I read his book "Miracles"...over 1200 small-print pages with thousands of minute footnotes, what an adventure that was !! What a brilliant mind to assemble so much information in one book. He deserves a second Ph. D. for the work and effort he put into writing such a colossal book.
I broke my back and neck, over half of the discs in my spine to be exact, I went form barely being able to move to going on runs with my Pitty. Miracles happen every day, sometimes I think we just forgot how to really say 'Thank you' in the west.
I was healed in the moment that i was dying,in 2019,all i said in my mind cuz i could not move or talk,i said in my mind, God i believe in you since i was 8 years old save my soul and take me with you,then i was by the side of my bed moving and saying to my sister look i can move before the pandemic...my sister immediatly starded to video me out of the bed ,she was shaking...i was dying of mercury contamination....
I´m really thrilled to find Keener and his work! Thank God, in Jesus´ name, and all his assistants, the Buddha et al and legacy community! Ref to Ramsey MacMullen 19:20
@@HarryNicNicholas wanting more doesn’t discount those that happen. Also if that makes it “bullshit”, how many stranded passengers have you passed? How many times have you not stopped a crime by failing to get some people together to patrol neighborhoods? It’s so easy to pass judgment on God when your own bullshit is a cause of many perils. Perfect yourself and then you may judge God for not healing the people you want.
I agree with you without a disagreement. Healing is different from Miracles. Mainstream religious heads/ priest can do healings. The question is " what kinda spiritual background it is. ? See from my point of view ,in an illuminated or purified human only Holy Spirit dwells and grants his gifts. Sacraments has greatest importance in one's life with apostlic succession.
Dr. Keener, I have a question which you may have a good answer to, but I'm curious anyways. So many of my friends have succumbed to unbelief and incessant questions about the truth of Christianity, to the point of no longer even respecting it. They cite well-researched academics such as Bart Ehrman who cause springs of doubt to rise up in people's minds. My question is this: why not enter the apologetics field and debate well-known skeptics and simply recount these miracles to them?
@@HarryNicNicholas dude what’s nuts is I’m not religious anymore. Life hasn’t gotten easier for sure, but it’s nice not having to ascribe to shit no one understands anymore
Disappointing. This lecture was little more than a series of anecdotes about healings, with scant evidence - medical or otherwise - to support their veracity. I'm hoping that Keener has more to offer in his other lectures here. It's mostly all "he told me... I heard... They said.." that there was a healing. No better than alien abduction stories. I'm a Christian but this was weak.
I have the same sentiments with you but not as apathetic as you (no offense). I think the point of this talk is just to address the summary of all. Dr. Keener's dissertation about miracles is peer-reviewed. At least, while we watch his video, let's suppose that everything he say (anecdotals) are documentarily reliable. Because it's really inevitable to say that all of these are anecdotals and falsifiable after further investigation - this is the counterpart objection to the argument of miracles. I just finished the video. The one-hour video of Dr. Craig Keener is more preferable to watch if we want academic in-depth research than just listening to an oversimplified seminar
He has a 1200 page book with the evidence that you are looking for. This is just an introduction. If he only has 30 minutes to give this talk, he's not going to waste time showing the medical statistics and what not.
Every protestant seeks from so called Bible. Untill the last of 3 rd century, after expelling the heretic books ( apocryphal) Saint Athnasius of antioch ( bishop of antioch) and the Church of antioch codified the Bible. There is the importance of Church fathers in Syrian, coptic and Latin rite. There valuable teachings are also important.. If you thoroughly examine paul's epistles you can see that he quoted from other apocryphal writings.
