Fabian Putting I don't understand why Iran did a deal with the U.S. Never ever trust a 🐍. Those gringos never keep there word, not ones to be trusted. Something a little off topic is... Now you can clearly see why the U.S. runs on a 2 party system. The DemoRats come in and play the nice cop in order to get deals done with there "enemies" then the RepubliCants come in and play the bad cop to get what they want out of every deal done.
Really? Do you think sending the Iranians 2 billion in cash to fund nuclear operations to the country that claims will be responsible dort wiping Israel and the US of the face of the planet?
@@theTeflonDon1 Not to necro an old thread, but you do realize that the 2 billion was unfrozen Iranian assets that already belonged to them, and were unfrozen as part of the liberation of sanctions, and if they don't have nukes it's pretty difficult to wage war against any nation that is armed with nukes (Like Israel and the US?)
@@itschrisguy I was on a diatribe on this page because of support I saw for the video. In hindsight it was obvious you were being sarcastic, didnt notice. See ya
We live in a day and age where countries that have stockpiles with hundreds of thousands of nukes tell other countries what they can or cannot do with their nuclear programs.
"Great inspections, Terrific Inspections, best inspections in the world" thats what the inspection part sounded like it didnt give me any information about them in general
Baker Harrington But at the same time, at another of their videos about "Iran, USA and Israel" they let you think that the nuclear deal is inadequate, and that Iran could make another nuke whenever it pleased. Vox has always been a very confusing and self-contradicting channel, and one shouldn't trust it too much.
also they can postpone an IAEA inspection for as long as 24 days, so plenty of time to hide what they don't want seen. also no inspecting of military sites...
I know. haha, these inspectors are boneheads. Anyone stating there's a 100% chance they get caught if they break the rules is a jackass. The UN inspectors in Syria got lost in Damascus when they were checking for Sarin gas.
+Vox do you really trust the Iran government to do right by its people and its word as they have proven time and time in the past and present that they will continue its war on civil rights, continue to fund international Islamic terrorism, and continue its war on Israel, Iraq, and Afghanistan? If so please explain why and how you can put your faith in such a despicably evil regime?
Think of this in civ v terms guys... Iran gets embargo lifted, Iran starts making caravans and cargo ships, Iran has ideology of theocracy, Iran generates 30 unhappiness because they adopted the wrong ideology (theocracy), Iran adopts new ideology (freedom).
Unfortunately this isn't civ 5 and its highly unlikely that they will reject theocracy especially after the theocratic state can now use propaganda to strengthen its hold on their society by saying they saved Iran.
"Wrong ideology," is that why Iran has a higher standard of education and a better life expectancy under this theocracy? Keep your entitled bullshit to yourself.
***** Woah come down. In civ v, the "wrong ideology" is just the ideology that no one else has in BNW, becuase world congress gets on you to switch, and your happiness goes down. It is just a joke pal. Making light of a serious issue sometimes help people understand it a bit better. (like me).
Israel doesn't have any nuclear weapons because it's not allowed to and btw if they secretly have nuclear weapons on who and where are they gonna use it to, if the world finds out Israel had a nuclear bomb and used it everyone would flip out, there not idiots to fire a nuclear bomb just think for a second what could happen and Israel is not stupid
That_llama_in_a_tuxedo i wrote my comment like 5 moths ago and yes you are right they do have nuclear weapons and yes they didnt sign the nuclear non proliferstion treaty but i doubt anyone would allow israel to use nuclear weapons nor israel is that stupid to use one since they know that could easily spark a nuclear war i think the only reason israel didnt sign the treaty is to scare off big countries like iran
USA didn't really give much if anything. If you mean the $150 billion, that money has always been Iran's. It is oil money and unfullfilled arms payments that USA never fullfilled when Iran started acting up by kidnapping people and threatening Israel.
Nuclear Proliferation, there's your answer. The RnD to go from a Fission Power Plant to a Fission Bomb can only take about as long as 20 years. More recent nuclear power plants either use different radioactive material or a safer system that makes it considerably more difficult to go from cleaner, cheaper, energy, to a weapon of mass destruction. Hell, North Korea figured it out by themselves, a country that's a huge part of the international economy, even easier.
Sammy Hannat in case you don't know, iran isn't ruled by normal dictators just seeking to rob the citizens of their rights and wealth, they're ruled by religious shia maniacs who want to bring about Armageddon and can t wait, iran leaders literally are shia Taliban. it's not about defending themselves, they believe they have an islamic prophecy to fulfil
Studio Retake did you watch the video. They are allowed 3.7 it takes 20.0 for medical purposes. People who just comment their feelings instead of facts really grinds my gears
If you understood the fact that iran is a terrorist state. And how they fund terrorrist organizations and constantly call death to america, you would understand why people are tough on em
Corey Weil When a media organisation makes international relations look simple, that means you're probably being told half the story. To be honest, in this case I agree with Vox that this is a good deal, but they didn't mention the expiry date, at which point they will have none of the nuclear restrictions and all of the economic benefits.
Michael Jones i think its a concern that just *LAST WEEK* the Iranian leader, Khamenei, just called the US "the great Satan" and that Iran only dealed with the US as a "means of infiltration and imposition of their wills" and he also said Israel will not exist in 25 years. He said this RECENTLY. As in LAST WEEK. Does this sound like somebody who America should doing any sort of business with, ever, particularly now by funding them? (there are other types of war strikes besides nuclear, you know. And now they'll have the money to do what they want)
A country WITHOUT nuclear weapons is a country that will be attacked if they don't bow down to those who have nuclear weapons (America, Israel etc)!!. So Iran and all other (independent) countries have the rights to build nuclear weapons but I wished nuclear bombs were never invented you have to look at this problem from it's cause!!!
They have nuclear weapons but don't use them. And they don't publicly declare they want to wipe out Iran off the map unlike what the Ayatollah says about Israel over Twitter.
AceProductions828 Israel have threatened to attack Iran previously so warrants an open inspection in my opinion of what they have for the world to see just like others. My point is it is a double standard that shows lack of ethics.
+Samantha W They live in the most heated part of the world and have been constantly threatened with extinction or at the least attack. These are people which people throughout history hate (for whatever reason). And yet they could take out Iran and their enemies with a push of a button but they won't do it. If Iran had the capability they'd do it, they even publicly declared they would. And don't say they wouldn't do it if they had the chance because Hitler openly said anti-Semitic related things and getting pay back for the treaty of Versailles and he went through with it. Israel has elections and freedom to worship despite getting attacked from those who kill in the "Allah". We can trust them unlike Iran. And please if you deleted my other comment, I'm not accusing you of doing it, don't delete this one. For some reason my other comment isn't showing up so I'm not accusing you.
Mustafa Iraq My apologies for my racist outburst earlier - it's just that it frustrates me when I witness the world's undying bigotry towards my people. There is no such thing as a "Zionist," Zionism is a nationalist ideology in which Jewish people get an established country since we've always been mistreated under the rule of a leader who's of a different religion. It's no different than any other sort of nationalism, I'm sure if you ask a Kurdish nationalist and a Jewish nationalist their opinions about their people they will tell you the same things - they've been mistreated and they must be independent. And also, it's human nature to be "materialistic" if you live in the modern world, it's the values most people are raised with nowadays since there's such an abundance of resources for the world to share, so your point doesn't really make much sense since almost any political or social movement will have materialistic people.
+Mhov77 Iran, and other Arabic nations, have also been under constant persecution in the last century, first by colonialism, and then by the shady dealings of the Cold War. This is the basis that helped the disease of extremism spread throughout the nations.
