What a fascinating discussion especially in Feb 2024. Sardesai came across as fierce, barking and annoying poodle. The three panelists basically ignored his underlying agenda, especially Dr Ravi. Thanks for the grace and dignity that was presented on stage by high powered intellectuals with differing points of view.
@@justicepeace8183 no he is not an advocate. He is a mathematician And he has got an inferiority complex. It is a mental problem. Probably when he was a baby his mother dropped him on his head.
Rajdeep please understand, they are the people who understand economy much more than you. Please allow them to speak. He intruppted all the three panelists when they were about to say something special and interesting.
The real slowdown started after demo and government said things were all hunky dory. GST was a double blow and it was still in a state of denial. Now we're in a crisis and finally it admits there's a slowdown. By the time we reach a point of no return it might accept we're in a crisis. Hope government will accept reality and resolve. The present mandate is so good they can achieve anything to their heart's desire. What is preventing them? It's a real mystery.
The other two speakers except Ritu Dewan, makes more sense and sounds logical. The other speaker idk why but sounds like she is moved by a bias more than economy.
@@pi-roh2862 I dont know bro, even I am a student of economics and the way I see it, it seems cyclical though we need labour reforms as well as our states individually to perform well. What I meant from my comment was that, she didn't gave any solutions to problems like private investment or relationship between job-growth-AI etc. That's why it seems she was biased, and the reason is because our universities have socialist economist which Ritu man is rather than welfare or development or balanced economists.
@@abhisheksrivastava2688 I think Ritu mam took anti-capitalist part so seriously. Yes it's all about people of India. But we need industries and infrastructure to give jobs. Government can't provide jobs. Most they can do is provide a growth friendly environment.
@@davidjuneja Yeah, you are right to the point. But the socialist nature of providing jobs is so deeply instilled in our mindset because of a certain section of media as well as JNU ECONOMISTS that we dont want to see the bigger picture. Government only provides an environment for private sector to create jobs, also India is a co.plex economy because of its diversity of sectors of economy. MSME sector is the one imo which can take India forwards leaps and bounds, and it's high time our government provides incentives as well as more competition in our MSME( in government I mean the state government). Every state has to come forward with their agenda of atleast 10 years for their MSMEs and bigger private players otherwise this mindset will just go on and corruption with crony capitalism will stay.
Better than anyone's opinion is the facts to understand the present state of economy like gdp growth and employment rate. One can access the success of economic policies of govt by those data
Great to see the positive talking young ladies Roopa Purushottaman and Shamika Ravi so articulately edging out the ageing anchor who despite his years of experience casts his lot with the old school lady economist to his left Ritu something, calls them "feel good" economists...and sticks with grandfather and father generation economics. The young ladies are not even painting a super rosy picture. Only Sardesai and his economist friend are harping on the very negative side of the current state of indian economics. The comment from Roopa that unemployment %ges should be accounted for starting at the state level - sounds like a very good argument - it has to be included in the political/electoral narrative/rhetoric by candidates. The lady Ritu is obviously lying about ujwala in 2012. What she says about cooking gas unavailability is a lie - because one of her own ilk Mr Shekhar Gupta has stated that tho they looked hard into kitchens in their election reportage they could not cite instances of lpg nonavailability. She is not telling the truth.
you have to listen her properly in starting she said I am not romanticizing with the past . Shamika Ravi never tell the truth as she is on govt side what ahe is doing just covering up and Roopa Purushottam is just balanced as she knows what can govt is able to do if she is in opposition.
@@studyengineering130 It's a shield that she is defending herself with(not romanticizing with the past). She is defending her leftist inclination with a shield of not being a leftist.
@@prakashshyamala we want left because it is the need of hour we don't want any croni capitalism Bank is totally destroyed by BJP now railway employer in strike
Shamika ravi is finding it very difficult to be honest...to criticize the govt she is working for.............this is the problem in our country....not having the courage to tell ur boss that he is wrong
India should follow Kautilya, not Adam Smith. In the current situation, India should renationalise the mining sector, increase public investments, import only those items which cannot be produced in India, provide full security to the people regarding health, security, law, employments. The Government is responsible for the employment of the people, because the welfare of the people is moral responsibility of the ruler, as Kautilya said.
