Interesting to read the different comments ;-). I tried the SD43 this weekend and i was surprised that actually the width wasn’t a problem at all. Although I am a big fan and owns 2 subs (1986 + 2007), I have to say that the SD43 is a very nice watch. The specs are improved comparing both watches. I ordered the SD43 and will sell one of my 2 subs. The new Subs are not my favourites. I prefer the 16610 40mm. The SD43 adapted the the size so it become similar withe the old sub. The cyclops and redline makes it a real nice watch. Personally I didn’t like the previous SDs without cyclops and a more rounder crystal glass as well as the steel of the band. But again it all depends again on your personal preferences and indeed if you have smaller wrists, than i first suggest to wear it (just have your own feel and opinion) at your local dealer. I am wearing my watches when I sail or surf. Best
I really like how you go in depth with how it wears on smaller wrist size for the SD43. I have a 6.75" wrist and is concern about the size but it looks great on you so it gives me more peace of mind as I have no way to try this watch on before buying.
Great content, Hafiz. I don’t believe these two have been pitted together and truth be told, one can’t want one without wanting the other. It’s the SD43 for me though due to its technical superiority and the history reflected by the Single Red Line Sea Dweller lettering on the dial.
Thank you for making this video Hafiz, I almost got the 2020 sub today but when put side by side the SD43 just looked so much better, like it was an upgraded everything, so I decided to wait my turn to get an SD43 instead. Great videos from you and really helpful
smart move! I went to get the new kermit one three weeks ago cause at Rolex here in NYC and he brought this out also, i instantly got The SD43. It's so sick and gets a ton of compliments vs my other watches like my hublot and tudor
Great video as always Hafiz! I think that in choosing a watch size it is also important to take into account the body type and build of the person to be wearing it. Eg. a broad shouldered/heavily built body would require a larger watch than a more skinny/lean body type.
I love the passion and pace of your videos. I own an SD 43 and occasionally am drawn to replace it with a Sub Maxi due to comfort as a daily driver. The bracelet is formidable on the SD 43 and can wear heavy like a cuff from time to time when worn daily. I may get an Everest band to give me some relief and to adorn the watch differently. At the end of the day, I’m always happier with the bigger dimensions given my 7.5 wrist size. The case shape being rounded sits better with me aesthetically as well. When I do put on a maxi case Sub, I do appreciate the balance and thinness of the case. The lugs make the watch plant on the top of the wrist and the weight of the bracelet doesn’t cut into the wrist at all. The SD 43 is much rarer to spot on someone else which I appreciate, however. The ubiquity of the Maxi-Sub can be a bummer. I can’t justify having one of each! But I’m always tempted. Especially to have a no date! Lastly, as I use the bezel multiple times a day, to time anything and everything, a fully graduated bezel would be missed. The additional power reserve is also lovely. I wear mine in almost all instances and it takes a beating as it should and as it’s designed to take. Again, thanks for the video; it sums up the dilemma of these 2 great models very well while paying them both the respect they deserve.
The hour hand on the SD43 is visibly larger. I only noticed that when both Rolex are next to each other. especially with the dark recording in your video very noticeable. The minutes hand seems to be the same. thank you for the interesting video.
Great video, love all the information like the lug and clasp widths, and dial and bezel size, not seen anyone else provide this info. So nice to see them side by side, especially from the back. Watched it twice it was so good. Keep up the good work, it’s much appreciated! John
Only if you are a saturation diver and take a watch into rooms filled with helium for days or weeks on end, generally in chambers above water on the back of a boat (doesn't get in from water)
I noticed in this video you're showing SD43 Mark II, where in your black dial sub vs SD43 comparison video it was a Mark I. Is that MK2 also yours? 😮 Btw your video comparisons are top notch, very detailed and clear 💪 👏
I have both of these and the 116508. Always love my hulk and wear,it all the time but gave the sd43 wrist time for the entire summer. It’s the perfect size. IMO but the green in the sun is amazing
I own the SD43, and couldn't ask for a better watch. The comfort and aesthetics are excellent. I had a Planet Ocean 45.5 mm, and sold it after getting my SD43, knowing it wouldn't get anymore wrist time.
