Establishment, Judiciary, Modi's India and the Establishment - Nadeem Farooq Paracha -
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2024
- Nadeem Farooq Paracha comes back on TPE for an epic 3 hour podcast where we discuss the Establishment, What is happening in the country today, The Judiciary's Independence, The Lawyer's Movement, The Erdogan Model, Modi's India, Karachi, MQM, Elections, Zardari, Zaid Hamid, Conspiracy Theories, Sir Syed Ahmad Khan, The Iddat case and more.
Nadeem Farooq Paracha, also known as NFP, is a Pakistani journalist, author, cultural critic, satirist and historian. He is a columnist for Pakistan's largest English-language daily Dawn and has authored several books.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
3:00 Establishment, Crticism and What is happening in Pakistan
5:40 Is the Judiciary exerting its independence and the Lawyers Movement
29:00 Erdogan Model and what should the Government do
34:30 Is Pakistan headed towards Martial Law?
37:20 Media Bias towards PTI
41:00 Karachi, PTI and MQM
49:23 Evolution of Economy, Democracy and Politics
1:10:00 Indian Democracy, Modi and the Media
1:16:30 Ayub, Zia, Industrialization and differences with Modi's India
1:22:50 Modi's India won't last and the downfall of Otherization
1:34:00 Evolution of PML-N
1:39:30 Zardari, Benazir Bhutto and Jiyalay
1:50:00 People who vote for PTI and not empathizing with others
2:00:00 Benazir's death and double standards in the media
2:08:35 Zaid Hamid, Charlatans and Conspiracy Theories
2:17:30 Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
2:21:30 Aamir Mughal and Polemics between sects
2:27:14 Iddat case and Elections
2:30:50 PTI in KP
2:35:45 Audience Questions - บันเทิง
![ภาพนี้ก็ฮาเหมือนกันนะเนี้ย #1 SS8 [ พากย์นรก MEME.EXE ] | easy boy](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ytc50m91QK8/mqdefault.jpg)
Please please support this channel for exclusive and unbiased content. Now I found a truly inspirational videos of knowledge and wisdom through their podcast. Thank yiu soo much brother.
❤️❤️❤️
What a shame he is so biased and boot licker we can see clearly that he is against imran khan and he has no valid reason for it, but it’s his own views we respect but strongly disagree and this podcast is not for me
True he's a zardari sympathiser. Sindhi Sindhi KO support karta hai humesha. @@ehtishamqadir8572
But paracha is biased
When you say that Modi's India is radical remember that Jinnah's grandson still lives in India and is prospering more than any Pakistani.
Still Pakistani doesn’t voted and made butcher of gujrat as PM
We have seen better days of Secular India during Congress days. Modi ka india 🇮🇳 is everything but Secular or democratic.
@@queenPAKLol u will tell what is secularism and democracy now 😂😂😂
Anyway we only care and prosperity and strength of our nation. Atleast Pakistanis shd first implement anything in their nation b4 talking abt others. Ghar me Naa ho daaney amma chali bhunaney
so? they have been living since independence. the last 10 years under modi is anything but secular.
@@queenPAKgreat 👍. Unfortunately we Indians can't say that about any regime in Pakistan from Jinnah to shehbaz. So maybe fix your own house first.
I salute these geniuses for creating a strawman on today's India.
Their argument is: Most Indians think that they built space ships and with the Hindu pride they want to oppress other religions. And Modi is somehow responsible for all this. Then, South India does not vote for BJP and instead votes for Left. To top it all, Hinduism didn't exist before 18th century.
Are you kidding me?
The reality, however, is: Most Indians don't think like that. If you are smart enough to think, Indians can think for themselves too. And how can polytheists impose their religion on others when they don't have the concept of supreme god and are even open to the idea of atheism? The conflict between Hindus and Muslims is ongoing for a long time and it has its own history and nuances. To see that conflict through this narrow worldview and claim that it is Zia's Pakistan is absurd. If that were the case, why don't you see a single Zoroastrian, Jain, Buddhist, or even atheist facing religious persecution here.
Do you know anything about South India, its own diversity, its own political cults etc? Do you know anything about East India? Then going on and making such sweeping statements about a country of over a billion people. Really?
For god's sake, get out of your bubbles. Talk about nuances. Understand the world better. And then have educated opinions. If not, then I am pretty sure you would label me as some RSS, BJP (even though you don't know the difference between the two) troll and live on happily in your bubbles.
Arey ye bandaa aise hi hai. Thumbnail dekhkar samajh gayaa thaa kya bolegaa 😂😂😂 dukhi atmaa hai . Typical pakistan liberal hai jisey india me charltan bolte Hain 😂😂
Such a long reply/explanation...but why they would not able to comprehend what you said... their country's situation and stance on India would never change.. They would end up killing each other.
And yes I am a proud kafir and our achievements in science n tech I because we are hindus and for us education and dreams are important.
