Who is making waves in the South China Sea?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 มี.ค. 2024
- For more:
www.cgtn.com/video
#southchinasea #military #cgtn #thepoint #liuxin
Who's stirring the waters in the South China Sea? Tensions have flared over a disputed reef - known as Ren'ai Jiao in China and Second Thomas Shoal internationally. Over the past month, the waters have become choppier with skirmishes erupting frequently in the vicinity. The debate over navigation rights and territorial claims is increasingly heated. Let's separate fact from fiction and get to the bottom of it. #southchinasea #military #cgtn #thepoint #liuxin
【Guests】
Yan Yan
Director, Research Center of Oceans Law & Policy
National Institute for South China Sea Studies
Herman Tiu Laurel
President
Asian Century Philippines Strategic Studies Institute
Prof. Klaus Larres
History and International Affairs
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Einar Tangen
Senior Fellow, Taihe Institute
Subscribe to us on TH-cam: goo.gl/lP12gA
Download our APP on Apple Store (iOS): itunes.apple.com/us/app/cctvn...
Download our APP on Google Play (Android): play.google.com/store/apps/de...
![ไม่ต้องมีที่ที่ให้ฉันอยู่ แต่ขอแค่มีฉันอยู่ก็พอ (Spaceless) - getsunova [SHORT FILM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MuT0d_cvJkc/mqdefault.jpg)
![ไม่ต้องมีที่ที่ให้ฉันอยู่ แต่ขอแค่มีฉันอยู่ก็พอ (Spaceless) - getsunova [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4N8idbxZ-7M/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. Laurel is a mouthpiece of China in Philippines
Certified traitor yung Laurel...
Taitor, China mouth face.. Shame on you
Laurel is a chinese with surname Tiu. And his tv program is pro China
Mr. Tiu Laurel son appointed by Mr. Marcos as agricultural secretary
intsek din kaya ganyan din ang paniwala umuwe ka na ng china.
I think its not Americans who provokes.There are videos showing whats happening in the West Phil. Sea not South China Sea
Philippine ships did NOT bump into Chinese ships that were there illegally any way! Chinese ships water blasted Philippine ships, cut off supply from the mainland to the Philippine base, used laser to blind, rammed Philippine fishing vessles, even used sonar to blast and injure Australian navy divers who were in Japanes waters at the invitation OF the Japanese.
President PBbm is aware of China doing to out Phil army ate ensure with their water Canon too much bullying with filipinos
@@lilyperalta2259 Can you post again please Lilly , it is hard to understand your meaning..thanks.
"cut off supply from the mainland to the Philippine base" The Philippine base which supposedly was just a stranded ship functioning as a US forward position on Chinese territory.
@@ensteffo Please explain how this is CHINESE territory? It would make a good read.
where is your evidence that they rammed Philippine fishing vessels? Anyone who saw the video of the supposed ramming on Friday would acknowledge there was no ramming. the vessels sailed close to each other, which is not ramming.
the second Thomas shoal is a low tide elevation and thus any ship ca be there legally as long as they are not exploiting the resources of the EEZ.The problem is whose EEZ does the area belong to especially as the UNCLOs decision was perverse and whose judges were biased
Also the Philippines has no legal claim to any feature in the Spratly Island group as shown in treaty after treaty then it can't be illegal.
The Philippines never even knew of its existence till the late 50's, even then the Philippines never claimed it until 1978
as for the Australian divers, they were injured by a Japanese sonar pulse. not Chinese. Moreover, if the Australians did not inform nearby ships that they had Divers disentangling their propellers then they have only themselves to blame regardless of who was emitting the sonic pulse.
This is such a waste of time.
Wrong person sent to represent the PI. All of this does not make any sense. 😡
he's Chinese by blood
He is pro China,, tiu laurel!!!!
I agree
herman tiu laurel is poor excuse for a filipino. even estrada the president that he served was impeached because of corruption. this person is not a credible source of truth
Because, none of the minions of PBBM can explain what really happen in SCS.. 🙊🙈 Mr. Laurel is correct when he accuse that it is US the one initiating to create conflict in sea region using his puppet BBM 🤡
This broadcast is in the side of China, it's not about the ship it's about the territory , China is very very far from Philippines shores , how could china owns this part of the sea which really belongs to the Philippines
true this video is to be in favor of china. and correct, this is a pathetic claim by china and a delusion . and china is the aggressor from the start bumping to ph ship and even water cannon them, those island are within PH territory and EEZ.
this chinese people are taking its name too literally. not because it was named china sea does that mean it belongs to china entirely? is the Indian Sea entirely India's territory? so dumb of these chinese people to be too literal.
These are all propagandist of China, this is very clear, base on UNCLOS, that is Philippines Exclusive Economic Zone, China is illegally claiming the shoal...
Forget it china claim the moon is theirs too
Don't forget that CHina built several artificial islands on those area, China indeed wanted to change the status quo in the south china sea. If the PHilippines has no maritime right whch is just a within their EEZ, how come that CHina is has more maritime rights if they are 900 kilometers away from that areas.
Hahahahaha 🎉🎉 happy birthday😂
Philippines should force Herman Laurel persona non grata pro China.
I agree with you 100 percent
I agree
That is philippines territory
I totally agree
I think That's EEZ not terretory.
Don't forget SABAH in MALAYSIA guys it belongs to Philippines terretory why we are not claiming it?
