Well Twilight still had Cadence, because she's an alicorn too. And even if Cadence passed, Flurry Heart would be the new alicorn of the Crystal Empire so at least Twilight had some family
@@ToonTimeEUA What happened to the mirror portal the human (Equestria Girls) world and sunset shimmer and her friends after g4 ended and before g5 began?
@@KristinaDepietro This question is a bit hard because The Sirens were sent there 1000 years ago and it seems like they didn't age, maybe they didn't age aswell
@ToonTimeEUA 🙂 it's all right. I'm always there for you. Friends👩❤️👨 stay friends👩❤️👨 to the end. Happy😊 Firework🎆 Independence🇺🇲 Day, My Little Pony🦄 fans, and God♂️ bless🙏 us, Everybody! ✴️ 🌟💫⭐️, 🌠🦸♀️🌌, 🎼🎺🎵, 🥳🎊🎆!
@KristinaDepietro 🙂 i like the magical, colorful🏳️🌈 Portal Tunnel (between the Pony🦄 World🌎 of Equestria Land🏞🇺🇲 and the Human👩 World🌎 of Canterlot High School🏫🏙🇺🇲) with the Sailor⛵️ Moon♀️🦸♀️(😇)[🎀🟢, 🦱🟡, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🎀🔴, 👗⚪️⚪️⚪️🔵🔵🔵, 👢⚪️🔴🔴🔴⚪️](🌕)❤️🤍💙 transformation music🎶 of the "Moon🌕 Prism💠 Power🌠 - Chilbiusa♀️🦸♀️(😇)[🎀🔵, 🦱🩷💖🩷💖🩷💖🩷, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🎀🔴, 👗⚪️⚪️⚪️💖💖💖, 👢⚪️💖⚪️](💞)❤️🤍💖's Transformation" 0:41 video🎦
I like the idea of Twilight sacrificing herself. If that was the case, then (assuming all this went down while the Mane 6 were still alive) it would hold true to Faust's word that "Twilight will not outlive her friends". It would also be wholesome and emotional. Sadly the way G5 has gone so far, I don't expect them to be that creative.
You know ....if Faust's word holds true.....that would mean that Twilight is dead in G5 alongside the mane 6 since it's already been confirmed that Fluttershy is dead in the G5 comics.
@@launacyko4523I figured it was obvious they were dead in G5 Without Faust's word. Considering Equestris is now known as Ancient Equestria and especially the Mane Six could live that long. And clearly Twilight used her magic to separate... Magic and I think that's why she died, her immortality was lost when she made the crystals and she died alongside her friends.
@dragonseer2251 🥺 the G4 human👩/pony Friendship👩❤️👨 Gang's death is a terrible tragedy💔. It's also a sad🥺, deep, passing loss with a sad🥺 heart❤️ that glows blue🔵 with tick-tocking⏰️ vibration📳
I feel like G5 is more of a G4 AU of sorts, because a number of things conflict with what we already know from G4, like the idea that G5 Celestia and Luna were born as Alicorns when in G4 they didn’t even believe that to be possible until Flurry Heart was born and all previous media stating that they ascended to Alicornhood, Spike’s entire form changing for no discernible reason, G5 Discord suddenly ageing despite being immortal in G4, etc. It feels like more of a “what if” AU scenario, so I feel like the G4 Twilight that we know probably didn’t encounter any Opaline because, by the rules of that universe, Opaline wouldn’t exist. Opaline can only exist if you alter Celestia and Luna’s backstories.
G5 definitely ruined everything that my little pony is and was. It not only has a very disappointing style to it, but the story of all pony nations splitting up after seemingly twilights happy life in the end of g4 is so contradicting! It sucks! I don’t understand why g5 had to exist. It only just adds confusion to the story of mlp
The animation felt so lifeless, everything seemed like plastic and I can’t feel any charm, unlike the old show it had that strange charm to it. Like genuine heart and love was put into it
@@Insertthestrangerit also has something to do with the animation style as well and I wish it was still the old style or mabye the one in the movie which was a slightly better animation style
Yeah like the whole thing about an Alicorn kingdom, and that Celestia, Luna, and Opaline originally lived there and were BORN as Alicorns. Since that contradicts what Celestia and Luna said when Flurry Heart was born, she was the FIRST Alicorn to ever be born. And if those two said that, there is NO Alicorn Kingdom. Oh and Twilight disabling Magic, her very talent and a part of the elements and her whole friendship LESSON. That sounds more like something Tirek or Cozy Glow would do. But the real kicker was the reason she did this was because... A Unicorn hurt an Earth Pony... Like that never happened before in Equestria. Now if it was "A threat that required magic to be disabled", THAT would have been better writing. Then we could have had a warning message come about saying "What have you done!!! You doomed us all!" In my opinion Opaline should have been born an Alicorn, but been born AFTER FlurryHeart. I mean she doesn't even look like Celestia, Luna, Cadence, OR Twilight when she became a full Adult. And Opaline was supposed to be around the same age as the two sisters? I think NOT. Then with her being born an Alicorn, they could have revealed the reason she viewed herself as queen was because her parents spoiled her rotten, calling her their princess. And that after they died, her mind just SNAPPED. Ironically enough they could have died in a fire, hence her fire obsession. Either that or she was the kid of a Pony and a Dragon, since we did see a dragon asking a pony out with a flower during the G4 finale's song. Oh and dragons.... Yeah they were done dirty. 1. Spike would not have been their leader, if anything he would have been living in a Pony city or town in secret, maybe the crystal empire where he would have been viewed as a hero even after all those years. Possibly with a beard, showcasing he can use magic with his claws. *Basically a Starswirl inspired sage character* 2. Dragons wouldn't have cutie marks or pony traits.
It’s OK she put all of her Alcorn magic in the crystal so that means she wouldn’t be able to live for long just like Lauren Faust said that twilight will not outlive her friends
It was inevitable. The way Equestria worked as a state shown in G4, other Mane 6 members mortality, the Wendigos killed in Season 9 final battle and many other things. Even without Opaline, Equestria was doomed to fall and honestly I'm surprised G5 was brave enouth to tell that right in the face.
I like to think Twilight lived on in the Unity crystals, and is now in control of all magic. Yes, she may be very slightly insane after being trapped alone for however long it took for the crystals to be reunited. It explains why they can be so violent at times!
Yeah, and i have my own theory on she countered it. Made her student Luster Dawn her successor, gave up her immortality and aged rapidly to catch up with them. Personally I consider G5 an Au.
Personally I think she was planning to make Luster Dawn her successor to give up her immortality which in my opinion was from Celestia and Lunas power over the sun and moon which was CONFIRMED by the writers to have been given to Twilight when they fused their crowns. One source says that raising those rejuvenated the sisters which is what gave me that idea. As for G5 I don't consider that canon to G4 as it contradicts Twilights final form. Alternate universe to me. But hey we all have opinions.
@samdickenson5852 🥺 But, G4, good😇-heart❤️, human👩/unicorn🦄 Luster Dawn♀️(👨🌾🚰🌼)[🎀🔴, 🦱🟠🟡🟠🟡🟠🟡🟠, 👁🟡, 👄🔴, 👗🟣🟢🟢🟢🟣](🌅💫 + 🌅🟠🟡⚪️🟡⚪️🟡, 💫🟢⚪️🟢)🤍🩷🩷🩷 (Goodness😇), you can't give up⬆️. Everybody needs friends👩❤️👨, even you. You need friends👩❤️👨 to protect you from evil😈 forces
The alicorns are immortal beings who can be considered demi-goddesses on whom time itself has no noticeable effect, we have seen that Luna and Twilight are rejuvenated when these were exposed to special magical conditions. But we also know that these alicorns age very slowly. Opaline was able to survive without magic because she had her internal alicorn powers when she should have died of old age. We know little about the alicorns, but all told their powers are not due to their originality as a race, but to the mysterious magic that all ponies share. We also know that when ponies die, it happens that these are "marked" in the sky as seen with Sunny's mother, and that there is a heaven, Elysion, for the dead ponies. G5 showed us that there is a "life" after death because ghosts and dead spirits were seen. Fluttershy was perhaps the best example from the Discord arc in the IDW comics, she "returned" as a transparent and luminous butterfly. It is likely where all normal ponies ended up after their death, so these are not completely gone forever. But it's open to question what Elysion, the mysterious dimension where alicorns come into being and the vacuum that almost swallowed Maretime Bay in G5, is. All indications are that Twilight was alone when she confronted Opaline for the last time. Spike had a pained expression on his face when Sunny mentioned this - which could indicate that Twilight had to pay a high price without Opaline being taken into custody. Probably all friends except for Spike, Discord and the other alicorns were dead when Opaline lost her magic. Twilight had probably lived a long time - possibly for many centuries - but in the end she disappeared. Sooner or later the alicorns had to leave the world of mortals, and her turn may have come. It is possible that she may have gone to Skyros, but that seems unlikely. Spike had used the past tense when talking about Twilight, but it seems he meant she's gone. Just gone. As if she can never return. There are many small signs that suggest that Twilight had ascended to the starry sky because the three crystals fell to the ground from the sky, believing that she had fulfilled her destiny predicted by her cutie mark - becoming a star. Wishing Star. And she may not have been alone, because Celestia and Luna may have fused with the Sun and Moon when they ascended. But she is not completely gone. She had likely predicted her successor, Sunny Starscout, ten generations before G5. And it is possible that she could be the mysterious intelligence in the Unity Crystals who has an active role both as a friend and as a manipulator. Because if she has become the Wishing Star, there is still something missing. The five companion stars - her friends. So if the Wishing Star gets the five companion stars sometime in the future, it could mark Twilight Sparkle's end. Because then she has joined her friends in Elysion.
