Watching from the UK. I have only been watching Dr Shabir Ali for the last few days as I came to know about this channel for only few days and Alhamdulillah I am immensely benefitting from Dr Shabir Ali's knowledge and wisdom. May Allah SWT increase him in knowledge and grant him long span and grant him great rewards for his good deeds and same to the host.
When a hadith says "_____ will be equal to hajj" or similar, I always figured it means the minimum reward for hajj, but most people who perform hajj would get more than the minimum for hajj.
I thought the last episode was the last of the series😅. I have been discarding this kind of hadith for long time, thank you for mentioning the logic behind it, Dr. Shabir...
There are so many of these types of hadiths existing in the hadith books - great rewards for small deeds and huge punishment for avoiding or delaying small commandments. These doesn’t make any sense for even a minimum sensible person.
@@I-AM-Yousuf “Don’t follow blindly any thing what you have no knowledge of. Surely the hearing the sight and the heart - all of these shall be questioned about that.”(Quran 17:36) Brother, have you read the Hadith books. Read these books and you yourself will find the discrepancies in these books. These contradict the Quran, contradict themselves and common sense. May God guides you to the true path.
The Quran says that the prophet Muhammad didn't know the future (6:50) and it also says that the prophet did not know what will happen to himself or what will happen to anyone else (46:9). He could not promise anyone that if they did something how they would be rewarded or punished. Only Allah subhanahu watala can judge and determine what rewards or punishments a person will receive. 6:50 50. Say, “I do not say to you that I possess the treasuries of God, nor do I know the future, nor do I say to you that I am an angel. I only follow what is inspired to me.” Say, “Are the blind and the seeing alike? Do you not think?” 46:9 9. Say, “I am not different from the other messengers; and I do not know what will be done with me, or with you. I only follow what is inspired in me, and I am only a clear warner.”
For 1400 years no one dare to question all This otherwise your head will be chip off.. It is the apologist of others faith such as Christianity who brought it up and attack it, then Muslims apologist have no choice than to come out obligatory to put the fire off to ease things..
Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet Muhammad said. Indeed, a letter in the Koran, which consists of 30 verses, can intercede for its readers until their sins are forgiven. Namely, the letter Tabarakal lafzi bi yadihil mulku (Al-Mulk). (HR. Tirmidhi: V/164) Anas bin Malik said, Rasulullah said. There is a letter in the Qur'an which only consists of 30 verses, which can defend its readers and even send them to heaven, namely the Tabarak letter. (HR. Ath-Thabrani: I/176)
@@HaFii23 I don't fear Bukhari. I just believe that the Quran is the only religious authority. If someone writes something that either adds, subtracts or contradicts the Quran. I disregard it.
PLEASE also discuss hadith mentioning exaggerated greatness and excellence of Prophets household and companions. They also seemed to be forged and tempered. 8:22
Nice playing with words As an aplogist does Hide all red flags in the faith Hope some people can read in between the lines Use styles and tactics suitable for time place and circumstance And during new modern times say they don't apply now May God protect us from religion
Having set quite a low bar in this series you've surprisingly managed to hit a new low point. The underlying premise of this entire video is the assumption that you're able to independently judge the fairness of God's rewards/punishments for certain actions. Shabir Ally's opinion isn't a valid source of religion. This video is a waste of time.
Your ideas are not based on the Quran. The Quran is the only true religious authority in Islam. Hadiths are man made fabrications that were attributed to the prophet. The prophet never said any of those things that Bukhari and the others claim. Hadiths were made in order to get the Muslims to abandon reading the Quran for guidance and answers to questions.
as i have observed over the past few years you have changed your trajectory of Dahwa, really hope it's just a miscalculation!.. only Allah knows how to calculate peoples deeds....different scale with a different way of calculation... this worlds logic should not be used to understand the logic of Qyama...
What absurd calculations of good deeds when the Bible teaches us that we fall far short of God's righteous standards. All who trust in their own good deeds will be shown for what they are on the Day of Judgment. You must put your faith in Jesus' righteousness and his sacrifice for your sake, it is the only hope for sinners.