4:54 There's NO Filipino perspective in this discussion. This guy doesn't even appear in any local media in the Philippines.
That's right they get someone that is biased and at china side
Because he is an intelligent idiot..
respect the EEZ in every country..... don't harass small country like Philippines. because pilipino men will fight even if our lives lost against china😡
😊I Prof Klause 400 bases all pointing towards China, how can you pretend it is nothing and , you are being evasive.
He is defending the indefensible and sadly his warped perspective of geopolitics is a disgrace to the prestige of the position he occupied.
That's a clear proof of a hypocrite! 😅😅😅
He’s doesn’t even know the UNCLOS rules. An EEZ is only sovereign rights but not sovereignty. The Second Thomas Shoal does not belong to the Philippines under UNCLOS but is disputed territory.
How do you point a base?
What’s the problem? China can’t conquer those areas?
if China was telling that PH lied in grounding the BRP Sierra Madre, how come no one talked about that CN set up some artificial islands in the EEZ of the PH? way back then, CN said that it was just a "shelter for the chinese fisherman" but now, it became a military bases.
CN questions a ship being grounded there but CN doesnt mind setting up some artificial islands inside the PH EEZ.
Ang pampagulo lang talaga dyan sa WPS ay yong China wala naman silang pagaari dyan bakit kasi andyadyan yang mga gaanid na China? kung wala sana yang mga hinayupaak na mga chekwa na yan walà sanang gulo dyan
The first country to militarise the spratly Islands was the Philippines which until 1956 never even knew they existed. While every major country recognised that they belonged to China and stated as much in treaties and legal pronouncements,
Te UNCLOS decision was perverse in that for the first time it claimed an island that had been inhabited by humans for years, had its own fresh water supply, was fertile, and had ample fishing was not an island, thus reversing all previous decisions. The fact that the judges come from countries all allied to the USA and who reversed their previous legal arguments showed the decision was political.
Mr Herman Tiu Laurel clearly a mouthpiece of China, I watched him being interviewed on tv depending China's behaviour in SCS.I
The ccp made him Wealthy
You hit It right
Makapili.
I hate that man!
He’s one of the traidor!!!
In short like in the Ukraine the US will fight China to the last Filipino🤔😳
Just like the ARVN in the Nam.
Bang Bang Marcos will be the first 🤣
Thank God not to the last Indian.
Tell your buddy Putin to get his imperial army out of another country.
Its 5 country’s lol Its UN related akso
Hon Laurel did you see what they are doing to the Filipinos fishermen?No to bully in our own EEZ
Mr. Herman Tiu Laurel is not a Filipino...his prerogative meant more advantage for chinese than to the Filipinos. I'm so disgusted why he was been choice to represent for the Philippines...!!! Then, why he says... The Americans will never win when getting into a war with China. It's ridiculous...as he had saying those in front of the media interviews.
A Chinese boat accelerates rapidly before coming to a sudden stop in front of a Philippine vessel, aiming to portray the Philippines as the aggressor in the collision. The angle of the video footage further strengthens this perception, adding to the convincing portrayal of the Philippines as the instigator.
A sensible person from the Philippines for changed.Thank you!
There are many peaceful and logical filipinos like him but their voices were ignored by Marcos Jr.
Ignored, or purposefully disregarded and even silenced? @Monkey341
"sensible"
You mean a guy being criticised for being too pro-China?
CGTN is funded by? 😂😂😂
@@chaoticheaven17 Partially funded by the govt. Same as DW, BBC, NPR and many more. Your point? At least they bring people from different viewpoint to debate unlike most if not all Western media.
20:03 with all due respect Professor, how did the US react when the former Soviet Union placed medium and intermediate range ballistic missiles in Cuba which is only 90 miles away from Florida? Or how do you think the US will react if China decides to open a substantial military base in Cuba in addition from a Signals Intelligence facility already established there?
What's more important but less known is that the US installed nuclear weapons in Turkey so the USSR installed theirs in Cuba in reaction!
@@tonym842 the Jupiter missiles were already deployed in Turkey even before the Cuban Missile Crisis.
@@johnlouised.garcia3375 that's exactly what I wrote!
@@johnlouised.garcia3375 Isnt that is what Tony said?
The US has no intention on stepping onto its neighbours, China is. The US is there on the express request by these countries to prevent China from bullying its way into territory that isn't theirs.
What are you saying the Philippines illegally doing things in the WPS. It’s within the Economic zone
It is inside philippines EEZ. What if philippines, build a base inside china EEZ? What do you feel ?
as they do not own any islands in the Spratly group it is not within the Philippine EEZ, that is why it is in dispute.
He was trying to remind us that China has a military base in only one place all over the world or 2. Djibouti and Cambodia naval base (one of the lowest number of external bases any powerful country has). And Djibouti is a country where almost every powerful nation has a military base in.
The US has close to 1000 military bases outside its country. (So you know, there are less than 200 countries worldwide… meaning it has multiples in various countries. And the US military is unwanted in many of those countries).
I don’t see his point here…
With these military bases alover the world but could not defeat the Taliban for 21 years.
With all the military bases but could not defeat north korea for 3 years ( 1950-1953 ). With all the toothless military bases around the world US could not supply enough weapons to defeat Russia in Ukraine war for 2 years.