I like to think of G5 as a terrible fever dream of Twilight's where an unholy terror of a villain used awful magic to take over the world from the great fausticorn so it could exploit it and that Twilight will wake up, find out she's actually Celestia's secret daughter and spend several months with her friends and aunt Luna learning to wield powerful alicorn magic and get used to her new alicorn body whilst fending off outside threats from distant lands and old enemies in some kind of epic fantasy anime.
There are so many things that dont make sense and the more the writers try to use g4 or fix plot holes the more they make. This whole show is another au and thats it! Its like dragon ball gt where its another universe and lets keep it at that. G4 had a freaking happy ending and basta!
G4 was just fine until G5 screwed everything over. It has ended on a decent note. But now, with G5 happening, the feels are all there, but for the wrong reasons.
Wasn’t the backstory of the unity crystals from the comics retconned? In the comics it’s said that Twilight created it to prevent the three Pony races from using magic against each other. Meanwhile in the show its purpose was changed to Twilight creating the unity crystals inorder to hide the magic from Opaline, who wanted to steal all the magic for herself. Also the creators for FIM have confirmed that. Twilight won’t outlive her friends It’s also possible that Opaline wasn’t entirely responsible for the Pony kinds separating, since Spike seemed genuinely surprised to hear that the three pony races had separated during his absence. The hard truth may be that the three tribes separated on their own merits. This would be sad but realistic.
Either Twilight extended her friends' lives or she dies sacrificing herself because unless Alicorns just have normal life spans there's no way she wouldn't outlive her friends.
First things first. When i saw the last episode of FIM, I felt a little betrayed. Since the writers had promised the fans that they wouldn't make Twilight immortal after she became a princess (at the end of season 3). Then Twilight appeared as a Celestia 2.0 and didn't show any signs of aging well the other main six members had beginning wrinkles and Rarity even some grey highlights. Second: I still refuse to say that G5 is taking place in the exact same universe as G4. Third: I kind of felt confused in both the G4 finaly and the G5 premiere movie: How is it so easy to set up the races against each other again? They have been interbreeding with each other for generations
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony. But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me. Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
They would just have mlp ended. My little pony friendship is magic was a legendary masterpiece and it's already enough that it existed. It will forever be in its prime among fans
Well theories we have is twilight is still alive and is now living with celestia and luna some place in alicorn land or Opaline killed twilight either way twilight just disappeared
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony. But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me. Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
You're telling me that after everything, EVERYTHING, they listened to an unknown newbie alicorn over Twilight Sparkle?!?!?!?!?!?! Nah, it's official, *G5 is a grim alternate future.*
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony. But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me. Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
The fact that they made G4 a waste of time just so this generation could have a conflict and try to gain brownie points from G4 fans is nothing short of insulting. I loved A New Generation and was really excited to see what they had in store, only to be met with insane disappointment. The people who defend G5 saying Twilight’s reign wasn’t worthless are nothing but liars.
I didn’t get into G5, but I would say that just because things went wrong doesn’t make Twilight’s reign worthless. I hate this trend that says just because things go wrong means the good is somehow pointless. Twilight either is dead or in stasis somewhere.
@@PeachWookiee literally everything Twilight did, mainly spreading friendship amongst everyone, was all reversed all because a pony cut in line. I could buy Equestria eventually falling apart after Twilight steps down, but the fact that it fell apart when she and her friends were still around all because a pony said a few racist things would be like a white person calling every black person the n word and instead of that person getting beaten up for being a jerk, it convinced everyone in America to start a race war. Not to mention Twilight’s solution to the problem was making an item that if ponies started arguing, it would make magic disappear. Even though Equestria literally needs magic to function. This also means that dozens of Pegasi must’ve fallen to their deaths once magic disappeared. Twilight could’ve just encouraged people to get along, especially since this conflict literally happened in the season nine finale on top of many other problems going on, but I guess some racism in Ponyville was enough to make Twilight basically give up as this decision basically lead to Equestria’s downfall.
If they had only set G5 a thousand years after Twilight’s reign then I wouldn’t have a problem with it. 1,000 years was long enough for ponies to forget that Princess Luna existed so it’s much more realistic and less insulting for things to go back to the way they were before the founding of Equestria if a long period of time has passed. It would have made it all the more interesting to see ponies rediscover all the things that happened in the past.
@@alyssakays367 exactly. But they decided to make it only five generations after G4 (by Elder Flower mentioning her great great aunt was Moondancer) because why meaningfully connect things when you can just use fan service to? 🤦🏻♀️
I have a similar theory, but she did it while alive and aged quickly to catch up to them. Made her student Luster her successor. G5 not canon to G4 for me.
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony. But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me. Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
My theory is that since Twilight got her alicorn form from her bond with her friends she probably lost it when her friends died, reverted to being an ordinary unicorn and died of old age herself.
It's true, One can only imagine how painful it must've been for Twilight to slowly watch all of her friends and family grow old and one by one pass away. Although Twilight would still have Cadence and Flurry Heart sure they would be the only family Twilight has left, But it would still be better than her being all alone. As for Twilight's friends. They may be gone and it may seem like Twilight wouldn't be able to go on without them, But deep down Twilight knows that her friends wouldn't want her to spend the rest of her life just grieving over them, The other members of the Mane 6 would've wanted Twilight to continue living on and make more friends. But no group of friends could ever have meant more to Twilight than her original group of friends, Nor could any new friends ever take their place in Twilight's heart. And I'm sure Twilight also knows that her friends will always be with her, Not by her side but in her heart. I mean after all Twilight has so many wonderful memories of them and as long as Twilight hold onto and cherishes those memories she'll never truly feel all alone.
Well, yeah. I guess it does make sense for now. We know that the G5 Writers or Hasbro Themselves hasn't gave us an official answer about if Twilight Sparkle is still Alive somewhere in G5 or not. I know Sunny's Mother and Father Argyle did used to tell her Stories about Twilight and how the Magic disappeared from Equestria. I guess we'll wait and see if we do get an official answer from the G5 Writers or Hasbro Themselves about if Twilight Sparkle is Still Alive somewhere or not in the future of Tell Your Tale Season 2. I do want her to come back. Maybe she went to Skyros or some place else. But I doubt that.
@@ToonTimeEUA yeah. Let's wait and see about that after Sunny Starscout and her Friends finds the Skyros Location in Tell Your Tale Season 2 Later down the line.
I think Twilight Sparkle went to luve near the ocean luke her name sake. Another name for evening is Twilight right? So west where the sun sets. That's just what i have to say and think. Maybe a feeling.
People have honestly got multiple ideas about how Twilight would handle the loss of her five closest friends, barring the G5 MLP’s story. One is that she is a cold ruler who mourns the loss of her friends. Another is a depressive state that makes her abandon her role as a princess and disappear. And the next one is a very dark one where Twilight snaps when she loses them all. She decides that she will turn other ponies into her friends by conditioning them until they believe that they are truly Twilight’s friends.
I personally think g5 is doing it all wrong, as a big Stan of g4 I just think g4 shouldn't have gone the way it did. I was thinking they should bring twilight back, not in a ghost or spirit form. More of a physical form, since twilight is an Alison she could've just possibly lived to watch all of these things happen. Luna and celestia lived to be almost more then 1000 Years old so I can imagine twilight pretty much lived 2000 *atleast* . Sunny and her friends could've gotten lost or thought everything was over at one point, possibly get lost or trapped in a cave by opaline almost like cadence was by crystalis. And then while looking for a way out they find a mysterious tunnel or door where they find twilight. Wether twilight trapped herself down their on purpose or she was banished. I also don't think she was shrunk down when she created the three pieces, perhaps she just lost power. Maybe that's why she hid, because she was afraid of giving opaline more power by being enslaved. Perhaps twilight was planning to overthrow opaline!? Or maybe was watching sunny do it to see if she could rest. Maybe twilight casted a spell to keep her friends alive in her place, so she died instead of her friends?? Dang I never thought I'd be so invested in a show about magical ponies- Also, I haven't rlly watched much of the new generation. I think the style of it is kinda... ugly. No offense to the artists I just don't like how fuzzy and 3d they look. So I don't know much abt opaline or sunny and her friends. I quite literally only watched the movie which gave me some explanation
Is it just me, or ponies other than the groups of six have trust issues (Everyone go all sad about the outliving thing and i don't like it, or i'm missing something important)
This is why I think that all main 6 characters should became ALL princesses as well and not only Twilight Like AppleJack would be princess of honesty, Rarity princess of generosity, PinkiePie princess of laughter, RainbowDash princess of loyalty and Fluttershy princess of kindness
"your friendship school was useless twilight" ahhaahah like bruh i know right like you dedicate a whole season resolving around a magic school and then this ahahahhah
And then, Canterlot High became part of the United Federation Of Planets. By the time Twilight goes back to CHS, there would be Starfleet officers patrolling around the school. And the students would look more alien-like. Heck, I would imagine Vulcans at Sunset's deathbed, since humanity made first contact with the Vulcans in 2063.😊 Twilight: Hey, girl in a yellow and black uniform, do you know where Sunset Shimmer is? Starfleet officer: Sunset passed away 300 years ago.