OKAY. Let's get the REAL facts about this deal, and Iran straight! The 24 day notice: The 24 day notice only takes place IF and only IF the IAEA wants to inspect somewhere else other than all the known nuclear sights of Iran. And no, it does not take 24 days, it take UP to 24 days- so they (IAEA) can inspect in the 24 days. If the 24 days are reached, the vote goes to the UN panel- where all the countries on this deal will vote whether or not we can inspect Iranian soil- and then inspection will happen. OTHERWISE, for all the KNOWN nuclear sights, the IAEA can inspect at anytime, and they will because there is a 24/7 monitoring service that is set up. What? Did you expect that the UN could just waltz in to any country and inspect? No there is a formal process. In fact, many of you don't realize because you listen to liberal/conservative biased media, but 24 days is REMARKABLY fast. It usually takes MONTHS to set up inspections as such. Cleaning up nuclear weapons, and even moving them (which is what everyone is afraid of) takes quite awhile- even months if you want to be close to exact. Also, it is nearly impossible, even with all the money Iran has, for them to get/build a bomb with the low level of enriched uranium, and the lack of centrifuges/sights they will have. The arms embargo continues to be in place, so they cannot receive major weapons. The oil embargo on the US will be lifted so, 2$ gas for us! NOW TO IRAN AS A COUNTRY: Why do they shout death to America/Israel? Well, for starters. We shot down a passenger airplane (Iran Air 655) - killing hundreds of people and affecting hundreds of families (sounds like 9/11 a lot). We took over their government in 1958 and put our own leader in (the shah) which eventually led to the 1979 revolution- nearly tore apart the country. The US and Iraq lied about chemical weapons that led to a terrible, decade-long war for Iran.Those are a few reasons why the relations with Iran are uneasy. So basically, we walked into their home and caused a bunch of unnecessary shit during the US imperial regime. Also, Iran supports any people whom are oppressed by their goverment. JUST AS THE UNITED STATES DOES EXCEPT THE UNITED STATES IS ALLIED WITH COUNTRIES LIKE SAUDI ARABIA- WHICH BEHEADS ITS PEOPLE UNDER LAWS SIMILAR TO THOSE OF ISIS'S! The Iranian goverment supports oppressed people in countries in Lebanon, Yemen, Saudi countries, etc.- and if you didn't know, those countries are so oppressive on many of its Shiite and Sunni people; many are executed under laws that ISIS abides by as i said earlier. IRAN OPPOSES THAT. So the 'rebels' Iran is supporting such as Hezbollah (which have seats in diplomatic relations with other countries), Hammas (which fight for the land that was stolen from them, and yes their is christians and jews in Palestine), and the yemeni rebels are fighting because they are oppressed by their governments. They support the destruction of the Israeli goverment because Israel unfairly took the Palestinian land that they say was given to them by their imaginary god. So the reason that they say death to America and Israel, is because they do not support the GOVERNMENTS, not the people, but the GOVERNMENTS because the United States/Israel openly supports the destruction of the oppressed people. If you don't believe me, just look in the comments below! Many want the destruction of Iran. Iran is a country who has NOT declared in over 200 years, has had nuclear power for decades, and has not touched the US in years, and we all the sudden want to kill them? Seems like another fake trilogy of wars to me.
Good job on not being hysterical and actually taking a reasonable approach to it. I swear this middle school level of thinking of "good" guys vs "bad" guys is poisonous to our existence.
TwZGaming As an Iranian, I thank you so much for this comment. I feel like a lot of Western people feel the need to hate on Iran because of what the media feeds them and not based on any truth. We are NOT terrorists, as I always say to people, if Iran wanted to use it's nuclear power for evil, we would've done it by now. Iran is full of intellectuals and science is a very prominent field, I can be sure that it is used for research and such. Adding to your point about the Shah and the revolution, the US and Britain were seeing that the Shah was becoming increasingly powerful and could eventually be the most powerful man on earth, which is one of the reasons they sparked this revolution (this is a pretty general statement because Iranian politics are super complicated). People cannot even begin to understand what the US has done to us, on a personal level, I can tell you. The same passenger plane that was shot down that you mentioned - one of my fathers friends was on board. The Iran-Iraq war that was supported by the US took away my parents' teenage years, the war literally started when my mom was 11, and ended when she was 19. Schools were shut down, bombs were raining down on the streets (even major cities like Tehran). It is very hurtful that we are called the terrorists when we have had our fair share of terrorism upon us.
There is only one issue I have with what you have said here, and that is the following, quote: "...Israel unfairly took the Palestinian land that they say was given to them by *their imaginary god*..." Their "imaginary god" is the same one christians and muslims pray to, the god of Abraham. They are all barking up the same tree, but just from different angels (read interpretations of that deity's message). These three religions, judaism, christianity and islam are called the abrahamic faiths, because they each claim Abraham to be their patriarch/ancestor.
***** he is a fear mongerer, who would rather go to war than use diplomacy cause, apparently to him, if Israel doesn't get everything it wants then its a 'tragedy'.
Big brothers not gonna draw blood now on the Iranian people :'( lmfao There wasn't even a bomb in the first place either. Just a fight to maintain the petrodollar. Hah. Suck it you fucking warmongering Netanyahuuing bitchboy LOL
To sum this video up: The US (along with other countries) pays Iran to not hold the world hostage with nukes and in return they don't pay a dime. Almost as if their economy relies on the deal because of a leader neglecting to fix the economy. "The Americans will take their dream of visiting our military and sensitive sites to their graves… It will never happen,” Ali Akbar Velayati, a top adviser to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran’s highest authority, said in 2017 (Now if he had thorough inspections done by the US and nothing to hide why is he saying that?)
WUB tile so I’m a little bit confused as of right now with all the news and stuff ....can you explain how the situation has changed right now...it doesn’t look good
Chanting death and actually bringing death is different! How many Americans has Iran killed? How many Iranian military personnel are surrounding America? And then see how many bombs has American dropped in the mid east! How many American bases are surrounding Iran. Now tell me who's actually bringing death to whome
Ratty Ofcourse sanctions can work, it depends what you mean with "work". Just like embargoes usually do work. A modern society is especially vulnerable to such measures . There are many historic examples of this. Iran is a powerful country with a lot of potential and smart people, I am sure they can live quite happily without some bomb that is quite useless anyways. A nuclear weapon is of no use whatsoever if you think about the lives of ordinary people. It is a weapon for deterrence, and Iran has proven to be quite capable of deterring and defending its territorial integrity without any nuke. That is why they chose to go for this deal.
Ratty US begged us to negotiate :) Yes , it really worked! By sanctions Iran makes their own nuclear power , different type of missiles , satellite etc and made US beg Iran to negotiate. Thank you so much for helping us improving :)
Are you governor? I said US but I mean US government not people. AND if they didn't beg , why they didn't leave negotiations? They threatened to leave several times :) You American just can insult , you're not gentle , non of you , you just pretend to be gentle :)
XZDrake Iran leaved? Desert? wow! Really? what a wasting time talk to a TV watcher. so I'm done with you. Lol Rofl Baby? Really? So how Hamas protect it's civilians against racists? And how Iraq defend it's people against mercenaries?
once the sanction is lifted, Iran's is economically connected to the world, and their people are enjoying the benefit of that, how willing do you think they are to risk losing all that and a war with US just for a stupid bomb?
The government they live under is not representative of the people, it is an evil regime that is the largest nation to fund international Islamic terrorist, all this money we give them will go into the pockets of Isis, al Qaeda, and the like to complete a mass genocide against Jews, non traditional Muslims, Christians, people of secular views, people of western culture, but please continue to live in your world where evil doesn't exist, wish i was there
+Harry Potter Yes, the Iranian government is going to continue to fund terrorism as a new generation of Iranians that like to drink coke, listen to pop music, and show some skin is coming forward. Iran will go through change whether they like it or not as this new generation of youth are embracing western culture.
+windingpath Yes, their government would do it. They are fanatical and if they kill Americans and destroy Israel......God will be pleased with them. They would die for this cause.
