I highly suggest watching the full song (it’s on TH-cam). I was stunned by her interpretation. You can hear her pain, anger, frustration, and everything. You truly feel like YOU are to blame for making her evil.
i think i prefer the more dark and mature sounding voices for Act 2 Elphaba just because she's gone through so much at this point. Also I just prefer a more cavernous voice for *The Wicked Witch of the West*
Eden and Idina both played Elphie and Maureen in Rent, and even Idina and Caissie Levy both played Elsa, Elphie, and sang I Dreamed A Dream- Idina on Glee, Caissie as Fantine in Les Mis
Damn, there is no way I could pick between all these talented women. Out of the women in this video, the ones I have seen live are Kerry, Rachel, Willemijn and Alice, and all of them were amazing. Also, Danna Paola has so much vocal power, especially considering she was just eighteen years old when she was cast as Elphaba in the Mexican production of Wicked.
I got to see Jessica Vosk perform in wicked live... it was one of the most incredible things I’ve ever experienced, and I believe her voice is part of why that particular song is one of my favorites
JEMMA HASN'T GOTTEN ENOUGH LOVE SO HERE I AM. She was my Elphaba all three times I watched Wicked, and she sounded the GODDAMN SAME AS THIS EVERY SINGLE TIME. She's amazing.
Always love Eden's "Let All of Oz Be Agreed, I'm WICKED...". The was she delivers that line, she sounds so much like Margret Hamilton with that very evil and witchy-ness to it. I get chills from it everytime I hear it.
There's one video of Eden performing this song, the one where her legendary "Fiyero" riff came from, where she absolutely demolishes the climax of this song. Sadly the video has been taken down because of copyright claims, so we may never be able to bask in her moment of heavenly ascension again.
What’s very interesting about this is that Idina Menzel was not a powerhouse blaster with her voice. This role pushed her voice to new limits and probably why she changed her technique later on. Block is what the song was designed for.
Pedro Henrique ok a E shape is pretty to hit if you know what how to breath; but finding and holding lower fuller notes is technically mastering your craft. And finding a vowel you can rock with helps as well to open you up to go higher. Sure Myra 5 E shape is cool listen to the rest of her words in comparison
I just fell so hard for Alice! Lol. I also love Ock Joo-Hyun (like.. are you kidding? outstanding!) Jessica's was unique to me and her voice sounded so clear. Jackie & Rachel were great, too. I liked them all. I can't really choose.
Jessica Vosk, Myra Ruiz and Willemijn Verkaik are my favourites, for individual reasons. I love how dramatically (but securely) Jessica hits the "again, ever again" and the last note or two as well. I love Myra Ruiz's intense and agile riffing, she pulls it off really well. I love Willemijn because she's my favourite Elphie so I have to admit some bias, but she performs the whole song so intensely and makes it feel darker than other performers, probably because of her slightly deeper timbre. She has the most unbelievable breath control. Though I feel Emma Hatton and Kerry Ellis each deserve an honourable mention.
Jessica's tone is SO GOD DAMN clear and fucking pure and so good. like, there is no flaw in her tone. Rachel's slide was oh god so good. I got chills, it really added to the telling of it.
I'm gonna go with Idina. She's got an amazingly powerful voice, and I could listen to her for hours. But honestly, if I could sing with a modicum of the talent these women have, I'd count myself lucky.
My vote goes to Jessica Voc, you can hear her despair/breaking point as she sings it and on "I promise no good deed, will I attempt to again" you can really feel her thoughts go in motion:)
jessica vosk, willemijn verkaik, and jackie burns just blew it out of the water for me. Their arrangements were exceptional and you can hear the emotion in their voices. They’re probably my favorite elphabas of all time. I like the way Jemma Rix brings it up at the beginning. Kerry Ellis also nailed it. Jennifer Dinoia splayed it. Also really liked Rachel Tucker.
Reminder that all of these women are amazing and while some may be better than others, they all have extremely good voices, and they're obviously on Broadway for a reason. Don't ignore that they all have their own individual strengths/weaknesses, and recognize that they are all ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE performers.