@captainbeckyrayshoichetuss6418 🙂 i like the good😇-heart💜, G4, human👩/unicorn🦄 Sunset🌄 Shimmer♀️(🦸♀️🤚💭)[🎀🟢, 🦱🔴🟡🔴🟡🔴🟡🔴, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🧥🟠⚫️⚫️⚫️🟠, 👗🟡🟢🟢🟢🟡](☀️☯️ + ☀️🟡🔴, ☯️🟡🔴)🤍💛💛💛 better. She's the good😇-heart❤️ Spirit🌟 of the Element💎 of Redemptions😇/Forgiveness🥺🥹😇
@@Third7Plays "watching everyone you knew pass away" - just like in mortal life, only every year it becomes more and more difficult for mortals to experience physical and emotional shocks
I barely see videos or photos in videos of Sunset Shimmer anymore! We. Need. More. SUNSET! It's sad how Netflix doesn't show all 9 seasons of MLP! I hate how it only show the first season then it show MLP Make Your Mark like yea I wanna see it but not before I see the 9 seasons of the first MLP series!!!!!! Bro Netflix needs to up their game I swear! Who agrees (not for likes I wanna see who agrees)👇🏽
It's canon that alternate timelines exist. *points to episodes where time travel and junk was mentioned*. So I tend to see G5 as an alternate timeline world. I also tend to view Opaline as a very unreliable narrator on some things... she can't stand to think of herself as having a form where she wasn't an alicorn, so she deluded herself into thinking she was ALWAYS an alicorn, she was just born naturally fabulous... and so were Luna and Celestia. She is the victor rewriting history to suit her own needs.... because god forbid that somebody find out that she was just a unicorn... or worse, a earth pony!
It's just another lesson of friendship. Even if Twilight wasn't an alicorn there's no guarantee she won't have to look her friends die. "Grief is the price we pay for love" There's no fairytale "they all died in the same day" thing (unless it's an airplane catastrophe or something). It's just a cruel reality of life. It's also a fact that friends can change and no longer be the person you once knew.
While I'm a big G4 supporter because it's literally my childhood, all things must come to an end eventually. Now we just see what happens for G5 which I believe is doing a good job.
1. I think she created the crystals and then she lost her wings (they disappeared )because she used so magic making them.I know this because in the message,she is a unicorn.Shouldn’t she be a tall alicorn? And she probably knows how old dragons live so she thinks spike is alive. I also think that Twilight and her friends did and/or casted something to possibly: A.Make them Immortal. B.Made them look like different ponies. C.Not be noticed in public. D.Protect equestria From threats with a barrier or something like that. Any and/or multiple of these might have happened. G5 Ponies don’t know the Mane six’ names,and call them The Guardians of Harmony,probably to be a reference to the Elements of Harmony.
@@Lunatheroleplay Well you think what you want but the bottom line is it acted like a recording from what I saw and didn't interact with Sunny and the others freely so its basically proven to me.
Curse my Curiosity, this is so sad, knowing that the story since gen 4 turned into an amalgamation of abandonment and torment. Gen 5 is not my cup of tea, and gen 6 just doesn't sit right with me, since the whole CGI thing. I just wanna watch gen 4 knowing that everything is ok, they are all alive, and Twilight's reign created peace for years. I'm happy you made this video explaining what happened after gen 4. Just not the decision that the writers made to turn this into a tragic story, behind the colorful scenery, characters and joyful expression, all this turned into was a tragic story.
“Upon the day when fluttershy passed on, her closest friends and family mourned her loss. As the years went by, the remnants of the mane six would visit her grave sight to reminisce on their many adventures together. Eventually, princess twilight became the last remaining member of the mane six who would see where her best friends were laid to rest and remember them. Though legend goes that a mysterious figure, Discord, would visit the site of his friends and leave a special gift upon their graves.” Fade to black, exit stage left, cue the applause from the audience.
Twilight saw Spike as a little brother? Hey everyone remember the first episode of mlp? Where we meet spike after Twilight slams a door into his face, a break hes gift? Oh yes good sibling memories, or whenever twilight use him as a mail? “ spike can you send this?” Whenever she send letters to anyone. Good memories 🤣🦊🦊🤣🤣
Something to note about Discord, something a lot of people seem to overlook. In the comics, what stopped Discord was seeing the message Fluttershy made for him, so either Fluttershy forgot about it and went back to having tea parties with him, or they never saw each other again.
I say she gave up her immortality and made Luster Dawn her successor to die with her friends, refusing to outlive them. G5 is not canon to G4 in my mind.
If only I make them come to life If just make believe if MLP G4 & G5 were here, I'm sure they'll understand me and we can make the fans feel special together by putting on a show performance!
4:58 with pleasure. Discord is my favorite FiM character...and to think that he had, too, to deal with the sorrow of losing someone so precious to him...
@@ToonTimeEUA I look forward to them. Also I just figured Twilight would eventually give up ruler of Equestria to her student, but I always had a feeling she would outlive the others
I just kind of dismiss everything in G5. I refuse to even consider any of it as canon. I despise what G5 has done. It might have worked if they had made it a new story and didn't try to make it a follow-up of G4.
I still think that G5 takes place about 1500 years after the last G4 episode. The rise & fall of Twilight Sparkle, her successor Luster Dawn, the fall of Luster Dawn & the division between the ponies, unicorns & alicorns & then fallout between the yaks & other species, the fall of G4 & rise of a more technological civilization that leads up to G5.
The whole point of each generation was to reboot the show but keep existing characters. So why tf did they think making G5 a continuation of the previous gen would work?
My theory is that Twilight had to give up her wings and immortality, maybe in the creation of the crystals. This is based mostly from the comment the show creator's made when they said word for word, "Twilight will not outlive her friends"
My theory is g5 is an au cause of the inconsistency with Twilight's form of regular alicorn vs big alicorn. In my headcanon for the true G4, Twilight made her student Luster her successor and gave up her immortality somehow. I personally believe its the power of the sun and moon that were the source of immortality rather than being an alicorn, one book said raising the sun and moon rejuvenated the sisters, and Celestia said they were leaving those in her hooves.
I’m new to mlp really & haven’t see much of the show compared to a lot of ppl but it seems to me like Twilights friendship effect could’ve had more of an impact, like not turning everyone into an alicorn but having say Fluttershy become immortal thanks to Discords friendship, or having the elements of friendship be almost immortalizing would make sense, all of them are supposed to be very powerful like the pillars from times past, being sealed away or resurrected would be a fun way to throw back to g4 from g5
As the baby gets older she getting annoyed of twilight overprotective but she had it she told her mom she hates her and wish she never have a mother but in the end turns she realizes that her mom is trying to protect her from the villain
Twilight basically made opoline another generations problem, if friendship and unity was so import in opoline's defeat they why didn't twight who is the princess of friend and cadence who is the princess of love try to resolve the problem, all am hearing is that the power of friendship that they keep preaching is fragile if is alway so easily broken.
HOLD IT! According to the Wikipedia of My Little Pony, Hasbro has been VERY SPECIFIC about not killing off characters…are they just saying that so we can chill out?! I’m so confused…
I think twilight is hiding among the Equestria thinking of her friends everyday and spike maybe gen 6 twilight will appear and be the villain when she realized her mistakes she surrender because she hear that she always says...... The MOST POWERFUL MAGIC OF ALL ....THE MAGIC OF FRIENDSHIP then she turns to normal and live happily ever after
...Why did I end up on this video precisely after finally try to watch all of FiM...and seeing that ending that I KNEW was way sadder than the episode made it seem. Seeing that Twilight ended up being a princess bound to be alone despite being the very princess of friendship, seeing that the mane 6, except her, became very old...even though I really liked seeing the series...the last épisode made me feel so sad for her.