(LIE) Optimism : India is shining and economy grows stronger inspite of the slowdown globally. (TRUTH) Pessimism : India's economy is growing so well and the fact is that it's GDP is competing with Bangladesh, Srilanka and North Korea and overtaken them.
See the joy of Rajdeep Sardesai..Demo was failure as his corruption money never came out ..Rajdeep Sardesai knows jab iska bacha rha to Demo fail hua..Wait Rajdeep u too will be delivered justice for ur Vendatta against Modi ji.
Bro please come out of politics and start appreciating asking questions... Not all should be PR of Modi.. Journalists job is to ask tough questions....
Ritu dewan is saying that patient is died in aiims but actually he is taking his breath and she think he is not able to walk Up and take breath what A negative minded lady
Has anyone noticed whenever there are rightwing governments in the world there is a part cyclical and part man made economic crisis in the world economy. And when there are liberal governments around the world the world economy grows.
So American economy is crashing down?Also Look what the so called liberals have done to London,record no. of knife attacks happening,Our embassy was vandalized & police were powerless,london's demography is changing,rapidly,underage girls are being trained as sexslaves & it is the perfect example of what "good" liberal politics do.
Auto sector will never grow up. You expect govt. to remove pollution from the city. To remove the pollution govt. Keeps up building metro trains , discourages people to buy cars in the city which are always in traffic jams , car parking issues , long travel time . It encourages car hire services like uber & Ola. . So I am not sad by people loosing jobs in Auto sector . It's going to happen it's nothing to do with govt. Policies. As govt. Keeps on improving the public transport a dream to buy a car will go .
@@pi-roh2862 you have to listen her properly in starting she said I am not romanticizing with the past . Shamika Ravi never tell the truth as she is on govt side what ahe is doing just covering up and Roopa Purushottam is just balanced as she knows what can govt is able to do if she is in opposition.
One has to understand, very simple the gap of inequality can be reduced how? , reduce the number of population who are making wealth, kyoki Garib to Garib rahega...according to Govt...& make most wealthiest to more superlative..
Shamika is a totally sold out "economist". I almost puked the day I saw her on a TV channel saying Raghuram Rajan does not deserve the top job because he came from the US and does not know about India well. The RSS spokesperson aplauded her for the comment and suggest she be encouraged for the same role. And she enjoyed it.
He had to mention that all of them are women. I mean, on a discussion over state of economy, he couldn't let the panellists be just economists. These 3rd class journalists and their labels.
Foreign trained and narrow minded, allow me to share what is really wrong with the economy and India at large. India is a spiritual country. To bring out my point, West Pakistan is ex India, but an ideological state that is almost spiritual with a 1 point anti India agenda re. Islam, clipped by the New Age Islamists the Arabs. If you get the above, then give India time to align it's true economy with national interests while the rent seeking rentier oligarchs and big biz. continued to Globalise. For eg. Brexit means duties on Tata JLR exports to EU etc. Simple, move production to India to save on costs to defer taxes on exports. Modi's roadshows are a run up to 1-3 % India govt. bonds listing in the US, Japan, Sing., Dubai and EU etc. Indian economy will be awash in cash as the govt. withdraws from the expensive 7-9 % Indian loan market where it's the primary borrower. Already Modi's India has made the maximum in bilateral, insider type deals like Japan's $ near 100 Billion on Delhi metro, $ 90 Billion on Delhi-Mumbai Corridor @ ridiculous, loss leading investment rates. Even bullet train project.
Sardesai is an oaf! He knows very little about a subject he's "moderating" - though what he is trying to do is prosecuting an anti-Modi position. The oaf should be put to pasture.l
When one talk with facts then chamchas, commies, leftist and liberandu only thinks about cow and its waste product , they can't talk other than cows, what a narrow minded thinking
I hope employment rate is calculated by unemployed to the labour force ..but it's doesn't seems to be silly ....we need to consider whether the all educated are willing to work or not ...may be they have other thoughts and ideas....many may settle in their lineage business ..many may do self business such as real estate shop business traders..agriculture etc ..these all about unorganised sector ....where unorganised sector never a structural and never considered ........
