Greetings. I tried to reproduce your tutorial with some differencies for my projects purposes, and got some problems. But i found the solvations and want to share with all of you: 1) time of physics calculating was sooo long, it took hours 2) the objects, which had to be filling the container were flying away or falling through the borders of main container The main thing is to use Convex Hull as Shape (Physics Properties ---> Collisions) for filling objects instead of Mesh (as you and the other artists adviced to use) and in Physics Properties ----> Sensitivity use Collision Margin checkbox. The Container object uses Collision -----> Shape - Mesh (as you told) By the way my filing objects had a shape of twisted macaroni, and the main container has a plastic bag shape. After this the simulation tooks only 1 minute and completed correctly. Thanks for your tutorial and Cheers!
Wooow!!..amigo, llevo 1 semana haciendo esferas y sus caminos para que el conjunto completo siga un movimiento como entrando a un túnel, pero esto que haces es sinceramente genial!...muchas gracias, de verdad muchas gracias realmente es buenísima la técnica que empleas. Necesito hacer cerca de 10 mil😢. Nuevamente muchas gracias!!!
Worth noting that for this go go smoothly the scale of the obj must be in the meter range. At time of this writting Blender struggle with physics of small obj. Just in case someone watch this is like me struggling for hours with impossible rendering time ^^
When he mentions 'press space' then bridge edge loops. It didn't work on mine, the space bar controlled the timeline. Press 'F3' instead! that worked for me :)
2:20 before applying the screw modifier, activate "merge vertices" so you dont need to manually merge the vertices ! You can also use a weld modifier after the screw, or if you dont want to use a modifier to merge the vertices, in edit mode, select all vertices (A) and then press M and choose merge vertices by distances, then adjust the merge distance to delete the vertices :) We can also activate the 3Dprint addon to see if faces are overlaping, select the intersection and merge the vertices in the selection - there are tons of ways to do the same thing in blender, that's what make it so powerful !
Theres a downward < on the modifiers, click there and youll see the apply option. And a comment up there said in this version you need to press ctrl a to make instances real
It is just the rigid body physics only with different way of duplicating the objects. You can just array and separate it instead of copying objects multiple times.
Hey! Yes, completely agree; I've added shortcuts in the new videos plus I'm working on my editing so there should be less desync issues. I really appreciate the help! Thanks!
I see you just started this channel. I'm new to Blender but I see you have a pretty novel approach to things. Great stuff. Looking forward to more content from you.
Hey, the tutorial is pretty good, but as a beginner get issues.. i am not able to copy the physic to all the balls, only one ball is getting animated.. Please Help
Physics sims are what separate capable computers from potatoes. Unfortunately, I have a potato. But this was nonetheless very, very useful, since I don't need to do animations with my objects, I just need to get them into the container once. Thanks!
Hey Tadej, which CPU do you have? Because I have an older CPU i7-2600 with 24 GB RAM and 1070 ti GPU and I get stuck at frame 3 every time I try to start the animation. Is my computer sufficient for the job or am I doing something wrong?
Hell yeah, agreed; whatever funds I get from youtube or gumroad I invest them directly back into youtube, so your subscription and like is mega appreciated!
what is the other way to use instead of Shift Control A? my keys doesnt respond to the the hot keys you used. Or can you show me how to set my hot keys?
It's probably because we are using different keying sets; you can check on Google how to change your keying set or search for functions with the search.
Very nice kind of what I was after but kan you add an particular seris of object of different sizes and colours, from a special keyframe. I can creat them at the begining but they then have to fall from realy high up and the get a lot of speed. Keyframes and physics does not blend so good togheter.
Hey thanks for the tutorial but i have one question: When I try to play the animation in my viewport the animation bar is runnig forwart put the frames dont have enought time to load so I have to skip to every single second to load the animation. I there any way to load the complette animation how it is in your tutorial? Thanks for help!
hey there! Sure, go under properties panel, go under scene, rigid body world, Cache and you'll have the option to bake the animation from frame 1 to 250. If you don't need that much you can go lower down the second number. Hope this helps!