I know this video is old as butt, but as a new fan from the show, I think I have an explanation that's similar to urs, Julie (: The writers are not afraid of jumping the gun and taking huge risks with the story, even though its a kid show We've seen it with the Tirek, and Chyrsalis, and Cozy Glow especially The show isn't afraid to be dark The death of Applejack's parents and how Granny Smith and Goldie Delicious passed away in the ending So personally? I think it was very intentional that they basically killed off Twilight, especially because of the one episode with the wonderful "Flawless" song -- Even though all of pony kind had access to all the lessons of friendship, they still treated it like a trendy thing that was just cool to have Only two little foals ended up reading it, out of possibly thousands or millions of ponies I think it's fair to say that Twilight's School of Friendship and the book she published wasn't a waste It's just the flaws of everypony around them that had Equestria fall, basically Opaline taking advantage of that weakness is actually pretty realistic, and I can see her winning in both interpretations With either the mane 6 being alive or just Twilight being alive; no amount of singing their "Flawless" song made a difference, so why would it then? This my personal perspective on the story between G4 and G5 :) Can't wait to watch G1 -> G3! And I've been loving all the fanfics fans have been writing (I also think Twilight x Pinkie Pie is just as real as Rainbow Dash x Applejack, there's so much evidence!) EDIT: Also, I love that Twilight and her friends didn't have an happy ending, in a way, because it shows that life isn't rainbows and sunshine
I think in G4 in the last epsidoe. If i remember Princess celestia said that she ruled for a thousands year and said to twilight "and you will for the same time" so I'm guessing that twilight will live for a 1000 years whilst the pnies may only love for 100-200?
the writers of MLP knew what they were doing and have told us everything that has happened from the time before Celestia and well beyond the G5 series---you'll find the storyline in the easter eggs hidden throughout the G4 series example: you made reference to the tree of harmony as it appeared as Twilight to Sandbar and the others under the school of friendship--the states that the tree has always been self-aware and tree has been in existence well before Celestia's time--- you suggested the hardship twilight faced after the passing of her friends and family well wouldn't Celestia have faced the same--the tree sensing the disharmony from Celestia's continuing heartbreaks would have made changes to restore harmony such as creating Candice and bestowing greater magic power to a new born pony named Twilight to compensate for Celestia's withdrawing heart (a heart can break only so many times) --you are a lot closer to seeing that storyline than other MLP content provider has been
The problem with G6’s portrayal of Twilight Sparkle is that she mostly wears her crown, making her appear less mature as compared to G5, where she’s shown fully grown. In G5, Sunny becomes an Alicorn, but they forget one key detail: Alicorns can't revert to Earth ponies. The Tree of Harmony played a crucial role in keeping everyone safe, but G5 disregards that to replace with something less effective than something that could help them. ---------------------------------------------------------------- Sunny didn’t earn her Alicorn status the way Twilight did, through a trial. Instead, it was given to her by a gem.which given her an Alicorn set makes the Additionally, G5 replaced the Treehouse of Harmony with a Prism Beam Lantern, which is a poor substitute. when she was got them for
This is one reason Season 9 should be revised. She wasn't supposed to outlive her friends even as an alicorn, much less rule Equestria. Join this campaign to help fix FiM.
I always assumed that Twlight would end up alone bc Celestia is literally thousands of years old, we say her when Granny Smith was a kid and Celestia looked the exact same in the present while Smith pretty much lived her whole life. But I feel worse for Cadance, like she could be thousands of years old but Shinning would die way before her. So the Princess of Love was just suppose to live for thousands of year without her true love? Well at least she would have Flurry. By this logic Shinning could have died even before Flurry reached adulthood cause alicorns age differently. So I was very upset when we never say any of them in the final episode, but I like to headcanon that they used magic to make Shinning an alicorn so he could live longer with his family.
There is No Possible Way Discord would EVER let Fluttershy die.
True
It's canon in the comic fluttershy passed away before things got much worse during the division:(
Haven't read a MLP Comic in Years , but I'm SURE Discord was none to happy to lose That little Yellow Mare.
But is Discord able to make Fluttershy immortal.
@@ShorkybunGameswait it is I will be sad she my one of my fav character 😢:(
Well Twilight still had Cadence, because she's an alicorn too. And even if Cadence passed, Flurry Heart would be the new alicorn of the Crystal Empire so at least Twilight had some family
What about her parents shinning armor etc
@@TheLastNoodleInThebowl But still, she had them. She's not gonna have everyone and I said at least she had SOME family
@@TheLastNoodleInThebowlI think you forgot what the word some means
Maybe Cadence and Flury Heart vanished with the Cristal Empire
@@alanjuarez8660 I think you need to watch the last G4 episode because it was confirmed that flurry took over the empire
Twilight would keep on making new friends and matter where she goes her old friends will always be around her
It's still sad
@@ToonTimeEUA What happened to the mirror portal the human (Equestria Girls) world and sunset shimmer and her friends after g4 ended and before g5 began?
@@KristinaDepietro This question is a bit hard because The Sirens were sent there 1000 years ago and it seems like they didn't age, maybe they didn't age aswell
@ToonTimeEUA
🙂 it's all right. I'm always there for you. Friends👩❤️👨 stay friends👩❤️👨 to the end.
Happy😊 Firework🎆 Independence🇺🇲 Day, My Little Pony🦄 fans, and God♂️ bless🙏 us, Everybody!
✴️ 🌟💫⭐️, 🌠🦸♀️🌌, 🎼🎺🎵, 🥳🎊🎆!
@KristinaDepietro
🙂 i like the magical, colorful🏳️🌈 Portal Tunnel (between the Pony🦄 World🌎 of Equestria Land🏞🇺🇲 and the Human👩 World🌎 of Canterlot High School🏫🏙🇺🇲) with the Sailor⛵️ Moon♀️🦸♀️(😇)[🎀🟢, 🦱🟡, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🎀🔴, 👗⚪️⚪️⚪️🔵🔵🔵, 👢⚪️🔴🔴🔴⚪️](🌕)❤️🤍💙 transformation music🎶 of the "Moon🌕 Prism💠 Power🌠 - Chilbiusa♀️🦸♀️(😇)[🎀🔵, 🦱🩷💖🩷💖🩷💖🩷, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🎀🔴, 👗⚪️⚪️⚪️💖💖💖, 👢⚪️💖⚪️](💞)❤️🤍💖's Transformation" 0:41 video🎦
I like the idea of Twilight sacrificing herself. If that was the case, then (assuming all this went down while the Mane 6 were still alive) it would hold true to Faust's word that "Twilight will not outlive her friends". It would also be wholesome and emotional. Sadly the way G5 has gone so far, I don't expect them to be that creative.
You know ....if Faust's word holds true.....that would mean that Twilight is dead in G5 alongside the mane 6 since it's already been confirmed that Fluttershy is dead in the G5 comics.
@@launacyko4523
🥺 Sometimes, sacrifices must be made
@@launacyko4523I figured it was obvious they were dead in G5
Without Faust's word.
Considering Equestris is now known as Ancient Equestria and especially the Mane Six could live that long. And clearly Twilight used her magic to separate... Magic and I think that's why she died, her immortality was lost when she made the crystals and she died alongside her friends.
@dragonseer2251
🥺 the G4 human👩/pony Friendship👩❤️👨 Gang's death is a terrible tragedy💔. It's also a sad🥺, deep, passing loss with a sad🥺 heart❤️ that glows blue🔵 with tick-tocking⏰️ vibration📳
@@ShawnPickettPauley please tell me you're joking and aren't really this sad about some animated colorful ponies
I feel like G5 is more of a G4 AU of sorts, because a number of things conflict with what we already know from G4, like the idea that G5 Celestia and Luna were born as Alicorns when in G4 they didn’t even believe that to be possible until Flurry Heart was born and all previous media stating that they ascended to Alicornhood, Spike’s entire form changing for no discernible reason, G5 Discord suddenly ageing despite being immortal in G4, etc. It feels like more of a “what if” AU scenario, so I feel like the G4 Twilight that we know probably didn’t encounter any Opaline because, by the rules of that universe, Opaline wouldn’t exist. Opaline can only exist if you alter Celestia and Luna’s backstories.
yeah that's what I've been going off of. I don't see G5 as canon to G4 since it's so different from G4
I just ignore g5 existence until the day a new chapter came out then the next day back to ignoring it’s existence
@@UNENSIONSme too lol
G5 definitely ruined everything that my little pony is and was. It not only has a very disappointing style to it, but the story of all pony nations splitting up after seemingly twilights happy life in the end of g4 is so contradicting! It sucks! I don’t understand why g5 had to exist. It only just adds confusion to the story of mlp
@@shannonjensen8934 pick and choose your canon! Thats what I do
I don’t consider G5 canon imo. Everything they worked for is gone. Plus, it’s not even by the same creator lol. It’s absolute dogshit writing
Yeah. And it contradicted stuff from the final episode such as Twilight's final form. Alternate universe I say.