@@agborebot28 Basically, Taiwan might end up being the Ukraine of Asia. (Possibly in addition to Philippine).
It’s a repeat of the same nonsense.
China was asked to put a base there to combat Somali piracy. If I remember correctly.
The Djibouti base was established by China under UN to protect commercial shipping due to Somalia piracy unlike the over 800 US’ bases all over the world to control, intimidate & invade other nations. One just needs to look at the number of invasions & regime changes (murdered of other countries’ leaders) that US had or continued to carry out after WW2.
@@TheactualclipsTBF, those US bases out of their country brings a lot of benefits more than harm.
Guess who's leading the protection of merchant ships in the Red Sea?
Does mr KLAUS live on another Earth or he is blind what's America doing 🤮😩
He has been spewing the non sense lies on Russia & China. The guy lives in another lala land.
CGTN is china owned network therefore the whole show is a propaganda, another china dirty trick!!!
America is not making troubles but china alone.
Mr laurel the Chinese is ripping the Philippines island one by one ..your not a filipino
right,..
Lau chinese
his middlename is tui
Where is the proof of your allegation?
HE DEFINITELY IS A TRAITOR...
Prof. Klaus Larres seems utterly deluded. "There are rumours.."
He’s def paid off by the US just a lapdog puppet doormat for the US to wipe the crap off their feet with 😂
This prof is digong ally.
That Prof. Klaus Larres is a silly human. Knows diddly squat. Biased.
They are beyond biased. They are those academic propagandists getting grants and career advancement for parroting US anti-China propagandist narratives and talking points. Like the US military industrial complex, the US propaganda industrial complex is a huge industry that a lot of people are benefiting from it.
He is a paid idiot
Clearly a US propaganda mouthpiece! 😅😅😅
He doesn’t even know the UNCLOS rules and he’s a professor?
Yes we never see this person in Philippines tv news
Intentionally or not grounding the old ship, those islands belong to philippine eez
Excellent discussion on the obvious American led conflict.
Prof Klause you sure you know the facts of the case????
he is protecting his job security at american university.
He doesn't. He's a Neoliberal Kraut 🇩🇪 who thinks HE the Kraut literally knows better about the situation and the details,than the actual Asian people if the region..because it suits his agenda to satisfy his 🇺🇸 master..typical Aryan narcissism
He doesn’t even know the UNCLOS rules. The Thomas Shoal is in international waters not Philippines waters. An EEZ is only sovereign rights but not sovereignty and is still considered international waters. Ships both military and civilian are allowed by innocent passage through a country’s EEZ.
Errr....what facts of the case ?
if you still can remember, BBM shocked after china Water cannon the resupply ships after visiting China 1 week prior,
If phil eez is not valid. Well, it is more not valid for 10 greed line. What is the power behind the person who draws a line on water
International Community sides with Philippines 🇦🇺 🇯🇵 🇰🇷 🇺🇸 🇳🇿 🇫🇷 🇮🇳 🇩🇪 🇬🇧 🇨🇦 🇻🇳 🇸🇬 . China’s 9 dash line claim is laughable 😅
The 9 dash line came from Chiang kai shek and thus came from the ROC not the PRC,
LOVE Einar!!! Same wave length bro! elder bro! I chuckled as you did!
Respect the UNCLOS
Good afternoon ❤️ASEAN🙏😇👋
But as a Filipino why US not sponsoring Talks with Beijing and Manila
14:07 Philippines doesn't need permission from any country regarding activities for grounded ship in the Second Thomas Shoal, the Philippines has sovereign rights in that area.
I don't get how long can You put hand in the Fire and not realize it's going to burn starting Pacific tension it's going to farther their sands of time and We know who can control or manipulate That❤️🇵🇭🇨🇳🇹🇼🙏😇🕊️💯
Last time I counted U.S. has 10 bases in the Philippines. Marcos jr. wants to get daddy's frozen assets in U.S.
5 veto unanimous civilization
@@robertrichard6107 Pumunta si Pangulong Marcos sa china para makipag-usap, anong ginawa Ng china? Dipa nakauwi si PBBM SA pilipinas Mila china nanghaharass Ng ang china...Kaya pinabalik ang americano SA pinas KC china traydor na...
Pilipinas ang bayan ni jesus Christ..
Hindi mananalo si china SA pilipinas.
Hindi Kami natatakot mamatay lumaban at ipagtanggol ang aming Mahal na bayan pilipinas.
More media should do what CGTN did... Bring both opposing view and have a debate. It is not about right or wrong, but inform the public of both side of the argument. In many Western media, they always bring a panel of one or a panel of the same viewpoint.
LOL... CGTN providing unbias news... comedy gold!
@@covertpuppytwo3857 Did I say anything about unbias? Reading comprehension is lacking in your neck of the wood. Did CGTN not bring people from different viewpoint? Specifically one with pro-US eventhought this is a Chinese media company? Show me a CNN or Fox news where they have those type of debate with 1 panel being pro-China.
Laurel is a filipino, but he is china mouthpiece.
@@allanbanes9665 He is not the panel that is anti-China. It is the guy with the mustache, so no clue why you are mentioning the Pinoy.
@@Tabula_Rasa1 no clue? i am a filipino and what laurel says is always against our government.
from the Philippines thank you so much brothers, friends and allies ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It has been called stinging reef and it is within the EEZ of the Philippines, China is the aggressor and there is no question about it.
