Prof Mcebisi Ndletyana unpacks further developments on Ramaphosa's Phala Phala farm saga
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2024
- Opposition parties represented in parliament intend to submit the names of four retired judges to the Speaker of Parliament, Nosiziwe Mapisa Nqakula, to investigate President Cyril Ramaphosa's conduct. This independent panel forms part of the bid to impeach the President following allegations against him regarding the burglary at his Phala Phala farm two years ago.
The parties have given details of the measures they will undertake to hold President Ramaposa accountable. Meanwhile, the ANC has stressed that the President is not avoiding accountability.
To unpack these developments further, Prof Mcebisi Ndletyana from the Department of Political Science at the University of Johannesburg joins us now...
For more news, visit sabcnews.com and also #SABCNews on all Social Media platforms.
Some people are ready to sacrifice with their dignity and careers for one man..I feel sorry for students taught by this man called Professor
Thank you!!!
His analysis are questionable
Well said. Look at the former PP as well.... they are many, who don't want to talk the truth.
He is a hired gun this one
This one is just biased n doesnt care
This is the kind of journalists we need in the country who ask really hard questions. I compliment her.
This interview proves that education does not equate to intellect!
I truly agree with you on that. I feel like this 'professor' is trying to cover up for the president.
Why is SABC waste their time inviting unethical person like this one.
He clearly protecting CR
I'm glad they invited him. This is the age where wolves are being exposed so they fall never to rise again.
What makes him unethical?
What makes him unethical?
@@GeniusLila his views are biased, his first statement was, Arthur Fraser is a liar, he set his tone on how he will respond to the questions
@@taskforcerydaz considering Fraser pushed to release Zuma even though there were no grounds to parole him I’d say there’s no credibility to Fraser either. He called Fraser a liar because I’m general he is, not that Fraser is lying on this matter.
I couldn’t finish the interview this prof is annoying me, Seems like he is covering something.
Me too bro, this is just rubbish and even a 7 year old can tell you that he is doing a serious cover up himself.
This should be the last interview of Ndletyana that I am watching 🤞
Me too
The Sabc need to take us serious to bring this type of reasoning for an interview
It beats me how the SABC keeps on calling this guy to canvass matters that are clearly beyond him. His incompetence in this role is astounding, how difficult is it to confirm that this indeed is a serious matter, does he even know that some people have criminal records for stealing items from Shoprite, something that would be less than a mere R1000. Imagine a discovery of millions of foreign currency and that answer is difficult to a whole professor 😳. I really feel sorry to the students under this guy whether doing their final year projects or post graduate programs and he's mentoring them. It seems the pockets of Mr Phala Phala are very deep, he's turned so many people as delusional
Couldn't agree more I don't think it's incompetence though I think it's bias he just won't say anything negative about Ramaposa and its a shame because he's supposed to come here and be neutral
Well said 👏
Useless professor ever I listen the interview between him and Dr Ndlozi about Nhlanhla Nene he was like this..
Funny, he is factual and doesn't want to speculate.
You are an Efffeeing idiot if you think the mere fact of having money means one committed crime. Has any institution confirm that they didn't know of the money????
This is sad. If I was enrolled in his class, I'd definitely drop out.
If this is the standard of a Uni Prof at UJ, the bar has really dropped.
It's a disgrace!!!
UJ is full of ANC party loyalists. You are quite right the bar has dropped
He is a useless Professor and he doesn’t have analytical skills
Only if you want the reply to be the one you want, is the problem
Came to read comments just to check if I'm still sane and yes I'm proven to be in a healthy state of mind... prof have you no shame? 🤦🏾♂️
I know Prof Ndletyana is pro Ramaphosa but here in this interview he seems to be under intoxication. Even his bias is wayward for me. I suspect there is something powerful in that cup. Look at the eyes and his behavior 🤔🤔🤔
I may agree. He's not sober minded as he asks us to be 🙄🙄
😂😂😂😂😂
This man is an apologist of the president and at the same time he doesn't want to seem to be against the criminal actions of the president...he has no balls..
Analysis of the stomach, he is looking for another Government Appointment
He is asking hard questions and exposing the lies.
This prof just prove that becoming a prof it's very easy. It's not even a position to respect because you can just wake up and become a prof.😂😂😂
How many times have you woken up in your life, are you a professor yet? 🤔
Did you ever have a professor in your life because people who had one respect the profession for many reasons.
🤣🤣🤣
This is not a prof
@@salomenkoana4937 This professor says Frazer is a liar.
I am saying Engobo Igbo is a liar because I did not wake up and become a professor so did this professor, so did Thabedi Salome
@@GeniusLila you didn't understand. it was a way to show how the prof undermine that title, you can't be saying things like that while you know you will be followed by different people. It's not wrong to be on the defensive side, but say what makes sense.