The animation felt so lifeless, everything seemed like plastic and I can’t feel any charm, unlike the old show it had that strange charm to it. Like genuine heart and love was put into it
@@Insertthestrangerit also has something to do with the animation style as well and I wish it was still the old style or mabye the one in the movie which was a slightly better animation style
Agreed
Yeah like the whole thing about an Alicorn kingdom, and that Celestia, Luna, and Opaline originally lived there and were BORN as Alicorns.
Since that contradicts what Celestia and Luna said when Flurry Heart was born, she was the FIRST Alicorn to ever be born. And if those two said that, there is NO Alicorn Kingdom.
Oh and Twilight disabling Magic, her very talent and a part of the elements and her whole friendship LESSON.
That sounds more like something Tirek or Cozy Glow would do.
But the real kicker was the reason she did this was because... A Unicorn hurt an Earth Pony... Like that never happened before in Equestria.
Now if it was "A threat that required magic to be disabled", THAT would have been better writing.
Then we could have had a warning message come about saying "What have you done!!! You doomed us all!"
In my opinion Opaline should have been born an Alicorn, but been born AFTER FlurryHeart. I mean she doesn't even look like Celestia, Luna, Cadence, OR Twilight when she became a full Adult. And Opaline was supposed to be around the same age as the two sisters? I think NOT.
Then with her being born an Alicorn, they could have revealed the reason she viewed herself as queen was because her parents spoiled her rotten, calling her their princess.
And that after they died, her mind just SNAPPED. Ironically enough they could have died in a fire, hence her fire obsession. Either that or she was the kid of a Pony and a Dragon, since we did see a dragon asking a pony out with a flower during the G4 finale's song.
Oh and dragons.... Yeah they were done dirty.
1. Spike would not have been their leader, if anything he would have been living in a Pony city or town in secret, maybe the crystal empire where he would have been viewed as a hero even after all those years. Possibly with a beard, showcasing he can use magic with his claws. *Basically a Starswirl inspired sage character*
2. Dragons wouldn't have cutie marks or pony traits.
Poor twilight she and her friends didn’t deserve such a future 😢
Twily : nope
It’s OK she put all of her Alcorn magic in the crystal so that means she wouldn’t be able to live for long just like Lauren Faust said that twilight will not outlive her friends
all due to the cruel hands of capitalism 😥
The makers of G5 ruined everything!😡😡😡😡😡
It was inevitable. The way Equestria worked as a state shown in G4, other Mane 6 members mortality, the Wendigos killed in Season 9 final battle and many other things. Even without Opaline, Equestria was doomed to fall and honestly I'm surprised G5 was brave enouth to tell that right in the face.
No, Twilight obviously used a spell to make her friends immortal.
Edit:Jesus calm down it was a joke
😲 Super🦸♀️-duper surprising
If that’s the case, where are they now then?
Hmm maybe ur right
It's definitely possible. I'm a possible thinker, so I'll stick with this!
@@sweetdreams1028in twilys ❤️🔥.
I like to think Twilight lived on in the Unity crystals, and is now in control of all magic.
Yes, she may be very slightly insane after being trapped alone for however long it took for the crystals to be reunited. It explains why they can be so violent at times!
I like to think she lives in the unity crystals too
that'd make some sense, she IS the element of MAGIC so being in complete control over magic would make sense
@@Maxwellchaos7439 It also gives a reasonable explanation for why she made the crystals
They weren't an effort to hide the magic. They were a weapon.
Immortality is and will always be Empty.
❤❤
Yeah, and i have my own theory on she countered it. Made her student Luster Dawn her successor, gave up her immortality and aged rapidly to catch up with them. Personally I consider G5 an Au.
@jusjetz
😠 Not for me it's not.
P.S, i don't give up
@@nelsonchan379
😍 i love My Little Pony🦄 generation 4 and 5
@@samdickenson5852
😠 i don't give up
Personally I think she was planning to make Luster Dawn her successor to give up her immortality which in my opinion was from Celestia and Lunas power over the sun and moon which was CONFIRMED by the writers to have been given to Twilight when they fused their crowns. One source says that raising those rejuvenated the sisters which is what gave me that idea. As for G5 I don't consider that canon to G4 as it contradicts Twilights final form. Alternate universe to me. But hey we all have opinions.
@samdickenson5852
🥺 But, G4, good😇-heart❤️, human👩/unicorn🦄 Luster Dawn♀️(👨🌾🚰🌼)[🎀🔴, 🦱🟠🟡🟠🟡🟠🟡🟠, 👁🟡, 👄🔴, 👗🟣🟢🟢🟢🟣](🌅💫 + 🌅🟠🟡⚪️🟡⚪️🟡, 💫🟢⚪️🟢)🤍🩷🩷🩷 (Goodness😇), you can't give up⬆️. Everybody needs friends👩❤️👨, even you. You need friends👩❤️👨 to protect you from evil😈 forces
@@ShawnPickettPauley Don't know what you're trying to say.
The alicorns are immortal beings who can be considered demi-goddesses on whom time itself has no noticeable effect, we have seen that Luna and Twilight are rejuvenated when these were exposed to special magical conditions. But we also know that these alicorns age very slowly. Opaline was able to survive without magic because she had her internal alicorn powers when she should have died of old age. We know little about the alicorns, but all told their powers are not due to their originality as a race, but to the mysterious magic that all ponies share.
We also know that when ponies die, it happens that these are "marked" in the sky as seen with Sunny's mother, and that there is a heaven, Elysion, for the dead ponies. G5 showed us that there is a "life" after death because ghosts and dead spirits were seen. Fluttershy was perhaps the best example from the Discord arc in the IDW comics, she "returned" as a transparent and luminous butterfly. It is likely where all normal ponies ended up after their death, so these are not completely gone forever. But it's open to question what Elysion, the mysterious dimension where alicorns come into being and the vacuum that almost swallowed Maretime Bay in G5, is.
All indications are that Twilight was alone when she confronted Opaline for the last time. Spike had a pained expression on his face when Sunny mentioned this - which could indicate that Twilight had to pay a high price without Opaline being taken into custody. Probably all friends except for Spike, Discord and the other alicorns were dead when Opaline lost her magic.
Twilight had probably lived a long time - possibly for many centuries - but in the end she disappeared. Sooner or later the alicorns had to leave the world of mortals, and her turn may have come. It is possible that she may have gone to Skyros, but that seems unlikely. Spike had used the past tense when talking about Twilight, but it seems he meant she's gone. Just gone. As if she can never return.
There are many small signs that suggest that Twilight had ascended to the starry sky because the three crystals fell to the ground from the sky, believing that she had fulfilled her destiny predicted by her cutie mark - becoming a star. Wishing Star. And she may not have been alone, because Celestia and Luna may have fused with the Sun and Moon when they ascended.
But she is not completely gone. She had likely predicted her successor, Sunny Starscout, ten generations before G5. And it is possible that she could be the mysterious intelligence in the Unity Crystals who has an active role both as a friend and as a manipulator. Because if she has become the Wishing Star, there is still something missing. The five companion stars - her friends.
So if the Wishing Star gets the five companion stars sometime in the future, it could mark Twilight Sparkle's end. Because then she has joined her friends in Elysion.
I like to think of G5 as a terrible fever dream of Twilight's where an unholy terror of a villain used awful magic to take over the world from the great fausticorn so it could exploit it and that Twilight will wake up, find out she's actually Celestia's secret daughter and spend several months with her friends and aunt Luna learning to wield powerful alicorn magic and get used to her new alicorn body whilst fending off outside threats from distant lands and old enemies in some kind of epic fantasy anime.
I think of it is an AU or loose continuity. Doesn't fit. Twilight not having her final form in the last episode among other things.
There are so many things that dont make sense and the more the writers try to use g4 or fix plot holes the more they make.
This whole show is another au and thats it!
Its like dragon ball gt where its another universe and lets keep it at that.
G4 had a freaking happy ending and basta!
G5 ruined everything
You speak the truth!
Fr
Yeah fr
Make that from the from the beginning sesaon 9
G4 was just fine until G5 screwed everything over.
It has ended on a decent note. But now, with G5 happening, the feels are all there, but for the wrong reasons.
Wasn’t the backstory of the unity crystals from the comics retconned? In the comics it’s said that Twilight created it to prevent the three Pony races from using magic against each other. Meanwhile in the show its purpose was changed to Twilight creating the unity crystals inorder to hide the magic from Opaline, who wanted to steal all the magic for herself.
Also the creators for FIM have confirmed that. Twilight won’t outlive her friends
It’s also possible that Opaline wasn’t entirely responsible for the Pony kinds separating, since Spike seemed genuinely surprised to hear that the three pony races had separated during his absence. The hard truth may be that the three tribes separated on their own merits. This would be sad but realistic.
That’s to sad to think about! I think will never know if she outlived her friends or not tho 😓
@@ToonTimeEUA
🥺 Sometimes, sacrifices must be made.
Anything is possible. Life is full of mysteries, changes, and prejudice
@@ToonTimeEUA twily pony Jesus lol
Either Twilight extended her friends' lives or she dies sacrificing herself because unless Alicorns just have normal life spans there's no way she wouldn't outlive her friends.