@@gavinhurlimann2910 I wouldn't agree with the original commenter that it's all guesswork but I sympathize with his position. The problem I have with the "miracles" is that they happen in other religions, too. If it is really God intervening then you would expect them to only occur for Christians. I'm assuming most of it is luck and misinterpretation. Humans are very gullible and bad at pattern detection. I know a lot of people who claim everything is a sign from God when it's probably just coincidence. Now, this doesn't mean that all of these were non-miracles. That's also irrational because we're just assuming that miracles can't happen which is what Naturalists do. Another possibility is that those "miracles" in other religions are magic from evil spirits. I'm also assuming that even the "miracles" that are impossible for doctors to explain, even some or a lot of them have natural explanations that we don't understand yet. We have to stop with a "Miracle of the Gaps" argument. Just because something seems to be a miracle does not mean it is! The best we can do with all these claims of miracles is to say that Atheists are extremely irrational for assuming that Naturalism is true when we have all this evidence for the Supernatural. We can also go by a case by case basis and try to weed out which ones are actual miracles, which ones we're not sure of, and which ones are a human invention.
Michael Sayad your whole argument ignores at least two other possibilities: 1- God CAN and sometimes DOES work miracles in other religions. There is no reason why He should in principle refrain from ever doing that. Sometimes God might want to mercifully cure someone for some special reason, regardless of their faith, for example. Or perhaps he wants to support a certain virtue, or has some other reason. I don't see why God should never be expected to work miracles in other religions. 2- there is also the possibility that miracles are more frequent in Christian contexts; and that the evidence for Christian miracles is better than that for miracles in other religions. Not a miracle of the gaps. Just an inference to the best explanation. We have apparently supernatural events, many connected to prayer, that can be neatly explained by theism or even Christianity.
@@mordec1016 "1- God CAN and sometimes DOES work miracles in other religions." I apologize. I didn't think of that possibility. "2- there is also the possibility that miracles are more frequent in Christian contexts; and that the evidence for Christian miracles is better than that for miracles in other religions." I did hear Gary Habermas, I believe, say something similar to this so it might be true. "Not a miracle of the gaps. Just an inference to the best explanation." I'm probably not being fair with Craig Keener's examples. They do seem very compelling! Though, there are definitely many examples I have witnessed in my life that people claim things that are easily explained are miracles. That has probably biased me against miracles in general. I've also studied human psychology and how bad human memories are. Things like this have tended to make me more skeptical than I'd like to be. Thanks for the feedback!
I don't understand why a loving God allows these people to become afflicted with such horrible physical ailments in the first place only to decide many years later to heal these same people. It actually seems like God is somewhat cruel in this regard.
@@rogerweigel7925 so why is God allowing suffering cruel? Who decides what’s cruel and what’s not? We don’t have a moral standard as humans because everything and opinion is subjective. That’s the point
Respectfully, I don't think you listened to this, nor have done must reading on this topic. God has done this throughout the world all throughout time, but maybe not personally on your life in your little part of the world, wherever that may be.
People from It's Supernatural are real people you should realize. I've known Heidi Baker since '78 and she was pretty amazing all along. Now with her saying there are 21 born blind, being healed, and many many people healed of deafness, and even eleven resurrections in Mozambique, I'm born away! It is supernatural, and this is from our savior Yeshua, Jesus.
Papa Smurf, my heart stopped in 2014, in the hospital. With an EF, after resuscitation, of 5%. After 4 days of work in USB cardiology, they told my family it was hopeless. That night, a good friend was praying with my daughter, over the phone. In the midst of praying, she proclaimed that she had a vision from the Holy Spirit. She saw angels surrounding the bed, she said there were so many angels she could not count them and it was like a bright white light shining outwards. She told my daughter, unequivocally, “he’s coming back.” I woke the next morning. My EF was doubled
That sound like a 'Why does my Icecream melt in the Summer Sun' kind of whine to me, you want to eat Icecream while Snowboardng in the Alps kind of retardedness. Oh what a wonderful day, the Sun is Shining outside and the Iceream Van is coming. Oh damnit my Icecream is melting, this day is poxed. Wah wah fucking wah, go get your head read you have Daddy Issues. Don't ask how I got to that conclusion unless you want to pay my hourly fee
Storm Born .... everyone was watching this one, Muslims, atheists, so on, and with all of the prayers for him, no healing came. Jesus felt the need to perform miracles to convince people. So why not use this opportunity to tell everyone he is real by healing Nabeel.
