Maggie Gets Arrested | Chicago Med
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- Maggie gets arrested by Chicago P.D. for protecting her patient's rights.
Watch full episodes Of Chicago Med on Google Play: play.google.co...
Watch full episodes Of Chicago Med on Itunes: apple.co/2yCC3Is
Subscribe for more videos from the Chicago heroes: / @chicago
They have every right to protect the patient no matter what they have done...If she doesn't she will lose her job...They can't do anything...No consent from the patient no blood work...sorry thats the policy that also applys to NHS in the UK...
Ikr! Tell that to voight
Yeah true my dad works in the NHS and you are not aloud to take blood no matter what they did you have to treat them first if not they could die
It doesn't matter in this case they don't need consent. When someone would want to kill you would you ask for their consent to defend yourself? If it was a criminal would have no rights... Those should be reserved for the innocent which clearly he was not.
Nuriko DB it’s completely different if they are a belligerent individual who is causing a danger to the public at the time, and even then the hospital has priority. Can’t charge someone if they are dead. Somebody’s life takes precedent over a charge after the fact. That police officer should be stripped of her badge. The law is this way for a reason, imagine if he wasn’t even the person responsible and the officer just assumed and caused him to die because she broke the law she’s supposed to defend? As for the human rights comment that’s so stupid I can’t even believe you said that. Does a thief who stole money to save his sick child’s life deserve the same lack of human rights than a murderer who killed 10 people because they thought it was fun? Does a person who committed a crime once deserve to be stripped of their rights entirely? No. People who believe that are committing far worse crimes than half the criminals in the system. And they are, in my opinion, far more dangerous.
Yeah. There is actually a video of something like this happening to a nurse.
In my country that police officer would have lost her badge for this.
Just out of curiousity, what country is that?
AveryScarlet i think england
Ssme
@RubyTheRainbowUnicorn same
@@AveryScarlet USA
Nuh uh, never piss off a doctor when they’re doing their job. My godmothers one she’s hella scary, stop her from saving a patient and you’ll be outta that hospital quicker than you can say I don’t need consent
MORE LIKE IN IT
You mean you'll be moved to the or
Opal Wolf ha ha that’s how it should be....😂
I’m your 1000th like 💜
No, you'd still be in hospital but you'd be getting treated in one of the beds.
WTF is wrong with that officer clearly she’s not professional!
Well, it's called acting-
@@florence4372 lmaoooo
firstname lastname think she means the character mate. Of course it’s fucking acting.
I think the episodes based on the time something like this actually happened somewhere in the states so they probably based her on the actual officer that did it
Hannah Green that’s because she isn’t professional🤭🤣😂
Ok, but can we talk about how Ethan stepped in asking what charge and such? Applause for that concern!
That police officer needs to be fired
Lewis Gaming they are legally aloud to do that
Aiden Prosty in uk there are not allowed
@@aidenprosty8893 not in any other countries, but hey *land of the free* amiright?!!
In the real life case that this is based on the officer was fired.
@@aidenprosty8893 I don't know what country you are in but this show is set in the USA and late last year an American nurse was arrested in this exact situation. The cop that falsely arrested her was fired
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/oct/10/utah-nurse-arrested-not-drawing-blood-police-officer-fired
A police officer tried this with me in the UK. I did not end up with cuffs on me. No patient consent officer you're on my turf now. Move!!! And he did.
The Utah nurse drama was bad!!!
Brian Harrison so outrageous right? Glad all worked out for you my friend. Thank you for doing the work you do.
Jay Elle Proper bad. Thank you :-) will keep doing what I love to do best.
Unfortunately, this does occur in the USA. Officer gets on the high ride to be able to obtain evidence and will arrest a nurse. The hospital probably did not have a contract, or has not disclosed its policies to the local PD. There has been a case where a nurse has been taken into custody. It is actually online if you want to see it. I think it was in NY.