I absolutely love the content you create, the comparison, your clear explanations, keep on making your great content! I'm very happy I'm subscribed to your channel. And with videos like yours made me confident the past half year to make some big steps in my watch collection. The GMT-Master II 'Pepsi' , the 'Root Beer' and the Submariner 'Hulk' really do it for me and sit great on my wrist. As you describe each watch carefully I came to the conclusion the Sea-Dweller is obviously a great watch, your information and after trying it on made me realize it's not for me, so I went for a Hulk. Thank you for all your content, keep on making your videos in your style and stay safe in times of Corona.
I’ve owned both (in addition to a variety of German divers and offerings from Omega) over the years. I’ve ended up with the SD43 as my present day diver and I like it a lot. I also remain interested in the G.O. Sea Q Panorama Date, which I almost bought on a couple of occasions.
Great video as always. I really like the amount of thought you put in to your videos. I strongly agree with your assertions regarding dimensions and wearability, however, one specification that is commonly overlooked that can significantly impact wearability is weight IMHO. That would be awesome information to include. Cheers
Rich content, you packed a lot of info at an very nice pace. Good photography, a real pleasure to watch. I own the SD43 mk1 since 2017. Back in 2016 I tried the Hulk at the AD but it wasn't for me. Both have great personalities in their own ways. On your wrist I prefer the SD43.
Awesome comparison, I really like the hulk, but my ultimate goal fora diver would be the smurf. But from these two I would definitely go with the Hulk, smaller case and my favorite color :D
Agreed, that's the number one feature that drew me to it. Tapered lugs and wider bracelet are what make the bracelet end links almost flush with the case, a huge departure from the square supercase.
Another great comparison video. The difference between the width of the crown guards & lugs between the Sub & SD was quite surprising to me. Just one observation - please remove all your stickers!!! You wouldn't wear a new suit with the labels still stitched on the jacket cuff lol :)
Many thanks. Most of the watches on my channel aren’t mine mate, I merely borrow or buy them for the review and then of course I can’t change the condition especially if it’s someone else’s piece. The SD in this comparison also wasn’t mine :) Thanks for watching and feedback.
I love them from aesthetics point of view, and looks. Haven’t seen them up close so will hold back from recommending until I’ve put one under my camera :)
The sea dweller 43 I've found such a disappointment as a replacement for my original sea dweller 4000, just to big and bulky and offers nothing much. The Sub LV however is a great piece and will hold on to it for years...that green sunburst dial is beautiful but also seems to be able to dim down and blend in under the low light of evening wear 👍
@@renkeschulenberg1596 a pointless comment which also lacks thought and substance. P.S I'm going to have a look for this 'sunmarimer' piece you're referring to 😁
Hi Hafiz, can you do a macro shoots in the Rolex movement for submariner and datejust, i want to know how is que quality finish of the rolex movmeent in reality ! I know a lot of fans of watches would like the same macro shoots, thanks a lot !
I prefer angular watches like Royal Oak over circular looking ones, so between these two, I’ll pick hulk, purely because I like its squarer looking case, even if it’s for black sub.
SD43 Lug to lug is 50mm Sub lug to lug is 50.54mm i read somewhere but your measurements are different. But its really hard to tell on visual inspection, probably due to the curvature on the lugs.
Umm.... I don’t think your quoted dimensions are correct. Sub lug to Lug is more precisely 48.8mm so ~ 49mm And sd43 is 50.6mm. Give or take some human error and/or zero error.
The 126600 looks and feels manly. The Hulk? Just put it back in the box for your next generation. Sea Dweller 126600 or the 126603... prefer these two over the 44mm SD. Just looks better with a cyclops.
I wonder how many people really put these watches through their paces? To me, it makes little sense to buy a sub or sea dweller for actual diving. There are much more economical and more secure (digital) options available.
Lighthunter I have just had my 1998 SD refurbished by perpetual time. See it on Instagram & you will see a watch that has been on my wrist since I bought it. I am a professional saturation diver & my SD has served me well. Love the anniversary SD 43. Also own steel & gold sub & blue face datejust 41mm. Great videos on here
![[4K] Rolex Sea-Dweller 43 vs Submariner 41 - SD43 vs SUB41; Beyond the obvious | Hafiz J Mehmood](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ga1ISNdGLmo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] Rolex Sea-Dweller 43 vs Submariner 41 - SD43 vs SUB41; Beyond the obvious | Hafiz J Mehmood](/img/tr.png)
“I don’t make videos to sell the watches, I make videos because I love watches..” Hafiz.