@@prashantsingh-jt7mw bhai tuze problem pakodi se hein to mat khana kisne khane ke liye majburkiya hein, and by doing this you will never apart of pakodanomics
Mr. Raj deep u r no one to be answered for demonetization Also it is beyond ur capacity to understand. Let us leave it there Mr. Baised and Crooked mind. Wish u a happy life
Roopa Purushottam was too good. So was Shamika Ravi. Good informed discussion. What Ms. Ritu is the problem that everyone has been discussing in those many words. But she hardly discussed the reasons or have any insight. Just rant.
Tum shiya aur Sunni , ek he Quran , ek hi Islam hokar bhi kabhi shanti se nahi rahe aur it given way to terrorist organisation like ISIS and you are talking about caste of a economist, मजहब है सिखाता हैं आपस में बैर
This lady is mentioning it is wrong we expect jobs from the government. At least if you and your government can't creat job atleast don't take our economy towards lower than Pakistan, Bangladesh, etc. The fact is that BJP is ruining our economy
Ravi aunty u are delusional , what are u talking , u say u optimistic and then u agree with ur partner ratan , who says there is definitely a structural issues , The point is u are someone who stays ON A sarkari kharcha and who gives a rats ass about the GDP BTW THE RATAN TATA CHIC "u hot" 😍
this attitude of denial by panelist SHAMIKA RAVI of not accepting the fact that economy is in deep trouble is the answer that why INDIAN ECONOMY is in slowdown ... bcz to fix it u have to first accept it .
People who hold higher position either in government or private companies are in tune with what the state wants people to believe. And more over when the two younger women, who could handle the language better have been automatically idolized as more knowledgeable about the topic. And its an Indian mentality to say all is well and show optimism, when we are in deep shit to carry yourself, as a true professional. If anyone disagree, he or she becomes a left liberal. Good that she is not labelled antinational in at least such type of a topic.
Ritu Dewan said words Deprivation to destitution.. as soon as She quoted hunger index to make her point.. I got that she lady rhetoric was more about philosophical differences than facts.. India IMPROVED on almost all the data points and parameters except stunting (more due to illness than due to lack of nutrition ) which earlier rankings were based.. It went down because in new list 43 RICH countries were added which were not in earlier list hence you see drop.. where she see destitution I see empowerment and alleviation . .. Poverty rate decline in India has been fastest in India amongst all countries.. hundreds of Millions of poor got toilets, gas homes, Electricity, bank accounts and INSURANCE.. Country has seen good 5 years of continued growth at healthy rate.. just small blip for "ONE or TWO" quarters and all naysayers are out beating their chests..
Rajdeep has for once come to express something correctly - informal economy to formalised economy. More appropriately, adhoc economy to streamlined economy. Our economy is going through this phase - decades of randomness to a more structured economy. The strength and the benefits too will be spread over a period of time.
whatamever demonitization did has certainly made some huge losses to u sardesai, but since modi has came to power even after demonitization and the ranting u do, why dont u just shut ur mouth and do some progressive work and give some suggestions if u have, regarding economy, rather than just ranting.
Your Ayushman Bharat doesn't work in North East. private hospitals only accept it in paper but not on ground reality . More over the Mudra loan is a bogus here . The Banks managers will just kick you out if you impose this on them. They said its a Govt.'s win election.
Kahan kahan se gawaar utha laate hain .. such illiterate woman has been made the head of economics department in mumbai university, Ritu Dewan did not speak one line of economic insights and kept on ranting like a street goon.
This slowdown is a mix of many thing, some of which you can blame on current govt (demonetization), some on past govt (NPA) and some on the slowing global economy (recession every 10 years; last was in 2008-09). Instead of blaming we should try to understand the causes.
Is India is BJP Mukht, all speakers they only propogate Modi Government instead of BJP Government, Leaders will come and go but the party will remain. "Jai Ho Modi" agenda of Congress Mukht is actually Mukht BJP (Looking Japan - Going China)
wao... retu gave same type of comments that previous day a bjp leader give as there is lack of quality and talents . good ... but answer me please why the lack of talent is growing... who is responsible for that ?
