They all do it brilliantly, It's hard to choose one Aimie - The original Queen Sam - Has lots of Riffs Courtney - Has the Young vibe to K-Howard Jodie - Emotional K-Howard after what she went through Allcia - The scream/Cry at the end to show she's being beheaded Vicki - Deep tone in her voice Georgia - Screams the note, But goodly Sophie - Mature K-Howard, More Britney then Ariana Personally my top 3 are Aimie,Jodie & Sophie
Im sorry but I'm partial to aimie. The anger and emotion in her voice just kills me. All of them are emotional but i just love aimie so so much and her voice kills me. All of these ladies kill it though!
Personally, I love Aimie's overall performance the most (and you chose a really nice picture of her!) but I think my favorite delivery of "fairest of the fair" is Alicia's
honestly 1. Aimie (I love the roughness in the bite and of) 2. Sam (I saw the broadway bootleg and she was so good) 3: Courtney (she’s like a more softer version of aimie)
Honestly, I think Jodie was the best. Mostly due to the fact that the way she sings, reminds us that not only was she 18 when she was beheaded, but a lot of the stuff those men did to her, she either didn't want, or was too young and naive to know better and was taken advantage of big time.
I love the way she lets the last bit slip out with so much emotion and it really seems natural. I’ve seen her live and she’s incredible!! But I love all of them and I couldn’t pick a favourite
@@liamholsgrove1404 I was meant to go see her in Dublin but sadly cause of Covid it was cancelled :( so I'm compensating by watching recorded versions of the UK tour cast ^^;
actually the I heard the live version of Sam Pauly singing AYWD and hers are most likely to be emotional too (like all the sh-- and the bs she've been through, she's like cracking up, that's my explanation for that) the ones that was used here was kinda unfair but I can't blame the creator if the live version of her AYWD was taken down in that time
PLEASE listen to this version of Samantha's all you wanna do.th-cam.com/video/Yo2pFiPJK3Q/w-d-xo.html It was doring an actual show and the acting is **chefs kiss**
For me, it's hands-down Aimie, Jodie, Sophie. Aimie's raw emotion was fantastic, that *growl* in her voice sounds damn near amazing. Jodie's conveys the hurt and sadness and confusion, it's unfiltered and sounds raw in a different way to Aimie's, but I love it just as much. And then Sophie's has this childlike essence to it that adds to the trauma Howard went through, and I love her variation on the riff, the change would've been enough to do it, but it compliments the atmosphere of her performance so much I just can't-- However - Alicia is a close fourth. I don't know what it is about her performance that I like so much, but it's definitely there.
my favourites were definitely Aimie, Vicki, Sam and Courtney. Courtney is so underrated (in my opinion) and I love the way she sings this song! But they were all amazing!
My Top 3 are: 1) Alicia - You can hear the pain in her voice. It’s like a beautiful cry for help before meeting her fate. 2) Jodie - You can heat so much emotion in the clip; and it honestly breaks my heart. 3) Sophie. The reason I like Sophie’s is because it’s more britney to me than Ariana. And that isn’t bad at all! I like that it’s a more mature take. Also the love the way she sings “Fair”!!
This clip doesn't represent Sam's intense emotion and power since she was just doing a cover in her bedroom, in the actual performance I think she is as good as the rest, if not even better
I love Aimie and Sophie, they are amazing. But everyone did such a good job and they can certainly do it much better than most people, so props to them!
I'm gonna be honest that isn't the best recording of sam Pauly (there are actual videos on stage going around youtube that show her performing it rather than just singing it) so based on that is how I made my decisions: 1. Jodie Steele 2. Sam Pauly 3. Sophie Issacs
Sam is by FAR my favorite. Not necessarily the recording here because it isn't her stage performance, but my god the raw emotion, pain, and anger she puts into her performance at the end outranks everyone else by light years for me. (They're all amazing, don't get me wrong. Her's is just my personal favorite)
I'm going to be honest, I don't know which one did it best. The original cast recording has gotten me so used to hearing that note hit perfectly, but at the same time there's some of the others in this video that pretty much slammed the spirit out of me. I just want to see the day when I can finally pull off arranging Six in 6 Minutes and find a way to put each cast to the test.
it’s unfair that Samantha Pauly’s one was her bedroom cover since in the show she puts an INSANE amount of emotion into it. She is by far the best K Howard, voice wise and emotionally.
