The whole spiel about The Avatar needing to walk alone is so forced and pointless, the expanded material for the universe makes it clear that EVERY avatar had their own close knit friend group, by virtue of their job requiring them to travel the world and connect with its people.
Right? Netflix needs to stop pulling themes from later in the show without doing any of the work to set them up. In the original Aang does get to a point of feeling he needed to do it alone, but that's not until season 3 and there was a significant reason for him feeling that way (I won't spoil it for anyone else). The way netflix slapped that theme on was terrible. And now what are they going to do when they get to that point in season 3? Is Aang just going to reset and go back to wanting to do it alone? Or will they just ignore it entirely? 🤷♂
The past avatars saying that the avatar needs to be alone is so weird, considering every single one of them were in relationships and had friend groups, like kyoshi had a wife, kuruk had a wife, roku had a wife and grandkids, pretty sure yangchen also had a wife, like all of them had people they were close to???
And it's the exact opposite message that Yangchen gave to Aang in the original series... Yangchen: "Avatar Aang, I know that you are a gentle spirit, and the monks have taught you well, but this isn't about you; this is about the world." Aang: "But the monks taught me that I had to detach myself from the world so my spirit could be free." Yangchen: "Many great and wise Air Nomads have detached themselves and achieved spiritual enlightenment, but the Avatar can never do it, because your sole duty is _to_ the world." But yes, considering that all the past Avatars had friends, got married and raised families, etc. (the Fire Nation Avatar before Roku was even an administrator in the Fire Nation government), it makes no sense why they all suddenly would deprive Aang of the same and put new rules and strictures on him that they themselves did not abide.
I'm so happy to see a video from someone who hadn't watched ATLA first, and I'm glad you still have criticisms over it. Makes me feel a little less crazy.
The live action is what initially got me interested in watching Avatar. I watched season one of the original just before the netflix version and then I went back, started over with the original and watched it from start to finish. As I went through the next two seasons, I got progressively more frustrated with the netflix version. Out of everyone, I think netflix butchered Katara the most. I won't spoil anything, but she has some very intense arcs in the last season and I do not see how netflix can get Katara to the point she needs to be for them to make any sense. Netflix didn't even let Katara get jealous of Aang, and that pales in comparison to what comes later.
Yeah, watching The Dragon Prince: The Mystery of Aaravos, I'm reminded how Erik Todd Dellums does so much better as Koh than George Takei. George's Koh just sounds like a predator playing with his "food". Erik's Koh sounds like an actual mysteriously sadistic demonic spirit who actually has wisdom to give, kind of like the Sphynx where you have to play his game; he will give you the wisdom you seek, but should you fail his game (via show any bit of emotion) and he steals your face, trapping you forever between life and death . . .
Having Katara stealing a bending scroll goes against the current message for women in modern media. They can't have character flaws, display weakness or possess any moral ambiguity.
i'm noticing this more and more where they pigeonhole female characters into black and white morality . rather than creating an 'empowered' character with agency like they intend to , people write another version of the 'fairer sex' stereotype
I genuinely wanted the opinion of someone who hasn't watched the original because I needed to know whether I hated this live action so much because I'm a fan of the original but now I'm sure it's not the only reason like most of the defenders of the live action argue. It just makes what is already pretty bad 10 times worse. xD
You've seen the episode where Aang gets caught, and his friends got sick, right? So you know that Aang is SUPER fast. That and with the now added fact in this version that he can fly without his glider. Who would have gotten to the earth king faster to stop the bomb? The two people that would HAVE to take the long way around by running through the city or the kid that could carry not just himself but his friends to the top of the city by flying? I, too, was half watching the show, yet I could still think of that while texting.
"They were pretty faithful tot he Boomy episode." You, sir, definitely downloaded the wrong Avatar... I don't know which one you downloaded wrong, but the Boomy episodes were so drastically different. The only things the same were the character's names and the location. That's it.