It's tough to talk about nUaNCeS when hundreds of churches have been destroyed, women r*ped, children murd3r3d, and minority groups ethnically cleansed in the past few years, in Manipur ALONE... This BS about it being a "complex issue" with its myriad "nuances" reminds me of zion@zi talking points a lot (not surprising, as the giant majority of anti-muslim and anti-palestinian content in recent history originated in India)
You need to shutup!! I know how radicalized india is!!! Just see the commemts here that espouce antiIslam
You need to shutup!! I know how radicalized india is!!! Just see the commemts here that espouce antiIslam
Sorry sir...but Indians never said..we look better than Pakistani...
It is the Pakistani people who says we have fair skin and Muslim is always above than others....
Whom r u telling this. 😂😂😂
Afghans call Punjabis as dalkhor and kaalu
Well paindus look quite hilarious to be Frank. Afghans call them Dalkhor and kaalo😂😂😂
Iss chwani chaap ko sir kyun bol rahe ho!?
You guys ll always be bhikaris @@GuzzarAwan
@@GuzzarAwanAnd that's why you lost Bangladesh cause of your racism; you were the ' good looking ' race and Bengalis were ' Kalos'.
Brother i am sikh but i always vote modi because his work this man nothing known about India
Kedda sikh aa Vai tu?....who jeya ki kita a modi ne jera onnu vote dita jave?....
Paaji aap inn propagandists ko bewajeh reply kar rahe ho... Yeh ola uber ke liye fatne wale aapko lagta hai aapke facts ko sunenge!?
@@user-fq1sm8sd8q he is your fake paaji like modi's degree 🤣🤣🤣
@@raghuveersinghrathore7395 not everyone is fake like you.
@@raghuveersinghrathore7395LOL raat me roti mili thi khaney ko yaa bhukaa so gyaa thaa😂😂😂
400 seats is a psychological play by bjp to divert the discourse towards changing the baseline of how many seats bjp is going to win rather than discourse being about whether bjp is going to win or not. I thought Shahzad and Paracha sahab would have understood this. 400 plus seats was never a realistic goal which indians on the streets also know.
Abey paracha ko saheb to Naa bol Kam se Kam 😂😂😂
Abhi bhi doubt hai BJP power mein aayegi ya nahi!??
@@GuzzarAwanbhai iska baap hai isliye Sahab jod raha hai
itni dimag inke pass hone ki aasha rakhna aapne aap me bohot haasi ki baat hai
Modi made opposition fall into his trap😂😂😂
They're so concerned about Indian Muslims but never a word about the Muslims in China!😂😂😂 Xi Jinping's dictatorship doesn't bother them at all, but feel entitled to comment on Democracy in India! Hypocrisy at it's best!😂😂😂
😂😂😂 asali baat kuch aur hai. And I m happy that most Indians understand the game
They aren't concerned about their own ppl also... They are hypocrite 😂
Views ka chakkar hai babu bhaiyaa 😂😂
Views ka chakkar hai babu bhaiyaa 😂😂
baat kaise karenge,, baat aukat pe jo aa jati hai,, aur aukat to inki pata hi hai apko
On one hand you have Uzair who reads and provides data-backed insights. On the other hand you have this gentleman who's only argument is "mere khyal se".
Take your pick who you want to believe.
Even opposition in india dont know about Modi, but this people know modi 😅
South India left is not a force anymore...I am from Kerala left politics is dying ...
Just finished a PEG of AMRUT Whiskey, excellent Whisky.
And with the comments of the Guest on India, made me laugh. Good stand up. I will have a good sleep
Amrut is just awesome. Please do try monkeys shoulder also 😊. Cheers
Next episode : Chinese man talks about Indias democracy 😂😂😂
😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Same as Modi talking about development
@@amish2394 but indian Growth rate is 8.2% highest in the world this year . Facts don't lie .
Brother u must come to India and live here to get the real truth abt India.
Iam a Loyal Modi Voter since 2014...again repeated it in 2019...did the same in 2024...and if he somehow stands in 2029 i will vote him...
Bharat Mata ki Jai...Jai Hind...Vande Matram❤❤❤
They will call u fake I'd and they won't get VISA anyway. Prolly most don't even know the picture in ur I'd , ant what it is. Jai hind
Ab yeh bolega aapko india ka nahi pata aap hindu ho naam badal ke comment kar rahe ho... BJP it cell
Balidan Badge ❤
@@dakkxh proudly wore it for 15 yrs ❤️
@@MohdNisar-zm6bo Your service to India is immeasurable sir. If there's anything that inspires me more in life, it's the army, their grit, their extraordinary perseverance have all taught me more than any stupid graduate course I've done.
Edit: I confess that I've been an islamophobe, but people like you are changing that❤️
Har wo Pakistani jo past 15 years se India travel nhi Kiya wo India expert banta hai
Couldn't agree more. Bhaai itna confidence aata kaise hai 😮
you guys probably won't know because it's still 2000 BC in india, but 2024 chal raha hai current affairs malom karne visit jaruri nahi.