@@blatadej5474 Thanks that solved my problem! But can I change anything so that the animation plays like in your video? so that the next frame only starts playing when its completly loaded and if not the animation stops briefly? so that I dont have to bake it before. Sorry for my english im from Germany
Thank you for the tutorial. I have a question. Your simulation is about 10 times faster. Did you speed up the video? As I heard Blender uses only one CPU core, no speaking about GPU physics calculation. So it is exteeeamely slow! Furthermore my objects go through the container. Playing around with the margins but won't help.
Strange, but the same scene made not in mm but relatively big in m calculates very fast. Even though I set margins proportionally about 1/1000 from the real size it really freezes with small objects. So it won't work for small objects. Also it messes if there is anither collection hidden with rigid bodies.
@@vavalexus As for the viewport speed no, I haveN't sped up anything, I usually make a point when there's a process that's sped up so that if anyone would like to, they can check it slowed down. When it comes down to margins it's worth to correct the rigid world and rigid body margins, check for any problems in the mesh, in the objects that fall into the mesh, etc.
Hi, thanks for this tutorial - I have a question: I've used your technique to create and fill a small glass bottle with pills. Everything works just fine. I line up around 250 pills vertically above the bottle, put my funnel in place, run the animation and the bottle fills up with pills. BUT: I now want to make COPIES of the filled-up bottle with all the pills inside, and arrange them in a scene, add labels to the bottles, move them around, light them, render them, etc. etc. But I simply can't do this! If I try to group the bottle with the pills inside, and then make a copy, my viewport simply reverts back to the 1st frame of the animation, with the bottle empty and the pills above. I cannot do ANYTHING with the filled bottle! It's driving me CRAZY. Any chance you can help - offer any advice or guidance?
Hi Bla Tadej - Thank You for tutorial. I had use it to one projct to fill bucket by objects (simple, not many faces). First scene has done perfect with 70 copies !!!. But something went wrong with Blender becouse thene I did another - but with different objects (also simple) and Blender stack in 1 frame of bakeing . Even if I have only 5 objects (!!!sick). Even if i start from scatch (!sick) . Do You have any suggestions what could happened ?
Hey Bernard! So I can't know for sure until I see your file; if you'd like to, feel free to dm me on Instragram and we can arrange an exchange of files so I can take a closer look.
bro if I want to texture all of them like emojis can we do that in blender and how? please can you show because in cinema 4d we have a multi shader but I am just switching to the blender and finding this difficulty any help from others will suffice.
I missed how you did that you click on one cube, do nothing and click the other cube and go to instancing and before you know it the 1st 'cube' has instanced 2nd cube on its faces...... (no matter how slow I watch your video it isn't clear)
How do you get the mesh from curve menu?...not working for me. Not at all sure what you are saying. Sounds like "Alt C"....but I get nothing with that. You need to turn on the screen keys so we can see what you are doing. at least then we will know what are the right keys. Great videos though. Thanks for them.
Yes, ALT-C is used to make meshes from curves (and vice versa). Apologies, I do have screen cast keys in my newer videos, plus I'm setting up a new audio setup for better sound quality.
@@blatadej5474 OMG this new keymap is giving me a hard time... AI use v.2.82.7 and key map doesn't match at all.... ALT-C doesn't exist....I need a translator... would you mention about the function name?
man half of the time i cant understand your pronunciation!!! but it would be more helpful if u jst could add shortcut keys at the bottom,but good video anyway....
When he mentions Shift Ctrl A, in new versions is Ctrl A Make Instances Real. Great Tut
hero in the comments
thanks!
thanks buddy
thnx a lot
been struggling for 10 mins lol thanks
To Blender 3.2:
Shift Ctrl A = Ctrl A
"Press Space" = F3
Excelent master! Thank you so much!
Never thought I'd be learning Blender from David Harbour.
bruh, I wish I'd have a jaw like him.
lol i see it too
Greetings. I tried to reproduce your tutorial with some differencies for my projects purposes, and got some problems. But i found the solvations and want to share with all of you:
1) time of physics calculating was sooo long, it took hours
2) the objects, which had to be filling the container were flying away or falling through the borders of main container
The main thing is to use Convex Hull as Shape (Physics Properties ---> Collisions) for filling objects instead of Mesh (as you and the other artists adviced to use) and in Physics Properties ----> Sensitivity use Collision Margin checkbox.