LOL thank you
this is in chicago
"he's belly is shredded if I dont operate him right now you wont have anybody to charge" I died
So would have the man lol
@@paigerennie9613 this deserve way more likes
@@rileywhatts3002 😂😂
Jesus christ. What is it about the Chicago PD arresting emergency service personel doing their job? Boden in Chicago Fire and now Maggie!?
Alex Ander I
Alex Ander i
I know
This happens in real life :/ It's not right tho
Probably because the time it happened in real life went so viral
To get the blood drawn without consent you need a warrant.
A warrant will only be issued by the judge if evidence is clear enough. You also have emergency warrants you can get on a shorter time, but it needs to be approved by a judge.
Without a warrant the suspect is not under arrest, which again means the suspect does technically not have to anything the police says, and is still considered a free person.
And the police can’t walk into a hospital and demand blood tests on a free person, technically not under their arrest.
Not according to Illinois state law (I guess). At least that's what it's like in the show (as the officer explained in the video). The doctor's aren't allowed to draw blood without consent according to their employment agreey
TTate don’t know how it differs from state law, but if I remember correctly, the 4th amendment stating that you can only draw blood with a consent or a warrant approved by a judge. So even if there is no consent, they can draw blood if the person is under arrest. Ofcourse lifesaving procedures should always come first(don’t know if it states the life saving thing first, but I’m assuming that’s common sense).
But I’m not American, I’m just working in a law firm in another country, so for all I know, the state law might be stronger than the 4th amendment.
Maybe the law is different if the patient is still conscious.
@@gonebytrain What she was doing was technically legal. State law is state law until someone takes it to federal court due to the law being constitutional. It's fucked up but that's America for you
Not only that the patient has a GCS (Glasgow Coma Scale) of 12 meaning that they are conscious, although not always cognitive, however, we work under the assumption and in an emergency that you are cognitive, when the patient was asked for consent of a blood sample the patient refused, they were not under arrest and therefore their Right of Refusal can only be overruled for either: a. The patient is found not mentally competent by medical professionals, or b. Through a warrant. As such they could not draw blood for the purposes the police were demanding, not only that but that police officer could killed that guy, he had internal abdominal bleeding a heart rate of 130 and a dropping blood pressure, even with them pushing fluids, he needed to be in the operating room immediately, and her holding them off could have killed him which I think could actually make her responsible for his death from a legal point of view.
@Fernando Soto chicago is in illinois
A police officer did that in my city once, the patients surgery was delayed, he bled out and died of blood loss, the police officer had to pay charges and then the family sued the officers
Oof
Bank: "Have you ever been arrested?"
Maggie: "Yes"
Bank: "Why?"
Maggie: "For being a good nurse..."
Nah, the Bank would just leave it at the confirmation. No one cares about the context, just the record itself
@@moviehermit5631 that sucks. She was arrested for a dumb reason and now everyone sees her as
This is something that actually happened with nurse Alex wubbles. She was dragged by the police. But even after the police department accepted their mistake, she refused to file any charges against the police officer. What a good woman.
Fucking idiot more like.
Women ☕
That patient wasn't even conscious. And they tried taking his blood. Just crazy.
I know it’s a show but still.. The guy who plays Voight should know that in real life, officers have to get warrants from judges or even an electronic warrants for emergency blood draws.
Maggi is so nice she cares more about her patients than herself and shes ok to even get arrested for one ot touches my heart
Doesn’t the police have to follow the doctor’s jurisdiction now because technically the patient is now in hospital care
Right? Don’t come at me I just assuming
They do, police are absolutely not allowed to do this.
Because that the guy actually hurt other people he would be in the hospitals care but after any operation he would be moved to a ward for people who were hurt but should be in or going to jail so he would still be in the polices hands until her is proven not guilty. I know its bad but its true.
The man would still be in police custody, but the police aren't allowed to do or demand anything that might endanger him. The police officer would, instead, wait in the hospital with him until he's declared healthy enough to be moved to a jail or prison ward.
