The Battle off Samar | 1 Month Animation Project
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 มิ.ย. 2022
- Over the last month, I've been working on this project. As part of my final animation class, I felt that I should do a story about one of the greatest naval battles in history. I want to take a moment to say thank you, Mr. Weston, for everything. Your continued support for me has helped me through so much.
I would also like to take a moment to say thank you to all my friends. Hunter, Ian, Caleb, Darrion, ReaperKing, S16_SpiceyDicey, AnacapaMori and Nortrick. You're all so amazing, and I'm so happy to have gotten the opportunity to meet all of you. Thank you, for making this world just a little bit brighter.
This project was entirely animated in Blender, using the Flip Fluids add-on. It's a great product, I highly recommend it if you simulate fluid in Blender often. Not sponsored, or required to say that, just genuinely love this product and I want to recognize that.
Anyways, enjoy the animation, and hug someone. They probably need it and don't want to say it. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![ความรักของยักษ์เขียว (ทศกัณฐ์) - เดี่ยว ไออุ่น [OFFICIAL MUSICVIDEO 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yCCy-QVHqK8/mqdefault.jpg)
(Update: Alright, so it looks like the most requested battle is the Hunt for the Bismarck, followed by the battle of Jutland and then the battle of Guadalcanal. I'll begin work on them in that order, thank you all so much for your input, I appreciate it! You can expect the Hunt for the Bismarck video to go live in late July/early August. I'll post minor updates on progress either in small short videos or in the comment section here!)
Alright, so first I’d like to thank you all for watching! This has shot up to become my highest viewed video in less than 5 days time. Thank you so much!
Now, onto the important question: what battle should I animate next? I don’t have the ability to create polls or community posts so I’ll ask the comment section here. Here are some of the options, but they are not limited to them. If you have your own idea please comment it! Whichever is the most commented battle will become my next project.
So far I’ve received requests to cover the pursuit of the legendary Bismarck.
I’ve also considered the battle of river plate.
The battle of cape matapan.
Naval Battle of Guadalcanal.
Got a different idea? Let me know in the comments, whichever is the most common will become my next project!
You should do a video on the Battle Of Denmark straight.
A little-known and the only battle that was fought on American soil during WW2. The Battle of Attu. A part of the Aleutian Islands chain in Alaska.
Have you thought about doing the battle of Jutland? Maybe it takes too much time due to the sheer number of ships involved, but I think it could look great.
@@MiguelGomez-jg1yl I did consider doing one on Jutland, however, with the number of ships involved and the sheer scale of the battle would require a lot of models to be made entirely from scratch. Which would turn that project into a several month’s Lon endeavour.
WW1 models are surprisingly scarce in comparison to WW2 models. So I would probably have to model only lead ships of classes and ignore small indivise changes between ships.
Jutland would be fun, but it would definitely, hands down be, the single biggest project I have ever worked on.
@@SwankySpitfire Make any battle you want the work is awesome, i would say the sinking of yamato would be an interesting one, safe travels!
Johnston's wreck was discovered last year, the deepest known shipwreck at the time, only beaten out in the last few days by her compatriot Samuel B Roberts at a depth of over 4.25 miles underwater.
They just found the Samuel B. Roberts over the weekend.
@@evilwookiee7655 yes, that was addressed in the second half of my comment ☺
Still looking for Hoel and Gambier bay. Then Taffy 3 will, if just symbolically, be together again.
Yeah, the wrecks of the Johnston & the Roberts were both pulled into the deepest depths by the sheer weight of the balls of the crewmen that died fighting that day.
The major tragedy that occurred was that after the action was over no one was allowed to look for survivors for over 24 hours! And a lot of the men that fought with such bravery and tenacity would die from the combination of their battle wounds, shark attacks & exposure before any help arrived. IDK, they said that they were worried that Japanese ships could still be lurking & didn't want another ship to fall as prey. HOWEVER, the survivors of those ships put everything on the line to protect the carriers & the forces that had landed on Leyte. For the US Navy to follow up such an incredible act of bravery & selflessness with, in my opinion, an act of cowardice, by not going in & immediately getting those sailors out of the water, was a major insult to the memory of the men that died. And I hope whomever gave that order paid dearly for making such a decision.
