Adrienette is in the air! ⎮A Miraculous Ladybug New York Review

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
  • Our review is finally here!
    Listen to our opinions on the recent hour long special set in New York!
    Let us know your thoughts on the episode, and your speculations on the upcoming special set in Shanghai!

ความคิดเห็น • 786

  • @Fl0rales
    @Fl0rales 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1138

    What I liked: I liked how cat Noir wasn't flirting with ladybug every minute. I also liked how Marinette wasn't really being a stalker.
    I definitely liked when hawkmoth made an actual good plan
    I loved the adrientte moments
    And I was happy when they put the substitute love interests on there

    • @cottonycloud
      @cottonycloud 4 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Lmao ikr

    • @supersonicdj6389
      @supersonicdj6389 4 ปีที่แล้ว +55

      I'd say this movie is better then season 1 ,2 and 3.

    • @okarym
      @okarym 4 ปีที่แล้ว +54

      @@supersonicdj6389 agreed, the tone, the writing and the animation in this movie is far better than the actual seasons!

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +40

      @@supersonicdj6389 Yes and if season 4 is like this IT WILL BE PERFECT

    • @micahtiel
      @micahtiel 4 ปีที่แล้ว +31

      Wow, yeah I didn't even realize that this special addressed almost all fan complaints. The only one remainng would be Chloe, but I honestly think that the reason why she was so sidelined is because they're planning something big for her and the movie didn't have time to address it. Season 4 is looking more and more promising!

  • @bronzeplays5335
    @bronzeplays5335 4 ปีที่แล้ว +277

    4:15 to be fair Ladybug and Cat Noir act different compared to their civilian identity while Nino basically acted the same way he normally does even as Carapace

    • @mara5759
      @mara5759 3 ปีที่แล้ว +20

      I really think is because if the fact that Adrien feels free and has a sense of happiness when he's chat noir and Marinette forgets her insecurities when she's ladybug
      They act like they'll like to act as civilians anytime they ladybug and chat noir

  • @beatrizyukie2789
    @beatrizyukie2789 4 ปีที่แล้ว +456

    The producers said "what happends in New York stays in New York"- Does that mean adrien will just "forget" about all those romantic scenes with marinet or he wont talk about it but start to see marinete in a diferent way? ( If he acts like nothing happened im gonna be so mad)

    • @indybun
      @indybun 4 ปีที่แล้ว +31

      Same. Like what was all that for if it isnt gonna continue in s4 yk

    • @PlatinumDagger
      @PlatinumDagger 4 ปีที่แล้ว +50

      If they do that he'll look Moore alike a player and cheater. They already borderline cheated on there lovers. He's getting emotionally involved now with Mari cause it's dry with KagaMi now.

    • @_euphoria_7025
      @_euphoria_7025 3 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      tHEY WHAT?

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +23

      If I had to guess I think that means that Adrien won't mention that they had "A Moment" *when dancing* and perhaps Ladybug will not harass Cat Noir to much about her loss of trust as on some level she know going on about it will only harm their partnership even further likewise she won't mention that she pretty flat out told him she "needs him" like twice. But I also think they will continue to have Marinette stalk him for the time being but will occasionally be able to convince herself he's "Just a friend" to have short conversations and likely Alya will sabotage those while thinking she'd helping as so long as Ladybug is giving him mix signals - even if he thinks she loves someone else he'd still refuse a confession from Marinette and so ruin their dysfuctional friendship.
      The reason I think they will pretend this all never happened - is - that they've done that already multiple times.
      They pretend Cat Blanc never happened
      They pretend Time Breaker never happened
      They never mention than she almost quit and screwed up in her 1st week as Ladybug.
      They (only mentioned Dark Cupid once in Prime Queen and otherwise ignored it)
      They rarely mention the oblique love declaration for someone else aside from the occasional vague mention in multi-parters.
      Marinette didn't act like Puppeteer 2 affected her, and didn't seem to give two hoots that Adrien said he was in love with someone else - she just decided and Alya & Nino just decided to make choices for him without consulting him.
      Though if he keeps looking at her like he does no wonder they think he's interested in some sense.
      There isn't much continuity in this show, Chloe being sad for example can be taken as her not wanting to go on the trip, or her being sad about Miracle Queen it doesn't require you to care what happened in Season 3.
      But I do wonder if they also shot themselves in the foot a bit with Cat Noir leaving town and her leaving town with no really reason to ever do so without suitable plans. & Marinette is going to do it again in the Shanghai special, so yeah she's going to abandon her duty twice on the trot without proper planning. I bet they do something stupid like say the Space Powers are nonsense fast and use that as an excuse. Even though the senti-monster attack was over in 7 minutes and they'd never have made it back in time as they'd have had to meet up and get back there via teleportation, and it's just not practical and if it was via space powers then The baddies can pull the powers from the Butterfly or feather and all their terrorist actions will stay as they are - they can then wait a bit and do it again and the Damage will always stay (and deaths too). Putting a lot of pressure on Ladybug & likely making people flee Paris too.
      So they don't want that to happen so they will pretend it never happened and hope we don't notice.
      Oh and another lore change we got was that Power ups are easy to make and can be stored n their costumes indefinitely & are eaten by the hero not the kwami so no power up animation and no transformation drop and retransform - that is a big change to the lore.

    • @PlatinumDagger
      @PlatinumDagger 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@90lancaster this is soo true. This show just tanked big time! Nothing makes sense anymore, they really think people are dumb and not paying attention.

  • @anushkabanerjee2317
    @anushkabanerjee2317 4 ปีที่แล้ว +102

    The best thing that I liked about the special is that ,
    Adrien finally realised how much great and loving friend Marinette is .
    And secondly Ladybug understood that she is nothing without her cat noir .
    And the romantic seens perfectly matches them too .

  • @Niko-ci8sw
    @Niko-ci8sw 4 ปีที่แล้ว +419

    Title: Adrienette is in the air
    Thumbnail: *literally them floating in the air*

    • @AnuelleCheng
      @AnuelleCheng 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @Huda Kay repeating the same word doesn't count as rhyming

    • @yourlocalrainwing1358
      @yourlocalrainwing1358 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Adrienette literally was in the air

  • @adriana.1354
    @adriana.1354 4 ปีที่แล้ว +422

    I rate this ep 9/10 bc they didn't talk about the miracle box and where marinette kept it so it stayed safe while she went to New York
    Edit: omg! Thx 4 the likes

    • @sabm8026
      @sabm8026 4 ปีที่แล้ว +33

      yeah I was kinda upset they didn’t mention anything about ladybug as the miracle box holder and all that.

    • @cymone2864
      @cymone2864 4 ปีที่แล้ว +12

      @@sabm8026 ikr like they show what happened to nathalie after the finale but not the miracle box? like what

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      They probably didn't have enough time

    • @cottoncandysiblings308
      @cottoncandysiblings308 4 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Yeah I wish Marinette and Adrian lived in New York so they would not have to keep their identity secret that would be perfect

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      I'd guess they are saving it for Shanghai.

  • @TheCartoonHotspot
    @TheCartoonHotspot 4 ปีที่แล้ว +267

    Actually If you have Thomas Astruc on Twitter he stated that in the initial script Mr Damocles and Ms Mendeleev had a story arc for the New York special but sadly that was cut because the episode came back too long. Tbh I think this was better idk about y’all but I don’t actually care about Mr Damocles and Ms Mendeleev🤣🤣🤣

    • @jewelminess
      @jewelminess 4 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      Same, I think they're trying to give too much character to characters who don't need it (such as Mr Damocles and Ms Mendeleev having their own akumatized episodes)

    • @TheCartoonHotspot
      @TheCartoonHotspot 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Jewel Mines Gaming! Completely agree

    • @noor5860
      @noor5860 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      I just read it mcdonald’s (thats how hungry i am)

  • @nonbinaryartist8661
    @nonbinaryartist8661 4 ปีที่แล้ว +86

    I don't think they're shrugging off what happened, I just think Marinette and Adrian aren't defining the relationships they have with Luka and Kagami

  • @kawaiiizzmerrychristmaszz4710
    @kawaiiizzmerrychristmaszz4710 4 ปีที่แล้ว +594

    I LOVED ITTTTTT. Im Ready For Season 4 & 5. And They Need To Make Moviessssss.

