decades of hard work by him, his family, and his teachers. Perhaps the state of the art in terms of drumming musical learning for heavy metal.
All this included does not mean he is not a phenomenon. Actually he is a genius and had great teachers.
you could go to the same teachers since birth and be a trash drummer. dude has a natural talent, yes he had some great drummers helping him but that does not take away the fact he is just that guy
“That’s an empty conch!” - never thought I’d be so ingrossed in conch watch
New head tattoos look dope man! 🤘🏻 Eloy is incredible, no better drummer to step in!
I watched this live but bet your ass I’ll watch it again
You and me both. 🤝
I dare you
craig is pointing out facts. I get annoyed when people say about eloy, that he's playing "robotic" and doesn't bring the "energy" because he's not rushing and playing fkin tight as hell. Since when it is a weakness for drummers to play perfectly in time and having built up this skill over years of hard work... this man is just good. just because you are conditioned to hearing unclean drummers live, pls don't discredit the ones that have put the work in their craft.
Great investigation.. Eloy is the most fuckin amazing and exciting drummer I've heard in decades
Thanks Craig. I remember 2-3 years ago when you said. "One of the biggest band on the planet, why dont you nick him" while watching an Eloy video.
Love a good bit of conch watching at lunch time.
Can we talk about how ridiculously cool that modified mask Corey wore is? That is sick shit.
From my experience, and I play drums with a click and only some my band members do as well: 1. The best way to check if the band is playing to a click is basiclaly overlay a click track to an entire song and see what happens. It will be dead obvious after only a few seconds really. Yes you can program tempo changes, even slight ones, but in general individual parts of the song will have set tempo. 2. You can absolutely play with a click as a drummer when no one else in the band does if you don't start the song, I do it all the time. You basically start the track (or somebody does for you) say a bar before your part starts, in sync with whoever's playing, and that's it. It works only if whoever starts the song is roughly in the right tempo, otherwise tempo change where there shouldn't be one doesn't sound great.
Jay and Eloy are friends. Jay is pretty happy with this and he's in a great band too.
I don't know anyone who's down on Eloy. He's just so likeable and talented.
@@crankfastle8138I don’t see how anyone could be a fan of drumming and not be a fan of Eloy. So skilled but also super humble to boot
Jay unfollowed Eloy on Instagram though, so idk lol.
@@sorin_ea6 LOL That's true. Eloy still follows Jay. That's weird.
I saw Eloy with Sepultura a few years ago and wow. It was a small club and you could feel his hits. Man is incredible and such a heavy hitter
Ive been waiting for Craig... to me,literally the only one on youtube who isnt biased..who isnt saturated with the whole (look af me im an youtuber bs) just raw drum talk,jokes,and honest opinions... exactly how it should be..
Thanks again Craigo .. you are a real one
thanks it’s also why i have half as many subs :(
@@reynlord666 subs nowadays are for fakery and delusional mumble talkers who "act" like they care for the music... we know who Craig is..and Definitely who we search for when we want an honest view on our beloved music..
Keep being exactly how you are...the banter is 🤘🤘
Eloy has relit the fire for me. He his hard, stays true to time. Not shitting on Jay. Thank you for your time dude, kept the band going! But I’m super super happy having Eloy join the ranks and offering his talents ❤
Love the insight, Craig. Always a pleasure learning something new
Glad I brought this up during the steam now. Made for a good video!
I mean the butt thing sounds like a product idea
I think a Chess Player holds the patent iirc
Don't give anyone any ideas, or 10 years from now we'll be doing much worse than Conch Watches D:
Its awesome to watch you talking about eloy and slipknot, since the first time I had desires of seeing eloy on slipknot was on your brillhant react of him playing The Eloy Heretic Anthem. Fan service at its finest. Also, really dig that you brought a non-obvious angle about all of this ❤
Still, your reaction is the best 😅
as a brazilian and huge fan of Eloy, having watched him with both Glória and Sepultura several times live, Jay will probably always be my fav Slipknot drummer.. I absolutely love him on vol. 5 and that became my all time favorite album of the band
it doesn’t mean I’m not totally excited to see what new works are coming out our way with Eloy, I’m super hyped to see if they somehow implement his unique style (which he developed even more lately in Sepultura) on Slipknot’s new stuff
Love using a click just for the first 8-16 bars at the start of songs. Really helps with starting off at the right tempo but then having the freedom especially to drag slow heavy parts. Have recorded a couple of albums that way too, just means the takes have to be solid all the way through.
