I was actually like.....Wait he's asking legitimate questions with no plot twist being thrown in the middle of the sentences? And he actually understood what Zuckerberg said when responding.
@@raffyreydado It was honestly baffling in a way. I've never seen at least one sentence interrupted, and/or being used as degraded or derogative or a twist of word play being used. Maybe I haven't watched enough of them, but that's a pretty typical pattern they will follow
Next get the Director of the CIA and FBI to answer what they do with all the data they are collecting and how much they collect. And why they are collecting all pictures of every person alive ?
Google does listen in through your phones though. Try an experiment. Mention some random product in the vicinity of your phone, then see if you get ads with that product.
bro im sure youtube does this with my fone as well..or im just going crazy..its happened enough times that i thought my fone was connected to my thoughts lol..or im just crazy
Exactly, I assume most of them worked hard in their lives to get to where they're at and have enough extensive knowledge to question him about ethics and moral conduct
Nick Bali really? Politics must be different in The us from the uk. As our idiots usually come from money, study politics in Oxford or Cambridge then go strict into politics. There is few exceptions to this. The majority of them never worked, only in politics on tax payers dime. Then they moan about the poorest folk in the nation and they getting £80 a fortnight in benifits, when they pick up massive salaries with even bigger expense accounts And get a £200 bonus for every day they bother to turn up to Parliament. Also they are mostly Brian dead just like all the US politicians I've seen regarding this FB mess. The questions are either stupid, or impossible for him to answer on the spot. I can't even stand FB, but this seems a bit of a witch hunt to me. It's not like Thr $100k the Russians paid in ads would of made a dent in the estimated 1.4b spent (total from all parties) on online ads that year. If that 100k really did swing it for Trump, all the head political PR bods need to be on the next plane to Russia to learn how to make a good ad.
Sandy 2319 oh I understand how big and bad this is. What you need is intelligent people doing intelligent work. Not this media circus crap lead by a bunch of morons. Snowden wasn't bad btw, the information he leaked was the bad bit. Don't shoot the messenger. It's the NSA and GCHQ that was the bad actors in that case. Snowden done the world, Inc US, a massive turn.
It's all an act. An illusion of justice. They're all playing their assigned roles and characters. EVERYONE is getting paid by the same "theater" company.
He's lying. I used to work with Guatemalans. I would drive with them in the truck for an hour every day. They'd be speaking to each other in Spanish the entire time. Guess what. I start seeing ads in Spanish on my Facebook. I don't speak any Spanish. Also start hearing Spanish ads on Pandora. They absolutely listen.
If you spoke about i all the time, then you probably watched videos on it or saw it on your facebook feed or somthing which involves interacting with the facebook app.
You really think out of a few billion people FB just picks you randomly while you talk about cats, to show you a picture add of a cat? Surely you must have sense.
“We delete data if a user deletes their account” - however I seriously doubt the company they sell the data to deletes it if the user deletes their Facebook account.
Most likely, you had made some queries or your relevant activity had an influence in the algorithm not fully conscious and eventually lead you to him. We all foresaw this at the begining of the development of a standarized internetwork. What is new ? People are freaking out for stuff techies already knew was going to become the next big thing...
Kevin Portillo no I have had the same thing happen to me and I KNOW for a fact I never searched for this person I just merely mentioned them in a convo
It's a billions of dollars worth of a company, it's impassible for him to know everything that goes under his level. You can tell his intentions are good, but someone/something in this system is listening to us, for sure.
I deleted my real name Facebook account and I created fake one,I wante to see is there still my deleted account I was going on friend Facebook to see is there my account and u know what ,yes there is still exist my account on my friend Facebook and when I click on profile I can see all my posts ,pictures itd .lol but when I trying to find on search my name I can't find it .
here is how to permanently delete facebook: *its hidden* While in facebook. Go to the section next to all your security options called "help center" click on it then in help center type in "How do I permanently delete my account?"- click on that exact link..... ok so now you will reach a link that tells you It may take up to 90 days from the beginning of the deletion process to delete all of the things. look for the blue clickable letters *Let Us Know* click on these letters. It will then send you to a submission link where you have to write that you want them to perm delete your account..... keep in mind if you try to log in at anytime before the 90day period it may cancel the request..... I can only imagine all the stuff they are doing going through your data for 90 days just to delete it.....
I was having a conversation with my partner just a little over a year ago about traveling to Amsterdam & Germany, Just before retiring for the night. Woke next morning with emails from different airlines hotels accomodation etc: ALL relevant to our conversation the previous night.. It was at that moment I realised we were being listened to......Anyone else notice things like that ?
I noticed that a long time ago, but with me it presents as a news article which will relate to something I have said on the phone.The weird thing is that l can tell most of the news articles are fake, that they are merely there to entertain me because l have an interest in that subject.
It's not the Sugarmountain only. I watch certain products on the internet or search items on Google, bang, next day I have a couple of related ads in my mailbox.
