Such a sweet relief that this question is finally giving a reasonable answer. Now how do you think CatDog is born? I recall that Dog suggested that his and Cats parents are also a CatDog. Yeah that's a bit more questionable than the poop question.
Not sure about how they were actually born but when it comes to them being born connected i have a bit of an idea, might be from some kind of rare birth mutation between a dog and cat. There is a mutation that can happen when someone is pregnant with twins where the two twins are born connected to each other and even share a couple organs, aka conjoined twins. Catdog might most likely have been born with that kind of mutation or at least something similar to it
A cloaca is a shared exit for the urinary, digestive and reproductive tracts. It's typically found in egg-laying creatures such as birds and platypuses.
@@VGamingJunkieVT if we’re going by real word logic, if they’re unable to be separated then the other would die quite quickly. As the parts of the body belonging to the other would start to decay and damage their body too. It’s also possible they could just die of a broken heart. Often with older couples when one dies the other follows shortly after because they just are too heartbroken to continue living and their body just kinda gives up. In the case of famous conjoined twins Chang and Eng even though they had barely any shared body parts, when Chang died, Eng died hours later. He reportedly died of shock after finding his brother dead.
I can imagine Edd watching all of the episodes and jump all around once Cat mentions the colon, finally a lead, love all the effort you put into the videos man keep it up
Cut to a large cork board with pictures of CatDog together and individually pinned all over and red strings tied to various ones to link them together, and a triumphant Edd excitedly shouting, "YES!!! It's ALL coming together!!" upon confirmation that CatDog has a colon. 😂
The final theory would also explain the contradictory instances of stuff coming out the other end. There's a connection that bypasses the digestive tract, and one that goes through it. All the regurgitation that happens on screen is because they're not working together and/or they've been caught off guard by something coming up- more like a burp.
I always thought that they just digested 100 percent of organic material that they consume and toss up anything that is in organic or just can't be consumed. Notice with the cake how we only see the candles comeback up but not the cake itself. In the ep where they join a circus you can argue that the food was passing through them so fast it never got a chance to get fully digested.
@@kinyacat5919 If you haven't seen it, I apologize for telling you the disgusting truth. Dog doesn't just lick the urinal cake....he puts it in his mouth, and walks out the door with it. Cat had to knock it away from him.
I figured it was like some sort of owl pellet sort of thing where they digest the food to where the nutrients are absorbed, and they just warf up a ball of bones and fur wrapped around the ick.
In regards of which side the poop comes out from.... Since the fart from the bubble episode came out from the bottom half, it's safe to say that the same goes for poops. Also, I love how there's this one guy who has public testimonies as to how they poop.
I don’t know how you were able to stomach so much CatDog, Eddie. I have the full series DVD and I only made it up to the first half of Season 2. Hope you’re well man. CatDog can really take a lot out of you.
Honestly the colonoscopy bag theory could hold a lot of water (among other things ba dum dish) especially considering all of the medical condition coding the character seems to portray in the show and it’s themes.
I have a theory. I believe that catdog is much like a giant desert centipede, with a false head to evade predators. But unlike a centipede, both halves are sentient. This may explain most if not all of the points brought up in this video. They share a spleen, colon, and stomach, but have separate lungs, hearts, and brains. This may be so that if one side were to die, the other side could live until the dead side was entirely replaced by living tissue. It is established that if one side gets hurt, the other cannot feel it. This would allow the living side to be able to escape alive and potentially remove the dead tissue (ew). Now that there is a clear reason for the two halves being seperate, we can now theorize as to how they poop. My theory is that they both share a hole, as they share most of their digestive organs. Now the next question is how they pee... I have other theories about catdog, but they aren't relevant to this theory. If you have any questions about catdog's anatomy, I might be able to give you an answer
Your video essays are astounding and I love them. After having seen and been apart of so much in the community, these feel like listening to an old friend tell me something he's excited about, and I can just sit back and listen to his passion and hard work. Keep it up Eddie!