You should have used audio from the actual Broadway production and not her tiktok video as on stage Samantha killed it with raw emotion and feeling. Her stage production is my fave by far
My personal preference is Courtney, (largely influenced by the fact that I saw her live and was completely blown away by her performance of this song. I can't get it out of my head, it was really powerful) but they are all amazing!! So impressed with all of the singing talent and how they can each take it and make it their own.
This happens with every musical though.. Plus its not comparing in a bad way, people are just saying their favourites, they're obviously all great singers.
I personally enjoyed Samantha Pauly’s the most, but that was in her bedroom and the only recordings of her for the show keep on being taken down. She has the best emotion and vocals in my opinion because I can tell when she sings and when she doesn’t, same with the rest of her fellow cast members. Aimie in my opinion is pretty good and Alicia was outstanding, but Sam takes the cake for me.
I've seen Courtney in the Syd 2020 run, and the new Howard, Chelsea Dawson now in 2022. Both were incredible live. Courtney is currently playing Anna in the Frozen Aus tour, which is why she didn't reprise her role. She was already set to be taken over by Chelsea mid-Melb 2020 run, to start Frozen, but the Melb 2020 run never even began.
Samantha Paulo is an alumni of the high school I go to and is kind of close with our theatre director so she submitted something for our online cabaret this year
here y’all go: 0:07 aimie 0:34 sam 1:05 courtney 1:34 jodie 2:03 alicia 2:31 vicki 2:59 georgia 3:28 sophie my personal top 5 are (in this order): 1. jodie 2. vicki 3. sam 4. alicia 5. aimie honorable mention: courtney
Hey everyone! So shocked and happy how this video has turned out, what video would u like to see next??
PrickUpYourEars The high note in “Heart of Stone” or the ending note in IDNYL
Who sang Get Down best?
The “I Don’t Need Your Love“ Riff would be awesome!!
Who sang the "No way" riff best? If you haven't done it already
No way, don’t lose your head, heart of stone, get down, and I don’t need your love.
Aimie must have been having a really good day in that one, she sounded great
She was FEELING herself
The *growl* tho..
It sounds great, but must've been well painful--
@@jessk1683 not if you do it right
@@purpleisfetch714 perhaps. I wouldn't know. Sounds amazing tho.
JessK growls don’t hurt if you do it right
I think no one will EVER beat Aimie she really was just born for the part
Gr4ce _4_life I knew there was something wrong with it just didn’t know what-
I agree she was perfect
Agreed
Yesss i miss her
SAME! I love her so much
They all do it brilliantly, It's hard to choose one
Aimie - The original Queen
Sam - Has lots of Riffs
Courtney - Has the Young vibe to K-Howard
Jodie - Emotional K-Howard after what she went through
Allcia - The scream/Cry at the end to show she's being beheaded
Vicki - Deep tone in her voice
Georgia - Screams the note, But goodly
Sophie - Mature K-Howard, More Britney then Ariana
Personally my top 3 are
Aimie,Jodie & Sophie
Beth&Luke totally agree with you on your notes!! I think my favourites are Alicia, Jodie, Aimie and I actually really enjoy Georgia’s x
What happened to Jodie?
i love aimie and sam
Mine are Aimee, Courtney, and Georgia.
‘Goodly’?? 😂😭😵
Im sorry but I'm partial to aimie. The anger and emotion in her voice just kills me. All of them are emotional but i just love aimie so so much and her voice kills me. All of these ladies kill it though!
You sould hear the on stage performance of Sam, it's unfair that they used that audio of her singing in her bed while recording with her phone :/
@@rwoosh-er2958 yeah fair enough
@@samara1676 ヾ( ͝° ͜ʖ͡°)ノ♪
You NEED to hear Sam Pauly on stage performance!
Personally, I love Aimie's overall performance the most (and you chose a really nice picture of her!) but I think my favorite delivery of "fairest of the fair" is Alicia's
Yes totally agree with you x
Sameeee
totally agree x
it's kinda unfair that u used sam pauly's bed room recording when it doesnt have the emotion when she's performing
Sadly it got taken down so there was no choice
@@adriangroenewald3825 It's up again ;D
Mhm..
if y’all wanna see it i posted it on my channel 👀👀
Trell C. Oh yeah
samantha's performance is amazing tho, i saw a bootleg
my personal faves were samantha, aimie, and alicia
@Mystery- Ish th-cam.com/video/1UHq5vBhUpQ/w-d-xo.html
my favorites are the exact same! i love the emotion of sam, the belting of alicia, but i'll always be partial to aimie
Same here :)
3:29
Jesus Christ her high note sounds like a child crying out for help- hhHHH- I- TEARS-
Hers was innocent-sounding, and it differed from the usual pitching of that note as well, amazing.
