ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.พ. 2024
- European Leaders Trash Trump's NATO Claim | Vantage with Palki Sharma
European leaders rejected Donald Trump's assertion that he would not defend NATO members who failed to meet the 2% defence spending target. Is Trump serious about ditching the collective defence clause? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
US | Donald Trump | NATO | Russian Invasion | Joe Biden | European Union | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#us #donaldtrump #nato #joebiden #russia #europeanunion #uspresidentialelections #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Trump WOULD NOT encourage someone to attack a country. He said that sarcastically! Off the cuff. Everyone knows that.
no they want, that's the typical tactic of the US over the past years, that's why they have lost all credibility! Europe doesn't need the US, who will attack Europe? Russia? they can't take Ukraine. before he says something against EU, he should stop send money to Israel. Until now he paid zero dollar for europe!
I get the Palki blues when I go more than a day without watching her 😊
Mee toooo😊
Trump is the best bet for the Americans in the forthcoming presidential elections. Being a core business mind he's the best to get nose diving economy back on track of revival and stability. 😏 🇮🇳
Agree 👍
Have you lost your mind? The economy is not diving! You must be one of those broke people that does not have a clue about what is going on in the USA or the world. Do you know anything about financial maters? I tell you what. Write out a check for 50k and send it to Donald Trump! Help him run for office. He needs your money and can not win with out it. Show Trump how much you believe in him! He is counting on you!
You need to be deported ! 😡😡😡😡
"Even Pakistan Stock Exchange has noticed that " Palki being Palki😂👏
Indeed.excellent yes❤❤❤
Thank you 👍
Trump did not say he would abandon NATO . He said either get behind us or get the hell out of the way. This is not a video game .
Palki Sharma is a great news presenter !!
yet not all, she said western newspaper have questioned the safety of Muslims in India? please tell us which newspaper, western media is like saying if China critics the US, asian Indian news criticized the safety of Christians! West are a lot of countries with different names, language and culture!
NATO pay your defence bills.
Good job trump❤
Hope you win and clean the mess caused By democracts....
Love from 🇮🇳....
This mess was a spill over from the Trump Administration. All of them are trash!
Trump did not say he would abandon NATO. He said that europe will be expected to should share a fairer portion of the responsability. I really like your broadcast.
Agree 👍, he's the best President ever. Voting for him in 2024. America needs him. He's been misrepresented by most of the news media, especially western and Eastern follows them blindly. I'm Asian immigrant residing in USA and have seen decline and caos ever since Barrack became President. And I'm guilty of Voting for that race baiter. Trump 2024.
NATO helped US with Afghanistan, but Europe surely doesn't need to fight wars for the US or Israell!
@@ajohal5471
yes, keyphrase "If a NATO member did not pay their bill".
listen sure, but understand?
He is not stable... france germany is already promoting theirs armament industry. USA lost billi9ns of arms sells.
To be clear , If NATO excerpts Ukraine as a member it will provoke Putin in to war .They are generals not states men they are dangerous
Thanks for the update
Is Palki Sjarmi telling everyone to not pay their bills? Does she pay her bills? And she's telling you not to? Strange person, she is.
thanks
greetings from Mexico
Those who dont pay the dues!
Thank you for sharing...I enjoyed watching you this news every day
Excellent reporting
Trump will not quit NATO, BUT he will put a lot of pressure on countries who do not pay their fair share.
I love Palki Sharma, best journalism.
I love Indonesia, one of the few Muslim countries with democracy!
Wow! Another great coverage from the No. 1 online media channel, Firstpost Vantage, with our beautiful🎉❤Ms. Palki. She is always bold as ever, simply the best.❤ Thank you for always staying elegantly and stunningly beautiful! We love❤ you! God bless you and your family, the Firstpost Vantage team, and India! We are loving❤ India and the beautiful people of India. God bless us all.🥰❤❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏
Palki should report about BRICS states, she was so proud, saying a new Europe will emerge, but South Africa trouble, China collapsing, Russia is in struggle, Brazil as always.