Well now that that’s settled, we can look into some of Eddache’s other ideas, such as: Fast Bird vs Fast Mouse Is Tom in love with Jerry? Is the Pixar Lamp a murderer? How to kill Mr. Burns Is butt legs? Monkey Tennis Why is the moon getting closer? How far can you throw a toddler? Why is anime? How budget cuts created furries The Biology of Pixar Cars Why?
@@scribblecloud All of these were taken from a list of video ideas briefly shown in the "How Many Times Was Road Runner Actually Caught?" video, minus the CatDog one.
The thing that seems really consistent is that stuff going in one mouth can come out the other looking at how the digestive track is handled seems like the stomach has two entries and they have some control on just passing it by. Or even the tube goes from one moth to the other with a stomach entry in the middle.
As a kid I was with the 4th theory, with the addition that the hole was bang in the middle and so they each had their own *ahem* special boy parts, which is how dog peed on his own.
So my theory, which isn’t covered here, is that CatDog is quantum-linked with another being, which is likewise a cat and dog joined together, but this time, it’s their asses. So when Cat eats and needs to poop, it comes out of the cat-butt on the other being, and when Dog eats and needs to poop, it comes out of the other being’s dog-butt. Of course, this raises the question of what such a being’s life would be like, but I feel like that’s a question I am not going to be able to answer.
I only watched CatDog a few times. I remember one episode someone saying they should "get off their duff" and one of them said "I wasn't aware that we HAD a duff" pointing to their middle.
And just like the rest of his videos, no matter the topic, a deserving amount of dedication and in depth analysis is always given. Bravo Eddie Bowley. 👏👏👏
Amazing! And to think, I did not watch his show when it was still on. (The only shows I remember watching on Nick/Nicktoons were The Amanda Show, Rugrats, Jimmy Neutron, Fairly OddParents and SpongeBob.) I saw a couple of episodes myself and I can definitely see why this is one of the most beloved Nick shows out there. Also, I think the fourth theory makes TOTAL sense!
One fine day with a woof and a purr A baby was born and it caused a little stir No blue buzzard, no three-eyed frog Just a feline canine little CatDog. CatDog, CatDog, alone in the world is a little CatDog! Out on the road or back in town All kinda critters putting CatDog down Gotta rise above it gotta try to get along Gotta walk together gotta sing this song. CatDog, CatDog, alone in the world is a little CatDog! CatDog (CatDog) CatDog (CatDog) Alone in the world is a little CatDog! CatDog (CatDog) CatDog (CatDog) Alone in the world is a little CatDog!
Tbh as I've watched this channel since the spoof movie and heard about Eddy Talking about I remember jokingly thought the other head vomits out the food I didn't even know there was a theroy of Em vomit out waste.
When I first saw the title, the first thing that came up to my mind was if the dog poops then the cat will barf out the poop out of his mouth, if the cat poops then the dog will also barf out the poop out of his mouth, and that’s what you also thought in this video.
FINALLY, this is the Half Life 3 of Eddache, the alternative version of Definitive edition of the OG GTA triology (of sorts), the one that blows you away, and not sucks you dry. (in a bad way)
Try out JustWatch, the free and ultimate Movie and TV Streaming guide - www.justwatch.com/uk?UA
This mystery has haunted me for years. Thank you for finally giving me peace 🥲
Watch deez-
Yea, How are baby formed? Do woman lay egg to? Is it a blood ritual? Where do the digers com into the picture... We will never know
Legitimately a useful free service. I use it all the time to find where shows have shuffled to in this age of a million streaming services.
@@DekaDanske they come from storks 🙄
Born too late to explore the world
Born too early to explore the stars
Born just in time to explore how CatDog poops
Lol
What a glorious time we were born into
We truly live in a golden era.