Fallout , Last of Us , and One Piece are 3 of the better adaptations I've seen. And all these 3 things have their creators monitoring the stories. Other shows need to do this.
this guy is like the prophet muhammad of the modern era....something of a religious figure, akin to paul maud'dib atreides from hit film Dune: Part Two
I did not like Dune 2... Its great on many level and a film I would watch again. Not like this avatar... Dune scenes were disconnected in time and space. I understood the story but it did not flow for me....
for the most part i think the acting wouldn't have been a problem if the scenes were written better. is it the writer's fault? was it some higher up decision making gone wrong (as usual). maybe the actors did succ BUT they were literally not given a chanse with this directing and writing, and now everybody will remember them like this and not cast them anywhere... that's kinda depressing
Yea..I know it is opinion based but meh..Im a fan of the original AND I loved the live action. It's OK to disagree with an opinion base. You put yourself out there and open yourself for criticism just ad the Netflix show. I'm not saying the live action is perfect but I'm also not saying the original one is either. The end.
@@Mally620 It's not though. It's good, it's *really good,* but it has some minor issues; first that comes to mind is Aang's conflict on how to deal with the Firelord, which gets resolved as a dues ex machina.
Im the easter bunny im the easter bunny
The whole spiel about The Avatar needing to walk alone is so forced and pointless, the expanded material for the universe makes it clear that EVERY avatar had their own close knit friend group, by virtue of their job requiring them to travel the world and connect with its people.
Right? Netflix needs to stop pulling themes from later in the show without doing any of the work to set them up. In the original Aang does get to a point of feeling he needed to do it alone, but that's not until season 3 and there was a significant reason for him feeling that way (I won't spoil it for anyone else). The way netflix slapped that theme on was terrible. And now what are they going to do when they get to that point in season 3? Is Aang just going to reset and go back to wanting to do it alone? Or will they just ignore it entirely? 🤷♂
Lit, natla making roku, kuruk and kyoshi say that aang has to "do it alone" had to be the biggest bs ever,
The past avatars saying that the avatar needs to be alone is so weird, considering every single one of them were in relationships and had friend groups, like kyoshi had a wife, kuruk had a wife, roku had a wife and grandkids, pretty sure yangchen also had a wife, like all of them had people they were close to???
And it's the exact opposite message that Yangchen gave to Aang in the original series...
Yangchen: "Avatar Aang, I know that you are a gentle spirit, and the monks have taught you well, but this isn't about you; this is about the world."
Aang: "But the monks taught me that I had to detach myself from the world so my spirit could be free."
Yangchen: "Many great and wise Air Nomads have detached themselves and achieved spiritual enlightenment, but the Avatar can never do it, because your sole duty is _to_ the world."
But yes, considering that all the past Avatars had friends, got married and raised families, etc. (the Fire Nation Avatar before Roku was even an administrator in the Fire Nation government), it makes no sense why they all suddenly would deprive Aang of the same and put new rules and strictures on him that they themselves did not abide.
I'm so happy to see a video from someone who hadn't watched ATLA first, and I'm glad you still have criticisms over it. Makes me feel a little less crazy.
Ohhh you’re so not gonna like what they did to Azula 😂🤣
The live action is what initially got me interested in watching Avatar. I watched season one of the original just before the netflix version and then I went back, started over with the original and watched it from start to finish. As I went through the next two seasons, I got progressively more frustrated with the netflix version. Out of everyone, I think netflix butchered Katara the most. I won't spoil anything, but she has some very intense arcs in the last season and I do not see how netflix can get Katara to the point she needs to be for them to make any sense. Netflix didn't even let Katara get jealous of Aang, and that pales in comparison to what comes later.
Insightful, humorous, and IMO accurate.
Zesty little bad boy💀💀
Yeah, watching The Dragon Prince: The Mystery of Aaravos, I'm reminded how Erik Todd Dellums does so much better as Koh than George Takei. George's Koh just sounds like a predator playing with his "food". Erik's Koh sounds like an actual mysteriously sadistic demonic spirit who actually has wisdom to give, kind of like the Sphynx where you have to play his game; he will give you the wisdom you seek, but should you fail his game (via show any bit of emotion) and he steals your face, trapping you forever between life and death . . .