1. Jackie burns (SHES LITERALLY BENT IN HALF AND STILL BELTS IT EFFORTLESSLY) 2. Jessica Vosk 3. Rachel Tucker 4. Ock Joo-Hyun 5. Alyssa Fox/Alice Fearn I cant decide
I just always loved idinas because i can really feel the emotion instead of “how many riffs can you do” competition that many other singers do. Plus her voice has that “witch-y” quality that i just loved
Willemijn Verkaik was amazing. Saw her live for my 16th and she made me cry! Loved seeing the international Elphabas. I’ve watched Idina and Shoshana sing and they are incredible too. But I think as witnessing it live and giving me all the emotions my favourite is Willemijn 💕💕
I have a very special place in my heart for Eden Espinosa, she was my first Elphaba and completely blew my 10 year old mind all those years ago. Left me completely enraptured and just in awe. I wish the recording did her more justice but with copyright and all that, it is what it is 💚 thanks for the video though, it was lovely!
I adored Ock’s version! amazing voice, so much emotion and she really showcases Elphaba’s wickedness. Jessica’s was out of this world. There’s so much clarity in her voice, Pure perfection!!
@@offcialmusicvotes7140 It's about representation. The Wicked casting directors have stated that they don't want Glinda to be played by a black woman, there has been ONE black Elphaba, and she wasn't even the main Elphaba. Correct me if I'm wrong. It's 2019, and there has been one black Elphie and NO black Glinda. Wicked has been playing for 11 years almost, and there's obviously been a shit ton of Elphie's and Glinda's because the show is so vocally demanding. I hope this clears anything up xoxoxo
Lindsay Medez sound very edgy and I love about her!!!! The others sound a bit rushed... Stephanie sounds like she's in great character as well hitting that note without too much power which I like... Rachel Tucker takes it a step down which sounds amazing...
I think the slide that Rachel Tucker does makes the song sound like a freaking awesome rock song. Just wow. It truly sets it apart in a different way and makes it so sound so different from the others. Vosk still wins for me, though.
Alice Fearn will always be my favourite Elphie. Saw her at the Victoria Apollo on the 13th October. She was phenomenal. I didn't know I could sweat and get goosebumps at the same time.....turns out she performed with Pharyngitis. Incredible incredible talent!
Emma Hatton is my favorite of those I have seen. She plays such an aggressie Elphaba which is really refreshing from the usual more sad version that I usually see around.
Kerry is the only one who sounds just perfect to me. Lindsay is also good, but it sounds to me like she is singing it in a lower key, I don't know if it's just the audio... I also like Jennifer's timbre, but she doesn't sustain the note...
Do you prefer the again part to be sung higher ("AgAAAAAAAAinnn") or just flat «not used in terms of pitch» ("Agaaaaaaain")
Mister Golightly donna vivino was the best for me but I don't see her on the list
The latter for me. :)
I prefer the higher. Plus I can hold the note easier when I do aAAAGAAAAAIIIIINNNN
Pearl the rebel true!
I prefer the AAAAAAAAAgAAAAAIINNNNN if that makes sense lol like the riff at the beginning and the middle like Alice fearn did
Just Incase you don’t know, shoshana was sick af during that performance and still managed to snatch both my main wig and my back up wig
Keith Harrell yAS
She's the best. Always, and forever.
Didn't she just lose her husband or something? I think i read that somewhere
Ikr
Keith Harrell YETH
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT SHOSHANA her little “again ever again” was AMAZING
Julian Brown and i think she had a 103 degree fever!! What an icon
Eva Noblezada does a similar thing in her D-EVA medley and I love it so much
Quarter note triplet feel - so hot.
I am ONLY talking about her! :-). Stupendous embodiment of the character ---- her voice is amazing!
Jessica Vosk's No Good Deed is the best thing I've ever heard
I saw jessika vosks 300th performance
Erin Twombly yeah it is
I saw her live she is amazing!
True
Jessica vosk’s everything is the best thing
tell me why Lindsay Mendez could literally sing anything and make it sound like the easiest song in the world
emidyliza / Elizabeth because she a amazing performer she one of the tops for me; my personal favorite is Shoshana followed by Lindsay
Ock Joo-hyun’s Elphaba seems so unhinged and I love it.
I highly suggest watching the full song (it’s on TH-cam). I was stunned by her interpretation. You can hear her pain, anger, frustration, and everything. You truly feel like YOU are to blame for making her evil.