People who claim to dislike the deal usually don't really care so much about the actual deal, it's the lifting of sanctions instead of bombing Iran they really dislike...
PixyDst500 Iran has not been given any money, what they have received is money that used to be theirs before it was "frozen". If you want Iran to build nuclear bombs, your way is probably the best: Steal their money, isolate them from the outside world, make any nuclear deal impossible by making impossible demands, make constant threats to bomb them "until the sand is glowing". Lots of right wing extremists don't want to make any deals with Iran. They think a deal makes the US look weak and they want Iran to remain this supervillain who they can use to scare people with. If that comes at the cost of Iran getting nukes, I think that is a price lots of crazy right wingers are willing to pay. I live on this planet, and I would prefer it if Iran don't get nukes.
PixyDst500 The thing about nukes is, there is no point in spending money on them if you can't tell anyone that you have them. The opposite is more common, N Korea says they have nukes but experts are sceptical since there is very little evidence supporting that claim. Israel will never go to war against Iran without consent from the US. There is hope of Iran changing and becoming more democratic and less of a terrorstate in the next 10 years, and that could not happen without this deal.
@@BarryAllen-ow2px it would be suicidal to all of us because if Iran and US start exchanging nukes chances are Russia and China will join the nuke party and every one would run MAD! (Mutual Assured Destruction)
Iran can easily develop nuclear weapons.. I don't see why not? Israel has like 300 nuclear heads. There should be a balance of power in the Middle East.
@@AR-jm8ce India and Pakistan had 3 major wars before the development of Nukes. Not a single major war has been fought after developing nukes. Thus, the only way to end all the invasions and violence is by the development of Nukes. Lastly, the US killed a half a million people in Japan and it's the only country to ever use nuclear weapons.
Kelly DeWitt thats debateable, because the big bullies fucked it up more than the 33 official times (broken arrow) while they were trying to ''handle'' their toys. its only NOW that they have enough experience (thats also debatable cause they dont fully understand those toys as much as they want to believe) to handle the toys with wisdom. the weaker kids in the playground are only trying to ''survive the day'' and have some fun without someone taunting them, beating them up, controling them ALL the time. the weaker kids can now have the established knowledge of what NOT to do wrong in order to handle their toys with safety. They can also have the high tech equipment to do that even more efficiently. Moreover handling and using a toy is so much different. A weaker kid can have the same toy as the big bully has in order to protect himself. its a ''war of impressions''. they are only trying to make it clear : ''leave us alone or you know what happens''.
Trump lied about that. It is actually 1.5 billion, although some say it is 33 billion. That's far from 150 though. If america went to war with them, US would lose a few trillions of dollars as well possibly indirectly creating the Islamic state of Iran
No. 1.5 billion dollars/16.77 trillion dollars of US GDP is 0.009% of our GDP, nowhere near enough to make them a superpower in the middle east. Even if Donald Trump was not lying, 150 billion/16.77 trillion is still just .9% of our GDP. We could make that in three days.
The 'experts' that made sure North Korea doesn't get Nuclear weapons now tell us Iran won't get nuclear weapons with this deal. Oops, North Korea does have Nuclear weapons
I love how Vox failed to mention that Iran can say no to inspectors. They have consistently failed to mention this EVERY single time they do an article on the topic. Awful journalism.
This deal sounds great! It is great. The last deal was great as well. What everyone is up in arms about is the enforcement. This deal has terrible inspection terms (e.g. the length of time of giving notice, and the sites that can be inspected) and enforcement terms (e.g. the time given to come into compliance when a violation is observed, and what actions we can take when there is non-compliance). That is THE critical part of the deal, and this deal has no muscle in that area. Also, sanctions were working. The reason this got done was because no one in global politics at the time would stand up to Iran when they threatened war. Yet war is always a last resort possibility, and we have to be prepared to use that tool, IF necessary. Turns out, only Iran was, so they got what they wanted.
Plato The video should explain the controversy surrounding the deal. Instead, it only explains the liberal argument for the deal and fails to talk the Republican argument against it, don't you think the video should present both sides of the argument and let viewers decide if the deal was worth it?
Isn't amazing how much this could of brought some peace in the Middle East. One of the main reasons Iran builds nuclear technology is simply because they fell they're trapped in a corner by the US and the Saudi's. A better chance at good relations with the west could of lead to better relations with the Saudi's.
The Iran deal looks fairly well constructed to me. Can someone pls tell me why president Trump calls it a mistake? What are those accusations based on?
The fact the billions of us dollars given to IRAN are being spent on nuclear weapons does not bother you? Can someone pls explain why liberals are so fricken stupid?
Billions of dollars were given to Iran. A place of which believed in “death to America and Israel”. Republicans do not hate obama for trying to make peace, but some of them did not like the fact that he handed money over to a nation that has been known to have terrorist groups within.
Iran funds terrorism they only have a few allies and one is North Korea The inspections were a load of crap Iran’s did the inspections And the money we gave them
Beau Biker well, why do the u.s. even bother sending nuclear inspectors then? Sending u.n. nuclear inspectors was part of the deal. To me this was the original plan to withdraw the u.s. just used the deal for espionage purposes. Simple as that!
trump had no problem with the restrictions imposed against iran in the deal, his argument was that, the deal did not warrant such relaxations of sanctions against iran. It's also a case of relative gains by the USA as they seem to get relative gains. They always try to get the best out of the deal
you completely forgot to mention that not all sanctions are related to Iran's nuclear programme. There are still numerous sanctions in place that are making life very hard for foreign & Iranian businesses
So America probably has nuclear weapons but iran shouldn’t be allowed to have them when they’re the one surrounded by enemies and in the heart of the Middle East surrounded by terrorists? I think 🤔 💭 that’s quite unfair. Tbh the US is stupid to accuse Iran for possibly bombing a country whilst their biggest desire to be part in the economy again. That just would not make sense in any way...
So removing the possibilities of developing nuclear weapons in exchange for a global market? This deal doesn't sound bad for the Iranians at all. Many countries that are doing better compared to Iran does not have nuclear weapons. For folks around the world they get a good assurance of no nuclear weapons launching from the middle east in the next few decades that might strike Europe and Asia, or nuclear weapons sold or smuggled to terrorists. The deal sounds pretty good to everyone. (PROVIDED no one cheats on this deal)
+Yeah,i guess so I guess you have not followed the News over the last 10 years ? Well, just utube Iran, and see what their government thinks of Americans and Israel and how they want to destroy both.
RevolutionaryMike Tf r u talking about? The left controls the media in the US so if something like how the black community is at its lowest unemployment rate under Trump and all these raises given to employees under Trump are covered up. You don't hear about it too much
The problem is that this deal has a ten year expiry date. After which they are allowed to make as many nuclear warheads as they please. The #1 problem for Iran has been how to deliver these warheads to your doorstep. Sanctions made that very difficult A warhead is pretty useless if you dont have a delivery system (the rocket part of the ICBM) This deal asks them to give up most of their useless warhead material...and in exchange they can now work on their delivery systems...with the money they now have with sanctions gone. And after 10 years, they can make new warheads....and put them in their new delivery systems...now they have a way to deliver Mr. Warhead to your doorstep...yay!!!
UDon'tNeedTo Know lmao that was all the after affects of Obama’s stimulus package trump didn’t even pass any type of tax reform when that happened he was only 3 months in. Have you been watching fox and fell for their propaganda? Most people can see through it even foreigners laugh at Fox
Awesome video Vox ! I've re-posted this article on facebook with the following comment: Thomas Jefferson summed up his foreign policy position perfectly in his 1801 inaugural address: "Peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations - entangling alliances with none." How many times have we all heard these wise words without taking them to heart? The Israelis may not like this Administrations policy with Iran but last time I checked - Israel was not part of our Union. And even though I disagree with this administration on many issues - this deal is not one of them.