In central govt universities ...quality is quiet good ...the major problem is with the local universities curcuilm mainly from TN up Bihar Kerala ...where the education is worst and that's leading to the quality less youth
The "Optimistic" claiming Shamiki Ravi has been kicked out of the Economic Advisory Council cuz of certain criticisms she raised 😂 Even the pappus/shills of Feku have no space in his council for just uttering legitimate criticisms. But bhakts will call her Congress paid 🤭
Ritu seems to be a communist. Samitha Ravi seems more balanced. About women employment, I feel it is given more importance than it deserves.It is an imported concept, will not give results in India.
Shamika Ravi no wonder you are at PM's economy advisory council... How come everybody from BJP pretending that India is doing great at it's GDP. All she spoke is full of shit btw what is with that attitude. There is no one ever stand's for the common people of this country.
Mr. Rajdeep is a master at asking unrelated questions in one go.
Awesome discussion bringing out multiple perspectives. All relevant perspectives.
Dr Shamica - it was an enlightening exposition by you on the economy. Thanx..
@Sk Muzammil Zeeshan when ??
Dr Swami is the best to take all these question and everyone will understand the economy
Ms. Ritu just serving her master
Swami is a better man to make rajdeep understand the economy of India at large
What a fascinating discussion especially in Feb 2024. Sardesai came across as fierce, barking and annoying poodle. The three panelists basically ignored his underlying agenda, especially Dr Ravi. Thanks for the grace and dignity that was presented on stage by high powered intellectuals with differing points of view.
Subramanian swami should have been in the panel.
Why?
He is an advocate not economist
@@justicepeace8183 no he is not an advocate. He is a mathematician
And he has got an inferiority complex. It is a mental problem. Probably when he was a baby his mother dropped him on his head.
Rajdeep please understand, they are the people who understand economy much more than you. Please allow them to speak.
He intruppted all the three panelists when they were about to say something special and interesting.
@Adam LB
Over acting! Rajdeep type generalists passing off as experts.
Journalism!
If nothing else, the Chinese and even punjabbdo Pakistanis are at least more disciplined Vs. Ganhi-giri type Indians.
India Today next time get an economist to do this session. Not biased political journo...
He got a great reply at 26:00
Two young ladies are awesome
And a rusty brain
The real slowdown started after demo and government said things were all hunky dory. GST was a double blow and it was still in a state of denial. Now we're in a crisis and finally it admits there's a slowdown. By the time we reach a point of no return it might accept we're in a crisis. Hope government will accept reality and resolve. The present mandate is so good they can achieve anything to their heart's desire. What is preventing them? It's a real mystery.
i think you people should stop repeating what raghu ram rajan saying in his videos and feel like an economist. because you are not.
The other two speakers except Ritu Dewan, makes more sense and sounds logical. The other speaker idk why but sounds like she is moved by a bias more than economy.
But the ritu mam said better than other two women an its fact also
@@pi-roh2862 I dont know bro, even I am a student of economics and the way I see it, it seems cyclical though we need labour reforms as well as our states individually to perform well.
What I meant from my comment was that, she didn't gave any solutions to problems like private investment or relationship between job-growth-AI etc.
That's why it seems she was biased, and the reason is because our universities have socialist economist which Ritu man is rather than welfare or development or balanced economists.
@@abhisheksrivastava2688 I think Ritu mam took anti-capitalist part so seriously.
Yes it's all about people of India. But we need industries and infrastructure to give jobs.
Government can't provide jobs. Most they can do is provide a growth friendly environment.
@@davidjuneja Yeah, you are right to the point. But the socialist nature of providing jobs is so deeply instilled in our mindset because of a certain section of media as well as JNU ECONOMISTS that we dont want to see the bigger picture.
Government only provides an environment for private sector to create jobs, also India is a co.plex economy because of its diversity of sectors of economy. MSME sector is the one imo which can take India forwards leaps and bounds, and it's high time our government provides incentives as well as more competition in our MSME( in government I mean the state government).