Travel kare Naa kare , pakistani india ko congress se time bhi gaali dete they. Aaj bhi detey hain . Part of narrative building. But difference ye hai ki pre Modi wo 4 baar india par attack kiye aur ghus gaye. Post Modi india ne maar lagayi hai inkey
@@sheryarahmed6331Abey tum log ko sidhaa jannat janey ko ready rehtey ho. Tumhey 2000 BC aur 200BC se kya matlab. Sargodha me dekhaa nhi kitno ke jannat ke liye haath saaf kar liyaa 😂😂
Pakistan ke haal jaante hai … ye jaalan hai ..
His understanding of South India is so wrong....oh god...where to start?
Please don't.. Don't waste your time on these irrelevant people
Howcome you are watching... or does the BJP IT CELL force you... my sympathies 😉
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s hum toh journalist hain bhai news opinion yehi kaam aur life hai humara. 😄
@@user-fq1sm8sd8q
Suure "journalist" 🙃😄
His understanding of Punjab is as wrong.
Thank you Shehzad for bringing another lande ka liberal on your podcast
Face the difference of opinion. Hosla kero 😂
@@queenPAK Bhai propaganda aur difference of opinion me farq hota hai
.
@@himanishdasgupta7217In Pakistan it is one and the same thing.
@@queenPAK banda maula jat ki baatein kar raha hai... Yeh hai alternate opinion wala... Aur woh bhi paki... Do you really think we take him or any paki for that matter seriously.. Pakis are laughingstock for us Indian.. So chill
@@queenPAKye Banda ekdum Pakistani liberals ko match kartaa h. Who have achuved nothing in their nation except supporting the foji narrative 😂😂
Yeh uncle kon hai , Total misinformation about India
Koi dukhi atmaa hai . Naa apney Desh me democracy secularism laa payaa Naa india ko samajh payaa. Basically irrelevant insan hogaa koi
Misinformation nhi they have no clue of India just like I.N.D.I Alliance
I think yeh uncle is living on denial. I don't blame him. How can he give India the allowance or the ability to not to care about what the West thinks about India or the West flexing muscles on India? Slumdog Millionaire was a movie that was released in 2008. Everyone has seen the progress India has made after that. Shehzad is more grounded. Anyway whatever makes the 'uncle' happy. And whatever be the case, Shehzad is good and I always like the topic and guests he picks. Keep at it Shehzad.
He is one of the eminent intellectuals of Pakistan with a deep understanding of Pakistani history. He used to write very sensible and popular columns in Pakistan’s largest selling English newspaper Dawn. But like so many other Pakistani intellectuals he has very little direct knowledge of India, forms opinion from people like Arfa Khannum and Rajdeep Sardesai and then consider themselves India experts.
@@gauravipal5691 well newspaper dawn was peddling Pak foj lies when they were doing atrocities in bangladesh and even when surrendering they told Pak foj winning . No one takes pakistani intellectual seriously . Most have grown up reading Pak studies anyway. That Islamist always sits somewhere in their brain
Inke hisab se bengaluru me BJP nhi jiti hai
Inko Bengalore ka B bhi nahi pata... Sirf IT IT pata hai.. 🤣🤣
Pakistani punjab mindset is showing it's intellectual level. 😂😂😂😂
Have lost a lot of respect for NFP after watching this sh!tshow!
He has zero understanding of what India stands for today.
Does he think that India did not anticipate the US reaction to the Chahbahar port deal? Do you think that India gives a f*ck!!
Any random Indian podcast makes more sense
Sun le Bhai. Time ke saath ye bhi badlegaa. Jab bharat me congress badal gyi to ye to pakistani hai
inko pata nahi hai chabahar port wali baat.. puri puri din hallucinate jo karte rehte hai
Ye vese he india expert hai, jese ki, imran khan sadeeq ameen hai. 😂
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Buffalo is calling the kettle black 😂😂😂
Pakistan should bring a law similar to CAA so that their Muslim brothers who were left behind after partition can finally join their country their forefathers have fought for. TBH we have grown sick of STSJ people (Sar Tan Se Juda) living amidst us. They belong to you. Cheers!
Don't worry the STSJ community will be getting their dose soon
Don't worry, they will make their own country soon
@@zyabsiddiqui8155😂kaise krrenge sayad agar 1947 ki tarah hindus secular hote to sayad krr bhe lete but abb....😎
vese abdul falastine ke masoom bache kya haal hai🥺 bechare vo chote abdul ke bache 🤡
@@gamingff5808 jaisa abhi recent main China nai ladakh ka significant part lia hai na waisa hi lai lainga ...now go and shit on tracks 🅿️🅰️jeet
@@zyabsiddiqui8155 They belong to your country. They are "left out" people who voted for partition but didn't leave. Take them. Give them citizenship. We don't want them here. Cheers and best wishes!
@1:26:00 - Sir, South India doesn't vote for left really except for Kerala. Tamil Nadu has Dravidian ideology, they don't vote for either Bjp or Congress or any national party.
Karnataka where Bangalore is situated has seen various BJP governments, last genral elections - they got 25/28 seats. Even Telangana elected 4 MPs from BJP in 2019 elections.
