here on America, they dint get the attention they deserve, I am 64 and still think this is still an incredibly rockin band, fantastic voices, creative and talented music, for any year past and today, sensational, thank you for your creativity❤❤
Hi Curtin, you’re right…for any year. In the sixties fan of Stones, Beatles, The Who and the Kinks. Five years ago I discovered Floor in a Dutch program (The Best Singers, is on TH-cam). Since that moment I am a huge Floorfan and discovered Nightwish ( and her former bands After Forever and ReVamp). Last year I visit three NW concerts and three Floor soloshows. My age? 71 years 😊. Waiting on ( I hope) 2025, the next tour of NW. Greetings from The Netherlands.
We here in Europe, especially in Germany, took care of making up for the American ignorance. Thanks for not caring: this gave use more time and attention with them. But hey - you got Taylor and Beyonce - they is also very talented. And they might even still sell ticket with Mickey Mouse on. So don't grieve too much. Next time.
67 years old and I just found this group a few months ago. In the words of a younger generation...OMG. Folks...you're never too old to love Rock n Roll
I'm 67 years and found this reciently too , same as u,and in the name in the words of a younger generation....OMG. ...I think the same of u!!!!geniuuuuus!!
I wholeheartedly agree with C David's comments below. I'm 69 and have just discovered Nightwish and am "blown away" ! Certainly you are NEVER too old to rock!
As pessoas que deu deslike tem depressão ou não ama a vida , porque essa cantora tem uma das voz mais linda que o mundo já ouviu amo Floor Jansen , canta muitoooo.só hoje já a ouvi essa canção umas 10 vezes e não canso de ouvir é simplesmente viciante ouvi-lá cantar.
Yes, but this song was clearly written for Tarja’s style and abilities so it’s a valid comment that her version of this slaps harder and sounds better. For starters Tarja’s version is several notes higher and sung in a more classical style.
@@MsJustice4ever Except that's just your opinion isn't it. I prefer Floor singing this, because there's more emotional depth (IMO). You're being too simplistic to claim higher = better and operatic style = better. It could just as easily be said that a contrived vocal style (opera) = worse. These are subjective statements that you're choice of language is presenting as objective facts.
@@PavelJoundaспециалисты утверждают, что Тарья всё же поёт не оперным голосом. Голос у неё красивый, никто не спорит. Но Флор отлично все потянула тоже, у неё тоже есть очень высокие ноты.
@@nana_nanni2023 У Тарьи нормальное такое сочное меццо-сопрано. Она кроссовером поёт. Песня то не оперная. Но постановка голоса и выучка у Тарьи оперная. Звучит она потрясающе.
Floor is smart enough to not try to imitate Tarja with this. She brings her own style to the song. IMHO this song is so written to Tarja’s awesome voice. Love the song anyway
I disagree. I fell in love with Tarja's version, however, Floor is a much better technical singer and makes this version sound her own and in doing so gives Nightwish a different perspective. Floor is definitely the best thing for Nightwish.
Agreed , Floor certainly floored me with her superb singing Also a stunningly beautiful woman as was the bands other vocalist Tarja who could really sing, as well. The guys in this band sure know how to spot talent.
Lyrics The sun is sleeping quietly Once upon a century Wistful oceans calm and red Ardent caresses laid to rest For my dreams I hold my life For wishes I behold my night The truth at the end of time Losing faith makes a crime I wish for this night-time To last for a lifetime The darkness around me Shores of a solar sea Oh how I wish to go down with the sun Sleeping Weeping With you Sorrow has a human heart From my god it will depart I'd sail before a thousand moons Never finding where to go Two hundred twenty-two days of light Will be desired by a night A moment for the poet's play Until there's nothing left to say I wish for this night-time To last for a lifetime The darkness around me Shores of a solar sea Oh how I wish to go down with the sun Sleeping Weeping With you I wish for this night-time To last for a lifetime The darkness around me Shores of a solar sea Oh how I wish to go down with the sun Sleeping Weeping With you
@user-pz1jb7xs7k не согласен. У них очень разный стиль исполнения. Технически что Флор что Тарья поют её превосходно. Но каждая по своему и мне нравятся обе версии и очень круто что Флор своеобразна и не пытается играть в Тарью. Обе просто восхитительны
I always respected the talent in Nightwish, the band, the studio recordings, their live shows, and especially the incredible songwriting! What a fantastic, and talented band!!! And that is hugely commendable in itself! But wow, when they had the good fortune of what they felt was a complete and utter disaster, and turning that into Floor joining the group, they caught lightning in a bottle! Floor Jansen is an absolute bad ass! "No one" does it better than Floor!!! No one has her beautiful, her memorizing stage presence, and incredible vocal ability! She always leaves me wanting even more!!! Floor is a rockstars, rockstar! And Nightwish gave her the ability to show the world how talented she really is! Long live Nightwish, long live Floor Jansen, and long live all of the members who've had the great fortune of being in such a wonderful band! Kiitos Nightwish, and thank you so very much for the endless hours of top notch entertainment:)
You like the song and the music, I'm with you, but you have to learn to be critical. Tarja was an interpreter with a powerful voice and a stage hostess. It cannot be imitated in any other way. That performance belongs to her, reinterpreting it differently is a fake
@@claudiosoldi9276 LOL. I watched End oof an era. I watched Wacken. On stage (talking about presence, and the way they behave), Tarja is almost a beginner in front of Floor. Technically they're different. Tarja was almost perfect in her style. Floor is very close behind, but mostly she's way WAYYYYYY more versatile. If you wonder why they were so happy to have Floor in Nightwish, remember they wanted her to replace Tarja, Annette was only the second choice because Floor was not available.
@@homere-d-allaure Errr....They picked out Anette from hundreds of possibilities and like her for her voice and singing style. Made two great albums with Anette too.
@@nafisahmohamed4371 did I say the opposite? Annette is a good singer, and her albums were great. I just said that Tuomas himself told that he wanted Floor when they fired Tarja. She was not available. THEN they asked Annette to sing for Nightwish. That's all.