Every state has to come forward with their agenda of atleast 10 years for their MSMEs and bigger private players otherwise this mindset will just go on and corruption with crony capitalism will stay.
Better than anyone's opinion is the facts to understand the present state of economy like gdp growth and employment rate. One can access the success of economic policies of govt by those data
Subramanyam swami is legend for this talk
He is an advocate not economist
Great to see the positive talking young ladies Roopa Purushottaman and Shamika Ravi so articulately edging out the ageing anchor who despite his years of experience casts his lot with the old school lady economist to his left Ritu something, calls them "feel good" economists...and sticks with grandfather and father generation economics. The young ladies are not even painting a super rosy picture. Only Sardesai and his economist friend are harping on the very negative side of the current state of indian economics. The comment from Roopa that unemployment %ges should be accounted for starting at the state level - sounds like a very good argument - it has to be included in the political/electoral narrative/rhetoric by candidates.
The lady Ritu is obviously lying about ujwala in 2012. What she says about cooking gas unavailability is a lie - because one of her own ilk Mr Shekhar Gupta has stated that tho they looked hard into kitchens in their election reportage they could not cite instances of lpg nonavailability. She is not telling the truth.
Ritu dewan seems to be more like of leftist mindset.
you have to listen her properly in starting she said I am not romanticizing with the past . Shamika Ravi never tell the truth as she is on govt side what ahe is doing just covering up and Roopa Purushottam is just balanced as she knows what can govt is able to do if she is in opposition.
@@studyengineering130 It's a shield that she is defending herself with(not romanticizing with the past). She is defending her leftist inclination with a shield of not being a leftist.
@@prakashshyamala we want left because it is the need of hour we don't want any croni capitalism Bank is totally destroyed by BJP now railway employer in strike
@@gauravdey4163 u want left... lol u can go to Cuba dont think any other country left exists...
Lol the present govt not only follows leftists policies like mnrega but introduces more leftists schemes like minority scholarship scheme. Hypocrites
Shamika ravi is finding it very difficult to be honest...to criticize the govt she is working for.............this is the problem in our country....not having the courage to tell ur boss that he is wrong
not at all - she is articulating her idea very well and in plain speech.
In fact she’s critical about government especially PMO and paid price for that today. She is dropped s from economic counsel today.
On a contrary I found Ms Dewan to be completely rubbish.
I think it's true
India should follow Kautilya, not Adam Smith. In the current situation, India should renationalise the mining sector, increase public investments, import only those items which cannot be produced in India, provide full security to the people regarding health, security, law, employments. The Government is responsible for the employment of the people, because the welfare of the people is moral responsibility of the ruler, as Kautilya said.
Ms. Ravi is brilliant.
Rajdeep wants Modi to apologize for demonetization; he demanded an apology from him on Gujarat riot - this guy is too personal to be a journalist...
2 sensible ladies and one congress paid is uncomfortable in her own skin
Bro Congress rather more communist
Dr Shamika Ravi launched Sardesai out of the Conclave! What an oaf Sardesai is!
First principle of being a good propagandist is to have smooth exposition. Ms Shamika Ravi has mastered that really well.
Dr swamy needed........
(LIE) Optimism : India is shining and economy grows stronger inspite of the slowdown globally.
(TRUTH) Pessimism : India's economy is growing so well and the fact is that it's GDP is competing with Bangladesh, Srilanka and North Korea and overtaken them.
growth rate not GDP dumbass! They are smaller countries with lower base..
Roopa Purushothaman seems to be most logical and crisp of all them all in her analysis!!
36:52 Bangladesh exports at the cost of their environment and public health...We don't want that!
India grows instead of government, not because of government
OMG this Ritu character!! Incredible.
India today can you please ask rajdeep not to bring mindset to show falling govt? Looks like he can't help it.
Sabina dewan should be in this panel
Roopa is amazing
See the joy of Rajdeep Sardesai..Demo was failure as his corruption money never came out ..Rajdeep Sardesai knows jab iska bacha rha to Demo fail hua..Wait Rajdeep u too will be delivered justice for ur Vendatta against Modi ji.