Something more scarier is that if you alarm system is internet based it will detect your movement in your house and camera's come on and you start receiving e-mails and ads from people but once you go back to bed ever thing gose back to a sleep mode but it takes a few minutes for it to do it cause all this stuff is linked to gether home security systems ,home phone,smartphones ,tablets,laptop,smart Tv's, all of it and it all gathers data on you and your friends so becafefull...... They are watching you!!!!
here’s the thing. even in the case the mic is not picking it up, the messenger platform will pick up your written conversation. and that goes for whatsapp as well once they’ve linked you as the same person. so what’s stopping them to use the mic ? there is nothing better than using the messaging platform to target ads because that’s deeper than just randomly clicking on the newsfeed items.
Finally lol. Even the frigging information that we provide to our telco are being sold to other advertisement / marketing companies. Consumers are just not aware of it, that is all and that is the sad part.
even though he says Facebook does not listen through mobile device mircrophones for advertising, I'm pretty sure they do. Maybe he's not aware of it. Every time I have my phone nearby and talk about possibly buying something or going on vacation somewhere, Facebook never fails to advertise that exact thing. Maybe it's a coincidence, but still super suspicious....
That's because you searched for it or even texted it about it to someone in messenger. Never use facebook messenger it is an ad tool that collects your data like any other social media outlet or messenger. Even cell phone companies hide it but they will be next in line.
I do believe they have access to your internet history but never a microphone!! That just seems impossible to try and spy millions and millions of people in the world
Maybe, but what's actually happening is location tracking and they have enough data on you that they don't need more to create a psychometric profile of you, with little historical data on you, your buying patterns, your phone sensors like temperature to gauge whether you are close to a vending machine that sell coke or pepsi etc. is all captured, re-iterated and improved by the algorithms.
People want convenience, people want privacy, people want this people want that but no one is willing to give back to the society. Screw that, Mark is making a difference in this world, amen to that!!!
Yeah, google does record your voice too when you said "ok google" or accidentaly pressed the voice search. You can check your voice activity by log in on *myactivity.google.com* , then search in voice category. The funny thing is when you play one of your voice history, you'll hear your own voice before you said "Ok google".. So yes, they listen to you all the time, wkwk. And also you can check your own history of everything you did with your smartphone that connected with google then delete or disable that if you want to, have fun..
They don’t listen but Siri does. In order to figure out if you said “Hey Siri/Alexa” the audio feed from your microphone needs to be listening constantly. What you say is too complex to be parsed on your phone so the audio is transmitted to a server, I think in Nevada, where it is parsed. So the company that parses what you said can then sell that data linked by your Facebook id to an ad agency that then uses it to target you directly on Facebook. So no in a legal sense it is not Facebook themselves that does the listening. Everything is ultimately linked together behind the scenes while each individual entity is protected behind a web of Eula’s designed to make sure the users have no recourse.
why so shocked that they collect data? Every site does it in varying amounts. If your to sensitive about it then just don't use it. It's not like he forced you too.
every time I see these videos of the senators asking questions I get reminded of that episode in spongebob when they get paint on mr. Krabs first dollar. "Spongebob, we arent caveman! We have technology!!" and then destroys the desktop lmfao
I've said brand names I've never typed on my phone into my mic and immediately started getting ads for that brand. Google is the culprit or Zuckerberg is lying.
cookies/ google ad service collecting your info. google ad service is used by a lot of website so they show similar results. someone correct if I am wrong. but that's what i know about this
CocoPlayer yeah maybe your right but when you travel to a place to much it actually knows how long it will take to get there or sends you a notification. Then what's that?
Had my device in my pocket the other day speaking to a co-worker about the benefits of fiber in your diet,and my device started talking about the same thing,tell me this crap isn't surveiling us
When you download an app, at least on Google Play it tells you before you download, that the app may have access to your phone calls, texts, pictures, location, etc. Its YOUR responsibility to be able to decide how much information youre willing to share. As much as I hate facebook it really seems to me that this hearing is pointless considering a good number of these questions are coming from people who are out of touch with technology. You have to be old or gullible to be dumb enough to let your info be so easily accessible.
I have absolutely seen things like this happen to me. For example, my one friend/coworker plays golf, he brings up golf at work, I get golf ads, Both on Facebook and Google. I don't like golf, I don't search golf nothing. My guess is it may be location based. The services see us both on the same IP, figures it might be realivent to show an ad to me too. I get golf ads afterwards even at home. (I have location off) Sidenote, after watching a good few interviews, Mark likes saying "I think that is an important discussion"
Why? Because they have to gather information about us to sell to advertisers (which these companies are pretty open about if you actually read the TOS) to get the money they're owed for providing an expensive service to us that we refuse to willingly pay for? Nothing is free, but everyone feels entitled to free stuff and free services, even though they have every right to charge us a subscription fee for these services, they don't because moochers will complain about "greed" and leave the site, so instead of directly charging us what we owe, they sell our information to recoup the cost of providing said services plus a the profit they're entitled to for their work, that's the deal we all agreed to when we created our accounts and started using these social media websites, that's capitalism, and it's beautiful!