@JassLJ
😠"out-live". Bah! Humbug
First things first. When i saw the last episode of FIM, I felt a little betrayed. Since the writers had promised the fans that they wouldn't make Twilight immortal after she became a princess (at the end of season 3). Then Twilight appeared as a Celestia 2.0 and didn't show any signs of aging well the other main six members had beginning wrinkles and Rarity even some grey highlights.
Second: I still refuse to say that G5 is taking place in the exact same universe as G4.
Third: I kind of felt confused in both the G4 finaly and the G5 premiere movie: How is it so easy to set up the races against each other again? They have been interbreeding with each other for generations
I haven't actually seen G5 but.... Look at our world. Look at how people have turned against each other, been led to hate each other.
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony.
But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me.
Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
They would just have mlp ended. My little pony friendship is magic was a legendary masterpiece and it's already enough that it existed. It will forever be in its prime among fans
I like to think that G5 doesn’t actually exist and we’re all going crazy :)
Well theories we have is twilight is still alive and is now living with celestia and luna some place in alicorn land or Opaline killed twilight either way twilight just disappeared
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony.
But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me.
Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
You're telling me that after everything, EVERYTHING, they listened to an unknown newbie alicorn over Twilight Sparkle?!?!?!?!?!?! Nah, it's official, *G5 is a grim alternate future.*
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony.
But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me.
Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
The fact that they made G4 a waste of time just so this generation could have a conflict and try to gain brownie points from G4 fans is nothing short of insulting. I loved A New Generation and was really excited to see what they had in store, only to be met with insane disappointment. The people who defend G5 saying Twilight’s reign wasn’t worthless are nothing but liars.
I didn’t get into G5, but I would say that just because things went wrong doesn’t make Twilight’s reign worthless. I hate this trend that says just because things go wrong means the good is somehow pointless. Twilight either is dead or in stasis somewhere.
@@PeachWookiee literally everything Twilight did, mainly spreading friendship amongst everyone, was all reversed all because a pony cut in line. I could buy Equestria eventually falling apart after Twilight steps down, but the fact that it fell apart when she and her friends were still around all because a pony said a few racist things would be like a white person calling every black person the n word and instead of that person getting beaten up for being a jerk, it convinced everyone in America to start a race war. Not to mention Twilight’s solution to the problem was making an item that if ponies started arguing, it would make magic disappear. Even though Equestria literally needs magic to function. This also means that dozens of Pegasi must’ve fallen to their deaths once magic disappeared. Twilight could’ve just encouraged people to get along, especially since this conflict literally happened in the season nine finale on top of many other problems going on, but I guess some racism in Ponyville was enough to make Twilight basically give up as this decision basically lead to Equestria’s downfall.
@@sweetdreams1028 Twilight might've cause a couple of deaths if that were the case
If they had only set G5 a thousand years after Twilight’s reign then I wouldn’t have a problem with it. 1,000 years was long enough for ponies to forget that Princess Luna existed so it’s much more realistic and less insulting for things to go back to the way they were before the founding of Equestria if a long period of time has passed. It would have made it all the more interesting to see ponies rediscover all the things that happened in the past.
@@alyssakays367 exactly. But they decided to make it only five generations after G4 (by Elder Flower mentioning her great great aunt was Moondancer) because why meaningfully connect things when you can just use fan service to? 🤦🏻♀️
She lost everything after the Great Division (1039-45 A.L.B)
I theorize that Twilight gave up her immortality so she can join her friends in the afterlife.
I have a similar theory, but she did it while alive and aged quickly to catch up to them. Made her student Luster her successor. G5 not canon to G4 for me.
There Are Acutally Very Many Episodes Of G4 Of My Little Pony.
But G5 Feels Gorgeous To Me.
Cartoonesians Don't Die, And Never Die, They Live On Forever.
it a good thing i treat G5 like an AU, as it should be.
Yeah. I feel the same. Doesn't fit the same with G4 with all the contradictions.
Count me in as well!
lets just hope she dosent go insane beacuse of losing her closes friends... Cause if she does we gonna have some Night PTSD
I really love Mlp Fim & Eg so much😥😥😥😥😥 it can't end like this 😭!!!!!😭😭😭😭😭
such a sap
@axelmurillo2589
🥺 i love My Little Pony🦄 generation 4 and 5. They mean more to me as much as anything
@ShawnPickettPauley I even did I too I don't care how long it gonna take.I'm getting them back this time
My theory is that since Twilight got her alicorn form from her bond with her friends she probably lost it when her friends died, reverted to being an ordinary unicorn and died of old age herself.
Why did they have to create a show that didint
Live happily ever after
😭😭😭😭
Wouldn’t shining armor die leaving flurry and cadence alone? Because he’s not an alicorn 😢
...That too...
Omg i didnt even think about that
It's true, One can only imagine how painful it must've been for Twilight to slowly watch all of her friends and family grow old and one by one pass away. Although Twilight would still have Cadence and Flurry Heart sure they would be the only family Twilight has left, But it would still be better than her being all alone.
As for Twilight's friends. They may be gone and it may seem like Twilight wouldn't be able to go on without them, But deep down Twilight knows that her friends wouldn't want her to spend the rest of her life just grieving over them, The other members of the Mane 6 would've wanted Twilight to continue living on and make more friends.
But no group of friends could ever have meant more to Twilight than her original group of friends, Nor could any new friends ever take their place in Twilight's heart.
And I'm sure Twilight also knows that her friends will always be with her, Not by her side but in her heart. I mean after all Twilight has so many wonderful memories of them and as long as Twilight hold onto and cherishes those memories she'll never truly feel all alone.
I wish the mane six would not age and time will freeze during the production of season 9 of MLP FIM.
Well, yeah. I guess it does make sense for now. We know that the G5 Writers or Hasbro Themselves hasn't gave us an official answer about if Twilight Sparkle is still Alive somewhere in G5 or not. I know Sunny's Mother and Father Argyle did used to tell her Stories about Twilight and how the Magic disappeared from Equestria. I guess we'll wait and see if we do get an official answer from the G5 Writers or Hasbro Themselves about if Twilight Sparkle is Still Alive somewhere or not in the future of Tell Your Tale Season 2. I do want her to come back. Maybe she went to Skyros or some place else. But I doubt that.
Let’s hope she’s back soon!
@@ToonTimeEUA yeah. Let's wait and see about that after Sunny Starscout and her Friends finds the Skyros Location in Tell Your Tale Season 2 Later down the line.
@@ToonTimeEUA
😲 Super🦸♀️ surprising.
Skyro Land🏞, a magical land🏞 in the sky🌌 clouds☁️ that fly in the sky🌌
@@ConnerKursave123
😲 Super🦸♀️ surprising.
Skyro Land🏞, a magical land🏞 in the sky🌌 clouds☁️ that fly in the sky🌌
I wish twilight will be back at their episode 😢
i hate opaline for what she has done, she should be the only one permanently banished from equestria
To save his friends Discord created pony life and covered it up.
OMG that would be so sad!! 😭
I think Twilight Sparkle went to luve near the ocean luke her name sake. Another name for evening is Twilight right? So west where the sun sets. That's just what i have to say and think. Maybe a feeling.
That’s a good point! Nice theory!
@ToonTime-hb6vj
😠 Not "luve". "Love😍"
People have honestly got multiple ideas about how Twilight would handle the loss of her five closest friends, barring the G5 MLP’s story. One is that she is a cold ruler who mourns the loss of her friends. Another is a depressive state that makes her abandon her role as a princess and disappear. And the next one is a very dark one where Twilight snaps when she loses them all. She decides that she will turn other ponies into her friends by conditioning them until they believe that they are truly Twilight’s friends.
I personally think g5 is doing it all wrong, as a big Stan of g4 I just think g4 shouldn't have gone the way it did.
I was thinking they should bring twilight back, not in a ghost or spirit form. More of a physical form, since twilight is an Alison she could've just possibly lived to watch all of these things happen. Luna and celestia lived to be almost more then 1000 Years old so I can imagine twilight pretty much lived 2000 *atleast* .
Sunny and her friends could've gotten lost or thought everything was over at one point, possibly get lost or trapped in a cave by opaline almost like cadence was by crystalis. And then while looking for a way out they find a mysterious tunnel or door where they find twilight.
Wether twilight trapped herself down their on purpose or she was banished.
I also don't think she was shrunk down when she created the three pieces, perhaps she just lost power. Maybe that's why she hid, because she was afraid of giving opaline more power by being enslaved. Perhaps twilight was planning to overthrow opaline!? Or maybe was watching sunny do it to see if she could rest. Maybe twilight casted a spell to keep her friends alive in her place, so she died instead of her friends??