The Container object uses Collision -----> Shape - Mesh (as you told)
By the way my filing objects had a shape of twisted macaroni, and the main container has a plastic bag shape.
After this the simulation tooks only 1 minute and completed correctly. Thanks for your tutorial and Cheers!
thanks a lot!
that really helps!
You saved me
Gracias!!!!
I never thought making a jar was this easy. Really great tutorial
Wooow!!..amigo, llevo 1 semana haciendo esferas y sus caminos para que el conjunto completo siga un movimiento como entrando a un túnel, pero esto que haces es sinceramente genial!...muchas gracias, de verdad muchas gracias realmente es buenísima la técnica que empleas. Necesito hacer cerca de 10 mil😢. Nuevamente muchas gracias!!!
dude blew my mind in the first 2 minutes making the container...
exactly!
Fascinates me seeing peoples' Blender tricks
Pro Tip: Use F3 to bring up that search bar
Worth noting that for this go go smoothly the scale of the obj must be in the meter range. At time of this writting Blender struggle with physics of small obj. Just in case someone watch this is like me struggling for hours with impossible rendering time ^^
When he mentions 'press space' then bridge edge loops. It didn't work on mine, the space bar controlled the timeline. Press 'F3' instead! that worked for me :)
*Holy moly, this is brilliant!*
Thank you for the sensitivity part. I can finally fill a bun with random stuff more accurately now.
3:37 Hi, whenever I'm pressing Shift+Ctrl+A nothing seems to be happening.
Can you help?
Maybe because I'm using the 2.79 shortcut scheme; try searching for the option make instances real
@@blatadej5474 Yeah, it worked.
Thank you for the tutorial though.Keep on making more.😀
@@ParulSharmaa glad it worked out! Thanks for watching, making a bunch more!
It's ctrl+A and then press M (or on the bottom of the pop-up menu)
@@BITE_MECHANISM thnx mate
I'm a simple man. I hear Yoshi, I subscribe.
He makes the video 10 times better
18 months later and this video is still relevant & useful. Thank you very much!
This concept is amazing...
Trying this as a beginner .... It takes about an hour or more for me to render this 120 frams
i love how the way you making a jar.. applause
Love your tutorials!!! You've got a new subscriber!!
this is amazing! thank you! you explain the why you do things very clearly.
oh it's surprise me. This tutorial is cool
good job with start of the video man
2:20 before applying the screw modifier, activate "merge vertices" so you dont need to manually merge the vertices !
You can also use a weld modifier after the screw, or if you dont want to use a modifier to merge the vertices, in edit mode, select all vertices (A) and then press M and choose merge vertices by distances, then adjust the merge distance to delete the vertices :)
We can also activate the 3Dprint addon to see if faces are overlaping, select the intersection and merge the vertices in the selection - there are tons of ways to do the same thing in blender, that's what make it so powerful !
THANKS
Nice and quick tutorial, the instancing is not a bad idea ! And thanks for the rigid body world settings, I didn't knew about about them !
Thank you so much! This will same me a lot of time
At 3:23 I assume Blender 2.9 does not have the "APPLY" option for modifiers. And Shft+Ctrl+A doesn't work in Blender 2.83
Theres a downward < on the modifiers, click there and youll see the apply option. And a comment up there said in this version you need to press ctrl a to make instances real
It is just the rigid body physics only with different way of duplicating the objects.
You can just array and separate it instead of copying objects multiple times.
I love your Tutorial, so straight and direct
You can incresse the steps in the world setting by a LOT without lagging don't worry about make it slower, just go crazy
Ah that frickin sensitivity messed my simulation. Thank you very much!
What changing that margin does?
Is it possible that you can show us which key you are pressing?
A great tutorial! But - definitely add shortcuts, maybe speak slower (feels like a desync between audio and video sometimes)
Keep it up!
Hey! Yes, completely agree; I've added shortcuts in the new videos plus I'm working on my editing so there should be less desync issues. I really appreciate the help! Thanks!
great video! thank you so much!
Very good , congratulations...
great tutorial mate pretty inspiring!!!
ur tutorials are awesome
make more dude
I see you just started this channel. I'm new to Blender but I see you have a pretty novel approach to things. Great stuff. Looking forward to more content from you.