Actually, it's Google than Amazon than Facebook. From my understanding, Google collects a lot more data than the rest, plus there is a lot more than that. Browsers also store that data as well which is how some websites can get that data. People think it's simply websites getting the data from the user's input but it's more than that. There are three different types of cookies that websites can make which stores almost of all your metadata and can get information from your computer or device. First off you have Session cookies which only stores on the session. The second and biggest that can be abused by any websites or app is called a permanent or persistent which is saved and stored on your computer so even if you clear your browser's data and website data, websites, and programs can still access that cookie and get even more info. Last but not least is Third-Party Cookies which almost all websites and programs use to get your data from websites and such. So in more of a technology since you don't even need to allow or input data in order for websites to get it. People need to understand this and the simple fact that once you're on the internet there is actually no real, complete privacy. The internet is a globalization which people need to understand. The human world is heading towards a global society which people need to understand and prepare for, but as time goes on and the older humans get they tend to hate change and are very stubborn about it.
Same question should be asked to Google and TH-cam because I have experienced something similar twice in the past when I was mentioning something about a scene from a old movie and within minutes, when I accessed my phone, I found the same scene in the suggestion list by TH-cam.
Oh yes you do!!! I am not even on facebook but answer me this.. when I talked about buying a reciprocating saw to my wife why does an advert come up for one on HER phone on facebook!???
so they do listen. That sucks no more Facebook on my cell phone no more Facebook at all a computer is more capable to do smarter things than the cell phone imagine the kind of information they getting from us using or owns computers.
Zuckerberg is great at answering questions he wants to be answered and avoiding questions whose answers he wants to conceal. Even a whole gang of senators can't crack him down . There's just no outsmarting this guy.
Welcome to an ecosystem where the moment your child is born today, they make sure that it will join FB and be the victim of hyperactivity and impulsive buying behaviour. Algorithms, Machine learning models running in plain sights are designed to hook you up, giving you that shot of dopamine that will leave you on FB for hours, because the content is new every time you log in. If I am wrong, ask yourself how is FB is still in existence at present? Because there business model involves new content feed system which will get you hooked and increase hyperactivity and useless stuff that you don't wanna buy. Think about it, it's your child's future on the line.
Rahul Singh Yadav I agree with you. I thought it was interesting when they were asking him about research in rises of dopamine and how to increase that dopamine high so ppl become more addicted to fb and the internet in general. Did you hear them talk about that during the testimony?
would be easier if Zuckerberg himself would use the correct terms instead of AI machine learning and AI are not the same thing everything done by Facebook by now is deep learning - nothing more
Definitions are always important. I find it interesting that in policy and legal documents, they always define terms. But in hearings, there's no attempt at establishing a baseline for common understanding. ESPECIALLY jargon. At the surface, I can see why artificial intelligence and machine learning sound like synonyms and might be discussed as such. I think Zuckerberg understood what the congressman meant, and rolled with it. When you're in a hearing, its ill advised to constantly correct the people questioning you.
Quarknjaguar Machine learning is a large part of AI. Therefore, if you use deep learning or any other machine learning tool, it's not incorrect to refer to it as AI. It's simply a broader term, which is more relevant to the discussion at hand since the congressman wasn't only talking about deep learning. Also, don't pretend you know what algorithms Facebook does and does not use; that information isn't even available.
im using the same keyword verbally for 2 months now to prove this. only vocaly, never typed it. im not gonna type it now as well. but yet i havent seen a single ad regarding this product. i purposly speak close to my phone just get it workin in an actual conversation. nothing yet.
Im always amazed how shameless the US gov is in accusing people and big companys for things they do themselves boldly and openly... i dont even want to start about the stuff they do in secret...
He acted the same way in the movie... He works with computers and logic. So he a sound in putting up a fine sounding argument. Philosophy: Its all about Input to Output. Nothing else matters to him except getting the right answer to solve problems.
Thats not true i know for a fact that instagram knows what you was talking about during the day. For example: i talked with a friend about snowboards the first time in years and a few hours later we see snowboard and snowboard aparrel ads
No they don‘t delete your data, last month i deactivated facebook, afther 2 weeks i returned back. So what‘s happend? My old messages i deleted 2,3 or 4 years ago, are still available for me to read them in my messenger, and i can if i wish to answer them to the people i wrote few years ago.. afther this i deactivated facebook again, i hope one day the will shut it down, and Zuck is gonna have to work at McDonalds.
In the same way that older generations, broadly, don’t understand social media and how the internet works, my generation, broadly, won’t understand how machine learning and AI makes decisions. Because of that, in 30 years it’ll be us asking the questions to some hot shot CEO of some new giant tech company that broke into a new space and destroyed (or bought) the competition. Meanwhile the new kids on the block will perfectly understand this and think it’s stupid and a waste of political resources to ask (and have the power to regulate) these questions in such an important forum and medium for discussion. That being said Peters clearly understands the current tech environment and that is a breath of fresh air.