Cutting through the noise is a great service however, if you also cut through the factual implications of the story, the value of your service diminishes. Major problems with this 'deal': - limitations on inspections (sound familiar) - relief from conventional arms acquisition - allowance of ballistic missile development/acquisition
Ed Stevens Did you mean to say "No, inspection standars established as part of the failed negotiation" Or did you mean to say No inspection standards [were] established as part of the failed negotiation.
If US pulled out of the deal why Iran should respect it? Now they are forced to build until they are taken serious like North Korea. This is mad politics.
I like the content that Vox puts out, but I remember watching Vice cover this issue more objectively. I felt much differently about the Iran deal than I do from watching this video. That's the problem with the ONLY watching news coverage from a network that skews a certain way.
It wasn't and Iran continued to fund and arm terrorist groups Hezbollah and Hamas during it.Last week they announced that they are enriching their uranium again
May GOD bless you and may his HOLY SPIRIT guide you all in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. John 3:16, 1 Thessalonians 5:3, Revelation 22:20.
Kitty The reports and interviews I've seen with Iranians in Iran does not point towards any kind of suffering though. My point was that it's wrong to just assume people are suffering because their country is a bit isolated from the rest of the world (or doesn't have a "real economy", whatever that means). It does not mean they can't be well and happy.
Hey, I used to live in Iran. Although I was 10 when I moved to Canada and now 14, I would like to say that all these theories about Iran are not necessarily true. As you two were arguing, I would like to say that we do not suffer what so ever. Although most accusations are false, the government is pretty bad. This is not the point but the climate and the air is also pretty bad but when I used to live back in Iran and visit every year or two, it is still a beautiful country and no one in my family that I know is currently suffering in Iran.
Nuclear deal works - for Iranian Nuclear program. Israel will eventually have to demolish Iranian Nuclear site - same we did to Iraqi Nuclear site in 83' and to Syrian nuclear site in 2007'. We got condemned by the 'experts'. Same 'experts' that say that the Iranian Nuclear deal is good.
2015: Peace at last
2020: That escalated quickly
Iran didn't let me in
They were paid for it
Theres never peace in the middleeast
PEACE, PROSPERITY AND GOOD HEALTH IN EVERY NATION IN THE WORLD
IS ANYONE HERE AFTER TRUMPS HISTORIC MIDDLE EAST PEACE DEALS? AND HE DIDNT HAVE TO DELIVER 1 BILLION IN CASHIKE OBAMA
Who's here after they abandoned the nuclear deal?
Tach aye
Lol
Right here ✋
So let me get this straight. It would still take them a long time to reach the weapons-level uranium right?
Heyyyy
aaaaand it's gone
Fabian Putting was looking for this comment
Yay
Fabian Putting I don't understand why Iran did a deal with the U.S. Never ever trust a 🐍. Those gringos never keep there word, not ones to be trusted. Something a little off topic is... Now you can clearly see why the U.S. runs on a 2 party system. The DemoRats come in and play the nice cop in order to get deals done with there "enemies" then the RepubliCants come in and play the bad cop to get what they want out of every deal done.
Fabian Putting south park!!!!!😄😄😄😄😄😄
@@dalegribble5661 We need them to withdraw from nuke production permanently.
This aged well
itschrisguy RIP
Really? Do you think sending the Iranians 2 billion in cash to fund nuclear operations to the country that claims will be responsible dort wiping Israel and the US of the face of the planet?
The Teflon Don sarcasm you tryhard
@@theTeflonDon1 Not to necro an old thread, but you do realize that the 2 billion was unfrozen Iranian assets that already belonged to them, and were unfrozen as part of the liberation of sanctions, and if they don't have nukes it's pretty difficult to wage war against any nation that is armed with nukes (Like Israel and the US?)
@@itschrisguy I was on a diatribe on this page because of support I saw for the video. In hindsight it was obvious you were being sarcastic, didnt notice. See ya
"Pretty much 100% chance of noticing if they cheat, that's how good they are." Made me lol.
So basically now if an Iranian soldier makes a 25 killstreak then he can get a tactical nuke
Tactical nuke is a 25 killstreak 😬
It’s 30 actually
We don't have guns
@@mranderson2215 i was just making a live adaptation of the streak but ill fix it lol
We live in a day and age where countries that have stockpiles with hundreds of thousands of nukes tell other countries what they can or cannot do with their nuclear programs.
It was always like this throughout the whole history. Strong tells the weak what to do or get beaten instead.
It has always been like this. Might makes right in international affairs
Iran constantly threathens to annihilate the US, that's the asymmetry.
"Great inspections, Terrific Inspections, best inspections in the world" thats what the inspection part sounded like it didnt give me any information about them in general
It didn't give any information in general on specifically, LoL.
True they didn't explain it at all. If you are wondering, the IAEA will inspect them, in a process called Safeguards
Baker Harrington But at the same time, at another of their videos about "Iran, USA and Israel" they let you think that the nuclear deal is inadequate, and that Iran could make another nuke whenever it pleased. Vox has always been a very confusing and self-contradicting channel, and one shouldn't trust it too much.
also they can postpone an IAEA inspection for as long as 24 days, so plenty of time to hide what they don't want seen. also no inspecting of military sites...
I know. haha, these inspectors are boneheads. Anyone stating there's a 100% chance they get caught if they break the rules is a jackass. The UN inspectors in Syria got lost in Damascus when they were checking for Sarin gas.
are you here after the Iranian nuclear scientist assassinated?
Vox forgot to mention that Iran gets to inspect themselves
Naf70 here's some info around that www.vox.com/2015/8/20/9182185/ap-iran-inspections-parchin
Naf70 The IAEA will be inspecting them.
+Vox do you really trust the Iran government to do right by its people and its word as they have proven time and time in the past and present that they will continue its war on civil rights, continue to fund international Islamic terrorism, and continue its war on Israel, Iraq, and Afghanistan? If so please explain why and how you can put your faith in such a despicably evil regime?
Harry Potter Iran isn't inspecting themselves the IAEA is inspecting them.
Naf70
... except that you are either a liar or a dupe.
mediamatters.org/research/2015/08/20/conservative-media-run-with-flawed-ap-report-to/205073
Think of this in civ v terms guys...
Iran gets embargo lifted, Iran starts making caravans and cargo ships, Iran has ideology of theocracy, Iran generates 30 unhappiness because they adopted the wrong ideology (theocracy), Iran adopts new ideology (freedom).
Weekend Gaming lol
Unfortunately this isn't civ 5 and its highly unlikely that they will reject theocracy especially after the theocratic state can now use propaganda to strengthen its hold on their society by saying they saved Iran.
"Wrong ideology," is that why Iran has a higher standard of education and a better life expectancy under this theocracy? Keep your entitled bullshit to yourself.
***** Woah come down. In civ v, the "wrong ideology" is just the ideology that no one else has in BNW, becuase world congress gets on you to switch, and your happiness goes down. It is just a joke pal. Making light of a serious issue sometimes help people understand it a bit better. (like me).
The Iranian people are not the problem. The Iranian regime is the problem.
In vacuum-cleaner salesman voice: "Oh and the inspections, well, you came to the right place. These inspections are like none you've ever seen . . . "
“You just made a deal without a negotiation”
-Alfie Solomons
Peaky blinders season 4
This video makes more sense now then ever
Hey josh if you were a cow then you would be a cool cow
Eddie W Yeah😂
radioactive cow
Welp it’s over now...
Trump?
It’s back now
so, How about israel nuclear?
Israel doesn't have any nuclear weapons because it's not allowed to and btw if they secretly have nuclear weapons on who and where are they gonna use it to, if the world finds out Israel had a nuclear bomb and used it everyone would flip out, there not idiots to fire a nuclear bomb just think for a second what could happen and Israel is not stupid
+Fkkfkf Kdmdmf Bloody serious?