Omg eyeless jack what are you doing here🤪💗
@@bcheaded
._. I'm not even an anon- it's just my pfp--
Random Fandom Addict wtf is an anon 💀
@@bcheaded it's when someone dedicates an account to roleplaying as a character
honestly
1. Aimie (I love the roughness in the bite and of)
2. Sam (I saw the broadway bootleg and she was so good)
3: Courtney (she’s like a more softer version of aimie)
wait can i please have the broadway bootleg -
Amelia Sellers
yeah she was so good!!!
Hey do want to join the Queen's group chat kathy
💚💚💚💚💚
Anne Boleyn
HELL YEAH!
**heard all about these rockin chickss*
Honestly, I think Jodie was the best. Mostly due to the fact that the way she sings, reminds us that not only was she 18 when she was beheaded, but a lot of the stuff those men did to her, she either didn't want, or was too young and naive to know better and was taken advantage of big time.
I love the way she lets the last bit slip out with so much emotion and it really seems natural. I’ve seen her live and she’s incredible!! But I love all of them and I couldn’t pick a favourite
So true
I haven't actually heard Jodie's before, but that was definitely one of my favourites
Katherine. H was 17 when she was beheaded.
deku aka random person She was nineteen when she died. She was seventeen when she married Henry (he was 49).
that’s no fair on sam thooooo hers is the only recording not in the show, hers honestly is the best in my opinion :))
right???
Yesss
Ikr I saw a recording of her in the shower and wow, she was phenomenal, she portrayed the emotion SO well.
SAME THOUGHTS
i saw sam opening weekend on broadway and she was FANTASTIC
Why is no one talking about Jodie Steele?? I know she's had some iffy performances but holy SHIT the emotion in that.
It’s so much better live! Legit had the whole audience in tears in Liverpool!
@@liamholsgrove1404 I was meant to go see her in Dublin but sadly cause of Covid it was cancelled :( so I'm compensating by watching recorded versions of the UK tour cast ^^;
Vocally for me it’s
1) Alicia
2) Samantha
3) Sophie
4) Jodie
5) Courtney
But my fave Howards are Aimie and Courtney
aimie is my favourite but this recording doesn’t quite do her justice but they’re all amazinggg
actually the I heard the live version of Sam Pauly singing AYWD and hers are most likely to be emotional too (like all the sh-- and the bs she've been through, she's like cracking up, that's my explanation for that)
the ones that was used here was kinda unfair but I can't blame the creator if the live version of her AYWD was taken down in that time
I wish Collette's was on here- hers is probably my favorite, right after Aimee
MapleHockeyLove I know I wish I could include all queens but decided to do this, would you like me to try and do a swing video for the song?? X
PrickUpYourEars I would love that! It’s actually not a bad idea to do that for all the solo songs (if you have the time and energy, of course ☺️☺️
I see your pfp 👀
K. Howards Ranked
8. They
7. Are
6. All
5. Perfect
4. In
3. Their
2. Own
1. Aimie Atkinson
lmao-
nice
Lmao yes so true
My favorite is Georgia and Courtney Monsma but ya know what I respect your opinion.
PLEASE listen to this version of Samantha's all you wanna do.th-cam.com/video/Yo2pFiPJK3Q/w-d-xo.html It was doring an actual show and the acting is **chefs kiss**
For me, it's hands-down Aimie, Jodie, Sophie.
Aimie's raw emotion was fantastic, that *growl* in her voice sounds damn near amazing.
Jodie's conveys the hurt and sadness and confusion, it's unfiltered and sounds raw in a different way to Aimie's, but I love it just as much.
And then Sophie's has this childlike essence to it that adds to the trauma Howard went through, and I love her variation on the riff, the change would've been enough to do it, but it compliments the atmosphere of her performance so much I just can't--
However - Alicia is a close fourth. I don't know what it is about her performance that I like so much, but it's definitely there.
How can you forget Samantha hello???
Jodie‘s all you wanna do broke me
I really like when the Howards' do the third "only thing" differently, Sam has a really good example of that in her stage version.
I really love Aimies voice 🥺🥺
Aimie and Jodie are my faves ❤️
Also, this recording of Aimie sounds old and doesn’t really do her justice
Samantha Pauly has always and will be my favorite. But all of them are amazing everyone in all the casts are perfect.