China's definition of peace is, let me grab your teritory and we're friends.
Meanwhile: Water canoning
China's definition of friendship.
Who wants a friend like that?
IF Philippines is not entitled to Thomas Shoal - how will you justify the increasing lines froma 9-line to now 10-line of China! That is the reason! Where can you sea a map with lines like in China! A sure aggression of seas! Overlapping many countries- China must be stopped!
Calm down! Emotions are running high and this creates conflicts. WE are only interested in facts!!!
@@isiahsteele7418 Shouldn't have reached for the United States crown.
Thomas Shoal is an international waters and is claimed by 5 countries. It is not Philippines or China territory.
@@Dept246 Right. And under UNCLOS, in which China is a signatory, the Philippines has sole right to exploit natural resources with its 200-mile EEZ. I can not understand why China contradicts UNCLOS which she commit by signing with UNCLOS. Why? Is China changing its mind?
True
I don' know if this Tiu Laurel is really a Filipino but the way he talk is like he is a mouthpiece of China.
I really hope Chinese coastguard stop any form of aggressiveness either watercannon or by any means like ramming on to ships
Btw we need put a historical context to any discussion in Asia, I dont think any country in South East Asia ever forget about Japanese aggression and brutality pre-WW2 and during WW2.
Now that Japan is thinking of rearming itself other than for self-defense and joining up with the US, seems like Japan has clearly forgotten who drop 2 atomic bombs on their 2 cities...
Last point after Japan decided to release treated radiated water into the ocean shows that Japan only care for itself and not the environment and the feelings of its neighbors and of course the US and the west supported Japan on this move since they are so far away from this release we already know of their double standards already in Gaza vs Ukraine so I dont think people should be surprise.
Well said
Japan and South Korea are military colonies of the US, hence they will remain lapdogs of the US as they depend solely on the US military bases in their respective country for their security. Hence, if the US says, "jump", they can only respond, "how high or how far" but never "Why jump?" 😅😅😅
Why do you think Japan forgot that it was at one time at war with the US? And the US supported Japan? You're not very intelligent, are you? And how exactly is WW2 related to current affairs?
Japan sided with Hitler that time, so let's not make another mistake by thinking china is better that the rest of the world.
or history repeat itself...
hitler before then who will be the next hitler?
Are you suggesting that the sins of yesterday are still the sins of today? If you are then every country has them! Convenience is a thing but truth is another, don't be convenient and don't be economical with the truth - unless it soesn't suit you?
This Prof Larres, the more he talked, the more silly he becomes.
He has been like that for a long time, spreading disinformation on Russia & China. He is the typical neo con, supporting western imperialism.
Shocking to say the least CGTN allowed Fair conversion like this even 4 to one. Great job!
How can China own all the sea (thousands of miles) that borders on other countries? Universally, all countries only owns a small slice of the sea that borders on a country. No country owns anything of the sea that does not borders on it. Although China borders on the SCS, China still cannot own the whole sea (thousands of miles) because SCS also borders on other countries.
DAVID AND GOLIATH story (The Philippines Small ONLY) Let me see who they are....
The collective area encompassed within China's bogus 'nine dash' claim is roughly ONE MILLION SQUARE MILES
"The nine-dash line is a set of line segments that encloses the South China Sea and includes the Paracel Islands, Pratas Island, the Spratly Islands, the Macclesfield Bank,
, the Scarborough Shoal, and the Vereker Banks. The nine dashes extend from the coast of China's Hainan Island, close to the coast of Vietnam, and into the South China Sea. The line covers approximately 90% of the South China Sea, which is 3.5 million square kilometers or 1.4 million square miles.
P.S. Since China claims to own the entire south China sea, I propose that Greece claim the entire Mediterranean, and Norway (aka Vikings) claim the North Atlantic ocean.
@@gregparrott ：Since China's 9 dashes enclosed a large part of the high sea, an international property, we should sue China for violating Article 89 of the UNCLOS. Why you wanted Greece to commit the same crime?
From what planet did this Lares came from?
hes a typical washington mouth piece, doing his job.
Planet of apes😂😂😂
Professor Krause, a question for you : How would USA react if China or Russia starts to build military bases in Cuba, Venezuela & the Caribbean countries? I presumed you know or remember the Cuban missile Crisis.
Idiot it is about Philippines asking help from USA Bully to deter China bully. USA is better than China, Democracy is better than communist. USA help china became rich and powerful that is why last time Pre. Xi visited USA to win back American busnesman....
Unlike nations like Russia... the US would not invade and destroy those nations! Maybe you should focus more on why Cuba, Venezuela and the Caribbean don't want Chinese military bases to begin with... unlike American military bases that are requested and wanted by those host nation governments!
@@covertpuppytwo3857 ,,
Blindness is inherent to you ?
Can't discern military actions ?
Been reading news event since 1946 ?
Who is the world terrorist since 1946 ?
There is no dispute on the reef. That would presume there is uncertainty over the fact that it's not Chinese, which it isn't.
Lauro tiu is not a Filipino but Chinese Blood and Chinese National.
However your try to turn or twist this issue, one thing is clear and you actually said it in the video. The US has 7
new bases in the Philippines. The American participant in this discussion talked about one (1) military base in
Djibouti. Imagine the outrage in Washington, if China would establish 7 new military bases in the Bahamas,
Mexico or Cuba ???