@@Renfrye you seem to forget that different countries have different rules
U absolutely correct my nan was a nurse for 20 years and won police came into the hospital they were not allowed to arrest it was super private
Maggie didnt even do anything so why was she arrested
This happened in real life, though she didn't get locked up.
@@dux2508 I remember that case..same deal..nurse was doing her job and the cop thru her up against the wall and arrested her
@ohwell94 Yeah, even though I don't live in the US it was horrific that they could be treated like that
In the US, cops think they are above the law and abuse their power shamelessly!
They literally explained that in the video.
who is uuu
1. Choi
2. Manning
3. Reese
4. Rhodes
5. Maggie
6. April
7. halstead
8. charles
9. the officer
0. choose
yee boi I'm Choi boi
Where is dr halstead and dr charles
justfans gaming Dr Halstead is Will
MANNING OH YEAH!
Dr. Manning😍😍
Is it just me or is it bad that the officer wanted blood just for charges and arrested Maggi for absolutely nothing because she is doing her job 🥴🤨
Hi you are right I know right you are right I know 🙂
I wasinfuretated
And she was only behaving that way cause she herself said her partner could of been hurt...so she was not being professional...she would rather take the blood and let him die.
@@highlyblessed2389 if you let patient die it mean you not a doctor
@@missb4645 I was not talking about the doctor. I was talking about the officer
There are 3 conditions required to draw blood from a patient:
1.patient has given informed, written consent
2. The patient is under arrest
Or
3.The police have a valid warrant from a judge stating that the blood draw can take place.
If none of those conditions are met, then the police have no grounds to force medical staff to draw blood. This is the law in every state in the USA. An arrest for obstruction is illegal on the basis of a blood draw refusal , because the officer failed to produce the correct paperwork therefore the DA would refuse to file the charges
What makes you think he’s not under arrest? He’s just fled from police at speed and crashed into a house. Of course he’s under arrest.
@@cjeam9199 Because he was in a hospital and no warrant had been issued for his arrest. Being held in custody and under arrest are technically different. You can be held on suspicion of something but to be under arrest you need to be charged. Police cannot charge someone, you need a judge.
SendarSlayer He’s not in custody though, he’s in hospital. You do not need an arrest warrant to arrest someone. Where I’m from this guy would be really under arrest.
@@cjeam9199 but you do need reason to be under arrest
In fact, there's a footage of an officer arresting a nurse for the same reason. But since this is real life, the officer was fired in the aftermath of the department seeing the footage. The police officer had talked even with the hospital director, who told him how the nurse was following the law. But still, after ending the conversation, he immediately arrested the nurse. It's disturbing.
In Utah, where it actually happened, the police officer arrested the nurse even after speaking with the hospital director, who had just told him how the nurse was simply following the law. And it was a veteran with a 27 years of service, not a rookie eager to show off. The police officer was fired after the department saw the footage of the arrest.
This unbelievable situation actually happened in real life not just on television… which is pretty messed up but due to public outcry the nurse that got arrested was released almost immediately
If that officer tried this in the UK, they'd have probably lost their badge.
Hey yoongi
@@santaemin2993 bonjour?
They couldn’t just get his blood from his car, the ambulance, the emergency room or accident scene?
llgla it’s essentially counted as tampered with because it had come into contact with other substances. The only way the test would have worked was if they had enough pure untouched blood directly from the bodu
Ya
Why couldnt they
Contamination
Why does this have so many upvotes? Do 188 people literally not know what contamination is?
That "police officer" doesn't know how to be a police officer
I love doctors who stand up for their patients.
That officer clearly was acting on emotion. She saw her partner in bad shape, got emotional and acted irrationally.
This reminded me of the news when police literally dragged the nurse out of the hospital when she refused to provide the police the information they needed. Damn, some police need to read the laws again.