No we dont put our trust in good deeds, we put our trust in God forgiving our shortcomings and our sins, that is His promise to us in the Quran, nor do we need God to die on a cross to forgive us, why do we do good deeds ? Simple, when the intention is to please God/Allah it brings us closer to Him and His forgiveness. Muslims dont take out a calculator and count how many rewards they are gona get on the day of judgement for good deeds done here, the mention of rewards is simply a way to motivate us to keep on going when life's day to day struggles are getting us down
Even the inauthentic and fabricated hadith is more reliable than your entire Bible, because we know who said what and who heard from who. What do you bring to the table? Anonymous authors?
@@musanicxon7154 So you follow a religion passed down through the lips if liars and you have faith in it? If Islam is true, then show me Dhul Qarnayn's wall, the stones that pelted the people of the elephant, or any archaeology that supports Mecca existed back to the days of Abraham. No truth claims made in the Quran are true. It is just a fabrication supported by a narrative of questionable validity.
Watching from the UK. I have only been watching Dr Shabir Ali for the last few days as I came to know about this channel for only few days and Alhamdulillah I am immensely benefitting from Dr Shabir Ali's knowledge and wisdom. May Allah SWT increase him in knowledge and grant him long span and grant him great rewards for his good deeds and same to the host.
More scholars need to be truthful and leave their "gangs"
Such a relevant and important topic. Most scholars are not brave enough to discuss this. Thanks to Quran speaks 💚👏🏼 love Shabir 💚
When a hadith says "_____ will be equal to hajj" or similar, I always figured it means the minimum reward for hajj, but most people who perform hajj would get more than the minimum for hajj.
I thought the last episode was the last of the series😅.
I have been discarding this kind of hadith for long time, thank you for mentioning the logic behind it, Dr. Shabir...
There are so many of these types of hadiths existing in the hadith books - great rewards for small deeds and huge punishment for avoiding or delaying small commandments. These doesn’t make any sense for even a minimum sensible person.
That's your Islamic problem...deal with it!
You faith is a little bet weak, make it stronger.
@@I-AM-Yousuf “Don’t follow blindly any thing what you have no knowledge of. Surely the hearing the sight and the heart - all of these shall be questioned about that.”(Quran 17:36)
Brother, have you read the Hadith books. Read these books and you yourself will find the discrepancies in these books. These contradict the Quran, contradict themselves and common sense.
May God guides you to the true path.
The great islamic scholar Hafiz Ibn al-Hajr al-Asqalani and Imam Ibn al-Qayyim has written extensively on these type of hadith material
MashAllah JazakAllah
The Quran says that the prophet Muhammad didn't know the future (6:50) and it also says that the prophet did not know what will happen to himself or what will happen to anyone else (46:9). He could not promise anyone that if they did something how they would be rewarded or punished. Only Allah subhanahu watala can judge and determine what rewards or punishments a person will receive.
6:50
50. Say, “I do not say to you that I possess the treasuries of God, nor do I know the future, nor do I say to you that I am an angel. I only follow what is inspired to me.” Say, “Are the blind and the seeing alike? Do you not think?”
46:9
9. Say, “I am not different from the other messengers; and I do not know what will be done with me, or with you. I only follow what is inspired in me, and I am only a clear warner.”
For 1400 years no one dare to question all
This otherwise your head will be chip off..
It is the apologist of others faith such as Christianity who brought it up and attack it, then Muslims apologist have no choice than to come out obligatory to put the fire off to ease things..
Can you tell me a person killed for doubting in some hadiths not the whole?
Good video.
Thank you for this video, awesome! But truly, I need to know Dr. Shabir's skincare routine 😁😂
Thank you dr shabir
Can you also discuss the hadith that says reading surah mulk every night will save from punishment of the grave
Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet Muhammad said.