Juho Pitkäranta oh well yes I am blOOdy serious
That_llama_in_a_tuxedo i wrote my comment like 5 moths ago and yes you are right they do have nuclear weapons and yes they didnt sign the nuclear non proliferstion treaty but i doubt anyone would allow israel to use nuclear weapons nor israel is that stupid to use one since they know that could easily spark a nuclear war i think the only reason israel didnt sign the treaty is to scare off big countries like iran
Oh it's okay if white people that think like us have nukes...
There is nothing about what America gave for the deal, so this is only half the story.
USA didn't really give much if anything. If you mean the $150 billion, that money has always been Iran's. It is oil money and unfullfilled arms payments that USA never fullfilled when Iran started acting up by kidnapping people and threatening Israel.
Nuclear Proliferation, there's your answer. The RnD to go from a Fission Power Plant to a Fission Bomb can only take about as long as 20 years. More recent nuclear power plants either use different radioactive material or a safer system that makes it considerably more difficult to go from cleaner, cheaper, energy, to a weapon of mass destruction. Hell, North Korea figured it out by themselves, a country that's a huge part of the international economy, even easier.
Why do I get the feeling that Vox omitted a lot of parts?
its a 3 minute video, duh
I don't understand why Iran doesn't have the right to defend itself.
It does. Just not that way
Sammy Hannat in case you don't know, iran isn't ruled by normal dictators just seeking to rob the citizens of their rights and wealth, they're ruled by religious shia maniacs who want to bring about Armageddon and can t wait, iran leaders literally are shia Taliban.
it's not about defending themselves, they believe they have an islamic prophecy to fulfil
abdlla hash le "america protects freedom" meme.
Sean Iran has the right to have nuclear weapons.
so Iran isn't even allowed to make Nuclear Medicines ?
thats a tad too brutal even for America imo.
They're allowed medical grade tops
Studio Retake did you watch the video. They are allowed 3.7 it takes 20.0 for medical purposes. People who just comment their feelings instead of facts really grinds my gears
US for profit healthcare providers need desperately sick middle class Iranians to maintain profitability
If you understood the fact that iran is a terrorist state. And how they fund terrorrist organizations and constantly call death to america, you would understand why people are tough on em
Winistan Nothing is too brutal for the US O_o
I love how you make complicated ideas simple!
Corey Weil When a media organisation makes international relations look simple, that means you're probably being told half the story. To be honest, in this case I agree with Vox that this is a good deal, but they didn't mention the expiry date, at which point they will have none of the nuclear restrictions and all of the economic benefits.
Ronald Hanlon where did you learn English - at Arizona State?
lol this jew hasbara nasaqlicos sob pos ----^
Michael Jones i think its a concern that just *LAST WEEK* the Iranian leader, Khamenei, just called the US "the great Satan" and that Iran only dealed with the US as a "means of infiltration and imposition of their wills" and he also said Israel will not exist in 25 years.
He said this RECENTLY. As in LAST WEEK. Does this sound like somebody who America should doing any sort of business with, ever, particularly now by funding them?
(there are other types of war strikes besides nuclear, you know. And now they'll have the money to do what they want)
Yasss Virginia......it's called "propaganda".
"How the Iran Deal Doesnt Work"
Sounds good. I'm glad to hear these news.
How you feeling now sir?
A country WITHOUT nuclear weapons is a country that will be attacked if they don't bow down to those who have nuclear weapons (America, Israel etc)!!. So Iran and all other (independent) countries have the rights to build nuclear weapons but I wished nuclear bombs were never invented you have to look at this problem from it's cause!!!
exactly.....America are terrified of Iran having a way to defend itself from American invasion
+Mo You can thank Einstein.
Who gave America the right to say that they are allowed to have nukes and Iran cant
Inspect Israel.
They have nuclear weapons but don't use them. And they don't publicly declare they want to wipe out Iran off the map unlike what the Ayatollah says about Israel over Twitter.
AceProductions828 Israel have threatened to attack Iran previously so warrants an open inspection in my opinion of what they have for the world to see just like others. My point is it is a double standard that shows lack of ethics.
+Samantha W They live in the most heated part of the world and have been constantly threatened with extinction or at the least attack. These are people which people throughout history hate (for whatever reason). And yet they could take out Iran and their enemies with a push of a button but they won't do it. If Iran had the capability they'd do it, they even publicly declared they would. And don't say they wouldn't do it if they had the chance because Hitler openly said anti-Semitic related things and getting pay back for the treaty of Versailles and he went through with it. Israel has elections and freedom to worship despite getting attacked from those who kill in the "Allah". We can trust them unlike Iran. And please if you deleted my other comment, I'm not accusing you of doing it, don't delete this one. For some reason my other comment isn't showing up so I'm not accusing you.
Mustafa Iraq My apologies for my racist outburst earlier - it's just that it frustrates me when I witness the world's undying bigotry towards my people. There is no such thing as a "Zionist," Zionism is a nationalist ideology in which Jewish people get an established country since we've always been mistreated under the rule of a leader who's of a different religion. It's no different than any other sort of nationalism, I'm sure if you ask a Kurdish nationalist and a Jewish nationalist their opinions about their people they will tell you the same things - they've been mistreated and they must be independent. And also, it's human nature to be "materialistic" if you live in the modern world, it's the values most people are raised with nowadays since there's such an abundance of resources for the world to share, so your point doesn't really make much sense since almost any political or social movement will have materialistic people.
+Mhov77
Iran, and other Arabic nations, have also been under constant persecution in the last century, first by colonialism, and then by the shady dealings of the Cold War. This is the basis that helped the disease of extremism spread throughout the nations.
I am not sure what else Iran could give up? But some how the American Mia managed to shut down such a deal. It’s not about world peace… it never was
This is a great video! Really explains it in a simple way unlike in other sources.
PEACE, PROSPERITY AND GOOD HEALTH IN EVERY NATION IN THE WORLD
This is so intellectually dishonest.
How?
OKAY. Let's get the REAL facts about this deal, and Iran straight!
The 24 day notice: The 24 day notice only takes place IF and only IF the IAEA wants to inspect somewhere else other than all the known nuclear sights of Iran. And no, it does not take 24 days, it take UP to 24 days- so they (IAEA) can inspect in the 24 days. If the 24 days are reached, the vote goes to the UN panel- where all the countries on this deal will vote whether or not we can inspect Iranian soil- and then inspection will happen. OTHERWISE, for all the KNOWN nuclear sights, the IAEA can inspect at anytime, and they will because there is a 24/7 monitoring service that is set up. What? Did you expect that the UN could just waltz in to any country and inspect? No there is a formal process. In fact, many of you don't realize because you listen to liberal/conservative biased media, but 24 days is REMARKABLY fast. It usually takes MONTHS to set up inspections as such. Cleaning up nuclear weapons, and even moving them (which is what everyone is afraid of) takes quite awhile- even months if you want to be close to exact. Also, it is nearly impossible, even with all the money Iran has, for them to get/build a bomb with the low level of enriched uranium, and the lack of centrifuges/sights they will have. The arms embargo continues to be in place, so they cannot receive major weapons. The oil embargo on the US will be lifted so, 2$ gas for us!
NOW TO IRAN AS A COUNTRY:
Why do they shout death to America/Israel?
Well, for starters. We shot down a passenger airplane (Iran Air 655) - killing hundreds of people and affecting hundreds of families (sounds like 9/11 a lot). We took over their government in 1958 and put our own leader in (the shah) which eventually led to the 1979 revolution- nearly tore apart the country. The US and Iraq lied about chemical weapons that led to a terrible, decade-long war for Iran.Those are a few reasons why the relations with Iran are uneasy. So basically, we walked into their home and caused a bunch of unnecessary shit during the US imperial regime.