Appreciate you taking the time to check it out and glad you find it useful, more to come!
😱🤝 thank you soo much))!
wow men, thanks a lot, i don't know you, but i love you
Hey, the tutorial is pretty good, but as a beginner get issues.. i am not able to copy the physic to all the balls, only one ball is getting animated.. Please Help
I have that exact same hat!
Great, but does it work the same with cloth? If you what to fill a textile bag or something?
Hm, I'll look into it a bit more; it would be murder on the cpu though 😀
@@blatadej5474 yes please! from what I found it's such a headache... shouldn't be so! we can use gpu though 😉
Physics sims are what separate capable computers from potatoes. Unfortunately, I have a potato. But this was nonetheless very, very useful, since I don't need to do animations with my objects, I just need to get them into the container once. Thanks!
thank you so much , very helpful
hey man thank you so much❤❤❤❤
I never thought the case could be made using bezier and screw modifier
Smashing.
your coloring is really beautiful, can you make a tutorial for giving textures, colors and lighting like the image in the title of this video?
Prepping tutorials for the future with exactly that!
@@blatadej5474 okay, I can't wait to watch the video😄
Hey Tadej, which CPU do you have? Because I have an older CPU i7-2600 with 24 GB RAM and 1070 ti GPU and I get stuck at frame 3 every time I try to start the animation. Is my computer sufficient for the job or am I doing something wrong?
the only thing is needed to be improved in ur videos is Lightning and camera quality!
overall is super Helpfull
thanks!
Subscribed!
Hell yeah, agreed; whatever funds I get from youtube or gumroad I invest them directly back into youtube, so your subscription and like is mega appreciated!
2:57 how do you pull this menu up??
Thanks! You've save my life!
how he saved 😂😂😂😂
Great tutorial, but my blender just freezes when i start the simulation. Any advices?
Subscribed!
Thank you
could i export as stl/obj (the resulting filled geometry) and open-render in keyshot?
cool
I am a big fan of your work in stranger things and hell boy
Good one thanks
Now to attempt this with 3D text instead of little balls! :D
what is the other way to use instead of Shift Control A? my keys doesnt respond to the the hot keys you used. Or can you show me how to set my hot keys?
It's probably because we are using different keying sets; you can check on Google how to change your keying set or search for functions with the search.
You look like David Harbour
Very nice kind of what I was after but kan you add an particular seris of object of different sizes and colours, from a special keyframe.
I can creat them at the begining but they then have to fall from realy high up and the get a lot of speed.
Keyframes and physics does not blend so good togheter.
really well done ty
Hey thanks for the tutorial but i have one question:
When I try to play the animation in my viewport the animation bar is runnig forwart put the frames dont have enought time to load so I have to skip to every single second to load the animation. I there any way to load the complette animation how it is in your tutorial?
Thanks for help!
hey there! Sure, go under properties panel, go under scene, rigid body world, Cache and you'll have the option to bake the animation from frame 1 to 250. If you don't need that much you can go lower down the second number. Hope this helps!
@@blatadej5474 Thanks that solved my problem!
But can I change anything so that the animation plays like in your video?
so that the next frame only starts playing when its completly loaded and if not the animation stops briefly?
so that I dont have to bake it before.
Sorry for my english im from Germany
@@maximbecker1563 like cloth where it bakes while playing, that sort of thing?
@@blatadej5474
yeah thats what I mean.
like in your video. When the animation not loaded completly the viewport starts lagging thats what I need.
Thank you for the tutorial. I have a question. Your simulation is about 10 times faster. Did you speed up the video? As I heard Blender uses only one CPU core, no speaking about GPU physics calculation. So it is exteeeamely slow! Furthermore my objects go through the container. Playing around with the margins but won't help.
Strange, but the same scene made not in mm but relatively big in m calculates very fast. Even though I set margins proportionally about 1/1000 from the real size it really freezes with small objects. So it won't work for small objects. Also it messes if there is anither collection hidden with rigid bodies.
@@vavalexus As for the viewport speed no, I haveN't sped up anything, I usually make a point when there's a process that's sped up so that if anyone would like to, they can check it slowed down. When it comes down to margins it's worth to correct the rigid world and rigid body margins, check for any problems in the mesh, in the objects that fall into the mesh, etc.