@@kennethdeanmiller7324 The reason why they didn't stop to help the survivors is because their ships would become a stationary target by the Japanese submarines and Taffy 3 group was a support group and they needed those ships to support the landing force and to complete the amphibious assault in Leyte gulf. That's the reason why they did not help the survivors right away. It's really hard to serve in Military, Navy and Airforce because to sacrifice everything just to fulfill your duty.
My father was a Navy Corpsman who went ashore with MacArthur's Army forces during the Battle of Leyte Gulf. Due to the bravery of navel forces like Taffy 3, I am here today and served 26 years in the US Air Force. My son served in the US Army completing two tours in Iraq and my youngest daughter takes care of our Veterans working for the US Veteran's Administration. Thank you for your well-produced and accurate accounting of the Battle of Samar.
Commander Evans, for his actions in leading Taffy 3 against overwhelming odds against his opponent, already deserves whole-hearted respect.
What is even more remarkable was that a little more than 2 years earlier, Evans was serving on the USS Alden, an American destroyer homebased at Cavite City, as it fought a desperate but hopeless battle against Japanese forces engaging them in the Java Sea.
On the night of 27 February 1942, he was aboard the Alden as his ship and 3 others disengaged from Dutch Admiral Karel Doorman's force, leaving the latter to fight to the death with Dutch, British, and Australian ships alone. As the American destroyers had run out of torpedoes, they withdrew from the battle where Doorman met his fate. Evans was reportedly so disgusted at this refusal to offer battle that he swore than when he was offered his own command, his ship would never turn away from confronting the enemy.
The rest is history.
I'm so proud of our sailors, and Taffy 3's heroes shall never be forgotten. I'm so glad that more people are learning about Taffy 3's legends!
Big Chief Evans is an absolute LEGEND!!🐐
Wow. You actually animated the gun director on top of the bridge to rotate with the gun turrets. This is the first time I've seen this level of detail. Outstanding.
Very nice!
One item that you didn't mention was the effort & effect that the aircraft from Taffy 3, as well as Taffy 1 & Taffy 2, had on the Japanese fleet. They harassed the Japanese so much so that Kurita was certain he was fighting a much larger fleet. That contributed to his decision to turn back.
You referenced both John D. Hornfischer and Drachinifel. Two of my favorite naval historians.
And, as I'm sure others have mentioned, both the USS Johnston and the USS Samuel B. Roberts have been located and positively identified. The lost crews of both are on eternal patrol.
You conflict lost submarines and lost ships
@@timber_wulf5775 Well, they're underwater in any event.
As a operations officer of Adm.Kurita said, " the attack was almost incessant but the number of planes at any given time was few. The bombers & torpedo planes were very aggressive & skillful, the coordination was impressive ; even in comparison with the great experience of American attack that we had already had, this was the most skillful work of your planes."
@@joevicmeneses8918 That was the case with Yamato. Without taking anything away from the courage of our surface ship sailors, the Japanese vessels sunk off Samar were sunk primarily as a result of air attack.
I have listened to, watched, and read a number of recountings of this battle. Until now, I hadn't been made aware of a most impressive fact which drives home the immense disparity between the belligerents. That the tonnage displacement of the Yamato was greater than that of the entire Taffy 3 task force.
I couldn’t believe it myself at first, so I double checked the math. Using standard displacement, the combined tonnage of TAFFY 3 came to about 50,000 tons… Yamato weighed 72,000 tons.
@@SwankySpitfire Did that include the carriers?
@@serwombles8816 yes, that did include the aircraft carriers. Again, only if you take the standard displacement of the escort carriers, and compare it to a full displacement Yamato.
Taffy 3. The definition of “full send”
CDR (Big Chief) Evans is a legend. His fingers were blown off his left hand on that bridge strike yet he continued relentlessly with his amazing Naval actions. No retreat. Native American badass. R.I.P. to all our hero sailors.