![[MV] A leap of faith...ความเชื่อใจครั้งสุดท้าย (From "Petrichor the series")](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U1piZH2CNXA/mqdefault.jpg)
This Senator is more sane sounding than others I've watched before.
I was actually like.....Wait he's asking legitimate questions with no plot twist being thrown in the middle of the sentences? And he actually understood what Zuckerberg said when responding.
@@JustRaikou And theres no interruption mid sentence, how crazy is that?
@@raffyreydado It was honestly baffling in a way. I've never seen at least one sentence interrupted, and/or being used as degraded or derogative or a twist of word play being used. Maybe I haven't watched enough of them, but that's a pretty typical pattern they will follow
Yeah, truw
Both of them are Bulllshittting us.
It's all scripted.
They are just trying to protect their job and their company.
They don't care about us.
He talks like a good boy who did a bad.
Derek JCG True
Derek JCG he's a guilty boi
He talks and acts like a tool, wich he is
Richest people in the world*
those are the worst
Next get the Director of the CIA and FBI to answer what they do with all the data they are collecting and how much they collect. And why they are collecting all pictures of every person alive ?
TopEvt To make memes out of them .Duh !
facebook IS the CIA
Basically ALL of social media who made by muricans are providing their data to CIA and FBI, but not only social media ALL of their Company
And the NSA. The FBI and CIA are actually great compared to the NSA
Every person in USA* in Europe we have strict laws for privacy
the woman behind Mark looks like a female nicholas cage.
I can't unsee that now
True
Shh its a cameo
😂😂😂
No, that’s a female John Travolta actually
Someone please take the youtube’s CEO to the court too. I’m sick of these ads coming to my screen.
Chill on TH-cam. TH-cam is truly a blessing.
Yessssss
You expect free TH-cam with no ads? How?
try TH-cam vanced and say good bye to ads
btwk 115 The way to get rid of those is if you use TH-cam premium
Google does listen in through your phones though. Try an experiment. Mention some random product in the vicinity of your phone, then see if you get ads with that product.
Your first mistake, trusting google the same way as facebook.
it doesnt , you just crazy
I’ve had this before about 30 min later got an email from bestbuy
This is true. Happens to me
bro im sure youtube does this with my fone as well..or im just going crazy..its happened enough times that i thought my fone was connected to my thoughts lol..or im just crazy
It’s a no brainer that we are being watched, listened to and micro aggressively controlled by technology
True
These people sounds like, they haven't used facebook and internet from 1990.
Exactly, I assume most of them worked hard in their lives to get to where they're at and have enough extensive knowledge to question him about ethics and moral conduct
Nick Bali really? Politics must be different in The us from the uk. As our idiots usually come from money, study politics in Oxford or Cambridge then go strict into politics.
There is few exceptions to this. The majority of them never worked, only in politics on tax payers dime. Then they moan about the poorest folk in the nation and they getting £80 a fortnight in benifits, when they pick up massive salaries with even bigger expense accounts And get a £200 bonus for every day they bother to turn up to Parliament.
Also they are mostly Brian dead just like all the US politicians I've seen regarding this FB mess. The questions are either stupid, or impossible for him to answer on the spot.
I can't even stand FB, but this seems a bit of a witch hunt to me. It's not like Thr $100k the Russians paid in ads would of made a dent in the estimated 1.4b spent (total from all parties) on online ads that year.
If that 100k really did swing it for Trump, all the head political PR bods need to be on the next plane to Russia to learn how to make a good ad.
Rohan Chowdhury they need to understand both.
Sandy 2319 oh I understand how big and bad this is. What you need is intelligent people doing intelligent work. Not this media circus crap lead by a bunch of morons.
Snowden wasn't bad btw, the information he leaked was the bad bit. Don't shoot the messenger. It's the NSA and GCHQ that was the bad actors in that case.
Snowden done the world, Inc US, a massive turn.
They haven’t. 🤣
Facebook: the company that saves your game progress.
WHAT ABOUT GOOGLE PLAY
It's all an act. An illusion of justice. They're all playing their assigned roles and characters. EVERYONE is getting paid by the same "theater" company.
One Love true
"An illusion of justice"
Jew
Lmao so true tho like the game clue
You’re right, it’s all theatre, a carefully orchestrated distraction.
How much longer until Jeff Bezos is sitting there in the hot seat?
Teebiskit lol too much money
I'd love to see that. Let's continue the witch hunt.
Yeah right. Bezos is too connected to the cia to get stuck testifying
Never... Amazon own everything
Never. He invested to much buying politicians.
Who came here after nitish rajput's video
"We Don't Use Mobile Device Microphones To Listen In On Users"...but the CIA/NSA do!
He's lying. I used to work with Guatemalans. I would drive with them in the truck for an hour every day. They'd be speaking to each other in Spanish the entire time. Guess what. I start seeing ads in Spanish on my Facebook. I don't speak any Spanish. Also start hearing Spanish ads on Pandora. They absolutely listen.