Sir...!?? Itni izzat!? 🤣🤣
Dravidianism or self respect movement is also a form of radical identity politics that a group of left really espouses. Moreover their views on caste and Hindusim are much more radical than atheistic left.
Now you are confusing him with facts
@@Dudenator203 what facts? Periyar was more radical than left on brahminism
@@AyushGupta-rq4qufacts that South also votes for BJP
Uncle Ji is all Gyan no understanding of how world works.
Love the fact that most Pakistani scholars would not stand ground against even 1st year Indian students.
This will ensure Pak stays where it is. No data driven analysis - just “Khayali pulao” presented as fact.
1st year of what ?? BTECH MTECH BA MA ... yaar koi bhi.
Pakistanis seems never have understood how to read data and derive results . Khud hi sapno me khoye rehte hain
Disclaimer: Paki intellect should be heard for entertainment purpose only.
@@GuzzarAwan
If you actually feel that way howcome do you watch a channel called the Pakistan experience in the first place... or is it just that the BJP IT CELL compensate you 😉
A common Indian is voting Modi for Hinduvta, whatever that means.
@@syedhussain7227 for a reason. His management of economy and foreign policy is better than the alternative.
Some misconceptions Pakistanis have:
- BJP is not present in south. Largest South Indian state is Karnataka and BJP has been either the ruling party or principal opposition for last 20 years
- BJP only gets votes on Muslim bashing. May be 20%, rest most of their votes come from economic handling / social safety net policies etc .
one correction, we are not only proud to be a hindu but even more proud to be an indian ! jai hind 🇮🇳
This man just don't want to accept economic, digital growth with also implementation of welfare schemes in last 10 years. He just wishes india would fall one day. We also accept there are some tensions but there is a lot of exaggeration around these.
Lets not forget Memons, Khojas, Bohras, other shia communities are prospering in India among the Muslims. I humbly submit that majority of the issues of Sunni backwardness in India is their clergy and leadership's doing.
Every Pakistani is an India expert.
Modi ne kuch toh kiya hai, pakistani itna daar kyu rahe hai.. Isolate ho gaya hai Heeramandi🇵🇰
1:13:13 aapka guest ko ghnta nhi pata yaha ka kuch, humko sach me ghnta fark nhi padta Canada se.... Kuch v bol raha ye
Guest Ko apna b ghanta ni pta😂
Inn logon ko Canada se fark padta hai toh inn bhikhariyon ko lagta hai India ko fark padta hai🤣🤣
They don't understand the Strength of India and power of its youth
Abhinandan yaad hai kisi ko?
@@emeraldknight84so in last 76 years Pakistan ka biggest achievement ya h ki ussne 1 Indian ko pakar liya jbki india ne 4 war jeeta h baithe h bhai😂😂😂
Is Pakistan running towards Islam? OR
Is it running away from anything other than India?!
If you run away from something. Where will you reach?!
Please try to understand that Zia controlled entire Pakistan Modi doesn't do so his party doesn't even have a majority in upper house of the parliament, his party is in power in only 11 out of 28 states in India third please don't forget that the IITians and other professionals in India comes massively from middle class and please do see Prashant Kishore analysis where he says that hindutva pitch for mr modi doesn't give him incremental vote, the middle class in India is far more educated and is interested to invest it's time and resources in productive work
Good point
@@ThePakistanExperiencea Christian mob lynched in Pakistan but 2 so called educated typical Pakistani r lecturing us on secularism and democracy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@ThePakistanExperiencetry raising ur voice against ur aaka China who have 2 million uyghur Muslims in re education camps
This is a good point, and I think the guest's viewpoint lack any depth and nuance. This is at best tangential knowledge about Indian electoral politics.
Another point, results are still away so don't know what they would show, but informed folks would remember that BJP was also expected to be on backfoot before 2019 elections like now. But, I am guessing if BJP wins 350 your guest would say ki "BJP ka safaya ho gaya".
@@ThePakistanExperience
Well the comparison of Modi who no doubt has fascist tendencies to Zia is wrong. One came to power as result of a coup the other by vote. But unfortunately it also true that many of India's middle class( which consists mainly of forward castes, ofcourse not entirely) support him. So that tells a lot about the health of the Indian society...
In the last rajastahan and chattishgarh election exit polls suggested BJP will lose. But they sprang a surprise by winning both. You guys do not know about BJP election especially booth management. Canada is not an issue at all. It is good we are not bowing to usa unlike your country which is a phone call away .
Whom are you explaining all this... What do these people know about the electoral process...!? Not a single govt in pak history completed its full term. 🤣
Canada is joke. It doesn't even make a news at all. No one even talks about it. But even if they did, it will work in Modi's favor for eliminating anti national forces wherever they are.