Not only that his clothing was blown off his body! He was barking orders down the rear hatch in his birthday suit!!
@@yankees29 🐐
@@advanceromance2656 I bought one of the Johnston paintings. It’s proudly displayed in my den as a reminder.
The Book “Last stand of the tin can sailors” depicts this battle in great detail and is worth the read
They really should turn that into a movie.
Nice work. This could be expanded somewhat with some commentary on USS Heerman, USS Hoel, USS Dennis, the sinking of USS Gambier Bay, the gunfire from the escort carriers, and their air attacks that helped to sink IJN Suzuya, Chikuma, and Chokai, and damaged others.
The 5 inch gun on the Jeep Carriers really get underplayed in most retelling of this story, that the Japanese were aiming at the "Fleet Carriers" while the DD's and DE's were more or less ingored, and since the Japanese had mis-identified all of Taffy 3, their Rangefinders were amiss as well for most of the battle as the ships were much smaller, so were thought to be bigger ships, but further away thanks to the lack of radar. Also, that Taffy 3 was the only ships engaged by center force, but the other Taffy Units were launching their aircraft as well, with whatever thay had onboard. Even if Kurita had correctly guessed what force was in front of him, the depth of the Escort Carriers, and the Advancing Battleships from the south meant it was always going to be a loss for Japan.
Yes, very true. You said you wanted to do another battle. But maybe you should FINISH this one first. There are a lot of stuff that happened that you left out. AND I DO MEAN A LOT.
There were plenty of heroic actions during WW2, but the history of this battle never fails to choke me up with pride and amazement. What a crazy bunch of SOBs!
They were far from crazy. They knew exactly what they were doing and the sacrifice they needed to make to protect the troops on the ground.
Those kids on Johnston shot almost every shell on board. They went down shooting.
Great stuff and excellent timing with the recent discovery of the Sammy B
Well done, sir. My father fought on Guadalcanal. He told of witnessing a night battle at sea. All they could see was the light from the ship's guns, and of course, they heard the impacts. There was no way for the grunts to know who was "winning," but they were told over Spam and mashed potatoes we had won, but we had to keep fighting.
These types of battles are why I was infatuated with the Navy as a kid. Tested and did all the paperwork at 16. At 17 I brought the recruiter home to have my parents sign the paperwork. Right after HS graduation, my journey began and ended 24 years later. Not as exciting as the video and other WWII battles...lol. No regrets here.
Well done, Chief! What was your rate?
GSE1 Newhall here. Six years Active, nearly thirty years Reservist.
My only "regret" ... that I didn't complete a full twenty years of active duty. But, then, I wouldn't have gotten to know all the great friends/shipmates I now have from the Reserves.
@@ELCADAROSA And a well done to you sir! I was an Aviation Support Equipment Technician (AS). Many of our guys, turbine NECs, transitioned over to the GS rating back in the late 80s for the better advancement opportunities. I can only imagine that they flooded the GS rate and advancement eventually slowed down for GSs. Cool rate, but too much sea time for my taste :).
@@usnchief1339, yes, the GS rating was ramping up quickly when I enlisted in ‘82. Made First Class in less than six years, but with the disestablishment of the reserve fleet during the late ’80s into the’90s, I was unable to advance; no billets available.
Thank you for your service sir!! 🫡
@@ELCADAROSA ASC (AW/SW) We had lots of our guys convert to GSE & GSM in the late 80s. Thank you for your service shipmate!
Really nicely animated. CDR Evans received the medal of honor for his actions that day. When I visit Memorial Hall at the US Naval Academy, I take special care to find his name.
This was a brilliant retelling of the Battle off Samar, I couldn’t believe to have found this channel with so little subs! I’m pumped to be apart of your journey from your beginning man, the quality is unreal and you’re only getting started. I’m really lookin forward to all the content that’s to come from you, I’m subscribed and sharing! God speed brother !
My favorite order quote from this battle, after the Johnston started her run, ordering the rest in: "Small Boys ATTACK!"