Phil and USA had a mutual defense treaty since 1951, after The people's republic of china (mainland china) won the civil war against the republic of china (taiwan)
that's the main reason why Philippines seeks help from the US after the bullying stance of PRC coast guard of the pilipino fishermen whos fishing it's own 200 nautical miles from its shores Exclusice Economic Zone or EEZ it's in the international law of the seas, carved by the international community that china ignored and China is one of the assignatory of that law..
Imagine the outrage if China would establish 7 new military bases in the Bahamas,
Mexico or Cuba from the people of the Bahamas, Mexico and Cuba!!! You see the difference is... US bases in those countries are welcomed to be there by the host nation. NO ONE wants Chinese bases because China is today's imperial NAZI's!
It's 9 bases, not 7.
Even worse, that's 9 too many.
not to mention, china wants the old ship be removed while they created their islands with military capabilities around west Philippine sea.
china is invading the whole sea and other country's territory like india, vietnam etc etc.
Maam yan Yan,you didnt say because of frozen assets🤭 in Switzerland and NYC 😅
The Real question is: Why this All Country in the World is Countering CHINA?? 😂😂😂😂 maybe you should Answer that!!
According to an international tribunal's legally binding decision issued in July 2016, the PRC has no lawful maritime claims to the waters around Second Thomas Shoal and Second Thomas Shoal is a low tide feature clearly within the Philippines exclusive economic
The People's Republic of China should act on the basis of international maritime law to determine maritime territory sovereignty with China, Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam etc.
YES..! friend i'm PILIPINO we always OBEY principles of INTERNATIONAL MARITIME we are UNITED ASEAN
Yea respect and abide to International Law or UNCLOS..
But that is what China is doing. The Philippines is twisting the UNCLOS to claim the islands which is greedy and deceitful.
Yes, china should honor UNCLOS!
It will resolve in peaceful solution...CHINA WILL RECOGNIZE THE INT'L LAW OF THE SEA...RESPECT THE TRIBUNAL DECISSION... the China history claim ,.then 9 to 10 dash line is not existing, unacceptable..that's all.
A waste of time listening to the silly moustachioed fellow and a shame to the university for having such so called professor.
CGTN is china owned network, this is a propaganda nothing more...
Profess lies
If your loyalty is not for your country, I think you don't need to be part of the government representative.
What US Coast Guard, instead of China Coast Guard, would have done long time ago to these intruding Philippine vessels? Would US Coast Guard have been so pampering and so gentle in using blocking and water cannon? Obviously not. Do you think the people on-board or this Philippine vessel that survived previous multiples attempts in intrusions be still here and intact today? No.
US and Japan who are currently interfering in South China Sea issues wouldn’t have been so kind to the intruding Philippine vessels. US and Japan coast guards would do chasing, onboard searches, shoot to kill, arrested fishermen, seized fishermen’s boats and actively rammed their boats many years ago. Other coast guards around the world would have used these more aggressive and invasive operations.
HUH⁉
Intrusions? Into what? ITS OWN EXCULSIVE ZONE?
And what China has done on fiery cross, subi and mischief reefs is somehow not intruding?
When you opened your mind, I think your brain fell out. 2nd Thomas Shoal is 700 miles from China's coast and 125 miles from Philippines coast. Even a dummy can figure that out.
8:55 This the best part of this discussion. Ms. Liu was overwhelmed by the statement which she didn't expected.
Arbitral ruling is a solid piece evidence, it can never be dissolved in whatever ways.
Actually the PH helps the war lover USA to stir up the waves in South China Sea! 😳🙄😁
not really. if there’s no aggression there is no US helping the philippines to defend. china must stop bullying the philippines and not going to west philippine sea and the problem is done!
You mean you invade territory within Philippines economic zone and do not have legal reason to bring your claim in any court? So it's fault of American because Filipino resist? How unreasonable and bully you are.
And what about the professional squatter w/c is the chinise? 😅😂😂😂
Isn't it china the reason of civil war in Mynmar😂you want other asean to follow Mynamar they have share boarder with china easy to invade .😂
not honoring the UNCLOS and EEZ will stir up the waves in west Philippine sea..
This so called professor is so childish! Unbelieveable. Is this the quality of an American professor?
Exactly, that's why United States University is going bankrupted and Americans very own High School students are contemplating whether to attend college or not after they've graduated.
Discuss also the Uncloss given to the Philippines!!!! And the sovereign rights of the Philippines !!!!
Some of them were mouthpiece of the beast,
What you sow you INDEED REAP IT.CONFIRMED.
Respect the honest commentators
Liu Xin's expression was so cute ahahahahaha....
⁉🎌
This discussion is bias towards China. Sadly, the Filipino speaker Mr. Laurel is clearly leaning toward China's interest ganging up with one speaker.
From what Base Points is China taking to measure the distance to the point of concern and the Base Points measured from Philipines.
From the scientific evidence the maps of the EEZ should be shown for everybody to understand
Dis-invite klaus larres! he called himself a professor, UNC@Chapel Hill, please make him go and be jobless.😅
If Professor Krause tells the true, he will be labeled as pro-China & his job will be in jeopardy. That pretty much sums up the real “freedom of expression”, American style.
Lares should be in “That’s Incredible”!