Love your videos man. Well done.
This video just made it clear to me the SD43 is the one to get over the sub
I feel the same too and I got the TT SD43.
Absolutely 👍🏻
Hi Scott, I'm facing the same decision...did you buy the SD 43, any regrets ?
@@pauldavies1375 no, still on the waiting list
I’ve owned both and the SD43 is the one I love wearing. Sold the hill before the prices went crazy obviously regret it
Bought my SD 43m back in june from my ad fits perfectly on my 7.5 wrist👍
Sometimes, wanting something is more fun than owning it
Sohail Japer very well said. Thank you.
So true
That's just what people who can't get something say to make themselves feel better. ;)
damachine3 doucher
always
Sea Dweller 43! Can’t find them anywhere. Perfect size too
Got the call from AD to pickup the Sea Dweller 50th Anniversary tomorrow. So exciting...
They’re everywhere on the secondary market.
@@gotstreetglide i am on the waitlist
@@djdc81 cool man 👍
Great comparison! Honestly, this is the first video that made me feel the 43 is wearable even on smaller wrists.
Thank you for this. I'm more excited for the SD43 now.
Interesting to read the different comments ;-). I tried the SD43 this weekend and i was surprised that actually the width wasn’t a problem at all. Although I am a big fan and owns 2 subs (1986 + 2007), I have to say that the SD43 is a very nice watch. The specs are improved comparing both watches. I ordered the SD43 and will sell one of my 2 subs. The new Subs are not my favourites. I prefer the 16610 40mm. The SD43 adapted the the size so it become similar withe the old sub. The cyclops and redline makes it a real nice watch. Personally I didn’t like the previous SDs without cyclops and a more rounder crystal glass as well as the steel of the band. But again it all depends again on your personal preferences and indeed if you have smaller wrists, than i first suggest to wear it (just have your own feel and opinion) at your local dealer. I am wearing my watches when I sail or surf. Best
I really like how you go in depth with how it wears on smaller wrist size for the SD43. I have a 6.75" wrist and is concern about the size but it looks great on you so it gives me more peace of mind as I have no way to try this watch on before buying.
You have a very unique watch presentation style, man. Love it. Subbed 👌
Great content, Hafiz. I don’t believe these two have been pitted together and truth be told, one can’t want one without wanting the other. It’s the SD43 for me though due to its technical superiority and the history reflected by the Single Red Line Sea Dweller lettering on the dial.
The SD43 look really nice on your wrist & seems to fit perfect. It seems to wear much smaller then I thought! Great quality shots as well. 🔥🔥🔥
I have the Sd43.. but I am thinking of trading it for a submariner 41 green. Any thoughts?
Thank you for making this video Hafiz, I almost got the 2020 sub today but when put side by side the SD43 just looked so much better, like it was an upgraded everything, so I decided to wait my turn to get an SD43 instead. Great videos from you and really helpful
smart move! I went to get the new kermit one three weeks ago cause at Rolex here in NYC and he brought this out also, i instantly got The SD43. It's so sick and gets a ton of compliments vs my other watches like my hublot and tudor
Appreciated the seconds hands sync at 2:33
Many thanks for noticing :)
Got the call from AD to pickup my Sea Dweller 50th Anniversary tomorrow. So exciting...
Wow. Many congrats. You’d be chuffed.
@@HafizJMehmood Thanks 👍
Great video. Best size comparison I've seen. Very useful as I'm considering the SD43 but cannot try it anywhere. Thank you
Great video as always Hafiz!
I think that in choosing a watch size it is also important to take into account the body type and build of the person to be wearing it. Eg. a broad shouldered/heavily built body would require a larger watch than a more skinny/lean body type.
Very rightly said. Thanks so much
Your production value is superb.