This was BRILLIANT. I just read "Last Stand of the Tin Can Soldiers" by James Hornfischer and this gave me a fantastic visual sense. THANK YOU and beautiful work, truly.
The Johnston was discovered a year ago, and the Roberts was discovered a week ago, 7 km deep
Now we need to find the Gambier Bay.
You did a great job in honoring the memory of these remarkable men. Thank you!
Wonderful little documentary thank you for making it and thank you for sharing it.
Well, thank you for your comment and thank you for watching it!
Many videos like this often left out one of the areas which the IJN lacks before and during the battle begins; morale, unlike the books.
Imagine being ambushed by submarines while you're on your way to one of the most important battles to stop the Americans from reaching your country. They didn't just sunk 2 heavy cruisers but including your task force's flagship (Atago) plus her sister ship (Maya) but also damaging another 2 heavy cruisers (Takao and Myoko).
Later in the day, one of your biggest ship, newest, and most capable battleship (Musashi) was sunk by overwhelming firepower brought by US carrier aircrafts that forced your task group to retreat and delay the battle by a day.
Then what if they also heard the almost complete annihilation of Nishumura's 'Southern Force' aside from Shigure? I'm sure that they will weap and lost their spirit even before they reached San Bernardino Strait. But it's a good thing that the IJN used strict radio silence so that they were unaware of Ozawa's success up north in luring Halsey together with his fleet carriers and fast battleships.
No doubt on Taffy 3 tho, they got huge balls to charge in knowingly that they will die in the process. Definitely, it's the US Navy's finest moment.
Well done and if you didn't get a good grade from this that teacher needs to be slapped into last week. You could also get a good grade in a history class with this.
Thank you! Your kind words flatter me! I did get a decent mark on my final for this 96/100, and it was only that low because I forgot to submit a self evaluation during the chaos of this project. I slept for 15 straight hours after finishing this project lol. Certainly was one of the most stressful timelines I’ve ever experienced.
This is really just like battle 360, hugely nostalgic!
Legend has it, the ships USS Samuel B. Roberts, Johnston, Hoel,and Heermann were the slowest in the fleet. On account the massive steel balls of their crews.
It was as if a dozen small dogs like Yorkies, Dachshunds, and Chihuahuas took on two dozen large dogs like Pitbulls, German Shepherds, and Rottweilers. And the little dogs attacking with overwhelming ferocity.
When Kumano was taken out, it was like a Chihuahua ripping out the throat of the Pitbull.
It's not always the size of the dog in the fight, but the fight in the dog.
Yamato is still one of the best looking ships till date. It's not just the size but the entire signature of the vessel.
The only things missing is an account of the aerial heroics and the sinking of the Gambier Bay.
I read in one book (I've read several accounts of the battle) that the Japanese thought that the spirited American defense meant that a major USN force was expected to arrive soon. The threat of a full battleship force coupled with current losses led to the Japanese withdrawal.
Drachinifel had a great video on this battle and represented the air forces well. The carriers, both escort and the oncoming reinforcements were landing, rearming, and re-launching ANY plane, regardless of their squadron. This constant harassing of angry hornets was no doubt a huge factor in why the Japanese thought they were dealing with something a lot larger. Their own doctrine would not have allowed for this kind of fast cycling of planes, instead holding them for wave attacks.
Gambier Bay took a pounding
Just came across this video, and boy oh boy, I do like it. Thanks for the great animations and calm narration, I also really appreciate the fact that you took the time to explain things like AP shells. Keep on the great work!!
The U.S. Navy won the day through pure courage, grit, and, unmatched fighting spirit!
Scared the piss out of them, they did. One Japanese cruiser came alongside the floating U.S. crew members and saluted them. They knew they had fought a courageous enemy that day.
If you haven't, I urge you to read the book..."The Last of the Tin Can Sailors". An amazing, detailed account of this battle. We owe so much to these brave men. Great Video!!
This was really well done, and I can definitely see the inspiration from Dogfights (one of my favorite shows ever)
Nice narration and production. Rwalky enjoyed that. Subbed.
