Not bad, a few bum notes here and there but good effort. One thing I would say is that you need to loosen up a bit, I know how switching the camera can tighten you up :) The bends need to be a bit more liquid so to speak ie. better control of the way you ease in and out of them (accelerate & de-accelerate). I like to think of part 8 as a slow funk and it needs your left hand to "chop" with that kind of feel to it. Floyd is difficult to play well because of the remarkable feel Gilmour has. I hope you're not offended by my critique :)
@@PinkFloyd1965 ... no one achieved excellence with a "That will be good enough" attitude. Some people can take constructive critique better than others and those that can't take it will be destined for mediocrity. It's not about being a snob, it's about being discerning and how we can improve because the details matter because you can bet every buck you have that the band themselves went to excruciating lengths to get every note just right on their albums which is why they spent a year or more recording them, and because of their exacting standards, their snobbery if you will, their unwillingness to be easily pleased with a "that will be good enough" attitude, because of that they achieved excellence which is why we love their music because it is so damned good !! Thus when one tries to emulate it one must be ones own harshest critique and if you can't tell the difference between your own mediocrity and their excellence then it behooves you to listen to the constructive critique of those who can. Note that I didn't make my comment to run the guy down for the sake of it, I just wanted to give him an honest opinion and some pointers for improvement rather than offer another vacuous "Yeah, that's great" from which no one learned anything. Nothing and no one is above critique or improvement including you... and me and the guy in the video too..... You can be offended by an honest opinion or you can learn from it... or you can explain to me what I got wrong in my initial assessment ... or you can offer me another mediocre insult, up to you bud :) best wishes.... Another Pink Floyd fan
I used the tabs from Ultimate Guitar, however they are not 100% accurate. For the last section of the song, those tabs are pretty incomplete, so I tried to figure it out by ear.
That tone is otherworldly
You’re possibly the only one covering this song on youtube and you killed it
I think I watched this video over 50 times or more. Really impressive, guitar sounds almost if not the same as it did in the song. Keep it up homie
Fr. This by far beats out any professional, produced cover of the song. Tony has fucking talent
Hiciste un gran trabajo amigo, es mi canción favorita, te agradezco por el video
NAILED IT!!!!!!!!!!! 🎉
Buddy, you're the only one on TH-cam who's making cover on this part and you sound great man ! 🤘
This is really good!
Outstanding!!!
😧wow 👏
Keep it up George!!
Awesome!
Nice job man :)
This is awesome!
Very good.
SICK
Bravissimo Antony!!!
10% playing 90% just listening haha
Sick x
What type of tuning did you use? Thank you
What tuning was this. This is the next song i wanna learn especially the slide part. Great job!
Thank you, it's just standard tuning.
Not bad, a few bum notes here and there but good effort. One thing I would say is that you need to loosen up a bit, I know how switching the camera can tighten you up :) The bends need to be a bit more liquid so to speak ie. better control of the way you ease in and out of them (accelerate & de-accelerate). I like to think of part 8 as a slow funk and it needs your left hand to "chop" with that kind of feel to it. Floyd is difficult to play well because of the remarkable feel Gilmour has. I hope you're not offended by my critique :)
Always that one guitar purist snob
@@PinkFloyd1965 ... no one achieved excellence with a "That will be good enough" attitude. Some people can take constructive critique better than others and those that can't take it will be destined for mediocrity.
It's not about being a snob, it's about being discerning and how we can improve because the details matter because you can bet every buck you have that the band themselves went to excruciating lengths to get every note just right on their albums which is why they spent a year or more recording them, and because of their exacting standards, their snobbery if you will, their unwillingness to be easily pleased with a "that will be good enough" attitude, because of that they achieved excellence which is why we love their music because it is so damned good !!
Thus when one tries to emulate it one must be ones own harshest critique and if you can't tell the difference between your own mediocrity and their excellence then it behooves you to listen to the constructive critique of those who can.
Note that I didn't make my comment to run the guy down for the sake of it, I just wanted to give him an honest opinion and some pointers for improvement rather than offer another vacuous "Yeah, that's great" from which no one learned anything.
Nothing and no one is above critique or improvement including you... and me and the guy in the video too.....
You can be offended by an honest opinion or you can learn from it... or you can explain to me what I got wrong in my initial assessment
... or you can offer me another mediocre insult,
up to you bud :)
best wishes....
Another Pink Floyd fan
Cant find any good tabs anywhere
Are you using an octave pedal for this ?
Yes
You know the chords for part ix
Are you playing in standard tuning?
Yes
Very good played, really ! :) How old are you ?
30
@@AnthonyGonzalez-gg4lj ; I will soon get on my YT portal the whole 9 parts - the whole composition of this band ...
tab?
I used the tabs from Ultimate Guitar, however they are not 100% accurate. For the last section of the song, those tabs are pretty incomplete, so I tried to figure it out by ear.
Dura così tanto il vento?
Precisa treinar mais tá tudo muito fora cara, principalmente o solo.. que não é feito na guitarra, e a afinação dela é diferente da Standard.