Indeed, a letter in the Koran, which consists of 30 verses, can intercede for its readers until their sins are forgiven. Namely, the letter Tabarakal lafzi bi yadihil mulku (Al-Mulk). (HR. Tirmidhi: V/164)
Anas bin Malik said, Rasulullah said.
There is a letter in the Qur'an which only consists of 30 verses, which can defend its readers and even send them to heaven, namely the Tabarak letter. (HR. Ath-Thabrani: I/176)
@@Friendlyinternetuser that's a fabrication. The prophet never said that. Bukhari lied on the prophet many times.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559what Bukhari? Tirmidhi and Thabarani are written here you’re blinded by Bukhariphobia
@@HaFii23 I don't fear Bukhari. I just believe that the Quran is the only religious authority. If someone writes something that either adds, subtracts or contradicts the Quran. I disregard it.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 so how do you pray?
Is third eye real in islam?
Sahih al-Bukhari 5639(momo turn into a garden sprinkler)💧👈🏿👳🏿👉🏿💧
PLEASE also discuss hadith mentioning exaggerated greatness and excellence of Prophets household and companions.
They also seemed to be forged and tempered. 8:22
Non Muslims will ve happy to see these videos
Nice playing with words
As an aplogist does
Hide all red flags in the faith
Hope some people can read in between the lines
Use styles and tactics suitable for time place and circumstance
And during new modern times say they don't apply now
May God protect us from religion
Allah Akbar
take thye BS you like and call all other info Forgeries, What an absolute scientific way to confirm your religious book.
Having set quite a low bar in this series you've surprisingly managed to hit a new low point. The underlying premise of this entire video is the assumption that you're able to independently judge the fairness of God's rewards/punishments for certain actions.
Shabir Ally's opinion isn't a valid source of religion. This video is a waste of time.
Your ideas are not based on the Quran. The Quran is the only true religious authority in Islam. Hadiths are man made fabrications that were attributed to the prophet. The prophet never said any of those things that Bukhari and the others claim. Hadiths were made in order to get the Muslims to abandon reading the Quran for guidance and answers to questions.
as i have observed over the past few years you have changed your trajectory of Dahwa, really hope it's just a miscalculation!..
only Allah knows how to calculate peoples deeds....different scale with a different way of calculation...
this worlds logic should not be used to understand the logic of Qyama...
What absurd calculations of good deeds when the Bible teaches us that we fall far short of God's righteous standards. All who trust in their own good deeds will be shown for what they are on the Day of Judgment. You must put your faith in Jesus' righteousness and his sacrifice for your sake, it is the only hope for sinners.
Mark 12:29
@@godisonegodhaswon You can't love the Lord your God without loving his son. Mark 12:1-12
No we dont put our trust in good deeds, we put our trust in God forgiving our shortcomings and our sins, that is His promise to us in the Quran, nor do we need God to die on a cross to forgive us, why do we do good deeds ? Simple, when the intention is to please God/Allah it brings us closer to Him and His forgiveness. Muslims dont take out a calculator and count how many rewards they are gona get on the day of judgement for good deeds done here, the mention of rewards is simply a way to motivate us to keep on going when life's day to day struggles are getting us down
Read Luke 1:6.
So many problematic hadith it takes 17 episodes to explain away. Why follow the fabrication called Islam?
There's been fabrication after several hundred years. Original Islam is stil safe.
Even the inauthentic and fabricated hadith is more reliable than your entire Bible, because we know who said what and who heard from who. What do you bring to the table? Anonymous authors?
That’s the dumbest argument I’ve ever heard Lmao
Islam ain't a fabrication. Its the fabricated words imposed on the prophet wc weren't true.
Buh with regards to islam, its the only true religion...
@@musanicxon7154 So you follow a religion passed down through the lips if liars and you have faith in it?
If Islam is true, then show me Dhul Qarnayn's wall, the stones that pelted the people of the elephant, or any archaeology that supports Mecca existed back to the days of Abraham. No truth claims made in the Quran are true. It is just a fabrication supported by a narrative of questionable validity.