I will watch the rest your videos 👍🏻
Why the USN does not have a ship named after Capt Evans is a mystery. He deserves that far more than the politicians that have ships named after them.
New Sub. Just found your channel. Awesome job with this video! Great job showing the size discrepancy between the destroyers and the larger Cruisers and Battleships.
This is by far the best video of this battle I have ever seen!
Very well done to you and what a hugely heroic and successful fight by those brave and skilled men!
Lest we forget!
Thank you for the kind words!
I believe history of all kinds is important, and if I can get others interested in history by making these animations then I consider it a success. I appreciate you watching! Take care!
Best line in this is that a single hit on the Johnston would destroy her. On her wreck they found that not only was she hit by 3 of them but that she kept fighting for another hour until she finally sank
The Sammy B's wreck was discovered a few days ago. Incedentally I watched a video about it just a few days before
WHY isn't this story a major movie? "Greyhound" was great, but this could be better!
Amusing story from this battle: the escort carriers launched all available aircraft to target the Japanese fleet. Many of them were only lightly armed, or not armed at all. When they ran out of bombs, they made strafing runs with their machineguns. When they ran out of ammunition, they made dry runs, with many of the pilots hurling trash and debris from the cockpits at the bewildered sailors below. One enterprising pilot drew his service revolver and emptied it into a battleship. It's doubtful he actually hit anything important, but imagine being the poor bastard who gets taken out in an aerial drive-by shooting.
It's important to contextualize Kurita's decision making in this battle and retreat. Center Force had already suffered heavy losses the previous day with two heavy cruisers sunk, one heavily damaged and sent back to port by submarine attack as well as the Super Battleship Musashi sunk by constant air attack with the rest of Center Force taking some damage as well. Kurita himself had to swim from his sinking flagship in the first attack to transfer his flag to Yamato. The Admiral and crews hadn't had time to rest, having been on high alert and station from the first attack until coming upon Taffy 3.
On top of the shell shock and fatigue, Kurita was utterly in the dark on the status of the Northern and Southern Forces, whether or not the Sho Plan was even still in effect or had worked in any capacity. So when he saw the silhouette of carriers and destroyers on the horizon, he made the logical assumption that this was the main enemy fleet that had savaged him the previous day with air strikes. He ordered a general attack to try and seize the initiative since he felt he would not have time to form a battle line, but in doing so dispersed his firepower and lost effective command control of the fleet.
Taffy 3 was well rested, its air groups while not equipped to deal significant damage to heavy surface ships, could still act like they could and repeatedly caused the already disorganized, demoralized and exhausted Japanese to make emergency evasive maneuvers from mock torpedo attacks. All of this coupled with the admirable bravery and exceptional seamanship of the sailors of Taffy 3 led to Kurita's retreat as he simply felt he'd taken too much damage and that what he might be able to do entering Leyte would not justify the complete annihilation of his force. He made the best decision he could with the information he had and the mental state he was in at the time, which was to save his remaining ships and men.
Even if Kurita had pushed through to Leyte, the transports had offloaded and the Americans had established positions on land with Halsey's fleet returning at full steam from the North and Oldendorf from the South would have trapped and annihilated the remnants of Kurita's Center Force with overwhelming numbers. All Kurita would achieve in exchange for his sacrifice would be the destruction of mostly empty transports, a single escort force and some minor damage at best to 7th Fleet. While the loss of supplies would certainly hurt the American invasion of the Philippines, it would in no way stop it as the ship losses could be made up in very short order.
Leyte Gulf realistically was unwinnable for the Japanese from even before its execution. Any hopes of the IJN being able to hold its own died in the Marianas earlier in the war. Lacking air cover and with its neglect of anti submarine warfare, the IJN sailed into certain destruction at Leyte.
Very well said. Far too many youtube videos portray the action off Samar as one of Japanese bumbling in the face of U.S. surface ship attacks.
"I fear we have Awakened a sleeping Giant and filled he with a Terrible Resolve."