I love the nurses and doctors they literally are like the best people I have seen
This pisses me off so much. Voight is always the one to bend the rules, specially in time senstive stuff but now he suddenly has a conscious about what's legally correct? Imo he just doesn't agree with Med's policy of treating any patient no matter what they did
This was also inspired by a real event happening to a nurse in the USA i believe.
Yes!! I’ve seen it
Oh! I remember that! The nurse was literally doing her job and even had others call the police to back her up
Maggie is amazing. She literally got arrested for a reason that would make the officer loose her badge in England.
That is one of the coolest thing ever! She agreed to have herself hand cuffed just for the patient's sake. That is so awesome.
Me : gurllll you is gonna be in trouble .you can't do that to a nurse
Well, she is not getting saved when she's there in the hospital😑😑😑
In my country She would lose her badge an would face serious charges.
This reminds me when the nurse got arrest by a cop in Utah a few years back. Sad that in this case they actually went and charged her for following procedure.
In Germany this Police officer would now sit in the jail
Sadly this actually happened to a nurse in Utah except the arrest was much more aggressive. Her name is nurse Wubbles and the detective cuffed her and dragged her out of the hospital to the police car after she refused to draw blood on the unconscious patient without consent.
MAGGIE MY QUEEN!!
getting arrested for saving a stranger’s life!! ❤️we stan
That cop would have lost her job in five seconds flat
I wonder what maggie would tell them
Them : What are you here for?
Maggie : I didn’t allow a police to collect blood from a dying patient
In reality, she would say "I followed my workplace policy, refused to violate a patient's rights, and was wrongfully arrested" and she'd have the paperwork to prove it. The problem is that some institutions, like banks or insurance companies, might not care about what exactly happened and automatically dismiss her applications or requests.
same thing in utah the nurse got money tho
That police officer was so unprofessional
Why is no one talking about the fact that the officer didn’t read Maggie her rights like-
"He was going 80 in a 25 zone"
That sounds like it is enough to charge him and take away his license for being dangerous. They don't need anything more.
No need to attack the nurse for following policy.
(this stuff actually happens outside of the tv show too smh)
If they had sufficient evidence, they should have applied for a blood warrant... they likely would have gotten it and then the hospital COULD draw the blood without the patients consent, without the warrant though the officer was acting improperly and should have been charged with abuse of authority, assault, unlawful arrest and anything else they could get. Maggie should have sued and would have won as the rules were not on the cops side.
I remember another clip where dr Charles said “the problem with the police is that they think they’re the police wherever they go”
She threatened to arrest her to scare her, she arrested her to keep her “honour”.
So sad to see black women work against eachother, but equally as beautiful to see them work together
Oh my God, you're so right
Yassss
Police has no rights to arrest ppl once there in a emergency
Jeez that lady needs to be fired(not in reality) like she can’t arrest a innocent women
This is what I don’t get, they are saying he did 80 in a 25, crashed in a house, nearly killed another officer AND a family…but no this DUI charge can keep him from
Getting out…really?
So many people are getting so worked up about a TV show...
I need my popcorn
0:31 I like how Maggie says thank you officer, for helping out and get arrested in return for trying to save the patients lives
I can't believe how much I love that Chicago pd was in Chicago med 😄
Maggie is so kind to stick up for a random person
More like the officer needs to be fired and the officer will be arrested to
That was soooo kind what maggie did that is how everyone should be people should be moreee kindddd😍😘😍😘😋😎😗😗😁😁🙌🙏🤝🤞🤞❤💓💓❤💕💕💖💖💛
“I dOnT nEeD cOnSeNt”-Stupid officer 2019
There doesn’t have to be delay: they could draw some blood with a syringe. That takes seconds. You need to test for blood alcohol levels before surgery preferably anyway to determine what risk there is to excessive bleeding.
sad how this actually happened IRL
This is actually based off a real case and the police department lost the lawsuit.
In fact their reached a settlement with a 500 000$ compensation for the nurse.