@@homere-d-allaure Yep. My bad. Reflect after seeing so many thrash and trash Anette. By the way, the three ladies have different styles of live performances too apart from voices and singing styles. Anette has most fun dance moves, Floor has best headbangs and arms movements. Tarja has best prowls around stage and dresses. Cheers :)
No, you are not the only one, who is listening and watching in 2024,... It's to beautiful,... Especially to hear the voice of the lead-lady-singer Madam "Floor Jansen." Her voice is very great. ❤❤❤
I consider myself a person schooled in lots of genres of music, however I am a bit ashamed to admit I have never heard of this band or Floor before yesterday. What a great voice.....the real deal
Floor versus Tarja, Tarja versus Floor - It's like a female version of Ozzy versus Dio!! If it has to be Floor for you then listen to Floor and the same with Tarja but, please, just respect each other!!
This Live Version with Floor and the Live Version with Tarja are my favorites. Both so unique versions although this song was made for Tarja's voice, Floor made such a piece of art here 👏🏻
@@qdoem4865 The discussion was about Tarja and Floor, not about Anette. If you want operatic singing, go with Tarja. If you want pop style, go with Anette. For everything else, go with Floor.
The sun is sleeping quietly Once upon a century Wistful oceans calm and red Ardent caresses laid to rest For my dreams I hold my life For wishes I behold my night The truth at the end of time Losing faith makes a crime I wish for this night-time To last for a lifetime The darkness around me Shores of a solar sea Oh how I wish to go down with the sun Sleeping Weeping With you Sorrow has a human heart From my god it will depart I'd sail before a thousand moons Never finding where to go Two hundred twenty-two days of light Will be desired by a night A moment for the poet's play Until there's nothing left to say I wish for this night-time To last for a…
Sleeping Sun was my intro to Nightwish and I will always love Tarja's vocals on this the most, but Floor is talented and smart. I love listening to what she does with the older songs and am always looking forward to what she does next.
Sleeping Sun was also my introduction. Floor is talented, there's no doubt about that. She has been a satisfactory placeholder. But I still stand by that the band will never be the same without Tarja. I hope she comes back one day. Hell, her and Floor together with Marco would be even better. Then we could have the best of both worlds. If I may ask, where did you first hear Sleeping Sun?
Same here. Sleeping Sun my intro to Nightwish. We cant compare Floor with Tarja. Both have best inside them. Nightwish will never real Nightwish without Tarja + Marko. But, Floor with Nightwish will be next best Nightwish. That's my wish on night.
I wouldn't be as big into Nightwish as I am right now if not for Floor. I know a lot older fans will cry anathema, but Tarja can be a bit of a challenging listen sometimes. Floor is instantly accessible because you can instantly tell how amazing she is.
Update after a couple of weeks of listening to NW: Actually, I prefer Tarja's rendition of this, and also of Nemo. Both songs benefit quite a bit from her dark tone, as opposed to the more airy Disney Princess style vocals Floor used in this video.
@@ChrisBach1138 Glad you posted this a few weeks later. This song was made for Tarja's vocal range and tone. That's why the Floor version is not as good as Tarja one. Same happens with Kinslayer.
Tarja and Floor both bring their own lovely interpretation of the song to it. Floor's voice is more delicate and pretty in this recording, whilst Tarja has such a full and powerful beauty in the original rendition. Both are excellent.
This video is awesome. I love how it sounds (especially the bass guitar) and how it looks (the colors and slow camera shots). Probably my favorite live video ❤️
I’m 72, and a friend from Finland turned me on to this band a couple of years ago. My wife and I are now full on fans, and in our opinion Floor is the most impressive of the vocalists. I’m continually amazed at her ability.
Sometimes I wonder if I only enjoy older Nightwish because of a period in my life or the amount of time I've invested into listening to it. Clicked play above. Goose bumps. It's just better.
You can hear just the way the band is playing and performing that they feel reborn...so much energy and fresh inspiration..they are happy...Nightwish is complete again with Floor..even more complete...cause...and this is coming from a Tarja fan...Floor is the ultimate singer for Nightwish..her voice has everything!
True fan supports the band no matter what. Yes, it is true, they play like reborn, this is perfect said. Dark Passion Play was a great album, Imaginaerum was better. I love Nightwish since 1998 (Oceanborn) and I will love them till the end of my life. Tarja fan? Anette fan? Floor fan? Why they should be compared? They are so good, but different... If you are a "Tarja fan" what the hell are you doing here?! She is not here. Same question if you are "Anette fan"... All the vocalists are part of the history of the band and they should be respected as equal. Nightwish was, Nightwish is and Nightwish will be!
I love the band- a story in every song, Floor has an amazing voice, but let us also raise a glass to the often forgotten, but essential and excellent sound engineer!!
When we note differences, we compare. That is natural and good. It gets nasty when we start to put different value tags on people (T/F is "better"...).
I am 64 years old and have been a drummer behind 8 bands in my many trips on this ball of mud around the sun! They are ALL excellent vocalists in their own right! I feel blessed to have experienced all of them! I just hope they can find another bass player and vocalist!
Nightwish one of the greatest and most overlooked band. Floor is awesome and on top of her game with this performance. The performance is mystical and haunting.
That voice..... She has a way of capturing the human experience in a way that is unique to her and the dimension she brings to the group is so multifaceted. This one makes my top 10.
What a beautiful song, I only heard this band a few months ago, I was shocked of how much the band brought everything together so brilliantly, I wish I'd been a fan a long time ago, all the best xx
I knew of Nightwish about 15 years ago when my grandson was singing and acting Phantom of the Opera, I listened to few other songs but never heard Tarja or Floor perform this before seeing Nightwish In Kitee in June this year.Awesome song my other fav is Ever Dream Wacken 2013 ,another older song performed by Tarja and Floor .
I like them all, but this is just epic and the version I like most. She has so much power in her voice, makes me melt away every time I watch it and it's nice for the eyes as well ☝🏻
nah. floor is great on many songs , but there are some - like this one - where tarja's voice fits better. Dead;s boy poem is another. Her voice is more haunting then floor;s , which fits the atmosphere of the song better.