Only Yamamoto knew what a mistake pushing the Americans would be. He lost when they didn't sink the Carriers with the Arizona and the rest of Battleship Row. But hindsight is 20/20.
I still think Yamamoto knew right Then, when the Carriers and their escorts weren't at Pearl, he knew it might cost them the war.
He as much as said so. THIS is what "Terrible Resolve" can do.
The Mice that ROARED!
Excellent work sir! Superb graphics. Keep up the good work.
Thank you! I plan to with my next project on the Hunt For the Bismarck
Halsey got away with a court-martial there.
Well made, keep up the good work!
Thank so much! You were a huge inspiration for me to take up 3D animation!
Great animation. Taffy 3 has special significance for me. A chemistry teacher at my high school had been in the Navy in WWII. I later learned he had been on Johnston in this action (LTJg Welch). He told a lot of sea stories to his class. They were all heroes in my book.
Honestly that was a really good story about the battle of Samar, one critique I’d give would be for when the ships superstructure are burning, don’t have that much fire as it looks unrealistic
Thank you for the advice! There are a lot of things about this project that I would change if I could. Namely, my audio isn't great in places, and the oceans glitch occasionally. With the way this project went, I had one full week to work on these animations plus one full day to edit it all together. The month kind of broke down like this:
- First three days of scripting, research, and storyboarding
- The following week was spent building the model of Samuel B Roberts from scratch. I looked for a 3D model of the ship and came up empty so I had to build it myself.
- 8 days to create the scenes and render them
- 1 day to edit the final documentary together, this took me 13 hours to edit together REEEEEE!
The TTLP is an inside joke with my animation teacher standing for "Took Too Long Productions" this project was no exception lol.
@@SwankySpitfire the fact it only took you a week to make all those animations is astonishing, one of my friends did a titanic real time sinking just using blender and it took him about 9 months to render the full 2 hours
@@dec_thesussy [Blink] [Blink] Nope. That's a hell nah from me. I don't think I'd have the resolve to create something like that. I'd probably give up after a few days. That, or I'd set the render time to like 15 seconds a frame and just brute force the thing through.
But man, 2 hours that's still a super long time. Assuming your friend rendered it out in the standard 24fps then that's
2h = 7200s
7200s x 24fps = 172,800 frames
Lets assume that your friend spent 5 minutes per frame
172,800 x 5min = 864,000 minutes/frame
864,000 minutes = 14,400 hours = 600 days = 19.7 months.
If you cut that down to say a minute per frame then the number comes down to 120 days of rendering. Yikes, I think the longest shot in this entire series was the Johnston opening fire. I set a 5 minute time limit on that shot and that took 2 straight days of rendering to complete 300 frames.
@@SwankySpitfire I mean the shot paid off in the end so the 2 days was worth it and is much better than what a 5 minute shot would’ve looked like
@@dec_thesussy thanks! Spending two days rendering out a single shot when you only have 8 days total to complete the project isn’t advisable but I definitely got my use out of it.
I don't know if anyone mentioned this,but the use of Dogfights' animation and music is pretty good,even if the video itself is full of certain flaws and a lot of reused footage of the same attack animations.
Man this is good animation. Well done
Nice History Channel music add-on. Good touch.
Is it just me or has anyone else wondered how the USS Johnston stayed afloat with the weight of Capt. Evan's massive balls? One of those mysteries that can never be solved.
First off Congratulations on using the Correct Name of the Battle ...
The story and animation was very good.
This was just part of a much larger battle but I can understand if you didn't want to animate all that.
This was sick. Thank you for making this.
Thank you for watching!
@@SwankySpitfire You definitely earned my sub, I'll be waiting for the Hunt for the Bismarck ;)
@@weisshxc thank you! Part 1 should be coming out soon!
I never thought seeing a Fletcher-class destroyer with QF 2-pounder AA gun mounts looked so blurse
I love how this is made with the style of _Dogfights_
Nice work 👍
Thanks man! I greatly appreciate it! It was that show that got me into naval history in the first place with their hunt for the Bismarck special.