Also, Iran supports any people whom are oppressed by their goverment. JUST AS THE UNITED STATES DOES EXCEPT THE UNITED STATES IS ALLIED WITH COUNTRIES LIKE SAUDI ARABIA- WHICH BEHEADS ITS PEOPLE UNDER LAWS SIMILAR TO THOSE OF ISIS'S! The Iranian goverment supports oppressed people in countries in Lebanon, Yemen, Saudi countries, etc.- and if you didn't know, those countries are so oppressive on many of its Shiite and Sunni people; many are executed under laws that ISIS abides by as i said earlier. IRAN OPPOSES THAT. So the 'rebels' Iran is supporting such as Hezbollah (which have seats in diplomatic relations with other countries), Hammas (which fight for the land that was stolen from them, and yes their is christians and jews in Palestine), and the yemeni rebels are fighting because they are oppressed by their governments. They support the destruction of the Israeli goverment because Israel unfairly took the Palestinian land that they say was given to them by their imaginary god. So the reason that they say death to America and Israel, is because they do not support the GOVERNMENTS, not the people, but the GOVERNMENTS because the United States/Israel openly supports the destruction of the oppressed people. If you don't believe me, just look in the comments below! Many want the destruction of Iran. Iran is a country who has NOT declared in over 200 years, has had nuclear power for decades, and has not touched the US in years, and we all the sudden want to kill them? Seems like another fake trilogy of wars to me.
Good job on not being hysterical and actually taking a reasonable approach to it. I swear this middle school level of thinking of "good" guys vs "bad" guys is poisonous to our existence.
TwZGaming As an Iranian, I thank you so much for this comment. I feel like a lot of Western people feel the need to hate on Iran because of what the media feeds them and not based on any truth. We are NOT terrorists, as I always say to people, if Iran wanted to use it's nuclear power for evil, we would've done it by now. Iran is full of intellectuals and science is a very prominent field, I can be sure that it is used for research and such.
Adding to your point about the Shah and the revolution, the US and Britain were seeing that the Shah was becoming increasingly powerful and could eventually be the most powerful man on earth, which is one of the reasons they sparked this revolution (this is a pretty general statement because Iranian politics are super complicated).
People cannot even begin to understand what the US has done to us, on a personal level, I can tell you. The same passenger plane that was shot down that you mentioned - one of my fathers friends was on board. The Iran-Iraq war that was supported by the US took away my parents' teenage years, the war literally started when my mom was 11, and ended when she was 19. Schools were shut down, bombs were raining down on the streets (even major cities like Tehran). It is very hurtful that we are called the terrorists when we have had our fair share of terrorism upon us.
There are no Jews in the Palestinian territories, lol
There is only one issue I have with what you have said here, and that is the following, quote: "...Israel unfairly took the Palestinian land that they say was given to them by *their imaginary god*..."
Their "imaginary god" is the same one christians and muslims pray to, the god of Abraham. They are all barking up the same tree, but just from different angels (read interpretations of that deity's message). These three religions, judaism, christianity and islam are called the abrahamic faiths, because they each claim Abraham to be their patriarch/ancestor.
There are: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_Jews
1:36 That's Iraq, not Iran. The man in picture is Ayatollah Sistani, not Komanei. Completely different things.
Potato potatoe same thing
lol Netanyahu is raging.
Perceptive Minds he keeps trying to lie about what it does, hes such a fear mongerer
***** he is a fear mongerer, who would rather go to war than use diplomacy cause, apparently to him, if Israel doesn't get everything it wants then its a 'tragedy'.
Big brothers not gonna draw blood now on the Iranian people :'( lmfao
There wasn't even a bomb in the first place either. Just a fight to maintain the petrodollar. Hah. Suck it you fucking warmongering Netanyahuuing bitchboy LOL
***** its not like neytanyahu is a war criminal and his hands are covered in blood
***** not to mention theres no bomb and there wont be one, so yes he is a fear mongering by saying that this is a Fatal threat to israel"
To sum this video up: The US (along with other countries) pays Iran to not hold the world hostage with nukes and in return they don't pay a dime.
Almost as if their economy relies on the deal because of a leader neglecting to fix the economy.
"The Americans will take their dream of visiting our military and sensitive sites to their graves… It will never happen,” Ali Akbar Velayati, a top adviser to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran’s highest authority, said in 2017
(Now if he had thorough inspections done by the US and nothing to hide why is he saying that?)
WUB tile so I’m a little bit confused as of right now with all the news and stuff ....can you explain how the situation has changed right now...it doesn’t look good
Iranians don't want war either.. it's the government. Most Iranians just want to live peaceful lives
@@yougetagoldstar America isn't. But the US literally called Iran, North Korea, and Iraq the three devil states/axis of evil a decade ago.
Chanting death and actually bringing death is different! How many Americans has Iran killed? How many Iranian military personnel are surrounding America? And then see how many bombs has American dropped in the mid east! How many American bases are surrounding Iran. Now tell me who's actually bringing death to whome
So why they keep choosing those leaders?
so I’m a bit confused.. so they abandoned the deal.. does this mean that they can now make nuclear weapons?
Ilona Losey basically
Yup.
And they are gonna sign a deal with Russia to buy some
Yes
& now it’s been suspended 🙃
This is great news, but one tragic part about it now politicians can say "You see? Sanctions can work!".
Ratty and what would you propose as a better alternative? Mutually assured destruction?
Ratty
Ofcourse sanctions can work, it depends what you mean with "work". Just like embargoes usually do work.
A modern society is especially vulnerable to such measures . There are many historic examples of this.
Iran is a powerful country with a lot of potential and smart people, I am sure they can live quite happily without some bomb that is quite useless anyways. A nuclear weapon is of no use whatsoever if you think about the lives of ordinary people. It is a weapon for deterrence, and Iran has proven to be quite capable of deterring and defending its territorial integrity without any nuke.
That is why they chose to go for this deal.
Ratty US begged us to negotiate :) Yes , it really worked! By sanctions Iran makes their own nuclear power , different type of missiles , satellite etc and made US beg Iran to negotiate. Thank you so much for helping us improving :)
Are you governor? I said US but I mean US government not people. AND if they didn't beg , why they didn't leave negotiations? They threatened to leave several times :) You American just can insult , you're not gentle , non of you , you just pretend to be gentle :)
XZDrake Iran leaved? Desert? wow! Really? what a wasting time talk to a TV watcher. so I'm done with you. Lol Rofl Baby? Really? So how Hamas protect it's civilians against racists? And how Iraq defend it's people against mercenaries?
once the sanction is lifted, Iran's is economically connected to the world, and their people are enjoying the benefit of that, how willing do you think they are to risk losing all that and a war with US just for a stupid bomb?
The government they live under is not representative of the people, it is an evil regime that is the largest nation to fund international Islamic terrorist, all this money we give them will go into the pockets of Isis, al Qaeda, and the like to complete a mass genocide against Jews, non traditional Muslims, Christians, people of secular views, people of western culture, but please continue to live in your world where evil doesn't exist, wish i was there
+Harry Potter Yes, the Iranian government is going to continue to fund terrorism as a new generation of Iranians that like to drink coke, listen to pop music, and show some skin is coming forward. Iran will go through change whether they like it or not as this new generation of youth are embracing western culture.
+windingpath Yes, their government would do it. They are fanatical and if they kill Americans and destroy Israel......God will be pleased with them. They would die for this cause.
+tlorenz1100 coke with 50g of Posion surgar and shitty PPP music like Nikki Minaj and taller swift
+Harry Potter What makes you think jews are better than the World ?! Jews jews jews israel... who the hell you think you are?!
Please show this to all the crazy conservatives that think that Iran has been give a pass.
You should make a video going more into depth about how the inspections are going to occur
People who claim to dislike the deal usually don't really care so much about the actual deal, it's the lifting of sanctions instead of bombing Iran they really dislike...