    • @djenalizardo7037
      @djenalizardo7037 4 ปีที่แล้ว +22

      Loospy Linda their making one I think it’s called miraculous awakening

    • @boo5681a
      @boo5681a 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Djena Lizardo good idea

    • @sabiqabatool6467
      @sabiqabatool6467 4 ปีที่แล้ว +17

      @@djenalizardo7037 and shanghai special

    • @sabiqabatool6467
      @sabiqabatool6467 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I don't know if shanghai special is a movie or something else

    • @lolha4816
      @lolha4816 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      Nooo it'd take like 1 year

  • @Lyda-qb5ci
    @Lyda-qb5ci 4 ปีที่แล้ว +275

    I loved the special, but there were some flaws that need to be addressed. The adrienette and lady noir was handled brilliantly, and showed lots of development that wasn’t there before.
    However, I agree on the fact that it didn’t ‘fit it’ with the ending of season 3. I feel like the changed it since a large part of the fandom didn’t like it, but who knows? Maybe it’s just set a little while after it, or maybe it does fit?
    As with the ‘Ladybug getting mad at Chat’ thing, I think it was justified, but not at that moment, y’know? I get that they are both teenagers, and both can be very ‘act first then think’, but if she were to scold him she should have done it after they defeated the villain (I think it parallels with the times when Chat has been cold to her, even though it is very different reasons).
    The reason they ‘failed’ first time, was because Ladybug said she was disappointed in Chat. This angered me at first, but then I realised the cleverness of the writing... Adrien is afraid of disappointment, and of abandonment. He does everything his father asks of him, since he’s afraid his father will leave him like his mother did. He’s afraid to disappoint Ladybug, in case she leaves him too. That’s why he didn’t tell her, since he didn’t want to be a failure.
    And with the Paris thing, I thought it was an interesting dynamic to introduce (the fact that they can fail sometimes). Paris is extremely dependent on Ladybug and Chat, even to the point that their forces do nothing to help, but ridicule them when they make a mistake. I don’t want innocent people to die, but I want people to realise that they need to not be so dependent on ladybug and chat saving the day all the time.
    However, Ladybug has a right to be upset. I understand this, as she literally has the weight of the world on her shoulders. She is only human, and will fail sometimes, and I’m glad the show shows this.
    The best things were the romance, and the development, but it lacked structure, in my opinion.

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      they would of defeated techno pirate A WHILE AGO and could of went back to save paris. The reason they didn't defeat and capture him was because of uncanny being cataclysm because of cat noir because of ladybug breaking him mid battle. I get she was mad but she should of waited till after the battle with techno pirate so they could go to paris and save them. As for the paris thing it would be cool if they would of went against a villain like zombiboo where the villain doesn't destroy stuff but has other abilities and be able to defend themself till ladybug and cat noir come back.

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 4 ปีที่แล้ว +19

      It fit perfectly fine with the ending of season 3. Luka and Marinette never started dating, anyone who believed that simply misunderstood. Kagami and Adrien's relationship is presented as a bit more complicated in this special just as it was in the season 3 finale. Adrien isn't fully committed to a relationship with Kagami but he won't flat out reject her either as he does like her, he's trying to move on from Ladybug, and he's just confused about how he feels about Kagami.
      Also it wouldn't make sense to try and take things in a different direction based on fans' response. Season 4 was already fully written before the season 3 finale aired. They are finishing up Season 5 currently.

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      @@kabsageigj8941 They did take different directions based on fans respond on s3 though. There was a lot of development and they fixed a lot of problems such as ladybug and cat noir not being equal

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@fieryicymilkman6098 There was a lot of development and I'm glad you thought Cat Noir was treated well. I've still seen people complaining he was downplayed. Personally I don't know if I buy that those things are the result of listening to fans complaints but if they are then great. I just see it as time for those developments to occur. In this special I can clearly see the build off from Miracle Queen. And some moments even remind me of things that I believe were being foreshadowed in Stormy Weather 2. So I don't know. I'm not seeing the disconnect of "fans don't like what we are doing, let's change it" Cat Noir's fight in Miracle Queen showed him being able to figure out how to defeat the villian and he took it seriously. I was hoping this was a sign of what's to come from him. Taking more responsibility and treating his role a bit more seriously. The development in him we got from the New York special fits with that. Even the episode that every Cat Noir fan (well.. just about) hates, Reflekdoll I took as challenging Cat Noir's typical unserious and carefree attitude.

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@kabsageigj8941 They definitely improve so many areas in the show during this special which makes me think s4 is going to be amazing since this special was probably better than s1-3 and a lot of things changed. Cat noir and ladybug got the same treatment and he's now accepting getting rejected by ladybug. Marinette's obsession got toned down (only a little but still). Side characters are getting development to such as sebrena (I don't like her but at least it's something) and hawk moths actually planning things out (even though they should of made him use the eagles talon on himself or keep it). Only a few things were bad about the special but these are probably just personal things. knight owl being a girl killed the character for me. Not that I hate superheros being a girl or anything it's just that I was digging his voice and stuff but then I got shocked. The adult superheros didn't get any development and basically stayed the same and a lot of them weren't even introduced when some of them looked cool like the 3 ant characters. Chloe wasn't shown enough especially considering she was about to take over paris in the s3 finale and only had like 4 lines. This special was overall good and hopefully season 4 is better with stuff like a adrian centered episode to tell us about emily and what she was like. Also waiting to see what Queen Banana will be like :D

  • @errolnacion971
    @errolnacion971 4 ปีที่แล้ว +134

    Unpopular thought: A lot of people died in this special episode
    I mean majestia just blew away the buildings you cant say that theres no one inside it
    Even if the miraculous ladybug fixed everything. Still alot of people died

    • @strawbrxes6627
      @strawbrxes6627 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Soo true

    • @XiaoIsMyHusbandBTW
      @XiaoIsMyHusbandBTW 3 ปีที่แล้ว +19

      And what about Paris you can’t tell me no one was in those buildings

    • @nixxdra
      @nixxdra 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@theteleporter1842
      Chat Blanc took place in an alternate timeline, this didn’t.

    • @jellysourbean
      @jellysourbean 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Um yk what true

    • @phoebe9047
      @phoebe9047 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Oh yeah people definately died behind the scenes☺

  • @nigaruddin1891
    @nigaruddin1891 4 ปีที่แล้ว +101

    I think that Kagami,Lila,Luka and Chloé were side characters in ny because they are season 4 plot and ny focused in the new characters which is a good thing

  • @minnieblossom1347
    @minnieblossom1347 4 ปีที่แล้ว +39

    I love how Cat Noir started to act like a friend towards Ladybug (instead of him trying to keep on ‘winning’ her over), and how Adrien started to see Marinette more than a friend!

  • @dark_soul5943
    @dark_soul5943 4 ปีที่แล้ว +120

    Tbh can’t Marinette know Cat noirs real Identity? Since Marinette is the owner of it

    • @AnyaShortcake
      @AnyaShortcake 4 ปีที่แล้ว +28

      The whole plot surrounds them not knowing their identity and I think they'll keep it that way to keep themselves safe

    • @hallerumm1493
      @hallerumm1493 4 ปีที่แล้ว +39

      @@AnyaShortcake astruc says that they'll find out their true identities in season five but i think he's just lying again.

    • @AnyaShortcake
      @AnyaShortcake 4 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      @@hallerumm1493 who knows- I think they'll wait until the final season to reveal themselves

    • @jewelminess
      @jewelminess 4 ปีที่แล้ว +18

      Yeah I've been wondering stuff like that.
      What if Adrien runs out of power-up cheese and needs more? He can't just make any, only Mari can.