If you have the capability to model the British Swordfish torpedo bomber, my vote is for the sinking of the Bismarck. One suggestion I have, reduce the volume of the background music when you are narrating the action.
USS Johnston and USS Samuel Roberts crew have the biggest balls in navy history.
This battle is why I enlisted in the Navy
You left out the major roll our aircraft played and the loss of a carrier. The TBMs and F4Fs used all of their ammo and bombs and then made dry runs to draw fire away from the destroyers and destroyer escorts. Give credit where credit is due!
He missed a number of things tbh. Good animation but he missed a good portion
a LOT is missing from this, which isn't surprising honestly given that it's 10 minutes long.
Our aircraft- and not our surface ships- were the primary cause of the loss of all of the Japanese warships sunk off Samar.
The USS Johnston is a credit to the US Navy. Mostly because that ship was taken with the spirit of the infantry, just on water.
I openly invite both naval and army forces alike to debate this, it’s this competition between us that keeps us the best
The actions of the escorts was a historic moment for the US navy. Bravery of astounting example. However, during all of there action, the Japanese fleet was under relentless attack by hundreds of CVE aircraft from the three taffy fleets in the area. The Japanese ships were forced to manuever out of formation regularly slowing there advance and throwing off the targeting solutions for big guns. It was the schwarming aircraft that ground down and finally turned the decision. The Japanese also suffered many losses following this encounter during the withdrawal from the engagement.
I noticed no mention of the aircraft launched by the carriers of Taffy 3 and others that contributed to the damage done to the Center Force. Even Halsey got planes into the air, late but the effort was made.
You’re absolutely correct, during my initial scripting I essentially created a 30 minute lecture about the battle. I had intended to include the aircraft stories about fighter pilots armed with .50 caliber machine guns, and sometimes nothing at all threw their aircraft at the enemy ships in a desperate attempt to discourage and intimidate the Japanese vessels. It’s why I mentioned during the laying of the smokescreen “the commander of taffy three orders the carriers to retreat to the east and launch all available aircraft”.
Unfortunately, with only two weeks to animate this a lot of things had to be cut out including all of the plane scenes. A whole bunch of ship stuff and finer details were omitted for the sake of storytelling.
Trying to strike a balance is hard, I could go into every single minute detail and controversies about the battle, but then it wouldn’t be a story, it would be a lecture. Instead I elected to leave out stuff that did any of the following:
- anything I didn’t have any footage for
- confused a general audience member who is not a history fan
- subtracted from the flow of the story and made it difficult to follow
- required too much explaining for relatively little addition to the story
Examples of planned material that was cut for the reasons above include:
- the courageous acts of the American pilots flying ill-equipped aircraft against a massive enemy force
- there’s debate over whether or not the torpedoes launched by the Japanese towards Johnston missed or if they were running too low. I’ve heard two sources claim two different things. I left this out because torpedo running depth would be confusing to an average joe and it’s simpler to say “the torpedoes miss their mark” while still remaining truthful.
- I had a comparison between the Johnston and the Kumamo, as well as Roberts and Chickuma. However, the comparisons interrupted a really good flow, and so I decided to cut them. They added little and subtracted from the momentum building up to those points. Therefore I cut them.
- due to the lack of gunnery radar the Japanese used dye in their shells to see the fall of shot, with the exception of Yamato. An interesting fact, but it takes a while to explain and doesn’t matter too much story wise. Therefore I cut it as well. This bit in particular hurt my heart to cut. The story about how Roberts commander ordered all safety mechanisms on the engine overridden, and drove Roberts from a top speed of 24 knots (designed) to 29 knots in reality. A super interesting fact but again, to an average joe 24kts vs 29kts doesn’t mean a thing. So I cut it out because it takes a while to explain, adds very little to final product and would significantly hurt the flow of the video.
Anyways, that’s the reason a lot of fine details are missing, and why I left out the pilots of Taffy 3. I didn’t have enough time, and I was mainly focussing on the surface vessels in this project.