This professor aka Chief Defender of Cyril Ramaphosa is lost. Does he not know that you can go to jail for avoiding tax or breaching forex regulations?
😂😂there is no amount of sense in the world that will override currency, stop expecting it.
@@shafiyaalgiquadra1105 you’re sick wena!
@ThokoHilda Mthombeni clearly this Prof doesn’t know and clueless about foreign currency that you can’t have it in your house without declaring it 🤦🏽♂️🙄
🤣🤣
@@siyabulelaklaasen2136 I have 100 pounds in my house 😆
Julius would be in jail if that was the case. SARS had to take his farm for unpaid tax!
Prof, keeping money under the mattress is tax avoidance and it's worse if done by a sitting president.
How can that be a misdemeanor? I definitely see your cognitive dissonance on this issue. This is SERIOUS and IMPEACHABLE offense.
He undermined confidence in our financial institutions. Money is kept in banks for a reason. It should be in in constant circulation to help grow the economy.
Tjo! O Mo hlabile ka sekgowa mfana. A ka se buseletse gape. I can recruit you to my R English T Force
Tjo! O Mo hlabile ka sekgowa mfana. A ka se buseletse gape. I can recruit you to my R English T Force
@@tcdcoptions 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I respect you Prof, you've studied hard to achieve your position. Please help us with an academic analysis next time. Let there be a difference between when an academic speaks and when we listen to a general person
I second this
Sakhina your guest is bias and not answering your questions, he's concentration on Frazer being untruthful doesn't make sense cos Frazer told us about something we were not aware of, in fact this interview was not fruitful.
So Ramadoller is so lucky that he even gets to be defended by professors 🙄...
The prof is struggling to confuse us here
He's even struggling to be still n focused
He is all over...🤦🏿♂️
@@theaskmembuyazi LOL I noticed that he can't sit still singing for his supper
Shivambu asked Governor, has there been a declaration of Foreign Money by any or the President during that time. Governor could not answer and side stepped the matter.
I listen to this guy to laugh 😂😂😂😂
A clown of note. How is this guy a Prof?
Prof is clearly protecting Ramaphosa. If it was Zuma he would have said different things
🤣🤣🤣 ngutata kabani loo , 🤣🤣🤣 he just finished by laughing .hayy , What had we done to deserves this rubbish
Sakina had fun bringing the CRness out of the "prof".
Yerr! I never thought a day would come where even Professors become ordinary and mediocre because of the power of money. Listening to this interview left me traumatized, we are in deep trouble
I have witnessed this before when medical doctors/professors became salespeople for the Fizer rona jab. It was sad watching them defending what they know is not a vaccine.
Mpongwana, Iam with you there. This professor is very economic with the truth. He is openly siding with the president. The same so called professor was spitting fire whenever the name "Zuma" was mentioned. I rest my case.
The Prof speaks a lot of sense. But ke Twitter/Internet intelligentia is focused on trends and noise!
Used to love Prof, but its so sad to see him sell his soul. I remember also how he would defend Pravin
Broer hai shame this one he was once cornered by Ndlozi 🙈🙈🙈🙈
Just admit it, you hate that he doesn't share your views. Simple!
I have views and opinions, I'm not a professor. The minute you start treat politics and politians like Marvel Superhero movie, i dont trust your judgement.
2. He has made up his mind that Cyril is a messianic figure. He has been consistent in defending the incumbent and find scapegoats for the problems of his administration.
@@GolelaSihle If it is about declaring for tax purposes then why most of us SA citizens are not facing the music as well because most of us are selling intsangu and we keep a lot of intsangu proceeds in our houses and we don't declare that.
I don’t see why this comment section is so upset at the prof🤣🤣🤣
Cyril will be acquitted and people will be angry because they think court of public opinion means something. The prof is right and people are upset because he’s not telling them what they want to hear.
Oh MY the only sane person in this comments section
Ramaphosa has disappointed many who hailed him as this clean, ethical and transparent President as opposed to Zuma. They now have to sell the truth and duck and dive in order maintain the “Ramaphosa image” of an upright President. Zyakhala ke manje 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 . This Prof is making a joke of himself to the public
I personally commend Sakina for relevant hard questions. But very clear that Mdletjana is a factional analyst. His dodgy responses in this as it involves his dirty master, it wouldn't be the same if it is JZ. What a shame.
This guy is an embarrassment, a Professor with such pedestrian analysis.
Factional professor.
I don't think this guy is a Professor, noways 🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣definitely is not a professor he's stupid
😂😂😂😂😂
it cant be.. hai khona 😅
Please Sakina don't ever bring this Professor to your platform again... a total NUSENSE from a Professor
Again Media with their so called love for Ramaphosa, they give this wonderful Professor enough time to change our minds on the matter at hand. SABC should know better and not invite this Man again because Wow he is not a great analyst
What makes him not a great analyst? Let me guess, because you don't agree with him?