I love Tarja's version forever but Floor always takes her time to find out how to make a song work from her, and here it's softening the gorgeous gentle first half into really feeling like a sea then putting so much power into the end. Her work is really a gift.
Of course I like Tarja's performance better, but unfortunately time goes by, it's not for nothing that Nightwish decided to do Floor. There are no alternatives to her at the moment.
I must say this is the most beautiful ballad ever made, it makes me feel being very proud of bening a Finn AND makes me think of the nature of Northern Finland in winter with loads of those Northern lights.
@@reithsymonds4517 I guess a combination of dark, cold winters, agony, alcohole and sauna! Not those sauna club saunas but a real wooden heated Finnish sauna!
Y lo seguiremos viendo en el 2024 🤘NIGHTWISH es un grupo muy estructurado, me Encanta la versión de Tarja 👏 es única , tengo 64 años, mi hijo guitarrista, rockero, metalero y juntos escuchamos este gran grupo
I can’t pick a favourite song from Nightwish but this one is definitely in my top 20? My list will always very on my mood. The diversity of Nightwish makes it hard to make a top 10
@@ХароН-й9с у обеих есть поклонники, значит обе уникальны. Для меня лично все, кто были после Тарьи, были лучше. Особенно мне нравится промежуточная девочка с высоким голосом, забыл имя. Но, кажется ее загнобили поклонники той самой Тарьи. А Флор я люблю особенно за ее размеры. Просто дух захватывает от больших.
Essa banda fez parte da minha adolescência e os 20anos. As músicas sempre tocaram minha alma. Ironia do destino casei com um Finlandês e moro na Finlandia.
I feel no goosebumps when Floor is singing this song. But the Version of this song with voice of Tarja....when Tarja singing this song, I ve got goosebumps every time I am hearing this song. Magic voice of Tarja.
Okay, I’ve wanted to stay out of this debate but after getting to know Floor and Nightwish better, I just can’t understand people who say Tarja is better than Floor. This performance is the smoking gun for me. Tarja sang this like exactly what she is: an opera singer. It wasn’t bad. But Floor brings a sensuality, a sensitivity, an entire palette of colors, a dynamic range, a huge vocabulary of expression-just an all around artistry that is conspicuously absent from Tarja’s interpretation of this song when you put them side by side. Tarja is a great opera singer, but Floor is a FUCKING ROCKSTAR!
To me, having grown up with Tarja as the singer of Nightwish, I really appreciated the opera voice on top of metal composition. When I think of Nightwish I think of high school and that's a very fixed time for me. I'm not a huge fan of the belting in this song, I liked the delicacy of a classically trained powerful chest voice. If I'm only judging this performance, back from the bridge/solo Floor misses the high note and because I'm so closed off already I can't forgive it.
It is so sad for me to watch this video, knowing that now Marco is also gone. I hope he reconsiders coming back. But I will support this band forever, no matter what happens. And Floo'rs technique, man. It is just perfect. I love this version of Sleeping Sun.
i have seen his goodbye posting on facebook, i think he will be back. Every artist has these episodes like a burn out. Because music artists are products generating money for others while working from 9 to 5 like office workers, that can be frustrating sometimes.
Could very well be that he will be back. If he is close to a depressive episode or in one, things can feel even worse. Not to say that his feelings arent legit, they surely are, even without depression. But even if he doesnt come back, Nightwish will always live through Toumases compositions more than anything and while noone may be able to replace him the way he was, someone may come and give the band a new colour, just like Floor did.
@@pedrocollado935With all due respect, Tarja stayed in the same level from the first to the last note, whereas Floor progressed from etheral to a belting climax. That is called dynamics without which any song remains lacking.
Honestly, I had the same notion whether Floor will do it better or not. But with due respect, I loved Floor's version way better than the original. But Tarja's voice is also immensely addictive. That's why Nightwish is the best. They never cease to surprise their fans. I Love this band. This song gives me goosebumps everytime I listen to it. It always feels like the first time. Thank you Floor and Nightwish for being a part of my life everyday.
Do you remember TH-cam's 'misheard' lyrics section, like 15 years ago? Nightwish had loads of songs there simply because no one could understand what Tarja was singing. 🤣
This is one of my favorite old Nightwish songs. After hearing Tarjas version like a 1000 times I have to say that Floor, (my new favorite singer in the world) has definitely payed great respect to the song and Tarja in this great performance.
@@charliewade1057 I hadn't heard the Tarja version, so I just popped off to listen. Very nice, but I prefer Floor's vocals. Not a big fan of the operatic sound with lots of vibrato. For me, this version is better.
The Valkyrie showing us she can pull off this song in a way that would make the Goddess herself proud. Floor can do softer vocals better than Tarja did, which is very different but I love it
here on America, they dint get the attention they deserve, I am 64 and still think this is still an incredibly rockin band, fantastic voices, creative and talented music, for any year past and today, sensational, thank you for your creativity❤❤
Hi Curtin, you’re right…for any year. In the sixties fan of Stones, Beatles, The Who and the Kinks. Five years ago I discovered Floor in a Dutch program (The Best Singers, is on TH-cam). Since that moment I am a huge Floorfan and discovered Nightwish ( and her former bands After Forever and ReVamp). Last year I visit three NW concerts and three Floor soloshows. My age? 71 years 😊. Waiting on ( I hope) 2025, the next tour of NW. Greetings from The Netherlands.
Me, from Finland, do appreciate this a lot. From all over, this is one of the band in this genre - like ever. - I Think....
You failed to say "Saxon" @@pietkeizer5279
We here in Europe, especially in Germany, took care of making up for the American ignorance. Thanks for not caring: this gave use more time and attention with them. But hey - you got Taylor and Beyonce - they is also very talented. And they might even still sell ticket with Mickey Mouse on. So don't grieve too much. Next time.