Thank you so much Ma'am 🙏🙏🙏 ur news is very important for me
It is better to say MA dump.
🎉🎉🎉
👌
Blood money are paid 😂😂😂 shame
One can only hope Trump will abandon NATO and pull out leaving the EU to solve its own problems
Thank you for sharing this important topic. As a proud Indian🇮🇳, I really love ♥ and have a lot of respect for the incredible work of Palki's highly captivating story regarding *How British looted 45 trillion from India* which unquestionably stands as a masterpiece of the highest quality. The content of the reporting is truly inspiring, and I thoroughly enjoyed watching it. The dedication, talent and hard work poured into the video are greatly appreciated by many. The Indian Union Public Service Commission has delivered a remarkable report titled संघ लोक सेवा आयोग *How Britishers killed 1.8 billion Indians. Chronology of British Raj's exploitative policies* | UPSC," is equally astounding. The Indian government consistently produces insightful and thought-provoking articles of the utmost caliber, and I sincerely hope they continue to produce such interesting exceptional work. Can it even get better than that? It should deserve an award for best report of the year. Thanks for telling the truth. Your show was really entertaining. I adore your passion
Where is the Chinese collapse
Accusations that Britain drained India of resources and starved Indians to death are nothing new in some circles, but at the moment they are being spread with religious zeal. Al Jazeera, the media conglomerate funded by the Qatari government, has recently joined in. But this accusation has long been disproved, and the truth is that British rule in India mitigated famine.
In an Al-Jazeera piece, Dylan Sullivan and Jason Hickel[1] claim that British rule inflicted ‘tremendous loss of life’ in nineteenth-century India by causing the devastating Deccan famines. Imperial policies, they say, made famines ‘more frequent and more deadly.’[2] They cite the economic historian Robert Allen to suggest that Indian living standards declined in the nineteenth century, because the British rule ‘drained’ India of money and food. Indians were starving when the famines hit them. Colonialism triggered the genocide. Social media posts spread similar messages with religious zeal. Many blogs and sites sharing such sentiments have reprinted Sullivan and Hickel’s piece.
Sullivan and Hickel are not doing anything new. In a 2001 book, Mike Davis said Britain’s apathy towards her Indian subjects caused mass deaths in late nineteenth-century Deccan.[3] Indian nationalists argued a hundred years ago that food export supported by a free trade policy and the British-built railways left the Indian countryside with too little food. B.M. Bhatia said that ‘in the earlier times a major famine occurred once every 50 years,’ whereas ‘between 1860 and 1908, famine or scarcity prevailed in … twenty out of the total of forty-nine years,’ implying that colonialism made famines ‘more deadly’.[4]
Economic historians have examined and discarded every one of these assertions. Sullivan and Hickel are salvaging an outdated idea by ignoring the most important research done on the subject. I will offer five grounds to show why their version of history is incorrect and biased.
Five errors of a biased argument
First, the claim that colonialism caused famines cannot be verified against previous experience because there is no evidence that famines were less frequent or less deadly before. Whereas the government statistical system recorded the colonial-era famines, the precolonial data came from hagiographies and travelogues. These dissimilar datasets cannot be compared. The frequency with which famines occurred in earlier times depended on the frequency with which hagiographies were written. If this was once in fifty years, we would conclude that famines happened once in fifty years, as Bhatia did. The authors of these hagiographies praised the relief work because the kings paid them to do that. We might conclude that precolonial kings were more caring than the British. None of this makes any sense.
Second, colonialism cannot be accused of causing famines everywhere. The famines that Davis called late-Victorian holocausts happened in the Deccan, 1876-77 in the Rayalaseema region west of Chennai (Madras), and 1896 and 1898 in the Deccan Traps closer to Mumbai (Bombay). All along, in the Indo-Gangetic Basin, the population rose. The Raj ruled over the north and south. Why did it spare the north?