Jessica is one of the best i've ever know, i just need more emotion on "i'm wicked", and i'm in love on every Elphaba that screams angrily "Wicked"
Iris Martínez omg I love that part too! I prefer the ones who kinda scream-ish the wicked part because it's filled with anger and cynicism
caleb barrera she’s not crap
Tucker,Fearn and Bentley’s Angel Forever you should follow your own advice because holy shit listen to the resonance and power behind her voice!
i think i prefer the more dark and mature sounding voices for Act 2 Elphaba just because she's gone through so much at this point. Also I just prefer a more cavernous voice for *The Wicked Witch of the West*
Julia Murney did that well her Elphie
I love Indina ❤️
For me its alwasy Shoshana. Not to mention the clip of her singing on the martha stewart show is when she was running a 100 levle feaver
Keating McFarland yes I know she is amazing!!
And she still sounds perfect!
That's a Legend right there!
You can hear it on her inhale. Astonishing that she sounded so good, she has superhero lungs
And I feel so bad for her when she lost her boyfriend and cried in one of her performances on stage. Poor girl 💔
Ock Joo-Hyun. You guys, she is so intense.
Christianna W I agree
Christianna W Most Definitely
She chilled me to the core ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
AGREE❤️❤️❤️
AGREEEE
No wonder Eden and Idina are picked for the same roles,they look extremely similar.
All three of them rotate thru similar things
Eden and Idina both played Elphie and Maureen in Rent, and even Idina and Caissie Levy both played Elsa, Elphie, and sang I Dreamed A Dream- Idina on Glee, Caissie as Fantine in Les Mis
Time stamps!
Idina Menzel- 0:24
Alice Fearn- 1:00
Shoshana Bean- 1:34
Eden Espinosa- 2:12
Lindsay Mendez- 2:48
Ock Joo-hyun- 3:21
Jessica Vosk- 3:56
Myra Ruiz- 4:32
Alyssa Fox- 5:09
Danna Paola- 5:44
Jackie Burns- 6:20
Stephanie J. Block- 6:53
Jemma Rix- 7:26
Emma Hatton- 8:01
Kerry Ellis- 8:35
Jennifer Dinoia- 9:09
Jacqueline Hughes- 9:44
Rachel Tucker- 10:17
Willemijn Verkaik- 10:52
🙏👑
Your a saint
You’re missing Teal Wicks!
Ock Joo hyun
Dana Paola
Jacqueline Hughes
They understood the assignment😭
Thank you so much!!
For overall tone- Lindsay
For technical perfection- Jessica
For emotion: Donna
Who’s Donna
@@susanstorm7910 donna vivino, not on this list I think but her version was really good. You should look it up
@@slowpopeisdead694 i think he meant dAnna paola
@@slowpopeisdead694 in my opinion she has the best rendition. The power and vocal control is perfect for this song
projection: jessica
I'm quite sad Donna Vivino was not here, but I live for Jessica Vosk.
i worked with donna at a camp called journey to broadway lol
i love donna 🥺🥰🥰
Donna is the queen of No Good Deed to me
I would go with Jessica because her resonance is unbeatable but 4:54’s arrangement AND resonance got the cake for me
Myra Ruiz is amazing!
Maicon nobody asked but that is true
Brazilian elphaba
Nasir Roper that’s the name of the actress who was singing...
The sequencing is incredible
Lindsay Mendez and MY GIRL JESSICA VOSK. Without question- Jessica!! I met her and saw her LIVE. I HAVE NEVER BEEN SO AMAZED! SHE IS TRULY AMAZING!
You can feel the rage in Jackie’s voice
tomgallowitz I freaking agree
tomgallowitz truly the best!!!
Jackie’s is the most emotional and best
Okay my favorites were Ock, Jessica, Jackie, and obviously Idina. But is no one gonna talk about Danna Paola? 😍
She’s my fav 💚
“Obviously Idina” Thank you!
THANK YOU!!! Christ, I went back 4 times!!
Jessica Vosk is at 3:56 you're welcome
my faves from this video
1. Rachel tucker
2. Jessica Vosk
3. Emma Hatton
4. Eden Espinosa
5. Shoshana Bean
SAME Slightly different order but they are all my favorites Rachel is the BEST Elphaba
There is not enough love for Ock Joo-hyun!!! The tone! The emotion! I'm dead.