![Craig Keener: Miracles (Part 2) [Talbot Chapel]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YUGKJz8Iuw0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Craig Keener: Miracles (Part 2) [Talbot Chapel]](/img/tr.png)
![Craig Keener: Trusting The Signs of the Kingdom [Biola University Chapel]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/72Hf1heiAaQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I read his book "Miracles"...over 1200 small-print pages with thousands of minute footnotes, what an adventure that was !! What a brilliant mind to assemble so much information in one book. He deserves a second Ph. D. for the work and effort he put into writing such a colossal book.
Was there any documentation of an amputee being healed?
I broke my back and neck, over half of the discs in my spine to be exact, I went form barely being able to move to going on runs with my Pitty. Miracles happen every day, sometimes I think we just forgot how to really say 'Thank you' in the west.
When we use our human minds and intelligence to question God, we fall short EVERY TIME.
Said the Mormon to the Protestant
Said the Muslim to Christian
How have we ended up with over 4,000 religions? Do you think we ought to be using our grey matter.
I was healed in the moment that i was dying,in 2019,all i said in my mind cuz i could not move or talk,i said in my mind, God i believe in you since i was 8 years old save my soul and take me with you,then i was by the side of my bed moving and saying to my sister look i can move before the pandemic...my sister immediatly starded to video me out of the bed ,she was shaking...i was dying of mercury contamination....
I attended a lecture on the historical-cultural context of the Bible here in Brazil. It was wonderful❤
Miracles are a part of who we are.
Being the exorbitant high cost of healthcare in the country, US ,we really need healings in our country.
And a lot of healthcare is not about healing
I´m really thrilled to find Keener and his work! Thank God, in Jesus´ name, and all his assistants, the Buddha et al and legacy community! Ref to Ramsey MacMullen 19:20
Great work Dr. Keener. God bless you.
Jesus used miracles to show His power to non-believers. Still doing it today. :)
Glory to Jesus!
We serve a supernatural God. It's only reasonable to say He does supernatural things. When and why and how, I don't claim to know. But I know he does.
kokonutts arefun, amen and know that I am one. Heart stopped with an EF of 5%. Resuscitated even though it is considered medically impossible
give this man a glass of water
HAHA ikr
@@HarryNicNicholas wanting more doesn’t discount those that happen. Also if that makes it “bullshit”, how many stranded passengers have you passed? How many times have you not stopped a crime by failing to get some people together to patrol neighborhoods? It’s so easy to pass judgment on God when your own bullshit is a cause of many perils. Perfect yourself and then you may judge God for not healing the people you want.
How about the correlation is not causation objection? What's Dr. Craig Keener's respond to this?
How much coincidence do you want?
I agree with you without a disagreement.
Healing is different from Miracles.
Mainstream religious heads/ priest can do healings.
The question is " what kinda spiritual background it is. ?
See from my point of view
,in an illuminated or purified human only Holy Spirit dwells and grants his gifts. Sacraments has greatest importance in one's life with apostlic succession.
Dr. Keener, I have a question which you may have a good answer to, but I'm curious anyways. So many of my friends have succumbed to unbelief and incessant questions about the truth of Christianity, to the point of no longer even respecting it. They cite well-researched academics such as Bart Ehrman who cause springs of doubt to rise up in people's minds. My question is this: why not enter the apologetics field and debate well-known skeptics and simply recount these miracles to them?
He debates and lectures all the time. Search.
@@HarryNicNicholas dude what’s nuts is I’m not religious anymore. Life hasn’t gotten easier for sure, but it’s nice not having to ascribe to shit no one understands anymore
Disappointing. This lecture was little more than a series of anecdotes about healings, with scant evidence - medical or otherwise - to support their veracity. I'm hoping that Keener has more to offer in his other lectures here. It's mostly all "he told me... I heard... They said.." that there was a healing. No better than alien abduction stories. I'm a Christian but this was weak.