PixyDst500 Iran has not been given any money, what they have received is money that used to be theirs before it was "frozen".
If you want Iran to build nuclear bombs, your way is probably the best: Steal their money, isolate them from the outside world, make any nuclear deal impossible by making impossible demands, make constant threats to bomb them "until the sand is glowing".
Lots of right wing extremists don't want to make any deals with Iran. They think a deal makes the US look weak and they want Iran to remain this supervillain who they can use to scare people with. If that comes at the cost of Iran getting nukes, I think that is a price lots of crazy right wingers are willing to pay.
I live on this planet, and I would prefer it if Iran don't get nukes.
PixyDst500 The thing about nukes is, there is no point in spending money on them if you can't tell anyone that you have them. The opposite is more common, N Korea says they have nukes but experts are sceptical since there is very little evidence supporting that claim.
Israel will never go to war against Iran without consent from the US. There is hope of Iran changing and becoming more democratic and less of a terrorstate in the next 10 years, and that could not happen without this deal.
+PixyDst if they get one....it would be suicidal for Iran to use a nuclear weapon.. even the dumbest animals can see this.
@@BarryAllen-ow2px it would be suicidal to all of us because if Iran and US start exchanging nukes chances are Russia and China will join the nuke party and every one would run MAD! (Mutual Assured Destruction)
Most adolescent argument I've ever heard. It's like having a 5 year old argue with me
I just want the world to be happy and live in peace.
Iran can easily develop nuclear weapons.. I don't see why not? Israel has like 300 nuclear heads. There should be a balance of power in the Middle East.
never give muslims nuclear weapons. see the situation of pakistan and then think.
@@AR-jm8ce India and Pakistan had 3 major wars before the development of Nukes. Not a single major war has been fought after developing nukes. Thus, the only way to end all the invasions and violence is by the development of Nukes. Lastly, the US killed a half a million people in Japan and it's the only country to ever use nuclear weapons.
so basically its another situation, where the big bullies forbid to other kids to have the same toys as them?
+PsychosGamers Basically, but the "big bullies" in this case are overall in better shape to handle the "toys" than the other kids
Kelly DeWitt
thats debateable, because the big bullies fucked it up more than the 33 official times (broken arrow) while they were trying to ''handle'' their toys. its only NOW that they have enough experience (thats also debatable cause they dont fully understand those toys as much as they want to believe) to handle the toys with wisdom.
the weaker kids in the playground are only trying to ''survive the day'' and have some fun without someone taunting them, beating them up, controling them ALL the time. the weaker kids can now have the established knowledge of what NOT to do wrong in order to handle their toys with safety. They can also have the high tech equipment to do that even more efficiently.
Moreover handling and using a toy is so much different. A weaker kid can have the same toy as the big bully has in order to protect himself. its a ''war of impressions''. they are only trying to make it clear : ''leave us alone or you know what happens''.
Well when the toys have the power to end the world in nuclear fire it makes sense that we don't want them to get those toys
Whos here after iran said they are pulling out the nuclear deal?
This aged well 😅
You forgot to mention the 150 billion dollars in cash...
Trump lied about that. It is actually 1.5 billion, although some say it is 33 billion. That's far from 150 though. If america went to war with them, US would lose a few trillions of dollars as well possibly indirectly creating the Islamic state of Iran
Oh daaaaaamn!!! My bad, so we literally made them a superpower in the middle east?
No. 1.5 billion dollars/16.77 trillion dollars of US GDP is 0.009% of our GDP, nowhere near enough to make them a superpower in the middle east. Even if Donald Trump was not lying, 150 billion/16.77 trillion is still just .9% of our GDP. We could make that in three days.
Capitaine 1.5 billion is not enough
That's just in CASH, but once the sanctions will be removed, they'll have a lot of $$$ coming their way!
1:36 is Iraq not Iran. Vox fails again
this is my first time checking out a video from vox, and will most definitely be the last
i hope iran the best in the future
-indonesians brothers and sisters
I have a serious question!!!
How TH-cam Recommendation works????????? ? ?
It knows what you like
Does that means trump wants Iran to make nukes?
The 'experts' that made sure North Korea doesn't get Nuclear weapons now tell us Iran won't get nuclear weapons with this deal.
Oops, North Korea does have Nuclear weapons
This guy sounds like he’s reading off a paper someone else wrote but doesn’t want to be responsible for what he’s saying
I love how Vox failed to mention that Iran can say no to inspectors. They have consistently failed to mention this EVERY single time they do an article on the topic. Awful journalism.
+Jeff Simpson
*I love how Vox failed to mention that Iran can say no to inspectors.*
-That's blatantly false.
THIS MAN I AM SURE STILL BELIEVES IN SANTA CLAUS
Please elaborate
lmfao
sadly i think the man child was referring to himself
This deal sounds great! It is great. The last deal was great as well. What everyone is up in arms about is the enforcement. This deal has terrible inspection terms (e.g. the length of time of giving notice, and the sites that can be inspected) and enforcement terms (e.g. the time given to come into compliance when a violation is observed, and what actions we can take when there is non-compliance). That is THE critical part of the deal, and this deal has no muscle in that area. Also, sanctions were working. The reason this got done was because no one in global politics at the time would stand up to Iran when they threatened war. Yet war is always a last resort possibility, and we have to be prepared to use that tool, IF necessary. Turns out, only Iran was, so they got what they wanted.
Fantastic video. Subbed.
Hey I'm from the future the year is 2021 and Iran abandoned this deal
* The US abandoned
@@a1izasdq no its Iran. They signed it the same way Hitler signed the agreement not to invade Europe.
Jesus, this is so biased.
+Dan Chen How come? It's the truth their is no opinion made on the point only facts.
in what way
+Dan Chen I'd LOVE to hear how this is biased, please enlighten us.
Plato The video should explain the controversy surrounding the deal. Instead, it only explains the liberal argument for the deal and fails to talk the Republican argument against it, don't you think the video should present both sides of the argument and let viewers decide if the deal was worth it?
It clear things up, I support this deal. I just think Vox is too liberal. To the point where they are not sharing everything with the public
And now Trump will repeal the deal
NOW WE GO BACKWARD EVERYTHING WILL BE LIKE REAGAN H BUSH AND THE REAL WRECKERS CHENEY W BUSH EVERYTHING WILL SKYROCKET HURRRAY
And John Bolton will be whispering in his ear.
Sounds very much like the type of deal that the US made with Iraq back in the 90's, but that didn't really work out so well
And Iraq didn't get a nuke. So the deal itself did exactly what it was intended to.
+AlphaXGames We Pakistani sold them plans and I still hate some of my leaders for this.
Isn't amazing how much this could of brought some peace in the Middle East. One of the main reasons Iran builds nuclear technology is simply because they fell they're trapped in a corner by the US and the Saudi's. A better chance at good relations with the west could of lead to better relations with the Saudi's.
Check the latest updates coming from iran. A fire in iranian nuclear facility has derailed the nuclear program
This story failed to mention advance notification for inspections. Isn't that important?
Something tells me this is a pretty one-sided explanation of the nuclear deal.
The Iran deal looks fairly well constructed to me. Can someone pls tell me why president Trump calls it a mistake? What are those accusations based on?
The fact the billions of us dollars given to IRAN are being spent on nuclear weapons does not bother you? Can someone pls explain why liberals are so fricken stupid?
Billions of dollars were given to Iran. A place of which believed in “death to America and Israel”. Republicans do not hate obama for trying to make peace, but some of them did not like the fact that he handed money over to a nation that has been known to have terrorist groups within.