Here is the answer. The British Raj did not start the famines. Geography did. 1877 was the driest year in over a century (1871-1978) for which rainfall data exists. The average rainfall that year was 30 percent short of the long-term level, and a 25 percent shortfall developed again in 1896 and 1899. Monsoon failure of such an order can cause distress by drying up all accessible water sources. The effect was disastrous in the Deccan Plateau because it was normally much drier than the north and did not have rivers fed by the Himalayan snow, unlike the north. Monsoon rain was the primary source, and when that failed, cultivation stopped, and distressed people lived on infected water to die of cholera. Colonialism had nothing to do with the reason they died.
Third, the living standard research that Sullivan and Hickel cite has a problem. Allen’s work on living standards is pathbreaking, but the India dataset on wages in northern India compiled by early-twentieth-century historians is of doubtful value. These historians left too few details on who earned these wages for what works, or on the labour market, or whether they were men or women, or the contracts involved. These are just numbers without context. A trend drawn by comparing such numbers over the long run may mean that the context of work changed, not the living standard. For example, there was an enormous expansion of casual-wage-based hiring of individual workers in the nineteenth century, whereas earlier employers often hired families or groups and paid them customary fees. The kind of work for which the Mughal household or urban silk factories or the East India Companies hired people did not exist anymore in 1900. Earlier wages were often job-based, later wages were daily or hourly. For all these reasons, later wages could look smaller, but that would not mean that the living standard had fallen.
That Sullivan and Hickel rely on weak data is the least of their problems. The evidence is not relevant at all. Almost all the data that Allen and others used came from the Indo-Gangetic Basin, which did not see famine in the nineteenth century. There is nothing comparable-in fact, nothing at all-for the regions where the Deccan famines broke out.
Fourth, the nationalist criticism of food exports has long been discredited. The economist Martin Ravallion showed in a 1987 article that food exports did not expose the countryside to a food shortage. Food exports rose when Indian prices fell below world prices or after a good harvest and fell when there was a bad harvest.[5] In this way, trade stabilized domestic consumption rather than reducing it.
Fifth, that colonialism caused famines is based on flawed logic. Dryland Deccan famines disappeared after 1900, though weather shocks did not. The significance of the end of dryland famines was momentous for India. It led to a permanent fall in death rates. From 42-50 per thousand in 1911-21, the rate fell to 33-38 in the next decade, 30-32 in 1931-41, and 25 in 1941-51.
Any good theory must explain the end of famines and their occurrence jointly. Colonial apathy cannot do that because there is no good way to show that apathy ended around 1900. It is a nonsensical idea and an unverifiable one. This is why Mike Davis’s work cannot be trusted. He avoided showing how mentality changed, yet the end of famine demanded that he should.
Why did the famines really end?
Why did the famines really end? Michelle McAlpin in the 1980s and recently Robin Burgess and Dave Donaldson suggested that the end of famine was owed to the railways.[6] McAlpin examined the experience of the Bombay Presidency, where the second and third of the three Deccan famines had happened, and showed that markets and railways improved food distribution enough to reduce the impact of harvest failure. Burgess and Donaldson show that access to railways reduced local food price instability. In short, statistical research confirms that the railways caused the end of famines and delivered the gift of life to generations of Indians born after 1900. I have made a similar point about well water in the Deccan countryside.[7]
These works suggest a better theory of why the famines happened. The capacity of the states and the markets to provide food and water to the needy was small against the scale of the natural disasters. All large natural disasters reveal such a syndrome. They show that the capacity of the people in charge of relief can be constrained by poor information, distorted information, limited money, limited knowledge of causation, and conflict among stakeholders. Covid illustrated the play of all these things that limited the state’s capacity to cope. But Covid also showed how governments learned lessons and moved on. So did the Deccan famines.
The Raj learned lessons. The three Deccan famines generated data and research under government sponsorship on a scale not seen before. The results were famine codes (a blueprint for relief), canal construction, railways, sanitation of water bodies, cholera control, and collection of weather, crop, and water data. The effort to gain the capacity to cope delivered a sharp fall in death rates from 1901.