67 years old and I just found this group a few months ago. In the words of a younger generation...OMG. Folks...you're never too old to love Rock n Roll
Тут просто для души.
Saw on Donnington 16 Amazing
60
Finland has really good musicians
I'm 71 and I'm with you!
Dieser wunderschöne Song begleitet mich schon so viele Jahre, erst Tarja, jetzt Floor. Bringt mich zum weinen im positiven Sinne
Mir geht es wie Dir 💪 Einfach ein genialer Song 😉
ohne Taja ist es nicht das ...
I'm 67 years and found this reciently too , same as u,and in the name in the words of a younger generation....OMG. ...I think the same of u!!!!geniuuuuus!!
I wholeheartedly agree with C David's comments below. I'm 69 and have just discovered Nightwish and am "blown away" ! Certainly you are NEVER too old to rock!
00
Me too❤
As pessoas que deu deslike tem depressão ou não ama a vida , porque essa cantora tem uma das voz mais linda que o mundo já ouviu amo Floor Jansen , canta muitoooo.só hoje já a ouvi essa canção umas 10 vezes e não canso de ouvir é simplesmente viciante ouvi-lá cantar.
this is shit after tarja turunenen... small worm
You're absolutely right there.
@@tonybell9551thanks❤
Ah se manca. Ela jamais chegara aos pés da Tarja
Love Nightwish, but i do wish people would stop comparing the two singers, both are good, love the band and their music no matter what.
I agree!
Yes, but this song was clearly written for Tarja’s style and abilities so it’s a valid comment that her version of this slaps harder and sounds better.
For starters Tarja’s version is several notes higher and sung in a more classical style.
Согласен, в этом исполнении эта песня звучит как скверно исполненный кавер. Без души. Такое ленивое исполнение. @@MsJustice4ever
@@MsJustice4ever Except that's just your opinion isn't it. I prefer Floor singing this, because there's more emotional depth (IMO).
You're being too simplistic to claim higher = better and operatic style = better. It could just as easily be said that a contrived vocal style (opera) = worse. These are subjective statements that you're choice of language is presenting as objective facts.
@ you realise how ironic you are by stating your opinion as counter fact? Then telling me how I’m doing that. lol. Carry on. 🥴
Она так приятно поёт. Не пытается повторить Тарию, поёт по своему, старается по своему. Это просто две версии песни и обе прекрасны 🥹
На мой взгляд, до Тарии ей как до Луны пешком. У той голос оперный, в конце песни она даже не напрягалась, а Флор не потянула....
Это какая по счету солитска? не держут голоса после родов,наша Нетребко их за уши положит по голосу,эти так просто пыхтят по сравнению....
@@PavelJoundaспециалисты утверждают, что Тарья всё же поёт не оперным голосом. Голос у неё красивый, никто не спорит. Но Флор отлично все потянула тоже, у неё тоже есть очень высокие ноты.
@@nana_nanni2023 ну в этом конкретном видео, в конце высоким голосом Флор не вытянула. Может, устала, не студия всё-таки...
@@nana_nanni2023 У Тарьи нормальное такое сочное меццо-сопрано. Она кроссовером поёт. Песня то не оперная. Но постановка голоса и выучка у Тарьи оперная. Звучит она потрясающе.
Floor is smart enough to not try to imitate Tarja with this. She brings her own style to the song. IMHO this song is so written to Tarja’s awesome voice. Love the song anyway
I think it's to do more with the band moving away from their operatic style of music. Not just floor's decision to sing it differently.
I disagree. I fell in love with Tarja's version, however, Floor is a much better technical singer and makes this version sound her own and in doing so gives Nightwish a different perspective. Floor is definitely the best thing for Nightwish.
Get over it, Tarja is gone !
@@jesterhead1980 I do prefer the version with Tarja. This song was meant to be simple, aethereal and sentimental.
Tarja who?
Heart-achingly beautiful - my favourite 'slow' Nightwish song 🤩 And Floor Jansen is just magnificent - she's a goddess ❤💪✨
Agreed , Floor certainly floored
me with her superb singing
Also a stunningly beautiful
woman as was the bands
other vocalist Tarja who
could really sing, as well.
The guys in this band sure
know how to spot talent.
Freya returned to Earth. I'd gladly join her army.
Lyrics
The sun is sleeping quietly
Once upon a century
Wistful oceans calm and red
Ardent caresses laid to rest
For my dreams I hold my life
For wishes I behold my night
The truth at the end of time
Losing faith makes a crime
I wish for this night-time
To last for a lifetime
The darkness around me
Shores of a solar sea
Oh how I wish to go down with the sun
Sleeping
Weeping
With you
Sorrow has a human heart
From my god it will depart
I'd sail before a thousand moons
Never finding where to go
Two hundred twenty-two days of light
Will be desired by a night
A moment for the poet's play
Until there's nothing left to say
I wish for this night-time
To last for a lifetime
The darkness around me
Shores of a solar sea
Oh how I wish to go down with the sun
Sleeping
Weeping
With you
I wish for this night-time
To last for a lifetime
The darkness around me
Shores of a solar sea
Oh how I wish to go down with the sun
Sleeping
Weeping
With you
..and this was written by someone whose first language is not english!
Floor has such a beautiful voice and her control is just unmatched!! Love this version so much, she's just incredible.
For someone that grow up with Tanja version, this is amazing. Her voice is like a warm blanket trown upon my heart
Tarja.
both women - beyond amazing and beautiful!@@alexlex5792
🤡
@user-pz1jb7xs7k не согласен. У них очень разный стиль исполнения.
Технически что Флор что Тарья поют её превосходно.
Но каждая по своему и мне нравятся обе версии и очень круто что Флор своеобразна и не пытается играть в Тарью.
Обе просто восхитительны
@@alexlex5792 who is fucking tarja?
Oh my god, this was such a soulful and intimate performance, my heart melted.
Melted mind to sweetheart 💝
Yes, a timeless message sung with appropriate pathos. At that moment, I want to have a woman at my right hand and hold her close to me.
I don't care much for Floor, but she performs this well - retroactively arranged for her.