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@jewelminess I think he was given the vials of the liquid and just steeps a wheel of cheese in each flavour so he likely has enough for a few Transformation if there is enough in each vial for 1 wheel of cheese and 8 or more slices in each wheel. Marinette likely has to bake a lot more macaroons though and unless her yo yo keeps them fresh has to make them more often too. But yeah he's not really supposed to have the means to make his own he'd rely on her to make more of the potions.
      As for the identity thing - all she has to do is ask and he'd tell her, as he's completely whipped like that. it doesn't even matter if she's the guardian or not.

  • @skylarlee9691
    @skylarlee9691 4 ปีที่แล้ว +77

    I - I was waiting for you to address "Gorilla's" fear of flying even if it was just for the humor . . . and it never came . . .

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Gorilla didn't go home on the plane with Adrien for the sake of plot convenience it seems. If that was Gabriel's plane then did he fly commercial to get home or send the plane back and come home later on .. or perhaps even fly immediately to Shanghai ?
      Speaking of Transport - I was amused that Hawkmoth was using a Tsurugi self driving car, like the one Kagami travels it.

  • @lucieellis3149
    @lucieellis3149 3 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    The uncanny valley/catalysm moment is one that really needed to happen.
    Yeah, Reflekdoll showed that Ladybugs powers are harder to use, but Chat Noir’s potentially has more consequences. If he is not care, he could actually kill someone, and as shown by Fu loosing his memory that the cure can’t always fix everything. It’s more of that equality and balance that the ladybug and cat are meant to be. Her powers are harder but nicer but his are simpler but ‘darker’
    I think that moment showed him, this time in a clear mind instead of being brainwashed, that he is dangerous and can easily kill someone and that’s a lot of a teenager.

  • @jemmajustine
    @jemmajustine 4 ปีที่แล้ว +93

    I loved this special so much. It almost made me cry. No, it wasn't perfect, but it was still an amazing episode.

  • @Kris_sy
    @Kris_sy 3 ปีที่แล้ว +29

    Been saying it all along: this needed to be a MOVIE rather than a special.

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      It might have worked a but better if it was another 20 mins longer

    • @XiaoIsMyHusbandBTW
      @XiaoIsMyHusbandBTW 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@90lancaster ikr honestly it ended too quickly

    • @kenziejeager4454
      @kenziejeager4454 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@XiaoIsMyHusbandBTW it felt so rushed

  • @dearmellow7517
    @dearmellow7517 3 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    top scenes in NY special
    1.Adriennette scene
    2. Ladynoir scene
    3.Gorilla scene(the relaxing scene)
    4. New master and new miraculous box and new miraculous
    5. teamwork

  • @popcornstarepic4565
    @popcornstarepic4565 4 ปีที่แล้ว +72

    Me: *Just watching movie being chill*
    Me: *Throws popcorn in the air when Adrien goes away*

    • @yoooo7749
      @yoooo7749 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      WHERE U SEE IT

    • @karynrobb8348
      @karynrobb8348 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Sahar Alizadehrad I watched it on the at&t tv app

    • @victoriafontes5919
      @victoriafontes5919 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@yoooo7749 you can watch on
      mlbepisodes 's instagram she posted both on her igtv feed and on a mega link

  • @khadraabeeb5007
    @khadraabeeb5007 4 ปีที่แล้ว +59

    Omg sooo cute my ship adreinnatte are so cute together 😂

  • @cherlinkim101
    @cherlinkim101 4 ปีที่แล้ว +56

    "ADRINETTE IS IN THE AIR"
    You mean, LOVE IS IN THE AIR?

  • @fieryicymilkman6098
    @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +60

    I feel like it wasn't either of their faults. Adrian dad literally told him he was going last minute so he had no time to go and transform. He was on a field trip so it's not like in paris where he could just ditch the class with a valid excuse and have time to transform and text ladybug. We also know that him and ladybug don't receive text unless their in their superhero form and even if cat noir could of used the signal thing what if marinette just look at her phone to see if there was an akuma attack but their wasn't she would of thought cat noir was playing around and wasn't serious. WHILE ladybug got way too mad and should of just focused on the villain at hand so that they could go to paris as fast as possible instead of breaking cat noir's heart mid battle and causing problems. She should of knew cat noir had a good excuse and let him finish. Last time she went on a trip master fu gave her the horse miraculous to go back to paris in case of a akuma attack and said she should be able to have fun. Why couldn't she do that now? Especially since she's the guardian she doesn't even have to go to fu for it. She should of had a backup plan incase things went wrong. Even if cat noir would of stayed in paris it would still be damaged. She's the only one who can purify akumas (cat noir can cataclysm it but what if he has to use it for something else) and repair everything. She should of knew that cat noir can't defend paris alone and that she needed to be their in some way. Hawk moth probably released the sentimonster so that cat noir and ladybug would be distracted with it instead of fighting him in new york but saw that they weren't there and thought it was pointless for it to keep going. I feel like it could of been prevented and that it was just unfortunate circumstances. The only thing that was good about this is that we know that ladybug really doesn't need to fix everything unless the eiffel tower falls down or something so we can have marinette/ladybug akumatized or be away and have cat noir defeat villains ALONE :D

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      @Ashley Michel I say it's just unfortunate circumstance but could of been avoided in many ways like if ladybug brought the horse miraculous like the last time she went on a trip

    • @jamesdaly7440
      @jamesdaly7440 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@fieryicymilkman6098 Yeah, the story tries to make you believe he could have told ladybug about him leaving, but in reality he really had no time. And also, he did tell ladybug it was a last minute thing.

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@jamesdaly7440 He had time, even if he had to tell her on the trip or when he reached New York. It would've been more complicated sure but if he pushes the button, alerting her then he knows she'll transform into Ladybug. And in that case they could communicate with each other via text or call. She was most angry at him because he didn't tell her about a change in plans. So had he made an effort to get in touch with her, although this would have complicated things for both of them she wouldn't have gotten so angry at him.

    • @Soundwave1900
      @Soundwave1900 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@fieryicymilkman6098 she brought. How do you think she was planning to come to Paris as soon as Cat rings the signal?

    • @jamesdaly7440
      @jamesdaly7440 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@kabsageigj8941 i still dont think he really had time to tell her, if he ringed the cat buzzer without any akuma attack happening, as fieryicymilkman said she probably would have thought he was messing around.

  • @user-xj8bn1su8l
    @user-xj8bn1su8l 3 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    Maybe after getting close to Kagami, Adrien became more comfortable with 'romance' and 'socializing' cuz I personally see Kagami and Adrien dating only as a cure to Adrien whilst to Kagami it's actual love

  • @twilluz7188
    @twilluz7188 4 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    Well done very good review agree with a lot.I really love your channel ❤️

  • @matthewwatson3160
    @matthewwatson3160 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    well according to Thomas Astruc himself. They had 2 hours of content and most of Chloe's scenes were cut from the final tv movie to get it down to 62 minutes. But hey can't wait for Miraculous World: Shanghi to air around Christmas. At least with season 4 being delayed due to covid we get to see the specials set between seasons 3 and 4.

  • @priscillaguerra4316
    @priscillaguerra4316 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Your reviews and commentaries are phenomenal, and I always wait to hear your thoughts on Miraculous shows. And I agree...I'm SOOOO glad Alya FINALLY broke with Marinette. I was so pumped when I saw that. Thanks, Smarty Pants!