Droughts are, and were, common in tropical monsoon geographies. The start of a peacetime drought had nothing to do with states. But states could learn lessons and be better prepared. The Raj learned how the government could get better at managing massive weather shocks, the type to hit the Deccan at the end of the nineteenth century. Sullivan and Hickel dare not tell that story, for that would dilute their partisan message.
1¹1¹11¹⅕
Defend Taiwan, safeguard democracy. 👎👎🇨🇳🇨🇳
why are you posting the same comment in every Palki video?
Excellent production
🙏💛👍👍👍
Thanks for the commentary on the elections in Pakistan
Critical times to deal with is here in the whole world!
Thank you Beta. You are good. God bless you 😊🙏🏼🙏🏼
Yes, why would you belong to a body and not pay your dues as and when due? Yet, you would expect to enjoy all the befits accruing to members. Political correctness is one phrase that has brought the world to the precipice. Sometimes it is necessary to be blunt.
Agreed!
Chinese can be dubious
So funny, but it's loved and popular for him to hold Europe's feet to the fire. He knows what he's doing when he does it about any countries.
because you think Europe cant defend itself? Alone France/Italy//Germany/Spain would have a great Navy together, airforce too, and the 4 biggest economies are in Europe. Why should Europe fight US wars? they participated in Afghanistan bcs US was attacked, but the other war were started by the US! the whole chaos in the middle east is because of the US. I hope Europe will start relations with Russia, this would mean a prosperity for both, the US never wanted that, they always feared that EU and RUS would find together!
Like the cars that dont work in cold weather
Trump said that he will abandon ONLY IF Europeans refuse to pay. Media is forgetting that. So if Europeans pay then NATO remains intact but the days of free money are over which is good.
European countries have been paying way more than 2 percent of their GDP since two years. Trump is deluded, he is just banking on anti europe sentiments. Most of the Trump supporters also think that healthcare in Europe is subsidized by american money while europeans are paying flat 16 percent of their salary for healthcare. All of his clamis are far from reality.
Europa has only to invest the 2% of GDP like written in the treaty, but most European countries have restarted a race war, Germany invest in a fast step 100billions, France/ Italy are already top, but they need to reach 2%, so Italy ordered over 100 new LeoA7ita tanks, new ships, planes, Poland is becoming one of the strongest country, if they can spend that much! Europa can defend itself, but they will never take part in wars that the US started, this is part of the treaty! We will not fight for Israel, thats for sure.
@@Ezekiel903 That is quite a tough talk for a European. 100% of European governments and its people are totally subservient to the US... you will exactly do as you are told... including paying up the amount Trump wants.
@@abhishes you have no clue baby, go to Israel you have to do what they say!
@@Ezekiel903 EU/NATO also worked towards making oktober 7th happen. You are the one that has no clue.
You they wont fight for Israel.. because they have been fighting against it for decades.
Bring the troops home,let Europe defend themselves…..
The us defense secretary must have vacation ticket to Pattaya, Thailand.
My first problem with going to Mars is the 7 months travel.
It is important the 2 country to have good relation i
👌💛☝️👍👍
Please comè to Manipur and spread to the World That Manipur is still on fire.
Palki Sharma,
Love to watch your news. Almost all the current topics are covered every time. 👍🏽
Palki, thank you for your work. I don't think you need to worry about the safety of NATO members. But, if you worry about their wallet, you should be. They will pay their fair share. Russian language is not a very easy one. It is much easier to part with 2% off your income than to learn Russian. I was forced to learn Russian for 14 years, and I still suck at it.
India should stand with all other countries and demand Israel to stop in front of Rafah!
@@Ezekiel903 why ? you want to protect hamas ?
@@ShaitaaN_raju In your little brain it is not possible to criticize Israel and support Palestinian people? then stfu
Americans should look after America and let the European nations to manage thier own affairs.
we dont need them, for what?? they create only war. The US is near a collapse, cities decay, drug, crime, homelessness and more!! who should fear Europe? Russia, they can't even take Ukraine! so what?