@@lyrafaeren *brown and golden
@@redguywithatophat1900 u don’t have a top hat, your just a red guy
I, a german, laughed so hard about "Die Insel" that I completely missed the sponsor lol
same
That’s one way to sponsor skip!
(I’m German too, well Franco-German, but that’s cool)
DIE INSEL!!
"It's german for the, incel the!"
Such a sweet relief that this question is finally giving a reasonable answer. Now how do you think CatDog is born? I recall that Dog suggested that his and Cats parents are also a CatDog. Yeah that's a bit more questionable than the poop question.
What if it's like a Phoenix and they reincarnate?
Clearly the head came out first
Their parents are a Bigfoot and a frog. Yeah this show is weird.
@@JohnaldV Adopted parents. But yeah, still a weird show.
Not sure about how they were actually born but when it comes to them being born connected i have a bit of an idea, might be from some kind of rare birth mutation between a dog and cat. There is a mutation that can happen when someone is pregnant with twins where the two twins are born connected to each other and even share a couple organs, aka conjoined twins. Catdog might most likely have been born with that kind of mutation or at least something similar to it
Nickeledoen officially proposing something called "Independent hole theory" is way more than i bargained for when i clicked on this video
A cloaca is a shared exit for the urinary, digestive and reproductive tracts. It's typically found in egg-laying creatures such as birds and platypuses.
Why?
@@alex.g7317 i dunno, ask the guy who made them.
@@manboy4720 but if I do, that will be saying his name in vain!
@@alex.g7317 send a strongly worded e-mail, or maybe you could send a fax.
@@manboy4720 the lord doesn’t use email, he uses gmail
Why would you be surprised that Catdog has two souls? They're two seperate people, and they have completely seperate minds
right
The thought of one of them dying, though, is exceptionally grim. Would the other die soon after, like many cases of conjoined twins?
@@VGamingJunkieVT if we’re going by real word logic, if they’re unable to be separated then the other would die quite quickly. As the parts of the body belonging to the other would start to decay and damage their body too. It’s also possible they could just die of a broken heart. Often with older couples when one dies the other follows shortly after because they just are too heartbroken to continue living and their body just kinda gives up. In the case of famous conjoined twins Chang and Eng even though they had barely any shared body parts, when Chang died, Eng died hours later. He reportedly died of shock after finding his brother dead.
Yes, and conjoined twins are a thing, so that’s obviously not very hard to believe.
I can imagine Edd watching all of the episodes and jump all around once Cat mentions the colon, finally a lead, love all the effort you put into the videos man keep it up
Cut to a large cork board with pictures of CatDog together and individually pinned all over and red strings tied to various ones to link them together, and a triumphant Edd excitedly shouting, "YES!!! It's ALL coming together!!" upon confirmation that CatDog has a colon. 😂
ok
@@cannibalisticrequiem yes
The final theory would also explain the contradictory instances of stuff coming out the other end. There's a connection that bypasses the digestive tract, and one that goes through it. All the regurgitation that happens on screen is because they're not working together and/or they've been caught off guard by something coming up- more like a burp.
It's not the fact this was his goal that surprises me, It's the amount of time he has to watch cartoons.
He’s a TH-camr what do you expect
[menacing Batman impression] You can always make time for cartoons…
Welcome to Eddache
When you’re getting made for it, I imagine it’s easy to make time to watch cartoons.
I mean, his job is to make these videos ... so he has at least eight hours a day to watch cartoons. Duh.
This was so worth the wait. But I don't think the mystery of where babies come from can be solved.
They’re a wedding gift from storks. Duh
@Cristian Monserrate yeah! As if you didn’t know lol
@@Speedoodleman what but aren’t babies found in cabbage, after mom and dad hug at night.
Technology isn't there yet, unfortunately. We'll know in due time
@@shadowclaw7210 @ShadowClaw yes, but then the storks eat the cabbage for nutrients and sort out the infant so they can deliver it
"How does CatDog go to the bathroom?"