I gotta say, the riff shoshana did on ever again was pretty amazing
Donna Paula was my personal favorite, while she probably wasn’t the strongest on the end, hers just was very aesthetically pleasing to the ear.
Danna Paola
Actually, she has the ending for "No good deed" she does riffs but this performance wasn't that good. Look for other videos of her. She was amazing.
that's because this performance wasnt for the public, was for the media basically. If u watch her other performances she slayed it
God Jessica's is just so technically perfect that it blows everyone else out of the water
Damn, there is no way I could pick between all these talented women. Out of the women in this video, the ones I have seen live are Kerry, Rachel, Willemijn and Alice, and all of them were amazing.
Also, Danna Paola has so much vocal power, especially considering she was just eighteen years old when she was cast as Elphaba in the Mexican production of Wicked.
3:21 Ock Joo-Hyun will always have the most emotional NGD for me.
I don't know who Ock Joo-Hyun but she nails the evil part like no other. She truly went from misunderstood to real witch.
I got to see Jessica Vosk perform in wicked live... it was one of the most incredible things I’ve ever experienced, and I believe her voice is part of why that particular song is one of my favorites
JEMMA HASN'T GOTTEN ENOUGH LOVE SO HERE I AM. She was my Elphaba all three times I watched Wicked, and she sounded the GODDAMN SAME AS THIS EVERY SINGLE TIME. She's amazing.
Yes!
Then she went from Elphaba to another Idina Menzel role and played Elsa. I'm so lucky I got to witness both performances she is amazing
And she played the Wicked Witch of the West in the Wizard of Oz. Absolutely adore Jemma and all her work 🥰
Excited to see how our new witches go!
Ock joo-hyun had such an original and amazing interpretation omg!!!
Diego M. Ramirez the acting!!!! I LIVE!!!
Diego M. Ramirez I really liked that shout before the last _again_. It really showcases Elphaba’s anger and desperation in the scene
Flawless, why isn’t anybody mentioning her 😢
Always love Eden's "Let All of Oz Be Agreed, I'm WICKED...". The was she delivers that line, she sounds so much like Margret Hamilton with that very evil and witchy-ness to it. I get chills from it everytime I hear it.
1. Jackie Burns
2. Indina Menzel
3.Jessica Vosk
4. Emma Hatton
5.Kerry Ellis
I love when they bite off that last note almost with a scream like Shoshanna Bean.
YES! Or with a growl it just makes it so much more emotional and out of control like Elphaba is in this song
And Ock Joo Hyun too
@@sorrynotsorry6 she lowered my body temperature with the chill she gave me 🥶
There's one video of Eden performing this song, the one where her legendary "Fiyero" riff came from, where she absolutely demolishes the climax of this song. Sadly the video has been taken down because of copyright claims, so we may never be able to bask in her moment of heavenly ascension again.
Danna Paola all the way!! I never knew she had what it took to sing this song so flawlessly omg
What’s very interesting about this is that Idina Menzel was not a powerhouse blaster with her voice. This role pushed her voice to new limits and probably why she changed her technique later on. Block is what the song was designed for.
While Idina Menzel is my favorite Elphaba, Jessica Vosk's No Good Deed is my favorite.
Myra Ruiz 💚 that higher note in "agaaaaaain"
Pedro Henrique ok a E shape is pretty to hit if you know what how to breath; but finding and holding lower fuller notes is technically mastering your craft. And finding a vowel you can rock with helps as well to open you up to go higher.
Sure Myra 5 E shape is cool listen to the rest of her words in comparison
I also have to say that Jackie Burns' growls are amazing.
1. Stephanie J Block
2. Lindsay Mendez
3. Eden Espinosa
4. Ock Joo-Hyun
5. Jessica Vosk
1.Jessica Vosk
2. Jackie Burns
3. Kerry Ellis
Same!!!! Kerry and Jackie are so underrated. My three favorite Elphaba's hands down!!
Donna Paola, jemma rix, and Kerry ellis all stood out to me, I love the emotion they showed 👌🏼👌🏼
katherine c. One of the best performance of Danna th-cam.com/video/fnpdqlgPlDY/w-d-xo.html
I just fell so hard for Alice! Lol. I also love Ock Joo-Hyun (like.. are you kidding? outstanding!) Jessica's was unique to me and her voice sounded so clear. Jackie & Rachel were great, too. I liked them all. I can't really choose.