I have the same sentiments with you but not as apathetic as you (no offense). I think the point of this talk is just to address the summary of all. Dr. Keener's dissertation about miracles is peer-reviewed. At least, while we watch his video, let's suppose that everything he say (anecdotals) are documentarily reliable.
Because it's really inevitable to say that all of these are anecdotals and falsifiable after further investigation - this is the counterpart objection to the argument of miracles.
I just finished the video. The one-hour video of Dr. Craig Keener is more preferable to watch if we want academic in-depth research than just listening to an oversimplified seminar
He has a 1200 page book with the evidence that you are looking for. This is just an introduction. If he only has 30 minutes to give this talk, he's not going to waste time showing the medical statistics and what not.
Amen
Miracles are real .
Did you guys ever hear about the Iraqi man who saw Jesus and then isis burned him alive 3 times and the man came out alive and unharmed
LMAO
Source?
Did ISIS give up and walk away? Where is the guy now?
It's kind of low to strengthen your disbelief with the most barbaric acts known to man.Someone pray for this man.
24:38 Barbara Cummiskey Snyder's miracle
Every protestant seeks from so called Bible. Untill the last of 3 rd century, after expelling the heretic books ( apocryphal) Saint Athnasius of antioch ( bishop of antioch) and the Church of antioch codified the Bible.
There is the importance of Church fathers in Syrian, coptic and Latin rite. There valuable teachings are also important..
If you thoroughly examine paul's epistles you can see that he quoted from other apocryphal writings.
The truth is no one knows if any of these miracles can be ascribed to God. It's all guess work.
Bullshit.
@@gavinhurlimann2910 I wouldn't agree with the original commenter that it's all guesswork but I sympathize with his position. The problem I have with the "miracles" is that they happen in other religions, too. If it is really God intervening then you would expect them to only occur for Christians. I'm assuming most of it is luck and misinterpretation. Humans are very gullible and bad at pattern detection. I know a lot of people who claim everything is a sign from God when it's probably just coincidence. Now, this doesn't mean that all of these were non-miracles. That's also irrational because we're just assuming that miracles can't happen which is what Naturalists do.
Another possibility is that those "miracles" in other religions are magic from evil spirits.
I'm also assuming that even the "miracles" that are impossible for doctors to explain, even some or a lot of them have natural explanations that we don't understand yet.
We have to stop with a "Miracle of the Gaps" argument. Just because something seems to be a miracle does not mean it is! The best we can do with all these claims of miracles is to say that Atheists are extremely irrational for assuming that Naturalism is true when we have all this evidence for the Supernatural. We can also go by a case by case basis and try to weed out which ones are actual miracles, which ones we're not sure of, and which ones are a human invention.
Michael Sayad your whole argument ignores at least two other possibilities: 1- God CAN and sometimes DOES work miracles in other religions. There is no reason why He should in principle refrain from ever doing that. Sometimes God might want to mercifully cure someone for some special reason, regardless of their faith, for example. Or perhaps he wants to support a certain virtue, or has some other reason. I don't see why God should never be expected to work miracles in other religions. 2- there is also the possibility that miracles are more frequent in Christian contexts; and that the evidence for Christian miracles is better than that for miracles in other religions.
Not a miracle of the gaps. Just an inference to the best explanation. We have apparently supernatural events, many connected to prayer, that can be neatly explained by theism or even Christianity.
@@mordec1016 "1- God CAN and sometimes DOES work miracles in other religions."
I apologize. I didn't think of that possibility.
"2- there is also the possibility that miracles are more frequent in Christian contexts; and that the evidence for Christian miracles is better than that for miracles in other religions."
I did hear Gary Habermas, I believe, say something similar to this so it might be true.
"Not a miracle of the gaps. Just an inference to the best explanation."