  • @kirakira7682
    @kirakira7682 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I loved that it had a lot of elements from different things I like. I am a fan of both Anairis Quinones, Alejandro Saab, and Hamilton. I was super excited about them referencing the American Revolution. There was even a cute comic on Instagram about Daveed Digs's Lafayette and Liri the freedom kwami.
    Something pointed out to me was Marinette's maturing physically, or like, better animation? As in, Cristina Vee deepening the high-pitched voice and Marinette's hair being darker and not bright blue anymore. Though, character development is always nice and hopefully happens this season.
    I hope they keep in contact with the heroes and friends they made in New York! I really liked the potential in the New York Heroes, and hope they get brought up again. Also, if this means there are many heroes, that more goes into the extended hero-verse of Miraculous! Also, I just love Aeon's character.
    I hope Sabrina keeps in contact with the American guy, even as just friends. I like that he was able to get through to her about being her own person. I know Marinette tried, but this new character was actually able to do it. I hope that continues in its own right and we see Sabrina mature into her own person.
    I know the Mrs Mendeleev arc didn't go anywhere, so my hope is that it continues into the season? Like, an arc that wasn't meant to be finished in this episode but continues on.

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      It's how SAMG have always coloured Ladybug hair (see season one) the other studios colour it more blue.
      I couldn't say if the timing issues will mean the deeper voices will stick but I've got multiple copies of the same episodes and some are deep like this and some are squeekier. it's supposed to be a side effect of a PAL show being retimed poorly to NTSC format.
      I think the reason Sabrina got a fella was more about Chloe than Sabrina they want to further isolate Chloe and torture her a bit more.

  • @TheBestOne_hi_34
    @TheBestOne_hi_34 4 ปีที่แล้ว +23

    5:40 Actually I wonder if Lila Would Hate Ladybug even More and Call her out for her leaving Paris Abandoned because of that...😏 Heck it would be Cool to see Some people Now Looking at Ladybug and Cat noir and Being like : 😕🤨

    • @PlatinumDagger
      @PlatinumDagger 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      That should be used as ammo to take shots at lady bug morality and ego next season and Hawk moth can use that to stir the pot even more.

  • @freddiet.rowlet525
    @freddiet.rowlet525 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I'm interested to know what they intend to do with the American Miraculous Box. The bonus end scene clearly implies the creation of a new junior superhero team with Eagle and Uncanny as the main pair, but are they going to mention that in the main show, spin off?

  • @candace219
    @candace219 4 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    6:13 your voice matched up with Marinette lips perfectly!
    Was that on purpose?

  • @doomertunes1092
    @doomertunes1092 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Edit: Adrien leaving NY meant she'd need to wait a week before she could see him again. Chat Noir surrendering his miraculous meant she'd never see him again, and she'd also never be able to find him since she doesn't know his identity. Losing someone for a week is significantly less worse than losing someone forever.
    They got stuck in a door and both sides of the door kept hitting them simultaneously.
    Literally the funniest part of the movie.
    Followed by Marinette falling off her bike.
    Repetitive failure is definitely funny at times like these.

  • @katiemarie5601
    @katiemarie5601 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I absolutely LOVED the special and I was so happy about it.
    The only critiques (if you want to call them that) are that I thought there would be more with Chloe. I do love how Sabrina had more character growth aswell. I don't know about you guys, but I thought there would be more with Alya, Mari, Chloe, and Sabrina being roomates on the trip.
    I also agree on the whole ending of season 3 and the transition into the NY special. I feel like there was no increasing growth between the two it just kind of went from Adrien completely seeing Mari as just a friend and with Kagami to Adrien and Mari obviously (even if they dont want to admit it) seeing each other as more than friends. I was a little confused on that because I did think season 3 ended with Lukanette and Adrigami and it wasn't a smooth transition but I did still really like the Adrienette moments and such.
    The other thing I wanted to mention was that I feel like we didn't really get to see much with Majestia and Knight Owl, and I was expecting something bigger with maybe the villain or something and Mrs. Mandelaiv. Again, this is my may opinion and honestly, I thought that the special was very well put together and was AMAZING.
    I really loved Chats and LB's character growth and same with Adrienette and the american heroes.
    They did a great job with the whole storyline and I was just so happy and enjoyed the special sooo much.
    Can't wait for Shanghai and season 4!!! (:
    - Also what about the Miracle box?
    I loved how in the end they gave foreshadowing to the Shanghai special too!!
    Sorry if this is kinda all over the place (and long too), I was just trying to put all my thoughts out there at once lol (:

  • @r3mhub637
    @r3mhub637 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Adrien in Seasons 1, 2, 3: sHe'S juST A FrEiND
    Marinette in New York: He'S JuST A FRienD

  • @kirannkornat7761
    @kirannkornat7761 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I think Mendeleev’s pregnancy was just to signal that time progression does exist.

    • @deematmok8156
      @deematmok8156 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@shesjustafriend2499 it is
      Also your name is hilarious

  • @cristyflaherty4902
    @cristyflaherty4902 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Alya figured out Nino was Carapace because of the way he talked. I also liked the explanation because it explains why no one can figure out their identities even though its so obvious. I think Mrs.Bustiee (I know I spelled her name wrong) will be an amazing mom. I really liked the girl superheros being dressed up as boys and it took me a while to figure it out, they were really good at hiding the fact they weren't the original team and were girls (That part didn't matter but it went with the original team being boy and they are girls). They could have showed Chloe being hated more than ever after stealing the miraculeses, and I get they could use a power up to fly but why couldn't they have taken the horse miraculous with them(Max doesn't have it permanently like Ladybug and Catnoir). I liked Adrien temporarily quitting and seeing Ladybugs reaction to thinking they won't work together again. And overall ADRIANETTE/LADYNOIR FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Only Hawkmoth, Mayura, Snake Noir & Dragon Bug know Chloe stole the Miracle Box, unless Marinette is so cruel as to go in front of a press camera and accuse her of "co-operating with a terrorist" which she didn't do for Lila - so she's not likely to do to Chloe. Everyone else in Paris was under the venom spell and so didn't see a thing - so the two villains know who the part time heroes are - the rest of Paris doesn't unless Hawkmoth decides to leak it to the press. & anyway she can claim she was akumatised and so isn't held accountable anyway.
      & yes she could have easily have taken the Horse Miraculous with her to New York and gotten back to Paris instantly. No need to fly. To be fair she was in a middle of a fight and couldn't just leave Uncanny Valley and Sparrow alone, and Robustus 2 was only active for 7 minutes before the powers were pulled. Not that she was really thinking straight at the time anyway as she was to busy arguing to do her job properly. She'd likely have had to detransform fed Tikki and re-transform to fight Robustus 2 anyway - and even then if the feather powers had pulled before she could "reset" she'd still not be able to cast her cure (according to the New York special alone) according to the 3 previous seasons - she likely could have cast it anyway.
      They have avoided saying if the cure works on the mundane though - such as run away busses, Escaped zoo animals, crashed helicopter and the like. So perhaps they always thought it wouldn't - slight problem with that - it renders historical Ladybug's powers kinda nonsensical if it doesn't work on the mundane too. Which might be a problem - especially as past holders are going to show up in some form so I hear. I guess the cure works on demons and such - but what about Aliens ? (yes Aliens Bunnyx specifically mentions Aliens)

  • @emilias8618
    @emilias8618 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I think that another reason people have a hard time figuring out who the superheroes are is probably because of the total personality shift of marinette and adrien when they transform. This obviously only applies to people close to them who actually know them irl but I don’t think a random person who has never even met marinette would be able to figure it out. Like you said, Alya was able to figure out that Nino was Carapace really quickly, but I believe that this is because she is extremely close to him, is portrayed to be good at that kind of thing, the timing matched up, and he acted exactly like Nino (calling people “dude” like every 5 seconds lol). Marinette completely dials her personality to level 100 when she’s ladybug, and adrien as chat noir is a lot more free and wild, kind of like an outlet to express himself bc he can’t as the perfect supermodel his dad forces him to be. As for “Oh but they literally look the same,” sometimes people’s appearance does change with using a miraculous. Marinette as Ladynoir has that one long braid, Marinette as Multimouse has space buns, Alya as Rena Rouge has cool ombré hair, Chloe as Queen Bee has that cool black streak. So who’s to say that they don’t completely change? It could be someone completely different looking under the mask, who knows? Also, finally, to quote the wise words of Plagg, “People are blind.” Idk if that made any sense, but Thank you for listening to my Ted talk.