The Best Five: 1) Shoshanna Bean, 2)Kerry Ellis, 3)Och Joo-Kyun, 4) Jessica Vosk and 5)Jennifer Dinoia. Honorable Mention: Eden Espinosa
Jessica Vosk, Myra Ruiz and Willemijn Verkaik are my favourites, for individual reasons.
I love how dramatically (but securely) Jessica hits the "again, ever again" and the last note or two as well.
I love Myra Ruiz's intense and agile riffing, she pulls it off really well.
I love Willemijn because she's my favourite Elphie so I have to admit some bias, but she performs the whole song so intensely and makes it feel darker than other performers, probably because of her slightly deeper timbre. She has the most unbelievable breath control.
Though I feel Emma Hatton and Kerry Ellis each deserve an honourable mention.
Jessica's tone is SO GOD DAMN clear and fucking pure and so good. like, there is no flaw in her tone. Rachel's slide was oh god so good. I got chills, it really added to the telling of it.
Lindsay Mendez does it so effortlessly 😍😍
Jessica Vosk’s Elphaba is growing on me. Her voice is so clear and she has such great control! One of the best
I'm gonna go with Idina. She's got an amazingly powerful voice, and I could listen to her for hours. But honestly, if I could sing with a modicum of the talent these women have, I'd count myself lucky.
Myra Ruiz is insane! I got to see her live, it was amazing
She's Brazilian girl
My vote goes to Jessica Voc, you can hear her despair/breaking point as she sings it and on "I promise no good deed, will I attempt to again" you can really feel her thoughts go in motion:)
jessica vosk, willemijn verkaik, and jackie burns just blew it out of the water for me. Their arrangements were exceptional and you can hear the emotion in their voices. They’re probably my favorite elphabas of all time. I like the way Jemma Rix brings it up at the beginning. Kerry Ellis also nailed it. Jennifer Dinoia splayed it. Also really liked Rachel Tucker.
Reminder that all of these women are amazing and while some may be better than others, they all have extremely good voices, and they're obviously on Broadway for a reason. Don't ignore that they all have their own individual strengths/weaknesses, and recognize that they are all ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE performers.
1. Jackie burns (SHES LITERALLY BENT IN HALF AND STILL BELTS IT EFFORTLESSLY)
2. Jessica Vosk
3. Rachel Tucker
4. Ock Joo-Hyun
5. Alyssa Fox/Alice Fearn I cant decide
I really like Lindsey's, her voice was very smooth and pretty. And Ock Joo-Hyun gave me chills, she was so fierce and Wow
I miss Myra Ruiz, she did Elphaba in the brazillian version of Wicked, and i think shes one of the best Elphabas of all times
Hjh Akm Myra Ruiz Sings awesome! I watched she at the Renault Theater 3 times
Myra is just amazing! I miss wicked here in Brazil so much!
Jackie burns is perfect 👌🏻👏🏻
Kevin W omg yesss
Yasssssssss
For me Willemijn is the beat Elphaba ever and I love her "no good deed" 💚💚
I love her gutes tun
This is really awesome! I love all the different vocal styles... Great job!
Jessica Vosk
Jackie Burns
Eden Espinosa
Jemma Rix
Idina Menzel
All these women are wonderful . But this is my top 5
Jessica Vosk were goosebumps I wasn't expecting
Myra Ruiz is my favorite
Yes
The Elphaba of the Elphaba's
She is amazing, I love her.
I just always loved idinas because i can really feel the emotion instead of “how many riffs can you do” competition that many other singers do. Plus her voice has that “witch-y” quality that i just loved
Willemijn Verkaik was amazing. Saw her live for my 16th and she made me cry! Loved seeing the international Elphabas. I’ve watched Idina and Shoshana sing and they are incredible too. But I think as witnessing it live and giving me all the emotions my favourite is Willemijn 💕💕
I saw Alice Fearn as Elphaba this year and my god she blew my freaking mind!!!
i saw Alice Fearn last month in London and she was spectacular! She and Willemijn are my favorites. I also liked Jessica Vosk =)
I have a very special place in my heart for Eden Espinosa, she was my first Elphaba and completely blew my 10 year old mind all those years ago. Left me completely enraptured and just in awe. I wish the recording did her more justice but with copyright and all that, it is what it is 💚 thanks for the video though, it was lovely!