MisterPeetBull mmm wonder if the GPS adjusted the ads based on your location
well that seems like irrefutable proof lol
KentoGS he most likely works in the us, he just works with Spanish speaking people otherwise he would have said
Of course they do!!! I get ads about something I spoke about all the time
If you spoke about i all the time, then you probably watched videos on it or saw it on your facebook feed or somthing which involves interacting with the facebook app.
You really think out of a few billion people FB just picks you randomly while you talk about cats, to show you a picture add of a cat? Surely you must have sense.
See..if you just provide us with proof thx...its not true just because you say so...bring proof not hearsay
RealMapler it's algorithms. All done by CPU
He lied about that forsure..
I started the site when I was 19. I didn't know much about business back then. - Mark Zuckerberg
“We delete data if a user deletes their account” - however I seriously doubt the company they sell the data to deletes it if the user deletes their Facebook account.
Yeah all our data is probably already spread across many platforms by now.
2:00 wait wait!! Don’t just blow past that. Did he just say they save the audio from all the videos we upload on Facebook for data?
So when are they bringing in Tom from MySpace?
:-)
That’s happened to me!! What I’ve talked about before has popped up on my feed as an advertisement. Same with my husband.
I asked about an old employee from 10 years ago. Within minutes he was on the top of my feed.....
duckymagic57 I think he might have asked his boss
Most likely, you had made some queries or your relevant activity had an influence in the algorithm not fully conscious and eventually lead you to him.
We all foresaw this at the begining of the development of a standarized internetwork.
What is new ? People are freaking out for stuff techies already knew was going to become the next big thing...
Kevin Portillo no I have had the same thing happen to me and I KNOW for a fact I never searched for this person I just merely mentioned them in a convo
Was talking about buying a powerbank with my brother.Next thing i know is some ad pops up of powerbank with prices.its creepy
Im pretty sure mark didnt force him to make a post
It's a billions of dollars worth of a company, it's impassible for him to know everything that goes under his level. You can tell his intentions are good, but someone/something in this system is listening to us, for sure.
Deleting an account is not the same as Deactivating it (which is the default).
thereGoMapo Thete are instructions for deleting your acvount if you want
I deleted my real name Facebook account and I created fake one,I wante to see is there still my deleted account I was going on friend Facebook to see is there my account and u know what ,yes there is still exist my account on my friend Facebook and when I click on profile I can see all my posts ,pictures itd .lol but when I trying to find on search my name I can't find it .
Siobhan Rennie yes but my account is still there
I Know Da Wae go delete it then bro
here is how to permanently delete facebook: *its hidden*
While in facebook. Go to the section next to all your security options called "help center" click on it then in help center type in "How do I permanently delete my account?"- click on that exact link..... ok so now you will reach a link that tells you It may take up to 90 days from the beginning of the deletion process to delete all of the things. look for the blue clickable letters *Let Us Know* click on these letters. It will then send you to a submission link where you have to write that you want them to perm delete your account..... keep in mind if you try to log in at anytime before the 90day period it may cancel the request..... I can only imagine all the stuff they are doing going through your data for 90 days just to delete it.....
Some decent questions and some decent answers
I was having a conversation with my partner just a little over a year ago about traveling to Amsterdam & Germany, Just before retiring for the night.
Woke next morning with emails from different airlines hotels accomodation etc: ALL relevant to our conversation the previous night..
It was at that moment I realised we were being listened to......Anyone else notice things like that ?
Gummy sue A ---- Zuckerberg is such bs
I noticed that a long time ago, but with me it presents as a news article which will relate to something I have said on the phone.The weird thing is that l can tell most of the news articles are fake, that they are merely there to entertain me because l have an interest in that subject.
It's not the Sugarmountain only. I watch certain products on the internet or search items on Google, bang, next day I have a couple of related ads in my mailbox.
Peter Kroll I am not sure why Facebook is being targeted on this... I mean Google can do this tenfold.
Do you guys use android, is this an android thing?
Facebook did well with React technology.
lol yeah :) only developers would talk of react at this point :D
And graphiQL tornado varnish etc
true that
Something more scarier is that if you alarm system is internet based it will detect your movement in your house and camera's come on and you start receiving e-mails and ads from people but once you go back to bed ever thing gose back to a sleep mode but it takes a few minutes for it to do it cause all this stuff is linked to gether home security systems ,home phone,smartphones ,tablets,laptop,smart Tv's, all of it and it all gathers data on you and your friends so becafefull...... They are watching you!!!!
here’s the thing. even in the case the mic is not picking it up, the messenger platform will pick up your written conversation. and that goes for whatsapp as well once they’ve linked you as the same person. so what’s stopping them to use the mic ? there is nothing better than using the messaging platform to target ads because that’s deeper than just randomly clicking on the newsfeed items.
Who actually cares?? Like hello every single internet company does things like this.
Caleb Langford well people finally found a scapegoat
Finally lol. Even the frigging information that we provide to our telco are being sold to other advertisement / marketing companies. Consumers are just not aware of it, that is all and that is the sad part.