Very descriptive video. Keep up the good work ! Greetings from Italy
Thanks so much :)
My SD43 is my daily watch. Love it
I love the passion and pace of your videos. I own an SD 43 and occasionally am drawn to replace it with a Sub Maxi due to comfort as a daily driver. The bracelet is formidable on the SD 43 and can wear heavy like a cuff from time to time when worn daily. I may get an Everest band to give me some relief and to adorn the watch differently. At the end of the day, I’m always happier with the bigger dimensions given my 7.5 wrist size. The case shape being rounded sits better with me aesthetically as well. When I do put on a maxi case Sub, I do appreciate the balance and thinness of the case. The lugs make the watch plant on the top of the wrist and the weight of the bracelet doesn’t cut into the wrist at all. The SD 43 is much rarer to spot on someone else which I appreciate, however. The ubiquity of the Maxi-Sub can be a bummer. I can’t justify having one of each! But I’m always tempted. Especially to have a no date! Lastly, as I use the bezel multiple times a day, to time anything and everything, a fully graduated bezel would be missed. The additional power reserve is also lovely. I wear mine in almost all instances and it takes a beating as it should and as it’s designed to take. Again, thanks for the video; it sums up the dilemma of these 2 great models very well while paying them both the respect they deserve.
The hour hand on the SD43 is visibly larger. I only noticed that when both Rolex are next to each other. especially with the dark recording in your video very noticeable. The minutes hand seems to be the same. thank you for the interesting video.
He’s got the Mark 2 dial in Sea Dweller
That’s correct. 👍
Yep, I have the Mk1 SD43 and I'm wearing it now. I also have a newer Hulk...not sure what it is, Mk?. ;)
damachine3 there you go again bragging on someone else’s channel. 👎
Great video, love all the information like the lug and clasp widths, and dial and bezel size, not seen anyone else provide this info. So nice to see them side by side, especially from the back. Watched it twice it was so good. Keep up the good work, it’s much appreciated! John
Thanks so much. :)
Awesome video! I prefer the SD43 too as I like the bigger size on my wrist and the red lettering!
Great review. But you didn't talk about the helium escape valve on the Sea-Dweller. That's one important distinction between the two...
Only if you are a saturation diver and take a watch into rooms filled with helium for days or weeks on end, generally in chambers above water on the back of a boat (doesn't get in from water)
Great video Hafiz. You really can’t go wrong with either watch. Hope that you and yours are staying safe. 👍🏼
The sd43 looks better on your wrist
Great review Hafiz excellent vid quality and shots! Hope you can consider a comparative review of the SD43 with the Speedmaster. Thanks.
I noticed in this video you're showing SD43 Mark II, where in your black dial sub vs SD43 comparison video it was a Mark I. Is that MK2 also yours? 😮
Btw your video comparisons are top notch, very detailed and clear 💪 👏
Many thanks. Both different watches, bought around 2 years apart for the purpose of these videos only.
Hafiz J Mehmood Ah nice! And you still own both MK1 & 2?
No. I don’t own either now unfortunately.
Hafiz J Mehmood do you thinking owning both of these, the Hulk and the SD43 (mk1) is pointless?
First comment! I've been waiting for the sea dweller macro view. Here goes.
Many thanks :)
More like here
th-cam.com/video/sCCs9eY03c8/w-d-xo.html
Not only best watch reviewer, but best TH-camr.
minibus1351 thanks so much. I’m so very happy to hear this :)
i agree, the wrist shots are perfect.
I have both of these and the 116508. Always love my hulk and wear,it all the time but gave the sd43 wrist time for the entire summer. It’s the perfect size. IMO but the green in the sun is amazing
I own the SD43, and couldn't ask for a better watch. The comfort and aesthetics are excellent.
I had a Planet Ocean 45.5 mm, and sold it after getting my SD43, knowing it wouldn't get anymore wrist time.
I absolutely love the content you create, the comparison, your clear explanations, keep on making your great content! I'm very happy I'm subscribed to your channel. And with videos like yours made me confident the past half year to make some big steps in my watch collection.
The GMT-Master II 'Pepsi' , the 'Root Beer' and the Submariner 'Hulk' really do it for me and sit great on my wrist.
As you describe each watch carefully I came to the conclusion the Sea-Dweller is obviously a great watch, your information and after trying it on made me realize it's not for me, so I went for a Hulk.