Dang I never thought I'd be so invested in a show about magical ponies-
Also, I haven't rlly watched much of the new generation. I think the style of it is kinda... ugly. No offense to the artists I just don't like how fuzzy and 3d they look. So I don't know much abt opaline or sunny and her friends. I quite literally only watched the movie which gave me some explanation
Is it just me, or ponies other than the groups of six have trust issues
(Everyone go all sad about the outliving thing and i don't like it, or i'm missing something important)
This is why I think that all main 6 characters should became ALL princesses as well and not only Twilight
Like AppleJack would be princess of honesty, Rarity princess of generosity, PinkiePie princess of laughter, RainbowDash princess of loyalty and Fluttershy princess of kindness
It does make sense since their friendship isn't born only from Twilight, but all six, but then Twilight would be the Princess of Magic ?
Twilight is my favorite since i was 12 and i hope she will can go to Heaven with her friends 🙏💜
"your friendship school was useless twilight" ahhaahah like bruh i know right like you dedicate a whole season resolving around a magic school and then this ahahahhah
And then, Canterlot High became part of the United Federation Of Planets. By the time Twilight goes back to CHS, there would be Starfleet officers patrolling around the school. And the students would look more alien-like.
Heck, I would imagine Vulcans at Sunset's deathbed, since humanity made first contact with the Vulcans in 2063.😊
Twilight: Hey, girl in a yellow and black uniform, do you know where Sunset Shimmer is?
Starfleet officer: Sunset passed away 300 years ago.
@captainbeckyrayshoichetuss6418
🙂 i like the good😇-heart💜, G4, human👩/unicorn🦄 Sunset🌄 Shimmer♀️(🦸♀️🤚💭)[🎀🟢, 🦱🔴🟡🔴🟡🔴🟡🔴, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 🧥🟠⚫️⚫️⚫️🟠, 👗🟡🟢🟢🟢🟡](☀️☯️ + ☀️🟡🔴, ☯️🟡🔴)🤍💛💛💛 better.
She's the good😇-heart❤️ Spirit🌟 of the Element💎 of Redemptions😇/Forgiveness🥺🥹😇
This is probably because Twilight is immortal and is a princess, and it surely is sad to leave ur friends because of this ability.
The wings/horn of an Alicorn really are a curse.
No. Immortality has no disadvantages relative to mortal life.
@@_Alari_ watching everyone you knew pass away, watching generations go by in loneliness, I think those are some pretty big disadvantages
@@Third7Plays "watching everyone you knew pass away" - just like in mortal life, only every year it becomes more and more difficult for mortals to experience physical and emotional shocks
I barely see videos or photos in videos of Sunset Shimmer anymore! We. Need. More. SUNSET! It's sad how Netflix doesn't show all 9 seasons of MLP! I hate how it only show the first season then it show MLP Make Your Mark like yea I wanna see it but not before I see the 9 seasons of the first MLP series!!!!!! Bro Netflix needs to up their game I swear! Who agrees (not for likes I wanna see who agrees)👇🏽
It's canon that alternate timelines exist. *points to episodes where time travel and junk was mentioned*. So I tend to see G5 as an alternate timeline world. I also tend to view Opaline as a very unreliable narrator on some things... she can't stand to think of herself as having a form where she wasn't an alicorn, so she deluded herself into thinking she was ALWAYS an alicorn, she was just born naturally fabulous... and so were Luna and Celestia. She is the victor rewriting history to suit her own needs.... because god forbid that somebody find out that she was just a unicorn... or worse, a earth pony!
It's just another lesson of friendship.
Even if Twilight wasn't an alicorn there's no guarantee she won't have to look her friends die. "Grief is the price we pay for love"
There's no fairytale "they all died in the same day" thing (unless it's an airplane catastrophe or something). It's just a cruel reality of life.
It's also a fact that friends can change and no longer be the person you once knew.
I have a theory that Twilight is hiding somewhere in Equestria and maybe one day the G5 will finally meet her and ask her what truly happened
While I'm a big G4 supporter because it's literally my childhood, all things must come to an end eventually. Now we just see what happens for G5 which I believe is doing a good job.
1. I think she created the crystals and then she lost her wings (they disappeared )because she used so magic making them.I know this because in the message,she is a unicorn.Shouldn’t she be a tall alicorn? And she probably knows how old dragons live so she thinks spike is alive. I also think that Twilight and her friends did and/or casted something to possibly: A.Make them Immortal. B.Made them look like different ponies. C.Not be noticed in public. D.Protect equestria
From threats with a barrier or something like that. Any and/or multiple of these might have happened. G5 Ponies don’t know the Mane six’ names,and call them The Guardians of Harmony,probably to be a reference to the Elements of Harmony.
well she does have her wings in the message but i like your theory otherwise.
You either die a hero or live long enough to become the villain. Everything she did was for nothing. Almost everyone died for nothing. 😔
Twilight is the Crystals she went into them after all this happened so this is how she gave the message
If that were the case she would have reacted to them differently and not said 'if you are seeing this' its a recording obviously.
@@samdickenson5852 She could also be questioning if it was working or if an pony was there
@@Lunatheroleplay I doubt that.
@@samdickenson5852 she could have also recorded the message but after that went inside it to then hibernate
@@Lunatheroleplay Well you think what you want but the bottom line is it acted like a recording from what I saw and didn't interact with Sunny and the others freely so its basically proven to me.
Curse my Curiosity, this is so sad, knowing that the story since gen 4 turned into an amalgamation of abandonment and torment. Gen 5 is not my cup of tea, and gen 6 just doesn't sit right with me, since the whole CGI thing. I just wanna watch gen 4 knowing that everything is ok, they are all alive, and Twilight's reign created peace for years. I'm happy you made this video explaining what happened after gen 4. Just not the decision that the writers made to turn this into a tragic story, behind the colorful scenery, characters and joyful expression, all this turned into was a tragic story.
I wish they made a season 10 and more to see how they growed up like inside outv2😢:(
@Flower38467
🥺 i wish🌟 for Season 10 too
“Upon the day when fluttershy passed on, her closest friends and family mourned her loss. As the years went by, the remnants of the mane six would visit her grave sight to reminisce on their many adventures together. Eventually, princess twilight became the last remaining member of the mane six who would see where her best friends were laid to rest and remember them. Though legend goes that a mysterious figure, Discord, would visit the site of his friends and leave a special gift upon their graves.”
Fade to black, exit stage left, cue the applause from the audience.
This is one of the reasons why I don't like G5.Why they destroyed the all fruit of G4's friendship adventures?
Twilight saw Spike as a little brother? Hey everyone remember the first episode of mlp? Where we meet spike after Twilight slams a door into his face, a break hes gift? Oh yes good sibling memories, or whenever twilight use him as a mail? “ spike can you send this?” Whenever she send letters to anyone. Good memories 🤣🦊🦊🤣🤣
Something to note about Discord, something a lot of people seem to overlook.
In the comics, what stopped Discord was seeing the message Fluttershy made for him, so either Fluttershy forgot about it and went back to having tea parties with him, or they never saw each other again.
Oh :(
My princess Twilight sparkle.❤❤❤❤❤
Twilight never deserved this type of pain 😢 😭 💔🥺
I don't want to twilight to be outlined her friends 😭 cool video 😎
I say she gave up her immortality and made Luster Dawn her successor to die with her friends, refusing to outlive them. G5 is not canon to G4 in my mind.
Twilight's friends are with the stars now
Legends say Unicorns are immortal so Rarity and Starlight would've been still alive to be around Twilight
If only I make them come to life If just make believe if MLP G4 & G5 were here, I'm sure they'll understand me and we can make the fans feel special together by putting on a show performance!
No twilight is so sad because her friends are dead she want to having fun with her friends so that why twilight is so sad🥺🥺🥺😇😇😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭👻👻👻
4:58 with pleasure. Discord is my favorite FiM character...and to think that he had, too, to deal with the sorrow of losing someone so precious to him...
Just wanna say love your banner art of all the characters as Alicorns
Thanks a lot! All the video thumbnails will have original and nice artwork just like the banner.
@@ToonTimeEUA I look forward to them. Also I just figured Twilight would eventually give up ruler of Equestria to her student, but I always had a feeling she would outlive the others
I just kind of dismiss everything in G5. I refuse to even consider any of it as canon. I despise what G5 has done. It might have worked if they had made it a new story and didn't try to make it a follow-up of G4.
Twilight Sparkle did lived happily ever after she did her friends were amazing and so as she 🥹🥹🥹
I still think that G5 takes place about 1500 years after the last G4 episode. The rise & fall of Twilight Sparkle, her successor Luster Dawn, the fall of Luster Dawn & the division between the ponies, unicorns & alicorns & then fallout between the yaks & other species, the fall of G4 & rise of a more technological civilization that leads up to G5.
The whole point of each generation was to reboot the show but keep existing characters. So why tf did they think making G5 a continuation of the previous gen would work?