  • @kimella3648
    @kimella3648 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I just can't help but mention about the hotdog scene where Mari and Adrien ate the hotdogs and started floating. They literally threw the half eaten hotdog on the floor like bruh x'D
    Some peeps wanted to eat those

  • @cloadetta2504
    @cloadetta2504 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I honestly really loved this movie! The animation quality was just- uGGH I CANT EVEN- IT WAS SO GOOD! Like- didheidisiidhsdksj my god- THE ENDING HAD ME. LIKE- THERES ANOTHER GUARDIAN? EXCUSE ME WHAT- JSDHSJDHSJFHSMM

  • @cartooncottage2024
    @cartooncottage2024 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I think the issue with Mrs.Bustier and Ms. Mendiliev was placed there as just a set-up for season 4.

  • @dennirafrancois5219
    @dennirafrancois5219 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Could Alya figuring out Nino's secret identity be of love? With the way that Alya looked at Carapace in amazement and that spark in her eye, could she have fallen for Carapace like she does for Nino, and in doing so, her love was strong enough to break through the blinds that magic holds? Like the intro says "the power of love always so strong". Just a theory.

  • @50ksubscriberswithonevideo84
    @50ksubscriberswithonevideo84 4 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    I’m still a little sad they didn’t talk about the miracle box.

    • @jellysourbean
      @jellysourbean 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yeah that could lead to a spin off

  • @dianix2011
    @dianix2011 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    In case you haven't check Thomas Astruc's twitter account (creator of MLB) He stated that the special was supposed to be 2 hours long. And there was an arc about Chloe and the teacher, but it had to be cut short because of budget. I guess they couldn't fit it all perfectly for an hour episode.

  • @tulip135
    @tulip135 4 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    3:03 but in miracle queen the problems weren’t really fixed; master fu’s no longer the guardian right?

    • @fieryicymilkman6098
      @fieryicymilkman6098 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      The things there were way bigger since master fu lost most of the miraculous which could of meant ladybug and cat noir could of been defeated and lose their miraculous and hawk moth would get his wish at a big cost which could of resulted in WAYY more damage then what happened here.

    • @nmtlnm
      @nmtlnm 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yeah but hawkmoth didn't get the miracle box.

    • @urfavlolobaji
      @urfavlolobaji 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      I am wondering if marinette needs to know adriens identity 🤣

    • @mara5759
      @mara5759 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yeah because hawk moth got to know the identity of the miraculous box holder...so he made ladybug the new miraculous box holder since hawk moth doesn't know the real identity of ladybug so it's cool

  • @gamingtiger31
    @gamingtiger31 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    0:50 he wasn't looking at her. He was looking at the city.

    • @Abielle
      @Abielle 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      He was looking at Marinette and the sunset. How do I know? (1) the sun beams strongly as he looks out the window, and his eyes shift from Marinette to the sky but when it cuts back to his face, his eyes shift back....and you can assume back to Marinette. (2) The last time he looked at the sunset he was looking at it with Marinette (3) He said the same thing both times "it's beautiful" and I think we can all agree he didn't hug Marinette then just because he likes the sky so much. ;-)

    • @gamingtiger31
      @gamingtiger31 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@Abielle interesting ಠ_ಠ

  • @vixaria3182
    @vixaria3182 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Just one thing, did they forget that there's a timer when they use their special powers? Cause it definitely seemed that more than 5-6 mins went by when they used their special powers, or maybe its just me

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      They did de-power in the sewer after running away from the adult heroes having both used their "powers" at that point - but I don't recall them calling attention to the beeping - at least not that I noticed so far - I'll try to remember to watch for that next time I see the episode.

    • @joseph86255
      @joseph86255 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      I feel that as they've gotten more experienced, they've gotten more time before they change back.

  • @WrenBird449
    @WrenBird449 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Just started watching your content and subscribed because you actually see the GOOD in the show, whereas the majority of TH-cam commentators really bash on it to no end. I feel like you have the broadest understanding of not only what what goes wrong but also what's right and what the director/writers intended for the overall themes/mood of the show. You make me feel less guilty about loving a children's show, lol. You've earned a permanent subscriber!

  • @caticliosanimations6927
    @caticliosanimations6927 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I loved Sparrow voice. Holy cow! Dark Owl's character is actually the voice actor for Marinette.

  • @janesvirtualworld
    @janesvirtualworld 4 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    I give the special a 9.5/10, I really wanted Paris to be mad

    • @bmb4rllyxcgsss837
      @bmb4rllyxcgsss837 4 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      Same, this will make more character growth on our characters and the Parisians will realize that they can't always be dependent on LB and CN every single time. Looking forward for s4.

    • @jellysourbean
      @jellysourbean 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@bmb4rllyxcgsss837 MAYBE, in season 4 Paris will be party destroyed

  • @kabsageigj8941
    @kabsageigj8941 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I have a very positive opinion of this special. It has flaws sure but overall, really well done. The animation is incredible (so happy SAMG is animating Shanghai too!) I really like the progression we see from Adrien with the Adrienette ship and how Marinette is trying to see him as "just a friend" now, even if her way of doing that is very flawed and didn't work out for her too well. The Ladynoir in this episode was also beautiful. I like the yellow rose Cat Noir gave her in the beginning further symbolizing he is trying to get over her. Cat Noir/Adrien got good focus in this special which was really amazing to see. It was time for Cat Noir to have a break down like this, seeing him go through that and come back from it, I think really bodes well for what we could see in the future. It was nice to see Lukanette and Adrigami briefly so we could get a glimpse into what roles they are going to play later on. The young American heroes were very enjoyable characters. Not a fan of them scheming to get Adrien and Marinette in the same room and stuff but other than that I liked them. Sabrina getting a little mini development of her own was neat to see. It looks like she's slowly becoming more independent of Chloe and getting tired of being bossed around by her. Chloe didn't get much screen time which I personally don't mind as the special wasn't about her but from the little she has you can see how they are building off of the developments from the season 3 finale. She was very anti-social through the special and didn't even want to go to New York. Which brings up a very interesting point. Her parents actually forced her to go. Alya and Nino both got their fair share of time in this special which was nice to see even if I don't much care for "Operation New York" Liiri was cute and the Eagle power was pretty cool. It's disappointing we didn't get to see it used by the hero but for what we got it was great. The guardian asking for the Miraculous at the end was a good sign of what's to come. I think the weakest elements were the main adult heroes and the villian (as a character, I liked the doc ock inspired akuma). They were serviceable but could've been better. Except Doorman, for some reason I really liked him. XD

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      There was a lot of shared art assets from Ghostforce in it I noticed.

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@90lancaster Interesting, I'm not very familiar with the show but I know SAMG is animating it.

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@kabsageigj8941 Times Square is the same, and there was a Graphiti wall that was also the same as well as a lot of other buildings - so I think they just shared them - I expect they will do the same with Pixie Girl too - which is also set in New York.
      I wonder if they might go back to London on the show and establish some art assets for that - which might then show up in their other "In development" show 'Miss Rose' which is also set in London.

    • @kabsageigj8941
      @kabsageigj8941 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@90lancaster That would be cool. I'd love to see a London special. Maybe to learn a bit more about Felix.

  • @soyurluve
    @soyurluve 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Alya knew nino’s secret right away because how he always says: Dude! LadyDude and more dudes!

  • @GraceSmith-zg2tk
    @GraceSmith-zg2tk 4 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    so no body is gonna talk about them switching the voice actors to crappy ones on us?

    • @toaster8094
      @toaster8094 4 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      Haha I believe that too! But I screen recorded a scene from part of the movie and made the pitch higher and it sounded like it- I’m guessing they didn’t have good recorded cause of corona and they were at home or they just made the pitch deeper or they are getting older but I don’t have a 100 verified answer

    • @kailisamantha.mp3
      @kailisamantha.mp3 4 ปีที่แล้ว +18

      Your voices do get lower as you get older, especially guys. I’m pretty sure the voice actors don’t use strictly their voice when reading their lines so maybe they were told to not make their voices so high to show that the characters are getting older. Other than that I agree and maybe they had to do some recordings out of the studio so maybe it was harder for them.