Time stamps
Aimee Atkinson:
0:08
Samantha Pauly
0:34
Courtney Monsma
1:03
Jodie Steele
1:33
Alicia Corrales Connor
2:02
Vicki Manser
2:30
Georgia Carr
2:59
Sophie Issac
3:27
I’ve never heard Sophie before and the way she delivers the lines, sounding so desperate and innocent, broke my heart... definitely my favourite here
*"And then I was beheaded.."*
sam’s personally my favorite because when she was on stage she had a LOT of emotion in her acting and she has a great voice. i love Aime’s too
You can never take away Aimee for creating all of the original cues for queens to follow but I am a HUGE Vicki fan!!!!
my favourites were definitely Aimie, Vicki, Sam and Courtney. Courtney is so underrated (in my opinion) and I love the way she sings this song! But they were all amazing!
Yeah she is so underrated, she's amazing! She was in the top ones for me
HOW DOES ALICIA MAKE THAT NOISE??? It scared me but was amazing. I couldn’t possibly choose who’s was the best! But you gotta love Aimie’s growl. 😍😍😍
They all nailed it tho
Aimie atkinson was giving every piece of herself in this song that she set the bar so high for those who will be doing this role too.
The VOCAL STRENGTH in Alicia’s never fails to shock me... how in the world-
Tbh Katherine Howard was literally my favorite queen,I’m gonna choose all of them < 3
Wish you used Sam's live version from every Howard I've heard she gives the best emotion and shes my favorite Howard (of course my opinion)
My favourites are definitely Alicia and Aimee, but they're all ridiculously talented!
Aimie Atkinson- 0:08
Samantha Pauly- 0:34
Courtney Monsma- 1:04
Jodie Steele- 1:34
Alicia Corrales Connor- 2:02
Vicki Manser- 2:31
Georgia Carr- 3:00
Sophie Issac- 3:29
I am literally analyzing all the singers and they all sound incredible and Alicia’s singing literally shocked me when she hit that riff so well
My Top 3 are:
1) Alicia - You can hear the pain in her voice. It’s like a beautiful cry for help before meeting her fate.
2) Jodie - You can heat so much emotion in the clip; and it honestly breaks my heart.
3) Sophie. The reason I like Sophie’s is because it’s more britney to me than Ariana. And that isn’t bad at all! I like that it’s a more mature take. Also the love the way she sings “Fair”!!
No Sam? Really?
This clip doesn't represent Sam's intense emotion and power since she was just doing a cover in her bedroom, in the actual performance I think she is as good as the rest, if not even better
Seeing Alicia live gave me chills she was so amazing
I love Aimie and Sophie, they are amazing. But everyone did such a good job and they can certainly do it much better than most people, so props to them!
I'm gonna be honest that isn't the best recording of sam Pauly (there are actual videos on stage going around youtube that show her performing it rather than just singing it) so based on that is how I made my decisions:
1. Jodie Steele
2. Sam Pauly
3. Sophie Issacs
Sam is by FAR my favorite. Not necessarily the recording here because it isn't her stage performance, but my god the raw emotion, pain, and anger she puts into her performance at the end outranks everyone else by light years for me. (They're all amazing, don't get me wrong. Her's is just my personal favorite)
i’ve never heard alicia before and damn she’s incredible
ALICIA AND SAM ARE SO GOOOOOD
I think they all have beautiful voices
damn, my top 5 are
1. aimie
2. alicia
3. sam
4. sophie
5. vicki
Forever sad I never got to see Aimee or Vicki as Howard, two of my faves ❤️
I think I'm the most partial to Samantha Pauly's version. Her vocal quality is just so dang flawless.
I loved sophie's high note. I just kinda felt right to me
i swear i cant stop coming back to this video. all you wanna do and all of the k howard actors are absolutely astronomical. 💕
They all were amazing
sams is the best hands down she puts the most emotion in her performance live it literally made me cry
1.) Aimee
2.) Sophie
3.) Courtney
4.) Sam
5.) Alicia
6.) Vicki
7.) Jodie
8.) Georgia
Well here it’s not Sam actually performing. When she performs I think it’s the best one
I like Aimee the best because, she was born for the part.
There is one live recording of Samantha and tbh is one of my favorite versions of All you wanna do
It was a tough vote between Katherine and Katherine, but I think it was Katherine.
Nah, mate. It was Katherine.
I'm going to be honest, I don't know which one did it best. The original cast recording has gotten me so used to hearing that note hit perfectly, but at the same time there's some of the others in this video that pretty much slammed the spirit out of me. I just want to see the day when I can finally pull off arranging Six in 6 Minutes and find a way to put each cast to the test.