Willemijn Verkaik, Donna Vivino, Ock Joo-Hyun, Rachel Tucker, Jessica Vosk and Shoshana are my top 6
1. jessica vosk
2. danna paola
3. kerry elllis
4. alyssa fox
5 . jemma rix
also can we talk about how danna was only 18 in that clip!!!!!!! amazing
RACHEL RACHEL RACHEL SHE IS QUEEN
Rachel Tucker definitely, the others are great singers but this woman can really transmit the anguish, the pain, all the emotions in this song.
Willemijn Verkaik, Idina Menzel, Alice Fearn and Myra Ruiz
I adored Ock’s version! amazing voice, so much emotion and she really showcases Elphaba’s wickedness. Jessica’s was out of this world. There’s so much clarity in her voice, Pure perfection!!
I wanna see a black woman play elphaba. That would be something to hear!
Look up Brandi Chavone Massey. She has a video of her defying gravity and its beautiful
You know either way they would still be painted green so it doesn't matter who does it ._.
@@offcialmusicvotes7140 It's about representation. The Wicked casting directors have stated that they don't want Glinda to be played by a black woman, there has been ONE black Elphaba, and she wasn't even the main Elphaba. Correct me if I'm wrong. It's 2019, and there has been one black Elphie and NO black Glinda. Wicked has been playing for 11 years almost, and there's obviously been a shit ton of Elphie's and Glinda's because the show is so vocally demanding. I hope this clears anything up xoxoxo
They've had a few. Look up Saycon Sengbloh she was incredible
Emma Theriot well, this comment is out of date now
Shoshanna, Joo-hyun, Jessica, and Jemma really took it for me.
I will always love Idina's version of the climax
For me it’s definitely between Jessica and Myra, tough to balance that perfect pitch and those leaps
Lindsay Medez sound very edgy and I love about her!!!! The others sound a bit rushed... Stephanie sounds like she's in great character as well hitting that note without too much power which I like... Rachel Tucker takes it a step down which sounds amazing...
I think the slide that Rachel Tucker does makes the song sound like a freaking awesome rock song. Just wow. It truly sets it apart in a different way and makes it so sound so different from the others. Vosk still wins for me, though.
MYRA MYRA MYRA AAAAAAAA also jessica vosk that woman is a legend
Alice Fearn will always be my favourite Elphie. Saw her at the Victoria Apollo on the 13th October. She was phenomenal. I didn't know I could sweat and get goosebumps at the same time.....turns out she performed with Pharyngitis. Incredible incredible talent!
Jackie burns had me feeling something
Willemijn Verkaik!! 💚💚
Kalli Karagianes good call 👍🏻I also love I also love Jessica Vosk
Yass every time!!!
i recommend yall listen to Donna Vivino's version i personally think its one of the best
They're all amazing and none of them sound remotely bad in any way
The ones that gave me goosebumps: Shoshana, Jessica, Alyssa, Danna, Jackie, Jemma, Kerry, Rachel, Willemyn (in order of appearance)
I love these videos !
Emma Hatton is my favorite of those I have seen. She plays such an aggressie Elphaba which is really refreshing from the usual more sad version that I usually see around.
SO, ARE WE NOT GONNA TALK ABOUT DANNA PAOLA?!?!?! SHE WAS LITERALLY 17 WHEN SHE PLAYED ELPHABA!
my absolute favorites have to be Stephanie, Shoshana and Rachel, and I love Jessica Vosk here!
Some love for the actual goddess Stephanie J Block 💕💕💕💕
0:47
HOLY. SHIT.
Danna Paola, una de las mejores :)
7:49
10:39
4:09
1:57
Rachel Tucker and Jessica Vosk will always absolutely blow me AWAY every single time
I love Shoshana's voice so much
I saw Jessica Vosk on Broadway, she was amazing
JACKIE omg I LOVE her!!!!
I'm so proud of Ok's voice. Of course most actresses's are amazing
Kerry is the only one who sounds just perfect to me. Lindsay is also good, but it sounds to me like she is singing it in a lower key, I don't know if it's just the audio... I also like Jennifer's timbre, but she doesn't sustain the note...