Bro please come out of politics and start appreciating asking questions... Not all should be PR of Modi.. Journalists job is to ask tough questions....
Yess there should be subramanian swami
This old lady is she talking about Pakistan?
Ritu dewan is saying that patient is died in aiims but actually he is taking his breath and she think he is not able to walk Up and take breath what A negative minded lady
Has anyone noticed whenever there are rightwing governments in the world there is a part cyclical and part man made economic crisis in the world economy. And when there are liberal governments around the world the world economy grows.
So American economy is crashing down?Also Look what the so called liberals have done to London,record no. of knife attacks happening,Our embassy was vandalized & police were powerless,london's demography is changing,rapidly,underage girls are being trained as sexslaves & it is the perfect example of what "good" liberal politics do.
Auto sector will never grow up. You expect govt. to remove pollution from the city. To remove the pollution govt. Keeps up building metro trains , discourages people to buy cars in the city which are always in traffic jams , car parking issues , long travel time . It encourages car hire services like uber & Ola. . So I am not sad by people loosing jobs in Auto sector . It's going to happen it's nothing to do with govt. Policies. As govt. Keeps on improving the public transport a dream to buy a car will go .
Professor Arun Kumar said that GDP growth rate is nil or negative if we consider informal sectors. We are in recession.
Bro it's our country it's our economy it's none of your business # madarasachap
@@motivatedaffairs7851 It's our country. We are mulnivashi.
@@fazlulkarim9123 then why you have Arabic name please keep Indian name
subramaniam swamy said nehru is responsible for current economy crisis...
When Swamy gets stomach upset after eating too many Idli, Nehru is responsible.
Economy is mess . Sector after sector under huge pressure. Next financial year will decide India economy feture.
Ye politician hai Kya ritu
Dhyan se sun bhakt wo head of economics department h maharashtra economic college ki aur sahi bola imploding tu andhbhakt h nhi samjhega
@@pi-roh2862 you have to listen her properly in starting she said I am not romanticizing with the past . Shamika Ravi never tell the truth as she is on govt side what ahe is doing just covering up and Roopa Purushottam is just balanced as she knows what can govt is able to do if she is in opposition.
@@studyengineering130 sb jagah yhi chipka rha hy bro. Copy-paste 😁😁😁😂😂
@@chummansahu148 IT Cell hoga shayad
I want Ritu vs swamy debate. Damn that would be funny AF.
One has to understand, very simple the gap of inequality can be reduced how? , reduce the number of population who are making wealth, kyoki Garib to Garib rahega...according to Govt...& make most wealthiest to more superlative..
Shamika is a totally sold out "economist". I almost puked the day I saw her on a TV channel saying Raghuram Rajan does not deserve the top job because he came from the US and does not know about India well. The RSS spokesperson aplauded her for the comment and suggest she be encouraged for the same role. And she enjoyed it.
It's not Shamika Ravi who is sold out, but Raghuram Rajan who is consistently spewing anti-India ill-reserched stuff sitting in USA.
He had to mention that all of them are women. I mean, on a discussion over state of economy, he couldn't let the panellists be just economists. These 3rd class journalists and their labels.
Foreign trained and narrow minded, allow me to share what is really wrong with the economy and India at large.
India is a spiritual country. To bring out my point, West Pakistan is ex India, but an ideological state that is almost spiritual with a 1 point anti India agenda re. Islam, clipped by the New Age Islamists the Arabs.
If you get the above, then give India time to align it's true economy with national interests while the rent seeking rentier oligarchs and big biz. continued to Globalise.
For eg. Brexit means duties on Tata JLR exports to EU etc. Simple, move production to India to save on costs to defer taxes on exports.
Modi's roadshows are a run up to 1-3 % India govt. bonds listing in the US, Japan, Sing., Dubai and EU etc.
Indian economy will be awash in cash as the govt. withdraws from the expensive 7-9 % Indian loan market where it's the primary borrower.
Already Modi's India has made the maximum in bilateral, insider type deals like Japan's $ near 100 Billion on Delhi metro, $ 90 Billion on Delhi-Mumbai Corridor @ ridiculous, loss leading investment rates. Even bullet train project.