It’s already NATO vs. Russia 🇷🇺….and Russia 🇷🇺 is winning 🥇
Good for trump
If they paid their share Trump wouldn't have brought this up.....he was being facetious
oHH PROTECTION MONEY AS LEGAL GANGSTER CANNOT FORMED WELL
🎉
Full support to Trump! NATO is overrated
Pathetic 😡
His goal is to make NATO much stronger.
We the United states have been used for far to long. Europe can afford to make there citizens lives better as the United States has paid a large % of these NATO nations defence over our own best interest. NATO/EU elites need to suck it up and do there fair share. Eukrane is not a NATO member as such. Not our problem.
@@Knox122771 Who is we? I'm an American citizen and I say Trump needs to PAY HIS BILLS FIRST before attempting to embarrass NATO! Trump is a coward!!
Biden uzd tik tok😅😅😅
I love you❤❤😮🎉
The western era has failed to produce hope for global south but humiliation and double standards.
Gws sir
I received a lot of scam callers from India. Not just me. Many are reporting about these things. I know India knows about this. I wish they would do something about that too.
Happy New week 💗... Thanks palki And your team.. it's interesting topics to beginning fresh week... impressive issues today... good analysis
Hi Palki .. lovely kurti top ❤ from UK
I don't agree with Trumps comments about encouraging Russia to attack those that don't pay up but I do agree we have to let these countries know that if you don't pay your share don't expect help from us...
I hope Trump pulls the US out of NATO. Americans are tired of NATO and all their stupid wars.
🇮🇳 Modiji is an unique and the most unpredictable visionary dynamic selfless leader & even Chanukya would have failed under prevailing Geopolitical situation both in Global and as well in Bharat (Guided by Dovel, Jaiashankar,Gadkhari,Shaw & Rajanath)🙏🇮🇳 Modi Hi Tho Mumkin Hi 👌👌👌🙏
I believe and confident that Trump will not dump NATO, an mportant collective alliance of the most powerful Democratic countries as an stable Guardian of Peace. Countries of an alliance must be fair to the alliance and the leader of an alliance shall have strong leadership and resolve to maintain a coherent strong relationship. In fairness to all, fair sharing not one way interest is what Trump emphasized. That is good and responsible leadership which the current leader do not have.
i day without this lady
Yes, I think nato should go bye bye.
Trump is absolutely right
I'm no history buff or anything, but I think the country we should be most worried about is Germany. They just don't have the best track record eh. I mean twice, they started a war, and the opponent they chose, was the WORLD! And it was close, they were quite close at winning WW1, and even closer to winning WW2.
It means that the U.S. cannot finance militaries in other countries.
Ithink its so hypocritical of other countries crying about looting when they toobdod the same thing during their heyday......cry me a river....
Good science fiction
Why mock Musk's 'vision/plans/imagination' ?
All the tech we have today, all the so-called 'advancements' human kind has made, were absurd, unimaginable and unimplementable at some point of time in the past, haven't they ?
Inventors, Scientists and Innovators ve all been ridiculed for their insanities for time immemorial.
I felt the same plus some of the footage they showed and what they talked about Starship were plain wrong. Starship is still in active development phase and is the fastest developed rocket in history. It is the also the largest rocket ever built. The speed of progress is absolutely mind-boggling. They just completed Integrated Flight Test (IFT-2) in November and they were already on the verge of reaching orbit had they not intentionally decided to terminate the flight. It is also one of the most radical idea for developing fully and rapidly reusable rocket which is our best bet to become a multi-planetary species.
Elon Musk doesn’t just talk out of the blue. His ideas are so whack and wild that common people find them hard to believe but he has proven himself right every time, albeit later than his insane timelines. We should all support Starship development collectively and take interest in becoming a space fairing civilization.
I really love Vantage and I am a big fan of Palki Ma’am’s reporting but Firstpost really need a good technical advisor who could advise on their technical reporting. I have found several discrepancies before as well. Had I not already been in a good job, I would have definitely stepped up.