My theory is that Twilight had to give up her wings and immortality, maybe in the creation of the crystals. This is based mostly from the comment the show creator's made when they said word for word, "Twilight will not outlive her friends"
My theory is g5 is an au cause of the inconsistency with Twilight's form of regular alicorn vs big alicorn. In my headcanon for the true G4, Twilight made her student Luster her successor and gave up her immortality somehow. I personally believe its the power of the sun and moon that were the source of immortality rather than being an alicorn, one book said raising the sun and moon rejuvenated the sisters, and Celestia said they were leaving those in her hooves.
I’m new to mlp really & haven’t see much of the show compared to a lot of ppl but it seems to me like Twilights friendship effect could’ve had more of an impact, like not turning everyone into an alicorn but having say Fluttershy become immortal thanks to Discords friendship, or having the elements of friendship be almost immortalizing would make sense, all of them are supposed to be very powerful like the pillars from times past, being sealed away or resurrected would be a fun way to throw back to g4 from g5
I miss they so much😢
And in discord comic it make me cry 😢
I hope Twilight is still out there in hiding.
*'All great things must come to an end, That is what makes them Great..'*
😭
Because it's a cartoon show, everyone can make a mlp show whatever as they makes
All of this would be sad, But luckily for us G5 is not Canon😁
Well G5 is cannon cause its 1000 yrs into the future meaning twilight is too old obviously now
If Mordecai and Twilight were canon, he'd give her all the love in their immortality.💙💜
Wish twilight get married and have a beautiful baby girl who’s gonna be the future ruler of equestria
@superhenrybrother7359
😍 Me 2.
I love G4, leadership, unicorn🦄-turned-into-alicorn🦄🪽 Princess👸 Twilight🌟 Sparkle♀️(🦸♀️💞👩❤️👨)[👑🟡🟡🟡✴️🟡🟡🟡, 🎀💖, 🦱🟣💖🟣, 👁🟣, 👄🔴, 👕💖🔵🔵🔵💖](✴️ + ✴️💖, 8 ⭐️⚪️)🤍💜💜💜 (Magic🌟) X G4, hard-working, pegasus🐴🪽 Flash📸 Sentry♂️(💂♂️)[🦱🔵, 👁🔵, 🎀🔵, 🧥🔵⚫️⚫️⚫️🔵, 👕🔵⚪️⚪️⚪️🔵](🛡⚡️ + 🛡🔵, ⚡️🟡)🤍💛💛💛 =
#1: Twins: 1st-born, G4, hard-working, alicorn🦄🪽 Princess👸 Tinker🛠 Sparkle♀️(👩🔧)[👑🟢🟢🟢🛠🟢🟢🟢, 🎀🔵, 🦱🟡, 👁🔵, 👄🔴, 👗🟢](🛠⭐️ + 🛠, 4 ⭐️)🤍💚💚💚 (short name: Tink), 2nd-born, G4, hard-working, alicorn🦄🪽 Princess👸 Peri Sparkle♀️(🏎🏁⚡️)[👑, 🎀, 🦱, 👁, 👄, 👗](❄️⭐️ + ❄️, 8 ⭐️) (short name: Peri),
#2: G4,
#3: G4,
Me too!
But villain is after the baby
As the baby gets older she getting annoyed of twilight overprotective but she had it she told her mom she hates her and wish she never have a mother but in the end turns she realizes that her mom is trying to protect her from the villain
@@superhenrybrother7359
😲 which villain😈?
Twilight basically made opoline another generations problem, if friendship and unity was so import in opoline's defeat they why didn't twight who is the princess of friend and cadence who is the princess of love try to resolve the problem, all am hearing is that the power of friendship that they keep preaching is fragile if is alway so easily broken.
Minty, Trixie Lulamoon and Thorax were mentioned besides Minty. She did appear in G5.
But what happened to the other kingdoms?
@@brianwhite9339 idk
We know that Spike live longer than Twilight right
Apparently he did. But we don't know if he lived more than her due her sacrifice of for something that may happened with Twili
HOLD IT! According to the Wikipedia of My Little Pony, Hasbro has been VERY SPECIFIC about not killing off characters…are they just saying that so we can chill out?! I’m so confused…
I think twilight is hiding among the Equestria thinking of her friends everyday and spike maybe gen 6 twilight will appear and be the villain when she realized her mistakes she surrender because she hear that she always says...... The MOST POWERFUL MAGIC OF ALL ....THE MAGIC OF FRIENDSHIP then she turns to normal and live happily ever after
...Why did I end up on this video precisely after finally try to watch all of FiM...and seeing that ending that I KNEW was way sadder than the episode made it seem.
Seeing that Twilight ended up being a princess bound to be alone despite being the very princess of friendship, seeing that the mane 6, except her, became very old...even though I really liked seeing the series...the last épisode made me feel so sad for her.
I know this video is old as butt, but as a new fan from the show, I think I have an explanation that's similar to urs, Julie (:
The writers are not afraid of jumping the gun and taking huge risks with the story, even though its a kid show
We've seen it with the Tirek, and Chyrsalis, and Cozy Glow especially
The show isn't afraid to be dark
The death of Applejack's parents and how Granny Smith and Goldie Delicious passed away in the ending
So personally? I think it was very intentional that they basically killed off Twilight, especially because of the one episode with the wonderful "Flawless" song -- Even though all of pony kind had access to all the lessons of friendship, they still treated it like a trendy thing that was just cool to have
Only two little foals ended up reading it, out of possibly thousands or millions of ponies
I think it's fair to say that Twilight's School of Friendship and the book she published wasn't a waste
It's just the flaws of everypony around them that had Equestria fall, basically
Opaline taking advantage of that weakness is actually pretty realistic, and I can see her winning in both interpretations
With either the mane 6 being alive or just Twilight being alive; no amount of singing their "Flawless" song made a difference, so why would it then?
This my personal perspective on the story between G4 and G5 :) Can't wait to watch G1 -> G3! And I've been loving all the fanfics fans have been writing (I also think Twilight x Pinkie Pie is just as real as Rainbow Dash x Applejack, there's so much evidence!)
EDIT: Also, I love that Twilight and her friends didn't have an happy ending, in a way, because it shows that life isn't rainbows and sunshine
I think in G4 in the last epsidoe. If i remember Princess celestia said that she ruled for a thousands year and said to twilight "and you will for the same time" so I'm guessing that twilight will live for a 1000 years whilst the pnies may only love for 100-200?
the writers of MLP knew what they were doing and have told us everything that has happened from the time before Celestia and well beyond the G5 series---you'll find the storyline in the easter eggs hidden throughout the G4 series example: you made reference to the tree of harmony as it appeared as Twilight to Sandbar and the others under the school of friendship--the states that the tree has always been self-aware and tree has been in existence well before Celestia's time--- you suggested the hardship twilight faced after the passing of her friends and family well wouldn't Celestia have faced the same--the tree sensing the disharmony from Celestia's continuing heartbreaks would have made changes to restore harmony such as creating Candice and bestowing greater magic power to a new born pony named Twilight to compensate for Celestia's withdrawing heart (a heart can break only so many times) --you are a lot closer to seeing that storyline than other MLP content provider has been
0:32
Yeah intell stupid Corporation just have to mess it up....
The problem with G6’s portrayal of Twilight Sparkle is that she mostly wears her crown, making her appear less mature as compared to G5, where she’s shown fully grown. In G5, Sunny becomes an Alicorn, but they forget one key detail: Alicorns can't revert to Earth ponies. The Tree of Harmony played a crucial role in keeping everyone safe, but G5 disregards that to replace with something less effective than something that could help them.
----------------------------------------------------------------
Sunny didn’t earn her Alicorn status the way Twilight did, through a trial. Instead, it was given to her by a gem.which given her an Alicorn set makes the Additionally, G5 replaced the Treehouse of Harmony with a Prism Beam Lantern, which is a poor substitute.
when she was got them for
I have a theory that Discord, being the partner of Fluttershy, made her immortal
Oh my God that's sad😢😭😭😭 how can that be
I don’t know if the writers thought this one through until it was too late.
I subscribed to you.
Skips felt the same way as well
This is one reason Season 9 should be revised. She wasn't supposed to outlive her friends even as an alicorn, much less rule Equestria. Join this campaign to help fix FiM.
I always assumed that Twlight would end up alone bc Celestia is literally thousands of years old, we say her when Granny Smith was a kid and Celestia looked the exact same in the present while Smith pretty much lived her whole life. But I feel worse for Cadance, like she could be thousands of years old but Shinning would die way before her. So the Princess of Love was just suppose to live for thousands of year without her true love? Well at least she would have Flurry. By this logic Shinning could have died even before Flurry reached adulthood cause alicorns age differently. So I was very upset when we never say any of them in the final episode, but I like to headcanon that they used magic to make Shinning an alicorn so he could live longer with his family.
i think opaline was there for princess twilight sparkle's coronation she would be so proud of her
Sunset Shimmer was more qualified to be a ruler in my opinion after she reformed.
Sacrifice all her magic for peace and magic for all the magic of Pegasus a pony