یہ شو 6 گھنٹے سن سکتی ہوں 😊 شہزاد ، این ایف پی ۔۔۔۔ اور سیاسی صورتحال پر تبصرے ❤ بہترین 👏
I am hungry for education but sadly when it comes to india... Pakistani expert either peddle the fake narrative about india or boosting my ego about how we have become developed already.....there is no nuanced version or rather truth in debates or podcasts....love and only love from this side ❤️
It's better to read books. Tilak deveshar books r great. Even his podcast. He is Pakistan expert ex R&AW
@@GuzzarAwan thanks for the suggestion bro.👍
Yes, apparently Bollywood and most Indians have the most nuanced idea about Pakistan. Every Pakistani eats paan, wears kajol and says "aadaab". Lol.
He is wrong that India is not a cohesive civilisation, he is wrong to say that India is antagonising Canada….india is only saying that Canada has no proof of their allegations…..he has no idea. Why don’t you ask theses same questions to UzairYounis rather than this ignorant person
Riiiight no proof 🤦🏻♂️
South India , North India , West India all are languishing before 1991 reforms. It is not important who is voting who , important is what reforms are happening in a country. Suprisingly most of the business communities belongs to Gujrat where BJP is power from last 25 years. But anyways ....
So wasn't Gujrat a business hub before 25 years..
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s Absolutely it was . But the argument fall flat that educated and hard working people do not vote for BJP. Most of the well off NRI's are BJP supporter irrespective of North or South.
@@ghanshyamjoshi587
Well yes the BJP has support from the more educated middle class. Ofcourse many of those belong also to the forward castes... Ofcourse not all but the majority. Those are just the realities of the society which some find sad and unfortunate and others rejoice...
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s You are right again. But to paint North India as ignorant because they did vote for BJP is utterly stupid argument.
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s And people often forget that Congress won in the backdrop of Mumbai attacks. So voters vote for polarisation is not backed by data. Factual relaity is Congress is not a viable alternative.
Nadeem Farooq Paracha is the kind of guy you can keep listening to for hours. Thank you Shezad for having him on the show.
Jald bulaiye ga phirsey. Keep up the good one.
❤️
Makesbme smile 😊 evey time i c thi uncle is talking about us Bhartiya..
Can you please ask respected uncle that when was the last time he visit India on ground...
Itsblooks agin that Madras... graduated..
Uncle thanks for making my day like this 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Me to this guest - Waah Kya soch hai teri yaar 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
I am a child of refugees. My parents were both born in Lahore. Not once have I ever been called anything like a refugee or have faced any discrimination. Neither did my parents. In Pakistan “Muhajir” is a permanent identity.
“Otherization” is a reoccurring theme of Islam. Hinduism and Hindu thought is inclusive in its core nature. How you gauge if Modi has been otherizing the minorities? You look at data and please find me one study that says that Muslims aren’t getting govt benefits etc.?
Also Indians now stand up to the Canada’s or BBC’s of the world because they are waking up to the civilizational pride that they must have. You are from the same civilization but choose to consider yourself different. Rassi jal gayi hai par bal nahi gaya.
"Otherization is a recurring theme in Islam?"
No, it isn't. All Muslims pray towards Kaaba and fast during Ramadan.
Sindhis who migrated to India are among the most prosperous community of India. In fact Sindhis rule the industrial belt of TN with majority SME owned by them. Sindhis form a large portion of supply chain of TVS motors.
@@frozendilemmaare ahmadis Muslim?
Shia vs Sunni
Barelvi vs deobandi
ashraf vs pasmanda
Thanks bro 3 house going to be amazing more interesting than a movie 🙌😅
One has to be a fool if anyone really thinks that a govt. can cross 400+ seats in India. That too in its 3rd term.
Given the diversity in India, and the no. of strong regional parties we have. Even Modi is saying 400+ when we add all its allies and not for BJP.
Even the staunchest BJP member says that 400+ in India is impossible in India if there is no cataclysmic events e.g. a war, a big corruption scandal, etc.etc.
If BJP even gets clear majority it will be a miracle. Last it happened was under Nehru, when opposition were almost powerless in the country.
Who cares ant 400+ 🙄 its always good to set the bar high. 350 to AA hi jayegaa
330+ BJP on its own
It's high time to implement Imran Niazi policy of Riyaste Madina to revive Islamic Pakistan...
😂😂😂 but already a SYED and hafiz e Quran jarnail is leading Al bakistan
You need to shutup!! I know how radicalized india is!!! Just see the commemts here that espouce antiIslam
Host has more knowledge than guest on India part😂
Ye Pakistan ke intellectual bhi dimaagi apang nikle🤣🤣🤣
Nadeem Farooq Paracha needs to explain how the same ''hindus'' vote for BJP at centre and other parties at the state if they are voting solely because Modi is lining up with Hindutva. This shows the lack of data and nuance while discussing India.
Benazir was the best thing ever happened to Pakistan ! We lost diamond ! Nobody is perfect but she was the best thing ever happened to Pakistan politics
Let me tell you Shehzad the people of India don't give two fucks about what Canada or US thinks and even if BJP maintains the number of seats as last time it is a huge achievement. +1
Thought the motto was 400+🤔..
@@user-rh5jp2sh4syou can say it's gimmick some articles says the seats will they get is 370 or or more than that but the thing is even if then don't get 400 seats they will get more seats than before
US is important....let's not get carried away
Except for Gujjus and Punjabis, they ate forever looking to migrate there...