Thank you for all your content, keep on making your videos in your style and stay safe in times of Corona.
Though Rolex or divers aren't my things, your analysis is always enjoyable 👍
Thanks so much. I’ll admit; I have a thing for Rolex, especially subs 😃
I’ve owned both (in addition to a variety of German divers and offerings from Omega) over the years. I’ve ended up with the SD43 as my present day diver and I like it a lot. I also remain interested in the G.O. Sea Q Panorama Date, which I almost bought on a couple of occasions.
Love the Sea Dweller 126600
words you describe these SD43 and Sub (hulk) is enjoyable. Personally I like enjoy wearing the hulk. thanks for great video!
Thanks so much.
Great video as always. I really like the amount of thought you put in to your videos. I strongly agree with your assertions regarding dimensions and wearability, however, one specification that is commonly overlooked that can significantly impact wearability is weight IMHO. That would be awesome information to include. Cheers
Great suggestion. Will add in further comparisons :)
Many thanks :)
Rich content, you packed a lot of info at an very nice pace. Good photography, a real pleasure to watch.
I own the SD43 mk1 since 2017. Back in 2016 I tried the Hulk at the AD but it wasn't for me. Both have great personalities in their own ways. On your wrist I prefer the SD43.
Great video yet again 👍
Great video, thank you.
I currently own a black 2019 sub date but should be getting the call in the next couple of months for the SD-43 👌
Awesome comparison, I really like the hulk, but my ultimate goal fora diver would be the smurf.
But from these two I would definitely go with the Hulk, smaller case and my favorite color :D
Assalamualaikum Another great review hafiz Sahb. Masha Allah soothing and informative voice.
Walaikumasalam. Thanks so much and alhamdulilah :)
this is how you do a wrist shot.
Love this video - great close ups :-)
Got both these watches - just got the SD 43 this week
Love the SD43 and how proportions make the case merge with the 22mm bracelet.
Agreed, that's the number one feature that drew me to it. Tapered lugs and wider bracelet are what make the bracelet end links almost flush with the case, a huge departure from the square supercase.
help me settle a debate, someone told me the hulk changed slightly the tone of the green dial after 2014. True?.
Loving the content. I don't know if you have the Omega Seamaster diver300m but that would be great to see and get your perspective.
jthink1984 many thanks. that’s coming very soon on the channel :).
Excellent Video, Hafiz!
Always great content! good job!
Very good and detailed comparison. As always.
Another great comparison video. The difference between the width of the crown guards & lugs between the Sub & SD was quite surprising to me. Just one observation - please remove all your stickers!!! You wouldn't wear a new suit with the labels still stitched on the jacket cuff lol :)
Many thanks. Most of the watches on my channel aren’t mine mate, I merely borrow or buy them for the review and then of course I can’t change the condition especially if it’s someone else’s piece. The SD in this comparison also wasn’t mine :)
Thanks for watching and feedback.
Great Video buddy !! thank you for the content you make.
Thanks so much for the support :)
On the wrist, I prefer the submariner, that lugs are amazing!!!
Loved it so proud of you bro. AWT for life 👑
Hans Wilsdorf thanks so much :)
Hulk absolutely… if I wanted a Sea dweller, I will look for the Sea dweller 116600 SD4K- the last true sea dweller
I have wide wrist and tried omega speedmaster, tag Heuer carrera but sea dweller is where my emotion is.
Congrats for your review and those shots are amazingly well made !!!
Great comparison - love both!
I see the Hulk as a gimmick and would never buy one myself, but I like the sea dweller. I wish it was a touch smaller though.
Amazing comparison!👌🏼
Great video. Have the Hulk and couldn’t be happier. What’s your thoughts on Glashutte Original? Thinking of getting a PanoMaticLunar.
I love them from aesthetics point of view, and looks. Haven’t seen them up close so will hold back from recommending until I’ve put one under my camera :)
Hafiz J Mehmood eager for you to do so!
Great detailed video!
You should review them in an actual dive vs others dive watches, after all that is why they were created. Great, great video!
Hafiz, tell us honestly: what is your favorite?