    • @Hjmh93
      @Hjmh93 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      It didn't change lol

    • @GracielovesStars
      @GracielovesStars 4 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      Actually there all the same except Nino

    • @kailisamantha.mp3
      @kailisamantha.mp3 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      The version I watched was pitched lower cuz copyright so I wasn’t sure if it was the same ppl or not

  • @heerasartandmusicgallery1600
    @heerasartandmusicgallery1600 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    3:09 actually it was mentioned that they will see each other at school again tomorrow so i just dont understand why marinette chased him to say stay longer even though they will see each other tomorrow! and also adrien could have said bye to nino, max, kim, ivan, alya, and others but he said bye to only marinette.. hmmmmmm interesting?..

  • @evergreenxd1491
    @evergreenxd1491 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    The really got my hopes up for ADRIENETTE, I was sad thinking that Lukanette or Adriengami would happen

  • @rainbowquartz2.074
    @rainbowquartz2.074 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Adrien left Kagami in Paris and he felt nothing, but when he left Marinette at New York, he felt depressed. It's this the sign of Adrien's secretly crush on Marinette???

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Yes - Plagg constantly teases him about it in Season 3 especially. He's been calling Marinette "Adrien's Girlfriend" since Origins and that is why Adrien has his catchphrase of "She's Just a Friend" as Plagg keep poking him about it.
      Remember Kagami tried to kiss him and he pulled away, The times he's nearly Kissed Marinette (like in Horrificator) - he didn't pull away.

  • @UUUU-dn9wz
    @UUUU-dn9wz 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Good review, i lived the special too. The only 2 things i do not completely agree with is that: 1st, LB had the right to be angry but at the same time she was kinda stupid to tell his teammate “i can no longer trust you”, since that is both exaggerated and dangerous to tell to someone that has cataclysm activated and can potentially obliterate NewYork if he does not control it. 2nd Marinette was obviously more upset about Cat Noir because she would have seen Adrien again in 2 days, while she feared to never see CN again

  • @BG0178
    @BG0178 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I think Newyork special is started really where season 3 ends as relationships. At the end of season 3, you see that Marinette accepts that Kagami and Adrien might have a thing so she had to give up on Adrien. As someone who falls in love with another, things wont change that quickly. It takes times to progress things and move on from a relationship in real life. So i think Marinatte is just trying to move on from Adrien but she is still in love with him and same as Cat noir. He also tries to move on from Ladybug. About Luka and Kagami, they never kissed before sooo its a movement for their relationship even in this episode and Luka understands that Marinette needs some time after Adrien. So i think timeline is perfect and they will be like this in the season 4 , Marinette tries to move on, and cat tries to move on. At least some part of season 4 i m sure that we will see that.

  • @ladynawar
    @ladynawar 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Title: "Adrienette is in the air!"
    Thumbnail: *well yes, but actually yes.*

  • @j12k8
    @j12k8 4 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    There were some errors to improve in the episode. But overall i loved it. I wanna different miraculous from all over the world. I can wait for season four and five.

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I'd love to see the Ancient Greece / Atlantis box - but that may have been destroyed.

  • @windshieldlaugh7411
    @windshieldlaugh7411 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    I like that they named it Miraculous World, that’s a hint for maybe future cities and a expanding Miraculous world.

  • @workkingtrojan2999
    @workkingtrojan2999 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    From season 1 to 3---
    Adrien: She is just a friend.
    New York special---
    Marinette : He is just a friend.
    Me: What the heck is this??? 😒 Why are they so friendly???🙄That's not fair.😑

    • @jellysourbean
      @jellysourbean 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Marinette was just trying to convince her self that.

  • @gnicole1700
    @gnicole1700 4 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    The sudden change in the voices kinda ruined my whole experience honestly, but besides that i think it's really good.
    I feel like Marinette's feelings are kinda relatable, she doesn't know if she should move on or not, and i also get why she cares about chat noir giving his miraculous rather than adrien leaving.
    I mean she could still meet adrien again, but not for chat noir. Also technically she feels closer to chat noir, even if as a partner. I wouldn't say that's a development but i think it's kind of relatable?
    Also i feel like ms mendelieve(sorry i don't really know how to spell it) is actually relevant? I mean i feel sorta bad for her for getting hated? Sure they're not really relevant but i still genuinely care for them. I honestly think the subplot with Sabrina was more out of the blue (a sudden possible romance? Like-)
    Also the dance in the sky adrienette scene, i think it'll be funny if each other pointed out how they're good at flying (from their space superhero costumes).
    Also how do you dance in the sky??? I mean seriously it looks more like they're hugging honestly.

    • @jessicab_0603
      @jessicab_0603 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      i honestly liked marionettes new voice. it showed they were growing up and around this time they should be around 15 or almost 15. and adrien had the same actor but he squeaky voice deepens a bit and he was less energetic which i LOVED. and marionette finally wasn’t so cringe and squeaky for once

  • @sugarpopz6949
    @sugarpopz6949 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Marinette reminded me of Anna from Frozen in this movie high-key

  • @nickioleary8577
    @nickioleary8577 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    4:15 Maybe Alya figured it out by Carapace’s voice and mannerisms (I’m pretty sure the voice isn’t masked when in costume, seeing as Uncanny’s recording of Marinette saying she couldn’t b LB without Chat seemed to still sound like her in her hero persona seeing as Adrien didn’t say anything about the voice being Marinette’s rather knowing it was LB)? If you look at the episode Anansi, she does give him a look when he refers to LB as “dude.” Alya has also shown to have figured out a lot more about LB, CN, and the Miraculous as a whole, and given that the universe established that this is not something easily found out, I think it’s easy to believe that she’s very smart and therefore able to work out who Carapace was

  • @jajathenewking6131
    @jajathenewking6131 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Hock Moth is now Mr. Worldwide.

  • @dayschange2
    @dayschange2 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    As someone catching up on the series after a long time away, and uncertain of exactly where the specials fit in the timeline, this one was really weird for me. Because it seems really clear that this one takes place between seasons 3 and 4, and I had assumed that Adrien and Kagami were dating by the end of season 3. Granted, Adrien was more passively letting it happen than anything else, but nonetheless, it was really weird seeing everyone giving Marinette such a hard time when she was seemingly doing exactly what she should have been doing in that situation. Her crush got a girlfriend. Why wouldn't she try to recenter her expectations to just being Adrien's friend, even if it meant exercising a bit of "fake it 'til you make it" attitude? I dunno. It just felt weird.
    I was also a bit sad that we didn't get to see what had Gorilla so on edge about visiting New York. The animators literally have his face go green when he finds out about the trip. For a minute, it seems like he was just afraid of flying, but he kept listening to his special relaxation tapes even after they settled into the hotel. And given that season 5 all but stated he's from America, I kind of thought we were going to find out he had a wife and kids or something that he had to leave behind when Felix's dad sent him over to France in exchange for the use of the peacock miraculous.

  • @pixisticks
    @pixisticks 4 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Andddd I'm starting to ship adrienette again. Dang

  • @NarutaUzumaki_
    @NarutaUzumaki_ 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I just wished they didn’t change Nino’s voice actor. Imma miss his old surfer voice😔😔

  • @jen3232
    @jen3232 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I feel with all the adriennette moments I definitely see Adrien having a bigger crush on Marinette in season 4,, but I don't think that they will actually do anything about it,, unfortunately

    • @esayem7746
      @esayem7746 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Same. In the synopsis for the New York special, it says what happens in New York, stays in New York and it just made me nervous about what happened between them. I feel like he's just going to put it to the back of his mind, even though it's clear he's catching feelings for her. But we'll just have to see.