So explain how whenever I speak about something I get an ad for it?
even though he says Facebook does not listen through mobile device mircrophones for advertising, I'm pretty sure they do. Maybe he's not aware of it. Every time I have my phone nearby and talk about possibly buying something or going on vacation somewhere, Facebook never fails to advertise that exact thing. Maybe it's a coincidence, but still super suspicious....
MrsValentina007 not a coincidence. Unless you happen to Google it
That's because you searched for it or even texted it about it to someone in messenger. Never use facebook messenger it is an ad tool that collects your data like any other social media outlet or messenger. Even cell phone companies hide it but they will be next in line.
I do believe they have access to your internet history but never a microphone!! That just seems impossible to try and spy millions and millions of people in the world
Isnt it great?
Maybe, but what's actually happening is location tracking and they have enough data on you that they don't need more to create a psychometric profile of you, with little historical data on you, your buying patterns, your phone sensors like temperature to gauge whether you are close to a vending machine that sell coke or pepsi etc. is all captured, re-iterated and improved by the algorithms.
People want convenience, people want privacy, people want this people want that but no one is willing to give back to the society. Screw that, Mark is making a difference in this world, amen to that!!!
I was talking about a brake disc with my step-father, 10 minutes later facebook shows me a brake disc for sale on my feed.
Y'all should be grateful that things are laying right in front of your lap.
I was shopping online for some basketball shoes then a day later I got an ad about the same exact shoes I was looking at lol
How helpful..!! Lol
Cookies right ?
I just tested it and it actually have microphone in it... Was surprised lol..
Yeah, google does record your voice too when you said "ok google" or accidentaly pressed the voice search. You can check your voice activity by log in on *myactivity.google.com* , then search in voice category. The funny thing is when you play one of your voice history, you'll hear your own voice before you said "Ok google".. So yes, they listen to you all the time, wkwk.
And also you can check your own history of everything you did with your smartphone that connected with google then delete or disable that if you want to, have fun..
Fajar Setyadi are you from wkwk land
1:56 "We listen to what's going on in your microphone and use that for ads"
lmao thats the part media will cut out to make him look bad
then after that “we don’t do that”
Except facebook does exactly that. The snake is lying.
I like this senator.
But you didnt explain why what you talk about can suddenly show up as an add??This happens to me all the time??How is this happening??
The easiest way to get rid of someone who catches them is to call them a "conspiracy theorist"
sooo what about google and amazon...
well if they're using a neural network then technically even they don't know how the decisions are made?
He's not under oath for any of this, it's a charade.
Its the fbi or cia that is watching through your camera right now :)
I hope they’re enjoying the millions of double chins lol
Its mostly the NSA ..
Well I hope they like seeing my dead face lolz
That's why when I think about it I flip off my camera..lol. Then carry on
@@randomyoutubeperson6954 no doubt!! LOL
They don’t listen but Siri does. In order to figure out if you said “Hey Siri/Alexa” the audio feed from your microphone needs to be listening constantly. What you say is too complex to be parsed on your phone so the audio is transmitted to a server, I think in Nevada, where it is parsed. So the company that parses what you said can then sell that data linked by your Facebook id to an ad agency that then uses it to target you directly on Facebook. So no in a legal sense it is not Facebook themselves that does the listening. Everything is ultimately linked together behind the scenes while each individual entity is protected behind a web of Eula’s designed to make sure the users have no recourse.
Best answer I have seen yet
He's absolutely lying about everything because he can get away with it because of PLAUSIBLE DENIABILITY
why so shocked that they collect data? Every site does it in varying amounts. If your to sensitive about it then just don't use it. It's not like he forced you too.
He wasn't under oath during this hearing
Enough said.
@@bobbyde_pressed4023 problem is Facebook know more about you then youselfe
every time I see these videos of the senators asking questions I get reminded of that episode in spongebob when they get paint on mr. Krabs first dollar. "Spongebob, we arent caveman! We have technology!!" and then destroys the desktop lmfao
I've said brand names I've never typed on my phone into my mic and immediately started getting ads for that brand. Google is the culprit or Zuckerberg is lying.
Ok Boomer
You realize Google and Facebook are not the dame thing right?
They say when a person looks in different directions when listening or speaking they’re lying because they’re self conscious about it.
Every modern sites does these. When you search in Amazon they pop out on Facebook explain that.
Felix S. Its cookies..
Research bridge company that combines them all.
cookies/ google ad service collecting your info. google ad service is used by a lot of website so they show similar results. someone correct if I am wrong. but that's what i know about this
CocoPlayer yeah maybe your right but when you travel to a place to much it actually knows how long it will take to get there or sends you a notification. Then what's that?
You can turn this function off , I did and the ads have stopped
Had my device in my pocket the other day speaking to a co-worker about the benefits of fiber in your diet,and my device started talking about the same thing,tell me this crap isn't surveiling us
When you download an app, at least on Google Play it tells you before you download, that the app may have access to your phone calls, texts, pictures, location, etc. Its YOUR responsibility to be able to decide how much information youre willing to share. As much as I hate facebook it really seems to me that this hearing is pointless considering a good number of these questions are coming from people who are out of touch with technology. You have to be old or gullible to be dumb enough to let your info be so easily accessible.