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Ndyetlan should keep exposing the lies
Aubrey Mashiqi is the most balance political analyst. Why is Ndletyana bieng given a platform to twerk for Silili again, what a dishonest man I feel sorry for his students, Sakina is also found wanting these days
As for tweaking 😂
He is not, he is in Mshowerlozi's pocket
We being insulted by this so called Proffesor here
UJ is in Trouble with this professor. No one likes duck riding Ramaphosa like him
We are indeed in trouble . He is unethical .
SABC must take us serious and call real "Experts" not clown, apologists & defenders of criminals, solely because the criminal can finance his way through. Never call Mcedisi Ndletyana. He is degrading the title "Prof"
By real expert you mean Sipho SEEPE???🤣🤣🤣
Agreed cz ds stupid so called professor is useless
I used to think professors were intelligent people
How do we get to the point where this matter is discussed as a misdemeanor. We haven't even gotten to the point of where exactly did the money came from, or why was it kept under mattresses instead of a safe or strong room
This professor's logic and reasoning/lack thereof leaves much to be desired
The SABC should call this guy all the time. We need someone this honest.
what honesty? this is the most dumbest&biased academic I have come accross! he is so subjective...
I swear on my life, this one is on the pocket of Rama and he disgusts me. He keeps on defending this President always, he has lost it as an analyst Shem 🤷♂️
How I intentionally wasted my time listening to this proffessor.
Kuchoka !To get tired!! ..South Africans sympathies...from Kenya 🇰🇪..
This prof is a member of ANC
SABC please next call intellectual analyst
This man analytics credentials are questionable beyond reproach.
The man is so captured, in such a way he can't even answer simple questions. It's sad
Yhoooo 🙈 I cannot make a head or tail of what the Prof is saying😟
Aaaaa Ntate Mcebisi 😨 😔, you've been one of the most analysts I ever relied on, but sadly you destroyed all my hope on you. I'm quite unable to finish this interview.
Tell me your joking please bra u can't be crs lol
Prof talks about Vendetta. A Mbekite by nature, and have seen him how he used to attack Zuma presidency. I wonder what does he call that?
i saw a picture of Mandela behind then I know that he sending a signal to superiors that he's going to defend Ramaphosa
Ndletyana is asking hard questions and exposing the lies. They won't like it.
Where is Somadoda Fikeni?? These ones are wasting our time.
What about this [takes the money does not deliver the buffalo]?? Hazim Mustafa, a football club owner and businessman from Sudan, now living in Dubai, has been identified as the mystery man who paid $580 000 in cash to a Phala Phala lodge manager - for buffalo he never got.
SABC must be ashamed of themselves. This man is bias to an extent that he’s trying to hide the finger.
I’m not an expert when comes to analysis but this is a shame.
Find his analysis very balanced actually.
@@scottcline183 Of course you would know about ballance
Why does SABC still call this guy. I haven't had a listen yet but I bet you, he favors Ramaphosa 🤣😂
This man has been waffling for a while now 🤣🤣
I actually usually don't listen to him, because I know his line of reasoning even before listening to him. However since this is a clear case of Ramaphosa being in the wrong, I thought let me give him the benefit of the doubt...mmmm was I not disappointed hugely as usual this so-called Prof is dancing for Ramaphosa, this time he was actually twerking. I am sure he also got money from the CR17 campaign.
WELL done PROF what you sad,its CLEAR as Crystal
Ndlozi dealt with this peanut brain
The Professor is very objective and he is very practical in his approach by already looking into the direction of possible litigation of the Phala Phala saga. He is truly objective..it is sad that some readers wanted to hear something else from Professor and such are disappointed
🎉
are you mad?do you call this gutter analysis objective?this ankole operative,who parades as a professor has clearly lost his moral compass🤔his an educated fool
'OBJECTIVE' WOW What a 'PROFESSORS'
Lest we forget about this 'OBJECTIVE' ACADEMIC LET'S BE REMINDED.
th-cam.com/video/LgLAbt9iRvA/w-d-xo.html
SABC will deliberately call this man in order to cover up the whole issue
Ramaphosa’s spokesperson has spoken. The man said we are doing fine
Prof Dletyana has gone on hibernation for far too long now, why? Prof used to be the proponent of Ramaphala to an extent that he campaign for him in public in media. Now ramadollar has accepted bribes from Mustafa suddenly zip Dletyana, why?
Can that professor tell us why the UK 🇬🇧 PM resigned?
eeish why mara do we have factionalist morons parading as professors&Phd...