Hfddhkbxf
I always respected the talent in Nightwish, the band, the studio recordings, their live shows, and especially the incredible songwriting! What a fantastic, and talented band!!! And that is hugely commendable in itself!
But wow, when they had the good fortune of what they felt was a complete and utter disaster, and turning that into Floor joining the group, they caught lightning in a bottle! Floor Jansen is an absolute bad ass! "No one" does it better than Floor!!! No one has her beautiful, her memorizing stage presence, and incredible vocal ability! She always leaves me wanting even more!!!
Floor is a rockstars, rockstar! And Nightwish gave her the ability to show the world how talented she really is!
Long live Nightwish, long live Floor Jansen, and long live all of the members who've had the great fortune of being in such a wonderful band! Kiitos Nightwish, and thank you so very much for the endless hours of top notch entertainment:)
You like the song and the music, I'm with you, but you have to learn to be critical. Tarja was an interpreter with a powerful voice and a stage hostess. It cannot be imitated in any other way. That performance belongs to her, reinterpreting it differently is a fake
@@claudiosoldi9276 LOL. I watched End oof an era. I watched Wacken. On stage (talking about presence, and the way they behave), Tarja is almost a beginner in front of Floor. Technically they're different. Tarja was almost perfect in her style. Floor is very close behind, but mostly she's way WAYYYYYY more versatile. If you wonder why they were so happy to have Floor in Nightwish, remember they wanted her to replace Tarja, Annette was only the second choice because Floor was not available.
@@homere-d-allaure Errr....They picked out Anette from hundreds of possibilities and like her for her voice and singing style. Made two great albums with Anette too.
@@nafisahmohamed4371 did I say the opposite? Annette is a good singer, and her albums were great. I just said that Tuomas himself told that he wanted Floor when they fired Tarja. She was not available. THEN they asked Annette to sing for Nightwish. That's all.
@@homere-d-allaure Yep. My bad. Reflect after seeing so many thrash and trash Anette. By the way, the three ladies have different styles of live performances too apart from voices and singing styles. Anette has most fun dance moves, Floor has best headbangs and arms movements. Tarja has best prowls around stage and dresses. Cheers :)
No, you are not the only one, who is listening and watching in 2024,... It's to beautiful,...
Especially to hear the voice of the lead-lady-singer Madam
"Floor Jansen." Her voice is very great.
❤❤❤
I love Floor since after forever, but for this song i prefer Tarja, sorry.
Nigthwish & Tarja only❤❤❤❤
@@geanderespinosa6112 Why are you sorry?
I listened to both after one another and I would prefer Floor above Tarja. Floor seems to have a more flexible voice.
Tarja for ever,!!!! Tarja nunca sera superada, esta nueva vocalista es solo de relleno, no aporta nada, tarja for ever!!!!
I consider myself a person schooled in lots of genres of music, however I am a bit ashamed to admit I have never heard of this band or Floor before yesterday. What a great voice.....the real deal
Did you hear of her through a Ken Tamplin video?
Welcome to the club! You have a wild ride ahead of you.
Tarja's version, Floor's version. Both beautiful in their own way. I love this band :)
Pfff Floor
Tarja made it sound very perfect, clear and flawless like a crystal. Floor made it smaller, quieter, more intimate and sensitive.
Floor Jansen - winner!
@@abstracting6411 No.
@@abstracting6411 th-cam.com/video/ttfQqnskTO8/w-d-xo.html
That woman is supernatural, in every possible way. Voice, emotion, charisma, attitude, intellicence, talent and optics.
Are you are crazy ?
she has the hole package
Optics? She's also an optometrist?
Odin's daughter, like all Valkyries.
Yes
She has one of the most beautiful voices I've ever heard
It makes me shiver to see this woman singing. She looks like a goddess !!!
Even when pregnant :) th-cam.com/video/ym1Wc5dmUYc/w-d-xo.html
I wholeheartedly agree. Her voice and presence is stunning 😍
ตีนแน่ ไม่ใช้หุ่นแบบนั้น เข้าใจผิดเพื่อนกูนะ
Floor versus Tarja, Tarja versus Floor - It's like a female version of Ozzy versus Dio!! If it has to be Floor for you then listen to Floor and the same with Tarja but, please, just respect each other!!
As long as we can all agree that Tarja is clearly better, I agree.
Ozzy sucks tho
This! But that shit will never stop...sadly.
Both ozy and dio are overrated not good example
hahahaha.... good one! rock on, brother!
This Live Version with Floor and the Live Version with Tarja are my favorites. Both so unique versions although this song was made for Tarja's voice, Floor made such a piece of art here 👏🏻
I agree that both are great. The End of an Era version is more classical or even operatic singing, this is more like a rock ballad.
@@MikkoRantalainen no, annet
@@qdoem4865 The discussion was about Tarja and Floor, not about Anette.
If you want operatic singing, go with Tarja. If you want pop style, go with Anette. For everything else, go with Floor.
Wspaniałe wykonanie. Floor i Nightwish to wspaniałe połączenie. Słucham wszystkich utworów codziennie. Jesteście cudowni.
th-cam.com/video/hCz35_-MAK4/w-d-xo.html
I've had two favorite bands for decades: Queen and Genesis. What I dared not believe: now there are THREE. Nightwish are absolutely great - THANK YOU.
The sun is sleeping quietly
Once upon a century
Wistful oceans calm and red
Ardent caresses laid to rest
For my dreams I hold my life
For wishes I behold my night
The truth at the end of time
Losing faith makes a crime
I wish for this night-time
To last for a lifetime
The darkness around me
Shores of a solar sea
Oh how I wish to go down with the sun
Sleeping
Weeping
With you
Sorrow has a human heart
From my god it will depart
I'd sail before a thousand moons
Never finding where to go
Two hundred twenty-two days of light
Will be desired by a night
A moment for the poet's play
Until there's nothing left to say
I wish for this night-time
To last for a…
Anyone an idea what the '222 days of light' refer to?
Beautiful.