It would also make sense for Eloy to not use a click (at least for the earlier stuff) since every album before AHIG wasn’t recorded to a metronome.
I am a 63-year-old multidisciplinary artist, focused currently on the visual arts. However, I do anything and everything creative. I am finishing up an MA at the Royal College of Art in London. I only recently discovered your videos. I really like that you are passionate about your art. I LIVE FOR MY ART. You seem to be into the whole art of drumming and the people who make that art great. For me, when an artist in any form of creative expression is passionate, it lifts the boat for all of us. Thanks for that. Be well, by brother.
Happy to be here.. conch watching with you.
Im not a drummer, but I follow Eloy since he was 15 years old, and I rember a interview with one of his teachers, showing a techinque of getting completely out of the tempo, and returning it back with no problem after awhile (without metronome), because it helps a lot to improvise in brazilian tradicional rythms.
some fun facts. in science, we use things that are un changing to keep as a standard for measurment. take for example the measure of distance a meter is the length of the path travelled by light in a vacuum during a time interval of 1/299,792,458 of a second
Eloy is the standard used to sync a metronome.
Craig, did you see the recent side view videos of Eloy's kit ? There are cables coming out of the very right hand kick. Kick 4 of 4. Interesting for a Slipknot set up.
The metronome follows him.
As you said, so the stage adrenaline doesn't take over. It just keeps him in the ballpark of the song.
10 minutes of Slipknot Ear-O-Vision > react videos. I cannot wait to hear the professionally produced version of these shows or at least something better than phone audio with Eloy on drums. Even on these recordings you can feel the rawness and power he brings. Jay is and was amazing but Eloy captures the essence of Joey (ergo the heart of Slipknot) so very well. Cannot wait to hear more
I’ve never conchentrated so hard
I remember seeing a bunch of the slipknot boys’ names on JH Audio’s endorsee lists many ears ago. I’m not sure if it’s the video quality or if it’s IEMs that blend in with their skin tones, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they were all on them which doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re playing to a click.
There’s a LiveBPM app (I believe with the same name) that I wanted to test the videos with, just to see how much variation there is in tempo because it’s just so tight, but then again, I know that Eloy is just a beast. I’ve even spoken to him about this (amongst other things) a few years ago and all he had to say was “No No, I’m not that good, man. I just try.”
Top guy, top drummer and I am so stoked for him.
"Conch shot" fucking got me
I absolutely lost it at “now we’re on Mick conch watch” 🤣🤣
I think the case with Duality, is that because as you said its a big song that they want at tempo, so Eloy counts it in to the metronome he has at the side of him to make sure it starts at the right speed. If you let the guitars and vocal control the speed anything can happen, especially as they aren't on clicks.
Probably because of the long drawn out vocal lines in the intro.
From the club show you can see corey point to eloy to start the, eloy loose to his left, nods his head three times at the tempo then counts in. Even if hes not using it through the songs hes using a blinking click to get the tempo at the start, i believe.
Eloy also doesn't use triggers which is nuts with how consistent his sound is.
I had the same doubt as to whether they were playing with a click or not. So I conducted a test: I downloaded the audio from "Before I Forget" at this show and tried to put it on the grid in Reaper
The song starts at 136 bpm, which is the original tempo of the studio version. After the first verse where Eloy makes the snare fills, the song jumps to a faster bpm. So the fact is that the click is only being used at the beginning of the song to ensure it doesn't start faster than it really is
Totally here for the start of OnlyConch
Sorry for the honesty, but Jay never had the power or precision needed, also, his double bass was sloppy and inconsistent. Finally a drummer who can honor Joey's legacy.
Not hating, but Joey’s tempo was even more sloppy than Jay’s, he used to rush absolutely eveything. Though, he had the right energy and glue with the band.
@@volpe_sol dude, get some new ears and watch Disasterpieces…if Joey was going faster is because the band wanted to go faster and for a period Slipknot had that thing to change it live. But before the Vol 3 tour it was really impressive what they could do while throwing pigs’ heads at each other.
@@or1on89 I love how the band sounded with Joey, he's the og after all. Im just pointing out the FACT that he wasn't the tightest drummer in terms of fluctuating tempos. Watch him subbing for Korn during the 2007 self-titled era especially.