    • @jen3232
      @jen3232 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@esayem7746 yeah,, i read the synopsis too,, and actually I am glad the writers aren't focusing to much on ships and actually focusing on getting marinette some character development

    • @KarolM_7543
      @KarolM_7543 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Leah Amador yessss although I wouldn’t mind if the creators slipped in some more Adrien and Mari moments tbh😏however something that really pissed me off is how the creators took so long for there to be some sort of "relationship” or "growth” between Mari and adrien. Yea there’s some moments between them in seasons 1,2, and 3 but in this movie we saw so much more "romance” than in those 3 seasons combined so hopefully they develop Maris character into a not so shy girl anymore. I love her for that but after seeing her character like that for 3 seasons straight I want to see some type of actual growth. Same goes for Adrien. I’m Hoping he will get a little more freedom or at least be a little “outgoing” towards Mari and hopefully show her that he’s catching feelings.🙀

  • @limshien2045
    @limshien2045 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Oh I saw on twitter with some fans asking Thomas that wasn’t this special supposed to be 2 hours long, with more character arcs with Chloe, Miss Madeleine (that science teacher), and the principal. He said it was in the initial stages but drop them in the end. I think it should be because it’s twice as expensive to make a 2 hour movie as compared to 1. You can find this on his replies on his twitter account. The topic discussed were in French

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      If they don't reinsert the Chloe plot into season 4 that is going to be such a plot hole.

  • @mika7446
    @mika7446 4 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I know this has nothing to do with the video but I just wanna say that I ship Marichat more than any of their other ships. The reason why is because they're themselves when they're with each other. Like that one episode when they were hanging out alone at Marinette's because they got their hearts broken. And aghhhh I just ship them so much- I hope there are more marichat moments in the next season :)

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      #Marichat where Marinette isn't being a jerk is what we really need on this show - instead we get #Adrienette cringe like Puppeteer 2.. I'd rather they were cuddled up on a roof under a shared blanket watching the night sky on the bakery roof drinking Cocoa as Cat and designer than failing to communicate as heroes or civilians.
      For so many reasons. But mostly because it's the easiest way to get them to know each other without so much pressure on them from themselves or people like Alya (who really isn't helping).

    • @regularpotato
      @regularpotato 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@90lancaster i agree 100% Adriennete is pure cringe. Give us marichat where they can be genuine

  • @dianag.1362
    @dianag.1362 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Thank God for someone who gets right to the point, explains it well, and does it quick, unlike CartoonApocalypse, you earned a sub from me

  • @waterpetalsXD
    @waterpetalsXD 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    2:13 Aeon is right that danger brings them closer together

  • @nikolaivanniekerk1626
    @nikolaivanniekerk1626 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I liked it, it showed Catnoir and LadyBug being partners not ladybug the save the day superhero. I mostly liked how ladybug reacted but I think she was far too mean to cantor, but it was made up for when she hugged him and told she could never do it without him (but still a bit too harsh). Catnoir development was great. the psychological trauma of alsmot killing someone and having his love, Ladybug, being disappointed in him, made for great development. this development being him doubting himself a little and him thinking he was unworthy of his miraculous. oh and Adrienette was adorable. Overall it was great just I feel bad for Catnoir, I still think Ladybug was a bit too harsh but it was awesome.

  • @jessicab_0603
    @jessicab_0603 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I love how their voices change prob new actors but they aren’t squeaky anymore and they have seemed to mature. What i’m hoping for season 4 is that their voices will change like what happened in the movie and maybe some new outfits or new locations would be nice cause i’m kinda tired of seeing the school and marionette/adriens houses every episode. maybe more field trips? also the graphics in the movie are absolutely stunning. and hawk moth actually had good plans which made me into the movie more. and i LOVED the marionette and adrien moments they were so adorable. u don’t see thoes that much in the tv except for marionette stalking him. she wasn’t so stalkish in the movie which was nice and she wasn’t acting so cringe except the part where marionette was sitting with adrien but i’ll let it slide since it was funny. Also i LOVED that their was new superheros around their age. also if u noticed adrien has the same actor but his voice was deepened and he wasn’t so flirtatious and not much quirky jokes. i think the movie was telling us they are growing up in a way. i’m pretty sure they are 14-15 in this movie. in the next season i hope their will be a time where hawk moth actually defeats them for once (but things will be better eventually) cause i’m always like oh don’t worry hawk moth won’t win. also i hope marionette and adrien or cat noir and ladybug will date next season because we deserve it. also i really want adrien and marionette to figure out eachothers secret (without the world ending ofc haha)

    • @animedude8712
      @animedude8712 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Actually only one VA was changed. Everyone else has there same VA. Most likely do to the pandemic they all had to work from home and couldn’t get the voice right or they’re changing the tone.

  • @cartooncottage2024
    @cartooncottage2024 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Alya figured out Nino's identity because she knows his mannerisms and as someone who has experience working as a superhero/sidekick with Ladybug and Chat Noir, she could use her deduction skills to figure out it would be Nino, especially since he would want to protect his girlfriend.

  • @verniceelijahsarte4590
    @verniceelijahsarte4590 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    UNDERSTAND WHAT NINO AND ALYA SAID:
    NINO: i love adrien but he's like a baby chick who just started cracking out of it's shell.. He's having a hard time understanding people's signals...
    ALYA: what signals? Marinette isn't really sending them properly...

  • @tylerensminger
    @tylerensminger 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I thought it was decent. I like the idea of having higher stakes and seeing Ladybug and Cat Noir deal with ramifications of not being able to fix everything.

  • @everlastingdragon4520
    @everlastingdragon4520 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Smarty Pants: Adrien and Marinette have a dance floating through the air.
    Me: Wait, what?

  • @emmamills671
    @emmamills671 4 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I felt like screaming cayse my second fave ship Adrienette was happening (my first fav ship is marichat) so i screamed in a pilllow

    • @KarolM_7543
      @KarolM_7543 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      IMAGINE HOW STRONG THEYRE FEELINGS WILL BECOME ONCE THEY FIGURE OUT EACH OTHERS IDENTITIES CONSIDERING MARI LIKE ADRIEN AND ADRIEN LIKES LADYBUG SO IT ALL TIES TOGETHER🙀

    • @emmamills671
      @emmamills671 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@KarolM_7543 i know

  • @reina6515
    @reina6515 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I'm not a good at analyzing things like stuff needed removed or added so it's an almost perfect episode for me. My only issue was how the their voices got deeper, the first time I heard marinette's voice at the start of the special it felt really off to me like I'm hearing a totally different character, it didn't seem like I'm listening to LB at all. I understand if they had some issues dubbing this because of corona but if they can re-dub this I'll be happy. Also if they're gonna change her voice pitch to low, I hope that they change their mind or just make it little lower or maybe make it lower little by little so the viewers can get pretty used to it and they'll feel comfortable listening to her new tone of voice. Same thing also goes for other characters. Thanks for reading my long rant about the voice thing.

  • @cloadetta2504
    @cloadetta2504 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    “It was also a bit upsetting that we didn’t see much Chloe in this episode”
    Me : wait- did- did you say EPISODE- LOL

  • @Misty-Rainforest
    @Misty-Rainforest 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    I think Alya figured out Nino was carapace since when he was saving her, Nino didn’t put on confidence front like Marinate and Adrian do. Plus he slips up saying “dude” in his normal way. The final reason I’ll leave you with is the fact that they are very close and openly in love making them recognize each other and their feelings.

  • @apaiaa
    @apaiaa 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Remember guys, this is between season 4 and FIVE. We still have a long way to go.

    • @IsmaelCiulla
      @IsmaelCiulla 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      weiiz no it’s seasons 3 and 4 not 4 and 5

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Both "Miraculous World" specials take place between Season 3 and 4. Next time it looks like we will get the build up to Shadow Moth (the fusion form of Peacock and Butterfly Miraculous) Gabriel will use in Season 4.
      I'm starting to wonder if we might even get "level up Ladybug" too in the Shanghai Special since they threw the Space Miraculous at us out of nowhere and are basically just using it as transport. I can see it making some sense to power her up once she gets Tikki back after loosing her for a little while.
      Unless they save the level Up mode for a bit later in season 4, but there is some suggestion that one of the dolls is Level Up Ladybug and that is out in October so - why release it months before season 4 is out.. ?