I assume it walks there.
I'd assume it could be considered crawling too, considering all of its paws are hands
What?
Have you already crossed out floating in the air?
Something interesting to note is that they have one long spot on their underside, which could back up the bag theory.
Actually that could be where the bubble gets out of.
Thank you for answering this intriguing question, Eddie Eddache, You truly are the hero we needed
it's like a car crash in slow motion. you see the title, you see the thumbnail, you hear the intro... its terrifying, yet you can't look away.
The fu....😆
I always thought that they just digested 100 percent of organic material that they consume and toss up anything that is in organic or just can't be consumed. Notice with the cake how we only see the candles comeback up but not the cake itself. In the ep where they join a circus you can argue that the food was passing through them so fast it never got a chance to get fully digested.
Cat- I hate public restrooms
Dog- At least the mints are good
Cat- THATS NOT A MINT!!
Ew did Dog just lick the... urinate?!
@@kinyacat5919 If you haven't seen it, I apologize for telling you the disgusting truth. Dog doesn't just lick the urinal cake....he puts it in his mouth, and walks out the door with it. Cat had to knock it away from him.
@@joshhacker8503 gross !!
As someone who speaks German "die Insel" really got to me XD
I figured it was like some sort of owl pellet sort of thing where they digest the food to where the nutrients are absorbed, and they just warf up a ball of bones and fur wrapped around the ick.
Finally! Somebody’s asking the questions that really matter!!!
The regurgitation theory is one I stuck to since I was a little kid.
To me, that's how they poop.
Never ask a woman her age or a man his salary.
Never ask CatDog how they poop and most definetly dont ask a baby where they come from
The line “why do they call it oven when you of in the cold food of out the hot eat the food” hurts me
PHYSICALLY
I feel like I'm having a stroke
In regards of which side the poop comes out from.... Since the fart from the bubble episode came out from the bottom half, it's safe to say that the same goes for poops.
Also, I love how there's this one guy who has public testimonies as to how they poop.
I don’t know how you were able to stomach so much CatDog, Eddie. I have the full series DVD and I only made it up to the first half of Season 2. Hope you’re well man.
CatDog can really take a lot out of you.
It must have been a pain in the *ass*
CatDog's great... What the hell is wrong with you people? O_o
@@Cooe.real. this show's so relatable to me.
This would be a lot harder to answer if it weren’t for 90’s Nick gross-out humor.
I love how there's an entire 13 minute video dedicated to how catdog takes a dump. now THIS is my type of content.
Honestly the colonoscopy bag theory could hold a lot of water (among other things ba dum dish) especially considering all of the medical condition coding the character seems to portray in the show and it’s themes.
I know it’s been a year since this was posted but the fact you typed medical condition coding completely seriously
Editing this video has made my entire degree worth it
We never see the bottom of their paws. It could be that they have the poop hole on their paws
Eww.
No no no no no no no noooooooooo…
We see the bottom
Like reverse Andelites
0:35
Im just glad this guy is still around, I remember the EddEgg cartoons on NG
he's not edd gould
@@electrostar5161 no shit edd gould didnt make eddegg
*Most Important Questions:*
“How can we cure cancer?”
“How do we solve wars?”
“How does CatDog poop?”
I have a theory. I believe that catdog is much like a giant desert centipede, with a false head to evade predators. But unlike a centipede, both halves are sentient. This may explain most if not all of the points brought up in this video. They share a spleen, colon, and stomach, but have separate lungs, hearts, and brains. This may be so that if one side were to die, the other side could live until the dead side was entirely replaced by living tissue. It is established that if one side gets hurt, the other cannot feel it. This would allow the living side to be able to escape alive and potentially remove the dead tissue (ew). Now that there is a clear reason for the two halves being seperate, we can now theorize as to how they poop. My theory is that they both share a hole, as they share most of their digestive organs. Now the next question is how they pee...