@@volpe_sol Oh yeah, he wasn't the tightest but it fitted well with Slipknot at the time, how chaotic & aggressive they were.
@@or1on89 The drummer is the one who controls the speed of the music.
Love you Craig. Miss your content, but I’m glad you’re busy enough that you don’t need to do it
Eloy MONSTER Casagrande.
The color on your head tattoo is so vibrant that it burnt my eyes and I fekking love it
Also Eloy is a god and you rule
Slipknot is such a huge act. I would beleive there is a crew member in the back whose job is to be a metronome operator for Eloy. Making live adjustments based on whats happeneing (i.e. surfacing)
The but plug click track line had me laughing. What a concept! Porter and Davies, over to you 😂
I dont get why people have a problem with a click being utilized. I had a band in high school and something we noticed when we played was we would end up finishing sets too early. We would have a 20-30 minute slot, we would hit our last song and there was an awkard amount of time leftover where we could have played one more or spent some time doing crowd work. We watched a video of us playing and realized we were playing way too fast.
So we bought a wireless system for some in-ear monitors for ourselves and we played to a click we could all hear. The difference was VERY noticeable. Soon enough we started utilizing backing tracks, synths, choral parts, bass drops, etc and brought more dynamics to what we were playing. We were just a highschool band that dropped $400 on a small monitor system and we suddenly had a new level that other bands we were playing with that just werent at.
We'd be the only band at a gig with in ear monitors and our laptop set up off to the side plugged into our monitors and into the house for all the different effects. We stopped playing in mid 2019 (life, were all still friends and jam now and then) but whenever we play together we still use our in ear monitors in the jam room, still play to clicks, still use effects.
You said everything, THIS IS ART!
Hoping the Butt Plug Metronome not only gets released, but that it was a reference to that Chess scandal
All 3 drummers are incredible in their own way. The songs Joey wrote no one can compete with they have some of the greatest drum parts in metal. Jay did an incredible job of brigning his own style into the band and making it his own and not just coping Joey. Jay is also a spectacular drummer to watch and brings the slipknot vibe to the band. Really excited to see what eloy can bring with his precision and pwoer to the band. However Mario Duplantier is the best metal drummer
We are not Your Kind and Grey Chapter are insane great albuns, but yeah dude, Eloy is a master since his 15 years old.
Jay was playing on Agaisnt me, took him time to keep up on live performances, very hard job. He was in the second biggest metal band of today, the bar is very high on being a pro. And Mario is surreal
Now THIS was the person I wanted to hear insight from. Heck yes! Thanks for this, Craig!
The metronome wakes 15min earlier to calibrates to eloy dude
I think there were songs they did and songs they didn’t use clicks for. Some of the songs sound better done without, but songs like psychosocial kinda really need that consistency to have the same weight to them as the record.
totally agree with everything in this but just wanted to add:
my band has guitar-started songs that I (sometimes) play with a click where I don’t count in and the guitarist doesn’t wear in ears! It is possible! I use an SPDSX with a footswitch to the left of my hihat pedal, that footswitch starts/stops the click in my headphones anytime I want. So I’ll let the guitarist start the song, and then when I come in I just hit the footswitch and we’re on the click. Guitarist is good+rehearsed enough that he’s never very far off and the transition isn’t jarring.
I’ll frequently cut the click after 8ish bars of the song, and then maybe bring it back in later in the song just to check. it also lets us rawdog gradual tempo changes which typically feels better to me than trying to follow an accelerating or slowing metronome. But I do also sometimes use more traditional preprogrammed tempo map clicks on certain songs with many tempo changes for the first couple shows of tour just we can get our sea legs under us so to speak.
Regardless, all that matters is they sound much better playing closer to the bpm of the recorded songs. It not only flows better, makes them heavier, but allows for Corey to not be rushed and out of breath.
I remembered Eloy's interview from drumeo, he mentioned there that he didn't use click track or metronome when he was recording or playing with Sepultura. He is following the flow or the feel.
"I'm a very hateable character." What a great line. 🤣 Craig Rules.
bro I’m at the wrong gig!
I'm seeing Chuck Norris jokes with Eloy.