Sardesai is an oaf! He knows very little about a subject he's "moderating" - though what he is trying to do is prosecuting an anti-Modi position. The oaf should be put to pasture.l
When you talk about GDP and bhakta cant get over Gaumutra.
When one talk with facts then chamchas, commies, leftist and liberandu only thinks about cow and its waste product , they can't talk other than cows, what a narrow minded thinking
I hope employment rate is calculated by unemployed to the labour force ..but it's doesn't seems to be silly ....we need to consider whether the all educated are willing to work or not ...may be they have other thoughts and ideas....many may settle in their lineage business ..many may do self business such as real estate shop business traders..agriculture etc ..these all about unorganised sector ....where unorganised sector never a structural and never considered ........
I think Ritu leftists. she criticizing all govt. Policies. N rajdeep got good friend.
pakodanomics zindabad ...
@@prashantsingh-jt7mw bhai tuze problem pakodi se hein to mat khana kisne khane ke liye majburkiya hein, and by doing this you will never apart of pakodanomics
An economy debate without Dr swami
Is not worth a penny.
Even though this debate host only women it was one of the most booring debate on economy.
Ritu Tai is wrong.
We have to learn from USA, privatization can be good solution
Sardesai must GO!
Thailand has three times foreign tourists than us because.............. well ;) :D :D :D
Mr. Raj deep u r no one to be answered for demonetization
Also it is beyond ur capacity to understand. Let us leave it there Mr. Baised and Crooked mind. Wish u a happy life
Rajdeep is worst possible choice for these kind of events. Will prefer Rahul anyday but even poor chap Karan thapar will do a better job.
YEAH, I QUITE AGREE WITH THE ABOVE COMMENT.
Roopa Purushottam was too good. So was Shamika Ravi. Good informed discussion. What Ms. Ritu is the problem that everyone has been discussing in those many words. But she hardly discussed the reasons or have any insight. Just rant.
Rajdeep ready to loose your job :p
I saw a vulture sitting with three ladies.
Isn't there any lower Caste economist in Mumbai to be enrolled as penalist?
Tum shiya aur Sunni , ek he Quran , ek hi Islam hokar bhi kabhi shanti se nahi rahe aur it given way to terrorist organisation like ISIS and you are talking about caste of a economist,
मजहब है सिखाता हैं आपस में बैर
too much accent for some one who have sir name 'purushotaman'
So what's ur problem idiot?
And its Surname not Sir name. Moron
I ve been to America for 2yrs after staying in India for 24 years Hence d Accent...
she was born and raised in the US and she articulates the right content - nothing wrong. Rise above the basics.
This lady is mentioning it is wrong we expect jobs from the government.
At least if you and your government can't creat job atleast don't take our economy towards lower than Pakistan, Bangladesh, etc.
The fact is that BJP is ruining our economy
JNU professor said to rajiv 😀
Ravi aunty u are delusional , what are u talking , u say u optimistic and then u agree with ur partner ratan , who says there is definitely a structural issues ,
The point is u are someone who stays ON A sarkari kharcha and who gives a rats ass about the GDP
BTW THE RATAN TATA CHIC "u hot" 😍
38:58
this attitude of denial by panelist SHAMIKA RAVI of not accepting the fact that economy is in deep trouble is the answer that why INDIAN ECONOMY is in slowdown ... bcz to fix it u have to first accept it .
People who hold higher position either in government or private companies are in tune with what the state wants people to believe.
And more over when the two younger women, who could handle the language better have been automatically idolized as more knowledgeable about the topic. And its an Indian mentality to say all is well and show optimism, when we are in deep shit to carry yourself, as a true professional.
If anyone disagree, he or she becomes a left liberal. Good that she is not labelled antinational in at least such type of a topic.