Prof.Larres thank you for a very well said truth about the Phil. EEZ souvereighnty and it belongs to the Philippines
We can't all deny that ayungin shaol is within 200 EEZ of Philippines and china nearest island is 500 kilometers away,, and we can't deny that china is claiming almost 90% of the south China sea,, and can't deny the fact that Chinese coastguard is bullying Philippines and other countries who have claim within their own EEZ,, if china only follow international laws and UNCLOS there is no trouble I'm sure and have peace in south east Asia,,, hope Chinese government will take it's maintenance for the health of the mind of their leaders....
Mr. Klaus, u live in a different world.
The US shud get their butts out of the IndoPacific. Russia, China, Iran and etc shud test the Monroe doctrine.
Then China should get out first from the West Philippine Sea.
The same way that China must leave to the Philippine eez.
china should get their butts out of the west Philippine sea. honor the UNCLOS!!!
How many millitary bases US requires,
How many you want..
It is not about the grounded ship it is when you occupy and make artificial island at the South China Sea
It's quite obvious the Marcos visit to the US had emboldened him with guts to counter China unlike Duterte who wisely cooperated for peace and trades , why had Marcos changed his mind after visiting America, he should come clean with the people of the country!!!!😢
"...wisely cooperated? Is wrong, duterte stupidly cooperated with the stupid jumping xi.
Money talks
He got the bucks
@@CHITODENTURESsince you are an expert, what is the volume of trade between The Philippines and China and that of The Philippines and US?
Frozen assets
Finally, a robust view of the true American geo-strategic objective in the region. American foreign policy and especially their military bases, is likened to their global franchise of fastfood outlets, the Americans have learnt the art of being the Global Sheriff or rather a US Marshall policing geopolitical regions seeing that they are tying into their AngloAmerican and Eurocentric geopolitical international rule of law since they won the Second World War along with their Five permanent members of the UNSC. However, now, two of the permanent five have become pacing rivals to the US Marshall and aa shootout at the Ok Corral seems very frequent since world war two. Nowadays, the worn out American Western genre is cliched and people can see the American modus operandi of getting regional squabbles a good time for the trusty US Marshall to ride into Town with his trusty Steed armed with his sizx shooter, but, now, its called the Carrier Strike Group and armed with JSF 35s and Sidewinder AAMs and Air to Ground Ordinances.
What has been learnt by most Nations is now, the old script has been figured out. Local bad guy does a stand over the local guy, the Big American with his forces waltz in to save the day. Except, now, the American builds military bases and doesnt leave at all. He turns each base like an American Embassy, no one allowed into an American base, not even the locals. Suddenly, we have American bases peppered all along the first island chain lines of containment, to keep China away from the High Seas and daring to expand too far from Asia. The lines of containment includes South Korean Bases, Japan and the Philippines, as well as Guam and Darwin Australia. In the centre of the Pacific is American Samoa and of course, Hawaii in the North Pacific. The Americans have become a constant reminder to the Asians of the Eurocentric Colonialism particularly with the recently formed AUKUS military alliance an Australian initiative to reach out to their Anglo American Apron strings for dear life for Anglo Saxon Neo Colonial Australia fearful of being swamped by Asians in a European Island isolated as an overgrown Singapore in the South Pacific alongside Anglo Saxon New Zealand.
The American modus operandi to contain China, and for that matter to divide Russia is to ensure that America's pacing rivals with Russia and China are adequately isolated by the Global community in a divide and conquer objective. More pervasive is the NATO objective to render the Russian Federation fate to be similar to that of the Great War division of the Ottoman Empire into the modern Middle East Nations we know of today, along with its over a century old problems, especially with the creation of the Palestinian State in 1917.
The fate of the Ottoman Empire after the Great war, would see the Picot Sykes Declaration an important remapping of the Ottoman Empire with new Nations and excluding Natons that should have been created, like Kurdistan and Khorasan Nations instead of some of the Middle Eastern Nations that are presently Middle Eastern States today, Of course, the Palestinian State was the purview of Arthur Balfour and the can of worms that was to unfold can be directly attributed to him alone. He did, after all create Palestine not for the local Arab tribes, but, for the Jews. Herein lies the rub today. As for the Russian Federation, it appears that the second part of the Glasnost and Perestroika dismantling of the second World of the Comintern, was to divide the Russian Federation into separate Repbublics, Krais and Oblasts, again not dissimilar to the Ottoman Empire after the Great War. It appears the unfinished mission objective of the German Nazis and now NATO is indeed to not only defeat Russia but to ensure its eventual collapse and disintegration into a smaller more manageagable State, to the pleasure of America, of course, and to the EU Nations wanting to knock down a Tall Poppy down from his high horse.
The casus belli and mea culpa would be Ukraine. Knowing full well that the Donbas was always populated by Russian Speakers the 1991 overstretched claims by Ukraine of their Soveriegn borders would ineluctably lead to the present tensions by those who had drew up the Ukrainian map from the outset. Sow the seeds of discontent until it matures to an outrage and mea culpa for NATO to interdict in the domestic affairs. Shoot down MH 17 and dishonour the Minsk Agreement of 2015 will help play out the confrontation and escalation of the conflict. NATO would eventually be drawn in after the Russian military were expected to be war weary and the Russian low morale exascerbated by the economic sanctions crippling the Russian economy to the point that the Russian people will turn against Russia likened to the Ukrainian Euromaiden revolution. Again not dissimilar to the collapse of the Soviet Union. This didnt work out according to the script. The CORDS CIA Program Play book was well known by National Security Analysts from all sides, including the Russian Analysts. The Russians dont play that way and yes, the Russians play Chess very well.