The sea dweller 43 I've found such a disappointment as a replacement for my original sea dweller 4000, just to big and bulky and offers nothing much. The Sub LV however is a great piece and will hold on to it for years...that green sunburst dial is beautiful but also seems to be able to dim down and blend in under the low light of evening wear 👍
Sunmarimer is for tiny women, sd 43 only for real men
@@renkeschulenberg1596 a pointless comment which also lacks thought and substance.
P.S I'm going to have a look for this 'sunmarimer' piece you're referring to 😁
You ve arms like Salzstangen
....go in the fitnessclub an you became a real man..
@@renkeschulenberg1596 Stupidity at its finest 🙄🙄🙄🙄
Need to bulk up my friend. SD43 perfect size unless you are Asian
Hi Hafiz, can you do a macro shoots in the Rolex movement for submariner and datejust, i want to know how is que quality finish of the rolex movmeent in reality ! I know a lot of fans of watches would like the same macro shoots, thanks a lot !
Go with Sea dweller, much better looking#toolwatch
The lugs on the SD are much better tapered in my opinion. I much prefer the case of the previous Sub.
Hafiz, so what is your pick out of the 2 models, if you could only keep one?
I prefer angular watches like Royal Oak over circular looking ones, so between these two, I’ll pick hulk, purely because I like its squarer looking case, even if it’s for black sub.
@@HafizJMehmood Fantastic macro and excellent content. thanks!
Wish they made a 42mm sub, with the maxi case outer lugs but wider bracelet like the 2020 “41mm” (which in reality is only 40.5mm not 41mm)
SD43 Lug to lug is 50mm
Sub lug to lug is 50.54mm
i read somewhere but your measurements are different. But its really hard to tell on visual inspection, probably due to the curvature on the lugs.
Umm.... I don’t think your quoted dimensions are correct.
Sub lug to Lug is more precisely 48.8mm so ~ 49mm
And sd43 is 50.6mm. Give or take some human error and/or zero error.
WOW suscribed! what a great channel
Great video. Best comparison videos
Fantastic comparison, many thanks for sharing 👍👍
Well done! Great video.
SD is obvious choice. No green watch looks good unless you're Ben10.
Great video!!
Thank you so much Mr Hafiz
I got the SD43 and I love it!
I’ ve the hulk, but and i really like it, but the seadweller is special.
I have a hulk, but wanted a sd43, I played it safe. It’s a watch I need to have. Does the sd43 mk1 go for a premium?
Andrew M yeah a small premium like 1.5-2k usd or 3k-ish Aud.
Is the AD in Australia allow to leave stickers on when you leave? I can see stickers still on on the clasp of the sub.
No they don’t. None of my watches are from Aussie AD. I’ve bought most from wherever I could find - almost none at retail price.
Beautiful videos 👌🔥
BIG ❤ for SD 43 SD so classy❤❤❤
Next change for SD should move from single red text to double red text
SD 43 🎉the winner !
Yet another great video!
I have both of these watches, both are mark 1 dial, love them both.
The sd43 in this video is mk2
Excellent video.
Both watches are beautiful.
Excellent review!
What is the watch that you love the most ?
Tarig Yassin that’s none of these two :)
The 126600 looks and feels manly. The Hulk? Just put it back in the box for your next generation. Sea Dweller 126600 or the 126603... prefer these two over the 44mm SD. Just looks better with a cyclops.
Hulk is best rolex ever made
Motorcar Classics I kinda agree :)
I wonder how many people really put these watches through their paces? To me, it makes little sense to buy a sub or sea dweller for actual diving. There are much more economical and more secure (digital) options available.
I agree and don’t think most buy them now for diving; but that doesn’t discount the fact that these are professional watches.
Lighthunter I have just had my 1998 SD refurbished by perpetual time. See it on Instagram & you will see a watch that has been on my wrist since I bought it. I am a professional saturation diver & my SD has served me well. Love the anniversary SD 43. Also own steel & gold sub & blue face datejust 41mm. Great videos on here
LV wins hands down - you can never get enough of that sexy green!
Awesome video Hafiz...Very well done...You've made me want to Subscribe to your channel and add a Sea Dweller to my collection...Cheers
Thanks so much :)
Sd43 is a lovely watch indeed. You simply can’t go wrong with it :)
@@HafizJMehmood ... Thank YOU