While the planes definitely rattled the Japanese the end result of their bravery was more like a riot than a military action.
@@SwankySpitfire
Cutting out the American air attacks really can’t be excused. THEY WERE THE REASON THE AMERICANS WON THIS BATTLE.
@@SwankySpitfire The Japanese used radar- assisted gunnery off Samar. Yamato's first- salvo hit on Gambier Bay at just under 22,000 yards was aimed soley by the ship's Type 22 radar because Yamato lacked a visual to Gambier Bay until approximately one minute after opening fire.
The destroyesr counter attack at massive japaness fleet just give me a goosbump
Would have been cool if u could have animated the air portion of that battle. It was super cool as well
At 3:08 U.S.S. Johnston was hit by three first- salvo 18" rounds (at just over 20,000 yards) from Yamato without being destroyed- although the ship took very heavy damage.
Noticed the Dogfights soundtrack. Nice!
Nice job guys
Well done.
Great work
Good job!
Can we all appreciate that he’s using the soundtrack from dogfights?
Well done
Thanks! I appreciate it!
“It is my earnest hope and indeed the hope of all mankind that from this
solemn occasion a better world shall emerge out of the blood and carnage of the
past - a world founded upon faith and understanding - a world dedicated to the
dignity of man and the fulfillment of his most cherished wish - for freedom,
tolerance and justice.”
Douglas MacArthur
NEVER Underestimate The
RESOLVE Of The U.S Military,
We Have ALWAY'S Been Tested Time & Time Agin & We ALWAY'S Come Out On Top, Time & Time Agin...
Ship models: World of Warships.
Background music: Battle 360 ....
great video !
DDG-141, a Flight III Arleigh Burke class destroyer will be named USS Ernest E. Evans, the second ship of the US Navy to bear his name.
Well done! My father was in the Navy, I was an Army officer.
ive always wanted to do this nice work
I rather enjoyed this video regarding the battle off samar. Well done. Music is very familiar. Is it from a combo of places like WOW, History Channel battle 360 and History Channel Dogfights?
Good work, particularly on the animations, which presumably was the main point. The voice quality was off in some parts, hopefully you can get a fix for that.
Nice work!
Thank you! I greatly appreciate it!
Tenacious. Sometimes you don't need to "win", you just need to convince the opponent that it's just not worth it. Like a bunch of bears stumbling on a thicket full of badgers, weasels, and hornets - just too much of a pain in the @$$ to deal with! Taffy 3 is like the "Honey Badger" of WWII! "Taffy 3 Don't Care". hehe
How does this only have 28k views?
Magnifique, une belle homage a ces marins
Man, i feel sorry for Yamato. She was build to devastate her enemy, yet she was denied her only chance to go down in History, as the super battleship that wiped out an entire enemy Task Force. Kurita was the worst Japanese Admiral.
Great narration. Narrator sounds like the guy from Battle 360 & Dogfights
Amazing
awesome
New sub, best wishes to you with it all here 👍 ☘️
It's not clear to me why an active volcano is depicted at 0:25 and then buzzed by a warplane shortly thereafter. Although vulcanism is an established fact in this part of the world, I am not aware of any account of this famous battle citing an active eruption nearby. I would edit it out.
---
Nonetheless, I commend you for releasing this concurrently with the archeological discovery of the "Sammy B" in deep water, preceded by the location of the Johnston just a year ago. Long may their great torpedo work, their feisty 5" gunnery, and their sacrifice be an example in the US Navy.
I swear, the Japanese Navy was run by knuckle heads.
New sub earned. I love naval shit!
Thank you so much! I have quite few requests to cover the Hunt For the Bismarck so it appears like that will be my next project. Hoping to put that video out around end of July, early August!
Would you like to see small clips of progress during this time?
Best vid so far. Here is your comment for the algorithm.
Much obliged commander!
Very informative 👏
Is there any dauntless on carrier escort to support the destroyers
USS Samuel Roberts wreck was found off the coast of Samar here in the Philippines just few weeks ago
Fire control - the difference between victory or defeat