I have absolutely seen things like this happen to me. For example, my one friend/coworker plays golf, he brings up golf at work, I get golf ads, Both on Facebook and Google. I don't like golf, I don't search golf nothing. My guess is it may be location based. The services see us both on the same IP, figures it might be realivent to show an ad to me too. I get golf ads afterwards even at home. (I have location off)
Sidenote, after watching a good few interviews, Mark likes saying "I think that is an important discussion"
Shut it down
Steppin Razor not gonna happen lol
Steppin Razor that isn't a good solution lol - google does the same thing and so do other companies lol
Why? Because they have to gather information about us to sell to advertisers (which these companies are pretty open about if you actually read the TOS) to get the money they're owed for providing an expensive service to us that we refuse to willingly pay for?
Nothing is free, but everyone feels entitled to free stuff and free services, even though they have every right to charge us a subscription fee for these services, they don't because moochers will complain about "greed" and leave the site, so instead of directly charging us what we owe, they sell our information to recoup the cost of providing said services plus a the profit they're entitled to for their work, that's the deal we all agreed to when we created our accounts and started using these social media websites, that's capitalism, and it's beautiful!
When I got a red vine ad on Facebook, I knew something was up
So basic the tech is broken
its google and Amazon not Facebook.
So what I'm trying to say is Facebook don't collect data by AUDIO because they don't have smart speakers yet.
vipul P, in this order: Facebook, Google, Amazon.
vipul P it's all 3.
Actually, it's Google than Amazon than Facebook.
From my understanding, Google collects a lot more data than the rest, plus there is a lot more than that.
Browsers also store that data as well which is how some websites can get that data.
People think it's simply websites getting the data from the user's input but it's more than that.
There are three different types of cookies that websites can make which stores almost of all your metadata and can get information from your computer or device.
First off you have Session cookies which only stores on the session.
The second and biggest that can be abused by any websites or app is called a permanent or persistent which is saved and stored on your computer so even if you clear your browser's data and website data, websites, and programs can still access that cookie and get even more info.
Last but not least is Third-Party Cookies which almost all websites and programs use to get your data from websites and such.
So in more of a technology since you don't even need to allow or input data in order for websites to get it. People need to understand this and the simple fact that once you're on the internet there is actually no real, complete privacy.
The internet is a globalization which people need to understand. The human world is heading towards a global society which people need to understand and prepare for, but as time goes on and the older humans get they tend to hate change and are very stubborn about it.
Older humans ? What are you a gerbil?
Same question should be asked to Google and TH-cam because I have experienced something similar twice in the past when I was mentioning something about a scene from a old movie and within minutes, when I accessed my phone, I found the same scene in the suggestion list by TH-cam.
Liar liar pants on fire!
Where can I watch the full thing of this
Oh yes you do!!! I am not even on facebook but answer me this.. when I talked about buying a reciprocating saw to my wife why does an advert come up for one on HER phone on facebook!???
Of course they do. I talked to my wife about a camera a couple times and the next day I had an ad for cannon.
This my first time seeing mark on suit 😂
That it goes in the direction that WE WANT... he said it!
omg he is so nervous
Yusra K his human suit looks pretty uncomfortable
Yusra K he has aspergus
No that lizard is trying to be human
Idk, I was talking about 4 Lokos and I started to see 4 Loko ads on FB
Fucc Facebook!!!!!
Zucc* lol
Well somebody listens as they always give me adverts about something I have only just spoken about a day previous!
so they do listen. That sucks no more Facebook on my cell phone no more Facebook at all a computer is more capable to do smarter things than the cell phone imagine the kind of information they getting from us using or owns computers.
They are listening. Sent a vn on WhatsApp about a product and 2min later it's on my news feed as an ad for me to purchase smh
Zuckerberg is great at answering questions he wants to be answered and avoiding questions whose answers he wants to conceal. Even a whole gang of senators can't crack him down . There's just no outsmarting this guy.
It's not outsmarting when the man goes "oh I don't know!" For every single answer 🤣🤣🤣🤣
But, they could scold him so that he got a stutter, and then truth will come out by his body language that he does bad things..
My son told me he wanted mcdonalds and 3 seconds later I got an ad for mcdonalds on youtube
just delete facebook. someone else will come along and make better platform.
MEWE is a better platform ... far far better.
It's called Myspace.
PREACH!
Try Vero
Man I want Orkut back
Get the director of the NSA, CIA and FBI and then let’s see if all these people have the balls to ask questions like these.
It certainly does. It's right in the permissions... it needs access to your MICROPHONE and Camera.
Avery Haqq But people are way too ignorant to understand that
Avery Haqq They need that permission for video's.
you don't need to listen in for audio, you have our spotify playlist information.