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s They only need to get 273 to form govt. No one cares who said what.
Not even single indiam expert in 22crore Pakistani 😂
1:12:14 Nadeem says even if Modi gets same number of seats as last time, it will be a failure. Really? Third consecutive victory with a majority is somehow a failure?
The ab ki baar char sau paar was a naara. Even the naara referred to NDA (which is the larger alliance with BIP as focus), not BJP alone.
Can Nadeem or any Pakistani point out a SINGLE policy of Modi government which discriminates on the basis of religion? What Modi has done is ending the appeasement policies of congress to consolidate Hindu vote. After decades of Muslim vote consolidation, there is a response by Hindus by way of some degree of Hindu vote consolidation. Modi wants to bring uniform civil code which means end to separate personal laws based on religion. That is secular, not communal.
He says Modi’s policies are backfiring. Can he explain exactly how? What metrics or markers has he observed that lead him to that conclusion? India’s economy, foreign policy, defense are stronger than ever. Communal violence is at its lowest ebb in independent India’s history. 250 million people have been pulled out of multidimensional poverty. India’s startup ecosystem is on fire. Digital India has visibly improved lives by reducing corruption and improving government interface with public.
Let me tell you Shehzad the people of India don't give two fucks about what Canada or US thinks and even if BJP maintains the number of seats as last time it is a huge achievement.
That’s what my read is too
@@ThePakistanExperience
Thought the claim was 400+ 🤔...
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s that claim is just political sloganeering. Getting full majority after 10 years is not getting downgraded and is a huge feat.
IF.... This if can become your worst nightmare
Classical case of paracha comparing lslam with Hinduism. Sir ji India will grow and remain a vibrant democracy bcoz of majority being hindu. Yeh faraq samjho. Even if India becomes a Hindu rashtra it will never become Pakistan bcoz of hinduism.
I appreciate Nadeem F. Paracha for his clarity and genuine persona while also recognizing the limitations in his analysis, particularly his focus on class struggle. An important aspect of political analysis is: the multifaceted nature of voter motivations and societal dynamics.
Paracha's perspective, rooted in class struggle, often overlooks the fluidity of social mobility and the various non-class-related factors influencing political behavior. For example, in India, the reasons behind voting for a leader like Narendra Modi are diverse and complex. They range from developmental aspirations and economic growth to cultural pride and religious sentiments. These motivations reflect a broad spectrum of individual and collective interests that go beyond a single narrative of class conflict.
Paracha overlap between analysis and wishful thinking points to a common issue among analysts: the challenge of maintaining objectivity.
This nuanced understanding can help in appreciating the depth and complexity of political landscapes, recognizing that a single narrative often cannot capture the full picture.
Pakistanis plz do understand that it will never happen in india as it happened in Pakistan one reason is because Hindu is majority and for that u need to understand Hinduism..it's not only about religion but caste factor plays an important part...
@ 1:11:27 the level of scholarship on India in Pakistan is embarrassing. Modi is transforming India’s identity by linking to the Indian civilization. A concept, that is lost on folks on our friends across the border who are classic example of what an identity crisis looks like
As an Indian from north , i hope all Pakistanis 😂think like their analysts. Its only does good for india.
Now i know why Pakistan is like this 😂
Don't worry. Please note that hindutva is not the same as islamism. Modi had to do hindutva to consoildate hindus (which otherwise are divided). Serious slum in India will not happen, it is a high consumption society which can self sustain.
400 paar, no doubts, full faith
4 ko dekh lena @@pinkythakur9554
400 seems unlikely but 350 is very realistic, would love to see 400 👍
@@pinkythakur9554 opposition ke supporters demoralized hain voting hi nai kar rahe
350
No 600 + for sure😉
Too long to finish in a few sessions, so reserving judgment. Unlike many here, I do not mind listening to a perspective different from mine, but I think the guest is unusually biased and his sentiment is that of active hatred towards India. That makes it a bit off-putting. Shehzad also criticises India and Modi but I always get a generous and kind vibe even in his disapproval. But it is his prerogative to choose his guests so I choose to cope with it and trust the host
Firstly learn to address Prime minister of world’s biggest democracy with respect.
Modi maharaj radi Allah anhu
India is a rising power because it’s a Hindu majority country….thats the real truth
Indians don't mind relationship with Canada or USA
Nobody in India claims that humne sb kuch banaya. The guest of this podcast is living in his own la la land. 2 wara harne ke baad bhi inke andar ka superiority complex khatam nahi hua 😂.
NADEEM NASHEDI FROM CONVERTED ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN GIVING BHAASHAN ON SECULARISM.