    • @IsmaelCiulla
      @IsmaelCiulla 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      90 Lancaster 😎

  • @koubeij
    @koubeij 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Am i the only one here that hasn't seen it??
    ;-;
    I didn't know where to look TwT

    • @Sedra_ki
      @Sedra_ki 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      If you find out, don't forget to tell me

    • @Hi-tz8iy
      @Hi-tz8iy 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Its on Disney, if you have Xfinity X1 you can just search using microphone on remote "miraculous new york" thats how i watched it on my TV. Idk if it only works on Xfinity X1 though

  • @courtisty6906
    @courtisty6906 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Hey Smarty Pants! I have been following you for quite a while now and I’ve been trying to watch this episode since it “came out” I wanted to ask you about where/how you found this? I know it was supposed to come out at 8pm on Disney channel and Disney plus but it’s not coming up🤔 Thank you for making your good videos and I wish the best of luck 😊

    • @kirakira7682
      @kirakira7682 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      Don't go to the link mentioned by u/interdimensionalrift because it is NOT a bootleg that (for now) works. I repeat. DO NOT use the link as it is a bootleg!
      www.reddit.com/r/miraculousladybug/comments/izrrtp/where_you_can_watch_the_new_york_special/

  • @kittycheshire5099
    @kittycheshire5099 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    If Uncanny can easily see through Marinette and Adrien's disguises because she's a robot, not properly human, then shouldn't Markov know who Ladybug and Cat Noir really are?

  • @sarmenti586
    @sarmenti586 4 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    Imo LB should have realized Chat is the one really cares for her and she starts to fall in love with him but Chat starts to carry on aaaaaand we see some emotional scenes. Marinette x Adrien just seems pointless to me rn. Marinette should definately fall in love with Chat, it just makes more sense than Adrien.
    Edit: typo

    • @90lancaster
      @90lancaster 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I have some problems with both #LadyNoir (when they are not actually friends and don't socialise outside battles) also ladybug is quite often a bit of a jerk to Cat Noir (especially in Reflektdoll) where she hits him and treats him like he's an idiot. I'd rather she actually cared about him and was keeping him away due to Cat Blanc - that simply treating him like he's useful and otherwise forgetting he exists.
      Also #Adrienette when Marinette is making so little effort to get to know Adrien as a human being. Not to mention Adrien is so attention starved he's coming across like he's mildly crushing on Marinette as she reminds him of Ladybug Physically and so she represents something he can't have - but he doesn't want to letch on her so he keeps her at arms length most of the time... besides he's asked her twice if she likes him and she's said twice she doesn't so why would he think she's lying out of panic ? he might actually genuinely fancy her and think just like LB - she's not interested and that just makes the poor kid sad than none of the girls Like-like him who he likes or like-likes*
      By Like-Like I mean "fancy".

  • @dweronika1170
    @dweronika1170 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I hated that they put the teacher part in but didn’t do anything with it, so as much as I SCREAMED when I heard that Miss B (I can’t spell her name) is pregnant I don’t think this was necessary. Now the part with Adrien’s guard. Like ok, cool, he’s scared of flying, but why do we need to know this? Why did we have 3-4 scenes reminding us that he’s scared of flying? I have no idea. Also the Sabrina love storyline. I would’ve LOVED to see her have her own 2-3 minutes of story instead of short clips.
    Also as the story progresses Marinette gets more cringey around Adrien. Like come on, I know it’s natural to be shy around your crush, but to run into a door? Call a plane seat a heating seat? Seriously, it’s making me uncomfortable.
    Now onto the parts I loved: I loved to see more Alya and Nino interactions because we don’t get them much. I loved every LadyNoir moment. Also, I loved how they put little details here and there hinting that Natalie is REALLY sick after using the peacock miraculous.
    Overall the special was great, I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT. I will definitely be rewatching it AGAIN
    Rating: 9,5/10

  • @shifaismail6692
    @shifaismail6692 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I ligit loved everything about it, I do agree it definitely doesnt fit with the S3 ending, which is why I found it so hard to comprehend that the special is part of the series, like the animation was different(in my opinion improved) which like made me.think of it as something fanmade🤣🤣🤣🤣 but srsly I found everything just amazing

  • @kayleighskopekimnottheimpo913
    @kayleighskopekimnottheimpo913 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Alya figured out ninos identitly because they know each other really well and he said dude while saving her and that’s just sparked her mind thinking he is caracolt (idk the name)

  • @shalinifrankline1420
    @shalinifrankline1420 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The scene when Adrian looks dreamy in the bus is not when he looks at marinette but when he appreciates the beauty of NY u can see his eyes shift......but thats just what I observed

    • @Abielle
      @Abielle 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      He was looking at Marinette and the sunset. How do I know? (1) the sun beams strongly as he looks out the window, and his eyes shift from Marinette to the sky but when it cuts back to his face, his eyes shift back....and you can assume back to Marinette. (2) The last time he looked at the sunset he was looking at it with Marinette on the plane (3) He said the same thing both times "it's beautiful" and I think we can all agree he didn't hug Marinette then just because he likes the sky so much. ;-)

    • @shalinifrankline1420
      @shalinifrankline1420 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Abielle Let's agree to disagree ❤️

  • @dragonslayerxd907
    @dragonslayerxd907 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    4:18the miraculouse put up a low level perception filter where you can see the person but you cant conect the dots. this spell can be broken though. alya has shown to have high perception. she has always had this curiosity too her, she so peceptive that shes been able to gues 3 miracoules holders identies not just nino's. there was a comment where she mentioned cat noir is similar to adrien but marinnette brushed that off and dont forget the episode where alya did suspect marinette of being ladybug in the pharoh because of marinette losing her book. she only found out nino's identity because at that point in the show they were dating and he gave it away easily. marinette wasnt there saying "nope and heres the bs why" so alya put 2 and 2 together.
    it would be interesting if alya was able to unmask hawkmoth one day. oh wait isnt that her job in season 4?

  • @elizabethgrace3791
    @elizabethgrace3791 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Our ship is SaIlInggGggggg
    Or at least floating 😂

  • @katieduong2024
    @katieduong2024 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Wait, did you find the whole episode on Netflix? Or somewhere else?

    • @thegoodguy4443
      @thegoodguy4443 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      wassup kate if you want to watch it than come to my channel I have posted the link of it in one of my latest video

    • @mohammedaldalan359
      @mohammedaldalan359 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      If you wanna see it soap2day.com

  • @orange.juice1596
    @orange.juice1596 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Alya knew it was him because when ladybug said for him to use his power he said "okay DUDE, I mean lady bug" she knew it was him because of that maybe not 100% but its just what I think.

  • @ultimatedisneycruiselinefa5112
    @ultimatedisneycruiselinefa5112 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    This NY special was a “Splash Mountain” of emotions.

  • @ellie2041
    @ellie2041 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    The cringe needs to go.period. I love Marinette and Adrien, but the cringe with Marinette has.got.to.go!

  • @abigailhong3567
    @abigailhong3567 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Okay... here me out. In the episode Oblivio, i saw something kinda strange?? In the scene where they run into the bathroom to hide, and both reach out to lock the door. They "touch" and *BOTH* Adrien and Marinette blush. And at this point, Adrien hasn't really seen Marinette in action. I've seen Analysis' that Adrien love ladybug for her fast thinking, but at this point, she was just being, Marinette. He just saw her and blushed. Proof that Adrien really does have feelings for Marinette? Even when shes not acting like Ladybug?

  • @monikaogorzalek7
    @monikaogorzalek7 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You miss a huge part of Gorrila ( Adrien's Bodyguard) . He was so cute in episode.