Try baking the physics :)
Hi, thanks for this tutorial - I have a question: I've used your technique to create and fill a small glass bottle with pills. Everything works just fine. I line up around 250 pills vertically above the bottle, put my funnel in place, run the animation and the bottle fills up with pills. BUT: I now want to make COPIES of the filled-up bottle with all the pills inside, and arrange them in a scene, add labels to the bottles, move them around, light them, render them, etc. etc. But I simply can't do this! If I try to group the bottle with the pills inside, and then make a copy, my viewport simply reverts back to the 1st frame of the animation, with the bottle empty and the pills above. I cannot do ANYTHING with the filled bottle! It's driving me CRAZY. Any chance you can help - offer any advice or guidance?
Did you find a solution?
Apply the rigid body system
Hi Bla Tadej - Thank You for tutorial. I had use it to one projct to fill bucket by objects (simple, not many faces). First scene has done perfect with 70 copies !!!. But something went wrong with Blender becouse thene I did another - but with different objects (also simple) and Blender stack in 1 frame of bakeing . Even if I have only 5 objects (!!!sick). Even if i start from scatch (!sick) . Do You have any suggestions what could happened ?
Hey Bernard! So I can't know for sure until I see your file; if you'd like to, feel free to dm me on Instragram and we can arrange an exchange of files so I can take a closer look.
Hi, I am new to blender all things happen so but I am unable to copy all others balls with the one which is moving.
thanks
thank you
Thx.
bro if I want to texture all of them like emojis can we do that in blender and how? please can you show
because in cinema 4d we have a multi shader but I am just switching to the blender and finding this difficulty any help from others will suffice.
Hey dude! Yeah, though you have to unwrap the balls; I was thinking about making an upgraded version of this project with texture faces so stay tuned!
splines modelling, you're one of the old ones eh
I missed how you did that you click on one cube, do nothing and click the other cube and go to instancing and before you know it the 1st 'cube' has instanced 2nd cube on its faces...... (no matter how slow I watch your video it isn't clear)
it will be very nice video if you explain slowly. Thanks anyway
How do you get the mesh from curve menu?...not working for me. Not at all sure what you are saying. Sounds like "Alt C"....but I get nothing with that. You need to turn on the screen keys so we can see what you are doing. at least then we will know what are the right keys. Great videos though. Thanks for them.
Yes, ALT-C is used to make meshes from curves (and vice versa). Apologies, I do have screen cast keys in my newer videos, plus I'm setting up a new audio setup for better sound quality.
@@blatadej5474 OMG this new keymap is giving me a hard time... AI use v.2.82.7 and key map doesn't match at all.... ALT-C doesn't exist....I need a translator... would you mention about the function name?
oh it is 'convert to mesh'. it says that the hot key disappeared in v2.8
how do I keep the balls into the container permanently
You look like that cop from Stranger Things
Shhhhh, keep it on the downlow, I don't want the studio to take away my computer privileges
had to watch at half speed because you were going too fast but great tutorial anyways ha ha
Why does he look like Jim Hopper from Stranger Things
David harbour but lil young
Can you make particles moving through a tunnel while bumping the sides of the tunnel without using instances of solid objects?
Depends, I usually use rigid bodies, unless it's a large quantity of particles
Why do my coins just explode everywhere ugh
i cant believe he doesnt show how to edit the curves or how to get those black lines to curve the shape, i got lost here and now i cant continue :(
I got so confused on why is he making all of that, i would have the same result if i just did a a jar filling a circle and extruding a couple times
1:44 how to add the point here?
oh~ Ctrl + mouse Right click
U BETTER TELL HOW TO SOLVE FUCKING PROBLEM MAANN
nice but you speak to fast
Apologies! Would it help if I create subtitles for the videos?
@@blatadej5474 also add the shortcut keys mate :)
@@alfred3551 apologies, will do in the next tutorials, thanks for the heads up!
slow down
man half of the time i cant understand your pronunciation!!! but it would be more helpful if u jst could add shortcut keys at the bottom,but good video anyway....
Waste of time
Why so? Was there something specific you were looking for?
as if you needed to add your own funnel lol.... cool stuff
thanks