Welcome to an ecosystem where the moment your child is born today, they make sure that it will join FB and be the victim of hyperactivity and impulsive buying behaviour. Algorithms, Machine learning models running in plain sights are designed to hook you up, giving you that shot of dopamine that will leave you on FB for hours, because the content is new every time you log in. If I am wrong, ask yourself how is FB is still in existence at present? Because there business model involves new content feed system which will get you hooked and increase hyperactivity and useless stuff that you don't wanna buy. Think about it, it's your child's future on the line.
????????????????
Rahul Singh Yadav I agree with you. I thought it was interesting when they were asking him about research in rises of dopamine and how to increase that dopamine high so ppl become more addicted to fb and the internet in general. Did you hear them talk about that during the testimony?
Rahul Singh Yadav dude ur on TH-cam, its even worse than fb
Holy crap I was looking up furniture stores on google then I went on ig and there was a city furniture ad
would be easier if Zuckerberg himself would use the correct terms instead of AI
machine learning and AI are not the same thing
everything done by Facebook by now is deep learning - nothing more
Definitions are always important. I find it interesting that in policy and legal documents, they always define terms. But in hearings, there's no attempt at establishing a baseline for common understanding. ESPECIALLY jargon. At the surface, I can see why artificial intelligence and machine learning sound like synonyms and might be discussed as such. I think Zuckerberg understood what the congressman meant, and rolled with it. When you're in a hearing, its ill advised to constantly correct the people questioning you.
Quarknjaguar Machine learning is a large part of AI. Therefore, if you use deep learning or any other machine learning tool, it's not incorrect to refer to it as AI. It's simply a broader term, which is more relevant to the discussion at hand since the congressman wasn't only talking about deep learning. Also, don't pretend you know what algorithms Facebook does and does not use; that information isn't even available.
im using the same keyword verbally for 2 months now to prove this. only vocaly, never typed it. im not gonna type it now as well. but yet i havent seen a single ad regarding this product. i purposly speak close to my phone just get it workin in an actual conversation. nothing yet.
Snowden exposed what happens. Never forget
I don't get what's wrong with the personalized ads
Im always amazed how shameless the US gov is
in accusing people and big companys for things they do themselves boldly and openly...
i dont even want to start about the stuff they do in secret...
Easy solution. Ditch all social media and call someone you care about.
Why doesn’t Zuckerberg actually answer anything? It’s always just changing the topic and saying stuff that’s completely just unrelated.
It's how liars speak
He wasn't programmed to
He acted the same way in the movie... He works with computers and logic. So he a sound in putting up a fine sounding argument. Philosophy: Its all about Input to Output. Nothing else matters to him except getting the right answer to solve problems.
The face on the 2 people when he says mega data, think you mean meta data
Liar!!
Can you please provide evidence?
Thats not true i know for a fact that instagram knows what you was talking about during the day. For example: i talked with a friend about snowboards the first time in years and a few hours later we see snowboard and snowboard aparrel ads
No they don‘t delete your data, last month i deactivated facebook, afther 2 weeks i returned back. So what‘s happend? My old messages i deleted 2,3 or 4 years ago, are still available for me to read them in my messenger, and i can if i wish to answer them to the people i wrote few years ago.. afther this i deactivated facebook again, i hope one day the will shut it down, and Zuck is gonna have to work at McDonalds.
Balls do they delete it. 3 times I've tried to delete my account from facebook and 3 times its been re activated with all the same information on it
That's so messed up, facebook leaks our privacy?!!
Athir Ashrar No they sell it. How else does this guy make billions, off a free service? Sending you ads?!
Not only that...but it spys on you...It knows more than you know about yourself
Athir Ashrar you’re not very clever aren’t you
Athir Ashrar Let's assume they do listen. Who cares? It's ai anyway. It's not a real human listening.
Athir Ashrar harvesting your data isnt privacy its no privacy.
I like how realistic this robot is. so precise.... almost as if everything is scripted. beforehand
They sold our data? Where to do we sign up for lawsuit? Those suns a beeches needs 2 pay!!!! and pay big.
Shouts out to the fact that the microphone data and the "I talked about it and got an ad" is completely Google and they're just keeping quiet
انا اؤمن بالمبادئ والقيم بالإنسانية اينماكنت الذهب لم يتغير وكل هذا من شأنك وسأظل وعهدا
Mr.peters coming with the good questions
In the same way that older generations, broadly, don’t understand social media and how the internet works, my generation, broadly, won’t understand how machine learning and AI makes decisions.
Because of that, in 30 years it’ll be us asking the questions to some hot shot CEO of some new giant tech company that broke into a new space and destroyed (or bought) the competition. Meanwhile the new kids on the block will perfectly understand this and think it’s stupid and a waste of political resources to ask (and have the power to regulate) these questions in such an important forum and medium for discussion.
That being said Peters clearly understands the current tech environment and that is a breath of fresh air.
That absolutely happens!
Why is Nicolas Cage there?
Good morning 💕❤️
The like detector determined....that was a lie.
Definitely not surprised by this. Bill Gates said that internet would get this point. Long time ago.