A few days ago I watched a podcast by a well known Indian media house.I think it was in lucknow and two very senior journalists (UP based) were asked about new houses being built under BJP programme in a particular district of UP.The reply was pretty interesting that 4 lack (400000) new houses were built there in the last five years and out of that 80,000 were for muslim households and when asked how many of them would vote for BJP they smiled and said that directive will come from the Masjid priest. I am fairly balanced politically but the scale and magnitude of developmental work done under Modi"s leadership is mind boggling irrespective of caste or creed or religion.In a country of 1.4 billion you need to do some hard research before commenting on a podcast like a scholar .Except Uzair (at least he spent time in India) the rest including Prof.Hoodbhoy(due respect ) were shooting blanks in the heavy smog.
Bro hum indian 🇮🇳 90s me bhi US ko 🖕ye dikhate thee aaj bhi aur aage bhi yahi dikhayenge.Aur canada koi superpower country nahi hai ki usse koi dare, punjabio ko chod kar aur koi ghass nahi dalta .Here people were appreciating indian gov for killing seperatist in canada 🇨🇦. We don't accept any foreign interference in our country, agar dusre karenge to tit for tat to hoga .Ego wale log to hai hum. Chahe humari economy kitni hi kharab ho ya achhi ho and this position is same chahe BJP ho ya congress ho (Congress thoda less aggressive hoga in foreign policy but overall yahi policy hoga) . Ye cha cha mirzapur wale lagte hai, inko india 🇮🇳 k ground reality ka kuch nahi pata . BJP is good at playing manipulation tactics in politics, opposition ko usne 400 seat bol kar unka confidence low kar diya, BJP ko bhi pata hai ki anti incumbency hai. Agar BJP 300+ and NDA alliance 330-350 bhi kar gayi to inke liye yahi bahot hai.
1:22:50 Modis Bharat won't Last look who is saying 😂😂😂...The audacity to say this it self reflection of the top level of hypocrisy, people who are radicalised as hell where democracy is a joke , is saying a a country who is heavily investing in capital infrastructure who is building make in Bharat who is being self reliant decreasing defence import and from being at highest defence exporter and eventually becoming 3rd biggest economy and market to the world is not on the way to become successful.....🙏
3rd biggest economy doesnt matter if per capita is till $2500. Thats lower than most african countries.
@@Khan-lm9wcIndia is bound to touch 2800 dollars by this year and 4000 dollars in the next 6 years
@@Khan-lm9wc bro population dekhi hai? i hope you know how per capita is calculated. Also as rupee has devalued, the per capita has increased more
@@prateekjain9805 tho wahi tho keh raha hoo kay 3rd biggest economy doesnt mean much when the population is 1.5 billion.
If you think one person, Modi, is India, then yes, modi's India is bound to fall, and that'll be a win for your country's democracy. If you think your country is much more than one person, then it can never fall, and I pray it may never fall
Ayy Shehzad. I know you are reading the comments right now. Just wanna say salam. And keep up the good work. Loving your series on Muhammad Waseems book. I want to give an advice. Subtitles urdu m agar budget ho to please add it. Might be more useful. Some of your videos has a lot more English then urdu. We gotta take all this knowledge to everyone!
Also consider when time is appropriate to do Balochi , Punjabi and Pashto dubbing when the budget is there
Sahi kaha
Happy Youm e takbeer
Yaar Shehzad, you’re on a different level. You can have anyone in front of you, from a journalist to a politician, a comedian, a bureaucrat, a musician or a comedian, and still ask pertinent questions . I don’t know anyone else who has those capabilities. 🙌🏼👏🏼💪🏼
🙌
Hindus thought process is fundamentally different from Muslims. You won't see Hindus picking a particular religion and blame them for problems! Trust me, if there's economical depression, which will happen definitely at some point of time, most of us will try to work harder and see off these phases! This person's thought process is mostly based on being jealous and hoping India won't be able to do well! To be honest, I like such talks at least someone is criticising and trying to bring negative side of the uprising hatred! Let's see what happens in next 5 year!
Hinduvata with Modi = popular
Hinduvata without Modi = No Go
There are layers in Hindu religion, the secularist (read pseudo Secular) took advantage of the same, ruled by appeasement of enough populace abt 30%.
Hinduavta partly united the Hindus and the present dispensation is ruling with about 37% of votes enough for first past the post system.
In South of India they have sizable presence in Karnataka and gaining ground in Telangana, Tamil Nadu and Kerala, may not translate in immediate gain of seats in Parliament.
India is a complex country and Hinduavta may galvanize the core BJP voter 20-25% which is not enough to win you Parliamentary election.
Hinduavta in my opinion is overrated, after 10 years of incumbency if the opposition had credible Prime Minister ial face, 2024 would have been a closer election.
I again reiterate HINDUAVTA WITHOUT MODI IS NO GO. The slogan is Modi ki guarantee not the party's guarantee.
Rest India will know only on 04 Jun.
Pakistani thinking Indians are same as Pakistani. We are different brothers.
One is democracy-india.
Other is Feudal theocratic Military dictatorship.
No way, P A J E E T S are worst
Wow! This is a big surprise!!! Good to see Nadeem Farooq Paracha is invited once again. Please keep inviting him quite regularly.