@@honingbijtje83 Possibly the polar night and the polar day (midnight sun).
@@honingbijtje83 the whole song it’s a tribute to the solar eclipse in 1999. The 222 days are the number off day that year before the eclipse.
Does not matter how many times I hear Nightwish, I get chills listening to Floor.
She has such an incredibly beaultiful and powerful voice. I love this song so much.
So true they are all great musicians drummer and the bass player are something else
So calm and in control of her voice.. Amazing singer
Sleeping Sun was my intro to Nightwish and I will always love Tarja's vocals on this the most, but Floor is talented and smart. I love listening to what she does with the older songs and am always looking forward to what she does next.
She do all and all better
Sleeping Sun was also my introduction. Floor is talented, there's no doubt about that. She has been a satisfactory placeholder. But I still stand by that the band will never be the same without Tarja. I hope she comes back one day. Hell, her and Floor together with Marco would be even better. Then we could have the best of both worlds. If I may ask, where did you first hear Sleeping Sun?
Same here. Sleeping Sun my intro to Nightwish. We cant compare Floor with Tarja. Both have best inside them. Nightwish will never real Nightwish without Tarja + Marko. But, Floor with Nightwish will be next best Nightwish. That's my wish on night.
I see Floor with an angelical voice, but, as the same time i can see her getting an sword and going for the battle..
She can command an entire army only by singing, whatba force of nature gifted by the gods.
@@squalllionheart3453 Yeah, she is a powerful woman !
That is also where I'm at with floor. Since after forever she's just been this warrior queen vibe
And also level the opposing army with her voice. Just check out her band ReVamp. Misery's No Crime live she sounds like a pissed off mountain lion :-D
Think Valkyrie
I wouldn't be as big into Nightwish as I am right now if not for Floor. I know a lot older fans will cry anathema, but Tarja can be a bit of a challenging listen sometimes. Floor is instantly accessible because you can instantly tell how amazing she is.
Update after a couple of weeks of listening to NW: Actually, I prefer Tarja's rendition of this, and also of Nemo. Both songs benefit quite a bit from her dark tone, as opposed to the more airy Disney Princess style vocals Floor used in this video.
@@ChrisBach1138 Glad you posted this a few weeks later. This song was made for Tarja's vocal range and tone. That's why the Floor version is not as good as Tarja one.
Same happens with Kinslayer.
Only Floor could make a live performance sound like the very best produced in a studio. Absolutely breathtaking. ❤️
Not to mention Floor is gorgeous❤
Well... the Eagles did it in Hell Freezes Over. But yeah... she did too. And she’s AWESOME!!
Then I take it you havent heard Tarja sing it live without mic, as I did in Oslo. Floor is a midget compare to her.
@@sluretass Tarja is not in the same vocal universe of Jansen. Try again.
Tarja is other-wordly.
The men are so lucky to have her as their vocalist. She has a delicate but poweful voice.
I get chills when I see Floor singing so wonderfully, an angel in human skin.
Секрет их таланта-их свобода!Только свободный человек может творить и созидать
+1000!
Ye. Sure!
I think I could watch this at least a thousand times! The talent shown by this woman is absolutely AMAZING.
Tarja and Floor both bring their own lovely interpretation of the song to it. Floor's voice is more delicate and pretty in this recording, whilst Tarja has such a full and powerful beauty in the original rendition. Both are excellent.
This video is awesome. I love how it sounds (especially the bass guitar) and how it looks (the colors and slow camera shots). Probably my favorite live video ❤️
I’m 72, and a friend from Finland turned me on to this band a couple of years ago. My wife and I are now full on fans, and in our opinion Floor is the most impressive of the vocalists. I’m continually amazed at her ability.
Me too, Sweetie!
Sometimes I wonder if I only enjoy older Nightwish because of a period in my life or the amount of time I've invested into listening to it. Clicked play above. Goose bumps. It's just better.
You can hear just the way the band is playing and performing that they feel reborn...so much energy and fresh inspiration..they are happy...Nightwish is complete again with Floor..even more complete...cause...and this is coming from a Tarja fan...Floor is the ultimate singer for Nightwish..her voice has everything!
Yea..... you're obviously not a Tarja fan.
@@volairelarp3773 why you think that it obvious that floor is much talented that tarja ever be man is objective
True fan supports the band no matter what. Yes, it is true, they play like reborn, this is perfect said. Dark Passion Play was a great album, Imaginaerum was better. I love Nightwish since 1998 (Oceanborn) and I will love them till the end of my life. Tarja fan? Anette fan? Floor fan? Why they should be compared? They are so good, but different... If you are a "Tarja fan" what the hell are you doing here?! She is not here. Same question if you are "Anette fan"... All the vocalists are part of the history of the band and they should be respected as equal. Nightwish was, Nightwish is and Nightwish will be!
@@IvoPetrov86 well said!
Amen
I love the band- a story in every song, Floor has an amazing voice, but let us also raise a glass to the often forgotten, but essential and excellent sound engineer!!
Here here!
And Tarja, Nightwish would never have been without her
Well said.
Simply spectacular!!
There are musicians and then there is NIGHTWISH... They are in a class all by themselves... 😎🙏♥️🇨🇦
Very well done. Floor is so incredibly talented. And please: No comparisons with Tarja. Both are completely different vocalists.
You are right
Да с Тарьей даже не сравнить.девочка старается но до нее и близко не дотягивает.вот Наталья другое дело th-cam.com/video/zfzIDdHql1s/w-d-xo.html
Masing masing baik tarja atau floor karakternya vokal Sopran, keduanya sama hebatnya.
When we note differences, we compare. That is natural and good. It gets nasty when we start to put different value tags on people (T/F is "better"...).
You are right, Floor is much better! 😂
The voice of floor jansen is simply perfect pure and refined like gold, I love this song.
I am 64 years old and have been a drummer behind 8 bands in my many trips on this ball of mud around the sun! They are ALL excellent vocalists in their own right! I feel blessed to have experienced all of them! I just hope they can find another bass player and vocalist!