Having Katara stealing a bending scroll goes against the current message for women in modern media. They can't have character flaws, display weakness or possess any moral ambiguity.
i'm noticing this more and more where they pigeonhole female characters into black and white morality . rather than creating an 'empowered' character with agency like they intend to , people write another version of the 'fairer sex' stereotype
A very well spoken and laid out take. You put your thoughts to paper really well
Once again, the ATLA remakes have lost their honor
I genuinely wanted the opinion of someone who hasn't watched the original because I needed to know whether I hated this live action so much because I'm a fan of the original but now I'm sure it's not the only reason like most of the defenders of the live action argue. It just makes what is already pretty bad 10 times worse. xD
You've seen the episode where Aang gets caught, and his friends got sick, right? So you know that Aang is SUPER fast. That and with the now added fact in this version that he can fly without his glider. Who would have gotten to the earth king faster to stop the bomb? The two people that would HAVE to take the long way around by running through the city or the kid that could carry not just himself but his friends to the top of the city by flying?
I, too, was half watching the show, yet I could still think of that while texting.
They got aangs name right at least
Enjoy watching the rest of the original. You have such a pleasure and joy to watch ahead of you
Your videos are fantastic, I subscribed after watching 2 of them. Keep it up!
What an amazing, and interesting point of view. It was enlightening.
To be honest 99% of remix are bad 😔
"They were pretty faithful tot he Boomy episode."
You, sir, definitely downloaded the wrong Avatar... I don't know which one you downloaded wrong, but the Boomy episodes were so drastically different. The only things the same were the character's names and the location. That's it.
this guys content kinda like frog leg soup…. GOATED!!!!!
Have you considered comparing the adaptations of "Mo Dao Zu Shi"?
Nice analysis
I'm glad I didn't see it 😅 😬
9:11 😭😭 that’s so crazyy
Beast mode!!
Already watched it in the premier, this comment is just for the algo
Real (I wasn't there for the premiere)
another good adaption is shogun. Wow. Such an incredible show. Puts NATLA to shame
Same with Percy jackson except it received so much praise despite being low key worse than avatar in some ways
i just think that they tried to mix up everything into 1 episode like omashu they have jet and sai which are episodes apart in the original
Okay there were references from later seasons so I feel like you gotta watch at least season two (I haven’t finished watching the video)
Fallout , Last of Us , and One Piece are 3 of the better adaptations I've seen.
And all these 3 things have their creators monitoring the stories. Other shows need to do this.
When I'm thankful that the writer at least cares enough about the series to not make a lot of horrible decisions.
They did though
@@visionentertainment8006 "not make a LOT of horrible decisions."
this guy is like the prophet muhammad of the modern era....something of a religious figure, akin to paul maud'dib atreides from hit film Dune: Part Two
I did not like Dune 2... Its great on many level and a film I would watch again. Not like this avatar... Dune scenes were disconnected in time and space. I understood the story but it did not flow for me....
I stopped watching lou after the episode joel pulled the bat out. He would not have done that in game.
I have with you agreed
Ya the show sucked so fucking hard. Cringey af to watch.
for the most part i think the acting wouldn't have been a problem if the scenes were written better. is it the writer's fault? was it some higher up decision making gone wrong (as usual). maybe the actors did succ BUT they were literally not given a chanse with this directing and writing, and now everybody will remember them like this and not cast them anywhere... that's kinda depressing
idk i liked it
Fun fact! In Legends of Korra it is revealed that Aang has an affair with Ty Lee
can you blame aang?!??
Sorry I really like to lie
@@cobyknight7850if you said Sokka then I would have been like maybe, but aang? Nah
Aang cheating on Katara knowing damn well that she can blood bend . Lmao nice try
Um... No? That never happened.
Netflix’s is not the worst the movie is the worst
Both are dog shit, End of story
Yea..I know it is opinion based but meh..Im a fan of the original AND I loved the live action. It's OK to disagree with an opinion base. You put yourself out there and open yourself for criticism just ad the Netflix show. I'm not saying the live action is perfect but I'm also not saying the original one is either. The end.
hot take henrysimmons!!
The original one is literally perfect tho
@@Mally620 It's not though. It's good, it's *really good,* but it has some minor issues; first that comes to mind is Aang's conflict on how to deal with the Firelord, which gets resolved as a dues ex machina.
Well that's the differenece, I think the original was perfect.
You like The Last of Us. Your point is invalid.