I have other theories about catdog, but they aren't relevant to this theory. If you have any questions about catdog's anatomy, I might be able to give you an answer
Your video essays are astounding and I love them. After having seen and been apart of so much in the community, these feel like listening to an old friend tell me something he's excited about, and I can just sit back and listen to his passion and hard work. Keep it up Eddie!
This video is a perfect example of a pay off to multiple set ups. Love it!
You always make videos on the most important content! Much thanks 🙏
Today is my birthday. I was far happier than I should be to see this in subscription feed.
Thank you for this gift, Edd.
The fact that I knew what a cloaca was before I watched this hurts.
Thanks Eddie and #CONTENT
He actually did it.
The madman actually did it.
Man is doing gods work.
The magnum opus of cartoon discussion videos.
The episode we were all waiting for
Seeing all of these clips brought back so much nostalgia; I used to watch this show all the time!!
I swear I remember there being an episode where we actually see Cat sitting on a toilet while Dog is waiting through a hole in the bathroom door… 🤔
Me too!
Well now that that’s settled, we can look into some of Eddache’s other ideas, such as:
Fast Bird vs Fast Mouse
Is Tom in love with Jerry?
Is the Pixar Lamp a murderer?
How to kill Mr. Burns
Is butt legs?
Monkey Tennis
Why is the moon getting closer?
How far can you throw a toddler?
Why is anime?
How budget cuts created furries
The Biology of Pixar Cars
Why?
wait which of these are actual videos
@@scribblecloud All of these were taken from a list of video ideas briefly shown in the "How Many Times Was Road Runner Actually Caught?" video, minus the CatDog one.
@@primrosevale1995 ohh i see, honestly id genuinely watch every single one of those
Thank you for finally giving this topic the serious attention it deserves. Has been swept under the Nickelodeon rug for too long
This is something we all needed for so long.
The thing that seems really consistent is that stuff going in one mouth can come out the other looking at how the digestive track is handled seems like the stomach has two entries and they have some control on just passing it by. Or even the tube goes from one moth to the other with a stomach entry in the middle.
As a kid I was with the 4th theory, with the addition that the hole was bang in the middle and so they each had their own *ahem* special boy parts, which is how dog peed on his own.
So my theory, which isn’t covered here, is that CatDog is quantum-linked with another being, which is likewise a cat and dog joined together, but this time, it’s their asses. So when Cat eats and needs to poop, it comes out of the cat-butt on the other being, and when Dog eats and needs to poop, it comes out of the other being’s dog-butt. Of course, this raises the question of what such a being’s life would be like, but I feel like that’s a question I am not going to be able to answer.
What a terrible existence…..
This imies the existence of another cat dog that exists as the ass of a cat connected to the ass of a dog
"Kill..... Me.....", the ButtButt murmured in a series of farts.
I only watched CatDog a few times. I remember one episode someone saying they should "get off their duff" and one of them said "I wasn't aware that we HAD a duff" pointing to their middle.
Eddache takes on to answer one of the World's questions
This channel deserves 1 million subscribers!
The moment we've all been waiting for! My skin is clear, my crops are watered, the sun is shining and everything is perfect!
And just like the rest of his videos, no matter the topic, a deserving amount of dedication and in depth analysis is always given. Bravo Eddie Bowley. 👏👏👏
0:08: idk why but that gave me a nosebleed and my headhurts.
At last
After all these years
He finally did it
Your random building name screenshots thread is my favourite thing to come out of this video
Amazing! And to think, I did not watch his show when it was still on. (The only shows I remember watching on Nick/Nicktoons were The Amanda Show, Rugrats, Jimmy Neutron, Fairly OddParents and SpongeBob.) I saw a couple of episodes myself and I can definitely see why this is one of the most beloved Nick shows out there.
Also, I think the fourth theory makes TOTAL sense!
the first 14 seconds were hillarious!