The Referendas and the ratification of the Donbass Oblasts into the Russian Federation was Grandmaster chess moves well ahead of the NATO chess players the Russians Statecraft had completely outplayed the EU and NATO and left them for dead as Punked Dumbasses. And so, the Americans, and the EU leaders, play on with deploying more weapons and munitions to Ukraine and the Ukrainian Russian chess game was well and truly over with the Ukrainian King well and truly dead. But, Ukraine continued to move their chess pieces and moving their Urkainian Forces as pawns to the Russian contact line, only to continue the denazification meatgrinder with First Person View Drones footages of Trench warfare deaths and destruction. Annhilated buildings, rail networks, bridges, power utilities, airports, hospitals, and other utility infrastructures, and yet the Ukrainians and NATO still continue to play out the end game when the game was already done since the Russian Duma passed their amalgamation legislation back in September 2023.
In the South China Sea, the Philippines scenario is a similar American playbook, with US Bases establishing a quasi permanent American presence within the South China Sea, apart from Darwin and Guam, the Philippines is yet another American military franchise along an island line of containment that will include the second Thomas Shoal to trigger a casus belli between AUKUS and QUAD against the local bully, China. Whereas, the Chinese are viewing the FONOPS issue as American post Colonial standover in the region, the Americans are viewing Chinese regional aggression as the bad boy attitude in Chinese regional Hegemonic dominance in their OWN Backyard. The Chinese will view American presence like the Japanese will view all European Colonial Powers since the fall of Singapore in 1942 Eurocentric and Anglo American Colonial bullying from a half millennia of European Colonialism of the Asia Pacific region. The Japanese had disseminated the regional decolonial mantra of Asia for Asians which was a key slogan that spread the decolonisation of the Asia Pacific like wildfire and more rigorously after World War Two. The Dutch were notable with their colonial repressive antics after World War Two in South East Asia that the legacy of their Colonial behavioural legacy left an indelible inspid legacy to the hearts and minds of the Asians. The Fall of Singapore was the inspiration for Asians to view the Americans along a similar vein.
The Second Thomas Shoal conflict is being viewed by Asian historians and especially by the Chinese as yet another Singapore mea culpa moment in the Asian decolonisation political history.
Thats right the Mutual Defense Treaty between Philliphines and USA is been around for long . US interest in the Philliphines because it was a Former US colony .
Ayungin Shoal is 121 miles from the Philippines while it's 1900 miles away from China. How come it becomes China's when their cartographer only drew the imaginary 11-dash line there in 1947? It's obviously inside Philippines EEZ. What if India draws an imaginary 11-dash line in the Indian Ocean, will it become theirs?
Thank You WE ARE WITH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS FROM THE COLONIZATION OF THE PAST....
If you believe in what is right... lets bring it to Arbitration. You can say whatever you like.
At the end of the day. The Philippines will not yield to manipulation and bullying in WPS.
we are UNITED ASEAN
The Philippines is riding on the back of USA to gang up on China and spreading disinformation about this matter on SCS. That is clear for all to see.
More of this please CGTN
The Philippine navy maintains a presence of less than a dozen Marine personnel on the 100 m (330 ft) long Second World War US-built Philippine Navy landing craft Sierra Madre, which was deliberately run aground at the atoll in 1999 in response to the Chinese reclamation of Mischief Reef,
Prof Larres you are telling the truth and nothing but the truth.thank you for bringing the facts not lies.
President Marcos of the Philippines is as notorious as his father.
A crooked family to say the least! Crazy that the people in the Philippine could put dingdong marcus in power after his father stole so much from the country ! Like father like son
Still better than Chairman Mao tho
For Marcous ( senior), the world know corrupted he was, then the Philippines vote in Marcous, make the saying "like father like son " quite credible.
So you mean to not being notorious, he should just let china invade territory within economic zone, what s your basis ? Bring it to any court. No you won't because you don't have legal basis,
Mao Tse Tung kills its own Chinese people, 40-80 million died by starvation.
The South China Sea Arbitration Tribunal was established in The Hague in accordance with Annex VII of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. It was a temporary team established and withdrawn at the end of the case. It was by no means an "international tribunal." The reporter's interview and investigation found that the ad hoc arbitration tribunal had nothing to do with the International Court of Justice (ICJ), also located in The Hague, which was the main judicial organ of the United Nations and was established in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations.
The ad hoc arbitration tribunal was not directly related to the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) in Hamburg, Germany. The only thing that matters was that, according to the requirements of Annex VII of the Convention, if the parties did not appoint an arbitrator, the President of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (in this case, the former President of the Japanese Nationality Shunji Yanai) will be appointed on his behalf. The ad hoc arbitration tribunal was also not directly related to the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA). Slightly related was that the Permanent Court of Arbitration provided secretarial services to the arbitral tribunal of this case and leased the Peace Palace in The Hague to the arbitral tribunal as a trial venue.
It can be seen that the ad hoc arbitration tribunal in this case was not a permanent arbitration institution, nor was it an authoritative judicial institution in the field of international maritime law. Its procedural rules were also interim arbitration rules drawn up by the arbitrators and applicable only to this case. Both the UN and PCA denounced the ruling.