When I saw the title I was like: “WTF”
And now that it happened I understand
The police sargeant says he can’t do anything but apparently he doesn’t know his own laws?
Wait since when can you refuse a blood alcohol test
I guess if he wasnt under arrest/havent been arrested and that he was under hospital care (meaning they need to ask for consent before dg any blood test/taking any blood)??
Aiden Rawlins They are some country that even a very simple procedure you cannot do without pt. Consent. In South Korea you cant draw a blood without a consent.
Aiden Rawlins there’s a reason they do breathalyser tests instead of blood tests when you are pulled over
at the hospital since is hospital's policy
Finally Chicago med and Chicago po is together♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
that girl got some sass
Maggie was a queen here
Wouldn't they have needed a signed warrant in Illinois?
the irony of VOIGHT wanting to charge a drunk driver, cause when it was HIS SON that was DUI, he went on a mullite episode crusade against Matt Casey to retract his statement
I feel this could be a question in a law class, if you were a judge what would your decision be.
When both parties are just trying todo there job, Who is right and who is wrong?
im amazed how good they are
Patient: *Literally has their head open, has broken many bones, and needs an immediate operation.
Officer: *Excuse me, I require blood alcohol test from that patient.*
Happens when you do 80 in a 25
The first thing the hospital needs to do is report that police officer for abuse of power
Personally I think the officer is a vampire and just wants blood.
There is an act that revokes the right for police officers to prevent a patient/suspect from getting the medical treatment they need, until deemed physically fit by a doctor.
In my country the doctor would have refused to treat a criminal patient. If police create issues they will simply listen to everything the police say!
what country??
Those cops did all that for a small raise
(cop) not got her way oh now I'm going to arrest you
This happened irl. A nurse was arrested after she refused to draw blood from a man who caused a car crash . She was following hospital policy for the patient's protection but he was having none of his and she got handcuffed
who’s watching in 2019
I loveeee Maggie the way she just stuck up her wrist and said “do what you must” like that takes guts
This happen in real life actually, a nurse in the USA was almost arrest (tho in the end the nurse was in the right and the police men was removed I think)
That's grave abuse of discretion.
This actually happened in real life
This situation is why resisting arrest shouldn't be a crime
Why does this episode seem familiar?
*-Remembers the nurse from Utah who got arrested for protecting the patient’s rights-*
That happened in Salt Lake City in 2017, the officer Jeff Paine was fired, later the nurse Alex Wubbels received 500 000$ from the city.
Payne also faced criminal charges for the incident. In 2018, he pleaded guilty to charges of misdemeanor assault and was ordered to complete community service and attend anger management classes.
When law comes over health... lol this worlds system makes me laugh
That awkward moment when you don’t know what they’re talking about but you know its bad.
I'm not the only one laughing at 1.26 right😂😂😅❤️
This was inspired on a case in Utah where a nurse was arrested for the same exact reason
The officer was fired a month after the incident and the nurse was released in less than 24 hours
I legit punched my phone out of my hands thinking I would of punched the police officer like wtf would they do that for b**** i would of squared up swear down.
They need to get the rules cleared!
And that police pisses me off so fucking much
In my country that police officer wouldn’t have just lost her job she would have also ended up in jail 😂
Maggie in a interview for a new job.
The interviewer: Have you been arrested before?
Maggie: Yea, For doing my job as a nurse
She has to arrest a fellow sister
right, cause the race of the characters is the most important thing
kimmy cuthbert why tf does it matter jeeze
That sounds racist, Jesus.
This sort of thing happens IRL as well.
She shouldn't have become an officer 👮😒👮♀️👎
Even if it's a time sensitive investigation, you still have to follow medical protocols by getting a warrant from a judge. You can’t just barge in a hospital without any sort of proof and demand something, your in different waters and you have to abide by their rules. That goes against Police protocols, Hank, you should know better.
Who else thinks that Maggie is your favourite and wants her to be your best friend
Like if agree
I actually find this sad that so many people think this is real