Pro drummers are so use to practice and play with a click you cant really tell, that s how they developpe solide time groove and correct the tendencies of rushing and dragging fills...to the point that the click is part of your brain even if there is none
Miss these type of vids from you (haven’t missed a beat since the pandemic) ❤️
Played in a slipknot tribute band (that ran Sid and Craig's parts via a backing track) - we based EVERYTHING off the studio releases, so the tempo maps looked like a rollercoaster after I finished building the click/backing track. Fluctuations every bar - not huge ones, but noticeable.
Exactly what I said on some other reactions, Eloy's timekeeping is just the best. It's a big change for Slipknot, and NOT a dis on Jay or Joey, their styles were just more rushed and a lot of people loved that about them. It's all subjective people, it's completely fine to have different styles of playing. Metallica in the 80's prided themselves at playing their songs faster and faster than their records. It's just cool we're getting a more controlled and album-tight Slipknot now.
Eloy is the click lol he is just that good he's insane the lad won an international drumming tournament at 14 years of age, he played absolutely insane in sepultura too
I was one of the many fans that was pissed when Jay got fired but seeing Slipknot Saturday at SNW I realized Joey will NEVER be replaced but damn Eloy is ELITE!
Every drummer plays with an in ear metronome.
Excellent video! RESPECT man!
where eloy really screwed up was not starting when corey told him to do it and he just ignored it, in this band if you bother the bosses corey or clown you're finished
You're spot on.
And to those taking issue with it, so what if they did play the whole set to a reference click? There are many production related reasons to do so and any band actually able to play to a click are far more capable musicians for it in my book.
I'm all for whatever works for the band and the music. I find the majority of people griping about a click are those unable to keep time well enough to walk at a steady pace, let alone keep time in a band setting.
Great video.
Playing to a click, especially with alot of time sig and tempo changes, is a LOT harder than folk think it is, especially live. It takes getting used to, for sure. Personally, I don't care, either... Eloy can use whatever ingredients he wants to cook with, and I am still gonna eat whatever comes out, bc that shit is gonna be gourmet! \m/
All things aside, you lighting and image quality is amazing ! One of the best I've seen on youtube !
Craig new ink looks sick! I can't stop thinking about how lucky and historical it would have been to be in that crowd. It's a Slipknot dream.
I had actually thought he was doing something like this (not having a click playing during the song, but using some kind of a reference to count him off), so it's good to know that a seasoned pro also thinks that!
Nolan created Inception after hears Eloy playing
Hated you? Far from it you have a new sub. Is so refreshing to hear someone talking facts and using logic to back it up rather than just spewing vitriol. Excited is the word from me, the best in metal playing for the biggest in metal. Dear me they’re spoiling us.
He is a legend in the making right now he is the golden child I feel it ive been a drummer all my life
You see, Eloy doesn't play to clicks. Clicks play to Eloy.
It's already confirmed he does use a metronome, but it's just to start off each song.
That's how fucking good he is. He sounds like being on a metronome yet he isn't. Out of this world drummer.
This is proper detective work, well done Craig.
You made me start watching reaction videos and NOW you're making me give up on them. Thanks.
You’ve just explained why I think they are just such a tight band in general and the standard any new members have to be at!
I am genuinely so excited to be living in the Eloyknot era
When you are actually a naturally talented drummer and you are into the stuff you are playing, particularly with faster music I find it easy to stay 'in time ' for me the slower the song the more difficult it is to hold perfect 'time'.
Duality has always been counted in live.
Love what you said: I play WITH the click. That’s such a key thing, instead of playing TO the click. Helps make it easier.
"I'm a very hateable character" pfffft
It's hard to hate that sexy mug of drumming knowledge.
Loving the uploads, loving the pod, keen to see you back in Aus soon Reynlord
he dont need a metronome, he is the metronome
The Return Of The King (extended edition)
I play to a click in a live electronic act, and I play without it in rock gigs. I've been using a portable metronome for years to get a tempo reference before starting a rock song. It's super helpful.
The metronome tries to keep in time with Eloy
Why would people hate on the mighty click?
It's the same people that hate on triggers.
I mean, a lot of music sounds significantly better to me when there's a natural shift in tempo between parts. I think a lot of people are way too obsessed with making things "perfect" and a lot of subtlety gets lost in my opinion. Nothing to do with hate, just different aesthetic sensibilities.
To be fair it does change how a performance sounds, but it's kind of personal preference at that point. I like that Slipknot doesn't play to a click although the pretention around it is very dumb.