The US is not even the signatory of UNCLOS yet its big mouth blares such a hype as if the US is the great defender of UNCLOS. When the illegal arbitrary (which was not part of the ICJ but a kangaroo court setup by the US and paid by the lackey Aquino) ruled that 1 of the islands claimed by China was not an island but only a shoal (which share the same criteria with one of the islands in the Hawaii), the US supported the kangaroo court verdict on China BUT refused to comment on the island in Hawaii that shares similar criteria. Till now the island is still considered an island, hence the US is allowed to claim 350nm of EEZ (not just 200nm). Isn't this the behaviour of a rogue nation?
I Stand with the Brown Guy with mustached hes a Pro US and Filipino. 😊😊❤
Beloved people of China. Know the story of our side Filipino. Evaluate if your country or my country Philippines is telling the truth.
And to add up. Notice all your neighbors are having disputes to all your territorial claim. Thank you
It is within the EEZ of the Philippines and China is signatory of UNCLOS. 9 to Dash line wss invalidated by Hague Arbitral Ruling which the China must respect, being signatory of UNCLOS.
the guy with mustache is incorrect!
according to og philippines map and the un map in historical records, the territory line cuts off the island, which was the point china refused to accept the ruling from the international court. but philippines used a revise version of the older map to include the islands as part of the philippines. if i remember correctly the map was made by spanish cartographer pedro something in the 1700...
also china has historical records dated back to the han dynasty (202bc), which 2k+ years ago and thru out the time china claims those islands up until to 50's, china decided to use an old map dated back to the ming dynasty (1368ad) to draw the 9 dash line. a replicate of the old map is at the museum.
so that mustache guy really needs to freshen up his history before he makes another comment...
The permanent court of arbitration doesn't care about the 9 dash line because it has no legal basis in regards to unclos or eez
You will find that most map drawn up my colonist and imperialist over reach into other people's soveriegnity. It is very typical and has caused many tensions and wars. The west has no right to draw the borders of the world in the image of their ambitions and countries who cannot lay claim to same foreign powers marking territorial lines.
@@Sean-giang
who controls the international court?! if you listen to the entire discussion, you already know why this is happening!
also if you read what i wrote, how is the international ruling fair, since the un historical map didnt show the islands are part of the philippines. even the og philippines maps didnt know the islands are part the philippines....
@@yehuo2825 china signed unclos and the Hague conventions so it's china's fault for not reading properly
@@Sean-giang
china signed due to trade and business...please reread the unclos and the hague conventions...
here is a quick summary and why china refused to follow the unclos and the hague conventions signature...
UNCLOS creates economic zones and the ocean.
UNCLOS does not cover land that was already claimed.
There are multiple islands all over the world that are inside other countries economic zones. Some are inhabited and some are not.
There are two separate issues:
The islands that China claimed previously. They are basically outside of the scope of UNCLOS if they were owned by China. If they aren’t then … that another issue. This debate is ongoing but is largely outside the scope of UNCLOS directly.
The islands/reefs that were built up. This one is more interesting. The basic idea seems to be that China says it has historical claims with pre-date UNCLOS BUT this is less clear cut which is the reason for the arbitration case a few years ago.
So from China’s point of view, it has abided with the UNCLOS agreement. Other people disagree so here we are now…
It's a matter of seeing oneself where one is - in terms of the Washington, China, and Phillipine speakers.
Reporter: How do we know for sure that these are construction material?
Director Yan Yan: Because we can see it, its all in there ship.
😂😂😂
looking Hot
as usual
just like a hot chilies of the PHILIPPINAS hahaha ''MABUHAY ANG BAGONG PILIPINAS''
marcos living on the promise of US is just like hanging on the spiders web of lies.
Marcos is only ration to do that, in fact even without the US he should make a stand and defend our territorial rights under the constitution. But because of corruption from Aquino to Duterte govt. We are unable to strengthen our nation defense.
The international decision is final and binding👏👏👏ayungin and scarborough are within the philippine eez
The ship is stand as an outpost, the boundar or area of Phil. teritory occupied, it was anchored there for a claim, EEZ made by UNCLOS
😂 These are all pro-China here except Klaus. The Philippines won the arbitral award. We always do it the legal way. Period.
''MABUHAY ANG BAGONG PILIPINAS''
It was a kangaroo court paid by the Philippines to rule in favour of the Philippines. UNCLOS does not decide the sovereignty of the territories but only the EEZ when the sovereignty has been resolved. Sovereignty first then, UNCLOS. Check the facts.
Not true
@@daohenliehow come it was paid, do you have any evidence? Blame it to your china government, no one has ever attended during arbitral hearing. Do you know why? It's because your only evidence is only your historical map which was not also recognized by other countries
@@daohenliepresent an evidence!
The question is why China grab waters, land and mountain of other countries?
People are not illiterate like second world war
THAT'S THE CONLICT OF INTERREST in other words EXPANSIONISM WANT THEM ALL TO CONTROL THE WORLD
After seizing Tibet, fighting with India, pissing off Mongolians, fomenting a military takeover on Myanmar, and claiming a million square miles of the south China sea based on a map that was drawn up shortly after WWII, would you expect anything different?
Philippines claimed only it's EEZ and not the EEZ of other countries and not whole 9 dash line
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻Invited Speakers from US, the Philippines and China - for fairer opinions