Nightwish one of the greatest and most overlooked band. Floor is awesome and on top of her game with this performance. The performance is mystical and haunting.
So good it hurts! There you have it... The best band on the planet right now!
That voice..... She has a way of capturing the human experience in a way that is unique to her and the dimension she brings to the group is so multifaceted. This one makes my top 10.
When she sings .. she remember me Tarja :’)
@@junseietsu4049 no chance
This song has helped me through such hard times, can't wait until nightwish starts touring again, really wanna see them for the 3th time
What a beautiful song, I only heard this band a few months ago, I was shocked of how much the band brought everything together so brilliantly, I wish I'd been a fan a long time ago, all the best xx
I knew of Nightwish about 15 years ago when my grandson was singing and acting Phantom of the Opera, I listened to few other songs but never heard Tarja or Floor perform this before seeing Nightwish In Kitee in June this year.Awesome song my other fav is Ever Dream Wacken 2013 ,another older song performed by Tarja and Floor .
This performance was a home run and it needs to be on CD. Maybe a Greatest Hits CD somewhere in the future.
I like them all, but this is just epic and the version I like most. She has so much power in her voice, makes me melt away every time I watch it and it's nice for the eyes as well ☝🏻
Helemaal met je eens
Top zangeres👍🥰
nah. floor is great on many songs , but there are some - like this one - where tarja's voice fits better.
Dead;s boy poem is another. Her voice is more haunting then floor;s , which fits the atmosphere of the song better.
You're not a Nightwish's fan. Tarja's version is the best. This one sounds weak, too Pop.
900
@@mihai000000 I LOVE Floor, but I fully agree with you.🤘🏼
What an incredible version. Floor has such a powerful voice and injects SUCH passion into her singing.
Floor is currently, in my opinion, the best vocalist in the style of symphonic rock! This is adorable!
What a great presence on the stage of Floor Jansen. Amazing voice and musical. Applauses from Brazil.
Wicked bass guitar to compare previous version:) love Floor's voice - she is amazing!!!
I just love Floor's voice! Especially her lower register is very special and strong. And she does understand what she's singing! Very wonderful.
I love Tarja's version forever but Floor always takes her time to find out how to make a song work from her, and here it's softening the gorgeous gentle first half into really feeling like a sea then putting so much power into the end. Her work is really a gift.
Tarja Turunen is the best 😉period
@@requin13 Nope, Floor is the best
Of course I like Tarja's performance better, but unfortunately time goes by, it's not for nothing that Nightwish decided to do Floor. There are no alternatives to her at the moment.
Real music, by a real band, with a really great singer.
But Tarja Turunen was the best singer for this song 😉
@@requin13 yes but we enjoy the difference in floors version as well.
Right on Kirk♊👍😊
Floor was definitely born to touch us with her beauty and voice.
,
Trr de
Iyvcf,
Most beautifull voice ever! So soft but powerfull, warm and emotional!
I must say this is the most beautiful ballad ever made, it makes me feel being very proud of bening a Finn AND makes me think of the nature of Northern Finland in winter with loads of those Northern lights.
How come you Finns can write such good music; Sibelius managed it too with Finlandia and many other pieces.
@@reithsymonds4517 I guess a combination of dark, cold winters, agony, alcohole and sauna! Not those sauna club saunas but a real wooden heated Finnish sauna!
I am proud to be Dutch. 😁
Y lo seguiremos viendo en el 2024 🤘NIGHTWISH es un grupo muy estructurado, me Encanta la versión de Tarja 👏 es única , tengo 64 años, mi hijo guitarrista, rockero, metalero y juntos escuchamos este gran grupo
Лучшая в мире вокалистка по всем параметрам!!! Просто мурашки по коже, море эмоций, просто космос!!! Флоор лучшая!!! С любовью из Самары
Magicall music and song and Floor's divine voice. Tarja & Floor and all musicians of Nightwish: all You are the best !
¹1
1
top
I can’t pick a favourite song from Nightwish but this one is definitely in my top 20? My list will always very on my mood. The diversity of Nightwish makes it hard to make a top 10
Fantasmic is the best.
best nightwish vocalist ever !
no "geknödel", no "diva.behavior" ... just a nice voice. authentic, clear, straight, just great !
i love floor !
Frumusetea ,femeii în toată splendoarea ei ,în armonie perfectă cu arta cu muzica ! Super !
This is what raw talent sounds like. No gimmicks. No electronic enhancement.
look to extreme left...vocoder.........................
Девочка просто Богиня! Все при ней! Вот ведь родит мать Земля таких роскошных со всех сторон! Удивительно даже!
Прикалываешся чЁли?
@@Валерий-б9х5с как по мне Тарья уникальная,а таких певиц хватает
Она просто алмаз в жанре симфонического метала!!🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
@@ХароН-й9с у обеих есть поклонники, значит обе уникальны. Для меня лично все, кто были после Тарьи, были лучше. Особенно мне нравится промежуточная девочка с высоким голосом, забыл имя. Но, кажется ее загнобили поклонники той самой Тарьи.
А Флор я люблю особенно за ее размеры. Просто дух захватывает от больших.
@@Валерий-б9х5с ага! Спасибо!
The most heart touching "Thank you" and so humble ! Thank you Floor Jansen for this moment of perfection, yet heartwarming.
Floor is the best singer in the world. She makes this beautiful song her own and touches me deeply!
In your opinion
Essa banda fez parte da minha adolescência e os 20anos. As músicas sempre tocaram minha alma. Ironia do destino casei com um Finlandês e moro na Finlandia.
Banda muito legal!! 😎
Хочешь бросить сраного фина,и мне отдаться?😎🤘
Ahhhh que incrível ❤️😍
Ele tem irmão??? Hahaha zueira, mas muito legal o que o destino nos reserva
Floor can sing the pages of a phonebook, I would pay to go see her!
🤘🏻🤘🏻😍🤘🏻🤘🏻
Für mich die beste Version! Selten einen so guten Sound gehört. Und die Basslinien ... 👍👍👍👍👍 Grüße aus Heisingen (Germany)
I had goosebumps ALL over- the whole song. SO very beautiful! Love this band and love her!