This professor is a joke, he even enjoys his coffee ☕ on a live interview shame, he gets paid for defending wrong doing by statesman
I'm disappointed in Ndletshana
Sober and balanced analysis by the Prof. not clouded by the hullabaloo. The justice system deals with hard facts and evidence. Well done Prof.👋👋. I wish our politicians can apply the same zeal in addressing our country's serious problems of our young boys eaten up by nyaope, high unemployment of our youth, high cost of living, ESKOM etc. But because this one, has capital political currency, they are in top gear to impeach Ramaphosa, hypocritical.👎👎
So you must want Zuma back then?
Exactly
Anyone can be a professor
Uyasidakelwa loMcebisi ndini
What the heck is going on in this guys head???
This man!!
He must just become the President's spoke person once and for all.
This Prof thinks he's the whole mark of knowledge. He is talking nonsense must say. I am questioning his professorship and academic standing. A professor of knowledge wouldn't go out of his way to analyse nonsense. He must be shameful to be called professor.
You are useless and you think everyone must agree with you
The man is a Ramaphosa analyst.
This prof is an embarrassment to institution he serves in
Ramapoz on borrowed time now ⌚🤔.
Please get other analyst. We are tired of him
Wonder why south african education is very shallow....you call this a prof?? What a shame
Prof is right am with you Professor.
You're with him on zero accountability agenda for CR?
@@phelelanimafuleka3854 no I am not on Zero accountability, am on the issue that evidence must be compiled and investigation completed before we guilt charge the president. The political agenda is not going to work here
@@koenaboitysherif1847 Auther fraser provided the evidence to Hawks but no update about investigation, Ramaphosa answer 31 questions but his answers are prohibited to be in publice domain. All other law enforcement agencies has no update for the past two months. Ramaphosa himself admitted to this Phala Phala claims but can't take the country into his confidence nor his political party. We as the public are allowed to connect the dots and come up with conclusions
@@phelelanimafuleka3854 who corroborated that evidence?
@@koenaboitysherif1847 Hawks should be be giving us satisfactory update and confirm whether there is prima facie case on Fraser's evidence and claims but nothing? Do you have any evidence at your disposal that Ramaphosa did not commit crime?
This thing is not a professor at all
Which University does Prof cime from. I would suggest that anyone serious about their academic progress, avoid such a University if possible.
This clown is employed by Wits,believe it.
@@monwalee1427, very close, I mean UJ is very close to Wits but believe you me, they are very far apart if you get me.
Let me give it to Ladies , I respect you ladies first Mshololo and now Sakina you are exposing men that they are incomplacent big up to sisters
Please never bring this clawn professor here again, he bought his PhD shame.
This professor is a joke..he lost his common sense and reasoning
If Ramaphosa is wrong, he will go. Let’s not be emotional. Government should be of laws rather than of men. Morally, the president should resign if he embarrasses his office. If there is a cover up by his people, it is his people and not him who will go.
Mcebisi Ndletyana decided long ago, to take an unpopular stance of not going with the flow, when it comes to the president "akahambi nomrhiba". Its an interesting view he seems to be advocating. I watched him during the R500k saga from Busasa.
I was not going to watch this interview of an ever grinning professor, if it wasn't Sekina who was handling them questions!
U not worthy the title "Professor" Mr Ndletyana.
Thank you Sakina for giving the Prof time not be misunderstood. He sounded and looked a bit tired.
Prof ur smile makes one's day. Ur view point so welcoming. Why would one keep their money in mattress when the president can own a safe. After 2 yrs wow.
What happen to Zuma more than 100 criminal charges😢😂😂😂😂
Ndletyana always speaks with passion. Hayi this time around uya a-a-za uProf. At least for now, I would not like the president to be impeached because the country can easily get into serious instability.
He's got a vendetta against Zuma and he is happy that he is removed
I loved this guy for his analysis, but today I am very very disappointed with him. He speaks in tongues.
Tax avoidance not a serious crime according to this clown of a professor.
Thank you for give us more knowledge and information about this matter
Disappointing analysis. Shallow, untruthful and annoying
People are suffering chest pains....a cash matter is hard to proof...😂😂😂 I took R20...no you took R500.... I took R500, no you R20😂😂😂
Disgraceful so-called analysis.
I can honestly say the professor is talking absolute junk he sounds like a sponsored gun
In 2008 there was a burglars at President Thabo Mbeki's official residence Mahlambandlovu on the Bryntirion Estate in Government Avenue in Pretoria. R20 000 was stolen and aluminum worth R30 000's the case was open at Sunnyside police station. Prof is talk kaka.
Professor Ndletyana is trying by all means to clear Ramaphosa's name
And you are trying by all means to smear him
@@khathurandela737
I don't care if he is alive or not.