Awesome video Eddie!!!
Ed, a father, not knowing where babies come from is cursed knowledge I did not expect to be burdened with
I always had this joke with my mum is that if one side had to pee/poop,The other half had to vomit it out.
"Where do babies come from?"
From the stork! Did you learn nothing in school? :P
And he has a kid
I laughed when you made the German title card sound like "DIE INCEL!", although it actually just means "the island".
I always thought what ever one ate, the other barfed later
I imagine it's like a backwards human centipede thing.
thanks for reminding me about face mites
When you respectfully disagree with a terminally online Twitter user: 3:59
“Where do babies come from?”
This man is a father.
One fine day with a woof and a purr
A baby was born and it caused a little stir
No blue buzzard, no three-eyed frog
Just a feline canine little CatDog.
CatDog, CatDog, alone in the world is a little CatDog!
Out on the road or back in town
All kinda critters putting CatDog down
Gotta rise above it gotta try to get along
Gotta walk together gotta sing this song.
CatDog, CatDog, alone in the world is a little CatDog!
CatDog (CatDog) CatDog (CatDog)
Alone in the world is a little CatDog!
CatDog (CatDog) CatDog (CatDog)
Alone in the world is a little CatDog!
The wait is finally over
There's also the theory that their stomach is quantum linked to another creature that's just two asses connected together.
I would like to mention this book called "everybody poops"
The way they climb that rope...I LOVE THAT lol and spinning plates
Tbh as I've watched this channel since the spoof movie and heard about Eddy
Talking about I remember jokingly thought the other head vomits out the food
I didn't even know there was a theroy of
Em vomit out waste.
4:00 im german and "die" is one of the 3 words for "the"(yes we have 3 words for the) and "Insel" is island :)
"That's German for 'The, Bart the'!"
BTW, I'm Italian and we have six, lol!
ah I love this show from when I was a kid
When I first saw the title, the first thing that came up to my mind was if the dog poops then the cat will barf out the poop out of his mouth, if the cat poops then the dog will also barf out the poop out of his mouth, and that’s what you also thought in this video.
Never clicked a thumbnail faster
German be like:
Text: DIE INSEL!!!
meaning: the island
He did it! He finally did it! The absolute madman!
Finally you cover this topic just days before I hit 25. Thanks Eddie.
The bodies of toons just change as and when needed. Its just how the toon world works, its physics are adaptive.
I'm taking the night watch with our newborn puppies, this is a good way to start the night lol
4:34 HOLY $&#! IT'S HEART STOPPER!!
If you hear closer at 1:19, it sounds like spongebob
Probably because it's Tom Kenny
03:59 "die insel" so funny because iam a german girl ;D
Catdog traumatised me as a kid. Actually, looking at it still creeps me out
on April 29th 2022, Eddache released his mangum opus
FINALLY, this is the Half Life 3 of Eddache, the alternative version of Definitive edition of the OG GTA triology (of sorts), the one that blows you away, and not sucks you dry. (in a bad way)
What?
@@andrewholdaway813 It is a video that was promised for some years and unlike Half Life 3, released.
@@dontspikemydrink9382 should've just said that
@@andrewholdaway813 but i don't want to. It is a joke
@@dontspikemydrink9382
Oh, umm er... haha?
Watching this while pooping. Living my best life
1:52
"Heyja CatDoug!"
*Silence*
"Nevermind"
Finally, he made the video!
Are Cat and Dog voiced by Jim Cummings and Tom Kenny respectively? I don’t remember either of them sounding like that.
“They have a separate body that’s just their asses that all the poop teleports”
-some random Reddit commenter
0:00 me: oh ok
0:11 also me: YOU LIED
12:50 Bobs orphanage, u make ‘em we take ‘em
i feel like they would have a cloaca in the middle
kinda like a snake…..but centered in the middle
It's ironic watching this on the toilet. lol (had to say it)