Ritu Dewan said words Deprivation to destitution.. as soon as She quoted hunger index to make her point.. I got that she lady rhetoric was more about philosophical differences than facts.. India IMPROVED on almost all the data points and parameters except stunting (more due to illness than due to lack of nutrition ) which earlier rankings were based.. It went down because in new list 43 RICH countries were added which were not in earlier list hence you see drop.. where she see destitution I see empowerment and alleviation . .. Poverty rate decline in India has been fastest in India amongst all countries.. hundreds of Millions of poor got toilets, gas homes, Electricity, bank accounts and INSURANCE.. Country has seen good 5 years of continued growth at healthy rate.. just small blip for "ONE or TWO" quarters and all naysayers are out beating their chests..
So shameful that we don't even have people with Indian accent
39:40
Rajdeep has for once come to express something correctly - informal economy to formalised economy. More appropriately, adhoc economy to streamlined economy. Our economy is going through this phase - decades of randomness to a more structured economy. The strength and the benefits too will be spread over a period of time.
whatamever demonitization did has certainly made some huge losses to u sardesai, but since modi has came to power even after demonitization and the ranting u do, why dont u just shut ur mouth and do some progressive work and give some suggestions if u have, regarding economy, rather than just ranting.
Mr. Rajdeep do you let them what they are trying to say or you putting your words into their mouth. You show the bias out.
people of india is busy with hindu -muslim ,bharat -pakistan debates organised by aaj tak and other godi media channel ...
That old lady is rotten apple and biased other two were centralist and Making Sense...!!!
U keep on expecting n barking to say modi to apologise to which vl never hpn in life time
Your Ayushman Bharat doesn't work in North East. private hospitals only accept it in paper but not on ground reality . More over the Mudra loan is a bogus here . The Banks managers will just kick you out if you impose this on them. They said its a Govt.'s win election.
Kahan kahan se gawaar utha laate hain .. such illiterate woman has been made the head of economics department in mumbai university, Ritu Dewan did not speak one line of economic insights and kept on ranting like a street goon.
Mr. Saradesai talks too much by himself.
One who doesn’t know economics & also same time Arunpuri given stage to congress chamcha
This slowdown is a mix of many thing, some of which you can blame on current govt (demonetization), some on past govt (NPA) and some on the slowing global economy (recession every 10 years; last was in 2008-09). Instead of blaming we should try to understand the causes.
Is India is BJP Mukht, all speakers they only propogate Modi Government instead of BJP Government, Leaders will come and go but the party will remain.
"Jai Ho Modi" agenda of Congress Mukht is actually Mukht BJP (Looking Japan - Going China)
wao... retu gave same type of comments that previous day a bjp leader give as there is lack of quality and talents . good ... but answer me please why the lack of talent is growing... who is responsible for that ?
In central govt universities ...quality is quiet good ...the major problem is with the local universities curcuilm mainly from TN up Bihar Kerala ...where the education is worst and that's leading to the quality less youth
Open up black money everything will be alright .
india today is talking about economy is this a joke ????😊😊😊😊
The "Optimistic" claiming Shamiki Ravi has been kicked out of the Economic Advisory Council cuz of certain criticisms she raised 😂
Even the pappus/shills of Feku have no space in his council for just uttering legitimate criticisms. But bhakts will call her Congress paid 🤭
Good discussion. But it's quite evident that the Indian economy is sinking and is sinking fast.
Just observe the time of introduction, the way the lady sitting next to Rajdeep looking at him saying like "why the Hell you are here ?"
The lady is telling lies.
no one is filling their stomach with half bhakti but all is having Full
This is just conversation between biased economists... I just wasted time watching this.
Mallus too busy in politics... not working
Shamika Ravi is supporting government but she was removed from economic advisory
She commented on slowdown...phew out of economic advisory council
Ritu seems to be a communist. Samitha Ravi seems more balanced.
About women employment, I feel it is given more importance than it deserves.It is an imported concept, will not give results in India.
Kautilya was a communist, Marxist?????
the moderator is just dreadful
That Old lady has 0 knowledge
Ye sala Modi ke chakkar mai mar jayega
Ms Dewan is a negative perspectice economist - she is still living in UPA era....
Shamika Ravi no wonder you are at PM's economy advisory council... How come everybody from BJP pretending that India is doing great at it's GDP. All she spoke is full of shit btw what is with that attitude. There is no one ever stand's for the common people of this country.