I think I Georgia is amazing especially as this is her first major theatre role and she is still young, an inspirational lady with great pipes 😊💖
Aimie and sam are perfect for the role.
it’s unfair that Samantha Pauly’s one was her bedroom cover since in the show she puts an INSANE amount of emotion into it. She is by far the best K Howard, voice wise and emotionally.
I love Alicia and that will never change :3
Aimie’s famous growl ! Aimie will always be my favorite k Howard but every queen brings something different which is the magic of this show
You can’t say ‘this is not to put the queens against each other!!’ in the description and then make the title ‘who sang it best?’...
y’all are sleeping on alicia her ending riff is the best fight with the crowd 💕
Aimee is spectacular, I love Courtney as well. Also the emotion in Vicki, Georgia and Sophie’s performances was really amazing
You should have used audio from the actual Broadway production and not her tiktok video as on stage Samantha killed it with raw emotion and feeling. Her stage production is my fave by far
My personal preference is Courtney, (largely influenced by the fact that I saw her live and was completely blown away by her performance of this song. I can't get it out of my head, it was really powerful) but they are all amazing!! So impressed with all of the singing talent and how they can each take it and make it their own.
They are all amazing and great! HOWEVER NO ONE APPRECIATES ALICIA CORRALES CONNOR. 2:02
You can't beat the OG. Aimie just does things with her voice that no other K Howard can do.
Who sang it best?
Well, all of them.
Are you saying there was a recording of Annabel's AYWD? ooooooh
they honestly all gave me chills so good job to them all!!
kinda missing the point of the entire show which is to not compare them but sure knock yourself out
Finally someone said it!!!
I totally forgot about that....
Oh wait, I just havent seen the musical yet xd
and that’s the tea sis
This happens with every musical though.. Plus its not comparing in a bad way, people are just saying their favourites, they're obviously all great singers.
Sara i know, it’s just quite funny to do it with a show that was specifically written in order to stop comparing women lolol
I think my top 3 are Aimee, Georgia, and Alicia. It’s really hard to choose tho
I love Sam she puts such an original twist on her
courneys is a a personal fav but i love alicias so much
I personally enjoyed Samantha Pauly’s the most, but that was in her bedroom and the only recordings of her for the show keep on being taken down. She has the best emotion and vocals in my opinion because I can tell when she sings and when she doesn’t, same with the rest of her fellow cast members. Aimie in my opinion is pretty good and Alicia was outstanding, but Sam takes the cake for me.
but you can’t deny that all of their voices are BEAUTIFUL
All of the K. Howard's did realky good with the riff. I get chills everytime whenever they sing the riff
I love them all but, Aimee and Courtney were my favorites.
Aimee: 0:08 - 0:34
Courtney: 1:05 - 1:30
No one can beat Aimie and you can’t convince me otherwise. I Stan for Aimie
I just love the more intense and emotional ones
I've seen Courtney in the Syd 2020 run, and the new Howard, Chelsea Dawson now in 2022. Both were incredible live.
Courtney is currently playing Anna in the Frozen Aus tour, which is why she didn't reprise her role. She was already set to be taken over by Chelsea mid-Melb 2020 run, to start Frozen, but the Melb 2020 run never even began.
Oh my god the *growl* in Aimie’s voice, I can’t- she’s definitely my favorite outta all the queens
I'm obsessed with Courtney, she is absolutely phenomenal at both acting and singing and put her own spin on it
Alicia corrales sounds amazing 😱
I don’t think u should have put the cover for Samantha Pauly when she’s on stage it’s much better there is so much raw emotion in her live stages
my fav one is sam pauly, i just think she's made for this role and i love how she showa the pain k howard went through
This did not do Sam Pauly justice that was her bedroom recording not her actual emotional one
Don’t even try to pretend that it’s not Sam Pauly
I thought it was “but it’s never ever different-“
Samantha Paulo is an alumni of the high school I go to and is kind of close with our theatre director so she submitted something for our online cabaret this year
This is my favorite song in the musical but I can only listen to it so many times in a row before the dark theme gets to me
I love the roughness in Aimie’s ajsjsj
Everyone:Aimee was easily the best one!
Me who liked Alicia Vicki and Sophie:**nervous chuckling**
Alicia nailed it Murdered it cooked and ate it for breakfast
here y’all go:
0:07 aimie
0:34 sam
1:05 courtney
1:34 jodie
2:03 alicia
2:31 vicki
2:59 georgia
3:28 sophie
my personal top 5 are (in this order):
1. jodie
2. vicki
3. sam
4. alicia
5. aimie
honorable mention: courtney