Let be real . The USA dont want Americans to use tictok because it get the real news.
Trump doesn't mean pay NATO. He means pay him. Notice he never criticizes Russia or Saudi Arabia because they pay him and they buy or rent property from him.
Palki 🫵 you save me time looking for News 🌹‼️Biji PalkiSha (long live) in Kurdish‼️🌹🌹🌹
Increase your defense spending and pay your bills europe
Enough money is wasted on war. It only benefits the arms industry and brings misery on ordinary people.
Abolish NATO.
pay your bills?? which bills? the US has 35 Trillion debt and all cities in decay! I hoped for Trump, but after hearing such bullshit i'm questioning now his mental fitness!
@@Ezekiel903 I am talking about Europe
@@goodysri yes, which bills?? and tell the name from the country? Europe is no country, or is India same as China??
@@Ezekiel903 who ever in the nato from Europe. Many country have 2% and won’t spend that too. Every nato country minimum should have 10% to 20% so that Ukraine can be defended. Only US tax payers are sending in billions
looking good for america out of europe 👍
Illogical demands from farmers. What should the rest of the country do? Beg on streets? if all money is spent on farming, who is gonna buy and eat? There is a clear political motivation given the odd timing of the protests. Just disrupting public life and taking Govt hostage. Farming is least productive, highly over employed, water guzzling, without innovation and diversification, lakhs of loans waived everytime a Govt wants to come to power, no tax on farm income, input subsidies and many more schemes, msp on two major crops, import protection by Govt to avoid foriegn competition. If despite all this farming is in such a bad state in rest of the country except where the protests are happening, one must ask there is something fundamentally wrong about our agri economy. And now the beneficiaries of the existing system ask for more. It should be really the poorer farmers that need to protest against the mandi monopoly and beaurocratic corruptions they face.
1.4
Of course they would.
Palki always bends the win to India
Why Americans want Trump: Without Trump and tik tok their life is boring 😅
⭐⭐⭐❤⭐⭐⭐
LNG deal came to bargain table...?
But USA sells also big parts of the weapons that Europeans countries have to buy ...
The first problem is to get out
There are rings
Its possible. No more american weapons should we buy.
An Evening,Grand Occasion in honor of Prime Minister of Bharat Modi in Abu Dhabi 13-02-2024 👌👆
It's 78 bull in filler gas deal vs 8 navy officers.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Only india buys oil and gas😂😂😂😂
Palki, have you ever watched on the Europe military? France, Italy, Germany, Spain are big enough, but now since the war all have increased their military power and I would like to see which country could present for Europe a big danger, Russia, they are not even able to take Ukraine, so which one? Trump, I love him btw, but I hope he will safe the US from collapse, the migrant crisis, the collapse of cities, criminality, addiction, homelessness! Europe doesn't need his help!
Sall must continue for the good of nation and world he is a great leader we must suport
Why would big countries be dependent on NATO? Smaller countries I can see. NATO is all about being funded. It's not a good thing for sovereignty.
GO TO THE MOSQUE ! Pray for Food and Water ...ok.
Starship he don't even have a stove for people come on
India should join NATO then it would be unstoppable.
Henry Kissinger - 'It may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal.'
@@htnaku4947 Kissinger is an idiot and a war criminal, he hasn't represented America in half a century.
@@htnaku4947Hahaha that’s gold and sounds about right. Never trust Americans.
Fuuuck no 🫷🏾
He's dreams made in holiwood it like he's Tesla smartphone never happend😂
American president obama notable slogan I believe,trump America first plus abandon nato and other US military station outside American land he don't care other countries.
You cannot get out of earth
He cannot put a satellite now he is going to mars
Time for Israel to do a Russia and be self sustaining in its equipment supply chain
Maybe if he wins ❤
Natenyahu want to deny a Palistinians state of Mediterranean sea coast and resources there in. Oil ect
This motivation part killed me =/