I'm probably not being fair with Craig Keener's examples. They do seem very compelling! Though, there are definitely many examples I have witnessed in my life that people claim things that are easily explained are miracles. That has probably biased me against miracles in general. I've also studied human psychology and how bad human memories are. Things like this have tended to make me more skeptical than I'd like to be.
Thanks for the feedback!
@@HarryNicNicholas Can you demonstrate that God doesn't exist? I look forward to your evidence lol :)
I don't understand why a loving God allows these people to become afflicted with such horrible physical ailments in the first place only to decide many years later to heal these same people. It actually seems like God is somewhat cruel in this regard.
Why you say God is cruel?
@@eugene3484 I just explained it.
@@rogerweigel7925 so why is God allowing suffering cruel? Who decides what’s cruel and what’s not? We don’t have a moral standard as humans because everything and opinion is subjective. That’s the point
@@eugene3484 Really? You're going down the objective morality road. You can do better than that.
@@rogerweigel7925 well then explain what gives you authority to decides what’s cruel.
Some people deny women in ministry lol miracles signs and wonders prophetess and apostles women raised by God Himself to serve and intercede amen
Tbere are no more apostles or prophetess today
Even God uses them to make miracles - it does not mean they can be preachers or pastors of God's assembly .
Miracle healing only exist in stories on TH-cam, 700 Club and Sid Roth's It's Supernatural. In reality, prayers will not magically heal anyone.
You receive what you ask for. No miracles for you.
Magically? By what authority do you speak?
Respectfully, I don't think you listened to this, nor have done must reading on this topic. God has done this throughout the world all throughout time, but maybe not personally on your life in your little part of the world, wherever that may be.
Well, Cindy that's just your barely asserted opinion. How is this a response at all to the video?
People from It's Supernatural are real people you should realize. I've known Heidi Baker since '78 and she was pretty amazing all along. Now with her saying there are 21 born blind, being healed, and many many people healed of deafness, and even eleven resurrections in Mozambique, I'm born away! It is supernatural, and this is from our savior Yeshua, Jesus.
200 million miracles and not a single one with a shred of evidence.
Rahul Dsouza, that is laughable....grow up and learn. Open your mind and your eyes.
Papa Smurf, my heart stopped in 2014, in the hospital. With an EF, after resuscitation, of 5%. After 4 days of work in USB cardiology, they told my family it was hopeless. That night, a good friend was praying with my daughter, over the phone. In the midst of praying, she proclaimed that she had a vision from the Holy Spirit. She saw angels surrounding the bed, she said there were so many angels she could not count them and it was like a bright white light shining outwards. She told my daughter, unequivocally, “he’s coming back.” I woke the next morning. My EF was doubled
Rahul, the speaker has a two volume set with hundreds of documented miracles, called “Miracles”. Craig S. Keener
Dr Craig Keener's 1200 pages of miracles is surely a powerful one two, against the atheist arguement.
@@olabashanda What do you mean by
" Documented miracles"?
If you want to know if miracles are real, check out the healing of Nabeel Qureshi.
That sound like a 'Why does my Icecream melt in the Summer Sun' kind of whine to me, you want to eat Icecream while Snowboardng in the Alps kind of retardedness. Oh what a wonderful day, the Sun is Shining outside and the Iceream Van is coming. Oh damnit my Icecream is melting, this day is poxed. Wah wah fucking wah, go get your head read you have Daddy Issues. Don't ask how I got to that conclusion unless you want to pay my hourly fee
Storm Born .... everyone was watching this one, Muslims, atheists, so on, and with all of the prayers for him, no healing came. Jesus felt the need to perform miracles to convince people. So why not use this opportunity to tell everyone he is real by healing Nabeel.
why? God says yes and says no. It is all up to God. Paul did not heal all , now do you think God did not heal through Paul the Apostle.
@Candice: So, if you die of disease, the other miracles were for naught?
Candice Arlebemus, questioning God is a fools’ game