Iran funds terrorism they only have a few allies and one is North Korea
The inspections were a load of crap Iran’s did the inspections
And the money we gave them
Beau Biker well, why do the u.s. even bother sending nuclear inspectors then? Sending u.n. nuclear inspectors was part of the deal. To me this was the original plan to withdraw the u.s. just used the deal for espionage purposes. Simple as that!
trump had no problem with the restrictions imposed against iran in the deal, his argument was that, the deal did not warrant such relaxations of sanctions against iran. It's also a case of relative gains by the USA as they seem to get relative gains. They always try to get the best out of the deal
This is geared for un-informed zombies
you forgot the part where iran lied about abiding by that deal
you completely forgot to mention that not all sanctions are related to Iran's nuclear programme. There are still numerous sanctions in place that are making life very hard for foreign & Iranian businesses
This is incredibly nïave.
Did you even watch the video?
Did you even learn how to spell?
I dont deserve this silent treatment
Explain your thoughts, I'd like to hear them.
Obama thinks Iran is just gonna not make nukes. Yeah ok, like anyone respects him
You only mention the pros not the bad parts
Id rather war with zombies than war with other country
You ALSO forgot to mention that they have a 30 DAY NOTICE when they get inspected more than enough time to move product if they are making a bomb!
This video left a lot of important information out.
What
some one get iran to have a word with North Korea
How this is unfair to the US is beyond me.
So America probably has nuclear weapons but iran shouldn’t be allowed to have them when they’re the one surrounded by enemies and in the heart of the Middle East surrounded by terrorists? I think 🤔 💭 that’s quite unfair. Tbh the US is stupid to accuse Iran for possibly bombing a country whilst their biggest desire to be part in the economy again. That just would not make sense in any way...
Sara Kha but Iran’s the terrorist. Don’t they fund terrorist organizations that chants “death to America” or the Nation chants that in general?
So removing the possibilities of developing nuclear weapons in exchange for a global market? This deal doesn't sound bad for the Iranians at all. Many countries that are doing better compared to Iran does not have nuclear weapons. For folks around the world they get a good assurance of no nuclear weapons launching from the middle east in the next few decades that might strike Europe and Asia, or nuclear weapons sold or smuggled to terrorists. The deal sounds pretty good to everyone. (PROVIDED no one cheats on this deal)
Jerry Lee no they shouldn't be trying to make nukes in the first place
Very educational, informative and straight to the point! I look forward to seeing more of your videos! You just earned a new subscriber! :)
I don't see what the problem is
+Yeah,i guess so I guess you have not followed the News over the last 10 years ? Well, just utube Iran, and see what their government thinks of Americans and Israel and how they want to destroy both.
RevolutionaryMike Tf r u talking about? The left controls the media in the US so if something like how the black community is at its lowest unemployment rate under Trump and all these raises given to employees under Trump are covered up. You don't hear about it too much
The problem is that this deal has a ten year expiry date. After which they are allowed to make as many nuclear warheads as they please.
The #1 problem for Iran has been how to deliver these warheads to your doorstep. Sanctions made that very difficult A warhead is pretty useless if you dont have a delivery system (the rocket part of the ICBM)
This deal asks them to give up most of their useless warhead material...and in exchange they can now work on their delivery systems...with the money they now have with sanctions gone. And after 10 years, they can make new warheads....and put them in their new delivery systems...now they have a way to deliver Mr. Warhead to your doorstep...yay!!!
UDon'tNeedTo Know lmao that was all the after affects of Obama’s stimulus package trump didn’t even pass any type of tax reform when that happened he was only 3 months in. Have you been watching fox and fell for their propaganda? Most people can see through it even foreigners laugh at Fox
Errick Flesch hope it does
netanyahu mad right now.
Him Downstairs ..... but not now ;)
forgot about the $1.5B United States gave them and that the deal expires... poverty grade reporting and information.
The money that Iran got was legitimately owed to them. Nothing wrong with paying a debt.
Noah Brüstle how did we owe them 1.5 billion dollars?
The money they got is their money, that we took, we took it.
George Blisson They way you speak and write LOL everywhere shows that you can't be older than 12...
bespetna awwww so butt hurt about the money that was actually owed to Iran .
a huge thank you for this great video
3 of the top nuclear site can only be inspected by Iranian officials. All other inspections require 24 day advanced notice.
1. It didn't
How did it not?
commander red What nuclear sub you moron? The only country capable of that is US & Russia.
Awesome video Vox ! I've re-posted this article on facebook with the following comment:
Thomas Jefferson summed up his foreign policy position perfectly in his 1801 inaugural address: "Peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations - entangling alliances with none." How many times have we all heard these wise words without taking them to heart?
The Israelis may not like this Administrations policy with Iran but last time I checked - Israel was not part of our Union. And even though I disagree with this administration on many issues - this deal is not one of them.
Thank you!! the only unbiased video i could find on youtube
Cutting through the noise is a great service however, if you also cut through the factual implications of the story, the value of your service diminishes. Major problems with this 'deal':
- limitations on inspections (sound familiar)
- relief from conventional arms acquisition
- allowance of ballistic missile development/acquisition
Ed Stevens
The ability to inspect is ultimately up to the IAEA, yes Iran has the ability to object but that can be revoked.
lee0495 No...inspection standards established as part of the failed negotiation.
Ed Stevens
Did you mean to say "No, inspection standars established as part of the failed negotiation"
Or did you mean to say
No inspection standards [were] established as part of the failed negotiation.
If US pulled out of the deal why Iran should respect it? Now they are forced to build until they are taken serious like North Korea. This is mad politics.
Iran today is no longer abiding by the 2015 deal ..thanks Trump
They weren't even when the deal was going on. That is why it got ripped up.
What a load of crap Vox. Once again you did not impress me.
George Bonta so what was wrong this time
Adrian Scharff nothing was wrong, George is just a moron and couldn’t handle that the facts told a different story than what he believes
I like the content that Vox puts out, but I remember watching Vice cover this issue more objectively. I felt much differently about the Iran deal than I do from watching this video. That's the problem with the ONLY watching news coverage from a network that skews a certain way.
Hello from 2022. Let's go Brandon.
This looked so promising, it's really saddening to see the current situation now
It wasn't and Iran continued to fund and arm terrorist groups Hezbollah and Hamas during it.Last week they announced that they are enriching their uranium again
@@richlopez4466 nah, the deal seems close now
The biggest mistake any fully developed county can make is to hand this type of power to a 3rd world country, it's a ticking time bomb.
How depressing watching this now.
May GOD bless you and may his HOLY SPIRIT guide you all in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. John 3:16, 1 Thessalonians 5:3, Revelation 22:20.
I really needed this thank you
Hey now the revelations are starting to get more and more accurate so this is creeping me out
I never got the impression that Iranians are "suffering".
Vermilicious they are not.
No. Do you?
Kitty The reports and interviews I've seen with Iranians in Iran does not point towards any kind of suffering though.
My point was that it's wrong to just assume people are suffering because their country is a bit isolated from the rest of the world (or doesn't have a "real economy", whatever that means). It does not mean they can't be well and happy.
Vermilicious then you must be blind because the amount of money controlled by the government is more than 50%
Hey, I used to live in Iran. Although I was 10 when I moved to Canada and now 14, I would like to say that all these theories about Iran are not necessarily true. As you two were arguing, I would like to say that we do not suffer what so ever. Although most accusations are false, the government is pretty bad. This is not the point but the climate and the air is also pretty bad but when I used to live back in Iran and visit every year or two, it is still a beautiful country and no one in my family that I know is currently suffering in Iran.
Thank you for this brief and informative video. It is soothing to read something to the point and moderate. Thank you
Nuclear deal works - for Iranian Nuclear program.
Israel will eventually have to demolish Iranian Nuclear site - same we did to Iraqi Nuclear site in 83' and to Syrian nuclear site in 2007'.
We got condemned by the 'experts'. Same 'experts' that say that the Iranian Nuclear deal is good.