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience I truly love his natural way of talks and deep analysis on populism and related topics. I never get tired of listening to Nadeem Sahib. I wish he record his latest books in audiobooks with his own voice. Kindly convey my this message to him that launch audiobooks and in his own voice. Thank you.
I remember we had a colleague, and he was well-educated and used to speak English and he used to listen Zaid Hamid...He was one of his Big fans.....I was somebody who objected with him....
It’s so hilarious. This guy is talking like Zaid Hamid and criticising him!!!🙈🙈
Been reading NFP since I was in single digits, rediscovering him in the podcast era has been great.
Indian logo aap meray bhai ho laikin yaar ajeeb makhion ki tarha toot partay ho. Janay do inhain bolnay do, itni kyun jalti hai?
Of course, let time and history be the judge. Some of Indian analysts' predictions about Pakistan haven't come true either.
🙌
As a Pakistani I fully support love respect and support India and Indian army on Kashmir issue from Pakistan 🙂. Best regards from Pakistan 🙂. I am new CEO and founder of Pakistan do not want Kashmir forum 😊. Please contact me 😊?
😂😂😂🎉 regards frm india
Honey Trap
@@GuzzarAwan
BJP IT cell very busy 😂
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s😂😂😂
Your guest has absolutely no knowledge about India,
Good man Nadeem Farooq Paracha. Enjoy reading him in Dawn
I like the way he shamelessly compares Pakistan to India 😂😂😂😂
"Sutta baaz analyst " 😅😅😅
There are 50 Islamic countries what problems they have with one Hindu country 🤔🤔🤔If it’s bad why not change those 50 Islamic countries than keep worrying about Hindus??
Pakistan has no problem with Nepal.
@@muddi900 Nepal not a hindu country and Pakistan is not a country it's a temporary nation 😂😂😂😂😂
@@saikatbaug1937 Nepal is 81% hindu.
@@muddi900 because they do not border Nepal. Its quite simple.
@@floe61 That's great, but there are more than one 'Hindu' country.
Thank you so much for bringing back NFP ❤❤
❤️
Thank you for Calling Jahil Adeem a Charlatan!!!! 👏
*Lahori Landa Bazar Expert On India*
Howcome you are watching...
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s I am watching then I am saying
Analysis = 0
Bakchodi = 100
Thats what you call an Andbhagt 😂
@@il313li 4th june- keep burnol ready😝😝
If it wasn’t for the excellent minds of NFP or Khuram Hussain, there’s no interesting in following Shahzad Ghayyas. Both the last two episodes are a must watch only for the brilliance of the guest as they also expose Ghayyas deep rooted biases and intellectual mediocrity
1:25:47
Tension nehi - its just a reaction of majority.
Who says South doesn't vote BJP, Karnataka state has 28 seats in Parliament, last election elected 25 BJP.
Amongst all southern states of India last election - the highest number of seats by any party was BJP - 30 seats on its own
Shehzad PPP ka azaab kab khtm hoga Sindh seee
When Imran ka Azab news media say khatam hoga😂 Azab e Azeem
@@queenPAK ok done. PPP manhoos khtm hojaye or Kuch nhi chaiye. Firoun se bhi badtar hain ye
Dekhay bhagyr comment kyon karte ho boss
@@ThePakistanExperience aisai sexy lagta haa 😃
🤣
NFP IS EXCELLENT.
I must say. He is brilliant
🙌
This gentleman requires another 50 years to understand INDIA and its Phyche.
NFP has lost it since his last podcast
Jo b kaha jo b socha sab ghalat sabit huwa
Ab dil nai ha accept krne ka
Couldnt talk about the most astonishing elections in Pakistani history where masses turned the table
AFSOS
Modi’s Bhakts will defy any law of economics and physics. They will take Indian land to Moon. 😂😂😂😂😂
Great to see NFP here.
🙌
HATTS OFF TO YOU GUYS !!!
I started reading Nadeem's article in Dawn in the year 2008. In those days in the ETV office, unrestricted internet access was not available to the staff, though access to all newspapers, including Dawn, was given. I read all his articles for almost a decade. He is a liberal guy. About India, Pakistanis must know one thing. No one can win elections here by abusing anyone. Ultimately, how leaders perform decides their fate. Radical Hindu supporters of the BJP indeed get encouragement during the BJP rule, but that is not enough for any politician to win elections. Modi came to power riding on the anti-corruption wave against UPA in 2014. Kejriwal was riding on the same wave against the state govt in Delhi. Muslims in India are radical. They oppose the uniform civil code, reject liberal culture, promote radical Madrasa education, want to keep women in the Burqa, and want sharia personal laws in secular countries like India and so on. All their radicalism has fueled the BJP's conservatism.
difference in zia's pak and modi's india is, most hindus don't vote/agree with Modi, and you don't need to call anyone to know that.
For a person asking people not to be dogmatic in their view, I think this is little unfair.
An Indian here, Agree with Mr. Paracha, The bravado exuded by the Indian right is a false bravado based on success that is earned by all Indians, time will grind down this bravado because unless it is backed by hard work and the ability to work with & understand others, it is bound to fail in the long run.