I had goosebumps during this: th-cam.com/video/ym1Wc5dmUYc/w-d-xo.html Enjoy :)
I feel no goosebumps when Floor is singing this song. But the Version of this song with voice of Tarja....when Tarja singing this song, I ve got goosebumps every time I am hearing this song. Magic voice of Tarja.
Okay, I’ve wanted to stay out of this debate but after getting to know Floor and Nightwish better, I just can’t understand people who say Tarja is better than Floor. This performance is the smoking gun for me. Tarja sang this like exactly what she is: an opera singer. It wasn’t bad. But Floor brings a sensuality, a sensitivity, an entire palette of colors, a dynamic range, a huge vocabulary of expression-just an all around artistry that is conspicuously absent from Tarja’s interpretation of this song when you put them side by side. Tarja is a great opera singer, but Floor is a FUCKING ROCKSTAR!
I do agree. Now that they have Floor they are the most amazing live band.
Agreed
To me, having grown up with Tarja as the singer of Nightwish, I really appreciated the opera voice on top of metal composition.
When I think of Nightwish I think of high school and that's a very fixed time for me.
I'm not a huge fan of the belting in this song, I liked the delicacy of a classically trained powerful chest voice.
If I'm only judging this performance, back from the bridge/solo Floor misses the high note and because I'm so closed off already I can't forgive it.
When I was little I know Nightwish as Tarja I was heartbroken when I learned Tarja leave but I love Floor.
Couldn't of said it better!
It is so sad for me to watch this video, knowing that now Marco is also gone. I hope he reconsiders coming back. But I will support this band forever, no matter what happens. And Floo'rs technique, man. It is just perfect. I love this version of Sleeping Sun.
i have seen his goodbye posting on facebook, i think he will be back. Every artist has these episodes like a burn out. Because music artists are products generating money for others while working from 9 to 5 like office workers, that can be frustrating sometimes.
Could very well be that he will be back. If he is close to a depressive episode or in one, things can feel even worse. Not to say that his feelings arent legit, they surely are, even without depression. But even if he doesnt come back, Nightwish will always live through Toumases compositions more than anything and while noone may be able to replace him the way he was, someone may come and give the band a new colour, just like Floor did.
Floor is the queen of this masterpiece! 👑🎶 Absolutely stunning! 🌟
And Tarja too !
Tarja is...
@@pedrocollado935With all due respect, Tarja stayed in the same level from the first to the last note, whereas Floor progressed from etheral to a belting climax. That is called dynamics without which any song remains lacking.
Hi,
I find this version a bit slower than Tarja's one (album ), and Floor's voice is calm and smooth. Really pleasant.
They are both great singers.
Nightwish songs and Floor's voice pass through the ears and go straight to the heart.
Honestly, I had the same notion whether Floor will do it better or not. But with due respect, I loved Floor's version way better than the original. But Tarja's voice is also immensely addictive. That's why Nightwish is the best. They never cease to surprise their fans. I Love this band. This song gives me goosebumps everytime I listen to it. It always feels like the first time. Thank you Floor and Nightwish for being a part of my life everyday.
Very well said, and I agree. Both great versions of this song, and unique in their own way. I just prefer Floor's a little more.
Look into After Forever. Floor J got her chops there.
I like Tarja's version. My son got me into Nightwish a few years ago and I listen to them all the time - and I'm 66!!
This is Floor's version.
''Floor'' aka Low version@@rientsdijkstra4266
@@HunGyilok Nope, the MUCH BETTER Version! Tarja = HORRIBLE
Angelo: Beautiful... Having seen 'best singers', a dutch programm, she was there with a select group of singers, I am definitly a Fan!
Just how you can hear and understand every single word she sings. Amazing articulation
Do you remember TH-cam's 'misheard' lyrics section, like 15 years ago? Nightwish had loads of songs there simply because no one could understand what Tarja was singing. 🤣
I thought it would be impossible to sing this song in an original way... but Floor made it! Man, she nailed it!
She always does. It's her signature
You can also listen the cover version by Natalia Tsarikova - she is pretty amazing too!
Good music, nice performance and an incridible nice voise, so strong and with feeling. Thanks Nightwish
Omg. I love this version with Floor. I just listened to it 10 times in a row. So hypnotizing
That is music,I discovered symphonic metal about a year ago and I love it-Great fan of classical music 62 years old
I really love Floor singing this one, she has such an amazing style that makes it sound beautiful and powerfull, simply great!!!
What an amazing voice Floor Jansen has. This is such a beautiful song.
This is one of my favorite old Nightwish songs. After hearing Tarjas version like a 1000 times I have to say that Floor, (my new favorite singer in the world) has definitely payed great respect to the song and Tarja in this great performance.
Floor I love you 😘, saw your performance on "Beste Zangers". Wooowwwww. I'm your biggest fan 🙏👌😍
Love it, her voice is unreal and the band is incredible
nobody like Tarja!
@@hannibalkaras1347O que?? Eu gosto e muito!
Это ангельская песня. Люди добра и мира вам всем. Я вас всех люблю.
i can only imagine how amazing it must feel to stand there in the crowd and just listen to this live feeling the beat in your chest
Except you'd be standing there wishing Tarja was behind the microphone!
@@charliewade1057 I hadn't heard the Tarja version, so I just popped off to listen. Very nice, but I prefer Floor's vocals. Not a big fan of the operatic sound with lots of vibrato. For me, this version is better.
I was there. It was amazing.
My favorite song in nightwish.. + my favorite female vocalist
The Valkyrie showing us she can pull off this song in a way that would make the Goddess herself proud.
Floor can do softer vocals better than Tarja did, which is very different but I love it
Frankly, I thought Floor did best doing straight up rock songs as she did with Northward - as in the song, "While love died".
As much as I like Tarja's version, Floor brings a softness to the song that the opera voice of Tarja never brought.
Amazing.